152 THE BOLEOF -iKS PRESBYTERIAN glUECE M THE ECCIIOMIc'l)?iyBI,OPMMT OF GHANA Kwame Arhin* Introductions Subject matter It is well knonn, that For the purpose of t h is papers, I e m s i d er the Presbyterian Church as a the Scottish .Mis- coitirmation of the Basel Mission. sion took over the Presbyterian Mission in -|9i8 when the Govemmaat of the Gold Coast arrested and deported the Basel Missionaries in 1917s and t h a t' the Scottish or Presbyterian Mission became the Presbyterian Church in 1926 (Broksisha, 1966j 25; Debrunners 1967J 294)• than the Presbyterian Churchj which played a significant role in Isying the foundations of s t r u c t u r al changes in the economy of the Gold Coast in the l a st quarter of the nineteenth century. Bauer has defined s t r u c t u r al eco- nomic change in the Gold Coast as thes It was the Basel Mission, r a t h er process which « . .. transformed the economy of the Gold Coast from a t r a d i t i o n al economy based en subsistence producticn and the collection of n a t u r a l ly occurring products into one dominated by a cash crop which has become a major s t a p le of i n t e r n a t i o n al commerce. 1 The cash crop wd-s cocoa and, as w i ll be seea? the Basel Mission was instrumaital in bringing it to the Gold C a s t. I define 'economic development' in t h is context as quantitative aid q u a l i t a t i ve changes in the material means of l i f e, owing to corresponding changes in the management of n a t u r al resources, including land, aid to the acquisition of new s k i l ls and tools* 1 shall suggest t h at certain sets of Directors I n s t i t u te of African Studies5 Legcn, 153 activities of the Basel Missicn, particularly in south-eastern Gold Coast, promoted changes in the use of natural resources and the acquisition of new skills and tools, which were necessary for changes in the material meais, as well as improvements*in the quality, of l i fe of the south-eastern peoples of Ghana amcng whom the missions established themselves* The sets of activities included (i) agricultural experiments and the ( i i i) the introduction of ( i i) infra-structural develop- intinduction of new crops, includfcg cocoa; ments, such as in housing and communications; new skills and tools and (iv) changes in life style. But before describing these sets of activities, and showing their relationship to the changing economy, I must, firstly, sketch the history of Basel Missions, in the l a st quarter of the ninetesith caiitiry and also say a few words about the eharac- teristics of the missionaries tha$ -cosld be presumed to have a bearing on eccnomic development. Secondly, I consider it necessary that I sketch the economic conditions of south-eastern Gold Coast as the framework within which the changes I shall outline occurred. The sketch will facilitate ai appreciation of the impact of the misgionaay economic activities* i* She n jn^teax th century Basel Mission 2 The story of the Bas*l Missions in south-eastern Ghana begins in the late eighteenth castury with Paul Brdmain Isert, a Danish physician and botanist. Isert first visited ikwapim in 1788, aid returned to Akr«pong in July 1789 to found an 'utopian colony*. Jhe colony did not survive Isert1 s early death in Jaiuary, 1790* Although his stay in Akwapim was short, I s e r t 's work bore fruit in im«ng those influenced was Andreas influaicing others to come to ikwapim. Riis, generally regarded as the founder of the Basel Mission m the G»ld Coast. In 1832 Hiis joined the Basel Mission which had been established in 1829 at the Daiish settlement at Christianborg* The Europeans generally felt that the coast was unhealthy for whites, and were m the look out for suit- able location for the missions. JELLis visited Akropong, the site of J s e r t 's 154 , en 25th Jaauary, 1835, finally settled there en March 9th, 1835» worked there t i ll his death in 1845* He visited Ktuaasi in 1839-4-0 "but the v i s it "bore no apparent ' f r u i t '. In 1842-43» he went an recruitment tour to the West Indies, in the belief that blacks would stand the climate better than whites. He was able to bring to Akropoag six West Indiaa married couples aad three bachelors. Of these the best known was John Rochester who, together with D?;vid Asante, aa Akwapim, succeeded George Widmaan at the Larteh. mission in 1847. By the tu.ni of the nineteen.th and twgatieth csaturies, the Basel Missioa had spread from the Christianborg centre to Akropong, Aisuri, Larteh aad further eagt to Krobo Odumase, Anum, Ada Foah aad Keta. It is significant that the Basel missionaries were Galvinists or Pro- testants, imbued with the sense of callings or devotion to one's chosaa duty* 'Devotion' was not aa emotionals but a rational matter? implying a systematic application of the most efficioat meaas to rationally determined ends. In the early days of capitalism, members of the Protestant sects are said to have distinguished themselves by their rational pursuit of wealth which, whoa acquired, #as a sign of "grace" or acceptance in the sight of God* Dae rational pursuit of wealth precluded prodigality or ostentation in aae' s l i f e- slyle, and thrived on f r u ^ l i oj which Puritanism enjoined up en i ts practi- tioners. It is the rational or methodical attitude .to one's work, c»upled with the ascetic manner of l i f e, embodied in the Protestant ethic, which dis- tinguished the Protestant aitrepreneur end gave him aa advaatage over Gatholic and other noa-Pxotestant entrepreneurs (Weber, 193^)* In. considering the relationship of ChrLstiaaiiy to the early development of cocoa in the Akwapim district, Brokensha states thats ChristianSj in their specific roles as Ohristiaas, did not play a leading part in the developmait of coo»a. The pioneers included both Christians and naa-Christians, aad it would be idle to look for aay sort of 'Protestant ethic' in' the development of the cocoa industry. (Brokensha, 1966:17) 155 jj ,/ But it seems to me that the point about the 'Protestant ethic1 relates not to entry into the cocoa industry. As he himself points outs (t966;36) the people of Xartehj .jwfth whom he was mainly concerned, had become used to trading enterprises for four centuries before cocoa arrived aamg them. The fruitful point to pursue concerns the relative success of the Akwapim Christians, as entrepreneurs, as compared with n on-Christians- Were the Christians, generally, more successful in the pursuit of wealth thai non- Christians aid what were the factors of their success? Was it possible, for example, that the Christians were more frugal thai others, and to what extent was this frugality reflected in the areas of social life, that demanded more than ordinary expenditure, such as the occasions of the rites of passage, birth, marriage and death? This seems to me a worthwhile hypothesis that can be tested in such a small, homogeneous area as Akwapim. It appears to me likely that the early Christian converts were influenced in their outlook aid mode *f life by the Basel missionaries who, like other missionaries in Africa, insisted that their converts should imitate their style of life (Ajayi, 19^5)» Again, it is likely that the missionaries prevented the converts from participation in the rites of traditional religion whi.ch presented obstacles to the accumula- tion of wealth. Such ritualistic obstacles included prohibitions en work en farms on certain days and the expensive demands of traditional deities for mmusu yie, pacificatory, supplicatory aid purificatory rites, sheep, goats and fowls* Hiis line of enquiry should reveal a positive relationship of presbyterianism to economic development. i i. The Akwapim eopnomy in the nineteenth caitury An estimate of the impact of the Basel Mission-an the economy of Ghana must be preceded by a reconstruct!on of the main features of the Akwapim economy in the ninetemth emtury* By 'economy' I mem the productim aid distribution of-goods and services in a gLvm area. But there is no material 156 for a detailed reconstruct ion of the economy and die is bound to resort to generalities'about the Akwapim econon^ which was not mlike the economies of the coastal forest zaie of the Gold Coast. Economies may be broadly divided into market aid non-market economies. A market economy is cne In which mm.'s livelihood depends en money exchange, so that a ll the factors of production, land, capital and labour* are for sale. A max hag to sell something in order to subsist aid the market, through casil transactions, structures prod-active activities. A non-market economy Is the reverse of this? mm produce for their cm use, and not for exchange and the factors of production have no market. The l a t t er iype of economy has been called a 'subsistence economy1, a generic term which has embraced the economies of hunters and gatherers, pastoralists and agriculturists spread in communities over Africa and Asia. Sahlinss (1972: 1-39) has shorn that a subsistence economy need not meai a 'starvation ecmomy1 but that it has the characteristic of iinder-use of natural resources and labour (Sahlins, 1972s 4i-74)> f-com the observer's point of view, of natural resources and labour? which puts a low ceiling on. growth in the material means of l i f e. liaderdevelopment follows precisely from this under-employment Hie Akwapim economy, like the economies of the Akan peoples »f central the In the years following the British formal abolition of the slave aid southern Ghana, had passed the stage of subsistence economy; developmait of chiefship had led to intensification of production and since 1482 there had been trade with the Europeans which had stimulated productive efforts* trade in 1807, the people rf Akwapim, like others in southern Gold Coast, had substituted trade in palm o il aad kernels for the trade in men. In the middle of the century, they took to rubber collection aid the sale of cottai. Pro- duction for use was shot through with production for exchange in order to acquire European clothing, tools and drinksj and money in the form of cowries had penetrated the economy. 157 Nonetheless, production for use was the dominant feature of what was becoming a peasait economy- Eccnomic organization was based on the house- hold whose productive activities were mainly oriented towards own. use rather than for exchange* division of labour and most people were in fanning. The material-means of l i f e, in the form of food, shelter and clothing, were not much altered at the time of arrival of the missionaries- Is. what follows I . shall suggest the various ways in which missionary activities contributed towards the change of the Akwapim non-market to market? economy- !Ihere •• was l i t t le differentiation beyond the se:xual i i i • Agricultural e 32j3jimen_t £L_an d th e_inj:rodu_ctjm of i cocoa Missionaries in Africas whether Protestant or Catholic, ?/ere expected not cnly to preach the Gospel "but also to promote industry among their converts- It was believed that in order to turn African's from the temptations of the Slave Trade, the Gospel must be accompanied by the plough. (Ajayi, 1965s 17); aad it was urged upon missionaries to teach Africans new skills in agricultures in addition to commerce* The Devil, it was said, found something for idle hands to do. On the Gold Coasts the iaexhodis'ts, under itev. '£•&* iPreemaij and the Basel Mis si en engaged in. agricultural experiments, creating model farms around their missions for imitation by their congregations- The Methodist mission had cash crop - ccii'ee aid cotton - p-u*roations at I-omanase and Abura in the Central Region in -]841; an 1842 they also purchased a coffee and cotton plantation called 'Napoleon' near Cape Ccast from the firm of F. Swanzy aad renamed it B nil ah (Debrunner, 13^7 £ 13O)» The Basel Mission agricultural experini^-ti, began, after the arrival of. the West Ihdiea missionaries in Akropong in -]84i.V43» a^d. advanced pari pasgu through south-eastem Gold Coast with the establishment of the mission in the different towns- Thus by the i8?0's the Mission, has cafctai plantations at Akropong, Abokobi near Accra, ICrobo Odumase, at I!pcng en the Yolta river aad Anum. 153 'Secondly, such crops as coco-yam, cocoa and the mango tree* were new Introductions, which spread later through the Gold Coast and Ashantl. Of these the most important was cocoa which has since the end of the last century, shaped the economy of Qiaia* $he Basel- Mission1 s first esqperiments in cocoa growing at Akropcng, with cocoa pods imported from Surinam in 1859 were not very successful* In -|866 only a single tree had remained in their plantation with yields which were distributed to the Mission's farms at Aburi, Kanrpoig and Ivxooo Odumase (Dickson, 1971: 165-166) • Today, Tetteh Qaarshie is regarded as the founder of the cocoa industry. But it ought be recalled that before he went to Fernando Po, he had leaant •of the potential value of cocoa from the Basel Mission, aid, that it was due to his training as Goldsmith by the Mission that he secured his job in Fe&iancjo Po (Debmsiner 19^7: 139)« Therefore, "the contribution of the Basel Mesial to the development of the cocoa industry i s, in the f i r st instance, it drew the attention of the people to the potential value of cocoa, twofold: aade it clear that the soil and climate were suitable for i t, aid also trained the migrant Tetteh Quarshie who brought cocoa from the Seychelles Islands* Missicn training contributed to the de"?clcpm.aic of cocoa in aiother wqy: Persons educated in 'the Mission schools acted as secretaries of the Akwapim •land purchasing companies (Brckensha 19662 17) which, Polly Hill insists* contributed more than small-scale individual farmers for the growth of the cocoa industry- Eie early effect ox cocoa industry en the economy of the Gold Coast; need only be briefly stated. The development of cocoa entailed more intensive use of a ll the factors of production land, capital and labour, and hastened the moietizaticn of life.' It led to' an increase in the purchase, and leasing of land, hastened the process of capital accumulation and stimulated labour migration. Far more than the production and sale of palm oil and rubber, the production and sale of cocoa was responsible for gubsi&itial changes in 159 the material means of life aid improvements in the quality of life at f i r st en the Akwapiai ridge? and later throughout the country. Ihxxdly, the Mission, through the Basel Mission Trading Factory, which it established in 1855* traded in agricultural products, so that the members of the congregation who grew cotton aid coffee, or produced palm oil aid kernels at Akropoig, Larteh, Abokobi, Ghristiansborg, Kiobo Oduntapej, Kpmg aid inum found a ready market for their products. One cannot state in any precise fashion the effect of the agricultural ejiperimaatSi cocoa production and trading in cash crops en the peoples of the neighbourhoods of tne missiois* But there is no doubt that th^y intgasified the induction of the people into the maricet economy and stimulated labour specialization. iv. Innpyatiaig. .in. infra-structure Quaititative and qualitative improvemmts in the material means of life Ifae major changes in comnafiications advaace with improvements in communications which enlarge social contacts aid widai the area for market exchange. ?si this country occurred after the establishment of colonial administration, tfhi.M built 'administrative' to connect regional headquarters and tr,acle roads to link district headquarters to the regional headquarters in the first half of this cmtury* Biese replaced the bush tracks which had served for roads* But the Basel Miss&oi made a beginning in road making aid introduced other means of porterage than humqn beings before the aid of the caatury. In the i860's, it begsa fee construction, of a road to link Christiansborg, the Akwapim ridge aid the Krobo area (Bebrunner, 1967s 132)* Members of the nrtssioi tried horses, muless aid asses for porterage. Biough their efforts were nullified by the tsetse in the closed forests whidii in the afosmce of vertinary services, preyed upm the pack animals, (Bixaicmsha 1966:21) the demonstration effect was salutary. 160 Infra-structural developing!ts included changes in house building. Riis was gained as Osiadan, house builder (Brokmsha, op.cit. i87)« Hie Basel ffi.ssicnaad.es built the first stone house at • Akropcng in 1846, aid by the end of the csitury the Akwapim ridge saw many fine stcne houses, modelled en the architecture of the missionaries. It may also be presumed that in both the separate christisn quarters and the nor,-Christian parts of the towns in which the Mission houses were situated, attempts were made to imitate, not oily the missions' architectural models but also the furnishing of the rooms- Later, meney from cocoa production was to enable the pioneers in the cocoa industry to erect stately mansions which have been called 'monummts' to the goldai pod (Brokensha9 19665 passim). The early mission houses became centres of diffusion of architectural models. The urge to build such houses acted as incentives for "tine'search for wealth. v* The introduction of new skills and tools Economic development is both facilitated aad measured by quantitative aid qualitative changes in skills; men and women acquire different skills and pursue different occupations- migration to centres of demand for different l:inds of skills- the emergence of a labour market, and therefore considerable monetization of the material means of life,, and hence significant structural changes in the economy (Szereszewski, 1965:59)« IMs developing t either precedes or follows It indicates The Basel Mission contributed to the developmaat of different skills through their formal educational institutions and artisan vsorkshops. The Mission's attempt at formal education began at Christiansborg on 2?th November, 1843s atid. at J&ropong at the end of -)844« Subjects taught an Baglish were reading, writing, Biblical history 3nd singing. The pupils also worked on the mission farms; and in -]847 twelve girls at Akropong were learning needlework. On 3rd July, 1848 the Mission opaied a seminary at Akropcng, which as the rules laid dowi by the missionary field cenferaace for seminaries put i t, was to£teachers and catechists* In 1869 the Mission schools were categorized as follows; i. Infant schools (kindergartsi Aburi and Akropong.) i i. Primarj day schools (3 classes): Larfceh, Maafe, Tutu, Abokobi, Odumase, Sra, Kibi, Kukurantumi, Aburi, (boys cnly) and Akropcng (girls only)* in. Primary boarding schools (6 classes): Akropcng for boys, Aburi girls* Middle boys' schools: (4 years)* Christian sborg and Akropong v. Seminary: Akropcng (3 years)* (Debrunner, 1967s 147-151 )• In additicn to schools, the Missicn also establishod workshops at carpsiters, masons, blacksmiths, Christiansborg for training a r t i s t s: shoe-makers, potters and hat-makers* In -j857— 1859 they brought two master carpaiters, specialists in house-building and furniture-making, a master chariot~maker, blacksmith, masm, shoe-maker, potter and hat-maker, (lbid:i37)* Those educated in the schools found jobs as pastors, teachers or catechists at the mission or clerics at government and coranercial establishments 1h* worktshops turned out skilled men, sawyers, coopers, masois, carpaiters, iraismiths, gunsmiths, organ repairers, shoe-makers and tailors who found occupation ?dthin the changing economy of Ghana (Biokai.sha, 1966:17; Debrunner? 1967:29)* Ihe acquisition of new skills oitailed the acquisition of the necessary tools, and increase in the technical equipment of the skilled craftmai* vi* Hew styles of life Finally, as Ajsgri, (op. cit*) has i t, the missicnaries aimed at influaicing, not cnly the spiritual outlook, but also the manners 9nd customs of their converts* Maaners and customs included such external things as mode of dress, and the furnishing of houses* I have already suggested (section iv.) 162 that missicnary architecture and furnishing influoiced, first, 1iie S&lems or Christian quarters andf second, non-Christ iaa sections of the towns in which the missions were located' It appears to me reasonable to suppose that the early Christians took the lead before non-Christians in the acquisition of dress and items of foreigi material culture which served as indicatims of their new way of l i f e. Smith (i966) has stated that the modem elite, as distinct from the traditional elite, had i ts origin in Christianity which was inseparable in the early d^rs from foaaal education Members oj the elite were distinguished,by their style of life, which was modelled oa the l i fe of the missionaries* The link betwem the change in life-style and economic development is that the neeu to acquire the material symbols of Christian or elite status, like the need to ps§r taxes in the early colonial period, acted as incentives for intensifying productive efforts, in fanning, trading or as paid labour. Sumnary Hie Basel Missicn contributed to the development of the economy «f the prepared the ground for the Gold Coast in the following ways. By means of i ts experimental fauns, it danoastrated the potentiality of the soil for a greater variety of crops* In showing that cocoa would grow in Ghana, it developmmt of the cocoa industry which has, since the turn of the century, dominated the economic development of this country. The Missicn. produced educated and skilled men who were necessary for the developing economy of the Gold Coast, and helped in the process of labour specialization which is a feature of a maricet eccnoiqy. Ihe Missicn offered a model of life the imita- tion of which spurred the neighbours to greater productive efforts. these areas the Mission made lasting ccntributions to the change from a non- market to a market economy. . In all 163 Gen elusion Based as It Is cnly en seccsn.da.ry materials this paper has beai necessarily sketchy. But I hope I have suggested the lines en \#iich a future enquiry into the subject might be pursued* 164 N o t e ...3 . p. Bauer Preface to R. Szereszewski* This secticn is based mtirely en Brokmsha, (1966), Smith (1966) Debrtsiner, ( ^7 ) See Polly Hill (1963; 19?O)- Refer® ces Ajayi, J.p.A. 1965 ChristianMission s in Nigeria; i84i~i£ ew elite, making of s. 391? The Lcngmsn a 1 Brokaasha, D. Debxunner, H.W. Dickson, K»B. 1967 1971 Social change at Larteh, C •U •P A History of Christianity in Ghana. Wateiville Publishing House, Accra» A Historioal Geography of Ghana. C.U.P. H i l l, P. 1963 The Migrant Cocoa Farmers of Sahlins, S« Smith, N. Szereszewski, S« Weber> M« 1972 1966 1965 193° _Studies in .Rural Capitalism in West' Africa., C«U«P. T avi s to ck Pub li cati on s • The Presbyterian Church of Ghaaa, .189^-)960. Ghana Uaiversity P r e s s, Accra» Structural Changes ..in t'.te Economy _of_Ghaia<, Weindenfeld and Ni^olsoa, London. The Protestant Ethic and the S p i r it of Capitalism. Trans, by T. Parsons, Uhwin University Books-