‘ . . . v - I _ ~ - ‘ . . I ‘ D. 5 ' - . ~ ~ 0 ' . - . “ - . l‘ ‘ I ‘ . \ _ . »‘ V . N ‘ a ' . a ‘ ‘ - ' s ‘ ‘ - O I ‘ . 0- V - . . . ~ H , . . ~ -‘ ‘ ‘ _ . ‘ ‘ . \ . .. . - V ‘ > V- - . . ‘ . K . ~ ‘ ¥ - \ h _ - ‘ . l - . h ‘ . - ‘ ‘ - - . - I ~ I ‘ V I - ‘ - ~ .. o I ‘ ‘ . .- - . > ‘ ~ ' ~ - ‘ ~ - .. - u ‘ - - u I - \- - . . ~ ' . v N ‘ _ < . . Q I‘ ' ~ - fl . _ ‘ -‘ ‘ > ‘ . ‘ I ~ ' ‘ ' ‘ . . ‘ - “ ' . - ‘ ~‘ ‘ . ‘ ‘ . .‘ - ‘ t > ‘ ‘ . A ~ . ~ . - . . ‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ _.‘ ‘ . ~ ~ . . ‘ . -‘- - . - ‘ ~ ‘ , - -~ ‘ . ‘ ‘ ~ ‘ - s u - I “ ‘ . . . - I . ‘ - < . ‘- . . ~ V . . ‘ _ - . - o . .. .v..i.7m.fi.awm.ufl;3£§$.31§i1§3¢1 . . ., . . H, : mama ‘ uvullbvbfiaIOIJIiJ. .. 44 ‘ ’ Lclounlv-l\ 1‘0»! THESIS ACKNOWEDGMENT The author: or this theeie are indebted to the menu of Reclamation 1'01- valnable information furnidxed by then; the to the helpful guidance end suggestion: a! _ f Pretend: c. M. Cade. v... 0.. ".‘~- -. as .V Mfg .e e K . \, g a '59” “29-? '5 ! 103.21% A STUDY'OF HYDRAULIC JUMP The protection of stream beds below spillways and weirs against erosion.has long been a problem for the hydraulic engineer to solve. Large sums have been spent in constructing aprons, weirs, cushion pools and other structures below dams to protect the stream beds against damaging erosion. In 1838 the phenomena of the hydraulic Jump was noticed and study was made or the mathematical formulas which.would gsvern it. It remained for the Miami Conservancy District engineers in 1915 to make the first real study for the con- trol of the hydraulic Jump and use of it to prevent stream erosion. Since that time more interest has been aroused in the subject and today the control of the standing wave or jump below a epillway is considered to be one of the essen- tial parts of the design of dams. The authors of this thesis took up the study for two reasons. The first was to improve their knowledge of the control of stream erosion and the mathematics or hydraulic Jump. The second was to build a model which could be used for this study and for future study of dam construction and design in the hydraulic laboratory of Michigan State College. The first step was to build a model in the form of s trough with glass sides in which.a model dam or weir could bezmounted and the action of the water observed while pass- ing over this dam. In addition a study was made of the available data and experiments that had been made in regard to stream erosion. It was interesting to note that one of the first laws, The conservation of Momentum, is still used and is one of the basic laws regarding hydraulic Jump. With the aid of the model the results obtained were compared with the existing laws and compared very closely with experiments whieh had been conducted in years past along this line. The Hydraulic Jump or Standing Wave gets its nae from the wave which firms below a dam under certain conditions. It remains at the same heigit and stationary. This forma- tion translated from a German article is called a surface roller. this is due to the rolling appearance of the stand- ing wave. It is difficult to discuss this formation without bringing in the mthenstieal discussion. The mthmtics of the forsation will be discussed later. It has been noticed thst as the water reaches the toe of a spillway it is traveling at a high velocity. If this velocity is main- tained ever the tee and out on the stream bed a large amount of material would be carried away, resulting in time in the undermining of the toe of the sea and the failure of the structure. is the water strikes the tee and the standing wave is formed the kinetic energ of the water is taku up by the impact with the wave. The velocity of the stream is reduced and water flows away at the normal velocity of the stream. In other words, the energy of the falling water is dissipated by the impact with the water telow and is used ~ 5:7" "’2'“ ,- x _ He'd-4.1119 - e .‘ . . I ,. ‘ - ' '.'. n ‘. ss:. _. ' "" 'I .. Ii. 4.- .. s _ . ' ‘ -""‘ -. - o. )9" on .3..‘.'..’ .'.‘~:'_- 2'31“. .‘5 *1 ’.‘-.4v~"“n" . 4 _ - -‘_ ' - ' ‘ .3 fifli ‘ _ .‘ 11‘""- m3... f:."»'-:‘ a, ‘r a «i 1“ A-“ .‘ 3.4337 141’ Z ". 1;- rh- .: ' White: ‘1 (ZML 11 r: I If'...‘ a 1 M. 1113'! . ., "J‘. ; 8’ '1 33%; 12.; «a: r A . a» - ‘ , , in piling up the wave into a frothy, foamy fornnti on that cuts down the velocity or absorbs it and dissipates it in the form of heat. One of the most effective ways of dissipating energy is to introduce friction. In some structures a weir is constructed below the toe to introduce a tumble bay or a cushion pool so as to increase the resistance to flow. is water is usually considered incompressible this body of water offers considerable friction to the mass flowing into it at a high velocity. The friction of the bottom and the friction introduced by the use of water directly in its path absorbs the velocity of the stream and causes the water to pile up. he cushion pool in the model was intro- dueed by raising the end gate (see drawing of model). With this end gate down the high velocity of the stress continued throughout the length of the Mel and no standing wave was introduced. By raising and lowering the end gate the posi- tion of the jump could be varied from the tee of the dam out to the end gate. When gravel and sand were placed in the stream the wave would form with the end gate down. his would indicate that there must be friction in some form or other in order to overcome the velocity of stream enough to allow the water to pile up. Also a higher eleva- tion of the and gate was needed to start the Jump than to nintain it. After the Jump was once started the end gate could be lowered considerably and the wave seemed to main- tain itself. o ;. II". ... . . I . o - n e . ‘ , 0“e!‘1}!r‘£. , . I": '3‘ t e <‘ . . - ',v s , ~ g. . s‘a "4flVI-I": 0": . ' 'n ’0. r‘?’- .' s ' i,‘\:'" e r fin ‘a‘ I "1"“: I. 1 I I . l. , i k M! ! ... ..r I ”17.; g 4 1 A.- 6.; .f’o’. .1 V I -C . ‘1 ”do” ‘10 L: . llie‘ 'lv.| e f " S. --' " ‘- 24355-3 A", ’ 0;, g '. ._. 3‘ . -. . n :q s‘iw-.; _-I’ a." ' e" .' ,‘r ""1 ".- ’:>'.’:'.{!rf 4; I “v:‘.:;' ‘ . ‘ t. .' ‘9 ...- O 0 O 4.... . ...... . ..u ‘4 Is ‘ 9 4.24133 . ‘7’ ' f . - .3! all . 1"»‘2... 1'1 ‘. 33,3! 3...:‘1‘ '15 ’11.; V at: pg: .1; its o ' ' ._ .. .-‘ a' e a I y ‘ I ' . O—I . I _ . . 3.; - :e‘J _ . . O ' e a: A .. .'.soe.0 v‘fa. _ 5. ~.. ‘ . ' . . . . Q . e i' J: - {7 . e ’4 . ‘ 1 s ' 9' u 0‘.a".." . . e‘of._. :- 5 "“"... 7.: "0': 'e . I" ‘ To a . 55’1"! ~’* 3 a . I if 3 ‘3'.” “it, I I! U“ - ;.e- i. I e. ..., 5.5"“! ‘2‘. . .. .?.'°. O‘; '1 H' e I‘ .- o '5 ’l.-e-_‘ v~ O t. “’0 In: . I . 'f'... 113/! T. do" -.=.-—. 31%? If: i 3' I. J. I. J’ . {If ’ ’ I Q ' C ll'3}‘.t;}:f£:‘g '-' ”awn 1;“ - 1‘” * s; -. l incl-11;;I.;1 ‘ r. Taps; 4. The time limit on this thesis doesnot allow much study on erosion of the stream bed. A few runs were made. some using fine sand for a bed and others using coarse gravel. The main deduction from these was that the Jump itself should occur on an apron of material that would not be eroded by the action of water. Where the Jump occurred below the apron it hollowed out the bed to a considerable depth below the apron. This shows that the position of the Jump is a necessary part of the design of a spillway. How- ever. the uterial eroded by the Jump will be redepcsited a short distance below the point of occurrence of the Jump. It is therefore necessary to have the Jump occur as near the toe of the dam as possible to have economical design of structure. In the February 8, 1927 issue of Engineering lewe Record, page 190 is a very good'article on the costly erosion below the Wilson Dam of the Muscle Shoals proJect. led the engineers in charge of this mode“ designed the spillway such that the Jump had occurred on a concrete apron the costly repairs to the structure could have been eliminated. The only way in which the authors of this discussion can recomend that the position of the Jump be determined before the structure is built is by the use of a model. This method has been used throughout Europe and is being used more and more in the United States. By its use the toe of the dam and the apron can be so arranged that with the laws of similitude and the assumed flow the . . _- ‘ - v A < .. . V P.‘ .- ' 3‘ flm;éi N“ W" n . . , ' .“ t- . i ' s . ‘ . - . $2 ‘a“ ' -":-.'l.-fi."\ ve‘j- ‘fis‘varw’f “. I s ' . ‘ ' ' _ an? designer can be reasonably sure that costly erosion will not occur. So far no one seems to have been able to place the point of occurrence of the Jump in a mathematical formula which will allow the designer to predator-ins the standing wave and design his apron accordingly. The mathe- matics of the standing wave or surface roller will now be discussed. “TREATICS OI NIP. Unwins formula for conservation of momentum [see Encyclopedia Brittanica, 9th Edition, Vol. 12, p. 499.] [Belonger 1830]. D"¢¥W TT’TL d - depth above the Jump D 't depth below the Jump '1'. velocity above the Jump g -. acceleration of gravity 1 Derivation of the above formula is as follows: (see sketch) . 'o o o o o o 332‘ . "0 900.99 M. .I.WI'Mt’o’.‘o‘o’do’do:o:.§ MNMMNMMON w . .‘o o 'o’o'0’”o’e’o’o’o‘e’o’e’o'o’o . . 'o’o’ooHNuneueo’w a Clo'oW’" ..ounuoueugé... .' W'“ «noun» \ ':'o’o'o'o°e’o\'o'e.e.0 6 d 0 e e e e e e e e o 9 N. h\\\\ sprout}at.to:.52.:cecaaeaeeoze. h b 0’ d - depth of stream ant ering hydrauli c Jump La; 2W '1 '- velocity of stream entering hydraulic Jump 1) ' depth of stream leaving hydraulic Jump 73" Velocity of stream leaving hydraulic Jump ‘ 11,- depth of same stream at critical flow Y0. velocity at critical flow . rim v5 - g D. Q - quantity in second feet of flos per unit width of stream. Qe'ld'YgD'Yfig'W (13) Haas of water flowing/sec. "w Q/g ' ‘w - unit wt. of water Change of velocity if 71 - 72 change" of‘momentum/sec. - i9“ (VI-Y2) Substituting _v+L -V vs '_‘év_9._(71 - rid - 33;; 3 (11-4) Static pressure acting on the face (a -'b) - wd2 .-g- Static pressure acting on the face (e - f) - :33 Hence: D-d)‘ (Dz-d2) #5 ‘ Ji- Dividing both sides'by w(D - d) lultiplying thru 1324.1» - 29,13 8 Substituting (Q - us) I" + m - 1123.6. ‘ 8 7. (1b) (10) (1d) (1e) (11') (1) (2) (5) (4) (5) (5) (7) (8) (9) D‘d-dD- Eled so (10) s i/,* 3' T In ":3"— D f 4 * g (11) --e1 \ T 4T*‘T"1"“lis ‘12) , 4. n-- W-e is 3: substituting + for 11 in (e) 2‘ z ' n dDd‘ s (it) fi— . en n+1 - ‘ - 3 (see la) (15) 1—24,..3...‘ ”0 dD D-l-d -. n93 (is) Dividing thru by n.” and substituting a: and y (lb and lo) for their equivalents r: (x + y) - z (17) mutation (1d) shows that tan d .- D. D also equals D, Substituting: in (it) Dannd-Dnl - ’95 (is) 2.25 £ 13.31) - n.” (19) Substituting 3 - n. 133‘ d- n.’ - 13,3 (80) D,3 e D‘,3 ‘1213 e no. equation (ld) is symmetrical in d and D. If d is less than D.. then D must consequently be greater. If d is greater than Dg ( impossible) than D would have to be 9. less than D.. As there seems to be no physical phenomenon that would cause a reversal of the Jump, the conclusion is that the Jump can occur only when (d) is less than (D6) and (D) is greater than (Do). When the conditions are right, so that the Jump occurs, it will always take place at the critical depth. The action of the hydraulic Jump is a continuous violent inelastic impact internally. by which the kinetic energ of the swiftly moving stream entering the Jump is converted into heat. To plot the results of the experiment the formula D " f E V 33 1' I: - d 17 '71—'- 1— r is reduced to the following form Dot J - D hl - velocity head of stream entering Jump. i'hen nt%_-‘ gym (at) n3+w+_i_2_-u%§g_+_%§ (es) Dividing thru by (dz) hate-fists ‘2" Substituting :-_ 3‘; and hl- 3&1 :‘4-3-5 2133 -41:; 32+J- 4b] (as) . - ..- .-.'-.-='~ ‘ Jfi'a.‘,o-' 3": ‘.~'! 4‘ I ; 1.. “r z \ ‘ 0‘ . . ‘25“ e ...“3' 0 Mc‘ . 53:: 2!"?! .‘J {I i ‘m. . at}: i Z? ‘ ’2’; ’1, M f 1" - e j./‘ a» h 0‘ I. 430335 flaw: dr’ ' ~ l at: -'-.- :‘_p;~:.g:}‘ “1.4;: . 52"! I I! I find? (if . i’f‘é’ I 10. Values of J as ordinates have bean plotted against values of (bl/d) as abscissa. ‘A A’ "I A [fl KKV$ PIN JUL: {Ks-l T‘V,‘ . ‘Vcfl .s-IJ' v ' P- .A ‘ W -¢U~-—.‘ d .-A¢—.. [1"‘O'v—H‘. 'AVfi ‘n—-~-s-J V‘ ”PT l‘n e 1 ..I ...»155 ._ o n. .' I ’e .. , . . . k. .. .9 v .—‘ ‘ . . . . . . s a . A _ .. . . I . ....‘ 1 . , . ‘. . . .. ‘ . . ‘ . v . - . . I .. IV... hit; a , . . _ _. . .....7 no» ._ mud .. . s ' W I . . . . . - +r—»<_ - -.. H ”My ...fi- p .— - - t - . . . - . A . O 0 O nsmmmummmurfinsrmzu . Je tug~rznm ‘ a M! 3? Q. f L, B 7. r_ L We «1.: - ~ 1~ 4 Wi‘r I - ’ ' . '7‘; I r t ' 9 b3. '-,. A .; . 4' Cue-5,- + - ¥+g A A r a ' * T‘ I l '5'; . 1 A ' . ’ g‘- ' e OI 0- ‘.o- ' ' 41 c . . ' ’-- - Y L I T317 r H :2 . ‘ ' ‘ s-a - - -- O ’r . ". . ‘ ' . . . r~~~~1~ _ cf .3. '. -..—~———_ - ,niiwasnmwmnmmom 0'! .; a. ... ”Ogd \ .... 44 “-..... 4». -e ...—fie 0 I‘d ’1v00 ..vudifil.‘ 'll . 1"" #v,v.e .I‘I.J\yle+1wl-.t,'ll. 0"..."Alt -. e d a - - w ’4. “-0... . v I’t‘L..\‘Q-I .I‘Ol A Yb»- mate“. Itb . M ..... _ . q . _ . . . . a . t a . . . r V V l 4‘ . a a a . . . . . . _ . 'alM! OI» 9 .40A ' . . . . 3| a 5 BREW... Laws. . h ML” \ eeeeee 4’»—‘ - . C“. .LLWVVHLDFW ...:WLLHM... 9 . . - 9 - $ 0 l I. . I . . o O _ - ; f ' . . . I s t - o . e I - ' Y -i. 0 T +1 9 ' O 1. g o . 0 4‘—- -~--O—{y--~. ‘.-—+~ I I ' ‘ ' ' A J. . f e - a . - a s d 9 e— o o e . ' z .0 - . .L. .. . . '. 0 .-.. r 9—10 . -— - 1 ~ . a g . . ‘ -_- 4 L, ' - .._ .41} 4 . , . . . . . a l . _ ' . . . . .- - .. , - . . 1 . i ' | +4}- > ‘ O I i a ‘. . - J , . . I- . . It . W - f ‘wu ‘ T D h 1 . — -T & - . t f o . ‘ ‘t' -?- * '7 t a O . . 1 . d . ; - - v -7 .7 ———-r—. fifl—(Fo—**‘—-+*4—O—O—fir H"~—-. o-o. . *4. 1 . . . . . . . t .. I . - 0 ~ - 0- . t > ‘ . 0 ~ 0 a3 ; ’ ' I ‘ ' L ' .\ 0 T v : . . .i . . 7‘ 0 i I t 3 'I“ 1" . I. Immxz. ' ‘ ““ ‘—° --- ' ' ° "7“ "I“ 0 ..n ,‘I‘_ 3 t a Ilhfiv 0 III, f;"__- J. ‘ Iflfi HR ‘ ‘2 H. ‘ § 1' 83-” 0 + .2: j: - : . 0 . ii. "1; ° , ~‘t'e_ 1 . . I “ -_ r. _ Iruu-. ' l 0 0 4 . . . é ‘ . +¥ O .: 9 ‘ O Iatssfv :Iluhrn. imrsgq» '- P O - . '0‘ - 3.. “I. ‘39.?" -. Shir Ilusa' !.'i¥t1‘ 1 ‘_ . ~-_. m ,—~A...-.< e—-—o A . . 0 s | 0 O . O '4 -v-v ‘ ? -—9~—o—.— - -— —o—o ~‘% A—Afi‘—«-——.——4 -.- -— e - —--— e -- ‘ . . A . n I - e . 0 . . . l Q n ' f A A 7 | . - i . - . . - l ’ . o .. . .. ' - . I 0 ‘ a . ‘ , 0 . - * o o ..-- -.——0—-1 » ——o-o ' Fo-o—o -o >—.- 4—0-—{ - \‘ ...“ ...... .-- W L ._.---._._.__.' .. .... «.0. , . . _.-.- .._..-.. .-.-..«J 0 ...,‘m ‘+..--. -..}..-M‘o 9—._._- o 1 d 0 0"""‘.“’ . 0 1 1 3 0 I t *_l_..'_..._.—-_ ...... , .._,_.- I ? -—4 . | B’s-Ii? Kama- -| Inrflli‘ _, . , ' P Q. 0| L-o... a: t .5- 8Lr_ ' ‘ ’ ~ 9 l - '.flyt’ . t "u - a— -- I.Fa‘y ‘ ‘ b". '9 o 0 ~— l n.1,“? [:3 ‘ 1 . fl ‘ “' r “ #. 'flft-sl ‘ 1 iIb‘J'S'_ ' ' : . + H~lr ... . j r .g; - .. “A..- . . "I" - . ' ° ° 1 to- 2‘ ' - -_ - 1 ' v o ., PF- *‘-"~~ _. 'au 0 . ... . . . .c-. * ' - '#~+» 0 e- ’ ‘ ' r .....J,__,_._‘ . P‘l ~ . . t ~ -——+ +—e>- —H --. "-- i r r ..., L V ‘ Imumn ltlm . es~ d'n ."~ 0 R‘UTJ' e ‘- .3 _ I; .0 0‘ Y" . V| .. H‘3‘.L . _. 2:338:33}: t'fiflle‘filiffii I . .,.‘ 'lJ s ' - l g ' t - w . —. . ‘0 O 0 o O a a ‘ V Y t . . . o .....- 7+ ”.---.. , L-‘-* “-74 -... .— Fa- H- ill‘s". 3. ‘ ‘ e‘I'IdIJFIL " A? _ 8 _ .7; 5 *Iftla'" [i I Eli. '_I A .—. --- _ ‘ .7.” , m , _ ‘ use: ‘ "‘31 Wilt}; ' ' :‘fi-R“‘\‘f' " ‘." 0 ' >-- -—.._ 1 _ .‘ d I ' J 4T ' ‘ 0 ’ I t "‘ 0- r Y - t i . ' I . ' ’ l | ' 0 , . ‘ 4 ‘ "I I '7 . . 9 ‘ Q ,. . ‘ . . . ; . ‘ . . _ _ A ' i ‘. . 9 r I . . ‘ . . '\r I 9 . V ' . . ' . ‘ . . . - ' ‘ h ‘ t ' I M A ¢;_..:._'r 4--..“ . ‘0' . T”“ "“"""“L ‘ ’“"” ...“ - -..." _.._._ . I 1 T 1 . <0 ---- .. --.. -+._ __ ”...-.fl 9 0 0 I.” +‘I‘I'IQAIAYI to, v-0 0 .0 o . { Illvzltot ...... - ¢_._-*.—._4> Lucy... In“. - .l! e o t . 7 t . ...._.-o-- .M’- ...fi?..usv. . t 3.7 bath-yr“; milu...il. -.Mw.‘ Luge”. PI DIE-”PL. ["35 8...: ....a... . . . . . . . o 1... ill L ...m........ r ._._ O aflrcput' \M‘d” ..Dm...‘....rdyuw.‘.!... .l.‘ are. .a.n v.5 . . fl . m l 9 0‘00..." . w _ . . . g? -0 .. 6.. .0 n. O t I . . . . m . . . . . . b a u 5 . .n . _ . ; g n +Qfi0m0-l0 $0.0.” - $0.0. -+. ...Olol. ...0.- . ~4. w a W n . .. . . v. ... . . . I w i . . . 0.... H . n _ n ..4. . . .n .~ ~ . . .. . b c 9.0 .4 n It 9 II+ a .‘I 60.”.0'. V- fitln’t Y- 06 0090.4...1 v . . c o . . .... . .. .. . . . . .. . s. .-. . H3 ......p- .5. .. ..a. .... .. . 1.03:1- {pi i _ I. #1 A w ., . p . k . H h . ._ . _ _ _ _ ,- 3 T H L-- .l- V _ _ . * . . + . . a . . . ’ a _ . u * v .. L. .r r[ .r a H . h . . H h u a v . . . I .. . m . k F . I * . fl . . . w p . to o . . Afi 0 4 V V : c o v 0. II ‘1'! O . .0 0 + L 1 9 0 . A Lfi 9 U 6 0 J . . ¢ . . . . . . . . f . _. . . . ‘ - . i . . .. A. . . . . . . . a . “U . m . . . . . . w m o . . . . . . . . . . . fl . . k . . . . * . . . . . . q . . v . p O 6_ v. . 0 ‘4‘ 01".44.0|!-IIQ-' LICIIOIIO OIOIII Ytul‘ 9" 9| 0 o c'. A 0 ‘1 Q: § J a 0 AW 0| 0 .I. .‘Q «- . — . . . . w . . . a . . . . . . . . _ . . . . . o . . . * . . . 3 . * . r . . . * . . 4 L. . - o . . w L - J - .- . ‘ . _ .-.;er . -L..h.T_.-.. ......L. - ... . _. ...-..-. .-.-{...am.-...-...- ...-5..--..- 9. ... ~k.u.. ......rhan‘ ......uotflcfifr . p» ‘ . . ...."svsp 3.6.5,. 3" (JR—1‘s...” a. .. 1.9“... .5: in... , .3... 23., 5:: b5 5? _ Finn.“ lLLfiIIPiEFlrIQ gBflINbDIIIu “gawk” “efllila.”.flml u. .M...F'o_l _.'._‘_---. -- ..... ._‘ -‘W v—«r -—“ . ‘fii vi —' "V -___+_.__.__‘P..._‘_~.~_..*~.vfl—~ - 1 t ..-. ~ Ill 2.3L. 3 '7 I I I E? I - 4-0.--fi..- - ...... u}. 1 8 I'HR‘" I'Ul_ I533! . ...lflifif' E”? w ” : H 3. _ .-.. 1.. g. _. .. T _. . W. --iz.l c3-.1---ct .. .I-o..u. ~.p. ..-.-ml-r.JIr-tf . y .- ....1!.ll.l._..’.-tvfluv o ...... .14 ....» .q ....u 7.7.. P..g~.r. u. ....Q ...; F:. riuru" -II:8“0_3I luau-Innu- q .. “L7“..I3nu 3.5.". $5. “'..3. _W»i3g‘.“til':-KH: ‘IiQNHIU'QISI-Ilua I‘M" w w - M 1 W 1 . . . .4 m * H w W . M . . . . . . ”W . w 1 . 1.1 .11- 1-19-1111 ; [H11 11.. 1 . A H . / . . _ n a W w . u . CV . . * . 1 1I1I1+Il1 I o 1 of; I10 iIJ.II IIIIII¢ I‘IIILYIII1I1I I . . . .. . . H .... . .. .- . 1...-;.1.+11111.-.1.11.. . . ..-1 ..... 1111B-“ _ ._ . .. . . ..h. . .m ... .H. .. . ..H . ..i. . P IL . - o a I, J . 1... . 1. 1 1.11 . f-.. _. . .. _ ... .. . . ~ . 4. 1 h .u . M . . . . 1H .. . . . . ., . . + 1 4 -1 11 11:. . 1 IQ: II -o .. .II III. II I1. III. A IIIII. -.-_-1 . _ .. W%\1 K 3 H M _ -‘ _ MM&V 13 M. H . .... --1 . 1.51. Na:- .- . . ‘ ks... _ . h ._ \NKN.uR . . 1- ...... ._ _- h . _ - t -.. haw QI.1..'.)u._.. . . Eggittf l {\t. b .. I * . .4! I 45/7/15 I I I I I I 1 ‘— I I 1 I A. I 1 .I. T I I I I I I I I #1 I I I ‘— 1 i $1I. 1 . , . .--,__.4*_...+----1._,_. . . . _ . 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I . 1 . . . j I + I I I I I I I .1 I 1 I I I -- - .. .77-”-P- fib— .It'llo « 11....“ f . . G . Q .J. | 1 . ¢ 1. 10.; . 1 1.. . 1 I . . .. . o c. 1 I .1 1 1 .1 v . I. . .1 I . ... «I! . w‘y ...._ .3 J1. . . ... .....m .11. v.1 . . -...‘1 a- -. «1'11... .1 ...W. 1 .u . . P..1 .. . .m..\.-... . . _‘-:-.v\..‘_ .1. aim: .w1 1 ‘1. Lu 1 .1- :BC' . 4.1.95 ....v "I.“ )rm ...u'. «arr... 1n.“ Elfin...-..-;..2n..r._u1$. . ...-.....msm . .L. .. .- ..... w... .13.... .- ...“...H Q I ... r5 ...IN .. . 1... f. Imu1lhnpi I Qu3nrneflu Ibrtalntnmrurrus , It'll-II . .IIEIIIIIIIIIIIII T I A1 A . . . Q . . . 1 F 1 1 w 1 o 1 1 . .. . 1 1 14 +1 #1. .1 . . . 1 . . ¢ . 1 . .1. L O. 111 1., 1p 1 1 fl J I 1 . III . . _ _ . 1 1 1 . o . . . ¢ _ . ¥ . $ . * . 0| A ~ . . . . . o . . w H . 9 . 1 c . ._ . . . 4 (J . . . . . . . . 1 . . . . . . . 1 . . . OI Jo II1I II t1 k I IIIifiII v- 1 iY1IIIIIII11. I f I IILIIIQII LIII‘IIII Iw 011 1 . / . — . . . . . . u . . h § 1 . a. 1 o o 1 i M . . . . . . o a » . n < ¢ 10 . o. . o O o O o c . _ . i .. 1 o a o . . 4 1 o . o o w o .QI . o . J v H h . . . . 1 + . . q .. . 1 . p A 1 o H A ...._ __———1 ....l' 0.0 . .11‘- . . ‘t.v _‘.& 3111.4: Qak uflk sHVH m . , F 1!]?! ; _ . \(L . . . H .. t o r 9 u. o LT & ; ...“ a . _ w M .. . u . . . m H .§ > V I4“ . A u w 4 1+1! . . . _ . .. h m 3 U V 1|. .. ‘ -0 a H 9 § . 0 #1 '-v o 4 . . . _ - M-....-r-..4-!--v! . . _. _ , . . . . _ ~ . . . _ _ . _ . . h a M. 3 . 4 . . I. .. J t . . _ H . . . . _ . n. w . _ h . h . . 3 . h . . o 0.0 ¢ '1 £911.. on: All « II. 9 5 I 1 9 0|! K+ |4|u 1 I 0| A A o ’4. t o to .14-: lei hit .. I i . .0 ‘l‘l’ ITc‘Jlo 9. cool _ ... . H . W . e . . . . . i . . — . h . . ~ . . . . n M . . . w . . , . . . . _ g . . A 0 4 w > 4 .4 LI I . . u . . . . . . A . . b . w . . . . . (y .. w . . . o . . w . . ~ . . . A . . . . . . . . « ¢ . . . 3 . k . . . . . _ . c o . . . . . . . . . ~ . . . . M o It ' a . ¢ 0 r0 o1 0|" + . p L 9- V40 91.7qu v..tI6I¢ A... Q o|V Tolt’ltivlt ’4' §+‘ll 4|} . Iol‘) no!o éLrI tloIO 6." V‘OInTonIllav‘ a o- ‘ . o . . . a .1“! . . o o . . . . . fi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ‘ . . . ‘ . . . . ._ o . «A . fi . . h . . 4 A . . _ o o . . _ .. . . . o . , . . . . .m . . _ . fi . . _ . , , . 4 ..1 4 4 . . . . . . * . . . . . . n . _ . , . H H . h . . ~ . .AHV . , . . . h . ., . W . . .. . . . . N . . . . . . . w . . ,0 9 v-1 ‘ . .050'010 O ‘ b buTLr‘vtOIIOtllu _ A Clo, IOvIVIoIT'OIVT‘ItLWIO!filrltlslo ' T‘l't -011 TI 0 LHW . h . .13»... : w 11. ... ... . . . v . gr . . . . _ . A ._ _ _ .W“ .. u H. . N _ _ u thwufi h - .I m w, .. 3 g _ M \Sn‘NQ. a . . H .. , . . . . * . _ ‘ . . . . f _ \NN “a . fi 1 . . . r . _ .‘ \ _. 3 _ . r_ . ‘33... ...._....... _ . ..., J ... 27.. ... ... .. . .. . ., h. . . . - .- _- . . v .. . .,v .... .. . 3.....3 w. .... ...... . ....H ...«M.?. ...p. SM“... n. . ..3. .. ...“...rr'h v _. bi. .. .WY. .. L”. .. 5.- . ......J .~ “V9... ........_... .3”... ..v. .... .u....;.u . DEEP .a..~m.¢,.. _........a.fi._..b. an;‘...0 em. , . -..” - ...-.L ,.-.«...hummwhwfi.firv .....-fivftvrnca . .rfir}..ruihxn.. .3..-F.cnumhhnun -...m. wwuu mfiumnmu n... - ...-~¢-- O _ -p— ‘ -3 e . - . ....— Q - . 0 .— qr—o—o ‘ . I all ,‘l‘ 9|? ,0“ l. . . I. m .3 . in g -3..- «V. .. . -. M. 3 _. . 3 . . .9 . . . . .. .t . M w _ .3. w - .. ; J . . U .. . . w . .... « ... . .. W. ....wii9ri-.;. . _. . w. _ .3 . w. . . . . . ... -..--Tk_--_.---_-L. o. - -- ---. 0_.... -..- n . . i..-3..~n. Jlnd...’vzu..c nu! .h‘L'! ailrLlaulllliI . .P ...» “.3. h.‘ ISIII Iodifi ... ...-aha é... Mil-nann EV“.- an“. - $ “ ‘P‘JQ .x;wcainlunue wEfia flunk. .o u.I.IIi.u\h. 1>‘\ . ..I la‘ [90.0 fu.‘.|od I «I fill . I II$.h.N.‘fl iv ‘ “I . III’O‘IIIIIOI‘I'- - 'l - . l,‘v|ll||"|..u A 8 Z’dw l -_ o 9 ; 4271?: ’73:" L. -- .lfal/QV. fld’J! 11/}! - - .. .--.JP, - .. ... - o 7 l'nl’l‘l." ‘1'! ....... . ... ...- w, 9 a a ., . ——_.__4r__ ._ .n, Pntwu... .....nm .1.‘ .iv-. .0 :- ..l‘n. . O. .n-u. I glad“? LAWS Ol' HYDRAULIC EIHILITUDE 11. The relnti on between the dimension: for etrnotnrea in nature and for models or such structures follow: ‘Subceript n in used to denote model. 11 in need to denote scale ratio amromt 3411931 on Linen: L z :2 n : 1 Are; A : :2 I:2 x 1 "1“” Q a z: n3 x 1 Weight I z 'n a: n5 z 1 Velocity (friction neglectedIY : V, :: _n : 1 Velocity 7 g 7n g: 811 3 Sn 1“” H : :: n3 : 1 1'13. 1 z 1. z: n : For” I : I, z: 33 x 1 lonentl M:I.::n‘:1 Work I : x. :: n“I : 1 Energy E :1. :2 n :1 Rate of Discharge Q : an :: n5 2 : 1 ‘r ,E i Q“ I4- I l U 1'! . _ . ”If? \ l < bhfl .- . ...‘A‘ “I - I - 31*- 2'1. '1". ‘. 'i Q! w ..II I. .ien' " .l . el\.i.e. . 3“.“ Ella} u .1. 18. In the construction of the model, the principle object was to obtain a nodel which would be satisfactory in deter- mining the reliability of the law of conservation of mentun. lo effort was made to correlate the model to existing conditions at some particular den site. The ogee spillwey was made to scale, however, representing type I of spillway shown on page 697 of the Engineering lows-Record, of Kay 3, 1928. for all the purposes of this experinnt no consideration of the laws of sinilitude was necessary. If mrther experiments had bem mn, however, with the purpose of determining the location md effect of the hydraulic :up for some proposed dan, the node]. would have been erected so as to closely resemble the conditions at the partimlar site, and in order to correlate the results from such a model to the dam, the laws of sinilitude would be used in all cases. The model as constructed is shown by the drawings, Plates 1, 2, and 8. The inside width of the trough is 1.00 feet, the heigxt 2.00 feet, the overall length 5.00 feet. i'he sides and floor are of wood construction with Joints waterproofed with asphalt paint. The Joints so waterproofed were satisfactory during the period the experiments were run. lo perceptible leakage occurred mer the first day. The greatest difficulty encountered was to obtain a watertight spillway. After the first day 3’. l 1' ‘ I Alir ‘ 'I |_ s g. I _ t a '. .01.“! .1 -.1.w;.:4.:.-:--.. .- o . . o' ' “U .‘_-.o'(~., .II.!vr. .L‘. Ir}. .7... H .v. wr‘l 3e|.11!¢.‘s. 13. the ogee spillway. made of white pine lumber and paraffined, began to swell. The gasket used between the spillway and the glass sides consisted of old rubber inner tubing. This gasket did not effectively check water seeping thru from the back of the dam. It did not compress sufficiently to allow for the expat-ion of the den. The consequences of the expansion of the dam was that the glass sides were put . under too great a strain. One side which had been nrked for cross-sectioning had several long cracks which followed these markings. The glass sides, 1/4” x 2' x 8-1/2' plate glass, were the most costly part of the model. It is to be reeouended that no scratching or cutting of the surface of the glass be done in cross-sectioning. The ogee spill- way 1: made of wood should have sufficient clearance to allow for swelling of wood. The wood. waterproofed with paraffin, swelled considerably. Oreosote is recomended for waterproofing a spillway built of wood. felt. impreg- nated in oil is to be recommended for a gasket. rubber does not compress sufficiently. The spillway should be made of concrete, steel or some material which will not expend when imaersed in water. The coke baffle, (coke broken up into small sises) worked very efficiently in quieting any turbulence above the spillwq. The results of this experiment are best shown by fig. 1. .4 .31---;flflvafi.hufiqqflNat-w. . .N to! an ..F. --- e .--____._.4 . . * _ . e 4 O 0 -Y -9 a Is I'Ivil . . . . . . . . . . p . o v s 491:0“; ». n 4 +1 4 W - J . . _ . . . n m . . . . b m _ l 3 ... . w w . q - . . H 4.11.1--. 1 . . N. . . .. _ . . _ .+. a . . . r? 4 ..M. H. MW * . 3 . h. _. . . . . ... . ... 5 . . .._. . ..... Y..- A. |[. u - 6| " in .v JFZQflMECTJI ---4p. -—v——-o --...- - «4‘ 4«--- - e . ~—.—~.—-‘p—--.. - .-. . ,' . . 0 - n . p - - -_z_._..___._..-._....-. -- b I ... ... . ,hh_h+%hhf- nmzfiroc. J. .- 13:3,... Pill .Oviw'fhv “flue cu1—--L— ‘ l I ...-I— ”a 7": I _ ' - l p ‘ ‘fi'r 1099/09 1, 3/4' bra-55:4 ' . x .jfz/o?” /7//borco’/m/e5 , _~ , , g 1 i i i i I? g ‘ - 3'. ecu/mm ' be": J%'4f’ Je/bwflfle 5///5 ‘+ Q! 47%” I J - m . T fir 066.45 J/a ”13/ :_//.” g gf-r—‘Ja L/ ___1L Wf/fi’ €572!“ /"’Z 00/? PAfi/v ‘ . fifi/ / A: FEW: fa be ////ea’ [407% coke 1i ll/a/‘c to 7 . fl//J///5 4— 57‘adnj ~jc//0W ,D/xze fl// /09_9//I_9 “47”“ a9‘M JI’J/r'a/o / . . ‘ - 3 506* 9" We/r ~ FYI/2‘6 (DI/78 . ' I A/flycs 7‘0 be ' fiat/7f yflf‘fipflé) f ‘ p/ocea’fiere ‘ . T ' " ‘ Ger/roan: adficreer) . ' ' mesfl /4”.59(/0/‘<9 45%,» 14;] * , . 5,96% P1. my .7 fna’jp/fln/qy %a P/Ofd’ fl 577/0! afi fi/D/Efiaz /C JUMP x905 flfijf/VDAJ’ MflDA‘Z 0:779/15 'M/Cfl/Gfi/V 57797?- C 04 4 :6: 5,937' .4 mas/wa- M/Cfl/é‘fl/V Zea/nwma' .sca/e /”= a” fiF/F/l- 26) /9~70 #5751” I %” Jpocer pipe Dflz/jfld‘d qrfia/// 4/ ___§, flbafl 44,6, M/af/mJ/x 2 00/13 +4 WaJ/Se/ts Foo/.3 7%;- Had //g” on com (900’ Jan 2. 5/0/96 Cfl/ij/EDUCflfl/V %” bear 0’5 n0//c=.d fagef/ficxr 50/5/76 d W/ 7% = // 72. ” £30.65 er 3 asA’cr" gray/70’ aafer 60:96 094/ 2‘ f0 57/05 .5, .5 affac e wofcrproo/co/ W/ 7% para //}0 Np Fj/W‘e J /9 .5 TOD/V flf‘ HJ/DE/eUL /C c/l/MP 06ft , 5H4 A Wfly MCfl/G‘fl/V .5 7‘ flff- (a; 4 55:. tfljréfl/VJ/A’G M/C/f/fi fl/V ..SCo/e /”= J” M5)” 9, A930 ,5:- 5/3/290’01 flax/7‘ 550’? 4 Mae/27474 Fax/”39 50 #7.- her/000. ' 'p/o'cc 4y 4.5”cm I I. ‘ ”WNW Ora/0' A!) 1_ Z" Z [“Vfl 770/1/ /Vo .S/Joccr ,o/ple on Two P/afc 67455 Z¢ "X 4.2” Crass-5657700 d/IAo/t d/’ [/ch *-——— ——_————-——-——m_ 5/4 1. fl/“ Mflff/P/xéz all» -—— —qj- —————————-—fi _-—d-- —- —~b- ——_ __-—-— )0: M 3 flmawn‘ ,{7/70’ Wafer/d/ .5/2: c- .5 77/015 Jar/arr Hoe //z" OWE—6” I fiaflfJ/a’cs F7,- (%”x49 9 ”2:2; ‘fear .5716: I/7r 6%"?! 47 /.a ”12’ f/aar /=/r - (%”x4ytzmy 5///.s . ..Ve/Kan/ fine I J‘ydI/x/élle/ flats W/vgjif I)?» - fill K Z219 Wasfl 67:5 Wraqyflflrm //a ’ d/a Mots Wroea/fZ/a/z ”a, // _———_——-——_-——-——-——- VI 'w A (a an: F- -r:-——--u-!L-——— M0 /o’//_79 Wb/i‘c fine é’k 72' x /2.’ 506A“ Wé/fc /7/2¢3 {fi’fi'fiflX/lez’ 546/577-4415 aVcfiV/aw x9220 +1 fife/09239 W/ 2’2: P/flc 94’? ~74 ”x2 " Z0” .5 777,05 I J’s/bwfl/Ie é”X//4” *2! .rcar rods. 5poccr p/pc- p/dceo’ on@ on 1 79/137“ fflrcc roe/.5. /' faéécr 645766;“ A cfwc cw fifaaéflj, aflo’j/d-SS Euééer foo'kef ée/M/efi/i Ujee 5,0////4/@// 0/70/ 6/055, obo befyyccw éca’p/a/‘c €fl0’j/0—55 571/0 V/fi-w .57'7'40 JéB//a w five X2 ” 17/4 ”x/fl 72' Mngf @0/‘6/ Wfi/f'e , Hm: . %~”xo’n’&//;é - Jp///wqy ». fio/Vafl/zav’~ I 77/; 7/l4/Za/f fled/5707‘: Wfl/f’c fi/Ie 93/1 ”4’ ”9? ’9/6’ flyec 5,0///Way W/i‘e Hm: /fl ”av/32912” fioffam /0/o/: W/S/fc P/xle % ”x //% ’WJ" J/rap fl/xgyas W/wyfl/‘Z/vn J” jerccxzs 60/ Mrs /2." x 2.4” fl/d/fl P/gy Wfl/f'e flyc- ear/959474” é jib/WC/fjfe/ Jx’éfrJ/a 'x M5 fins/(’6 7‘ Eaéécr /// xJ/ f0////7_9 Wfi/fe fine % le3/Ix I, jmccrflm [re/7 ~34 ”X/J ”é.” P/afc 6/055 Z4l/X4Zev npum\(\.\1\»1\.\\\\\\unf\s\\R’QEN\I\JN§ 60/. Mcfo/ ///X Z" . .Sf‘r/ps [77.5 7' Afi/VJ/A/e 560/6 /”=C3” 0659/760/ 94.45Z///7L by \j ’11; 7"” fl jfz/py a/= fl 40/67/404 /6‘ JUMP M3054 fljthfiz J/ M/C/V/Gfl/V 3 C04 4 [‘65 M/Cfi’lé‘fi/V -/&”’Y//£’l/”"/d’ ...