52 DJ FAOTOHT BflPLOYMEHT; A PASS By Eugenia Date-Ban* The advent of Ghanaian women in industrial employment is a new phenomenon.. Their traditional economic, activities have been trading and farming. With respect to trade, Bosenip (i97Os87) reports that 80 per cent of Ghana's labour force, both.&h the village and in the city, is made up of ':vsiQm&i (also see McCall, 19^1). This would imply that Ghanaian -women have always vrorked outside the home to support themselves, although not as industrial employees but as self-employed. The -women who participate in trade and farming are mostly i l l i t e r a t e. With increasing education , however, the educated Ghanaian women are branching out into other employment areas - mostly nursing and 2 1 teaching and a few of them into factory work • This paper examines, among other things, the characteristics of Ghanaian women in factory employment and whether there are any differences with respect to work behaviour, between these women and their male counterparts working in the same factory. The data to be discussed here are extracted from a study conducted from July 1972 to March 1973, of a group of Ghanaian factory workers with the main aim of providing a further test of the Industrial man hypothesis in the Ghanaian setting. These workers were the employees of a Ghanaian State Garment Factory situated in Accra. Althou^i it was a case - study, the employees of three private garment factories were also looked at. Therefore, where appropriate, comparisons will be made between the employees of the state and private factories. Forty ei^it per cent of the state factory's 283 employees and between a half and a third of those in two of the private factories consisted of women. If we accept Moore and Feldman's view (1960*85) 53 that none good test of the degree of commitment of a labour force is the per cent age of it comprised by women11, then this Ghanaian labour force could be described as committed. However, as Lambert (1963»85) points out, the proportion of women in a labour force sometimes is not related to the choice of the vjomen concerned nor of their families, but upon the vailing!ess of the employer to hire them. For example? in the third private factory looked at in the study there were only 3 women out of a labour force of 65 because of a deliberate policy of the management not to employ many women owing to the amount of working time lost through the maternity leaves of women employees. F?vctory jobs, however, have been described as not attractive to Ghanaian women as self-employment (see Peil I972as 36) because it requires working regular hours and also because of the scarcity of It would .appear then that day nurseries where children can be left. the garment factories studied are exceptional in having a high pro*, portion of women employees- Peil, however, mentions sewing as among the occupations in which Ghanaian -930men are mostly found and since sewing is the main work done in these factories, it is not surprising then that they have such a high proportion of female workers* It is true to some extent that most Ghanaian women with skills, like sewing, seem to prefer self-employment to wage-employment. Almost two thirds of the seamstresses in all the factories investi- gated began their sewing career in self-employment. Self-employment attracts Ghanaian woman because it allows the married woman some flexibility s she can leave her work without any fuss to attend to home duties like children and husband when the need arises. She can thus work shorter hours or fewer days in the month (cf. Boserup 1970s 115), the kind of freedom denied her counterpart in v/age- employment in the factory. Self-employment, however, has a dis- advantage, namely the irregularity of the income derived from i t. 54 Many of the seamstresses interviewed gave this as their reason for entering into regular wage employment. Marital Status Most of the Ghanaian factory women studied were married and thus differed from the Ugandan factory women studied by Blkan (i955°4i) mho were reported to have had marital disruptions. However, these Ghanaian workers needed regular income because their husbands were mostly in working class or low middle class jobs like the typist, driver and clerk. The women1 s regular income was thus necessary to supplement t h e ir husbands1 small pay packets. There were very few of the husbands in upper class occupations like managers. 5br example, one female junior superivisor in the. state factory had a husband who was an Assistant Manager with the State Cocoa Marketing Board, There was, however, one case where the husband Y/as unemployed, ao the seamstress had to use her factory income to feed and clothe the husband as well as the children. Also for most of the women, their work was necessary so that they could support some members.of their extended family especially mothers, brothers and sisters. A fifth of the women were divorced, separated or widowed. These needed their factory income to live on. Ibr example, when the marriage of a thirty year old Kwahu seamstress broke dowi, she learned tailoring from an aunt and found employment in the factory as a seamstress* There was also the case of a woman from the Volt a Region who learned tailoring in her youth but gat married immediately after her training and became a full-time housewife. T.7hen she divorced her husband and the l a t t er took away the sewing machine he had given her, she found employment in the factory. A further fifth of the women were in polygamous marriages. This could be explained in terns of the fact that it is easier for a woman to leave home to work, if there are co-wives at home to serve the husband (McCall 1961?293)» 55 Children Most of the vKjomen were v/ithin their child "bearing period. Therefore, the married 3nd even some- of those who were not currently married had small children but were in full-time wage employment with i ts regular hours of work. This was helped by the fact that they had they had parents, grandparents, maidservants and other relatives to look after their children for them while at work. This would seem to suggest that the Ghanaian kinship system makes it easier in a country where nurseries are so few for these wDmen to enter into full-time wage employment. The fact that the Ghanaian woman in wage employment continues in regular employment even though she has small children represaits one point of difference between her and her counterpart in Britain and the other western industrialised countries where married •women tend to leave employment during their chilclbearing period (or take up part time employment) althou,r£i some may re-enter vjhon the children reach school gping age (see Klein -]JoO; 1961 and 19&3? Confederation of British Industry 1967). Ghanaian women factory employees cannot be described as "birds of passage in industry" as Lupton (19^5° 191) does in. connection with the British women in industry. One attraction of the factory for i ts married female employees is i ts shift system which permits them not to spend the whole day in the factory. During the interviews, some of the women mentioned that they liked the shift system because it left them time to do. their house work. In this sense, then, The average age of the women in the state factory was 33 years. This was slightly lower than that of their male counterparts which was 36. Generally? however, the average age of both the men and women employees in the state factory was higher than in most Ghanaian factories (see Pe.il I972as 39) and in the three private garment factories studied. This high average age is explicable in terns of the nature of the state factory's labour force, i ts history and i ts turnover rate. The employees -we re skilled workers and Peil found (i972as 43) in her study that the median age of skilled workers was above the median age for a ll the- other workers* However, the workers in the 3 private factories were just as ski lied-trained tailors .and seamstresses - as those in the state factory, yet the fomer had a lower average age (28, 3O and 26 respectively). This would seem to imply that the hi$i average age of the state factory's employees is explicable in t e ms of other factors* The state factory, unlike the private ones in the study, was established in 1962 and this makes it quite old in a country where factories are mostly of very recent origin (Date-Ban 1972s86). In addition, i ts labour turnover has been low. This means that although the state factory's employees were recruited young, they had grown old on the job. The l a t t er factor is related to their comparatively long, laagth of service in the factory (8.6 years). This is illustrated in Table 1. Table I The Distribution of the Employees in the State Factory by len/?bh of service and sex (percentages) Laigth of Service Male Female Total 1 year or less 2-5 years 6-10 years 11+ years* Total . N 4 5 77 14 100 146 3 8 84 5 •jOO 135 3 7 78 12 100 281 57 In contrast to this, in the three private factories the average length of service was 3? 4 ?nd 3 years respectively. The employees' short length of service in 2 of these factories is due to high labour turnover while that in the last factory is explicable in terms of i ts short history. As Peil has said, factories, in those factories experiencing high turnover" (i972as 39)• riworkers will "be younger in new Education It has already been mentioned that educated Ghanaian women tend not to participate in trading and fanning, the traditional economic activities of Ghanaian women, but seek employment in the modem economic sector. Thus it is not surprising to find that most of the women found in the factories covered in this study were educated. The majority have had ten years of education. Perhaps this is explicable in teims of a deliberate recruitment policy of these garment factories to employ only educated people since the work done in them demands ability to read and measure. For example, the few tailors end. seamstresses with no formal education, have some •working knowledge of reading these measurements* This high proportion of educated people, both men and women, among the employees is in complete contrast to their parents, a majority of whom are i l l i t e r a t e. This is explicable in terms of tvjo factors - a general increase in the country's literacy rate and the different kinds of job engaged in by the parents. About two and a half decades ago, only 4 per cent of the total Ghanaian population (Gold Coast Census 1948s 18) was educated but in 1970 as much as 44 per cent was educated (1970 Ghana Population Census, Vol. 11sxxiv). This expansion has meant that more of the younger people including the fempJLe have received education. Again unlike these workers, the parents are mostly farmers and traders; the mothers following the well-known occupation of Ghanaian viiomen are in trade and the fathers in fanning. Compared to their paraits then, those factory women have achieved considerable inter-gene rational mobility in education and job done. 3h this respect they are similar to their male counterparts. However, apart from the fact that they are both first generation wage-earners, the women were in the main, in their first or second full-time job while the men tended to have had longer ri/ork history and were thus in their third, fourth or fifth jobs. It wruld appear that compared to the men, most of the women tended to have no previous experience of wage employment since even those who had had jobs before their present one, had been in self-employment. How socialized then have these women been in the conditions and ways of factory employment? How committed are they to factory employment? These two questions will be answered by looking at certain indices of the vaomen's work behaviour like absenteeism, lateness, turnover. .Absenteeism, Lateness and Turnover iO-though the absenteeism rate of the State Factory1 s employees It was found that that for the women was gaierally not hi^h (7»5$0« was higher than that for their male counterparts. The women's total absence rate was 9 per cent while that of the men was only 4 per cent. Behrend (i95i) also found a similar thing with regard to the women in the 51 factories she studied in Britain. She reports that the absenteeism rate of the British women was 5 "to 9 VQT cent, while that for the men was 3» 5 to 5 per cent. regard to the rate of absenteeism there is no difference between these Ghanaian factory women and their British counterparts. It would' seem then that with Two reasons have been put forward by Argyle, Gardner and Cioffi to explain this high incidence of women's absences? 59 i) Absonteeism is higher amour, unskilled workers and since women tend, to have less skilled jobs, this explains why they have a high absenteeism rate. i i) ' It may be due in part to domestic affairs which impinge on women, especially married women, more than on men. The first explanation does not account for the higher absence rate among the female employees in this Ghanaian factory since almost a ll the women there performed skilled jobs. The second reason seems to be the cne which explains the situation, for most of the women were married and even some who were not currently married had children. They absented themselves not only nil en they themselves' were i ll but aiso when their children were. i i i) This would seem to indicate that these female workers' external associations and interaction with their family explain many of the diversions of their time and energy temporarily from the factory. Some working time was also lost through lateness. Although Lateness was less widespread in this Ghanaian factory and was a t t r i- butable to mainly the irregular transportation system in the city of Accra, the women were • more often Late than the men. This was con- firmed by the remarks made by tho factory's supervisors. According to them, the female employees were always late to work and thus were less productive than their male colleagues* On one such occasion during the study period, ten seamstresses in the State Factory on the afternoon shift came to work twenty minutes l a t e. The senior pro- duction room supervisor stressed the fact that no tailor or male employee was among these latecomers and warned the seamstresses that they would be sent home if they repeated this practice* The 60 next day, this supervisor ordered the production room door to be closed five minutes after the start of the shift and three seam- stresses were sent home ?«id thus lost their wages for that day. Like the higher female absenteeism rate, perhaps this hi^ier female pro- pensity to be l a te to work cam. also be explained in terms of the duties they have to perform at home. This would thus seem to be cue of the consequences of a woman or more precisely of a mother or wife* combining her house duties with wage employment outside the home* TCLth regard to turnover, none of the state factory's employees It was however, obvious from responses to the question left i ts employment either voluntarily or involuntarily during this period. "would you like to continue to work in this factory or go elsewhere to work?" that some of the employees wanted to leave but had not actually done so because of their inability to obtain alternative employment or find" the capital to set up themselves in private practice. leave, the seamstresses were generally inclined to stay. This might be explicable in terms of the fact that the former have higher aspirations because they are primary breadwinners, and, therefore, were searching for avenues- where they could be adequately rewarded. The seamstresses, on the other hand, can be regarded to some extent as secondary bread winners* It was found that while most of the tailors wanted to Informal Relations With regard to informal associations at the work place, it was observed that both the men and the women employees engaged in them. There were friendship associations, nSusutf groups, card-playing groups and other specialised associations like the cigarette-sharing and lottery groups. Some of these groups overlapped in the sense that for example, workmates who are friends may also belong to the same "Susu" group, or share sticks of cigarettes. It was, however, observed that some of the informal associations were sox-linkodj only men for example engaged in cigaixDt to-sharing .and in working on the lottery. u/ith regard to the Su.su /"-croups, those tended to be mixed groups. These informal associations were sometimes carried outside the factory. This was, however, done to a very limited degree owing to a number of factors - the marital statuses of the workers? their residential non-propinquity and the fact that they ai gaged in additional money-earning activities in their free time after work. Marriage (see Peil 1972bs6) has been found to limit the worker's freedom of movement off the job since the time off the job tends to be spent with spouse and children at home. The women, after work or at the week-end when they did not go to work, engaged in household chores like cooking for the husband and children, washing and ironing of their clothes .and those of their family and in going to the market. (see Table 2)0 This table indicates an interesting sex difference in the off-the-job activities engaged in by the men and women workers.. For example, the household activities already mentioned were in the main done by the women, although generally for both men -and women their single most important activity en Sunday is going to Chapel, since most of them belonged to one Christian religion or other, on Saturday they wash and iron and after work on the -working day, many just rest. The women, however, rest in addition to performing their household chores, while this is not the ca.se with the men workers. The women did not indulge in much visiting after work not only because their household chores took a, lot of t h e ir free time, but also because the workers did not a ll live in the same neighbourhood nor near each other but were scattered throughout the city. small to MI with one industry or in an isolated community like a mining village, work mates are the same people one meets during leisure (Dennis, Hairiques and Slaughter 1956*79-82; Gouldner 1954« 134-6). Blawner (1960s35)? however, says with reference to factory In a 62 workers in the city that occupational communities rarely exist among them. Since the workers, in my study, lived in different parts of th« city and taking into consideration Accra c i t y 's irreguXar transpor- tation system at t he time of the study and i ts relatively high, expense for t he lowly paid worker, it could not "be envisaged that there would be much interaction between workmates off the job. The Bn-ployees' off-the-.job Activities* by Day of the TJeek and Sex Sunday f. m. Saturday f. m. TTbrking Day All A c t i v i t i es 143 182 126 226 145 Class of Activity A) Household Dirties Wash/iron Cecil Cleaning 3) Recreation II" n in - W - I H I MM Totals Cin ema/drinldn g b a r /f 00 tb a ll T V/mu si c/raA io Cardgame/taHc Rest Totals r>> Other Out side A c t i v i t i es CTnarch Visits Travel to hometown Attended funeral ¥ent to market/shop Totals D) Sewing/Private Business E) Haircut/Platted Hair 18 3 3 24 8 3 4 21 36 38 16 7 5 0 66 16 1 26 42 20 88 5 0 3 3 13 45 8 3 4 8 68 10 3 24 4 2 30 10 2 /* 0 13 31 3 15 8 2 3 31 33 1 57 39 36 132 7 1 ^ '-f 5 17. 2 10 4 2 33 51 22 4 0 2 5 7 3 9 13 45 70 16 18 2 1 3 40 27 1 15 -> 16 65 3 7 8 35 % •) ^ 17 0 2 15 46 1 186 Activities in class as percentage of all a c t i v i t i es A) B) 0) 17 25 46 12 0 100 48 7 37 5 2 -99 24 25 25 26 0 100 58 8 23 9 2 100 5 48 28 18 1 100 35 29 24 11 0 99 Totals •* Activities l i ke "took my bath" and "ate" were excluded from the table because almost every employee did than. Both the msi and woman, wore found to operate "businesses in addition to their factory work. These took the form of sewing for t h e ir private customers in their spare time and in a few cases petty trading. They said they engaged in these money-earning a c t i v i t i es to supplement their poor factory pay* During the study, it was realised that the major grievance of most of the factory's employees vras that their pay was small which in July 1972 averaged /$36.OO monthly. Most of them reported that "they could not make ends meet on t h e ir factory pay and therefore had sometimes to borrow from friends and money lenders as well as use their free time to work for money. This meant that they had l i t t le or no leisure time within which to v i s it work- mates ?nd other friends off-the-job. This short exposition has illustrated a number of aspects with regard to the female employees in the garment factory studied. They have been shorn to be educated, have a relatively short work history in wage employment and comparatively young compared to t h e ir male colleagues. They have young children but are working full time, with respect to t h e ir work behaviour, they have higher absenteeism aid lateness rates owing to t h e ir home obligations which tend to interfere with t h e ir factory working time. At the workplace, they fGun friendly and other informal associations with their 64 colleagues although these did not tend to extend much outside the confines of the factory organization. These are a few of the side lights which were shed on female employment from this case study of a Ghanaian gam en t factory. Being a case study meant that one cannot generalise on the findings. To find vjhether the findings of this present study are applicable to other Ghanaian women employees, therefore, it would be necessary to do a further study in which sxi attempt is made to cover a large number of these employees. Ibotnotes 1) In i960, the percentage of uneducated Ghanaians was but in 1970 the per cent age had decreased to 56. Q% made up. of 49.3^ males and 66.^ Vol. I I, p. xxiv). (See 1970 Census females. 2) Boserup (1970s 109) mentions that Ghanaian women employees form only 3 per cent of the total industrial labour force. 3) This trend is illustrated by the work history of a 32 year old Ga Seamstresso After completing her elementary educa- tion, she entered trading but abandoned it because, in her own words? "trading is not a fitting job for an educated woman." She fpt apprenticed to a Seamstress in Accra and, after one year, got employed to a garment factory as a Seamstress 4) Two sets of interviews were dones the one at the beginning of the study sougfrt to e l i c it information on the basic .social characteristics of the workers like age, marital status, employment history, ethiic background and number of children. The second interview at the end of the study concerned i t s e lf with the workers outside work activities. A lot of data was also collected throu^i observation. 5) These are contributory clubs where members contribute fixed sums of money at regular intervals and the sum realised is given to each member in rotation. 66 Bibliography Arayle, M., Gardner, G. and Cioffi, F. 1958 Behrend, H. Boserup, E. 1951 1970 Central Bureau of S t a t i s t i cs Confederation of B r i t i sh Industry Date-Bah, B. ELkan, Klein, V. 1967 1972 1974 1955 1948 i960 "Supervisory MethDds Related to Productivity, Absenteeism snd Labour Turnover" Human Relations, Vole 11 pp.23-4° j&sence under full Employment Monograph A3, University of Birmingham. I/oman* s Rol e in Economic Development, London, George Alien & tin win, Ltd. 1970 Population Census of Ghana Vol. 119 Ac eras Govern- ment P r i n t e r. Employing Tiiomens The Employers1 View. London. "Informal Relations Among the Employees of a Ghanaian "Factory", The Ghana Social Science Journal Vol. 2, No*i, pp. 86-71 "Societal Influences on york Behaviour and Interaction of Ghanaian T/orkerss A Case Study" Ph.D. Thesis, Faculty of Commerce and Social Science, University of Birmingjiam. An African Labour Force, East African Studies No. 7, Kampalas East African I n s t i t u te of Social Research. Gold Coast Population Census London. Tferkinfc wives. I n s t i t u te of Personnel Management, Occasional Papers, No. 15* K l e i n, V. Lambert, R«D. McCall, D. 57 1961 1965 1963 1961 Bnploying Married Tifomen, London: Institute of Personnel Management. Tom en 'Jorkers, Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation arid Development. Ilforkers, Factories and Social Change in India, Princetons Princeton University Presso •Trade ?nd the Hole of the wife in a Modem "Jest African Tom" in Social Change in Modem Africa, Southall, A.V/. (ed. ). Moore, 17.E. & FelcTman,A. S. (eds.) P e i l, M- 1960 1972a 1972b Labor Commitment and Social Change in Developing Areas, New York Social Science Research Cbuncil* The Ghanaian. Factory vTorkers Industrial Mm in Africa^ Cambridg Cambridge University Press. "Men' s Lib?" Le/pn Family Research Papers No. 3? Oppong, C«^ (ed.) Universitry- of Ghana? I n s t i t u te of African Studies.