DESIGN or A REINFORCED I ' Thesis for the Degree oI B S I MICHIGAN STATE. COLLEGE Henry G Dunkererg ‘ ‘ I943 9'-"* CONCRETE .QPEN SPA'NDRELl-BR‘IDCE' 7 f __- ————. ‘l-—‘ ALA...‘ .__ _ —I.I. A. _Q_ .fl-” 1- _ 4-_‘____. 4A ____A_ -__‘_.‘_-.____._.____nn‘___-a_n_ .- __- i _ _ n_m- -—__-.___-_—__._ _. w... . .k a... {w In... . a . 4‘ .0.§...,.\. \- u \ulc../r.. fr... If ., ..,,......,...............¢..._z . . .. . ..\r.. . .. .1. IN. .\.-- . _ 7...... .. H.732-.. u: \ I ._. v.-‘..m \u\ u;5 In v». .A‘II .146 . H.. r ’1... .u- ..v .. .h........vw.... .\. . . wsfifimmwfihvx 53% $9.153 . .. .. .2802 .\. r‘ . . . .. . . at"! r. . . . .- IMI.A . F“ u r 4 . . . . .. ...... ‘. I . .I..I . MI: . .. _ . . . .. 1...”..nfiulmp... ....§Iauu1.|.§.4 5". II. .. .123}... ......._ .. .. . is. .u 2.. 4 . _ . _ _ 2.... .n: . . . .. 22......2. . . . 2 a. 3...... <4... .3...... r... 1...}... m . . . s... r _ . . . , 3.-.». .34..- ........33.-.... -. 7.). ... v 2........;.. s . . .........m..r\.?.... 1:. .1. 1.1. . .... 0.1 .. .. . .. . $..w«.re-nr 4.. J .12 - . ..v.. IO. .0 .. . 3: ....L....._... . . .... .. _ . I .. .53....2... 2..... .A w.r6..ru 3%.. Jr]. Ivmle..fl .. \ v0.\. . 0.! : a...\..l:o.. .. . . ~..\_ . .PIWHOuMfiler wk)». .cl..... ., .. . . ...w:.. I . ».A.< .r .. .. I l . . . u t . a..- w .r I.“ 2.... . . .. v... . . .. . .. . . . -«ww..,wu.. ..8....: yr. .2... in... 2..... .2.“ «M». .2“... 4:... ,. .. ...... . . .. . . . ..._ . ..........¢..u-_....-... 2.. . 2.3... ; c. .v a .y ..:.. If JV urn-3%.- :.¢\-u f..! .... 2.. \2 ... ._.._..m...‘ _ .~._-...-.........u W... J . “7.. ..., ,. v ,. n . n. . . . . .l 0,19 . l .12.»?! . .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . r .. (LOCI. fl .5 5.3....) ..... wlflvfn (3‘). . I .. . . . . . ..I.... . ... , . n. u. \ n V.I. u. I L . Xx . . . .. 303 [N ,h . Design of a Reinforced Concrete Open Spandrel Bridge A Thesis Submitted to The Faculty of MICHIGAN STATE COLLEGE of AGRICULTURE AKD APPLIED SCIENUE by 1’ r" (-7‘ . \ .,- e “. Henry G..Qpnkelberg Candidate for the Degree of Bachelor of Science June, 19h} TABLE OF COET31.TS Page Acknowledgment.......................... ...... .......... Introduction.......................,... .......... .......1 Design of floor slab, floor beam and spandrel column.... Design of floor sléb.................................. 3 u Design of floor beam....r: .......... ...... ......... ...5 Design of spandrel column.............................7 9 Design of arch rib. ................. ...........L...... Drawings and design of abutment......Pbcket on Back Cover D' ‘ . l‘ - _ . h .. ’ '5. -H It .. . “- 4. a... ”.2 ..... lI-‘I eAcK OF BOOK iibwd matron-53mm: The author wishes to express his appreciation to Professors C. L. Allen, J. E. Meyer, and G. A. Miller of the Civil Engineer- ing department of Michigan State College for their invaluable suggestions and.aid in the following design. Also, his appreciation is extended to Mr. Veigt, head of the Michigan State Hiway Bridge Drafting Room and other members of his department, who so willingdy gave information and suggestions as to bridge design problems. IIITROZ'MCTIOE The importance of bridges is unquestionable when one reads the history of the world. Important battles have been fought at bridge sites, weary miles of travel have been saved by the spanning of tur- bulent rivers and impassable canyons. The very lives of many peOple have been altered by bringing within easy reach routes to heretofore inaccessible places of market and.trayel. From.the ancient draw bridges over castle moats to the magnifi- cent engineering structures spanning the San Francisco Bay and the Golden Gate,bridges have been essential to civilization. In the beginning, if a bridge was structurally sound enough to support the traffic upon it, it served its purpose. Ifith.the development of civilization, however, and the building of arch bridges, the requirements for a bridge grew. no longer was structural soundness sufficient. The structure must also present a pleasing appearance. And some of the ancient ardh bridges which have stood through the years with their graceful, pleasing, spans surpass many of the modern attempts at artistic design. With the advent of reinforced concrete as a building material, . a new type of structural beauty has come into existence. The modern builder wdth his modern materials and greatly accelerated construction methods, must now vie with the ancient day builders for that illusive gracefulness and artistic orginality in bridge design. It is with these thoughts in mind that the author presents this fdlowing arch design. First the bridge must be structurally sound and then it must present a.pleasing appearance in harmony with the setting. The ground profile used in the design, while only assumed, ap- proaches very nearly the conditions to be met with the building of a new bridge at Berrien Springs, Michigan, to span the St. Joseph river. The greatest difference in the design site and the actual site is that three or more spans would be needed to cross the St. Joseph river. It is the author's Opinion that the following arch design could be used as one of the spans for this bridge. Design of floor slab, floor beam and spandrel column. Fbr references see "The Design of Reinforced Concrete Structures" by Dean Peabody, Jr. The pages will be noted below. Notations and Equations. b a width of section. h a total depth of section. d e distance from extreme fiber in compression to the center of gravity of the steel in tension. jd = moment arm of internal couple. kd a distance from extreme fiber in compression to neutral axis. EC 5 modulus of elasticity of concrete. t M. modulus<3f elasticity of steel. n a ”ratio. of moduli, or ES 30 fC I maximum intensity of fiber stress in concrete. f8 5 average intensity of fiber stress in steel. M = external moment at the section. MD I positive moment of resistance exressed in concrete terms Mn sznegatize moment of resistance expressed in concrete terms As I area of steel AP = area of positive tension steel An 5 area of negative steel v e'unit shear R a least radius of gyration H e axial column load 2 ._f . ‘p'_£2=. kada pageEu 1L Min. (13/ __1-_'I page 2’4 Kb AP .333. page 211, f8 35. v ‘3 page 36 b j d R J E pa e 227 . .A Design of Floor Slab (pages 22-25) Span between center of supports is 13'-u". Designing slab as simply supported for positive moment and.using 2 I¥%_ for negative moment is on the safe side. Assume 7“ slab Live load 8 200 lbs. per sq. ft. Dead u g 88 u u n u Total '288 " u u .. Using 2500 lb. concrete fc I 1200 fs .L 18000 lbs. per sq. in. n =.12 k = .h ,j -= 1- pg - .867 . 3 . 2 no a 3.33 - 288 x (13.33) = 76,800 in lbs. ‘ . 8 , 8 . ’p‘f kad2 =76,800inlbs. mlo d2 = __»Zb,SOC x 2 = 5.21 1200 x .857 x .h x 12 Minimum d = 2.29 Assuming 7/8" steel, 1—1/2" covering, 1/2" wearing surface on t0p from Kichigan State Hiway Specifications. h 8 d + clearances e 2.29 + 1/2 + 1-1/2 + 1/2 = n.79 Hence 7" slab satisfactory Commercial d = 7 - 2.5 8 6.5 Positive steel Ab . i = 78,800 a , 6 . 1 . ‘ ring a ,18,000 x .867 x 6.5 75 Sq n Use 2 — 3/M” round bars 6" on center Plot 5, page #36 gives point of inflection for positive bending moment at 10% of clear span or lhh x .l 8 1h". Point of inflection for negative bending moment is at 21.5% of clear span or 31". Hence steel is bent up between these points. Design of Floor Bean (pages 55-60) A'beam with two equal overhangs, supporting a uniform distributed load. The most favorable condition is when the bending moment at the center equals the bending moment at the supports. f the distance between the supports 8 d and the length of the beam = L, equal bending moments are obtained at the center and supports When d = .5x6 L. In this de- sign L = M5' giving d 8 .586xu5 = 25.u'. d is taken as 27"the distance between the centers of the arch ribs. Assume a 16" x 32" beam. Live load 8 200 lbs. per sq. ft. ON Dead load = _§_§ lbs. per sq. ft. Total floor load a 288 x 13.3 = 3830 lbs. per lin. ft. Wt. of beam 8 15x32 x 150 =' :3” u u u u . 1 ' . Total uniform lad 3 36” lbs. per lin. ft. 4364 7 x 45': 146,300. JIIHIIT [[UJll III, 9' 27' I 4' 48.6.50" Q8,650 ‘ SHEAHL fl 'BEhflMLH§ l moment W ~ 4376.800 476,300 " 2500 lb. concrete fC- = 1000 fS 8.18000 K a 185 plot page uju Minimum d =‘/ 'g 8 J 226;000 x 12 ‘ 30-3" . Kb , 185 x 16 . Assume one TOW'Of l—l/u " bars. Min. clearance to stirrup 2.00 Stirrup diameter .50 Distance to center of bars .63 Tbtal 3.13 Hence use 16"x3h" beam. An 3 M = 226,000 x 12 = 5.7% sq. in. * _f‘Dj d 18,000 x .867 x 30.3 - 6 Use h l-l/h" square bars. An.‘L§E__ = 176.800 x 12 3.21 sq. in. .fs 3 d I 18,000 x .857 x 30.3 Use M one inch square bars. Shear v = 59.350 v s ,_1_ = 59.330 a 130 lbs. per sq. in. , bjd lox.807x32 . Allowable v using web reinforcement without ordering anchorrage of longitudinal steel 8 150 lbs. per sq. in. Eence beam is satisfactory. Design of Spandrel Column (pages 223-228) The longest unsupported column will be 18'. Assume column l6"x18" x 18' long. R =.f__"" = J 18 x (16)3 = n.63 12 x 18 x 16 . PIH Limiting lengfih - h = to R - 185". Actual length a 18x12 8 216“ giving a long column with radius of gyration of h.b3. Column load = 98,650 lbs. wt. of col. '= 5,000 " 001. 18x16 x 150x18 114$; Total . n a 10u,050 lbs. By article 306. page M01 for column with lateral ties, fc ‘ 553. By article 1108 b fe.A = 1.33 - ;L_ , 120 R fc‘A fe = 563 (1.33 — 18x12 ) a 563. A 120 X1Lb3 , U = fe x A (1 x (n~1)p) ' fe x A (l x 11p) 10h,050 a 530 x 18 x 16 (1+llp) p ='-029 As 8jp A 8 .029x288 = 8.35 sq. in. Use 12-l"'round.bars and 3/8" ties 12" on center. Design of the Arch Rib Fbr references and derivations of formulae used see "Bridge Engineering" Vbl. I by J. A. L. waddell, pages 783- 877. The diagrams noted are to be found within these pages. Rotations The Calculation of Stresses in Arch Ribs with Fixed.Ends. L 8 length of span of arch, r s rise of arch, x,ly I co-ordinates of any point with reference to the crown C as an origin, y being positive when measured down- ward, and x being positive in each half when measured from the crown toward the springing, a 8 angle of inclination of the axis at any point, Fig. 37t B = angle of inclination of the axis at the springing, L i length of rib, measured along the axis ( = 2 ds), b e width of rib at any point, b 4- width of rib at crown, 0 b8 8 width of rib at springing. h Bthickness of rib at any point, measured.normally to axis, ho" thickness of rib at crown, measured normally to axis, hS 5 thickeness of rib at springing, measured normally to axis, A = area of rib at crown, or area of concrete plus n times area of steel, A0 8 area of rib at crown, or area of concrete plus n times area of steel, 10 I : moment of inertia or rib at any point, or moment of inertia of concrete plus n times moment of inertia of steel, Io = moment of inertia of rib at crown, or moment of inertia of concrete plus n times moment of inertia of steel, Fig. 17t J Iq 8 moment of inertia of rib at springing, or moment of inertia of concrete plus n times moment of inertia of steel, E = coefficient of elasticity of the concrete, to be taken as 2,000,000 when dimensions are in inches, and as 288,000,0C0 when they are in feet, w = coefficient of linear expansion of concrete ( = 0.000006), t e change of temperature in degrees Fahrenheit, positive when the temperature rises, negative when it falls, P1’ P2, P3, etc., = any loads on the arch, acting in any direc- tion, Po 8 equivalent uniform load at crown, pS 8 equivalent uniform load at springing, naps, 1Do I J- p 8 equivalent uniform load at any point, B V , Mo = thrust, shear, and moment at crown, 0’ O H Ma 8 thrust and moment at crown from arch shortening, a! Ht’ Ht 3 thrust and moment at crown from temperature change, C = coefficient of temperature thurst, Fig. 37ff t yo 8 vertical distance from crown to plane of contraflexure for arch shortening and temperature change, Fig. 37ff T1 3 normal thrust at any section in left half of rib, positive when compressive, 11 Tr 8 similar quantity for right half of rib, T a Hormal thrust in general, T '= normal thrust at the springing, M 8 Actual beniing moment in general, M In actual bending moment at springing, on = moment coefficient Fig. 37ee Equations sec B = leT (hr)? I” h 3 ho +.§§ (Es - hg) sec a L sec. D u 3 p8 . 53 Thrust due to loading . hSr T 8 H see a o m '2 sec B As Ho Thrust due to arch shortening Ia Ha=-(1+o.3_:. Hoh2 Io "2"Q"B r sec Moment at or near a.spandre1 col. due to loading Moments at other points due to loading M = + DOLE 3000 Positive and negative live load moments (exclusive of the effect of arch shortening) at the crown, springing and various intermediate points. 12 M = 0m pL3 Moments due to arch shortening Ma 3 -Ha yo 1.: a sa (y-yo) MS 8 Ha (r- '0) Moments due to temperature changes i: = Ht (If-3'0) MS a H.c (r-yo) The following procedure is used to calculate the arch rib. 1. Assume values of ho, hS and calculate p0, p3. and.u, for dead load.plus one half live load. I 2. Compute Io’ 1; .2 and 3 Io L 3. Figure the dead and live load stresses at the crown and springing and at one point in the haunch. Use Fig. 37ee H. Compute the stresses for arch shortening at the same sections. Use Fig. 37ff. 5. Compute the stresses from temperature changes at the same section. Use Figs. 37 ff and 37 gg. 6. Test the various sections for the calculated stresses. Calculations of Arch Rib L e span a 120' _3_'. 50 5 .hl6 L 120 13 sec B = (1 + (Pi)? = 1.91'r L Assume each rib 3‘-0" thick x MJ—h" wide at crown 6l_on n X hP—M" u n springing hsuho) SEC 9. h=h0 +_2_:5( sec B u 36 + £3 ( 2—76) sec a = 35 + .309 x sec a 120 1.9fi . Po and pg for dead load + 1/2 live load p0 for one rib D. L. floor - paving, spandrel cols, etc. 6,lOO#/1in ft. Arch rib 3'-0" x h'—u" x 150 lbs. 1,950 " " Live Load - 60' span ~200#/sq ft including impact 2,250 II II 1/2 (L. L.) 200 x 22.5 x 1/2 Total 10,300#/lin ft. pa for one rib D. L. Floor - paving spandrel cols, etc. 7,275fi/lin. ft. Arch rib 6'u0" x u'-M" x 150 lbs. X 1.0h 7,5“0 1/2 (L. L.) as for pO 2,250 17,065#/1in. ft. u '25 - 11,065 = 1.66 .po , 10,300 . ,4 Assume reinforcement as 0.5a in eadh face throughout located at a distance of‘E from the surface. 10 :. I0 = bh3 — From tables d . .106 e .106 x n.33 x 3 x 3 x'3 - 12.h IS = .106 x u.;; x 6 x 6 x 6 a 99.25 a???” 1h Stesses from dead load + 1/2 live load Crown 9 I... 2 Ho ‘ Po1 (n+5) = 10,300 x 12 # , , 1* o 9 Mo - p01“ = 10,300 x 130“ = 98,000 ‘1500 ' 1500 Raunch——say at a spandrel col. located at a distance of _JL from the crown 10 , # T I: 58;; + l408,000 . 1# M a + 98,000 Springing # Ts B M08,000 x 1.9M = + 792,000 \1 .. 2 ' ' ,1? . 3000 . 3000 Live Load Moments Crown Mo 8 f Cmpl2 - 0m from tables at crown haunnh .springing 1# Mo = 3 .00u3 x M500 x‘1202 = 3 278,500 Haunch 1 9 a MO . 3 .007 x M500 x‘IEU = z 1“511.000 Springing ___2 1? M0 - f .023 x MSOO x 120 I 1 1,H90,000 Stresses from.Arch Shortening Crown H'-(1+.113)Hh2 2 a J in o o B a -1+(.3x8) 3 Ho . ‘5‘“; 0 I Be . ‘ Egg; 1.9M # s -.00hu5 Ho - - 1820 15 IS = 8 from tables ‘Zg = .225 when __ I0 "3 y = .225 x r 8 .225 x 50 = 11.25 o . 1% 34a a -Ha yo = 1820 x 11.25 = + 20,050 Eaunch' . 7." T 3 say - 1,800 H? 1: = Ha (or-yo) = —1820 (6-11.25) = + 10,!+70 Springing . # g = Ha x coo = Ha 4 en E = -1820 4 1.9U = - 9h0 '4. 1:3 = Ha (r-y) = ~1820 (50-11.23) = - 70,500 Stresses for Temperature Changes Crown 50° 28.11 30° Rise Ht g Gt £13.32; Cc from tables . r2 - -le.000006 x50 3, 288,000 x 12.1; - -12,850# +. 7,700“ 5°" ' Ia _ .18 Mt = -Ht yo = 12,850 x 11.25 “1110.500 - 86,500 Haunch . 'zl.‘ at T = say - 12,850 + 7,500 . 15 P! 2-: - 12.550 x 5.25 + 67.500 + 140.900 Springing H # at T3 ' coo .-.. - 12,850 x 1 a - 6,620 3,970 ' . t . 131+ , '..# 3.3% ms - Ht (r-yo) a - 12.850 (50.11.25) = 497,500 ~298,000 The Three Sections are now Tested as Follows: Section at Crown Temperature not Temperature Thrust Considered Considered Dead + 1/2 live + u08,000 +‘u08,000 Arch Shortening . 1,820 - 1,820 Temperature - 50° Fall ------ - 12,850 Total + h06,l80 + 393,330 Koment Deed + 1/2 live + 98,000 + 98,000 Live Load - Positive + 278,500 + 278,500 Arch Short + 20,h50 + 20,u50 Temp. 50° Fall ------ T IMMI50O 1# 1% Total + 396,950 + 5ui,u5o «9 u# 0r h,760,000 6,500,000 e - 16m 4 Thrust = 11.72" 16.51" Dimensions h x b a 36"x52" : 1872 sq. in. g ~71;§ a 3.6 = 2.18 e .11.?2 R/fc I U 60. 00 a .118 00 000 _ 52% 600 . 52x%§5€7‘80— $236 d’ = .6 . .l .l h '%3’ , p per face Fig. 37g. This is satisfactory. Section in Haunch Thrust # # Dead + l/2 Live + U08,000 + h08,000 # # Arch Short - 1,800 - 1,800 Temp. 50° Fall ------ - 12,850 1 ' # , # “30.909 393.390 17 Temperature not Temperature Considered Considered Moment 1% 1# Dead + 1/2 Live + 98,000 + 98,000 Live Load Positive + h5u,000 + 05%,000 Arch Short + 10,070 + 10,n70 Temperature 50° Fall —————— + 6[,500 u# 1# + 562,H70 + 7,560,000 n# n# or 6,750,000 7.560,000 e = Mom a 16.6" 19.25" ,.mnmt Thickness Hbunch Section 8 h = hO + .309 x sec d sec =: J 1,+(§¥§FE = 1.3 h-36+.309;_ x1.3=56+52 1+1" . 10 . Dimensions Ml x 52t a 2132 sq. in. h . hl - ' = 2.u7 = 2.13 _. .7 __ e , 10.6 19.25 p per face .55 x‘%g 8 .h83fl .3839 l R/fc Fig. 37g fc ' ._§§__ = 6,£50,000 B .bh- X .128 '52 X -1- x .128 60k Section at Springing Thrust Dead + 1/2 Live + 792,000 Arch Short - 900 Temp. 50° Fall ..... Total + 791,050 2, 60,000 52 x .12 z .129 = 671 + 792,000 - 900 - 6,620 + 78M,hh0 18 Temperature not Considered Moment Dead + 1/2 Live - h9,000 Live Load - negative —1,h90,000 Arch Short - 70,500 Temp. 50° Fall ..... '# -l,609,500 "# or 19,300,000 e = Mom 3 2h,h" . Thrust Dimensions hxb = 72x52 8 37th sq. in. .2 a ' 2 ' = 2.95 e , '%E.h . R/fc 8 19,300;000 = .1193 . 52i72 00 . i=2 =-05 h , 72 . p per face Fig. 37g .39 Steel for the arch rib Crown Dimensions hzb a 36" x 52" = 1872 sq. in. 9 per face = .55% ' Use 12 - 1“ sq. bars in each face raking p = 1221 = .6Mfl .1872 Eaunch Dimensions hib = M1" x 52" = 2132 sq. in. 0 per face = .h83fi J. Temperature Considered - M9,000 -l,h90,000 - 70,500 - 298,000 I -199079500 # I 22,860,000 29.2' = 2.h65 §§§§32999 . .1086 52x72 x780 . _ ...._Cl». ._......——._4 A.) A «b- ' J‘A' 19 Use 12 — 1" sq. bars in each face maaing p 8 122:1 = .55;3 . 2132 Springing Dimensions hxb = 72' x 52" = 37MM sq. in. J p per face = .35 Use 1° - 1" sq. bars in each face making p = 12:21 = .3256 . 3753 fl? - 7L4 C’llrff/Lfi‘ - J ‘_ .7 5.. 22076" 5 b OPE-N anemone-L que- 16143 1 JUNE 5H 2+7 ' Cit-Ni-‘RAI. pLAN - Deanm—n 87 8.911 DRAWN BY H1010 NORMAL LE—v H- # LlVE— LOAD = zoo/5Q H OPE-N spANDIzE-t nubqt- Allen-I LoAbmq Dr-squt-D By HMO ~ JUNE— 1443 “0121111034 BY Haw aide-661' ‘2_ ' o-‘P-Zi":3£m. “12.1%; 3-2;“. 7' ‘ ‘ ‘“ _—""'L 1 1 L § 7 50201410205— - Lave LOAD " — SLAB w ‘ v A O n “F 0 W8 ‘0 6 V \ .9. u 1' “1 4 0; A w 2 w 0 K Hem/v — N— ctr/V“ ' """ NM 31 h") 66 6 ix. it Q i 5‘“ » 11,200 / \ ~ , s 9 /,/ j o 1 ° ‘ 0 / 1 °‘ 9 \ : F39 l \L- )7 / / / / a. 10,000/3QH3 15.11 = 154,000 THIS Is GflZE-AIHZ THAN 12 , HerCfr ABUIME-NT us 3A71sf—Ac7027 10' DH : “120° lw5 2.4' qu N075- :~— W. = wanes-17 Of— [—2061] WALL we = .. wmq WALLS , ALL A SECTION 07- Asuwem 1'Wme f-O‘QCE—s SHOWN 001451061151) AS ACI'NCI 0N OPE-N .spANDne-L 311.1qu- ABUIME-NI DE-SquE-D 87 Mid). DRAWN BY Iii-2w JUNE- 1943 sue-e7 3 “5T >3 "111' I'll 11 M 111111! 111'" ~\. I . I l M 2: \mL 1.1 1 1 1 1 1 1 llL/lli/ /§ 9 *1 4-0: BARS 4* 1:123“ ' ’i” 51'1”” I ' ”$12—13: BATES '[YPICM I‘ANSVl-RSI' SI-ctuon SCALE- 1'34, L 17" J, 14;] V 1 l ‘1, / 21/ — \v \. \. 1;. i \ 4 ~1 "'3 “BARS \ . I I . . .A- 3" , x ‘ . ' > i A '2 I _ l -., . A I. (f - . P“ ' l I "”l— g 95 13/125 6" 0.0 ‘. x W/ 4~ if; 0 BARS Iypucm. Louqnuomu Suva» SCALE— 1‘: 2' fir c; ——-———-—-—-— T *7. 0 250811125 *Aa‘ Cowuu 87:07 ScALe— inc—'2' f_ _______~_ ‘3 .3 o O o 211" . A‘CH l|~q S‘IUI 4”£¢BA125 SCALE- Ini 2' F L H Ll] E‘LE-VAIION fl 55—07106: HANDuAu W"~“ W~-~v¢’”w"‘w‘\/V’V‘ ‘ 111‘— 3210" Alarm-NI E-LAVApON SCALE 1 z 6' (T'j :w! ~ ‘ lZ~ \"cp 0/515 / 3-7183 12"o.c. MK BATTER 451053 {70 110" TYPICAL Cowman SCALE- 1'2 4 OPE-N .spANuut-L 31:1an DE-IAILS DESIQNE'D 137 91010.. Jun: 1443 ‘DD'AWN .37 11.2140 SHE-ET 1+ ‘5. F. ”42' we: I, r z - ' .. —. j 1‘ ‘1' ””01!“ «#11;- 519%., 32" 3"» ‘2‘“ -‘ r. 1‘ .- -3..- ‘¢‘-' - ' I .‘ . J t I. h J .- ta MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES II I 3 I "‘IIIIIIIEII I 1 193030126