2:. ---—' 222%?2? 2222222 ’ ’ ’3 f?” '27.? . - I J fitzl: $331!”. 2 '5' .I’ ’ I $r4’: ‘ "U ’ . .0" " a 'I‘XF’Q. ? “It”?! 4 ha_&, > ‘. I. I‘gig;3’~"a’ ’firéYfig" bit? I 4’31?” I 91*“: I"! ' ofimpf'fyffl" . 2? >4 3’ 4-“ "?&".’N V7” A: I. If ’ 4.._1. - ""' f» if} ..2 7 (ft =‘if2'7”9\‘§’~ I)” 1;" “”7763” ’7}; I‘": in“? "5;," ‘II’ I 2222? o 0’ hi " ' II’ ‘ firs-{1416773 ””73"?!" . . fiffifim‘ I ”I. «r ‘1') ' ' I {an}! ”4 .5 y; 3-‘2223”..‘ fifs‘zzgxrh - ' «22.222922422222212 2&3?" ‘1 - 0 ‘ Q’II’IW’IIW ‘ ’2‘??? . .' ‘. 2: I' I - '- - v. a. ‘_ E". 2 2,. .152!“ ‘ ~ 42. “222% "1212’, .7222222322' ’2’; 2 -~. “2,2 222%: ’ ,fw‘i ’7 2222292922.: ‘b‘d yIi’Ilf‘ 1"“! qfé 943w . ,9.- --54-~ .‘u. 1;“ ’«qr ”3231:.“- 7: it 323-522;?" 111$}? Influx! 1" {Qt-3.; 7" 3’57‘: 3.5?“ .y :1“ ! ‘lro D! ‘f ' 2"" ~222212;“: 223542 222222221: ”fhw 2%. ‘ ’wezg’flm. .,.1' "‘°’""' {3321-2715522 ?"’.§§3;”:_..?.2‘r’"7’"7£~ 2‘5“ ' 22.222 ’2’5’“”'«4;’.1 .2 .2 2«2.2 (“323% {522? 2 "rf‘! ’u E‘. ?‘&&3,,‘ if. ’V‘.’-.I..= fl L- #77:"? 2:3, ”3&27‘72544} “1‘1 .3". .f‘§f“u$ ##E.“ ‘4" h ‘J« ¥ . : ’19,?‘223‘ ’22” J", 323%» 4. 732%., ”325.. V7222”... Ifiimiu 9}.“ .- 5% 2:22-13; ' 222 2.1.2321: 52"" 1"".2 ““57222‘22’2" ‘1. 2"? ‘ 725222... 252 .221" 3f" .22 «2., H27 ~- 0 ’2, 2:21.77? 1” E ' ‘5‘”: 2’9" 1’“ 1’» 7 i222. 1W" 2'. - 2 ° 212 ’ I 3"" ‘14 ’9’2’ #22:; n" "t." «'51:; 2». .f- imf 39“" . ' ' - - .. I . ‘ A} t 1:; :5 ‘9’ . . . S A.) ('fié‘ ,1 713:3"? (721“: 21’ ffié":’~:'w’ ’ _ ‘. 2" 'c' 2 r2”- 4‘; ‘9» ’"H 7* 'J - ”'1'”? .; _JI :32; ’ _ ~ . . .‘ . ‘ ‘ .’ O . ‘ 2332:“? - ‘.’ 2L!" '~.‘,'«2:.2~‘;'2 «NJ-9‘7, t‘ ’~":~"’~i‘*" ‘ ‘4 $2”, '7‘» it“. I‘ #264}: ,3 .2373; .2 U 2.22233. x. ‘I" 21'.» . 1.2 :2... '1'32‘R" ' ‘ I'r ‘3' K2)" 2 L" 'fl’ s v x ‘ 7"" "O 'Q ' ' c ' . ..'~. , "'c ‘ ‘ .'.‘ '.."‘v .‘ ’ ;".é :3 {-‘JJ .- U ‘ 1‘. . ’V’My‘o‘.mI o'eaah‘f ‘2! NI.C\~~I' I3Y::~o.fi”:'. :3 ' WI I ' figs}, '7" {13' "’3 I? - r gut-2. . «7) .9222; F1“ .r. jam" ~ 3.3.32 2; «1‘ .. 2.13 ' Y‘I’; M 3/1””? "F? ’ ‘It""x:-‘"“"fi?ggftifi\2% :‘i—figfio 3".I‘v I'm: 7.“:33’75; “WE—I." '1 . 0 V ' ." ‘ -. H s '1 I , J ' ' ("0, ob, Jr. Pf. (2...:‘r ";"l/ ,Lh' ' l 'o—‘ 3‘ .. c, 3'“ 1 ¢ “1‘ ’. " ’(Iig’u M” H ‘ #37:: ‘ >f""~ 'Y'H;'~L" 2 . v .2 .- 'Q '2 c 1 . O - ("11” ”mg/2&- 2‘3 2 ~ ' .‘ g?‘{"w?'23.+-2§,’I”: ~7’z-‘7g'Oi-G; 1’ é-kvfiunr' «3-, «,3; 2225.26] - ‘. ! ”Hg 5 ‘v f3 \g . 7 4‘" ,I‘ 7- .1 5".5‘.‘ ‘ ’1V" ' 2 .4 :1" If. W 7!- I”. ,—;,:. :.o_.1..“jr"‘0 6 ' "a, 0- 25; . "HE’JS‘R‘ grids " {3;V‘: “GMT; ‘53‘92‘1'3'; 3.. !'-v- ‘ ,‘fl. gay?“ ' - - .‘r’ . ' ’ ' - . .,' :'- n 2. ., . . . -:.- 2% r . "22% M232. 2:? 27' 2f. 2-«2‘? 2”. 2:92 2 7? ‘ but»: ‘ "232,222? 12:24. 2 2171274252 22.3.2 O 0 J} 1‘ Wz‘kglhz:§.’i.’ ‘l'. 1‘ “.é" ‘ffym M}‘z .‘g‘u zd$“% '1. Wuh.';\‘ .Jv'lz; ' ’."‘I~“" ‘ ‘ .~ .. .' " 2 ‘.'a . ’ .. Ii 4?:~"’—o2*"';"" "Wig-2") ”"3“; a I. '33? “hi-:Q‘rWJI. 2. .' ‘- \‘ '11“. 5"!" I'I 1"“. ’l ’I O" I" 7‘0! 7"". .3)” .c "b' v30”; " ° 7. . ’ ‘ 2 .I“. ‘1" . ' i). ’r )K“ . \‘uéo’ . ‘fi. w‘ fla"‘ ,1, v.-'~“ r . Q . 1m? "'0 ' "id" '.|f§_".. ‘7' ‘y'V :7" \l "’ o v I o ' 2".- ‘ I Alix ‘x’Vazfik I “hf": ’.’tt’ .5: ‘.' I A' I 5* I" ‘21 J ' “r... 7" a 7 t ‘I flit}. Ir.-;f‘a.tsl,;'y" 1. “Lt": '$.£m‘ .’v( §5~‘ : "fig"? " Int " L '3’; ’2‘ 2. . 1’2“"? ”(5")” 'fi' 17‘1’5'IES‘P ‘.',".‘.,1"."‘ '. "I”."Ib’u 4;}, I". «.iflv'lx‘si" .' o o ’ . V“. 4 '1 "(gay 'I; ’4‘? ykfit. “: ”I v' “a“ .. ‘42! '14 ';:’ 7.; {wt}... ' ‘ ' r 2H"? 52"” 2‘2"? . ‘22'1'2‘22‘ mm Mn- "~71‘2’""’17~s-~ '2" '« 1‘ .' .13.”. fl , ., $9749.! 'iIf’Iw ’o “I'-"‘:Lm 1-: ”JP”? - -k 107,335. ’ I 2;}:2' . ’ J"? *7’217174‘3122222‘223‘ ~‘¥?.-:"23‘71§712=*-§v{‘:22:' 2211‘s; 443'." 'I , (,1 ’51:" V}. 1-76. \J,j!b‘,"-._.’.‘p,.' A'.’YSIL' ,5 3.31 g‘ o. ., 2,‘ i,’ ‘2.’ . m I ‘ ' 7 ’9 J1)“. 1:5?7'y-5197‘I‘1k’7-49; ”‘4 :27“ F; 4 ”I 1‘. 1" V2 . bf“? § — r 53:2 ‘.‘JW‘ ‘1“: 'u 'v .“ o ’ r 9.. ‘ "'1'." . ."' v. 2 q . 4.. v 531:, 1?. vita”: '3." :.£§.,_,-‘, 29¢" J _‘£’;§ 3"”..‘5fiu " 7 ‘ 1;"! ’ 3 7r l“~fl.;;vs”’;‘.‘f‘,u J L::.:’ ‘s‘v J‘I e}; Q.’{1I“Iv4'4I"fp1‘ M" "‘ ‘3 .ml‘i '2.f’1€a"i"7""2 24“ I’ ' ‘3' . .‘r J L U y 'lscI'sQ ‘ . nta' *5. "3‘“ ”'5‘“ \‘Q '1‘ : -'fi-i': . I,” I ' 31-0. I- .‘L » ~ ? ' ”. ”4"" ”)’\'{~.:" 2;...‘2: ‘~ ' ‘5.“ "y! raga. '75 .' ”12.31, ', .\ ’ 2 2‘ k-‘tsuCn '-'. 2‘4 r. r " *4. ‘ d1 '23" ' « 4;,292’: t ‘3", a . fin. '0- a Q‘ “ h." “’2 .~ 2 u "1.4 1,, _ ' .~ 3“: n b! h o~(’ Q .I-' v. . 2 2 2- 2 . ~ . . . - 2.2.27: ' “222m.-:?'d'---"“"* 4" 2‘ ”LVN 3""? 2 3'21" "Y M: :9 2%. 7 " " .. '4 ' ' l ‘2 r« a.» mum ? - -. N 22/2»? 241.5222.- , . ~g .2. .~.: 2 I H_’ . .9 K' ' H. , If .--.’¢* ... .Ie‘ ‘ ~42. \ .- V! (J a o. l. in ‘v s k 2‘ -" ' 2- .2 '« ' - I.“ fwd. -2..? 2.222 " . wave»: «.1 ‘ '. '. ruw 2 wow" ‘12: 3‘ v - o - . II '5‘::L, 3.“ (Jim. I, M??? iglm'm‘ 4 7..- 3%. ~"’ fig“ "a: {\; k9 6"“;5” "14.1“?" 1‘2“. ‘ghuéfi 'b? V” ' ' :".\;§ I. “ " I ‘I a ‘ A ‘ ‘ F v ' ' 2 . -' ‘ ‘- “2:222”: “22:2; “'éjnfirwu 222-23229“ 2222222. 22"»?1222~=r£'«222~2*-.ws.- 232': 21‘ 52.222222: ; - 2 o‘, . um: .‘ . . .-'-".'. 2... 2 "'.- ‘-'" " -- 3 '- '=~ ” ‘ ' ' "‘ 1 2 7 ’2’. 7 ' ": .2 " ‘ :£«»;.'«"~T'=‘:‘ "2""Ls’fir‘i5;#."22~“?’22”’§?. "213M? -2 "77“1272," "3. ..’:2t 2‘35: - ‘ ,1,‘ 7: ‘ I. 2': ' .I r . , -. .‘ . .u t. _ I. _. v I t .’ . I ' I I‘ ‘AI " riII \ I413. *1"? 3‘7 2 ‘- CYN,"‘.'.I’~’2;.”1-“ by” “7”} :. 73.1.”{232}. ’R’. 1} 2:- 75.799- u“ .‘:or’. "Ifih' s’.’ -' - . I $972.1. ". {2214'17‘ . ~ -'~ Q7";- ~ 2,:“’3-‘"-2I ‘,,. dim-gs. Féc‘?‘ $2.21.‘."vv3;‘.--,;. «71.: 2 - 23'.“ 217;... 7‘ v ‘ ' 2. {.955 2.332.“ ’v:\"‘i’ (2,322}. ;.2..“;\2"‘h 1...; .; v.39“? .. «7717‘s; ,:_‘ 3'1 Sp». wwm‘ " "fit-2* 3:42, '- .,-., «. _;. ' ’ . g 7’” ‘ ’ ’H ’ ’L \2 ‘ U ‘ ' ‘L "3'4” -""’."’.v7'-- ”‘77 3' W. 1 ‘1‘panv"t¢h~ J“. 75f": 91‘024‘.‘ V272,, 2" . 'J. 7m". . ’ '~ WW"- ..-‘ 2 .2 .9‘?‘ ‘3~ ~ W ': “22-2... M29.» 3.; ~.;.'.2.1v-. ‘ «-..3.,r-2, 222.222,; m... 22.7.2.5 62.. 22-. - , ,_ '5- ~. ‘3’ 33..” 3‘4”.” ,I'fmr‘fdu”.- ”v.1“... ~9~ 1‘. l, 3 _g,‘*,.3. ”we”. . 2. L ”.4. 2'31”“. c, ‘. 5. :2. 2 c . “ I .fi.) .1 7“ $7 .7‘ 3:} i“ ' - ”'7’?” “up '.'~ "" ’5 " ‘3‘ . '2‘ P "-‘5 7 7‘” ' " I/I‘V“, ’- I ‘ 'Q~ n". :"f 2. W - - ’I 0,1 ,4 s.|* I .0 '. “ \ .. O 53‘. ‘_. _ ,fi V.) .l ‘ 1. ._.’..|"fl4.4“.?.‘5' . M '3’ o“. ..‘.l. .1 “‘*‘« ~24" ‘ W" 22"” ‘2" '4 aw.“ ‘o’ ..t4.c;2\\52n..qg- wouflw ‘ x w- -. 2.21:»... 9.11 - v‘ws .' 9' ' ’ ' : “Eb Lg'Vk’c" I‘l-t‘fi' U ‘ .;'.I ' r ';“‘5‘.- "’1-743“ g. 1:1,é’fo'; I’ «find?» i I? J, d~‘.'o ,,;“.2, (‘12 _ Dr ’1‘ . 2 ... ~ .u- 2...; 1 2.24.» ~:.1“-‘ 1.9.- 22.2]... w - «. «-nru 2222. . . . 2. 2.. 2-. «. . .2» s. M. o} - n ‘ a “’ kl \.’;P' -'J.‘..: {2’ ‘ QL.’ ’i it" ’ ‘1‘"..- I‘)‘; :i'.{alfla‘TLIM‘cb—‘lAv‘fiu ’ ,~ ’ u'phflvv"; ' ‘4 .k"-_ ' 2 "4‘ .g“;’,.-f7 J24 F. ' 49" ; . . ,H, ".-.' .4“ 2‘ . . '- ‘0’ 3,...2.’ R .1 . ,. "“'II._‘ '. ‘1. '9”V"'f".’ 5".H,,..|. L“ _ ,J .r‘" 2;... . ’1‘ ‘ ”J ‘:'l"‘ 'I‘ ,“-_ L. 4 - v 2 . T .74”. ,‘..-f':‘:hi‘;' 2 “2 ’I‘jg‘t'mfi; :leufig‘t'qpfl'a‘ic' 2. 2 Y: “.-,".;-.-'.,2" ’12-?1-1 a} £5qu- ‘-. "’31..“ "13" 3x ’l'; 2 "fig? 2 = .. ~ :"+2«L‘*“' '2' Ana/3&2 .‘?:.’.-. ‘ . . .. -._; ;2:«.-‘» . -"i-.-~.;.~.u-.«'-1......a_:2..2.;:« 2442.0 w, 2.2.2- .2 «. . 1 - 0‘9 ;,__.,’.2;.. 51,2532, ”‘J"’I?‘I14-'II\IWE .2 .3 ‘,'-2‘,"2“:~1I“Qflb‘:!:fii'fl§ 70.3, “3%.: 2’: t..:.2.?’f‘}~ . 2' 47‘5"” I’lf;f~‘7?7’:"‘I§-CI”’;: ; s ‘1'. . '7'. 2" 1‘.'..: v.‘ 0': .2“ 1 l . X 7 ' ..". ,-.' . 'n’u" ‘. z .‘ .o‘v - 2, fig, ‘4,_ ' ‘1 ~‘“o {.fi 9 .. "‘¥ .f'fy". In , fl 7“! l; ..‘.‘ .‘ v 1 v .l ‘ ‘ ‘ V ' ‘ .' . .- ' . 5: “ 0 ' ’ *- "fi’. '7««‘ "‘72 “5‘33; PHI-".91" “-‘:"'2 “2211‘ 2" 4 24:22.3. RIM-2““ ,‘2f;;'~‘g'%4‘7..3§":.'F-'.-ej'-~‘~'A‘Q.m‘:‘-g..;:~-:z “rm-4’ K: , . J. 2 .1.- 2. .. . ‘ - ‘ ' 7 ‘0 't" ’ . .2“ N e - .‘2 « 4 .22.! Him. 2. ~" ’8 ‘4 s~ 22w 4 E: 3:: Raff") * JM ".- « "'- d'x- M «"2" 7‘ " . 2. * .- 2 M '4. «4 . - ‘ . . . ‘3 A‘ .‘U ‘Fo ,' '\ J , ‘.. sf. “u I ‘fi -N.. “3.. _ [A ,a “I 'Y! ' . 2‘..h‘-; .. . . 9“... “, 5 v «2 .,‘1, {:LI\!:« ' l"5f' q.“ ,gH.‘ U" Q” ... "§-*§ ., gn’r"~, “L's. ,; _ a.“ ’F.”- s.,‘. :.x « — ‘ - *2'3‘E.*7*« «32313.29 22-72757. “-51?" '-: '2'22‘222‘Ml7 .1-2;‘~‘.'.-"".~~22;:'.~.;.‘-'2 2": 22'22- 2' «:«.4-"r-~:.‘ 2m 3:42.22 , . ' In 0‘ . . ‘V‘ 2 . Q . .. 2 4' a v 2 . C ' ' ’. ' o ' '1 o , . I ‘ ( -'.‘ ‘ . ' i. d. \‘ :0" ’.\.:: ;v..g.’_~'l .v‘at‘fl bp'I’h..I' "50' ’1‘ ‘ "5' ~'(’ '1"“-tf'"’ b: :1 '2‘ ~11 31?..‘0‘ Y‘Ifi‘ -‘ '4 .7 ’«nyI‘- -\ 0|" . 'I . v ” " t "I. "76’": If ‘.1I".("1 . 5:“: l'l$*.'2 ~( 07“. ‘5 a.\ ‘- ‘f‘[ 0‘. "nt‘: . '1’4’:.I‘I"II" ." 2‘ fl" —pu'.'.!9_ 1. ~' . :7 ' ' ’ ' .( 3'!!!» I [’0 "t. “ z. h“ u. :7. “‘3‘!” :10'fi_,‘~,“. (M; r4. N‘- ‘.'.‘5’; ‘quz's‘i‘ N. .5: .‘1 I I‘ 1" ‘ a I 5": .V'...‘ . ‘ ~. \ v 2 2 .~‘ .v . .4 ‘. v_".. I c ,2 -_ J 2' . . " . 2 .. ._‘ N z ' ' - I. " ”I'l“.‘h ’nl'h;~'l’ ’ ’ ' 0.: ".7” " A”, 7t ‘1‘ #“I '1 ~‘I c" "’ “’ Hath: :‘m‘ ""717. 5"}. "v’.I}‘ W’ "rv'fl '. ‘H ' ' a ’ 2 . . 2 s~' ~ . H" ' u v- 2 ' .«2 . 2'2.‘ .2. - ‘u'\z§ '0 -y i" I“ 3" ‘10.’ '. --I' "\ ">u-)-2)-\ : 2. .' 2’. Ah”- . r 2 . '2 ‘ ‘:‘ ‘I V "r'I ." V. ‘ H’« 1'51" ‘n. "' ” v . “’- I 2 ”' k ' V " ?... .37 - ' M. \l .t‘ I ~ '- "“" y. .‘4 I'I‘7 /‘ f” 'I .l 2‘ .3 J ' ' " " . ' ”-‘ § 7 ‘ ”pm-2,.) r‘L"“'f""I . «9 .-_ -2"r '-.-. ..,.3. m. \ fo‘e-A ..'-\!A.:$«'f. .4r-p..,.~.-. “$5.2”. “.245”... . 2. (t 2 , ., o. f . 2'. :4 .31} "1’ .h ’ O“ “'13,. 2. H: ‘9) ' .f‘y: A a“: 3‘1. 7‘ z . . _' "5".'0\"c"-. j¢-J-. '.~,l,~‘-.v‘ . n’l‘k ‘2‘,,‘~# 25"" ?I <1—.".,‘ 3'“. 2’ . . “A; , ;' «q. {”1} ' . ' a .2 _ . ) 332""I5iII' “‘1. hi“ ’9‘? .. I“ . ”5‘... . 'y . "~_. . 2'.._ y 2 ON ?i"~h;‘-l" :L'vs”\1"."m‘ 1 "13- if! \, 2.-.." C“ 5' 7"... {5.1. “ ’ "2‘2. . I".‘. ..\;_I;..‘I. .' .' -' .2 2.1.. -:2 ~'-..". “rt-”m ‘ 7‘ ’ .‘2. 5'“ 4-2-0" '-' '. '7' " .°"° . ' ’2’ 5 .2 ~ ’ :‘ {:OO‘.I"‘;'T”iZ ‘.l.“:‘-~:. :g‘III ’7‘th . $0 2“ I.’ z— ':‘5:' ," '1 ‘O‘AP‘l T - .b‘c Ivfl‘t‘lot‘ I‘N" U... ~u .. .:'.l;‘ “’5 2 ;..."..;.‘IE K .: 9‘ "o. ‘1... :1! '3’ ’ IL ’ ' - "'"’7’“~'II'II".° M" 7' I’IIr’ ‘ "I-bI. Iv“: ' -"I 2'1"" I I ' ?".I"'I‘- i' ""‘ 3’415’; :L 2ht"v ’0'; ' ’17“ .I’ " "'n I'.’I‘.Vb’:'J 2 \' .' 3 - ,‘v.;:2v‘[!.l.:‘ 22-2‘ v. . .x';a‘\.‘.'¢ . ‘ _L~ "2"" "I _ 2;...5“, 7‘ \h"'~g ‘2 22:2 ‘3‘: 22.” .l ,. “*112-‘2‘0. 1".” 1”... ,’%| ’1, _ . ‘2 1 O l' ‘0 v <_. 2'.. ‘ ‘p < ~‘ _".v_ 2.2- . v: |- 2'2 .2 .. «. 2.223.222. 4;» 2 2 7.2.2 m . z . M2 .. « 2;- ~ 2.2-... -s--«« *2: ...- *2 4‘ 2 2.22 ' 2w L . . . o. ‘Sgé‘o-V” . ,»,I~O. .2125‘0'141'” 1‘2. (IN 7’ \':‘ ":7. .o ‘5’; ”I . . .’“\‘;_.\1I‘L,:t?§’oih .' "‘2." 1 .I‘ . if” ”for ”nil _. ‘ _ 0‘ 2 ‘2 , . '2" . I A v- x v ‘n ‘ - ‘3'. '.' 5 4 '.~ ' 2 . 0'“ -" l . H. o l ‘ v # o I??? in...“ L2. 5.!fs"o|a'u': :‘,."-’ ,3. 2...”.71217“ h .P‘FZ’L’" "'~’I2'I’ ‘I-o-‘.‘ '1...“ 5'2". 2-, a: (4} . ’12“. ‘ u H. 2... 9‘" d. "' . ' 11' ‘I :I’:’ .’ ‘7' ' 5:1,... ?1{~ Ill" 5" g‘IvIn'su" "t‘ 9. I ’ I"? 5 I 2’2’71' o 1‘2}. . '2 '1‘! l ‘ I ' \I« . ‘ - ' '. . v \‘a . .". ' '.-.‘lo ' _ s". .7. .. a :35. 73!»... .‘ '2. :42‘7‘ “h“. ‘4 :12 :. Cf." .7 " «1- 2". .‘ . '. .“9'9' 2.. 3.39:2. ” . I! ’0, ' o ‘ . !;YL ‘ '. $31."... 5&5 'vvflI ) {5"‘5'0‘...~ ' I." ’¢‘~ i"~"‘ 2|. ‘ . a . ‘4’. 7‘ 4 '2 . $3.- ' QIO. "\"v‘\‘.(’|t.‘y:i>' . "’1‘ ':-"'.~ ‘. ’I"..""II'. .0 4:1. ‘1',"1 .0: L. I c ' ’4‘! Q - o o - . n. V 91;" ,.' ".1.qu 1lm'b12'n.' '29. ”UV." ‘ i ‘ I" ' 0‘ "K I ’ - 2“ ,2 IN"; “"0" w: I i.£$.-‘I , . :?:£.::;‘l'6: 2"; :23): V‘. .‘v’; 2‘. ' 2. |‘7~.,."J;,. J71‘l;, I.1.‘_ ~" oh"> “1‘. ')-~ h: .‘ . . I . . " " u..'...'. c' ; . v ‘ . :,' 3'" u A: §-'--~ .. , 2 . ~ I )8“ ’ 'I y; ‘ ‘ ’ 3“ z’rm‘v".' I” .5 "IN. K .: \. ’1"-_ 1' ’1 ’ " {IL 21‘ 9" Y"; .‘I a " . ' ' o 7 ’ ' ‘5. ' °" ' ‘1 N 4" 0 ‘ ' 2 ’ ' “ I . I I ' o ’4‘; . If} I . o 7 "4 '7 ' 2 '2 1" "H N‘ ' ’~' " "‘M ’ f""1 "V "‘ ’ ' "’ ' I ta..- 7‘? l ’ ‘ ’ l ”N" ‘2‘: ‘ ‘ ‘1’. JI‘ .l‘V-‘M "I. 7"."~;"7:“ ft? 2.74.... ‘- " '3‘ ’ I‘IyJII, An . i .1" '. ' . l ‘H-" "Q. ‘ H, v ’ 20.4 O .9 - . ' I I. I'I‘ I «A, ‘.I" - {"I‘ ‘ - 7‘7]? 0 a . . 2 ..05 ,‘4” ’«f- v - 2.321..“ . h“ |°:~ '2‘, ‘ ,«.{..|\. ...:§.a..; ..,..d“. A": ‘1_“”4 5 .2 2:. 731L15, ' ' I o I v v :. . 4 . a " - ‘ ¢ V -’3"I33' - -v -'.'"- ‘9' I" " 3L“‘-’." ""17" "t 2 f1: "'I‘vc“‘~"‘ L ’ Lsfi‘ue .3» ‘~ '-2\‘."1."v. I ’24 . . o ' ’ 7 7’ .7" I ’ :‘uh‘ " "7”" 2"” L " ’0 ' L'S‘ ‘ I." "’ '2" 1’v’.’ ' 3" ‘ ‘ W I ’4. ‘ i . ' "- 5,3. '. 2 L , 2. v \"fii'hh 'h“!’.' q 'q . _. 0 § 0'. . "."L‘r. 721‘“; x L 2 o |' “ ) o l 9 Y . o {0%,}, «2". "N 7‘. ‘2 §_ ." | u ‘ “HIS § .g. {‘1 2 ‘2‘. ‘2'. ‘_'o." ‘ '.,o6,u" ‘ 1 3.2;}? I * " ,. 9?".\' 7253'“ "‘2 ' “:53? *"~ . 1 u 27.. — ”5131'". ‘32- str-‘\;"?: .‘I . 2 "‘3. '21:” '« ’ i k; ." -: O a "’ ' . 7’ ‘ I I ’ ‘ ’ I ""‘v -'.I ..::"~3 "‘t\“‘h"‘o' . O .‘ 4". ‘ ‘I.;“‘ f:. : "I'. ’\.I'.‘ \‘J . ‘ .L" ".‘ ‘ . "_ . .. _‘ 'l . ' 1 . c, “No ‘ .,,-""V": "V . '{,¢. ,. .L.\d.‘ - . v." V'Wa ”Jun 2’: '3 ‘ ‘ .. ' , o. I g (5 .“v,~. ~. . I. '0. x 294172. c» \ .‘Nr‘: “'5' JLu .22. ‘ .7 Dogfbr h,“ . “o. "1“. I I" . 0 : ‘33.:wg.‘ " §.LI“ n ,lfl, v0 2 7.52:7- ‘l‘ " ,‘n . (’1? 7 Q? d”. [Mk v . .I I . o ‘ v p,’ $.I ‘ I :3“ . ' H ’2' I- ..9_""~..I¢‘." , u- 7 . 2 f - a. 73‘2m‘... "2. ’ I ' I 1 ’ ’ "8". I ‘ ;' "C'¢‘~ "Q. : "2":27’2’N- '¢ ’ l‘ s‘I I "J, -"'}',’ .-':I’.) \2 ' ‘ J .‘. u . l O ' n l . o . ‘ g | . _ ’2‘! < 2 I . 3j"~:’I L #71:. "L'?’ j’“;"“‘ u "IQ" 333210. ‘.~‘: 1'“ ' : . _‘ ‘ InZ £7 0 ”I ’. ‘ u . . '. :‘S" " . '~. ~ '. I.‘ .' I‘ .fi“ '..o\' .3 4 ‘..‘~‘.1>. , Y”|.”.|’ ‘. \‘u1:)2~“" ". i ' l . {Q .‘~‘ 'I" f‘u,‘ ‘H‘. 2 2‘. “Q. O’;‘| F._"-u_". '3',“ ‘ 7“ ..’B‘.b‘." a 2"“. 2 ‘ ’ Jkfll " ‘0 'fnq'V "‘ ..“‘.."| ‘ 7 K '«I ".‘"- I ' ‘J . 2 ‘ ‘ ...' 2 2 . 1 ' . ' . . . o I. ‘ a o ' . u ., -_ 2' . : : 2 ‘ " ‘7’:.~:‘:‘? ‘-,“ : _-‘_ 0 2. 12‘ Lg: ~.‘=-3‘ ' . 2 ‘2‘ ~ . . . 1 .0 .fl ' . .‘I ,p. ‘.“~W“_ “(-9.1 '\.":‘~ 4}: h | ”‘f‘:‘,hx\’ "1 $2.51.“; ~' ‘ a " I ‘f ;;\" ’\ ,‘i" 1'33? '. off-G‘Ns‘ 2' "- ‘ . '- ' " « ‘ . 2 .«'-. ' '-~ .., :4: u -n «1.,‘a ’2 . ".q- a 3 ’ ‘ ' -' ' ' 24'7-12924" :59?- 17’21'5- '-..' "23¢. . ‘ -' ' ' -- " .-.‘.‘ ".w:«u.¥772‘.~‘; >24 um": "“’ "m "’1‘. - ,92 'a.:..~:-..~‘. ‘22 3:2: 12“" ~ .' 17'5"“. {2"2‘227-74’99‘1 ’— . v as. .. n. I. 2.». 2 ~‘ fi . y. . - . v 9’ ‘ V‘OII'JL‘V.’ . .‘t’ D '1‘ Q _ I '1. - -~ “” L:_“\_ \‘ .M¢ ‘—\ 9.. L- ‘ - uh: I l ‘Vv . P. o|h\‘n‘“\\1.>|hnrn‘, . v ‘ . A A: I .. A T‘.L ADV Irru- Ann? I at .. ..r .. n .. . . . . . n .p Q. . . . . . r . n . V n. «x. 4 , . x a . ‘ . .. l I . 7 . . .‘n . l I 1 .. . . . I A . . . . u S .43... .u - ‘ . . 30 . . .A z. u A .0 I . a. t . . . I. .. . \ fifll , - 4 i. A. \ I . - ~ 9 a » ... m1: SUPPORTING VALUE OF MARI: FOB HIGHWAY WTS BY .. 5' My OLAR Libsmxsmn A @2318 PRRsmmn '10 m FACULTY or MICHIGAN sum COLLEGE 0R AGRICULTURE AND APPLIED semen IN PARTIAL MILLMENT or m RRQUIRRIwNTs FOR 1m: mean or MASTER OF scmncn: EAST LANSING 1933 TH E818 The writer wishes to acknowledge his indebtedness to Dr. C. E. miller for his assistance in planning this report and for his study of the preliminary draft. To hr. F. R. Olmstead, State Highway Laboratory, who made the chemical analysis of the marl samples collected. 0‘33“} 1. INTRODUCTION fiichigan swamps range in depth from a few inches to sixty feet or more. All soft materials such as muck, peat, marl and lacustrian clay found in these swamps were,until recently,eonsidered unsuitable for supporting highway embank- ments. They were therefore usually removed and the cut filled ‘with suitable materials. Needless to say this practice added materially to the cost of highway construction. It was finally observed, however, that occasionally road fills would become perfectly stable despite the fact that very little of the underlying soft material had been disturbed. Investigation disclosed that there are three groups of swamp materials which more or less successfully support highway embankments. These materials are marl, mixtures of peat and sand, and soft lac- ustrian clay. Earl deposits may be larger, occur more frequently, and include greater variations in composition and position than the other groups of materials mentioned, and consequently offer more of a problem to the highway engineer. This paper deals with the supporting value of marl. The term "marl” as used in this report refers only to fresh water deposits of lime carbonate (Ca003). Such deposits are never absolutely pure, but usually contain.varying amounts of fine sand, clay, or peat. Sand improves the supporting value of marl by its contribution to the internal friction and unit weight of the marl body. The influence of clay may be beneficial or detrimental depending on its position, distribution and amount. 2. Unlike sand and clay, peat, because of its small volume, weight, great water retaining capacity, and coefficient of ex- pansion upon wetting, is far more important than percentage figures based on dried weight would indicate. The two tables that follow illustrate how the weights of marl and peat compare (1) to other soil materials and (2) to each other. 1. The weight of one cubic foot of (l) (5) (4)* water 62.42 pounds Dry sand Approx. 100.00 " Dry clay " 85.00 " Air dry marl " 55.00 " Dry muck " 40.00 " Air dry peat " 15.00 " 2. The peat and marl content of a single sample under different conditions. ** (l) (4) Basis of comparison Peat Lhrl Air dried. Figures based on.volume. 50% 50% Saturated condition. Figures based on.volume. 76% 24% Air dried. Figures based on weight 1573 85;: * Numbers in parenthesis refers to literature cited on P. 31 ** Figures are approximate and based on weight and shrinkage factors contained in the literature cited. 3. Numerous tests, results of which appear in table page 26 , containing enough lime to be recorgnized as marl by visual field inspection may contain from 90 to 99 percent Ca003 provided, of course, that the impurities are organic rather than sand or clay. marl has certain physical properties which are of consider- able assistance in distinguishing it from.other swamp materials. Earl and peat, for instance, are quite easily separated on the basis of color alone. When moist, peats range from various shades of green and brown to black, while marl varies from almost pure white to dull gray or slate. After these materials have dried, however, peat becomes dark brown or black and marl, gray or white. The inexperienced investigator often has considerable difficulty in distinguishing marl from clay. Color is of assistance since the most common color of lacustrian clay is a blue to bluish gray instead of the gray or white of marl. Plasticity is another property by which clay can be distinguished from.marl. Wet clay feels very sticky when tested between the thumb and fingers while marl shows very little or no cohesive properties when tested in this manner. There is also a difference in.the way marl and clay are deposited relative to position. The lacustrian clays are always found at the bottom.of the deposit and are usually thickest in the deepest part of the swamp. marls, on the other hand, may occur anywhere in the swamp profile with the purest samples coming from the shallower portions of the swamp. 4. Aside from color, prdbably the easiest way to distinguish marl is by its texture, variations of which depend upon the mode of formation. In all the deposits encountered in this study the bulk of the marl was so fine grained that individual grains could not be recognized by the unaided eye. However it always had a decidedly "chalky" feel. In most cases some material with a finely granular texture was present and could be recognized by rubbing a small amount of marl between the thumb and fingers. Some shell material was generally present and on close examination the fine cylinders deposited by Chara usually could be found. REVIEW 93 LITERATQRE marl is described by C. A. Davis (6) as follows: "marl, when dry and pure, is white or slightly cream colored, nodular, coarsely granular to finely powdery, very loosely coherent and effervescing freely with acids." It is not the purpose of this paper to discuss the geology of marl deposits, but as a matter of interest it may be in order to quote a summary contained in a paper written.by Dr. R. A. Smith, State Geologist. (5). ”The facts so far stated may be summarized as follows: Spring or stream water, carrying lime carbonate in solution, deposits it in lakes in the form.of marl, this deposition.being caused by: 1. Escape of carbon dioxide, owing to decrease in pressure. 2. Supersaturation, owing to rise in temperature. 3. Abstraction of carbon dioxide by plants. 4. Freeing of oxygen by plants, resulting in the formation of carbonates from bicarbonates. 5. 5. Direct abstraction and crystallization if lime salts by Chara. 6. Abstraction of lime by molluscs and formation of shell deposits." No studies dealing directly or indirectly with the supporting value of marl for highway or other embankments have come to the attention of the writer. EXPERIMENTAL Much of the investigational'work on which this paper is based has been carried on over a period of four years. The field‘work has consisted mainly of sounding, boring, sketching, collecting samples, making settlement studies, and obtaining pictures. Follow up inspections have been.made to check the behavior of pavements where surfacing has been laid. Soundings have been.made by means of the Davis peat sampler. Borings were made by means of a hydraulic drilling outfit. The laboratory work has consisted of determining the moisture content and complete analysis of a number of peat and marl samples. Out of a large number of so-called "sink holes” where fills have been.made, seven have been chosen for the particular infor- mation that each may contribute to this study. Some of these marl deposits show almost perfect support of the highway fill while others have apparently afforded little support. This difference in behavior reflects the effects of various peat and clay impurities in the marl. Each deposit is designated by a project number under which heading the location, cross sections, records of work done and results observed will be recorded and discussed. 6. Project 063 - 21 This marl deposit lies about four miles south of Pontiac on the Telegraph Road, Oakland County. It is surrounded by hills of morainic origin which are composed of sand, gravel and clay more or less segregated. The hills to the north, especially, are very springy along the base and at one location furnishes 'water for an artificial lake which occupies part of the depression in which this deposit lies. The profile and cross sections (Figures 1, 2 and 3) show that the marl is covered by a very thin layer of muck. Borings also indicate that while the deposit varies greatly in depth it is very uniform.in composition both vertically and horizontally. Some aquatic peat has been deposited with the marl, mainly in the deeper portion of the swamp at station 547/50. 063-21 Telegraph Rd. Sta 5&6 - 55M Looking N. Marl deposit in foreground Stokstad h—ae-33 Figure 1. A longitudinal profile showing a deposit of marl supporting a highway fill. Note the small extent to which the fill and underlying muck has settled into the marl. 0"! .00 .AOQ'QOln 009' 000' .A 60 to 0. IO. V 9.9.0... Figllre 2. A cross section taken at station 547/30 of the profile shown in Figure 1. Under modern construction procedures the muck between the clay fill and marl would have been excavated. The muck seems to be largely responsible for what fill penetration has been obtained at this point. “4... I t in“; I O 0 1 ? O ---.A-.~ 0 o a o—L—Hwe- O -4--.—...._— - O 0 ea. r ( - y m...-..+--..-_..- -- 0 e o I .---L ---‘ --o o o -<—99bo~-‘ Figure 30 A cross section taken at station 550/30 of the profile shown in Figure 1. Note again the efficiency with'which.marl supports highway embankments. There does not seem.to be much difference in the amount of penetration at the two loc- ations illustrated by figures 2 and 5. 4“! Jae ._._ _. .3 T1..\1.|.i. JJ‘u.MI wax. ...... 4 .-_‘-¢o‘l -- ._‘ vv—v-~"-r- _. ., I 0 "7-5-0 1‘ ... ._ . ."Wu' .0 ......u. o . . ...- . o.’.f..r ..... -..orkrtwflrrflm. mumu-MW'flnPont1filol ...-.01.." {w ”NWT?“ OOPW>4$ Iaigéd \ ...m\..b~..flnu_.o.+01.va..144 ...-o Nb. .0 ...-“gov ..r...P..rw....m. V17, W44. b .-.. .HL‘L ..vh Pb. #. F. F r - . . . 4.. F .1 1. . . 4}..th ...... _ .a . . _z...-z ifs-11.. . . .1 o III. ...-1., .. .. // / «1.. ..I I ...A . .. ,. . z/, / 4 ._ , .. 4.1% >140 .0th 02 ml. z z.z- ....././ / x K / . . . .39. SQ ._ 0M1. du- ox . d... . . 4.\ cu- on. 9v w m at. ....ohh. W . .Io‘kfikmfl. to...h.ufl.h.. UnsatuU .. ........ ....-.E.....uqn ..H .. t‘ttn‘n‘“. .... . I. . Fu'Tut . .H ...-mi N . , an. _. k. . 3. one. Q . .. . . w ... . m .. _ . . .---..04: 7-2-..- . .. _. .H. . . . . w i h . . 4-1 H n .3 a m n _. ....y i. m. 5;. e? .._. .. ... 3.. -..» ...... .. .wL-h 1.7. 7...“: L. 1 . ......M... 7. When the original survey was made at this location ordinary rod soundings indicated soft unstable foundation conditions. It was assumed that the peat visible on the surface extended the entire depth of the soundings, con- sequently plans were prepared for sinking the fill and displacing the peat by the use of dynamite. The construction Operations of filling and blasting were carried on in July and August, 1928. Field engineers were somewhat puzzled to find that in spite of their efforts they obtained very little settlement of the fill into the soft underlying material. A soil study was therefore made. The results Obtained are illustrated by figures 1, 2 and 3. This project was the first to emphasize the extent to which marls would support highway embankments. The pavement has been in place at this location for four years with very little apparent settlement. There is a slight dip between stations 546/t0 and 548 that reaches a maximum.of about six inches. This dip is not sudden, however, and the average driver does not notice it. Some observations made while studying this deposit are: l. The aquatic peat present has been deposited below the marl and is located about 16 feet beneath the surface. 2. marl that is relatively free from organic impurities is capable of supporting a highway fill. 8. 5. Dynamite charges left cavities in the marl and fill into which water drained from the fill surface. 4. Very little settlement has resulted on this deposit despite the fact that no adequate surcharge* was used to compact the marl. *When an embankment is built especially high in order to compact underlying peat or marl, the portion of he fill that rests above the final grade line is referred to as surcharge. 9. Project 063 - 22 This deposit is located about one mile north of Ortonville on M-15. The poor alignment on the old gravel road was corrected at this location and necessitated a 25 foot out immediately south of the swamp. This cut extends thru uniform.sand and gravel (Bellefontaine sandy loam) and is of particular interest because of the very large number of lime concretions found below the weathered portion of the soil. This observation helps to explain the unusual centerline profile of the deposit illustrated by figure 4. .. . ,. f' \ .- -L ..L .L 4 v ~ _. 1 3 1 K.» “JIL‘I. 14L: . -’ ~ I\ . 0 ~ . 1 ‘1 .‘.‘7 ~‘.- ‘1 . 4.;111 LOIU J-ij.‘ .. 5 ~ '“l _ _. L ' . . _ L- 3 (- r - . ‘- .‘ i The gravelly hill at station 560 to 564 evidently has been the source of both moisture and lime as proven by the fact that the marl deposit is thickest and purest next to the hill. A.bench swamp has also deveIOped above the marl and up the hillside “which could only take place under quite uniform.seepage. Figure 4. A profile view showing adjoining cut and fill sections. The surface peat was excavated six feet deep before placing the sand fill. The sand influence between station 568 and 569 undoubtedly helped to support the fill thru the area of aquatic peat in that part of the swamp. The main stabilizing influence throughout the deposit, however, is marl. \ N5 "\ \ \\. \ ,p\ Us \ \ Loam \ \ \_ “ \. ‘\._ N u M ER 0 \ W‘\ \a \ ’ \- \.\ \ BaLuzi-‘ogstTI-MNL. \ \SRNDY \ /\/ r \ .Ll ML CONCRL‘TID \. DHSHELD LNE. FPEPRiLssN-rs gRESENT‘ pAJITION 0F [Vaw FIJI—L. 10. The marl in this deposit was very soft and watery when investigations were first started. 30 soft, in fact, that the Davis peat sampler would slowLy sink into it without the application of pressure (Station 566/50)*. It was with consider- able interest, therefore, that the behavior of this material was watched to learn if so soft a marl would flow or compact when subjected to the weight of a heavy sand fill. An examination of this location after the fill was in place indicated that there had been practically no latteral flow in the marl and that it had become compacted. M‘— O: - Earth of Orto:ville 3t". F.L to "71 :3. 1?.11/12. Gen. View of highWry over marl degos' from high sandy hill. The original study of the location at station 568/50 failed to reveal any very pronounced marl influence. After the fill was in place, however, and the material had become compacted a strong marl influence made its appearance. This phenomenon is probably explained as follows: *50 feet beyond station 566 in figure 4. 11. As the load or fill is applied to the marly peat, water is squeezed out of the material causing a much greater shrinkage in the volume of the peat than in the volume of the marl. The marl influence would, therefore, appear much stronger after than before compaction. The fill across this swamp was placed during the fall of 1929 and the concrete surfacing was built the following summer. Considerable attempt was made to force the fill to settle thru the marl to solid bottom. The following is a quotation from.the Engineer’s weekly construction report for the period between October 17 and October 31, 1929: "The contractor is dynamiting the fill from.station 565 to 570 after the second loading. As result of the first loading and dynamiting the fill settled from 6 to 12 feet. As soon as the second dynamiting is complete the fill will be brought back to surcharge grade and settlement observations taken.” The method used in dynamiting at this location consisted of placing 4O sticks of explosives 2 to 3 feet below the bottom of the fill, 5 feet right and left of centerline, and every 10 feet longitudinally. This means that each time the swamp was dynamited 400 pounds of explosives were used per 100 feet of roadway. Before any filling or blasting was done, however, the surface peat was excavated 44 feet wide and 6 feet deep. The uniform compaction of the marl was greatly facilitated by this excavation which removed the mat of living roots as well as a large amount of fairly well preserved wood. 12. After two years of service the pavement over this deposit has not become appreciably warped. The only noticeable settlement is located at station 567. This settlement, however, is not serious enough to be apparent to the average driver. 13. Project 059 - 2h The third deposit of marl and peat to be considered is located on trunkline M-lh.about one half mile north of Sheridan in Montcalm.County. The original road across the swamp was built of sawdust and slabs. When this road began to fail another cor- duroy road was built and as this deteriorated and traffic demands increased the logs were covered more and more deeply with land and gravel. The profile study (Figure 5) shows two points in the swamp that evidently gave former road builders considerable trouble. Note the amount of corduroy, boulders and fill material at stations 5&9 to 551 and 556 to 558. At the time the profile study was made the fill at station 5MB to 551 was settling at a rate that demanded constant maintenance. The interesting feature about this profile study is the relation- ships that exist between the troublesome sections of the road and the marl areas of the stump. The old gravel road never 11059-24. 3—8-28. Ste 563 ~ Sounding in sink hole Figure 5. .A longitudinal profile showing one-half mile of highway construction across a swampcaf varying depth and composition. Note the supporting value of marl as compared to that of peat and marly peat. The old fill, corduroy, and surface were excavated before any new fill was placed. . . b 8912 , ‘_ -‘ _ ---JJU iii/g ____, .573 if? 5’15 Jf/é Jya 5?? . 7:514 TL}? LIKE. . PIPJLLLLL .9270 I I 1.. . s ._ r H I . ~ . 5:57 R'LY, .HQQJ'HTIE~ ' ' ‘ Ln $25.2 , Cu". .925”! .555 .1256 1.57 4:21 4:79. [/415- OHS/4&0 0F NLW FILL A. . ~E_ Snows SGT‘T'QM OPERHT/ONS HR; CoMPLaz-rg. .5211 -.fi’él. --. HF‘T'EF? CONSTRUCTION 8.00 -_ “.5111 ________ .523 Figure 60 A cross section taken at station 5h6+00 of the profile shown by figure 5. The supporting value of marl is again illustrated by this section. ‘ . . .0~ ...: q . H. .. n. -1 - . .. H . i . . .h. . q _ . n . h . . . a . i U U 1 . r _ _ . . _ . . . . . . . . n . .. Q o .. . . . o . . 7‘ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ‘ ¢ _ w . V . .. . N u _ _ a . h H , . . . . o . ..... I. . . . n W . . . _ .. 0 .....e. . . .0 0|... .. .. c .c . _ .9 . . . . u .o . . e . . . . . . . . _ _ . o . 0.. . . . . .Q .. . . .9 c . . H . H . _ . . V _ . . . . . . a V “ . H . . . . . . i . _ . Jfl1+Q§vQU ....BNT . . . . . _ . H , . . . V . V . . . a . W . . . V . . n A m . . , .“zuahtt‘nmfl ZQaabuuutLrnan 0"ka . n . H . a u . v H . . . .. . A . . . . . . . . . V U . _ H T.‘. .vlt‘.-yl0 ..--.V--‘le. . . , . o . . _ _ .00.! . . . V . . . . . .. . ., . . . . nelsu... 19$. SUHWF.G.QVIW::¥ - . . . i- .u ...: .H n . . _ . . . . M . .. . fl . W V . u u _ _ _ v o . _ . . , . . . . V . . . . H . .H . . . . . _ . 0251“: 427‘ lineman mind}. W q . u i _ _ H i H u _ . . . . . . _ o . V . . . . . . _ . n V . . _ H u . . . . . _ i Q‘ VI. 10.nlohb ’u. v.“ -... invvl I. .--.Q’...e . h..l.90t.-"..volb.'n toil... ,, 9.. ....-. "o. .9 . ,9 . a h ..c . . . h . . H . . m .h .. o . . a . ~ _ . . . . a .16“ . . . . . “HQ: . . V _ . _ . _ . fl . . a . .r _ . . . . . . . a ‘ . . . . . . . . . . . _ . . o . . _ o . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . ‘ . . . V . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . v. -. ... . . . . a . o . o. . . 9 . .. . . . .. ... .o . o . .e o . . . . a a .o . o . . . . . _ . . . . . . . _ _ _ . . . . _ . . . .e . . . . . . . . . . . a . . . . . h . . _ H V . h .. H H H H u H H _ . H u . .. . . . a _ _. e. . H ......O‘-'-hunl ...:‘OO .....Ino-. .. ¢.be..vao :1... o v.. .‘9090V6.v0..oe~ .-e...o...l.o . .. ... e u . .0 . ...... . . . ..“u .. . o .... .. e . . .o. ...-t. o . . . w . . . . . . . . .e“ .. J \ a . . .. . . .. . . . . _ _ . . . . . . . r. . . . . ~ . . o . o . n a . . . w v. u u QR SP. I.“ . I . . e. a . . a . . . . . . A . . . . . . . . .‘o o . 9. . , o , a . . . . ... . . . . . -Ot0bifit’..0|illbl§-ltt '10- . e"-‘.fi.c .. u . ... . .Oa.'c. ”to: o I . -..llto‘ '0-‘ . o . . .. . . . . . , .0!“ . _ i . o . . . . . . . . . a . . . . . . a _ _ . . i . .oo. . .~ . o . . .... ....-. . . o -.. . . . . I'OOA ~--+.-- i -.--o-o 7.99o‘400 ...... Q\a QFIW Figure 7. A cross section taken at station 550+OO of the profile illustrated by figure 5. There is no marl in- fluence at this point. The new fill, consequently, settled to firm bottom. “.mU‘Lux a .lflL-‘JI‘IOU. Iraq ”ZU.L.Q..IH‘Q . i 4 , .. . . . . . . .. a Q7 ...ZU.L.U.3E.rfl.ZQU 5.5.13. .41..l wen-Z. km 2.0 L. Q BL . . i . atmi_x0tfikm ”£4,01va 4.2.4 _DUInIQ H, ... . . . 4.»qu W. a u — . . .... ”a . . . . .m . , .4. . , . . . . . . . L. . . . .. . . . .. ... . . .. . _. ... . .. . . p. . . .. ...)...T ......,,.u,............ ... .. ... or. e 0 u. . . u ”a“. . 1.... («...- _..¢1.- ' . ... . u .. er ... I“... .~.ol. ufvo ......t to»... o . “2““ .. : .e .. _ cc... ... ..s ..q . . \ ... . . ... .% ... .. . ..., .. , T . .. u” . . o , .0 .n.I. I. ...l.e".l..u 0.1 ..l fe.;......ol , ....fi...” 1.0 .4. n,- a . It. .I a: e F... C»!- I...l\. . ...: .. p . — ;...'.‘. .ayi .. .... a..... .1 . . ... .fl . . . v. ... . .. . . . ...t. Tw......“~...M./.J.I.4_...a L”...b._rrl.”A-.nr..-V.V...V... ”141’ ......r...‘... .me..~.1...r..fim..r._.. ‘...J ...ra. .550F .. ..I 0%.”... th/wrrvw . w . ...J.Ll;a u . . .... .... . V . .. l \. 3.431“. . .. -...Qra. “who...“i ... \ . . . . . Kg. . " hid-ill?! e- ., , . ..... h J—uuoa Q” . .i 4 H i . i m I . m _. . . . + H ._ .. LLQHQ. Ushthflm . ZUJHEWNH . ... .. _ . . . . w ..... - . _ . _ . m H H .. .. ........ .. .. -. . . . . . . «\h :Fi -..-I..- . .. . . . «TIN- ... rt .. .1 w .7 . .. ... . Ii “ _ . H — _ ‘N ..t \I' ‘ I _ . . . .. 2+. - ow; éq J.d§r40su.rdmsmrn’.e"luu1w\rn . .1... . -.. . .. a x if x. XXMwm , ...?w. . .. p Q I“ \/ IN “I Q! . ’ésl . Q. ”A o \l a ... ' .l. . '. ...! ‘hliol li‘-'-‘.'II-I.!" bps “9......th ZO‘FIFn Iuanrnuuumw. WWOFQU ...... . ,. :-I~L2Q>e 2‘nnadt0. *‘N‘vhg Fdfluugkm Figure 8. A cross section taken at station 556+OO of the profile illustrated by figure 5. There is enough.marl in the aquatic peat at this point to prevent total peat displacement. Note the influence of the marl at the left on fill penetration. OQ axh oth. P---— o..-o.—..--——.4<--ON_- . . o - l l I .. oo~c6oo- V O l . ..-.. I Ii.“ . . (I o. . o. .- .o 0 .. u. . .c . Ucn'~-? .....- . . o . _ h . . . . . . o . . . . - . O--- . . . w IO . . oqq . “ . n u u _. . u” o . . . . . . . . . . . . o - o _ . 0.- -. o . . ~ - . . . . . . . . . .. . ... m .eeotg.; :ou ..on r an ....n A>B¢WI 1w... .3 tan... o. '0‘. o . . y - ..oe Q ~. _ . . . .... . .. . .-OE'IL.'O-91.4'O‘I|I; . . . W i . w . H 1 . .. o O I...‘.. . a ... . . ... .v«. Q ... ‘ . ...".-» fixmoha. .20.?PQL.W.. -?Q.~F . . O 9 UN.” -0420th . . . . . thmflfiz:~. . ... . vQVo.Q.-O.O_.vo-?c..o... . > . y -.l . . . .. . . o .c. o . . o. o a . ... . . . ‘ 5|... OI’iAiOO‘.tO-v lotto- . in. . . .. . . . . H o > . . o .. .0 . . , 0!... O¢A - .OO'IO ... v o . o o o ‘ n.w. .0 0 e o. . . o . n . o . . . k ._ . .. . . . . 0 Ll ! -99.!c0 Av c- It. . J .. . . . . fi. .» ... .. . . .. . u .. . . . . . . . _ a t...' .... .o ......n . v. . .. . g a . . . . . a o n . _ y . . w . . .09.-.-V‘i. n-0‘. DOV-.. 0' -I 0.! . 7., 4 . . q§ . . . . o n _ H . . . o . . . ... M q o -o .. . u . o .1 w . .. . . . a .. .. .I 0.. . . . 90.19.lo..o.-C,loo o .009.‘¢f‘ .V-t-. - 0-- 9.. t .I . A a. . . . . .> o *0. .....m. . . . o. I . . .. . . .. ..... . . . n ....a . o .. .. e . . . u D o n ” «I. O . . . n . u . . .'$.04 0...--v Q o A . .Q\“‘ .0 .- n y a .. ... .. .. . .. or . ., SR ._-- 15. Very little action was obtained. Practically all the additional settlement occurred at the two points where the marl influence is the weakest, namely, stations 5&8 to 552 and 55b to 559. Figures 6, 7 and 8 show in detail the relative supporting value of‘marl, peat and a mixture of the two materials. The pavement across this swamp was constructed during the summer of 1931 and to date no settlement is apparent to the casual observer. Some facts observed in studying this location: 1. The best marl is located in the shallower portions of the swamp. 2. No amount of dynamiting or jetting would cause the good marl to move out from.below the new embankment. 3. The old road had been giving trouble from the first over the two short sections of the swamp in which there was no, or very little, marl influence. The most troublesome spot was located at station 550. 16. Project 059-27 The twin deposit of marl, peat and clay considered in the following few pages is located on Trunk Line M-lb.about three miles south of Sheridan in.Montcalm County. The upland soils to the north of this deposit are largely sand and gravel, while the soils to the south seem.to consist of several feet of till clay underlain by sand and gravel. Both of these soil conditions permit a springy condition at the base of slopes as is shown by the accompanying photographs. The marl found in this deposit undoubtedly has its source in the waters seeping from.the uplands surrounding the swamp. The first glance at the sketches of this deposit (Figures 9, 10, 11 and 12) would lead one to suspect that the supporting value of marl is very low or no better than that of peat. The reason for including this swamp in the study is to show the influence of a soft lake deposited clay on the sup- porting value of overlying materials. It had been observed on several locations that this soft lacustrian clay accelerates the movement of peat under load and sometimes even causes the highway embankments to assume unusual cross sections. In other words, this clay acts as a lubricant and is efficient enough in this respect to permit marl to move laterally when subjected to unusual pressure from above. See Figure 12. A study of the swamp profile reveals the fact that, here again, the better marl has been deposited in the shallower , “- . 1‘3! /.: ‘K. .at ~ 4* J .Ji§‘~flm4ihg" is" )57-27 Sheridan So. 2-23-33 Stokstad Sta 327 R. POggy condition of side hill indicates seepage. Figure 9 A longitudinal profile showing highway construction across a twin deposit of peat, marl and laoustrian clay. The heavy dashed line indicates the depth to which the new fill penetrated. Note that the marl is almost completely displaced. For explanation see pages 16 and 17. _VAT FUR 1.---.EA m . .1 .Iw'xwlp.-.rln>| . ,1 .} +IT~I 91:}?! _ f .‘ “9| t ., “in” ‘6' IA v1.H| k e .\.'lf.lc 5.57" Help. f 7'“. 2 ’2 -.5’ HLUE. 0F MG 1... -.- ..— o~o- -o.-oo-. F3530.) CT, 051770 - TING Hows Q a ... R E o W. IV a 0 L. N L u L F N a T. Luvs. THE. juppo E5 -— 5?.OFILE. 5 a..w1N 0 b l— - -.-»... iyf- HIS/9' 5! ”0.8:, H QR_ URCHB R E. No '71:. OF’ NEW F/ N75)? Lma UPCHBF? /" ~45 Figure 100 A cross section taken at station 528+50 of the profile shown in figure 9. The marl influence in the aquatic peat is enough to prevent lateral flow in the lower portion of the clay fill. -7—uu--—--- —.--— , "'T v I Jan-9:4 c: ..‘ffi 5.95).! -w.’ I _' O. I O I 00.0-09-0- O. at. 09500‘9.0 Nculn/ 3’1; ,tf" \ o i O .1-r--..--. 'v 0.0 o“‘ ..~-1- I - 1-....-. . A. L---.~ Figure 110 A cross section taken at station 352+OO of the profile illustrated by figure 9. The marl has been only partially displaced in this shallower portion of the swamp. 7/5 .9. 7Com. 772A -.., ..- ...- ._.A ._.._._. ‘H- #0 v 3‘ J Q ‘3 / 9 i /0 p 1 c J o // o 50 do 70 X0 7: AM fl 4 F/ N 3.1—..- -A- - . ~ A. -~ \Y\ . \ ‘ \\\\ \\\\\: \ \ / ‘ .‘\ \ \ ‘ ‘ “ Wm“- 'z _~~ yk‘bfigfi ... «no \\ \\\ \ \ \\ Wflff' W i ' . _ .9 9.9,..."' . .v. - ~ - ~ .. sTflT/DN 332+00 ,i. ..-—...- .q... - A... -..... £730 "‘ v— x , 5’10 , , {a . '. . v - _ '1: /‘_ V . )\ J» ‘d; _ -l . ‘ ‘3"..- ‘ ". .. ‘g i.( i . £53.: ... T. - ... a,‘ ." ‘ ‘ ’ _ r’r. . 1‘" ~ M m a- s ...“ ‘ .h . .2 VI. . .3. '- .-- l- ' ;. "'. - - -‘ < M"”M.-fi.--Mn- IO-~----wu-~---.—I_~--V"—-- »- ...--- » ‘ '— ' o . . 0 , . 4. . ."%V ‘nv V‘Vers‘ _j ; . .Mmez. . I . I V I A V ' i b , 270 99999 999 999999 99"? 9,9'9‘99 _. ,. _ . ~k¢.’.’9’9’.9.”.9i9.9.9.9.9l99. ”Aargyag we“ - .‘ .. ‘A‘A '. ,,u . 'Vv " ' v ... .... V VVVV 'Vv vvvvvv v ; 5m ~ .99’9‘99‘5' 9'9’9? «“99'99'9999'99999 9999' 1 , “QM _ 0" an” ‘s/ i/Xj Y . . _‘ . ~, ‘ l 7&0 O ..- wins v»""..'f.- , 1 2* ~ 'e‘esar» - mum cagflmvnx ~~-- " ‘ a' ' ..... 1"” ~ f¢-'-. ~a < a Figure 12. A cross section at station 33h+oo of the profile sketch, figure 9. The marl has been completely displaced on centerline. The lubricating influence of the blue clay seems to have facilitated lateral flow in the marl. t W-—+i-~. 5730 30 0 /0 ID 9 ELEVHTION oo oo 0 0 17. portions of the swamp. The aquatic peat between stations 327+50 and 528+50 does not contain enough.marl to support the fill on centerline, but it does contain enough to prevent the complete displacement of the peat at the sides. A clay fill displacing pure peat over lacustrian clay would tend to dis- place all the peat, much of the underlying clay, and often spread out to unusual widths on the bottom. In other words, the marly aquatic peat, shown in figure 10, offers enough resistance to flow so as to confine the embankment even tho it does not completely support it. The marl displacement, shown by figure 12, is very un- usual. It can be accounted for only by the combined effect of the clay fill and the soft clay layer between the marl and the sand bottom. A wet clay fill has a tendency to flow laterally. As stated before, the underlying lacustrian clay aids this tendency by acting as a lubricant. The rebuilding of the road across this swamp was started during February, 1932. The swamp was excavated and backfilled from.station 336 to 3h2+50 and surcharged and dynamited from 327+30 to 336. The heavy dashed line on the profile shows the depth to which the new fill penetrated the swamp. The section between stations 327 and 330 was blasted after the original filling was completed in order to obtain more thorough displace- ment of the marly peat. Very little additional settlement was obtained, however. 18. The pavement across this swamp was opened to traffic August, 1932. To date the only settlement apparent is loc- ated at station 328+75. It is of interest to note that this settlement has occurred in the deepest part of the swamp where the fill rests directly on the underlying lacustrian clay. No settlement has occurred from station 327+50 to 328+OO where there is a maximmn of 12 feet of marly aquatic peat below the fill. __~‘ 06"27 Sheridan 3. Sta 327—3uo CLS 2-1-3; adjoining deposits - one is marl and the other peat. 19. Project 0111-37 The next swamp considered is one-half mile long and is located on the new West Belt Road of Grand Rapids about 1% miles south of the intersection with M-SO. The swamp is timbered to a considerable extent with elm and maple. The soil survey of Kent County classifies the swamp area as Carlisle Muck, and the surrounding mineral soils as Plainfield, Coloma and Bellefontaine. Here again is a high-lime swamp surrounded by sandy upland soils. The work of constructing a satisfactory grade across this swamp was accomplished in two stages. Most of the work was done between March 1 and November 8, 1929. On this contract the fill was placed 1.]. feet above plan grade and 32 feet wide. Next the "sink hole” was blasted using 260 pounds of dynamite per station and then reloaded. Borings taken to study peat displacement after construction work was completed indicated that considerable soft material still remained below the fill. It was decided that another attempt would be made to more completely displace underlying unstable peat and marl. In order to give a clear picture of the work performed, and results obtained, the Project Engineer's weekly construction reports will be quoted. "12-10-31. First overload complete. (Overload consists of building fill 5 feet above grade). Started driving pipe for blasting. 12917-31. Settlement of from 2 to 6 feet obtained on blasting. Figure 13 A profile view of a highway embankment across one-half mile of swamp. Centerline soundings on which this profile is based would indicate that practically all of the marl and peat has been displaced. The influence of the marl is best shown by figures 1h and 15. d 570 X \ \ 47D \ , p \ - 1..., 3‘ T\"\\' .\ - . ' ,-\\ \ .k‘ \ K \ \s “ \ 140 AM ‘I XI. 2.7 Waxes: \ \ \ ‘ .\ x \. \~ \. \ \ ~ \ \ x K \ ~ \ \ \ \\\‘\ \ 22’ \ \ \ \ \ r 7» ~ -A \_ x \ \ \ \ \ \ \ n \ \ \ \ \ \ \ 2C9 N. - \» ~\, \ \ ‘;.vaa.‘_fi‘oiofi‘rensvm-vo—Q—-——‘-<-—‘.r———‘--—-.¢- \ \ \ '\ \ \ \ _ « \ \ \\ \ \ . \ \\\ \ \\ \\ \ \ ~ ~ ~ ‘ \ " . \ ‘ \ \ \ . A\ x \ - ‘~ \ " ~ g X \ O ,. I Ffiwdscr G .9 FM; (3‘— 4" ,._, , ‘3le .HHD\:1_. \. “ \. “‘I‘\ ‘ / , , \y - \.\.\ \ y/P’; .\ fifimy. \ W , w ~ V‘ m. , ”fir-..‘ t//_ . . I h ' >‘I " I.‘\‘T\-_“/: . , '."I"‘“ I'.‘ ... D it ‘ ' xéuIIJCH'HIYt-‘ELIZ '7 a £34 .77 if? ‘3'7 (3-3 SRHNQ F04wv37 CLN'I‘EI? LIME \ \ x x \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ~ \ \ \ \ \ \ \‘ \ x \ \ \ \ ~ \ s \ ~ ~ ‘ \ x \ x ,. - . \ \ \ \ \ . \ s _ ‘ \ - \ \ \ ‘\ \ u v ‘ ) H \ \ \ \ x \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ‘ ‘ \ \ x \ \ \ \ \ x \ K \ \ . \ -\ x x '\ x x \ 'x \ a \ x \ \ \ . x \ ‘ x \ \ x \ x \ \ \ x x \ x \ \ \ x \ \ \ \ t \ ~ \ \ \ x \ \ \ x \ \ \ \ r \ ». \ \ \ \ _ \ \ x \ \ \ \ \ \ \ x s \ \ \ a \ \ \ \ k \ x \ \ \ x ~ ~ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ t \ \ \\» FP/QPI 1:35: FDROF‘ILJL. ./-,.' . ‘ .-. “A,” --.L..‘~’ \ i \ \ . x \ \ \ x \ x t x » up" "sfi.-- ,_ ,. HI‘LJ cm ’7; 9L H *‘ -e v"."“" _‘fi‘flffigfih B LFLST‘LL; M/ .5: z; 7" - (7.7 t- \ t \ k x t _- . x >- ...4 \ . GLLT‘ \ #2 #3 ' v-——._—-V_. w ’f‘b 52 Figure 11;. A cross section at station 37+OO of figure 13. The marl influence in the aquatic peat has prevented total dis- placement. ¢ . o o o t , . r «- O<>O*O 0 -osuo -101 O D. 9' CV. }. 1‘. I. .0 .. ...—-Hq-» - e v- 7‘ " . . i Q ... 04 e ..v.. {Ii 1 As 1.11 41. ‘ 41 4‘ . 01.14. . u. .. .... o. .M *.e 0. «>5. HUI“ ......o.. . . o.fi.¢ .... .. . o . .. . .. . .."o.... o «co. ... o o . ... . I s . o . . .. q . . . a . m. on I“ J .... ........ ... ... .. . .u. 99. ... . . a. .. u . . .oer v... . . . ... . .voa..ee. . . . 91010191.; x. OOPO . 1.1T 1. .o‘vvnt I, ....... -oYlOo“ ..o .. . .v ..... . o ... . . u . o. . . .. .. . .. 01...... . u I. . . u . . .o .u o . . . c .. ... . o e v ..V V’OOOI'IV‘IO-A '.!011 v- ? 1 i V 0 i 9 i 9 I O J 3 1 o >- o I 0 ’I“- 0 i '. ...AL... ' o o . .. .. e ... u . . . .. . n s . . . . . ... n . o 1 .. . .. .... ... . - .. ... .../st ..rc .. fi‘.."l’{e 1’34.-fl.$ t'!‘ : o..l.'v.tl..ll‘sll‘.|"911.-.l.’ -Lit‘. it; . ob. ..v Clo . 1 n . . u .. u .. . :‘J’l' . .. w; . U ...... . an ..... . ... .. Tum“. ...... . . ... ...«u .........\.. s v ... . .. .35... .r . 2...... .... .... ... .I.r......”: 4...»... ... J..... ;w o a! o . . . ... . ...\ . . ... ... .. 1.. .. . u o. .a......w.. u.sh.......1r\liwolh.o‘n" 2‘ ..l . ... P. I a ho ...JJ... . . . . . .. . . c '0 u‘n .9..-“ inc. e. .. ...... .. ”.....o‘o. b ‘0‘ in}... o“?. . v .- o. .0 . V1.11. O . .t- . . .... I. . 0.. .3. ...v .- .$.. .I....a..1..h .aIOLIL—‘(flv ..I . . . . . i . .... .. s. and: \. ... . of...fl..... .. . s. .1 .0”. J“... t” .nled...su.nn . o l . . . . a.” . . ....sof...n .0. ..fflolcrb - .IUW «I; .... ... ...kWuAX-T... P.m.ol . $0....- wank“: ... ...:45 t...) .n . ,. . . . . rnob... Kn ..l...... . s I ....c: o:uro ...- . . . . . . .Lln‘ . . ”tag. .. >4tqz. >Q£ w KM . .....-.f...-. . , 1.140-091..- w .obwllo-.v-o.3.0-.f o 3 --- 1&1...” 01-- Olson v - 3.10-. . o . . . .. 11.. '1‘- . . . s 4 . . . . . 51: t.:.‘ - ..o.. . 1". ' u w‘OwLMWtukuW‘CO" ......Istt. H whit... ...a.....~.§s.3 , $9. . 9v .9“. . QR .. . ox u... 3 ed cw; QOtFfl: Zeatttm... Lt zoxkdum unoflxb Q §. .L": in ..o.-- — o -'- FJHQ hmuxxi flQ\QQQ szkb humiliu .ruufiomafik Figure 150 A cross section at station h3+00 of figure 13. A boring on centerline does not truly portray the in- fluence of the marl at this point. The marl content in this deposit is only strong enough to partially support the highway fill. .mux .cK. snn11‘1i<‘flwl.altll1 I in I 4. , u u . . v . . . ..Ol .‘ .... .1 1.. .le.I$Iu ..--.- . . , .. ...} ...;---..-- '1' Q h. . . . . . . . Y-I.«-l0ncv1.o.- .. .. . ,ot 0... stock.......‘ _ ... .. . . v. . . . o s n _ . . . , . . _ a. ... . r.1 ' o . . . .. . .v _ . .. .o. . . . . vQ. I. .... a. . e... 1 «a a . o . r . . .. v I, . . N ,. O . s ' . . ‘ . I s A _ v.-1-§l.1ll!‘01. 01h! .-. ¢’1 1.; -19.. . . o . . I 0 no r . . o . .00. o l u o 0 d . T 1 Jul . n . cl 0 O . . .I o I .u . I e. . . - . a... c .. y . I. I. .. . v1. .00 .... ? I 1 6 f l I V O 0 1 1 I‘VV'--7V-- . $4QKE.>K~K0 . . . . A . . _ I‘.1A.IIII‘-I IQOO{IY|1-1:OU 111 0.9.1 . . . . g Q . a . o . . . o . . . . . . I L I 9 l 1 i ; . 1 20. 12-31-31 First blasting complete. Drag line excavating trench along sides of fill to provide space for peat displacement. Second loading and blasting to follow soon. l-7b32 Peat excavation complete by end of week. Second overload started. 2-19-32 Second overload complete. Second blasting started. 2526-32 Second blasting complete, Settlement of from 3 to h.feet obtained. 3-hp32 Started third overload. Considerable settle- ment obtained because of additional fill weight. 3-16-32 Third overload complete. A925-32 Surcharge removal in progress. 5—20-32 Surcharge removed. Grade raised one foot to provide for waste peat. 7-11-32 Highway paved and open to traffic." When.the filling operations were complete for the second time, borings were taken again by means of a hydraulic drilling outfit to determine the position of the new fill. These borings showed that peat displacement was incomplete in spite of all efforts to displace it. These borings also showed that since the peat had become compacted a fairly strong marl influence had made its appearance. Again compaction of the peat and loss of water in the compacted.material resulted in a change in.the volume differential between the peat and marl. In other words, the marl occupied a larger percentage of the volume after compaction than before compaction. 21. After discovering the presence of'marl in the peat no attempts were made to widen the fill at the bottom. A check- up on the behavior of the road to date indicates that absolute stability had been reached before surfacing was placed. Much of this stability is undoubtedly due to the time factor involved. Grading over this swamp took place over a period of two years during which time the swamp was blasted three times and the surcharge brought back up to surcharge grade five times. This tremendous amount of work, excellent fill material (sand), and ample time for settlement have combined to produce an unusually stable grade. 22. Project 030-19 The new highway grade between Hillsdale and Osseo crosses a small swamp located about two miles southeast of Hillsdale between Baw'Beese Lake and Boot Lake. The surrounding upland soils are sandy and gravelly, consisting mainly of the Hillsdale, Bellefontaine, Plainfield and Fox Series. The marl content of this swamp seemed small at the time the survey was made. In fact, it was thought the construction procedure would not be seriously affected by it. The road plans were consequently set up for total excavation from.station 156 to l§9+h0 and from.station 1hl+70 to 1h2+50. The balance of the swamp was to be surcharged and blasted. The swamp at station 137 proved to be too deep to excavate, consequently the con- struction procedure was changed. The new plan called for excavation 8 feet deep and 2h feet wide throughout the entire swamp; then loading to 5 feet above grade to compact or displace the marl and aquatic peat below the 8 foot depth. Excavation thru this swamp was started.May 28, 1951 and the filling was completed by the middle of June of the same season. No surfacing has been placed on this grade up to this time. It is expected, however, that the finished road will prove to be stable. There are two important factors combined in the construction across this swamp that usually result in an excellent finished job. These factors are (1) the use of a sand and gravel fill material and (2) ample time for proper settlement. 23. Figures 16 and 17 are sketches showing a profile and cross section of the highway embankment and its relation to the underlying peat and marl. r”...-- < ...... ,\\ ‘. ._4 V Q o 1 9- 1 o O I O --.-- . . "3; HH 5N PHGI’. 22 A~023 ' w’SCUGSIOh-I I i M" 7 :' E ””5; 0‘ 5 I - : f m i' H: ' I ' N g... - N . . ‘ : 2 u - . : 2 ' g E .3 {L ... i ' . 2 . z . 5 . ... Q I--. a. .- . . . z . i .: . . 9 . 5 I’m ': 11' 7 :' . . . Q ' ' : : 3 I I“; ---...... -- . . _U - -- -: I...- 4 .. i " 3 Inn-3% f1. I.-. a... in“: {mauinwriEfi 2"} [..--3 g . -. - . a ' Z w . h ......_: -- .-. .,._. .--...J .' .. i -- I‘. : 2:“) . ' 3 Ii ' g " . ”ufi}§"_“u H“ ..HH 9) . u z q - Q g -: ;m_“§,nwfl}u m . g . 3 o- - ... " '" of”? P' -4 - u: ' :. .H: rt--~-~:~--« ~— ' " --r---: [1--- “I“ 2 ; I . “-..”..“o-o—o- 5 I T‘ --. «--.. - -. I O o o 0-0.”--- 0..-- ... .. ' ,. ' . . o n ' ' n '0. ‘ 9~ - . 3| s . . 1 1 .b-..-.-...-.ooo—‘I .- 1/00 I090 FIG. 214. Project 039-? The new highway crosses this swamp just off the east end of Sugarloaf Lake about three miles north of the Village of Schoolcraft in Kalamazoo County. The swamp at this crossing is almost 3000 feet wide, has a maximum.depth of about 56 feet, consists principally of marl, and is part of a long chain of lakes and swamps. The mineral soil uplands surrounding this area belong to the Fox, Plainfield and'Warsaw Series. The thin.mat of surface peat over the marl in this deposit ranges from.6 inches in thickness thru the central portion to a maximum of about 5 feet near the edges of the swamp. The surface of the marl remains at a fairly constant elevation, whereas the elevation of the peat surface increases as the edges of the swamp are approached. This change in surface elevation is also reflected in the type of vegetation growing on the peat. The principal reason for locating the highway across this swamp was to elimdnate two railroad crossings and two right angle turns. A prelimdnary study of the swamp was made during the winter of 1930 and 1931. By this time considerable knowledge had been gained regarding the value of marl as a sup- porting material. When it was found that the swamp consisted largely of‘marl, it was decided to study the deposit in detail to see if the marl.might be of such quality as to pr0per1y support a road bed. Preliminary soundings were obtained during march, 1931. Three different lines were studied before accepting the final highway location. The first line included 5300 feet of lcr"ft 2912C. "—1 -\2 surcharge accelerateu “cross in 2 days. 3 d 25. swamp, ranged in depth from.h.to 12 feet, and contained no marl. The line chosen included only 2800 feet of swamp, but had a maximum depth of 36 feet of which 6 inches to 5 feet was peat. Grading operations thru the swamp were started in February, 1932, and were completed to surcharge grade by August, 1932. The procedure followed is illustrated by figure 18. Sand and gravel obtained from special borrow pits at each end of the swamp fill was used as fill material. During the course of con- struction gradual settlement took place at all times, more rapidly at first, but gradually slowed up as the marl became compacted. At times, certain sections settled faster than others, but there were no sudden breaks causing the fill to disappear below'water, such as characterizes filling operations over swamps consisting of peat alone. Figures 19 and 20 are cross sections taken after settle- ment had stopped and before the surcharge was removed. Figure 21 is a longitudinal profile study showing the position of the fill at the highway centerline. The shaded profile near the top of figure 21 shows graphically the fill settlement that has taken place during the three months period between August 27 and November 30, 1932. The maximum.sett1ement during that time was 0.70 feet which occurred at station 68. Note, however, the uniformity of the settlement. By November 30 the settlement had practically stopped. It was decided to remove the surcharge immediately in order that the finished cross section.might have ample time to arrive Figure 18. This figure is a detail showing the construction procedure used in grading across the swamp. The amount of fill needed was underestimated by about 19 percent. i‘,..$‘.m.-&.'w:. 7:4,. %%‘~., : ‘1);in ‘ - H" I is? if“; h | I - t L“ . "‘1 “p Q; cgfled K): on phi/’75 » ‘ _ , , "—N .- --_ _—_a 3&3 - . ._ _‘ -- [0 >4 /& " ‘h i l L («g/roam loco-"K79 ( r 7 Pro oed finished earfh “J _ '7 A. \ \\\ 93 \O/ 5urf‘ace Peav‘ fa \ g \\ :1". ”an“; " - be excawafea’ "‘ \ . / | . - Swan? bn‘ch as . co//e for on p/ano ‘ . _fg flaaahc Peat Mar/ éfc. _/ Prabab/e d/olb/acemenfi of aaaaf/c Peat mar/f ego—r k/ fofima/ed 01' 25% or" deaf/x: / | / \ . // \ \ ~ I '§~_ : EXCAVATING SURFACE PEAT, BACKFILLING TRENCH, AND COMPACTING MARL AND AQUATIC PEAT. / From are 537* 70 2’0 3‘0. 6/»‘60 fhe 50/7603 060/ #5 7o be exooyar'ed fo rhe w/a’z’h ,Jnd/cafea’ /n fhe 3ker‘ch I down 7‘o he more ofaA/e m/xfure ofMar/ana’ Honor/c / Feat 'vmedzafe/y *hereaf‘fer fhe french shah 'be baa/(fined ana ."daded wn‘h Sound earfh ofher fhon , do or o/xf it) fne he/ bf and wxa’fh ma’lcar‘ed 1n fhe _/ o/refch for 5archarae oad/nrz. The fl/h’n and /oaa’/'n :50 for a: ooo/b/e ‘oho// be aa’e m /a re of‘no/ mo / fhon one 002‘ m fh/C/rneso and aha.” be fhorou h/ com- /.,' , Pocfea’ b) driya/na and I’D/H07 or ofher Mean [D/OI'OVCO/ . by Me Eno/ne r ’ ‘ j /’ The 5dmharae Load/no aha/I be ma/nfa/nea/ by fhe (4 Uflflc Peaf Mar/ 8/0 A Grad/no Confxac/or or fhe’W/dfh and e/evaz‘l'on shown In rhe q U ' t ‘ L 3/“:ch for a @7091 ofnof /eoo fhan nx'nerzeabyo ano’ShO/Y _ . W rhen be moo /- fr/mmed up and /ef‘f er move/ by fhe Hf m ”70/33/70 , Surfacv'na Confroal‘or. The excovafed [veaf shah be d/o ooed of In fhe area oefween the 5am. or e Load}, a a fhe 5wam DI/C‘heo DETAIL SHOWIN METHOD OF or berneen fine 5 ’I’C/‘ZN’QG .190 '[n and fhe ff W fines EXCAVATION AND LOADlNG SWAMP Line/"e no a’ir'Cheo are aimed for: na’ sha// be uniform STA 53+7O Td‘) STA- 8' + 80 abreaa and eye/ed 50 a: 2‘0 d‘a/n nar'ura/ly away from 8 .Kl. fhe Contracfor ana// momfa/n dra/na e b dire/7.31 ransom/1 Caner-rs, or crher mefnoa’a oahofacfor 7‘o fhe En Ineer Jun-to a/x operar/one of‘araa’m? fhra fhe [Deaf moron. F76 - [:“élJ-B-C-B -. ZQfi‘r Fri ”U.QJ.HN»HHNN ---.Ifl. kttU4UQbUQ.--. ...... 81.“.HEQ-Lfijuu \J-QVLHKFWHK ___' - ? ooooo-o— ......i. h ... E i i 7m“.-“ .T‘------_- §$3§tON ll“- .ti' I 0 >4 tees ‘ i t _,--...-~.—. I ‘ f 3 -- -- a- ..f- 0—--- . - o l A v .------.. ---. -... ’. s - VP”"+”' » . {r---.4----4 ...----4 ...... I 0 - r“ -77-.. 11 3 a i 8 1 ...-.....a “7’1” . .--..¢-.s ~00- .... v ..c... .-.-0..-. oo—dr’--.‘ ./9 F" TnuhVivrfixfi n zcxzb. .19.}. «Wt. .hm.\. «(«UVTF. “1.!va .rvluflrxfidukw ...ZAHU $.51. ......- “wield-1.1. ..ilh. EtHuIJnVAUICUmMHI .... . “Lolnvnifiv «FUN . Q§ (VU'J-UHH I: l 0 I . ~ ‘ ..-. ”ofO-oo-O , . . ... l 4%. . . . _ ... t v -.....mp. -v 9w -.-' F T” 1 -15; 7 - T :i ‘ 4 V v . WW» Mahala..-" - I ' . 1‘.- O n | .‘..¢ 4- , --l-- .-- v .--- '--.,_-_.____‘- «m 0 “0.. .c. e. .l.., ...a... lie .w...r.—~-- ..._. -¢--. 7....-.7‘ ;.‘--- -2. -..---u- l I u c‘ I ....... ‘ . .... v» ..« 7v. .yw ..—..Y._.-..~r-v.-r,.w .. ‘ I 0 zhiifiaiziéz His? > {$3. .4:‘ I“... -4; ..-, .y .1: . V, ... 8 ..‘."‘- a o ....-q -... ...T7-.+.H._.,_,..__.+_7.,-_-g-_ / ’J H No .J ‘. A-I .qfiu Av- 7 ". .. " 'r 1 . g Ls. A 4 FleT'- 73 £9.81?! r «aio‘hn-vul: C‘Il‘ ‘JU‘O' ‘.W-‘.d"‘fl-u.--Mv-n-....u.‘ ‘7‘."""" I I .-4. ...—.4 “a -.. . ‘ . V r . 'u --p... . v v H”-.-H-.._. . ..... .‘.L_.*.__l' ' 7““ .... ._;,.... / ‘Ill 4.e‘..-.--.-1--.»-_.v..-... . 'I yofic‘W‘ , irl‘b- T..g,.q’...:‘e.u;~ A _.-<_,...—o__v_ ‘ .-.-...,--..'._-l.... ..l... u . y . , . . 7 7 / ..... : .- fiadficr 039—7 SCHOOgCRRFT‘ RELOCATION -. . PROF/1.5 l/usw £9: MflFfl. DLPasl-‘rs— . .. Q STHTION 53 To Y3 2‘ I DISCUSSICN QM PA as. Z: {. . Hazy-.33"; aw -...‘.—..._._-‘._ .--.A- . . -o 5.. at a new equilibrium before construction is started on the concrete pavement. The pavement must be in place by July 1, 193% During the process of construction samples were collected of the marl to study its uniformity. Table 1 shows the results of analyses performed according to the outline accompanying the table. There are a few things of interest to be learned from a study of Table 1. For instance, note the relationship that exists between the Ca003 content and the field classification of the sample as listed under Field Netes. ‘When the CaC03 percent falls below 90 the sample is usually classified as peat. The samples classified as marl with only a slight peat influence range in CaC03 content from.92 to 96 percent. The material des- cribed as compact aquatic peat occurring near the bottom of the deposit proved to contain from 7 to 39 percent clay as well as a considerable amount of CaCO3. The organic content of the samples collected ranged from 0.1 to 9.0 percent and.mineral content ranged from 91.0 to 99.9 percent. These figures are not a true index of the importance of the organic influence in the marl. See page 2 for the discussion of this subject. A special attempt was also made on this swamp to determine what had happened to the marl over which the highway embankment had been built. Numerous samples for moisture tests were taken. It was assumed that some information regarding the relative comp- action of the marl below and beyond the fill could be gained by studying the moisture content of samples taken to form a cross section. Figures 22 and 23 show'the results at the two sections studied in this manner. PROCEDURE FOR m ANALYSIS 03' SAMPLES Dry sample at 105'0 to 110°C until the water is removed. Pulverize sample taking care not to break the mineral particles. 002 determination Loss on ignition at (Lharshall's 900'0 will be 002 improved Scheibler's evolved from carbonates Calcimeter) and organic matter. \ / 1 Organic matter obtained by subtracting 002 evolved by acids from loss on ignition } Wash sample thru 270 mesh sieve ( .053 mm opening) . / \ mm 2m Sand Soluble salts such as Ca (E)? plus c ay and silt. TABLE NO. 1 LABORATORY ANALYSIS or MARL SAMPLES PROJECT 039-7 Depth Loss on % 9 Composition of Mineral Field Notes Taken .Station .Sampled ignition 002 Organic Mineral % 0a 003 8 Sand 393120? Silt When Samples Were Collected 55 8.5-11.0 28.95 26.29 2.71 97.29 58.96 15.00 23.80 Sample of peat. Sandinfluence. 57 3.7-9.5 99.65 91.70 2.95 97.05 93.50 Trace 3.55 Marl with peat influence. 7.0-8.0 93.05 92.70 0.35 99.65 97.00 0.0 2.65 Aquatic peat, strong marl inf1ueaee 11.0-12.0 93.30 92.96 0.89 99.16 96.00 1.9 1.76 a..§‘..a.;.1"’ 15.0-16.0 91.8 91.3 0.5 99.5 92.0 _- 0.3 7.21 9 9 9 19.0-20.0 92.0 90.1 1.9 98.1 89.6 1.9 7.1 9 n n 23.0-29.0 93.0 92.6 0.9 99.6 95.0 1.9 3.2 Fair marl. Sma11 percent peat 27.0-28.0 99.2 91.2 3.0 97.0 92.0 0.5 9.5 u 9 u ’1 n « 31.0-32.0 93.8 91.5 2.3 97.7 92.7 0.9 9.6 9 n n u a 39.5-36.0 39.9 38.5 0.9 99.1 85.7 0.5 12.9 Marly aquatic peat. 59 3.5-9.5 99.6 92.2 2.9 97.6 99.2 0.9 3.0 a... with some peat. 7.0-8.0 95.0 92.0 3.0 97.0 93.7 0.2 9.1 u 9 n u 11.0-12.0 93.9 91.9 1.5 98.5 93.5 0.5 9.5 n n n u 15.0-16.0 99.5 93.0 1.5 98.5 95.8 0.1 2.6 9 u u u 19.0-20.0 93.0 92.9 0.1 99.9 95.6 0.5 3.8 u u u u 23.0-29.0 93.0 38.1 9.9 95.1 85.0 0.6 9.5 Aquatic peat with some marl 27.0-28.0 91.5 37.9 9.1 95.9 83.5 0.8 11.6 n n v m n 59 30.0-31.0 19.5 19.6 9.9 95.1 32.6 23.1 39.9 Hard aquatic peat. 63 1.0-1.8 95.7 92.9 3.3 96.7 99.5 1.0 1.2 aura... of deposit 3.5-9.5 95.9 3917 5.7 99.3 88.5 0.5 5.3 Marl and surface peat. 7.0-8.0 99.8 92.0 2.8 97.2 93.7 0.1 3.9 Marl and some peat. 11.0-12.0 95.8 90.5 5.3 99.7 90.5 0.2 9.0 N n u n 15.0-16.0 96.1 38.6 7.5 92.5 86.2 0.1 6.2 Aquatic peat with some marl. 19.0-20.0 95.9 37.9 8.5 91.5 83.5 0.2 7.8 n n u u u 23.0—29.0 39.2 38.0 1.2 98.8 89.6 1.0 13.2 Compact aquatic peat. fin 27.0-28.0 92.0 90.8 1.2 98.8 91.0 0.5 7.3 " u n 30.0 6.8 5.0 1.8 98.2 11.9 86.8 0.0 Bottom 67 3.5-9.5 96.2 38.8 7.9 92.6 86.5 0.3 5.8 Peaty Marl. 7.0-8.0 95.6 39.1 6.5 93.5 87.2 0.2 6.1 u 9 11.0-12.0 96.0 90.3 5.7 99.3 89.8 0.3 9.2 " " 15.0-16.0 96.9 39.2 7.7 92.3 87.5 0.2 9.6 Aquatic peat and some marl.) 18.5-20.0 95.3 36.3 9.0 91.0 81.0 0.5 9.5 .. u n u n J 27. The first set of samples was collected at station 60+00 (Figure 22). To obtain marl below the fill, holes were first put thru the sand by means of a hydraulic drill; then the samples were collected with the Davis peat sampler. Subsequent moisture tests indicated that water from the drilling equipment had affected the moisture content of the marl immediately below the fill. In order to check this indication another hole was bored on centerline by means of angers, and samples were collected. The moisture content of the sample imnediately below the fill proved to be 85.8 percent instead of 123 percent as showm by the sample collected when the hydraulic drill was used. The other two check samples on centerline coincided approximately with the original samples. The percentage of water in the first 10 feet of mrl, immediately below the fill, suffered a reduction of about 117 percent (from an average of 161% to about 85%.) The moisture content of the more compact marl near the bottom does not seem to have been affected by the highwayembankment. At station 7S+00 (Figure 23) an interesting contract is shown in the difference between the moisture percentages of the peat and marl. This peat was excavated before placing any fill material. In collecting marl samples below the fill for moisture tests at this station, the holes thru the fill were bored by hand in order to avoid the error made at station 60. The marl im- mediately below the fill at this location has had its moisture content reduced from about 914 percent to 76 percent. This is I 1 - I . . I 1 . 1 1 -149. . .1 . .1. . . . ' . t a .. . . 1.1 ..1111.v- .. .4 Q I l . 1 (101: 0‘1. 1 11. 1 - _ . fr n. . _ 7‘. 9 .1 - v 1 . 1 11 . . 9 . 6 _ 8 . v‘el . . - . _ . .. .. . .1 9 . , e . 9 . . . . e . 1 Q . 1 . .. . . 9 _ ...... . . V. .. . I . .1 . . . . 1 9. 1 . 1 .. . . . . h . . r 1.11 . .... ..e.1le 1. a . .. .. ... . . . .- _ _ 1 9 1 . . . 1». e . 1 . . . .~ . . 1 . . . . . .1 . 1 . .. . . , . 1 _ 111...... .. 1...-- 1 ....1.-. . 1 1, 1 . . 11.. .t. 1.91.1.- .. . . . r. .. . h . . .. . 1.... . . . - . .1 . .9 . 1 ..H 1 ... . . . . . .. . 1 . r. . . . . . ...--1 .1“ ,. . 1 . 1 H 9 1. ...- 1....--..-.1..-... .. - 1 . 1 1 -.11.-.. . . q r . .+ . 9 . . _ . 1 19 . 1 m a n . . . 1 . 1 . 9 . 9 9 .. . 9 . .... . . . 1 . . . 1 .. 1-e.. 1. 1 .- , . . . . . .1 . ,. . . 1 . . 1 . _ . H 1 1 . r . . . ..-o1.11191.-1--...-.1.1 .... 9. . H . . ., 1 9 . . 1 ...1 . . s . 1 , .1-1. -....--.- .1 - 1 9 . . 1 1 . . . . . 1 t . .1-.- .... e . -1- o -1.1 ‘1. 1 1 . . 1.. e . . . - . e . . . a. . . . e 9 . . 1 ~ I . . . . v.. 1. .. . ,. . . .. . . . .... . . . o 9 9 . . , . 1 . v u . . . . . . . . . v11... 1.- 1 W.» -- ..--1-. 11-3.-.. 1...- . L.. . 4 9 [a . _ - a 9 . . . v .. .O 1 1 n \ v . 0 _ . . 9 . a . v' 1 .1. ,. v.1. .1 - . ... v.11-1 1 .- . . 1 .. .T . . . . . o/ . 1 l 0 1 “I! . (I a r. 111...}. ..- 1.-.. .-. --.. ...-...... -.1 .. . . . . . H . . v... . . 1 o 9 . e . . 1 ... . . 9 1 9 1. 1— 1.11111 . .. . .. . . . 9 . . . ... 1.. . . 1. 9 w 1 s . 9 < . o r. . 9 . . . H . T-.. .1-. ..1.. .... .--....1....1-.-.---9--... . .+. r . , w .1 . . . . . s o 9 _711110 0 C e 1 ~ ...1 . 9 . 1 . 9 9.1.1-111 111._v -11.-1- .. - 1 11.111111111- -.. - 11 1111111111111.-1 -. . . 1 . . 9 9 . . . 4 v 1 1 . _ 1 . . . v. r- --- .- - ..1...1.1.. 1-. 1......11..v1-11.. . w 9 u 1 . . . 9 . . 9 . . 0 1 .1 , .11 11.- 1.11.. ...-111111111 ..... . 1.1...11-91 1.11.1.- .1111 1 . . . 9 . 9 v . . . . ..1-.---11.-. . 1.. .. .....-1..- . . 9 . n 1 .. . . . 9 1. . 1 v . . . o 9 L f - I - .1 .. 1 1 . ~ . 1 . 1 4 .-.-1. . _ 9 . V . o _ . .h . .-h 1 9 . o 9 .19... .;1-.-.--.-.- 1. . L H . 1 1. _ . .. . . . 4 fl . a1M “ T H U a . m .H a a“ : w . 21 15 M. _ 91.. 0-.. . . . 111.¢ Wh‘rah kit-1:111 -.--1 gem—awn: HH*- 9H-. «.99.9 1 1 1 .- 45? 11:3 . 1 - ...... 1 -1 .11.. .1.11 10 . 0 . . ..4 in 9. 1 9 .. .. .H 9 .. v . . 1.. . ... 1. . ...9 .H 4. 8 _ . . . , ._ . ... A . 1 a . . o o . 0.. t . ...Q.....> .... . nL-vb.f11lfin .....A h 9 .9 . _ . 9. .. 1 1 . 1 .9 . 4 . . .. 1 . . . ..... . . ......_. . . . . 9 .1 .19.... § 9 1 .. 1 . 9. .- 1... . .1 ..q . .. .- ... .e-.1 0 .v quotQOH . ..9 s 9. 91 . . 1 .. _ ..19. . 1. . 9 H . , ..._..... _ . 1 9 .1 I........ w . . . .v..s4 . eoao.e-. . . . 9 ... . ........ . . . . .... .1 . 1 9 .9 . ........ + 9 . e ..-t..1.a- 1.1.1 0 0-6-1 ‘19-.. _ . . . .H . .... 1 . _ .1. . ... _ . . 1 . 0 _ . . . . .H ..... ....H . .. .... 1 . 2.1 . . . . , . ........ . 1... .‘ . ... 9.... . . . . fi.... ... . ....9.... 4 . ~ . . 1 . 0.. ..o - e 1 0.01.... .- e..1...-.61 1. 1010+L a“ 1 . . ... ... ... .... .... ”. . . ....9 ... 1.. .. .... . . . . ...» ... ... .. . .. .... . . . . 1 . 19 ... ... ... .1 ....A . .- ... .- ....ee. . 01.14???’ .0‘. .v-e. 0 . 9 , . .19 . ..9 ... .. .9909 1 . 9 9 ...H ... ... . .1 .... .. . . . . . . ... ... . 9 9 . 9 H H... .e . .e- ..‘1 -.Q.1.v11§-.1-1 9-1-L9 9 p . 9 . . . .9 .1. .... . «H 1. . . . . .9 . . ... . . . _ . . ... .. ... 1 1 . .. ... 1 . .0. v - 9 . .e 1.9... e--..1..e-.v .9 Va -..-16... ., . .. . . 1...... .... . 1 . . . .. ... ... ‘ . 9 . .. 0 e. 90 v4 9 9 .- -- - .- - ...-1.1111... 1 1 . .D _ . . .1 .1 . ...9 ... .E.. . . 1 . . . . .11... . 9 1 . . . . . ..M ... ... ... 1 9 . O. . .. .. ... ... 4. ..7'1....- .41-9.9 191.....ev1- -E. . 1 9 . .1 1. ... ,. . - . 1 . . 9 1 . . 1 . 1 111.19.161‘ 4h .. . 1 . . ... ... . 1 9 . . . . .. .. 1 e a o .. o .. . o... .1. .+... e... . . . 9 .1” . 1 . .9 . 1 ... . 1 . . ,9 M. . . . . ... . a . a - .. . . .. ..r. 0111111111911.11'-&1. .. _ 1 ...-1.1.111 .1 . 1 . .1... .. _ .91 . 1 _ 4 .9 . . ...... .- . .... .. 1 . . .... .. .. 1. 4..--..1-w1.--.-.-.91....... a..8 .60.,- 9 . . .H . . ... 1 . .1 . . 4 .. .. .. . 1 . 9 . 9 01.11-111-11“?- -..- . 1 . H . . 9. I . . . .lu . .. . _ R . .. _. . 1 .. ..1.- I D . .1. 1 .¢ . * . fl H7 bias/Lt .1 .Y . 1 . U . ., 4.1.3 ...... i... .. 1.1.9 1 .4 a . L . a ,1 4 HH ...5 ..H..._.7JRH 1.1.W1: ..U . 5 H . 1.30 F5410. INN-r: ... ...-11. ...-11.1111". £54-”. I... away:- . 2.4.» 1.1.9.... .../4 1 w. .1 0.1. gr; 5 . _ r . 19 Y ..9. . -- 1111-9 . a: .1 g . . W TE p a. .4 . m . 4 . 4 G .1 a. fa. . . 1 . 11.9... .r .. .. . 1-1111111--. . 111-11111.-- ...-3.1.9.111 ., ..- ”EH “1115*: H . . H S w 4 Tim. 1111.11.11: 11.1. ----.-11».111.-.--1”1-111“ . 9, . N. .. . .1 . 1 . m 9: 1.4..mamh»; .-H --...t . H .. ..-.9---........SH...1.$..T 2.21.1115... m i 2. m 4.3 . ...J an; . . . . ... . o . . 1 . . .1 111.1- 1.- -1 11- . . - 1 1.1111111111111111 . 1 - -. .11.. L.111.r1.11. . ......11111- - 1 -.1.+.;|-.»1- . 1- 11-1 . .11... .1 . 1 1 .1111 4111.1- .111 ...-+111- 1111 111..- .11 1 1 .1 .. 2 . . . . 1 a 1 . . . .. . . 1 . 9 1 . 1 . . . 9. . 1 9 w 0 V 4 . . . 1 9 . . .3 .' 1 A 9..." 1 . . . 9 . 1 . 1 . 1. . . - 1... . - .... I.1-.1.-.. .. .. .-. 9.... .. ... .. . 1 .. 16,. .-..-H..1.9..9..-.v -. .... . . . . . . . . 1.7 _ . 1 . g B . . . . . 9 . . . . 9 r n u . . 9 . . a . 9 1 . 1 v. 1.. - - - .191 1111 1.11.11 111+1. .11411111- - 1 . 1 . - 1 11 . . 11. 1.11 1H11 .9, . 119. 1.. - 1-1.111. 14.71.11.11‘.. .1.- 11.11 ...11 . .9 .- .. . . . H 1 g H 1 1 . . . . . 1 . . . 9 . . . 1 . 1 . 1 . 9 . a H . . v . . . r-1..-. 1 . . - 1 .11..‘ - e. 1 .11+.- .- . I. c 1 . .. 1. . .. . v. . . .1 9..- . ... .. . .1-L.... . . . _ . . _ . _ . .1 . . .. . .. _ .. . 9 .1 . L 1 . . 1 . . 9 . . . . a . .1 1 . . 1 _ 1 . . . . . . 9-1111- 1 11.1Lr 1111.1 . 1 - 1 0.11.1.1. . ... - 1 1-11-1fi11 9. 1-11 1. - .-. 1.-1|1l 11.9--1111- : -14 1.1-”..11H111-1 11 1 . . . . . . [H . . . . . _ . . . 1 . . . . o . . 1 . . . . . . . H . 1 1 1 . H . .|W.1..1-H11 .1- 1. . o. ... .9. .-.1.T..H.. .0. .9.1. 01..1 . .9 . . ., . . q . . _ . . 1 9 . . . . , 9 .. .. . 1. L . . . . O . . . 1 1 .11.- 1111111111111 11.11. 1111-1111119 .11m1.1.1 - 1.1119111.- 1 1.4 4 1 . .1 . . . . 9a . 9 . 9 .1 . . 1 . . . . .4 .. .1 . . .. 9 . . . 9 . H ... . 9. 9 .-...O-1.-n11 1-&-.1.1.-11-.6..1.11|Oo. ...--. .... t1.1..-.-9 ... .. .9 . H . . . w ......I... 9 . .. 9 . . .. ....1. . . .. 9 . 1 1 9 .- .11....»- 1.. ..i . 9 . .r-..... ...-9.1.- p 4 fi-o...--11-.--.9.-. -1..--- .1.v..1v.. .119.-9-.-.-.-. .-.-..- . 1...‘ 14.4.-+-... .1...9se.oa 1.1...9-1.---14.v-.1.-.- .-.1,....-.......v ...-...m .-. -11....1. ..... . 1 ... . ..-e.o.... ....o-ov'a 911.1-11-111. -.-.-..--1 ...-«1.. .-.b-w0.. .1 ... ..1...1..-. ...... . ... r»..~e.... ..--1+1-1o-1 10-e-1e-co- 11-.~1... ...-«.1-V-1.11v.-1-... 11- -1 -..-.9..v.-..O...1191.- 91.90.10.00. ... .VtP-l 1 r 01> It .OIO‘LVI'IOIOI 1 -....-11- --.-H..1.-4-.,-.+.-1.19.-. 9. .. ...... - -..-.....4--..-..-- ... ..9.W...1 v...h--.1 ...-v+.-1111.-1..--1. . -.-.-- ....9. 1 .. 1. . ... .....4-.-.. ..1... 9 ..«L. 1.... .....+...1 1--v611.v.1-1.-111 v-..... 1.. o. . ... 1 . .1... 1.A. .10. 1 . .Afi ..+-.e.qo. v¢.-.....-o-. v11- VO e 0110-6 .- 1 1 1 e . . 6 . 970 1 . 1 O o 1 . - . . 1 a . . 1 . 1 . . . 1 . 1 . . 1 I 1 1 . . e - 1 . 1 1 - o . a . o . p e V vs 0 e o 9 '1. o . t 1 > 1 i 1 ....1.--...............-....... . -1... 91.119... ...-1..-: -...1..-19--....... -...91 . ... . . 1 . . . . . ....9-.. ..-....-J 111.1-1-011-1-1-.¢.- ...-.... c . .1 .. .... .9... .9 -.b.o.e-.-. 1...»...019 1.1.010Hv-1-119-111o.001 1.119.... . .... . .11 1.1.. - ..- 017T49¢ew1v01 .1.1>.e1.19 1 1 v.1 > r 14.111111101016101 111-1. -...- ....9-1-1 ....... . - .... 11 1 1.6... .4. 9.91.... .91. ......1-114 710.1 01-1 ...-0.1.. ..9... .1... .-- ..4. 9‘1 .11.. use. .... .o- 9..-. -1- --.. ..-..-. .- ..--. ...... .1 . .-.... .1.-- .11.... -... ....-.v-o1 V1119v01..1-1-r111 1.1.9... .. .o A 1.. ...-e.- . v.- 01Lo.vee e901 ee.-eI.1.’A . t 1 .1 r 111 1.0 w 1 11- - - . . . Q a - - v e . 1 . 1 . A 1 . . . . a . . o T v 1 o n 1 . . a. . . 1 .19 10101019 111114-41-11. .91.-. -1...- .. ..111 1. . . 1.7... . . . v... ..v. ...-901011. 1-009-111 .1.._>--o9..1.... ...1 . . ... ...9 - .o 9 a . .... .... ....09911'1 .11--1v1-111..--.-111.1 -..... . . . ..L.-1. . . ..... .....-. .- ..vV4o..w.H..-.1r...1-e-v¢t-Ol9 97 9111-9111111 0... 11 111-1.-11-1--1-+--1 1......1. --.-....r- .1. .. .. .. .-.1. .. 9..11.-.. ...-91.91-111 1-111L1-11.-..9-..- . . . ... -.1.. -.. 1- . ..... . . 9. .. .. ... ...: .... 1.1.4.... ..6101 T1119 10.11....9.1.- . ...1110.1 116.1... .- . .. . .. . . .1... 1 .1 . ... H. . ... . ...- ... ..211... -... ...-11". w1.-ID- v.-.111.1.H....9. .o ... .. ...-v. . .. o .. - . e. u. .. .. .. . o. ...91.. ..ev ...-.1 ....<9. .... ....v 15.1.01; 111 b 1 r L 1 . 4 4 1 1 1. 111 6.1 1 1 o 1 - . . - 1 9 . 1 1 n . 1 . . . . 1 . . o . . . . . 1 . . 1 - . . 1 c . . . 1 . 9 . . - . 1 1 1 - . . . . 1 . . . . . 1 9 . . a a t . . . I . e o . . u . . . v v -%1-.9.01t.9 1111-1111.. ....H.. 1 ......u 4.- .. 1 . .11.”. .9.. ..1. .. . ...... - v..- .. ..v-. ......1. ... ..9. v... .... ...- 4.019911 V11-vl1.91. ....4...Vv...-...-. 1...v . . -. .. . . a b . s. .. +. . e. ...+.'-. .... .0 . .... .... ...-0-15011 T1111n11-.. ......1.-1.--1o.... ...... 1 . ... .. .-.-.1. 1 .. .. .1 .. ....19.... .9... ....... . .... .... ...9.-.-9 4 a». r . - t 1H 1 b 1 _ 1011-0110. .11-.e1-« 115. .... .-. > 1 1 11. e. .. . -.o..1 .......-. .. . 1 ...-.. u. ..1- ..1.>.¢1Yti 1--...11111.11111+11.11 -1-1 --.-.-1.-1-1-11 1.1.11-11149.1-.--. .-.-.-. ... -. M...-....-1....9 ...-19.11 .1-1.1111.1 -....1.- ...-.11114.--11.-114.-.-1..-...4-.1..-.-. .- 1.1 1- .1. 1. . 9....1.1-1 ..... 1111 .1161 . .1... .. 1 40.1.1. ..1.. . - 9 91-v.4-Q.. ....F VO-IA P - . . 1 -.....1.. ...... .v - . ~..1..1... ..-.4 .7..th . . . 11. 1...... .. ..1 1.. 1 -.. ...-. 1.... .111 T1.- . . .-.-1...-.. .......1. .. . ..1-..-.. 1.... 11.9 . - . . . . . . 1.... . . .. . . . - . .P 1 - . - . . . . . .9 .9 .16.... 1 1 L 11- ... 1111 ... ..... o 1.... . . 1.. 9 . .1 1» t 1 .. . .14.... . .. .. 1 . ... 1....-. ...+ .1601 .11. .. ..4.... . . .1. ...H ..--.. .. .. .-.- 1-.1 ..- 19 ... o ..1.. ..o.1.19 . . .1. .... ....» 7.01 r . a 114 H F “ ‘1 5 111. .v ... 1 9. .....- ...... . .... 1 , . 1.....1.1 .. ... .. ...-1.21.11...- vt..1-... -..-111 11111 .M. . . ...... ... . .. . . . ... . . . .... .... .... ...v. .... .... ....OL v111-1- . .. 1. . .- . .. .... 1 ..-...1 .. . . .. .H.... .-.. 1.x... Po..H.--11....111-..I 1-1.- > 1 9 4 7111109 . . - -1 e . 1. ....e.... ....9-011 010v .Xtove-eow1..eb e¢>11 19vtlA 1.11.914 . 1 . . .. . ..-1e-.-9..1. ~¢.JL1.6110.9.-. 01!. ea... . 110.119 1 v. . . . . . s .1 . . 1....900009.2‘o ..e... 11.1 9 . . . .. ..... .1. ...1. 191.1...1-1 ....19- L 1 L r 1. 1- 4 v1.11 . - 1 . . w . 1 . . . . o. 4’. ... .... ..v1 .1... . . . . . 111.1191 . .. ..... .- . 1 ......I-v- Y‘OeLr-loVHO... . 111- .9... .. .-.- . .. .. . ....L-.-. J-.-11.1‘..o... . 11lo- .1H.... ....1 .. ... . 1. . ..o.... .1 6.1.01 .15.... 11 1 1 1. .1111.- . .H . - . . . . . . 1 . . . . . «a o v . o. 1 07.019 . . . . >1 .111- ... . . . . 1 . 1...+...-1 .‘ 1.9-1.9.1.... .1111 .o. . ... . . A . ......01-0 .. be... ...... 1111*”..- .H. . . . . . . .. ....»1... . ... ...... a 1 1011.9.- ..1. .11..~. . .1 . . .... 1. .... ..- ....e1-01o ..-aLv-)vv. -e.-_r.1 T111$e ...-... . a . .0. . . 1... 1e 1 ...? ...1-...1.-. ~11-Ov1vt-41.1.1 alv-IO -v.oe-Q1- flv011f1-V119 - .H1.1.. 19 . 1.9 . ... . .. .. ..H... .1-.. ..--v...-. .......1..r....9-.. -..-14.11... 111111-1111'HIV--. 111-0111196111-1- 1.1»1 1 '1 11911-11. .... .. 9. . . . .. . .... ..... ... ....1 1. ...-11.61....111Dfi6. . ..-1-1 1. 1 .1 .9 . h . 9 ....4 .. .9...1 .. ...-n. .. .a... . 140.019 11 . .1 . § ..H . . . . . .. . .1-.. ......1191.1.o-11. ...vH-.v ..- 1ro11..9 v1|.v.1 .e a +. .. .. 9. .... .. . ... . ...-.11 ... c .11. 1. 1 .....l. .-+1-s-9 1 k 1r > 9 1 h _ 4 4 . . - . .. .. . . . L . 1 . . . 9. .....4.......... ... .. ... 9.... .. ...-... 1. a . e .. . . . . . 9 .. .1 .9... ..... -.. b . . ......-......,.1. H..- .....9 111-11111 9 . . w. . . . 9 . . o . 9. . . 1 . . . - . . - - 1 1 . . . . v . - . . . . . . . - 1 . . . . . - .9 71-- -9 . . . 1 . 4... .. . .9.. . .1 -..-..-- .. ... 1.1-.W1...-....-. 1 11W. 1 4 . I . . 1 . O 1 l v. - 011‘ 1 . e I 11 v 1 1 I 1 .1 1+1- - 1 O 1 1 . . e I 1 - 1 l 1 1 - G 1 - a O . 11-9-111111.. I. 0.111! 1-1 A 1 111 7119 111. 1.9 1'1. 1 9.10.91. H . .. - . .9 . . . . e a e . ... . 1.1- 1 ..... ...v... . -...v.. 9. . . . . 1 . . 1. . . ... . . . . .... -. ..... .... ..1» . . . 9 H.. 9. . . . .. .9 .~ 13.1...11 . 1 L. r 1 1 . 1 M. . n . . ... o . H . . . .o 1 . ... . . .. .. ... ... 9. 1 . . . . . . .. H . . . . . .. . ... . 1.... 1 9. 9.. . . . 9 .- . a . 9 . ... 1 . ..... .. 1.... 1 H. 9.. . . . . . . . . o 1 . . l. .. 1 . 9.. 1. 1. -.111- -r- 1. <.... ..11--..... .. 1. v . . n . .111. .-o11 D 11...... 1.9.1.--. 9 . 1 .11- 9 . 9 . 9 .. 9 . . . . . .. . . .9. .. F . .. . . .- . I . . . .9. . .. .. 1.79 . .- ... w o. . 1 . . . . 8 . . ..-.. .. ...1. . . . . r +. 9 . . . . . .1 . . .. . .a. .- . . . 1.. 11.1 .1111? 111.11 111 I1 - l - 1 11......- 1- 11-. .1 1- 1141- .1111 . . 1 .11 .11.. H1 .... 9. . 11 ..9 . . 1 9 . . . . . . . . . 9 . -1r . . . ... . 1 . .. H. .... 1 o H . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . ... r . 9 .1. . . a . 9 9 . . . . . ,9 . . . . 1 v - .. ... . . 1 .... . ... . a 9 t . . . . . . .. . . 9 . v . 9.1---...1111-4-1...1111.111-.-..-19.1-11....1-.,-n.1-..1..1-.1. .1 .1 9 1- . . , ..-.. ...-1......-......... .-....l....-.. -. . .... -.1 . . . . .. . .... .. .- . . h _ . H . 9. . H . . 1 . . 1 . .... . .....9 1. . 9 . . . .. H . ., a . . .. 9 .... 119 .-.... . .. . .1 u . . . 1 . . . _ .. . . . .. 1 . 1 . 9 ...-1 ...-.. .1. . . - 9 . w. . . 1 . . . . . ,9 1 . . 9 . . . 11 9 . 1. 1.1 fie .1 111 -1111 1- 11111-1 . 11- 1. 1 111.1111 +-1-1... ..1.-L1.111111 71 . .1 . ...-1.. .19.... - - . . .. .. . 1 . . . . . . . . . w 1. 1 1 . H ... 1 . ...- . . . .1- 1 . . . H. .. . . 1 _ 9 . . . _. +1. . 1 _. .. . .... .....1.-. . 1. . . . . . . 1 . 9. . . ... . . - . . . . -.. .1. 1....1 .. .. - H. 1. . . . . . . . . 9 . . . H . r . .... . . o . . . 1 111.1 1. 1..- ..1. 11 1. .11.-.. . 1 . .H . . . - 1 . r 1 1.11.1 . 1 . . . o . . . . . . . . . . 9 1 . . . . . 1 v4 . . . u . . . . 1 1 . . .. ...-.9 . ...»... . . .. . 4 . . p . 9 . . . . .w . H1 ...... . . 1. .. .9 9 L. . 1 . . . . 1 H . 9 . . . . ... . o 9. . . .1.H. ... 1 . . 1 9 . 1 . 1 .. .. 9 . . . . . .... . ...... 11. . ..9 w .. .. . . 9 9 . .. . 9 . . . 9 . ... .. ”111 1 1 . 1 A 11.. 11.11.. 1% 1.1 L 1 v 1.. 1 1.1 I 1 1 O 1 v 11 11.1 ...-11. . 1 11110 J1 1.111 011.141-110. - .-11v._9.. .1110. . l.- 1 1111-... . . ...1 . o1. . H. . 1. . v . . . .9 . .. . . . . ... . H . .. ... . . . . . 9 - . _. . . . . . . . 9 1 . ... . . 1 . . . .1 ..-... 1 1.. .. H. . .1 . . . . . . .. . . 1 9 - 1. . .- . -.. 1. . .. . 1 . . H .. . H . . . .- 1 « .... .. 9 1 1 011111. e. - . - 1.11.9 Y11-1111- 1 1 1114.1 - . . . 1 4 .1. ... x .. A. 1 1 1 1. . . J . . . . 1 . o . . . . - 1 9 . . . . 1 . . 1.1 . - o . 1 . . . . o - . . 1 1L 1 . . . . . . . . 1.. . . . . 1 . . . . .JHY. .. . . 1.. .. . . . . H 1'. . 9 1 H . .. . . _ . . 1.1-1- ».. .. 1... 9. . . H H . .. . a ... . 1 . . 1.. . . . 1 ..... .... . . . 1- . .. H 9 w . . H 9 . . . . . . . 11111 1 b. b 1 L. .0 > 14111 0111 1 -.. 9 . ... .9 1 . . . .. 1. . 9 . 9 a . 9.. 9 . . . . 9 ..v . H 9 . v .. . . ... .~. . . 1 .. . .1 . 9 . 1 1 1 . . . 1 . . . . . . .. . .. ._ . . . .. . . . . . . . .9 . 9 . . . .... 9 . . . . .. . . . 9 _ . . . ... . .. . . 1 . -1-1.-1.1.--4,..16..e11.o-..- -.. .11111.1fw.-....-1.1911113... --L11.11..Ixr..411-1..11..91- .. ....1111v111-w...1.-.-.9. ..1 .-.1........ .....- . 11.1.... 1 .. . ... 1 . .... . . . . . . 1 . . 1 . . . . 1 . . .1 . . , . . .... .. .... . .. . . . 9 , . . ,9 9 . . . _ w . . , 1 . 1 H . 9 . . . . . 9 . . 9 . 1 .c 9 . . .. . H 1 w + . 9 . .9 . . . H . 1 I 1.1.. _ > 1 1. 11> >11 -11 4 1 AY‘I’ . 1.11.111. w . . .9 . . . . .. .. . ... .9 .. . 9 . . 9. . . H 1H .. . _. 9 . . .1 . .. . .. 0 . . 9 9 1 . . 1 . . .. .. . 0 1-1. . 1 H . 1 . . 1,0 . 0 . . . .. . H . .. . . . 1 .. _ ... . . . . . . 1. . 1 1 . .. _ H . . ..1 1 111 .1 . 1 - .1! 91111.14 11- 010.10.01q. . 1- 1 n - . 1.01919111‘ . 1 I 111... 11101.1 1 - V1 .1‘ ..o. .- O 1 a . P. w - '11- v 1.9 - 1 . +1 . 1 . . . v . fa ... .t .A 9 11 . . .. . 1 . . o 101- . . . 9 . .. . . .H 1 . . 9 1 . . . H . . H . . 1 1 . . .1 . ....q . . . . . . .2 . . . 1 1.6 9 ... 1 . . . . . ...w. . . D. . . . 1 _ . a . . . . H . .. 1. . .. .... H .. . . . . . . . r11111?.1-11$.1. 11.1 9. 1.9 1-1.4 1h . I14 +1111 .111 .1 1 a 1. . . . n o . . . . 1 ... I . 1 .. 9 . H .. 9 . .. 1 .. ... .. 1...e... H . 9 . . H o . . . .... 9 .. 1 . . 9 . . . . . . .. ...1- . . .. 9 ., .. . - . .. .. . . . . 9 . . .... . ... . .......-9 1. . 1H . .11 . - . . . . . . ... 17+ 1 1 - . . 1. :- - . . -.- 1 1.. . V1.1 1 .H ..1 1.1. . . 1 11 1...... . o . - - 110.. 1 . 11. 11 - 91 -1. .. 1 . . . .1.-. -1 . .191. 9 vi . .31.. .1. 1 .1 111e11‘101 ~ . .. .. ...9 . . . . ...- . .9 H 9 .- ..... 1 . 1... 1 .... ... .....Huo1. . . . . . . . 1. . . ... 1 . . . . 9 . ... . .- . ..... .. .... .. ..9 1 . .. 1 . . . .. . . . . . .. H . .1 . ... ._ . ..... . .... . .... .. .1...9.. 9 . .. .0 . . . . . 9 .. . H . . .... H1 . . . . . ...... ..w. . ... ...-.1 131111.... ..61-111...1.-11 .- n .1¢.-1-b1-1..-..9111111- 1H1111-1-111-161-16191- 0.1-111.111.111-111 4 A. . . 1 H. . a 1 9 .. ,1 9 . ... .. 9 . . .... . 1 _ 1 . 1 H . . 9 . 9. .. . 9 .. a .. ..9. 1.... _ . . .. . 1.... . . . . .. . 9. . . _ . 9 . ...H .... . 1 . .-.H... . 9 . 1 . . H 1. . . . . .1 . . a. 9 1. ... . . ... 9 . .. ...... ... .. . ..1- . ...-...» ........4. . 1...9 ...9, .. ...... ..14111....+.111.. 9 _ . , H . . .1 1 . . . . H H H 1 9 9 _ 1 1 9 . . . H .1 . .. _ 1 . . . n .. H 9 . _ . . . . . . . 1 . . _ 1 . . 1 .H. 111.91.1- ... ...-1- ......6..-. 9.. 101-1. .111911-1-1...1.1111110.Ols1-.v » < 1. 14 . . . H . 1 . . 9 1 . . . . . . . . H 9 . .. . 1 1. . . . 1 . 1 1 . 1 . . . ... EH .. .... H .... . 9 .......... . . . . . . . . 9 . . . ...! . . . . . . . ,- II. 1 9 . . . . ...! .11111--.-. .. ...-1.«.1...-...111..1.|-.1v -.v ..Ir. . H . . 1 r . . . 1 . 1 1 1. . . . . . . . . ..- ... 1a . . ... 9 ..... 1 9 9 .- 9 9 . _ . 9 o 9 . . . 9 1‘. 9 .. . ... .1 11.- . . ..4. -. . . ... .. 1... - ....“1 15, .22. .1-9919.11 C O O D C , 7 a _ an o 7. «a 9x. 7, H a H . w“ 11111 a OH. . 1 111.1“ 1 11H 9 _ .. . H . n In I. 7. . 4 9 9A 5 o. 2. . 4 9 . .- 5 , _ ..- . a . . _ . 4. 4 4-. H H _ .. H 9. . . 4 H m a 0- _ 4 . . .... _ _ , 1 . ..... . .... H . 1 014 . 4 9 H _ m - - .4 1 H . N H H H 7. . 4 H H ......2 1 . m _ . . _ 4 . 4. .2. . H . 1, 1 . 1 . , . H . H.U. . . 4 . _ . _ . v . .a . .... ....... -- H . . . r . «.9. ....... 4 .:...H. -.-..cLHE-M ..--M ,. H _ , . H H . _ S 3.4 4 ... .4. ..H 4 a . , .4 4 a. 4 . 4 D: 4 ...-.1. 7 . D1,.H . . -H. -...-.H ......H-.. -H11. . . - _-.- -191-” 9. H H _ _ 4 .. H .1 4 H . 9 9 9 H 9 -.H. 9 9 . . - H 4 . _ H . . ._ H _. .. H ... 4. 7 , _N - 1,. 5 4 - L. .---1.1;; 4 . ‘ . 4 _ h _ _ . . 4 4 4 1 . 4 4 4. 4 H ..... 4 . 4 , :4 9 Q’ . I H 9 H H . H H 0 4 . 4 4 4 . 4 .4 4 .4 H . H 1 H 4, H :4 . ,4, 4 .....z. . H U . _ . . 1 4, ,1 .1. 30.. ...-H. .---1. .-.: ---..ng -- 1 .- ..-; - 1r--- _ . 4 4 a. H 4 U 4 H H H . . . .444 ._ ...H .0. h H h 4 . 4 H. . ._ 9 . H 5H 179. .H a . ..H. ........ H .. .1 H..._.. H. . IQ . , , H H ....4H 8.. 46 H H H H. . H .- . H . _ _ H . . . . . , . ”V...- nfi-l-ha-mllawguil .....49- 99. . 1. . H- ... 1. ,.|-..1..s-.m11.-.1.. .11? H...-99HH.1.}..l.i.-.1..u.-.1¢M14... 14.1.1 . 1i- 01.9w .9. .- .1-11L.ll.1 1 4 H 1 . . AH . H ...- ..111..1..v.-.1J . e 4 4 ., H- . . 11:99-11 --. . ,. ,. . . 4 ... .1, . .9. . .. H.- HTMH. “3.....-“ H 1.. H 14.44 4 4 ...4 4H 4.3H7F _w .. 0. . 4 . _ e , : H ._ H _ , . .--:ME-H1.f¢ ..... 1 -.. . .1 H... - 9.1%-“- fi-..1 11.011-111-1- .11 3 I .. 9 4 . .4 H W , H . 91. . w 4 ..... ..., 41m..0. ...tH: 4 r/9 a _ 4 4 a. .99 .19.. 9.1 . . 9. ,4 1 H. ... .1: N: _. ..T-.-.1‘1.1.h1-.H_. ......... 1 a 1 . 4 e g a. p s 6 L .4. ......MHc .1. I r. - 4 4 _, H 1. _ .9 . 9.9/ . _ . : 4 4 .9 E L .. .,. - - . ,d ..... . -- -. . . .. - ...... 9H _ _ 3 3 . 4 R a w W1 H 1 . 4 E . 1.... _ 4 . 1 . 1 _-as:y., , 1 9.9999999. 9999.9 1 1 1 7 1 I I .' H99HHHHHHH- _ r 1 .' . 1. . 1 ~ 1 1 . : : ' 9‘ - - 1 ' 1 ' I --7.’.HL1 . - 1 1 1 5. . r ”hm T1- 11141 1.11111, ,- . . . . . . 1 Ar... . . .9. ;. .1. : L-T£{_£ -_HH 1 1 1 1.1- 1 9 -9 O 1 g.0 99-..- u— ..9. 1 Y - —--.~9 ... _. 04 -,.-.1.,1---..-.1./.T «1&4. ' 1 TEN?” 952:.pr19 can-11$,“ . 1 . 41921-991119; : ..... - 1 99122: 1 1 .- .i.. .1 . 1‘- v 1 ,- 5 ..-—9.4.99- 1 f - l BMPLiS~ .s ire-fi- 359 95 _u 1?; ......... 1 1. £11.1- 11. . r. _, , . . E H . J H .. _ I .. .6 9 . p #1... . ,. .. .. .. . .- .. E . , H 9 Q _ . . I I . . 9 4 4 , _ _ . 5 . . 8 . 99:95.5 5.91 . 1 . . H . . . H . 9 9 _ . _ . e . 1 o . 1. 1 . . - . . .. - 1 1 ..- . - . 19110-1111.. r11-1111 1111 1 11.1.1 -. 1 1 . 9.11.11... 11- 1 1 9 1 . 1 1-.- . . - - 9 . .., . 9 -1 111..- ..111-1 . . 1 . . . . . _ . H H _ . _ _ H , _ _ , .. H M _ H 4 _ _ .4. _ . H , _ . T 1 _ H . ... ., t .. -9. . f . ........ - -.--_ ........ . ---”. . _ . . H . _ ._ . H . H o9 H . . . . 9 H . 9 9 9. . 9, . 9 1 . H . 9 H H _ 9 1 . 9 . . . . ... . ‘ H .9 9 . Y1... 1 9.- 1...-..9-.. 11 -1-T111..111.%.1.1111 11. -1 ..11-111111410 111.1 - 1‘11-11AYIOIOIJIQ1 1fi1111111 9..-I ‘11 1.1 . .1 .. .. 9 9 9 .- 4 . . . 9 . . . 9 . 9 . 9 . . 9. H H .. 1. ... 9 1 . 9 . . . . . . . . H . . _ . . . . ... ....... ..v- 1911 9 v.- . H 1. . . 9 w . 1 . . a 9 V 9 11- 4- 1-.-.-. 911:9---.9)..-...--....474-114191-:1 .. , .. . . ...-.1...»-4-..-1.1.1.1191.-...911-....-;.11...- . , 1 . .. 9 . . . .. H H H .. H .. H H H , 9 . . . 9. . ...... 9... . H . ...... . H1 . .. 1. H - 9 9 u 9 _ 9 . . 9. 9 .. . . , 9 . ,. . . . g ,_ H _ _ . .._ . v-- H . ,..9 .4 . H1 9 9 1 1 0191.11.11.0111-1 9111.. 1 1 .Hvl -19 1T1w...w-111. ..1-1- . .. . H . .. . . . . 9 . . H. . 1 9 9. 9 4 H .9 .- 1.-..-- L -3...:.....-. 21.“-- -- 9.1 1H 9 ...-...... V. 1.. 9 9 . ..... 9 . . ,I H. , . . _ . , . 9 . . - _ 9 . _ . . . I1 9 11. L111 1 111 1 ............ ..--..---. - £9.41... ,. .. . 1 . 9 . X ,. 9 w . .9. .. .....H H 9 1 . H ..... ,9 H ... H . . H 9 . . . 1 ... ..... . ....... 1 -J..1-.-.1.-.1-1-1 -1-1.0f-.-191...1~.1.0 . ,. . ... . . 1 5 _ 1 . . .... . .9. .- _ . 9 1 . ..9.. 9 .9 - m . . 9 . 9 . ..9. ,9 .9 ......... .1 .1 1 w} . 1 1 .-.;_ 1 1 1L .1-L11 1 1 1911.11 10.- H 1 1r .9 . _. . . .. .... 1 . . .. .-- . 9 9. 9 .9 9 . ..9 .9 ¢ . .9. 9 A 9 . 9.H. ...... 9.. . ... F H. . H . _ .. ...... . . . . . 9 . . . 1 1 o 9 91016 1 O . V.- 9 . 0.1-91911111 -11 b. 1 a v 0 I. A b o 1 11.01.: 1 Y..- Io-11 . . . . w. . .. . ..H. .H. . ... M 4 , I . _ _ .H . .. . ..9 . ... . .. . 9 . .9 1 .9. - . ... 9 .. . . . .11 fl H . DH .9 M. . ...., . .H . . ... v11- 1 1 1- a 111111111 H 11.1I .. 91¢. l 1 r v .1 1 . .9 . H ....... 9 9 . . . .H . -_ H . 9. . .. .U.. . ._ _ ,9 H 4 .. H: . .. ..... . . . 9 9 .. _ .. .... . .. ..H .9. .9... 41.- 16. .1.--.H1- 1.1-1-.. 9 4 111.119 1.1-. H . 4 . . ... . . . H , _ . . . 9 . . . . . H . ,. . . 1, . . . H _ 9. . - L. . . .9 . . v1.11 . 1- .... 9 1. .1 11.. 1.... 11 1- 11 1| 1 . _ , H 9 v” 1 .011 . 1H . _ _. a L . . 9 9 . 9 a ., . H _ . 4. . _u . ., . . 1 . H . . H 9. . . ..... . -. _ 4. H . : .. .......... .-. 1 .9: - . g . H 9 9 9 9 . .. . u 9 . . 4 1 . N H . H _i H . U : . u 1 _ 4 , 4 4 4 . _ H .113 9 , ... Ti 1 .. .1 . .. fl ..1... .1 1...; - 9 - .9 - - 1- 1H....- 1 1- .- 1 111... 1 .1 , - 111-1 +1 1. 9 _ . . . . .... , . . . A: .H _ 9 . 9. 11M 9 . ., . H . . . . . . 5 H _. H H H . H 1M . . . 1 . 1 _ . , . . . . 9 9 1.1.. 117.111- ..11- V 1.. 1 . - -. . .......... a. 9 . . . . 1 . I. 1. _ . v , _ , 9 .. 9.. .. ,. . 9 . 1 . . 9 ,_ . . . . 9.. . . -.1 . 7. 9 9 .9 U ,, 4 4 ._ , . H . . . _ ... . . ,. S ....... .. . 1 .. .. 1 . 4 , 4 . 4 _H o. 9.. . . 1 .91 , . . . . . H .9 . v11 . - 1 V1 11 .. .... . . ¢ 1 . 11 1 . 1.1 1 1 9 1 .11 ¢ .-QI§.-1 . 4111 1 o 9 . 01 fl 1.. f V 1 r 1% o.#11 - 19111 L 1 . I... .4111.- c 1 1H . 1 H 9 H 9 . . .. . 1 ..H9 . . .H .. . . ._9. H ... 1 9 . H. 4 H . .ZH ._ o . . .,._ . . .19. . , . . ... .4 . . .9 19 .. . _ _ . .1 . . 1. . 9.. . . 1. .9. . . . . 9 . ,9 .- 9. . 9 H . .. H ._ 41 1 .39 9 8 H . V ...H . . .. . . , .. .9 - . .. 1., ......- 9 ..., .. . . 9 v1 . ..... . ...1. .. 1. 1- .1 .1 -.......1 1 , H . . a... ,0 .4. ;:_ , ..... ...... . _ H . ,9 . 1.119, 9 , .9. 9. ..,..._.9 .... 9 9 H . . .- . . I 9 _H _H .. . . . .... .. 9.... .- .... 9 ....9. ... ....H.... ...L. . 9 . .9 9..-9.... .. . . .. . . . . .. .... . . . . . ...... .... 1. .1... ...-9. .. .... ... . n L c 1. 9. 1... .... 4 . 1. . 111 ... r 9 .1r11111-.1.1.-..-.....1- .11. 1111.11..-- 1.. ....... .10 it . 11 .111 . . _ . . 9 H . . _ 9 , ...9 9 , H . _. . . ... . . . . . .. .. G ... .9 . ... 9 1 .- 9. 9 9 . . 1 .. 1 . a. . . ....- H . o 9 .- 9 - 9 . .... 9 9 H 9 9 t 1 I 1 1 1 1 - - 1 1 t . 1‘ . , . 1 - I ‘9 9‘ .914- 1 1 1:51-95. 1 1 1| . 1 1 who 1 T Y 1 1 1 99 l ..... .99999 4 £413... 1 1 1 1 1 . 1 _ . . , . . . . 1 . 1 . 9 . . .. . . . ... 1 . -. .1 . , . . . , _ . . . . . ., 1 . _ ,... . . . . . . H . .9. . .1 . 1. . . 1....1 1.. . .9. - .1 . . 1 1 -. . . .. o . 1 . 1 . .. - v11 11 ..1.11v‘lo11 1.11Hr11101 1. .1101. 1 - 11.. 1 119-1191111-1. . 1. 9 . . . , . . 9 9 9 1111-11.- 911- 1 - 1|. 1| . .1111. 1 1 l A O ' 1 - 99.9—-99 1 1 0 1 999999.944. , , 1 1 ' 1 91;; 1 311‘! 1 4.-- ----.-- 1 1 1 1 I 1 l 1 4 1 1 715.- 1 COM H n H .4 -9.- . ....9 h 1. ._- -. ... . ... .. - . - . ..1 ......... - .-.. 1 . - .9 . .1 . 4 . 1 _ 1 4 .199 . . 4 . . H , . . U E .H. T .... 9 .H . .. H. - ... -1111. 1.1.1.11..- -. ...-.14... . .-w .1...- 1.11.. 1 9. .4 M .p. .4: ... 1.5....4 . . , H . . . 9 . . . . . . . 9 . . . . . . H .111. 1.11111411111 111+1. 111111- 111F1-11111-111111111+ .1. 1 1... 11111 .11.. v . 9 . . . . . 1 *VmO—Fv‘ “~4ka— f - 1 . . - - H 9 . . . .. _ . - . .1 1 . . .H.- . . . - .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . H . . . : . - . . 9 . . 9 - .. . 1 , , H , 4 . .. ..w , T91. 1 .. . . . . . .. . . . 1 . .1 . - H1 .11 1.1.1 1. . 1+1 1 ...? 11111 .91 v 1 9.- . . 1 .1 1. ...-1191111 9 o 9 9 _9 . O . 9 . . . o 9 H. . . 9 . 1 . 1 . - . . . . H. _ H -. . , _ . . . 9 . 1 . . , . . 1. .. , . .. .. . ,.. . . ... H; 1....-.. ...-.11 1. ...Vv.-.. .. . . . 1 _. , H . 9.. H . ... 9 . # H 9.. 1 .9 . . 9 . 1 9 --.1.-.-. ..... K1. .1. ..-. 1. 19 1-1 1- 1. ....9 ......... 1 1.1-11-11 - . . . . _ _ _ . H . :H . 9. 9 . . 9 o .. 9 .. H v .. H . .19.. 9 H 1... .”.¢ 19 a , _ . 9 .1 -- ,9 .-.. . . .9 -1... 1 1 ..... o - 1 11- ..--3.1.19 1 Y1 11.91 1 1 - 1 1 ‘1.- 1 1. 1 1|- ,. 01.? 1. 19‘. 1-1191 > o . 1 H . . :H: . . , fl .... - H 9 .d.... . ...... . . H .. 9 ...... ..H 9. _ 9 “1..w.1 . . . .. . . . _ . 9 9 a . . W - 1 - 0Y1v- ......... H.. -»19.- ......... v.1.rvOOowH1111-fat-.bl H H h . . .. . 9 . . . . 9 ..- . H 9 . . .9. ._ 1 . 9 7 . . 9 9 9- 1 0 H 4 .4. ‘ '» ul- t .bfiifllu‘pl‘.. .Q ‘ """"" 28. a loss of only 19 percent. (In arriving at these figures the abnormal reading of 197.0 at the left of the fill was dis- regarded.) Here again the weight of the fill does not seem to have affected the moisture content of the marl near the bottom of the deposit. 1. 2. S. 6. 7. CONCLUSIONS Good.marl will support a highway embankment with approx- imately 25 percent compaction of the marl. In other words, the fill will penetrate the marl to about 25 percent of the thickness of the marl. See the preceding table. The disturbing effects of excavating machines in removing peat lying on top of the marl causes a loss as high as 50 percent of the marl in shallow deposits. Highway fills will penetrate a marly peat as high as 90 percent of the thickness of the deposit on centerline. The marl influence will show its effects, however, in sup- porting the fill at the sides, thus saving a considerable amount of fill material. See figure 15. Deposits of soft lacustrian clay below'marl may have a very detrimental influence on the bearing value of the overlying marl, because they permit the latter to flow when subjected to heavy loading. The moisture content of the marl does not have an influence on the supporting powers of the marl, but it does affect the volume change that occurs in marl subjected to loads. Explosives may be justified to speed up compaction of marl on a rush project. There is a tendency, however, to blow "shell holes" which do not immediately fill. Time allowed for settling is an important factor except in comparatively shallow deposits (up to about 10 feet). A project such as shown by figure 21 should rest from.l to 2 years under surcharge grade before surfacing is placed. 3o. 8. The supporting value of marl is due to a possible combination of four factors: a. Internal friction due to the more or less granular structure of the marl. b. The volume weight of marl is considerably greater than that of peat. 0. Water moves thru the marl quite freely which permits the marl to compact as the load is being applied. d. There is enough cohesion in a marl body to exert a considerable influence on its bearing value. 9. Fill penetration in marl or marly peat. Percentages based on original depth of marl Material Percent penetration iii-2. Average Max . Good marl (shallow) 8 37 80* (deep) 10 25 L2 Marl with some peat 2O 30 L6 Peat with some marl 56 77 91 The figures given in this table summarize the information on penetration shown by the profiles and cross sections contained in this report. In excavating peat from the surface of the marl some of the latter may be removed with the peat. This accounts for part of the loss of the marl. Excavating equipment also has a tendency to disturb the marl and cause it to flow ahead of the backfill as the latter is being placed. * This figure represents penetration plus loss of marl. l. 2. 5. 6. 31. REFEREKCES Bergquist, S.G., Musselman, H.H., and Millar, C.E. Marl -- Its formation, excavation, and use. Bulletin 22h, Agricultural Experiment Station, Michigan State College. McCool,‘M.M. and Harmer, Paul M. The muck Soils of Michigan. Bulletin 136. Agricultural Experiment Station, Michigan State College. Lyon and Buckman. The Nature and Properties of Soils. Dachnowski, A. Peat Marshes. Geological Survey of Ohio. Bulletin 160 Smith, R.A. Origin of Marl Deposits. (Unpublished) Davis, C.A. A contribution to the natural history of marl. Vol. 8, pt. 3, Reports, Michigan Geological Survey, pp. 65-103. 1903. Lane, A.C. List of marl localities and portland-cement malls in.Michigan. Vol. 8, pt. 3, Reports Michigan Geological Survey, pp. 22h-3h2. 1903.