VARIATIONS IN THE CALCIUM METABOLISM OF PRESCHOOL CHILDREN THESIS FOR THE DEGREE OF M. S. Veda E. HiIIcr ‘ I932 ’ V > In: an. 2075 Y.- ll; my”, u , H. VARIATIONS IN THE C A L C I U H M E T A B O L I S M 0F . P R E S C H O O L C H I L D R E N .03.. .00! ..~. .. .H A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Michigen_8tate College in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science . by 1.5“] Veda Engiller Department of Foods and Nutrition Division of Home Economics 1932 Acknowledgement It is indeed a real pleasure to take this opportunity to express, in some measure, appreciation of the untiring interest and helpful criticism of Dr. Jean Hawks who directed this investigation. Grateful appreciation is due, also, to Dr. Marie Dye, for her kind advice and suggestions during the entire study. 101410 I. II. IIIQPIMOIStud’IO'QO000000000000... IV. V. Table of Contents Page Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ._. . . . Review of Literature. . . . . . . . . . . . . .'. 01 up +4 Discussion of Results . . . . . . . .'. . . . . . 16 1. Daily variations in the calcium balances. 2. Differences in calcium metabolism of the two children on each diet. 3. Comparison of the reactions of the two children. A. Variations in the Caz? retention ratios. Summary......A...........c....}7 List of Tables Table: Page I. Summary of Studies on Calcium Metabolism of Preschool Children. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 II. A Comparison of the Height and Weight.of'the Children with the Woodbury Tables. . . . . . . 10 III. Composition of Medium Protein Diet. . . . . . . 12 IV. Composition of High Protein Diet. . . . . . . . 13 V. 'Tests of the Accuracy of'the Method on Known Solutions and Previously Analyzed Food Samples. 15 VI. Comparison of Calculated with Analyzed Values for Calcium Content of Food . . . . . . . . . . 17 VII. Daily Calcium Balances on the Medium.Protein Diet. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . l9 VIII.Daily Calcium Balances on the High Protein Diet 22 11. Percentage of the Calcium Intake Excreted . . ."23 x. Daily Calcium Balances on the Medium Protein Diet Calculated Per Kilogram of Body Weight . . 26 XI. Daily Calcium Balances on the High Protein Diet Calculated Per Kilogram of Body Weight. . . . . 29 XII. Daily Calcium Balances on the Medium Protein Diet Calculated Per Square Meter of Body Surface . . . . .‘. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 XIII.Daily Calcium Balances on the High Protein Diet Calculated Per Square Meter of Body Surface . . 32 Table: Page 11?. Daily Intake and Retention Ratios of Calcium to Phosphorus on the medium Protein Diet. . . . 33 IV. Daily Intake and Retention Ratios of Calcium to Phosphorus on the High Protein Diet. . . . . 34 XVI. Comparison of Balances of the Two-Children. . . 36 VARIATIONS IN THE CALCIUM IMTABOLISII OF PRESCI—IOCL CHILDREEI du n Little is known concerning the calcium requirement of children. Investigators first estimated this requirement by preportionally reducing suggested-standards for adults, which had been obtained through dietary and balance studies. The values thus obtained did not indicate the increased need for calcium during the growth period and were therefore inadequate. Later, through dietary studies on children, investigators determined the calcium needs I for the growing child more accurately. This type of re- search measured the amount of oalciun.shich children con- sumed but did not determine the amount actually needed for optimum storage. To obtain this information, it was necessary to conduct quantitative metabolism studies. Al- though several of such studies have been made they do not give a complete picture of the child's metabolic processes. This investigation is an attempt to give additional information on this problem through making a study of the daily variations in the calcium metabolism of two normal preschool children. It includes a study of their reactions on medium and high protein diets. -2- W Sherman and Hasley (8) conducted a series of calcium metabolism studies, in order to determine the rate of cal- cium storage in normal children of different ages; the quantity of calcium required for optimum storage; and the most valuable sources of the calcium. Twelve children from three to thirteen years of age served as subjects for per- iods consisting of one preliminary day plus two or three collection periods of three days each. In order to measure the rate of storage, the investi~ gators gave the children a fairly constant diet containing 750 grams of milk. The food consumed contained about one gram of calcium per day. The retentions varied from 0.15 to 0.62 gram of calcium, the amount increasing as the age and the size of the child increased. Table I shows that the Children of preschool age, on the basis of body weight, received 0.5} gram and stored 0.010 gram of calcium per kilogram per day. To find the quantity of calcium requir d for Optimum storage, the calcium intake of three of the children was varied by adding 250, 500, 750, 1000 and 1500 grams of milk to a fixed diet. The data for the two preschool children are shown in Table I. The amount retained varied from 0.008 to 0.01% gram of calcium per kilogram of body weight. The differences between the amounts stored on the - 3 - 500, 750 or 1000 grams of milk were negligible. To determine whether children could utilize the cal- cium in the form of vegetables as efficiently as the cal- cium of milk, the daily allowance of 750 grams of milk was ‘reduced to 375 grams and enough vegetables were added to yield an equivalent amount of calcium. The retention on this diet was 0.006 gram per kilogram, as compared with 0.011 gram per kilogram mn.the former diet. The authors state that this difference hn the retentions indicated that the calcium of milk is somewhat better utilized than that of vegetables. 0n the basis of all these retention figures they conclude that one quart of milk per day should be given to each child. Wang and her associates (IO) conducted calcium metab- olism studies on ten normal children and fifty undernour- ished children between four and thirteen years of age. The children received a weighed diet during a three day preliminary and a three day experimental period. On the basis of body weight, the calcium intakes of the preschool children (Table I) ranged from 0.061 to 0.082 gram per kilogram and the retentions varied from 0.006 to 0.019 gram. On the whole, the intakes and retentions were higher than those observed by Sherman and Hauley (8). The calcium absorption and retention, however, showed wide individual variations among both normal and undernourished children. In 1930, Wang and her associates (11) compiled the - h - data on 18 children obtained during their study of underb nourished children, in order to show the minimum calcium requirement. The calcium intakes varied from 0.009 to 0.103 gram of calcium per kilogram of body weight per day, and on the same basis the retentions ranged from 0.003 to 0.018 gram. In every case a calcium intske above 0.0278 gram per kilo of body weight resulted in a positive balance and below that figure the balance was negative. This diff- erence may have been due to the difference in the source of calcium, since the milk consumed varied from 130 to 1&00 grams per day. The authors concluded from their results that the minimum and not the Optimum calcium requirements for a growing child weighing 20 kilograms and living on a mixed diet would be 0.46 gram of calcium per day. , Willard and Blunt (12) made a study on the comparative influence of evaporated and commercially pasteurized milk on the calcium metabolism of three normal children, three, four and eight years of age. The method of procedure was the same as that used by Wang and her associates (10) (11). The children received a simple, adequate diet which was varied by the addition of 810 grams of pasteurized milk or _an equivalent amount of irradiated milk. As shown in Table I, the calcium intakes of the children of preschool vage ranged from 0.06# to 0.070 gram per kilogram of body weight and they retained from 0.0309 to 0.013 gram per kilogram. The amounts retained varied with the calcium .. 5 .. Thhba I ._ 001311” 01‘ 010012;... 012: 001.0130 m301.1:;;s.:~,;_ 014‘ 111120013001. calm-0:13 . m w 20 hours hildren Intake Output Retentian 9g :1 P Total '2 mt investigator Age ‘00. Total 123; aces brine Total Per Tit—e Tm.'i‘11'r-Q W1: C§§s. (am) "(007 am am (am ”am am am am gherman-Hawley 3~5 3 0.883 0.053 0.69 0.02 0.71 O.Q#2 0.17 0.010 19.3 "(béggiéiaii 0—3 2 0.386 0.020 0.23 0.02 0.25 0.013 0.14 0.000 36.3 .. u~5 2 0.677 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.00 0.023 0.20 0.013 35.5 0.211191211_. 0 00 m __ 0.5 2 0.932 0.040 0. 6 0.03 0.69 0.036 0.20 0.013 25.0 0.8:1m0.§;;‘_ 0 m _._ 4.5 2 1.207 0.063 0.90 0.00 0.94 0.009_0.2e 0.014 23.2 1giahghaLaL.JmuaaL1ithLJEXELJmLJmuug__.._i_ __ 0.5 2__ . 22 0.089 1.113 0.03 1.116. 0.076 0.27 0.009 1&1_MWWW aeg1e§ 111 0.5 2 0.666 0.033 0.51 0.02 0.53 0.026 0.10 0.007 21.0 4; . .H ' v . 0.3 2 ll&gig 0 o 0.92 0.02 0.94 0.006 0.09 0.000 8.7 .~._§eries.1v 6 _1 0.95 0.050 0.73 0.02 0.75 0.221.Q.§0 0.011 21.0 0.9;1_ fi1;1_,r x 01 m k __ 6 1 0.390 0.05 0.03 0.80 0.046 0.11 0.006 12.3 KangmL111L1930‘ 3 1 0.318 0.01 0.25 0.09 0.34 0.020 0.02, _. a .1. 1.483 0.082 1.10 0.15 1.29 0.072.0.1§.0.009 11.3 __. u 1 0.323 0.041 0.22 0.02 0.30 0.020 0.22 0.017 02.2 .1. ‘ . u 1 0.666 0.009 0.00 0.02 0.02 0.031 0.25 0.012 37.3 2222;1101L13281 5 ,1 .1.450 0.00271.1&“0.21“1.35“0.035 0.11 0.006 7.07 __ 5 2 0.900 0.067 0.74 0.07 0.01 0.057 ofimqgfl __. 5 1 0.970 0.06 0.72 0.06_0.70 0.049 0.18 0.012.19.0 _. . 1.5 2 0.778 0.061 0.51gldxagagzLjhgfle 0.209.019m11g0_ §9f33§o§2’ 3~6 4 1.09 0.05 0.60 0.06 0.66 0.001 0.02 0.0&§_55.0 1:1 .1. 3.5 u 1.36 0.0e0 0.69 0.04 0.73 0.005 0.6310.039 06.0 0.2.1 0 12. Egg??? 3-0 1.12 0.07 0.90 0.02 0.92 0.52. 0.21 0.013 13.5 1:1 W3: 3. 1‘0“ oiQQ—Qnfig 0:029:ng 0.55 0-14 0.009 13.0 1:;- - 6 - intake and were higher than those given by Sherman and -Hauley (8). Burton (2) conducted a study to determine the influp ence of cereals upon the calcium retention in four normalflfl, boys from three to five years of age. The children rear eived a fixed diet to which was added either refined wheat ‘ or oatmeal. The procedure was the same as that used by Wang and her coeworkers (10) (11), and only one day was allowed between the change in diets. Since the children had been receiving sun lamp treatments these were continued during the experimental period. The calcium intakes varied from .0.080 to 0.084 gram per kilogram of body weight and the .retention ranged from 0.039 to 0.048 gram. These retentions were considerably higher than those reported by other inves- tigators possibly due, either to the high intakes or to the influence of the ultraviolet light. iang and her associates (11) found that the calcium retention varied diryctly with "the calcium intake. A number of other investigators have shown that vitamin D may be a controlling factor in mineral metabolism whether administered as ultraviolet light, cod- liver oil or irradiated food or ergosterol. In Burton's study the intakes and retentions of calcium were less in the oatmeal period than in the wheat period. Calculated figures showed that the residues of the two diets were practically neutral. According to Blunt and Ocean (1), present day investigators believe that a neutral diet is - 7 - the most satisfactory for the storage of calcium and that diets with an alkaline residue give better retention than those with an acid residue. Recently Stearns (9) reported a study on the signif- icance of the retention ratio of calcium and phosphorus in children. She stated that a ratio of two parts of calcium to one of phosphorus would indicate a more rapid growth of bone than of the soft tissues and that ratios above this would signify a previous starvation of calcium. A ratio of less than 1 to 1 would indicate that the major growth was in the soft tissues and if long continued would result in a deficiency in the bone growth. She confirmed the statement made by Sherman and Harley (S) that more calcium is stored by very young children than by children of school age. Sherman (7): however, stated in his latest edition of “The Chemistry of Food and Nutrition,“ that if Optimum amounts are retained the ratios will care for themselves. Therefore, with the normal develcpment of the child the Optimum ratio will be constantly changing. These studies show the tendencies in calcium absorption and retention but are not conclusive because of the small number of children studied. The results of different inves- tigators are not entirely cemparable on account of the great number of variables. Some of the children studied were not physically normal, nor were their previous environmental conditions comparable in all respects. The diets used also - g - varied to a great extent and some of them were planned to study the comparative values of different foods. The pre- liminary periods were not more than three days in length and the experimental periods varied from three to nine d ys. In some studies the time between different diets was not more than one day. Investigators assumed that the body reached equilibrium during the short preliminary periods and that the experimental periods which followed were in- dicative of the metabolic process occurring in the child at all times. With these facts in mind, the plan of this experiment was to continue a test period for a long period of time and note the ordinary fluctuations which might oc- cur in calcium metabolism. W The general purpose of this entire investigation was to study the daily variations in the metabolism of two nor- mal, preschool boys, who were fed a fixed diet for an extenp ded period of time. The experiment consisted of three parts, a 15 day preliminary period, a 30 day period when the child- ren received a constant diet containing three grams of pro- tein per kilOgram of body weight and a 15 day period when the diet contained four grams of protein per kilogram. This paper is only a portion of the entire investigation and re— ports the data on the calcium metabolism of the children during the last six days of the medium protein level and -.9 - the first nine days of the high protein level. There acre several reasons for conducting this portion of the inves- tigation; first, to determine the daily variations in the calcium absorption and retention; second, to find the dif- ference in the metabolism on the two levels of protein; third, to discover whether each child re