\I __—___ ”—fl ___———— ———- _—___ __—_‘— —' __——— _—_— __._’- .___‘— ___—_—— _—_— —__—— __’——- ._——— ’— __—_ ’_—— .__—_—— __—_ __—— ’4 —_" ___——— ___.—— ’_——— ___—— 4 3‘ c , " '6’" rug...“ ‘a‘ 9.37.3-“ <‘ ‘K? I. ’ .3 L'.‘ s h “V .0 Q . . .6: -3 . . 1‘ 8......“- . M’ \..LA. ' ‘ ‘ ' 0.7 u “" 'fl .. , "h x. 6- “1’0. ”my? " " as“ ‘ nuaiéJ-I. o . '-\..- ch ‘6; '- ‘.‘. '4 ’swx ‘-"§-6N"~ .» 5|. ‘- 1 ‘ " ‘2... a"- v. I r ,w.‘ - »- - .._;-.- J ',' . ' 3.34.151. \ ".‘ ao\o-d O‘n‘ U- -—\- 1hr f fi'. “ ‘5' ,-.l\ .. .4: -\\.‘ . o 1'.‘ .' «.9 :3 ."2' a u? "1 . ' . A. "-' W A: :7; .fi‘fi. {{Ii.".‘. 0 . \J c u \f ‘3“. . ~ .. "1‘ ‘- f \o‘ — .‘k-;AQ\‘: _ ..-—-'\oo o no; ‘ I 3‘. t. \. .. 2 - ..'.s 'v'.‘ "t .‘\ Cl": blil‘ u... " 5" ll ' It". .13" ‘.. ‘ \iy; “3"1',"1.-h'-:- ‘{ v u. ’5ffi%%¢€A£&¥£WTfiw.gm£pgfl 5. ‘ ;' “_ a ~77 1. ’I ' 7‘: 1 I-.-' ‘, -5;‘— ' '7: . Ihbb":’ ‘ i ”If. h l t a 4 till; ‘ l 1. sf f Liv .-‘ “Z a ‘, .‘r . I «15" ‘ a J .‘x: I, 5 A“ ltlé”" t ‘A 9 Flu. " ‘ If ( I l ‘ l "“4 -_.'.. Ar... .- - H7 4. v 'll-IA‘. {:33 ‘.',t. . This is to certify that the ..; {3? _‘ thesis entitled Studies with Cycloheximide: Toxicity _. to Wood Rotting Fungi and Utilization '3} by Tissues and Organic Compuunds : ; presented by .; William Klomparens a. ’11 -' J 4 7" ‘ ' . ”l. -k‘ I f “i I. 7 r. has been accepted towards fulfillment of the requirements for 7‘ p _M..S._degree in Wathology a 5- .& STUDIES WITH CYCLOHEXIrIDE: TOXICITY TO woco- f< ROTTIRG EJLCI, AID ULILIZA‘LQI E” TISSUES APB ORGANIC COmPOUhDS. bv I! William chmoarens Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies of Michigan State College of Agriculture and Ap-‘ plied Science in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE Department of Botany and Plant Pathology 1950 ACKNOWLEDCELEIT The writer wishes to express his gratitude to Dr. John R. Vaughn for timely help and suggest- ions, and to the Upjohn Company, Kalamazoo, Michigan for its financial aid, without which this work could not have been done. 6 244562 lETFODUCTICK ............... LITERATURE REVIEW ............... MATE lIALS Alli) L'JI'HC_)S ............... EXPERIKENQAL RESULTS ............... DISCUSSIoi ............... CQICLYSICNS ............... SUMMARY ---—-—'--7 ..... LITERATURE CITED ——————————————— Page (1) INTRODUCTION Since l9h8 when-cycloheximide was found to be of potential value as a fungicide, practical exper- iments have shown it to be effective in many cases, both with and without phytotoxic effects, Rose mil- dew, Sphaerotheca pannosa Ltallroth) Leveille var. rosae Weronchine, was found to be controlled by a l ‘% ppm. concentration, but with some injury to new leaves; bean mildew, Erysiphe polygoni, was con- trolled by a 10.0 ppm. with no phytotoxic effects. As a turf Spray, the antibiotic apparently was ver y effective, and no phytotoxic effects were observed, from the use of applications as high as 1000 ppm. Cycloheximide at 10.0 ppm. indicated superior con- trol of cucumber scab, Cladosporium cucumerinum, in one field trial. The antibiotic demonstrated fur- ther promise for control of cherry leaf spot, Hig- ginsia hiemalis, under field conditions. Inasmuch as the early experimental work demon- strated practical uses and possible applications, an attempt was made to determine the action of the antibiotic when in contact with organic tissues and compounds. The aims of the experimental work were partially to investigate the constancy of the fung- icidal activity of the antibiotic under varied en- vironmental conditions, and also a study of retent- (2) ion, absorption, recovery, or possible translo- cation in living and non-living tissues. It was also hoped that a correlation could be establish- ed between cytological aberrations produced in on- ion roots with the absorbed quantity of the anti- biotic. Eundamental knowledge of this type should be of vital interest to scientists dealing with anti- biotics, and to those interested in fungicides. LITERATURE REVIEW Cycloheximide, an antibiotic produced by Strep- tomyces griseus, as a by-product in Streptomycin production (h,7,15,16), was initially suggested as a possible plant fungicide in l9h8. In this first fungicidal experiment (5), powdery mildew,Erysiphe polygoni, on greenhouse beans, was found to be con- trolled effectively by cycloheximide concentrations between 5.0 and 10.0 ppm. Mention was also made of possible phytotoxic effects by higher concentrations. In l9h9, in Michigan, the effect of the anti- biotic on seed germination in petri plates, and action and control on rose plants with mildew under greenhouse cenditions was investigated (13). Radish seed inhibition ranged from 100% in those soaked in 100 ppm. cycloheximide to only a delay in germin- ation at 1.0 and 5.0 ppm. The other seeds tested (pea, wheat, and bear) were inhibited less by the 100 ppm. concentration but displayed the same pro- portional change as the concertration was lowered. lhe rose mildew was controlled by 2% ppm., but the increasing of the concentration to 5, 75, and 10.0 ppm. caused injury to young and new leaves. Eur- ther investigations showed excellent inhibition in agar plates against Honilinia fructicola, Clado- sporium cucumerinum and Bones so. Also, a recheck of the bean mildew trial (l9h8) resulted in con- trol at 10.0 ppm., and no phytotoxic effects. Another possible application for the anti- biotic was described in igha by vgughn and Eamner (12). As a Spray for such turf diseases as " Dol- lar Spotss", "Brown Patch%," and "melting Cut," the cycloheximide appeared to be at least the e- qual of the fungicides commonly used, and possi- bly superior - particularly for the "Melting A ll .‘ “ out, paused by Belminthosporium 3p.. However, the spray trials were limited by changin; weath- er, and should be repeated for more definite re- Slllts 0 1"Dollar Spot" - caused by Sclerotinia homoeo- gfr and the brown patchV'caused by Pel- calaria filamentosa 3 Corticium solani. F“! de geeuw and Vaughn, in 1950, reported the cy- cloheximide as the best apparent Spray in a single field experiment with cucumber scab, Cladosporium cucumerinum (2). The antibiotic was used at 10.0 ppm. and compared with Crag 658, Tribasic copper sulfate, Dithane, and Zerlate. As a postharvest Spray for brown rot,Honilinia fructicola, in concentrations of 2.0, 5.0, and 10.0 ppm., four sprays of cycloheximide were compared with liquid lime sulfur and sulfur dusts by Peterson and Cation (8). After cold storage for two days, and common storage for four, the peaches sprayed with 2.0 ppm. cycloheximide showed 2% rotted, the 5.0 ppm. Sprayed peaches 0% rotted, the 10.0 ppm. 1.0 % rotted, the lime sulfur sprayed and dusted peaches 57 rotted, and the unsprayed peaches 7% rotted. In another test, under conditions of heavy inoculum, a 20.0 ppm. cycloheximide spray was compared with wettable sulfur and to grower sprayed liquid lime sulfur. The cycloheximide sprayed peaches showed 8h% rotted, the sulfur sprayed 67S rotted, and the grower sprayed 89%, rotted. In other trials with peaches, a 20.0 ppm. spray of cycloheximide was found to cause crack— ing in firm-ripe Halehavens, and possibly to dissolve the Skin coloring matter. The severity of these actions was less with lower concentrat- ions. The same report indicated that cyclohexi- mide may be a superior spray for cherry leaf spot, Higginsia hiemalis, in that 1.0 ppm. almost com- pletely controlled heavily spotted Montmorency leaves, and these same trees held a high percent- age of noticeably greener leaves for a longer time than the trees sprayed with "Tennessee 26", "Ferbam," "Crag Cherry Fungicide EhlB," and "Nab- am". ‘ Gottlieb et al, in 1950 (5) in a report based on visual observation of growth in liquid media of six pathogenic fungi, all but one - Monilinia fruc- ticola, were inhibited by a 100.0 ppm. cyclohexi- mide concentration. The report also stated that in phytotoxicity tests with tomato, bean, peach, geranium, and strawberry; the strawberry alone was not injured by 100.0 and 1000.0 ppm. concentrat- ions. In Canada, eight fungi were tested for Spore and mycelium inhibition, and for the effect of the antibiotic on pea seed germination by Wallen et a1 (1h). Using the agar streak method of Waksman and Reilly, spore germination varied from complete in- (6) hibition in the case of Ascochyta pisi Lib. at 1.0 ppm. to slight inhibition at 50.0 ppm. with £3213 cillium sp.. However, using the filter paper disk method of Vincent and Vincent, which consisted of placing disks saturated with cycloheximide near the growing colony, no inhibition was found in con- centrations up to 255 ppm. It was also shown that soaking infected pea seeds in varying concentra- tions of cycloheximide did not control the inter- nal parasite A. pisi; but the pea seeds were in- jured as shown by reduced germination as the con- centration increased. The same workers alSO investigated the ac- tivity of the cycloheximide on germinating pea seeds. In the lower concentrations, an abnormal, discolored root, and a long shoot resulted, while in concentrations from 10.0 ppm. and up, there was little or no germination. Recently Whiffen tested thirty-three plant pathogenic fungi in cultire for effect from var- ious concentrations of cycloheximide (17). If spores were produced, suspensions were streaked on agar plates; in the case of fungi not spor- ulating, a mycelial disk was used as inoculum. The concentration needed for complete inhib- ition after hd and 72'hours was noted. The antibiotic was found to cause complete inhibition for 72 hours in concentrations of less than 1 ppm. with Ustilago tritici, and ranged to 100.0 ppm. for 72 hour inhibition when used against Ramularia pastinaceae and Fusarium lycopersici. MATERIALS AED METHODS Since broad objectives were chosen with the hope that facts concerning absorption, retention, possible translocation or utilization, and/or re- covery might be obtained, the experimental work was divided into six separate parts dealing with different phases or dissimilar organic compounds. PART ONE Biological Assay Technique Inhibition of linear fungal growth on agar plates containing varying amounts of cyclohexi- mide*, forms the basis for assaying unknown a- mounts of the antibiotic (see TAELE I). * Crystalline, pure chemical used, unless other- wise stated. Disks, five millimeters in diameter, of Poria microspora* taken from a six day old culture - were seeded in 2% malt extract agar (Difco, dessicated), and incubated at 300 C until the necessary measure- ments were made. The medium was made up in single lots, either 500ml. or 1000 m1., and the desired dilutions made by pipetting from a standard 1000.0 ppm. cycloheximide solution into smaller flasks. The smaller flasks, containing enouwh medium for four plates, were autoclaved, and the medium pour- ed into previously labelled Petri dishes. Pour replications were used in every case. The inocu- lum pieces cut with a curved, sharpened, brass tube were seeded - fungus side up - as near the center of the plate as possible. After incubation at 500 C for forty-eight hours, the first linear measure- ments were taken with the aid of a Specially con- structed box, illuminating the culture from beneath so as to define the periphery of the colony. The growing colony was measured and the growth recorded (see TABLE I) at twenty-four hour inter- vals for six consecutive days. * Poria microspora : Poria monticola, recently has become welléknown as destructive to wood in service, (1). (9) PART TWO Retention by Wood The retention of cycloheximide by non-living tissues was investigated by using Basswood, Tilia glabra Vent. chips, and the bio-assay technique. Forty Basswood chips (5/16 x 13/8 x 2 inches), were submerged in one liter of 200.0 ppm. cyclo- heximide for a period of three minutes. The sol- ution remaining was retained for subsequent bio- assay (see TABLE III) and the chips dried to ap- proximately the original moisture content. In re- .peated leaching trials, the chips were placed in one liter of distilled water and shaken vigorously for fifteen minutes. The chips were re-dried.and the solution saved for bio-assay for cycloheximide content (see TABLE III). The control followed the procedure with chips not previously soaked in cy- cloheximide, but was determined only once as there was no evidence of either stimulation or inhibition in the assay plates. Chromated zinc chloride (DuPont) leaching was also investigated. A biological assay table was set up (see TABLE II) and leaching trials with sub- sequent assays were attempted. The procedure was identical to that followed with cycloheximide ex- cept for the autoclaving. .The chromated zinc (10) chloride precipitates under conditions of high heat so the chips were sterilized with propylene oxide (6), submerged in sterile distilled water, shaken vigorously as before, and under sterile conditions, the leaching water was added to warm, sterile med- ium for pouring into the assay plates. The leaching trials with the chromated zinc chloride were discontinued, due to the resistance of the compound to leaching under these conditions. PART THREE Leutritz Technique The Leutritz method of evaluating wood pre- servatives (10) was employed, using varied 100.0 ppm. treatments of cycloheximide and Ponderosa pine test blocks. In this method, two feeder* chips,Pinus pal- ustrig, were placed i inch apart on approximately two inches of soil in flat-topped jars. The jars were sterilized, and the feeder chips seeded with Ioria micrgspora as an inoculum disk placed be- tween the chips. After five weeks, when the chips % Feeder chips of Pinus palustris served to "feed" inoculum to the test blocks. (11) were covered with mycelium which had also pen- etrated the soil, the previously weighed test blocks were placed ; inch apart upon the chips with a treated and an untreated test block in the same jar. The treatment of the test blocks (approx- imately l/fl x l x 2 inches Einug BEEQEEBEE ) was as follows: 1. Cold soak in 100.0 ppm.* crude cyclohex- imide solution for twenty-four hours. 2. Cold soak in 100.0 ppm crystalline cyclo- heximide water solution for twenty-four hours. 5. Hot and cold bath*% for one and one half hours in crude cycloheximide water solution. A. Hot and cold bath in crystalline cyclo- heximide water solution for one and one-half hours. 5. Hot dip (three minutes) in 100.0 ppm. crude cycloheximide plus crankcase oil (at approx- imately 9hOC.). The jars were held for one hundred and twenty * All treatments with 100.0 ppm. as Hot and cold treatments averaging 950 C. and cooled in the same solution. days in a humidity chamber which averaged 280 C and 87; relative humidity? Loss in weight by the treated and untreated blocks is presented in TABLE IV. BART POUR Synthetic vs Organic Medium Two types of liquid medium were employed in this part of the experimental work.- Coon's synthetic broth (9) consisting of suc- crose, 7.2 grams; dextrose, 5.6 grams; KNOB, 2.02 grams; MgSOu, 1.25 grams; KHQPOA, 2.72 grams; per 1000 cc. of distilled water, was used in comparison to 2% malt extract liquid medium. Four concentra- tions (0, l, 10, and 20.0 ppm. cycloheximide) were used with each type of medium and four replicates containing 50 ml. of medium per flask. Eggggigg gp. was grown on a 2% malt extract agar plate and cut with the 5 mm. rod for seeding purposes. The seeded flasks were shaken contin- uously for four days, after which the mycelium was strained, dried and weighed (see TABLE V). *Leutritz jars containing quercus ruhra blocks, and tomes igniarius var. laevitagus as the wood- rotter were discarded. There was nearly a 1002 failure of the fungus to spread to either the treated or the untreated blocks from the feeder chios. The liquid media, and the mycelium, were retained for future antibiotic assay, as in TABLES VI and VII respectively. PART PIUE Onion Root Reaction Onions which had been germinated for thirty- six hours in tap water, were transferred to flat dishes holding 100 ml. of distilled water or 100 ml. of 100.0 ppm. cycloheximide in distilled water. Pour onions in each dish were left for periods of 1,2,h and 6 hours in the cycloheximide solution and in the distilled water checks. At each inter- val the onions were removed, and the solutions re- tained for biological assay. After a one minute wash in running water the onions were returned to 100 ml. of fresh distilled water for a twenty- four hour leaching period. Growth patterns for comparison to TABLE I are found in TABLE VIII. Although the roots were retained for assay, the absorption results were too indefinite to make this step of any value. PART SIX Cultural Inhibition The inhibition in culture was determined with the method described in Part I (Biological assay technique). The graphs represent a single repetition with the exception of Graph I constructed from the re- sults of TABLE I, from which all unknown cyclo- heximide concentrations were estimated. is based upon drv weight of Poria It Graph III microspora growth in 50 m1. of 2; malt extract liquid media. Twelve flasks ior each 01 five cy- cloheximide concentrations - 0.0, 0.01, 0.1, 1.0 and 10.0 ppm. were held for seven days at room temperature, after which three of each concentra- tion were removed and the mycelial dry weights noted. weight determinations were made for four successive days. Thus the graph is based upon three replications, while Graphs IV thru VII of Lentinus lepideus, Tomes igniariis var. laevig- atus, Lenzites trabea, and Schizophyllum commune as the reSpective fungi, are with four replicates, and based upon linear measurements. EXPERIMETTAL PESULTS ihe master table (IAELL I) was established from the constant linear growth rates of Poria microspora on malt extract agar plates containing known cycloheximide concentrations. The numerous replicated trials showed the method to be adequate- ly accurate to check the experimental work that was undertaken. The choice of the funéus was fortunate as its hith susceptibility to the antibiotic allowed ac- curate determinations of a small amount of cyclo- heximioe. ihe susceptible fungus further allowed an almost unlimited range for detection merely by using dilutions for the higher concentrations. The fungus served admirably also in that its my- celial growth on agar plates is comparatively flat and quite consistently forms an almost per- fect circle. The malt extract (Difco, dessicated) as a nutrient source was also found to yield re- sults consistently within the ranges of the twenty- four hour periods, even when made up from two dif- ferent lots. A burette technique for dilution in- to single plates under sterile conditions was found to be less accurate than making dilutions 01 a vol- ume sufficient for the replication of four. In periodical assays of the 1000 ppm stock (15a) solution of cycloheximide, it was found that the antibiotic did not lose determinable amounts of fungicidal activity when stored in the refriger— ator for periods up to three months. TABLE I, and Graph I, indicate that the deter- mination of a 0.01 ppm. conbentration is below the scope of accuracy of the method due to overlapping of growth ranges. However, the 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 ppm. cycloheximioe growth ranges show clear cut, in- dependent ranges at the twenty-four hour periods. This gave quite accurate determinations when used as the standard for comparison to Crowth rates in plates cintaining unknown cycloheximide concentra- tions. flhe plates with 5.0 ppm. concentration showed no growth for the six day period, but did show slight growth aiter the sixth day and-would recover if the inoculum was transferred to a plate contain- ing no cycloheximide. The plates containing a 10.0 ppm. concentration, however, inhibited all growth and the inoculum, when transferred to a pure nutri- ent agar plate after the seventh day, would not re- cover. It was noted that, except in 10.0 ppm. and up, growth on plates containing cycloheximide was pre- ceded by a marked lighter colored diffusion zone. (16) TAFLE I Growth rates of Poria microsppra in 2% malt ex- tract agar plates containing cycloheximide. Master table used for bio-assays Rate of growth in mm.* Day 2 5 h 5 6 0.0 ppm. 12.5 22.5 58.0 h7.6 61.5 Renae 9.5 17.2 25.2 57.7 5u.5 to to to to to 1h-5 25~5 39-3 h9-5 63-2 0.01 ppm. 10.7 20.1 51.6 A2.2 52.7 Range 8.2 18.5 2.14.02 56.? LL90? to to to to to 12.2 22.7 35.2 h5.0 56.7 0.5 ppm. 0 8.7 15.7 20.7 25.0 Range 8.2 11.2 17.7 25.5 to to to to 12.0 17.5 28.5 51.7 1.0 ppm. 0 6.5 9.5 15.5 18.0 Range 5.2 9.2 10.2 15.7 to to to to 7.2 12.5 17.0 22.0 2.0 ppm. 0 0 6.0 9.0 11.0 Range 5.1 8.5 9.7 to to to 7-2 9-5' 12.7 5.0 ppm. 0 O O 0 0 10.0 ppm. and up - no growth. * The daily measurements include the 5.0 mm. inoculum disk, and are based upon six trials with replicates of four. (17) The diameter of the zone varied inversely as the concentration of the antibiotic. Table II, and Graph II demonstrate the growth rates made by Poria micrOSppra in plates containing chromated zinc chloride. As previously mentioned, the chromated zinc chloride was to be used as one commonly employed water soluble wood preservative in contrast to the antibiotic, cycloheximide, as a wood preservative. Since attempts to analyze the original dipging solution of chromated zinc chlor— ide after the three minute dip indiCQted there was still the original 5% solution present, and a trial calculated 10 yield leaching iigures showed no leaching — even when concentrated ten times, this part of the experiment was discontinued. The table and graph do show a possible stimulation ty very low concentrations of chromated zinc chloride, and a sharp, delimiting toxicity line as opposed to the gradual suppression with cycloheximide when slight dilutions are made. flable II and Graph II are, however, based upon much larger concentration variations. In ppm. the C.2fl chromated zinc chloride would be 2000 ppm. and the ,3% would be equivalent to 5000 ppm. The crit- ical toxicity point for Poria microSpora in culture is between 0.2% and 0.53 or 2000 and 5000 ppm. of (18) TABLE II Growth rates of Poria microspora in 2% malt extract« agar plates containing chromated zinc chloride. Rate of growth in mm.* Day 2 5 h 5 6 0.0% 12.5 22.5 58.0 A7.6 61.5 Range 9.5 17-2 25-2 57.7 58.5 to to to to to lh-B 25-5 59-3 h9-3 65-2 0.1% 15.5 26.0 58.9 u8.2 60.2 Range 11.2 22.2 57.5 R5.0 59.7 to to to to to 1k.7 29.5 59.2 k8.5 66.2 0.2% 6.5 1k.6 21.7 50.5 57.7 Range 6.0 12.2 1h-2 28.2 52.2 to to to to to 7-7 16-7 26-0 55-7 39-7 0.5% w 0 0 0 0 0 Range 0.h% and up - no growth * Each figure represents linear measurements of Poria microspora taken at twenty—four hour in- tervals, and are an average of twelve plates; e.g. they represent three trials with four replicates. (l9) chromated zinc chloride, as opposed to 10.0 ppm. or less in the plates containing cycloheximide. TABLE III, showing results of the assay for cycloheximide content in the solution having had the chips submerged in it for a three minute dip, indicateS‘that the active antibiotic content was , materially reduced - by mechanical adsorption by the wood, chemical alteration, or a combination of these factors. Two dilutions, made for 0.5 ppm and 1.0 ppm. growth rate comparisons to TABLE I, show that very little over 100.0 ppm. cyclohexi- mide remains from the original 200.0 ppm concen- tration. The dilution made for a 1.0 ppm. read- ing fits the 0.5 ppm. dilution as found in TABLE I, and the 0.5 ppm. dilution of the dip solution falls just below the 0.01 ppm. range. The two, cross- checking each other, lead to the conclusion that 100.0 of the 200.0 ppm. cycloheximide was retained by the wooden chips. Leaching trials I through V, in which the un- diluted leaching water was used in the medium, in- dicate a leaching of between 1.0 and 2.0 ppm. for the first leach (l), slightly over 0.5 in (2), slightly less than 0.5 ppm. in (5), and progres- sively less in trials (h) and (5). The original solution, diluted_for 1.0 ppm. reading, falls (20) TABLE III Linear growth rates of Poria microsporg on media containing cycloheximide leached from Tilia glabra chips. Rate of growth in mm. Day 2 3 u 5 6 s 11ti bifdreogip 0 6.2 9.0 15.0 19.2 Solution ‘ h after dipel) 8.2 12.5 21.0 25.5 52.5 2) 0.0 8.2 15.2 19.2 22.7 Leaching trials 1 0 5.7 7.5 10.2 15.2 2 O 8.2 12.2 1707 2007 5 6.0 12.0 20.2 25.5 50.2 h 6.5 15.0 21.0 27.2 5u.7 5 '8.0 16.0 22.2 51.2 59.5 * Solution after dip: l)- diluted for 0.5 ppm. reading. 2)- diluted for 1.0 ppm. The solution before the dip was diluted for a comparison with 1.0 ppm. in Table I, all others were assayed undiluted. (21) perfectly in that category in TABLE I. The results of a modified Leutrita technique (10) experiment are shown in TAELE IV. Treat- ment (5), the 1% hour hot and cold bath in water solution of the crude antibiotic, gave evidence of cycloheximide being an excellent water soluble wood preservative. The twenty-four hour cold soak solution prepared from the crystalline product, (Treatment 2), yielded results which indicated that the antibiotic was valueless as a preservative, as the treated blocks were more severely rotted than the untreated in both replicates. The twenty-four cold soak in crystalline prepared solution (Treat- ment A) was also found to be.an ineffective wood preservative. Although the treated blocks lost less weight than the untreated, the resulting fig- ures were inconclusive. Treatment (5), an oil base cycloheximide solution, was entirely incon- clusive, varying between the replicates. All results may have been affected by the high humidity at which the jars were held, particularly as the antibiotic was used as a water soluble wood preservative. High humidity may lead to a higher loss in weight percentage when using the Leutritz technique (10, page 11). Northern white cedar, Thuja occidentalis é. (22) TABLE IV Percentage loss in weight of Quercus rubra blocks after being subjected to rotting conditions used in the Leutritz technique. Treatment* (1) % loss in weight Cold soak in crude cycloheximide Treated 11.5 solution for 2h hours. Check 67,8 Treated h.l Check 61.6 (2) Cold soak in crystalline cyclo- Treated 15u,7 heximide solution for 2h hours. Check 99.7 Treated 70.5 Check h8.1 25) _ Hot and cold bath in crude cyclo- Treated 1.6 heximide solution for 15 hours. Check 109.9 Treated 1.9 Check 72.9 (A) Hot and cold bath in crystalline Treated 8Z.0 cycloheximide for 1% hours. Check in .9 Treated 2.1 Check .9 (5) Hot dip (5 min.) in crude cyclo- Treated 5 .3 heximioe plus crankcase oil. Check .8 Treated , 109.2 Check 118. * Test blocks removed after 120 days in a humidity chamber averaging 28°C. and 87% relative humidity. All treatments with 100 ppm. cycloheximide - Poria microspora as the test fungus. fence posts were given treatments identical to those listed for the Leutritz trial, and were placed be- neath greenhouse benches in four replications. After. seven months, visual observations yield no indica- tions of the superiority of one treatment over the others. In TABLE V, in which increase in mycelial weight of Fusarium pp. in synthetic and organic liquid media is compared, the Coon's synthetic me- dia is shown to be superior to the 2% malt extract when used with no cycloheximioe concentration. Al- though there is a greater weight increase in the synthetic medium flasks containing 0.0 ppm. cyclo- heximide, the flasks of this same medium containing 10.0 ppm and 20.0 ppm. cycloheximide show consider- ably less mycelial growth than in the 2% malt ex- tract with a 10 and 20 ppm. cortent. The synthetic medium is evidently superior to the malt extract liquid medium when the antibiotic is not present, but inferior for producing mycelium when the antibiotic is added, 1.6. the fungus is less inhibited in 2% malt extract medium containing cycloheximide than it is in the Coon's synthetic medium containing the same amount 01 cycloheximide. The difiicult analysis 0' TABLE VI, in which the antibiotic assays of the two media is presented, (2h) TABLE V Comparison of Fusarium 13. dry mycelial weight increase grown in two different media contain- ing cycloheximide. ppm. Coon's Synthetic 2% Malt Extract % . Grams % Grams Increase Increase Increase Increase 0.0 h200.0 0.071h 3hll.7 0.0580 1.0 3929-h 0.0668 5652.9 0.0621 10.0 2u05.8 0.0u09 269h.1 0.0u58 20.0 2017.6 0.05u5 2576.u 0.0u58 yields evidence of antibiotic presence, but also the presence of at least one possible metabolic product. The synthetic medium originally containing 1.0 ppm. cycloheximide, and the synthetic medium check, which were diluted one part of substrate with one part fresh 2% malt extract medium, showed no evidence of either cycloheximide or a metabolic product. Both fit well into the check range of the assay table (TABLE I). If the antibiotic were present in 100% active forn,‘the original l.0 ppm substrate assay should fit the 0.5 ppm. range in TAELE I. The malt extract check medium however, gives evidence of the presence of a toxic metabolic product when assayed' in the same manner. Both the check and the orig- inal 1.0 ppm. medium gave considerable inhibition. The check media for the 10.0 and 20.0 ppm. cy- cloheximide flasks, were diluted one part of sub- strate to nine parts of fresh and one part to nine- teen parts of fresh medium respectively. The growth on assay plates shows definite stimulation of the linear growth rates when compared to the check growth in TABLE I. Stipulating that the stimula- tion is not only acting upon growth in the check media flasks but also upon the noticeably inhibited growth on the plates containing media from the 10.0 and 20.0 ppm cycloheximide flasks, TABLE VII is (26) TABLE VI Growth rates of Poria microspora on 2% malt extract agar containing fifibstrate Tram two oiflerent media which had supported iunpal growth in cycloheximide concentrations.* Rate of growth in mm. Coon's Synthetic Day 2 5 u 5 6 from flasks containing 1.0 ppm. 11.0 22.7 55.5 05.2 u8.5 0.0 ppm. 15.0 20.5 57.0 07.5 59.0 10.0 ppm. 7.5 16.5 25.5 29.5 55.0 0.0 ppm. 16.0 28.0 uu.0 55.5 6u.2 20.0 ppm. 5.5 11.5 19.0 2u.7 29.5 0.0 ppm. 18.2 50.0 u5.6 5.7 6h.5 Malt Extract 1.0 ppm. 7.0 11.5 20.0 28.2 55.5 0.0 ppm. 7.2 12.0 21.2 52.0 no.0 10.0 ppm. 10.7 20.7 29.7 57.2 A5.2 0.0 ppm. 17.0 28.2 ui.7 5u.2 67.0 20.0 ppm. 10.5 19.7 28.7 56.5 85.5 0.0 ppm. 17.0 50.2 hl.7 5b.? 65.? * Media in which cultures had been grown was di- luted, hoping to avoid action by possible met- abolic waste products, i.e.; original 1 ppm. media diluted 1 to l to yield 0.5 ppm. cyclo- heximide if the original amount is available, and check media also diluted 1 to 1. ppm. diluted (1 to 9 and l to 19) to yield 1 ppm. and comparable dilutions with the 0.0 media. Dilutions made with fresh 2% malt extract. Re- plicated four times in all cases. 10 and 20 (27) TABLE VII Revised liquid media assay showing growth rates after removal of the stimulation factor. Coon's Synthetic 10 ppm. (day) 2 5 ll 5 6 % stimulation 28 25 16 12 u Revised rate 5.h l2.h 19.7 26.0 55.6 20 ppm. % stimulation u5 5k 15 1h 5 Revised rate 5.0 1.6 16.1 21.2 27.0 2% Malt Extract 10 ppm. % stimulation 56 26 10 1h 9 Revised rate 6.6 15.5 26.] 452.0 hl.5 20 ppm. % stimulation 56 55 10 15 7 'Revised rate 6.6 12.8 25.8 51.0 h2.§ presented with figures showing the percentage stim— ulation in the check plates and that percentage subtracted from the stimulated growth as found in TABL: VI. After the elimination of the stimulation factor, the assaLS, all of which were diluted for comparison at 1.0 pom. concentration in TAELE Vii are as follows: the 10.0 ppm. cycloheximide in Coon's synthetic medium assays at slightly less than 0.5 ppm. indicating that 50% of the cyclohexi- mide was unavailable or altered; the 20.0 ppm. syn- thetic medium assays directly in the 0.5 ppm. range in T ELE 1, indicating that 75% of the activity of the antibiotic was missing. The 10.0 ppm. cyclo- heximide in malt extract assay shows a concentra- tion of the antibiotic slightly more than 0.01 ppm. cycloheximide, indicating that 0.1 ppm was present or approximately 99% was inactive. The 20.0 ppm. in malt extract assays at nearly the same level as the 10.0 ppm. flask. The difference between the theoretical 0.1 ppm. present in the supposed 10.0 ppm. malt extract medium and the 0.2 ppm. in the 20.0 ppm. cannot be determined by the method used. It is obvious that there is much higher retention of the antibiotic by the malt extract medium. The possibility that the antibiotic was previously utilized by the fungus is unlikely, since the synthetic medium was the more suitable medium when no antibiotic was added. Since the media retained or altered the anti- biotic, or it was taken up by the fungus, an assay on the dried mycelium was made. The results in TABLE ViII indicate that the cycloheximide was not present, in detectable amourts, or was altered so as to eliminate any chance of anti—fungal action in ’the assay. Had the 0.1 grams of mycelium added to the 100 ml. of media been one thousandth part pure' cycloheximide, it could have been assayed as an approximate 0.1 ppm. concentration. The Lrowth rates all fall within the check range as found in Ta m m The results in TAELE X indicate that no anti— biotic was taken up by the onion roots when they were immersed in the 100 ppm. cycloheximide for the 1,2,h and 6 hour periods. However, the water in which the roots were leached for twenty-four hours and assayed undiluted, gave indications as follows: the one hour dip assayed very close to 0.5 ppm., two hour dip at 0.5 ppm., four hour dip at slightly over 1.0 ppm. concentration, and the six hour dip at 1.0 ppm. cycloheximide concentra- tion. . V The results indicate that very little, if any, (50) TABLE VIII Assay of mycelium grown in two different media containing cycloheximide.* Cgpndgngynthetic Rate of growth in mm. Day 2 5 Ll i 6 From flask containing 0.0 ppm. 15.5 2b.? 55.5 u8.5 62.5 1.0 ppm. lh.5 26.0 55.0 i7.7 60.0 10.0 ppm. 11.0 21.0 28.7 58.7 52.7 20.0 ppm. 10.3 12.Z_i 29-Tn_ L2.Z 55.5 Malt Extract 0.0 ppm. 10.7 21.5 52.0 u5.0 56.2 1.0 ppm. 10.0 19.2 29.7 A2.0 56.0 10.0 ppm. 11.2 20.5 51.2 u5.5 57.5 20.0 ppm. 15.2 26.0 56.2 A6.7 59.7 * The washed mycelium from the Coon's synthetic broth and from the malt extract liquid media were collected after weighing, pulverized, and 0.1 gm. added to 100 m1. of 2% malt extract agar for the assay with Poria microspora. of the antibiotic was taken up, but positive evi- dence of inhibitory material, possibly cyclohexi- mide in the leaching water, is shown with the tech- nique used. when diluting one milliliter from the 100 ppm. original soaking solution to 99 of pure water, the possibility arises that ten, twenty, or more ppm. could have been taken up and that the 0.8 or 0.9 ppm. could not be differentiated from 1.0 ppm. by the bio-assay technique. in the assay of the leach- ing water, however, the undiluted use would allow assaying of the small amounts. The indications are therefore, that the amount of antibiotic taken up in the original dip could not be detected by dilution from a concentration as high as 100 ppm., but that 0.5 ppm. was leached from the one hour and two hour dips, and 1.0 ppm. from the four and six hour dips. Unfortunately the lack of data as to the quantity absorbed allows no conclusions as to whether all or only a percentage of the antibiotic was removed in the subsequent leaching process. The assay of the check plates gave no evidence of stimulation or inhibition from the presence of the onion roots for the 1,2,; and 6 hour periods. Graph 111 based upon the dry weight of mycelium .UopsHHnds finance momma oucH oopmaomaoodm *$ .H mqm4e dH somHAmQEoo .Edd o.H you oopSHHm * o.mm m.ae m.Hm m.am o.mH s m m.am m.na s.ma m.m o s m 0.:m o.H: m.om e.om pros s : o.ma e.ma e.m o o s : m.mm o.mm m.mm m.mm ~.ma s m o.mm m.Hm o.ma ~.m o s m n.mm m.4: o.mm o.mm m.aa .mg a s.mm m.am o.ma o.ma m.m .sm a sammmm 5.3mm noon :m axon :m 0.3m 0.4: s.am m.am o.aa s o m.mm m.sa o.ma m.s o s p o.em m.m: s.am 0.0m m.aa s : m.am m.ea m.ma o.o o s o o.mm m.s: o.mm m.:m >.ma s m m.mu s.mw 0.3H e.o o s m ».mm s.»: 0.0m 0.4m m.ma .mg a m.nm o.ma 0.:a ~.m . 0 .mm H case same e m n m m an o m in m m to *amXconc momma noHHHpmwm *mfip .Edm 0.00H .QOHpSHom wsmsewoa m no no man pooh Cease Cm mm pond seen on: mean; doapoanm ecfiEHxQSOHoho m2wcfimpdee mopwam amom pomauxc mama Rm do whoomoaOHE mfiaom no mopma apnoea xH mqm<8 ”-1 AV sour-x“- ' '9‘ A \ H \N V grown in liquid 2% malt extract media, shows a grad- ual suppression of total growth — grading through the suppression of a growth peak - to total inhib- ition in 1.0 and 10.0 ppm. cycloheximide. The graph also demonstrates that the antibiotic is more effect- ive in the liquid media which contains no agar. Growth is not totally inhibited in agar plates con- taining the same, 1.0 ppm. concentration of the cycloheximide (see TABLE H and Graph I). Graphs IV through VII show the inhibition by cycloheximide of four common wood-rotting fungi. All except Schizophyllum commune were totally in- hibited by the 2 ppm. concentration. DISCUSSION The bio-assay technique developed for use in sub- sequent trials probing the action of the antibiotic, was found to be an accurate standard for determining very dilute, unknown cycloheximide concentrations by comparison of growth rates in agar plates. The Leutritz technique showed that the crude cy- cloheximide was an effective wood preservative. How- ever, despite the high retention by wood, and extremely high toxicity of the antibiotic to wood rotting fungi, crystalline cycloheximide treatments were not as con- clusive as the treatments with the crude product. In a leaching comparison, chromated zinc chloride gave evidence of resistance to leaching, but needed two thousand times the concentration for the same cultural inhibition as cycloheximide. Possible explanations for the inconclusive re- sults are found in the very high humidity at which the jars were held, and in the fact that the extremely toxic substance leaches out in amounts sufficient to permeate the soil water with a lethal dosage of the antibiotic. An explanation for the superiority of the crude product as a preservative should be sought. Also, since the leaching trial was undertaken using the crystalline antibiotic, there is a possibility that (35) the crude cycloheximide preparation would not yield the same leaching results. The results also indicate that cycloheximide may be of value as a killing agent to be added to inorganic preservatives and water repellents. The experimental results also showed that the cy- cloheximide was-not as active as an inhibiting agent when in a highly organic media. Greater fungal growth was found in a synthetic broth containing only sucrose and dextrose as carbohydrate source, than in a 2% malt extract media. It was definite that one or more sub- stances found in the malt extract - proteins, various carbohydrate and nitrogen sources, and enzymes or prowth regulators - served to alter or retain the anti— biotic. Agar also seemed to retain the cycloheximide, as a.lD ppm. concentration would inhibit all growth in a liquid medium, but would not totally inhibit in the same medium in agar plates. There was however no apparent recovery of the cycloheximide from the dried mycelium which had obviously absorbed and altered or 'closely retained the antibiotic. The above facts indicate that further work could narrow the number of organic compounds showing high re- tention, and might yield more valid recovery data if a larger mycelial mass was assayed. A leaching study on growing mycelium should also be undertaken. The lack of positive absorptive results when onion roots were dipped in 100.0 ppm. cycloheximide solutions for one, two, fcur and six hours suggests that more valid results might be gained by lowering the concentration of the original dipping solution. The lower initial concentration should allow an assay if only 10.0 or 20.0 ppm. cycloheximide are taken up by the growing tips. This could be aided further by the use of more onion roots per 100 m1. of solution to increase the proportional surface area. Valid re- sults as to the amount of removed antibiotic activity compared with that leached from the roots would yield the quantity actually held by the roots. The onion root absorption was undertaken, not only for purposes of determining action of the anti- biotic when in contact with the growing tips of higher plants but with the hope that its absorptive power could be correlated with cytological aberrations found to be caused by the antibiotic. Wilson (18 1950) found that cytological recovery of the antibiotic was impos- ‘sible from initial dippings in concentrations up to 200 ppm. cycloheximide. Also, the cytological results in- crease after the onion roots are removed from the cyclo- heximide solution and placed in the pure water. As previously mentioned, a low concentration in the original onion root dip solution should yield a valid (37) assay as to the quantity of the antibiotic absorbed; this coupled with the assay on the leaching water could lead to correlating graphs constructed from cytological data and from the retention data. Another line for possible continued study would be the investigation of the noticeably lighter colored zone produced by the fungi growing in the malt extract agar plates containing cycloheximide. There is a possibility that the zone represents removal or alter- ation of the antibiotic and is a diffusion gradient established by the fungus prior to its linear growth. Whatever the cause, it should be investigated for cy- cloheximide content. CONCLUSIONS It was found that with a biological assay using Poria microSpora and 2% malt extract agar, it was possible to detect cycloheximide concentrations in amounts as low as 0.5 ppm. The cycloheximide was shown to be forcibly ab- sorbed by the wood used and could be leached out in quantities very near 1.0 ppm.. Despite the high re- tention and toxicity, the crystalline antibiotic was not an effective wood preservative in all trials at- tempted, however the crude preparation showed excell- ent preservative properties. Cycloheximide was also shown to be somewhat less effective as an inhibiting agent when used in highly organic media. The assay of the medium in which the funLus was grown indicated that from 50% to approximate- ly 99% of the antibiotic was removed or inactivated by the growing fungus. The synthetic medium containing cycloheximide suppressed fungal growth more than the 2% malt extract medium with the same antibiotic content. The negative results in assaying the dried mycelium is an indication that antibiotic activity of the cyclohex- imide was altered or destroyed. The antibiotic also gave indications of being ab- sorbed by growing onion roots. The amount absorbed was impossible to determine due to the high initial concen- tration, but the leaching data showed that 0.5 ppm. cy- cloheximide was leached from the one and two hour dipped roots, and 1.0 ppm. from the four and six hour dips. An assay of onion roots treated in this manner indicated that the amount of cycloheximide present was too small to be assayed, or that the antibiotic was in an altered, non-toxic form. Substantiation of the data indicating that the anti- biotic is considerably less active when in contact with organic matter, was found in the replicated liquid culture growth of Poria microspora. The funtus was totally inhibited by a 1.0 ppm. concentration in the (59) liquid culture, but not by this same concentration in agar plates. Cycloheximide was shown to be highly toxic against four representative wood-rotting fungi, using linear measurements on agar plates as a basis for comparison. Three of the four were totally inhibited by a 2.0 ppm. concentration. ESIJiiiiiifilf Pertinent facts brought out as a result of this work are as follows: 1. The antibiotic can be assayed biologically for concentrations as low as 0.5 ppm.. 2. Cycloheximide was extremely toxic to wood- rotting fungi in very low concentrations, and was an effective wood preservative in two trials, but of doubtful value in others. 3. Cycloheximide is forcibly absorbed by wood tissue, and released in minute quantities on subsequent leaching in water. A. The antibiotic is less effective as a fungal inhibitory agent when in highly organic media as compared to a synthetic medium. 5. Cycloheximide is absorbed by growing onion roots, and can be recoVered by leaching these growing 0 roots. (1+0) 6. Recovery of the antibiotic from dried my- celium and dried onion roots was not possible under the concitions of the ex- periment. Suggestions for further research are as follows: a. Ca d. Study of possible absorption, translocation, and recovery in higher plants. Repetition of wood-rotting tests to prove or disprove that crude cycloheximide was superior to the crystalline product for wood pre- servation. A leaching study with the crude product would be valuable. Investigation of possible selective retention by organic compounds in nutrient media. Study of the mass effect upon re- tention by mycelium and higher plant tissue. Attempted recovery from larger masses of organic tissue. Diameter in millimeters (1+1) Graph I Linear growth of Poria microspora in 2% malt extract agar plates containing cycloheximide. 0.0 ppm. cycloheximide 0.01 " " ' O. II I! 1.8 .. .. 2.0 II II Diameter in milliliters (42) Graph II Linear growth of Poria microspcra in 2% malt chromated zinc extract agar plates containing chloride. 4' and up Weight in milligrams * (1+5) Graph III Cultural inhibition of Poria microspora in 2% malt extract liquid media containing cyclohex— imide. “‘-‘ 0.0 ppm. cycloheximide n...- 0.01 n u ..._...o 0.1 N I! ~---- 1.0 and 10 ppm. cycloheximide * Increased to mg. for graphing. Diameter in millimeters (1:14) Graph IV Linear growth of Lentinus lepideus in 2% malt extract agar plates containing cycloheximide. ppm. cycloheximide II n II II II NHOO o O O o OOKDO Diameter in millimeters ('45) Graph V Linear growth of Fomes igiarius var. laevigatus in 2% malt extract plates containing cycloheximide. “—-' 0.0 ppm. cycloheximide —.___- II II .._...._0 3:3 II II A II II _" 2.0 Diameter in millimeters (A6) Graph VI Cultural inhibition of Lerzites trabea in 2% malt extract agar plates containing cycloheximide. ppm. cycloheximide II II II II II II .o .5 .0 .o O NI—‘OO Diameter in millimeters (1+7) Graph VII Cultural inhibition of Schizophyllum commune in 2% malt extract agar plates containing cycloheximide. ppm. cycloheximide II II BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. Davidson, Ross W., Frances F. Lombard and Ray R. Hirt. Fungi causing decay in wooden boats. Myco- logia, WIX, No. 5, 315-527, iay- June 19K7. 2. de Zeeuw, Donald J., and John R. Jaué hn. An anti- biotic of potential value in field control of“ cuc- cumber scab. Plant Dis. Reptr. Vol. 5E, No. 17 Jan. 15. 1950- 5. Pelber, Irma M., and C. L. Hamner. Control of mil- dew on bean Elants b means of an antibiotic. Bot. 08.20110: ;2 "' 45, Ii. 0 "’ h. Ford., J._I., and E.E. lea ch. flcti d1 one, an anti- biotic Irom btrentomlces gri seus. Jour. Am. Chem. SOC. (0.1245-1cc6, 194;'. 5. Gottlieb, David, H.H. Hassen, and M.E. Linn. Acti-dione as a plant protectart. Phytopath. hO: 21o - 21;, Le C1. 6. Hansen, H.i., an Wm. C. Snyder. Ca ilizati :n oi biological naterial for use as culture 1 _____.- .. '-_....._ L _ .-. _‘ mec a. antooath. 27: :5) - ‘{U, may \ ". Le ach, E.L. J.H. ford and Alma J. Whifien. ’ ’ Acti dione, an antihiotic from Strepiomgces griseus. Jour. Am. Chem. ooc. by: E7h - 475, 1947. 3. Petersen, D., anc D. Cation. Ix ploratorl ex- periments on the use of Acti-diole Io I the control oI peach brown rot and cherrv leaf spot. Plant DLseg se Reoorter, Vol. 3!, no. 1, Ta n. 15, 1950. 9. Rawins, Thomas E. thtotatholopical Methods. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., London, 173:, page 92. lC. Richards, C. Audrey, and Ruth m. Addoms. Lab- oratory methods for evaluating wood preservatIVEE: Preliminarl compari.son 23 agar and soil culture technigues using imp*eanated wood blocks. re— print - Amerlc:n IOOO‘ -Preservers' Association. 19h7. ll. Unpublished. EIELIOCRAPEY 12 . Vaughn, J. R., and C. L. hamner. Che present status LI cycloheximlce (Acti-dione) as a fungicide. PPDC. JL' 0 UJCQ 110171.. bCLSDCG, V'Qlo ELL, 1914.90 15. Vaughn, J.R., Dockwood, J. L., G.S. Randwa, and Chis. firmner. ”he actl on oI Acti- ~di one Ln plant tissue and upon certain IurLi. Euich. Agr. xper. Eta. ¢;art.1u1., V131 :1, no. _ ,hSé-né)i, ay 19h9. 1a. mallen, v. R., 3? Sutton, and A. J. Skolko. Ihe ggiect LI Acti- -dione on the prowth of certain patho- EPJC Iungi and Ln the germination LI ea seed. bhytopath. ‘hO: no. 2, 156-160, reb.195 15. Whiffen, Alma J., N. Bohonos, and R.L. Emerson. Uhe product on LI an anti- Iungal antibiotic bv’Strep- tcumyces griseus. Jour. Bact. 52: 010-611, 19 o. 16. Whiffen, Alma J. The production, assag, and antibiotic activity 2: Acti-digne, an antibiotic from Streptomyces griseos. Jour. tact. 36: LEE-291, 19ho. l7. 'whiIIen, Alma J., The activity in vitro Lf cvclo- heximide (Acti- dione) aLainst Iungi pathoTenic to plants. fmycologia XLII, no. 2, March- -April, l9§5. 18. \Vilson, G. B. Erom conversation at Michigan State COllegeo \‘ —\ ’I RIES ( “7:711?ng 171: Mid; [MI W 113W