A. 3W3? OF THE 5011305”!!! 0?. AUTOflGfiiLE $853? fiflt 31min: ’é‘cr fl» flaw of M. S. MKZHIGAfl $11M? COLLEGE is Ray. Lemard’ 639%:an 3949 Qua-.515 This is to certifg that the thesis entitled A STUDY Lb“ 1.11“) CL‘Mn'CiSiCT‘J (5F z’aU'l‘CMTTBlLL SE‘IEEJT STEEL presented In] LeRoy Leonard Peterson has been 301?]:th towards fulfillment of the reqltirellwxlts tnr Lawns— deqrct‘ in Mr . Majul‘ ltrnhtsxur Date May 19, 19,49 A STUDY OF THE CORROSION OF AUTOMOBILE SHEET STEEL By LeRoy Leonardgggterson - A THESIS Submitted to the School of Gradnate Studies of Michigan State College of Agriculture and Applied Science in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE Department of Chemical Engineering 1949 [THESE g3 FOREWORD In presenting this information, it is not the intention of the author to attempt to fix the responsibility for the corrosion of auto- mobile bodies on either the manufacturers of motor vehicles, nor on the governmental agencies using chloride'salts on streets and highways. .It is felt, however, that this prOblem can best be solved by the c00perative action of all the organizations connected with.motor transportation. This information is presented, therefore, not as a solution to the problem, but as an initial step toward that goal. It is hoped that this work may, in a small way, contribute to the ultimate success of their efforts. The author wishes to thank Dr. C. C. DeWitt, Dr. M. G. Larian, and Dr. R. W. Ludt of the Chemical Engineering Department for their helpful counsel and guidance. Sincere appreciation is expressed to us. E. A. Finney, Mr. C. C. Rhodes, Dr. Richard Thurm, and the other members of the Michigan State Highway Research Laboratory for the friendly assistance and cooperation which contributed so much to the completion of this work. Without their assistance, this project would not have been possible. L. L. Peterson May 19, 1949 East Lansing, Michigan {21789 8 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Factors Affecting Corrosion . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Scope and Gen eral Pro ced'ure e o o o o o e o o o o e 5 Inhibitor Study 0 e o o o o o o o o o o o o 5 Study of the Corrosive Media . . . . . . . . . . 7 Discussion of Results_ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Chromate Inhibitors o o o o o o o o o o o o o 9 Phosphate Inhibitors o o o e o o e e o o o e o 18 Corro Sive Media. 0 o o o o e o o o e o o o o 25 COHCIUSions o o o o e o o o o o o o o o o o o 51 Appendix A o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o 55 Data Sumry (Tables 1-12) 0 o o o o o o o o o o 54 Plate PhOtographs (Figures 15"18) o e o o o o o o 46 Appendix B o e e o o o o o o o o o o o o e o o 74 Laboratory Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75 Equations 0 e e o o o o o o o o o o o o e 80 Brine Analyses . . . . . . . . . . . . 81 Chloride Content Of Road.81u5h. o o o o o o o e o 82 T9813 Plate Measurement 0 e o o o o o o o o o o 85 original Data to o o e o o o o o e o o o o o 8 5 Selected References . . . . . . . . . . . . . llO Supplementary Biblio graplw o o o o o o e o o o o 112 A STUDY OF THE CORROSION OF AUTOMOBILE SHEET STEEL In recent years, the problem of automobile body corrosion has become increasingly troublesome to motorists. The extensive use of the automdbile as a means of transportation has demanded that streets and highways be kept safely passable under all weather conditions. To this end, sodium chloride and calcium chloride have been applied as a means of ice control and dust palliation. The use of these chemicals has mounted in direct proportion to the increasing traffic on our highe ways and has brought the prOblem of corrosion sharply to the attention of the motorist. The opinion of a great majority of motorists seems to be that these chloride salts are the chief cause of this destruc- tion (Figure 1). Little published information is available on this specific phase of chloride salt corrosion, although some work on this prdblem has .been reported in recent periodicals and press releases. These reports have apparently been based on opinion and visual field surveys, lacking (1) (2) (5) (16) in quantitative support. . However, considerable data may be feund on the corrosive properties of refrigerating brines and sea waterSS) Speller(7)gives an excellent bibliography on the general subject of corrosion. This investigation concerns the feasibility of reducing the corrosion of automobile bodies by the addition of corrosion inhibitors to the chloride salts used on streets and highways. Since a thorough study of the complete problem of automobile body corrosion would require a very extensive investigation, the scope of this work has been limited to a laboratory study of the corrosiveness of sodium _. _._...‘ ....o. .. - .. x . 3%-. or I ”on. . \_ . I. ~ . .H. 3......“ ..... _. . 5.9. . I; Q‘ff . . ..o.i .1 “ .uc-Wt . 4;.4. M too. a a C . .r .. x .. . . . . a . .w. w .. - — a . . .. a. .. t. ' “a l. \c .l D . 4 ‘ .‘th . I w . I J. t .‘ IV .5 J b..~.w.s 9 , i . 4. ... / r «alt t4 5. 3 o . a _. .. 3.! . Va. 4. L O euu\ . .. - .n . xix .. a. _. \\ r. .. RN. k... . u. b 0‘ H .. . .. . . . n) s; . _ :94.’ I. . . . \.\.. I o .5 Iv. . \.r _ A ‘ V . .._.. . .. and calcium chloride salts and of the effects of various corrosion inhibitors. FACTORS AFFECTING 0012303191 Generally, corrosive action is similar to the action occurring in a galvanic cell. Just as the galvanic cell has positive and negative terminals, so a sheet of metal has positive and negative areas. There may be a great many of these oppositely charged areas on a single sheet of metal. These areas are caused by internal stresses, heterogeneity, ruptures in a protective coating, and many other factors. Corrosion takes place when metal dissolves at the positive area, or anode. The corrosion products are generally depos- ited on the negative area, or cathodef7)(8) These corrosion products form a film over the negative region, isolating the metal and thus retarding corrosion. Excellent examples of the formation of very thin, dense and adherent films of corrosion products over the metal surfaces are afforded by stainless steel, chromium, and aluminums Corrosion continues when this film is mechanically or chemically broken. In the case of chromium, aluminum, or stainless steel, film destruction is very difficult. Other metals, such.as iron and steel, form.filme of corrosion products which are easily removed or broken, thus allowing corrosion to continue. Many agents such.as oxygen, abrasive action, or the presence of certain chemicals accelerate the breakdown of the film of corrosion products. It is the function of corrosion inhibitors to form new or repair the old films on the surface of the metalsg) Inhibitors are classified as anodic or cathodic depending on whether they form a film.over the positive or negative areas of the metal. The isolation of the metal -5- from the corroding medium is essential if corrosion is to be pre- vented. Consideration of the prdblem of automobile body corrosion indi- cates that the following factors are involved. 1. 2. 5. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. A.corrosive brine is formed as a result of the use of sodium and calcium chlorides on roads for dust palliation and ice control. Rain and other forms of precipitation, in the absence of chloride salts, cause corrosion. In industrial areas sulfur dioxide-laden rain and moisture contribute to active corrosion. In the case of rock salt, crystal growth.by evaporation may mechanically loosen the protective paint coating. Calcium chloride leads to corrosion by holding moisture in cracks and crevices. .Accumulation of water, with.or without dissolved chloride salts, in hollow body members such as doors, door posts, and running boards likewise contributes to the corrosion picture. Abrasive action of sand and pebbles thrown against the body breaks paint coatings and films of corrosion products. Soil and other foreign matter, comprising the mud that exists underneath an automObile, materially affects the character of the corrosion. ‘The changes in metal thickness and the stresses set up in the metal by deep-drawing Operations contribute largely to localized corrosion failures. -4- The above factors Will, directly or indirectly, affect either the actual dissolving of the automobile steel and the continual des- truction of the protective film of corrosion products. In this paper, only the first of these factors will be considered. CO G The investigation was divided into two major parts. First, an examination of several inhibitors was undertaken. This was done to determine which inhibitors might be effective in reducing the corro- siveness of the chloride salts. The second part of the investigation consisted of a comparison of the corrosive effects of distilled water, sodium chloride, and calcium chloride. Its purpose was to learn whe- ther or not the chloride salts were more corrosive than rain or ground water. Throughout the investigation, the chloride concentrations are given in weight-per cent based on the weight of water in solution. The inhibitor (or inhibitor mixture) concentrations are in weight— per cent based on the weight of total chloride salts in solution. The various components of the inhibitor mixtures are given in parts by weight, with.the entire mixture taken as 100 parts. In all cases, except-the elimination study, triplicate samples were tested. bi ‘ St In studying the effects of the various inhibitors, eleven series of tests were conducted. The test periods were two weeks initially, but were increased to four weeks later on. Room temperature (75° F.’ was maintained throughout the inhibitor tests. -5- Series 1 was an elimination test of several inhibitors and inhibitor mixtures conducted on single samples. The inhibitors were used in concentrations of 0.5 per cent. The corrosive solution was a 5 per cent calcium chloride brine, saturated with oxygen by a con- tinuous flow of air bubbles. Series 2, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 12 were confined to a study of chromate inhibitors. Samples were continuously aerated throughout the test. In series 2 the effect of various organic additives on the inhibitive efficiency of sodium chromate in a 5 per cent calcium chloride brine was studied. Series 5 compared the inhibitive prop— erties of sodium chromate and sodium dichromate at various concen- trations in a 5 per cent rock salt (NaCl) brine. The effects of hydroquinone on sodium dichromate and of quinone and quinhydrone on sodium chromate in a 5 per cent calcium.chloride brine were examined in series 10. In series 6 the Optimum sodium chromate-hydroquinone ratio was determined.by varying the proportions ofeach at a constant concentration of inhibitor mixture. This was done in a 5 per cent and a 20 per cent calcium chloride solution. An effert to ascertain the minimum effective inhibitor concentration was made in series 11, by using various concentrations of a fixed sodium.chromate—hydroqui- none mixture in a 5 per cent calcium chloride brine. Series 12 was identical to series 11, except that sodium chromate alone was used. In series 4 the effect of road soilcnzinhibition efficiency was studied. ‘A mud consisting of road soil passing a 50-mesh sieve and {a saturated calcium chloride brine was made up to simulate a graveled road immediately after a chloride application. Weighed metal plates -5- were immersed in the mud for eight hours and exposed to the air for sixteen hours over a period of twentyaeight days. The plates were cleaned and weighed once each week according to the procedure des- cribed in Appendix.B, and returned to the test. This was done at room temperature with.brines containing varying amounts of sodium chromate as an inhibitor. In series 7 several phosphate inhibitors were tested at a l per cent concentration in a 5 per cent calcium chloride brine and a 5 per cent rock salt (NaCl) brine. The metal plates were alternately im- mersed in the brine and exposed to the air. This test was repeated in series 8, except that the metal plates were continuously immersed in aerated brines. These two tests were performed in order to compare > the continuous aeration and alternate immersion types of tests. In series 9 several other phosphate inhibitors were tested at 0.5 per cent concentrations in both.a 5 per cent rock salt brine and a 5 per cent calcium chloride brine. Study 9; the Corrgsive Media In this study, the influence of temperature, aeration, and agitation on the corrosive effects of distilled water, sodium chloride, and calcium chloride was investigated. Brines of various concentra- tions were used, ranging from distilled water to a saturated brine for both calcium chloride and rock salt. Series 5, l4, and 15 were all continuously aerated tests. Series 5 and 15 were run at 75° F. and were identical, except that series 15 included rock salt solutions. Series 14 was the same as series 15, except that it was conducted at a temperature of 55° F. -7- Series 15 and 16 were conducted under conditions of limited ac- cess to air by placing the specimens in sealed jars. The brines were prepared with distilled water that had been freshly boiled. The two tests were the same, except that series 15 was conducted at 55° F., while series 14 was run at 75° F. The detailed procedure for all of these tests may be found in pp. 75-79 of Appendix:B. Series 1, 2, 5, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, ll, 12, 14, and 15 were conducted according to cycle 1; series 7 according to cycle 2; and series 15 and 16 according to cycle 5. Series 4 was performed as previously stated. Data summaries and photographs are located in pp. 55-75 of Appendix A. All original data is included in pp. 85-109 of .Appendix B. DISCUSSION OF RESULTS The chief factors affecting the results of all these tests seemed to be temperature and aeration. The temperature variations were within : 5° F. and did not appear to introduce any appreciable errors. The control of aeration, however, was not completely satisfactory. .According to Speller(7)the supply of oxygen to the metal surface is influenced.by the solubility of oxygen in the solution, the physical distribution of oxygen throughout the solution, and the rate of diffur sion of oxygen across the liquid film at the metal-liquid interface. Since the degree of aeration affects all of these factors, and since oxygen is essential for ordinary cases of corrosion, it can easily be seen that aeration is a critical factor. In concentrated brines and in the presence of an effective inhibitor, i.e. at low rates of corro- sion, no appreciable variations were noticed. However, in dilute brines, i.e. at high rates of corrosion considerable uncertainty was -8- observed. At these high corrosion rates, the supply of oxygen to the metal was apparently the controlling factor, rather than the nature cf the solution itself.(10) Although it is well recognized that pH and its proper control exert considerable influence on corrosion, it was deemed unnecessary to control pH in these tests. The reason for this decision was the apparent impracticability of controlling pH over miles of road surface under widely varied conditions. For this reason, it was decided that an inhibitor should be effective without any particular attempt at pH regulation. The pH of some of the solutions was, however, checked with a Beckman pH meter at intervals throughout the tests, pp. 87-109, Appendix B. The only significant trend noticed was a general decrease in pH as corrosion progressed. The higher rates of corrosion also appeared to be accompanied by a larger pH drop for aerated solutions. The unaerated tests, however, sometimes exhibited an increase in pH. All data presented represent the average results of three samples. Chromate Inhibitorg The data of Table 1 and Figure 2 show that the corrosiveness of a 5 per cent sodium chloride brine was reduced considerably for a period of fourteen days by either sodium chromate or sodium dichro- mate. There appeared to be very little difference in the behavior of the two, although the chromate lost most of its effectiveness at low concentrations after about seven days. In series 4 an attempt was made to determine what effect soil particles would have on the effectiveness of inhibitors. This attempt was unsuccessful because the brine used was too highly *9“ concentrated to show any significant trend (Table 2). A later analysis of road slush showed that the actual concentration of chloride salts present did not exceed 2 per cent, pp. 82, Appendix B. This confirms the data reported. by Finney.(15) From Figure 5 and Table 5, it can be seen that sodium chromate alone was fairly effective in reducing the corrosiveness of a 5 per cent calcium chloride brine, losing its effectiveness after about fourteen days. The addition of small amounts of pyridine, sodium sali- cylate, formaldehyde, or sodium benzoate increased the effectiveness of the inhibitor only slightly. However, the addition of hydroquinone maintained the effectiveness for at least 21 days. The effect of quinone, hydroquinone, and quinhydrone on sodium chromate as an inhibitor is shown in Table 4 and Figure 4. They all appear to affect the inhibitive properties of sodium chromate in about the same manner. This would be expected in view of their chemical similarity. Sodium dichromate behaves in the same way in the presence of hydroquinone as does sodium chromate. xAn examination of Table 5 and Figure 5 reveals that, for a 5 per cent calcium chloride brine, increasing the hydroquinone-sodium chro— mate ratio resulted in a sharp drop in the corrosion rate down to a minimum, after which there was a comparatively gradual increase. The total concentration of inhibitor mixture was held at 0.5 per cent throughout the test. The optimum proportions of sodium chromate and hydroquinone appeared to be in the range of 80 per cent chromate-20 per cent hydroquinone to 90 per cent chromate—10 per cent hydroquinone. However, for a.20 per cent calcium chloride brine, there appeared to .be little advantage to the use of hydroquinone with sodium chromate. -10.. 700 L .00 / A U I o W \ LEGEND o 1 500 NO INHIBITOR V —————— 0.5 °/. SODIUM CHROMATE —-——I.0 °/. SODIUM CHROMATE z ------------ 2.0 °/. SODIUM CHROMATE O —-«-—o.5 °/. SODIUM DICHROMATE a ‘00 ——I.O °/. SODIUM DICHROMATE O —--—2.0 °/o SODIUM DICHROMATE Ir. I: 0 U 300 C UMULATIVE 200 / IOO 2| 28 AERATED a AGITATED AT 75°F. SERIES NO. 3 _ ‘_ E _._———.———- COMPARISON 0 Na, rO 0262/ NdCrzO ea CORROSION I HIBITORS fa: ROCK SALT IO GAUGE SAE ‘IOOB SHEET STEEL IN A 5'/o ROCK SALT BRINE Figure 2 -11- /;—NO INHIBITOR .00 ,5- . 3 500 1 \ n 5 I O IOO'IO SODIUM CHROMATE —} z 400 .’ ° / n C o . / a: / 95% SODIUM CHROMATE +2 I t 300 5'/o FORMALDEHYDE ——'\ o 5% PYRIOINE ° 5% SODIUM SALYCILATE U S'lo SODIUM BENZOATE . 5% HYDROQUINONE 3 200 . h . < J 3 5 Io "’1 3 0 ./ ° /' _ / -- / 7 / . .3 . ,4» g4»? :. — .‘f”"—” o o 1 I4 2s AERATED I. AGITATEO AT 7S’F SERIES NO. 2 :75. EFFECT 42/ ORGANIC ADDITIVRS m SODIUM CHROMATE 4.4 a. CORROSION INHIBITOR I9 GAUGE SAE'IOOO SHEET STEEL IN A 590 Cam; BRINE, COMENTRATION OF INHIBITOR MIXTURE ‘O.S°/o OF THE WEIGHT OF TOTAL CHLORIOES Figure 5 -12- O [—NO INHIBITOR an. 600 f‘ x 1 \ . " I 3 ; V iwloo °/o SODIUM CHROMATE * ' z 400 o l "’ I O I) I: 300 I O O I :’ 95% SODIUM OICHROMATE +: 1, 95% SODIUM CHROMATE +2 - 20° #5ch HYDROQUINONE : 55:?) 339333;;2222—1 O 2 :- svo QUINONE -I .1 3 2 3 I00 U IX’.’ 0 I..." “2 I" o as T I M E C D A Y s ) AERATED a AOITATE’D AT 75°F * SERIESZ— *SERIESIO EFFECT 42/ ORGANIC ADDITIVES ma + CHROMATE CORROSION INHIBITORS I9 GAUGE SAEMOQ SHEET STEEL IN A 5°/o CoCII- Mac '1. BRINE , CONCENTRATION OF INHIBITOR MIXTURE :O.5°/o OF THE WEIGHT OF TOTAL CHLORIDES H Figure 4 -13- so A \ ° : Ia \ 0 5° \ LEGEND "\ \ 3 A \ -- 59° CACI: BRINE -' \ ——ZO‘/e cw, same 2. x 9 40 U P < C so 2 O n O C C O u 20 .J J < C U Io > O O 96 53‘.th O 20 , 40 so so I00 ‘5 C6460"). IOO so so 40 20 o AERATEO I. AGITATEO AT 75°F SERIES No.6 519245 0‘ SODIUM CH ROM ATE -HYDROQUINONE MIXTURES U22 OVERALL CORROSION RATE - I9 GAUG'E' SAE .IIOO, SHEET STEEL,CONCENTRATION OF INHIBITOR MIXTURE =0.5‘/o OF THE WT. OF TOTAL CI-LGRIDES k ¥ l 013‘ Figure 5 -14- [III I] I00 90 SO \ \ .—-OO '15 SODIUM CHROMATE 4- IO ./0 HYDROQUINONE - SERIES II 70 \ OO n ). < a \ N 3 o x o 3 0s\ 33 \\ < I: 3 SO 3 \ o \ 5 4o \ O E ° \ .1 \c—IOO 'le SODIUM CHROMATE-SERIES I2 .I < 1 I 30 v “ \ 3' O \\ 20 \i I: - Pkf___i__f O I INHIBITOR CONCENTRATION (WT. PER CENT OF TOTAL. CHLORIOES) AERATED 8- AGITATEO AT 75‘F. ffjc'cz‘u OI: INHIBITOR CONCENTRATION ER-ALL CORROSION RATE I9 GAUGE SAE “IOOO SHEET STEEL IN A 5‘16 C.CI1 BRINE Figure 6 ~15- In series 11 and 12 it was desired to learn at what concentration the sodium chromate was most effective, and what influence the addition Of hydroquinone exerted on this concentration. Tables 6, 7, and Figure 6 show the minimum effective concentration to be about 1.5 per cent of the weight of the total chloride salts in solution, whether or not hydroqui- none was present. In fact, the curves indicate that the presence of small amounts of hydroquinone has practically no effect on the inhibitive properties of sodium chromate. Although these results were not in agree- ment with thoseof Figures 4, 5, and 6 time limitations did not permit a duplication of the tests. In spite Of the lack Of agreement with the previous data, some interesting information can be obtained from series 11 and 12. An examination Of Figures 15 and 14 reveals that at low inhibitor concen- trations, the corrosion appears to be rather evenly distributed over the surface of the metal as evidenced by the even coating of light red rust. IAs the inhibitor concentration is increased, the appearance Of large uncorroded areas can be noticed, accompanied by rather hard, dark red blisters over the corroded regions. This type Of corrosion is known as pitting corrosion. It can also be noticed that areas which were once pitted and then cleaned during the weekly cleaning and weighing were not necessarily sUbJect to continued attack on being reimmersed in solution. 0n the contrary these areas often appear to be completely protected. This can probably be explained on the basis Of a change in polarity of the pitted areas. It is now widely accepted that rust ordinarily forms by electrochemical loss Of metal at an anodic region, the corrosion products being deposited at the cathode.(ll) For this reason, it would -15- seem that the once-pitted areas had, after cleaning, becomeccathodic relative tO certain other areas on the metal surface. It will also be noted that pitting appeared at about the same inhibitor concentration, see Figure 6, at which the corrosion rate became relatively constant.' In the light of this fact and the pitting exhibited by the photographs, it can be seen that althOugh the rate of corrosion has decreased, the area actually subjected to corrosion has decreased also. This indicates that the corrosion taking place under the blisters is probably more rapid than the data lead one to believeElZ) This indicates that the metal may actually corrode completely through I in a much shorter time over a small area under pitting conditions than under conditions Of overall corrosion.(9) According to Hoar and Evansflz) pitting diminishes and finally ceases as the chromate concentration increases. IAlthough some of the preceding data regarding hydroquinone as an additive to sodium chromate are contradictory, there is a strong indi- cation that hydroquinone may have some beneficial effect. ‘The opinion of some authors is that the chromates could not be expected to main- tain their effectiveness as inhibitors in the presence of easily oxidized material.(l4)(15) It would seem that these statements were based on the fact that the chromates, being oxidizing agents, would be reduced in the presence of easily oxidizable material. The results of these tests show, however, that the chromates maintained their effectiveness whether or not hydroquinone was present. Moreover, the effectiveness of the chromates was, in some cases, actually increased. -17- IAcceptance of the fact that the chromates would be reduced by easily oxidizable material, such as hydroquinone, merely leads to speculation as to the effect Of chromous ion as a corrosion inhibitor. Generally, these data show that there may be some merit to the addition Of hydroquinone to sodium chromate for corrosion inhibition, although this is not conclusive. Pitting conditions persist at chromate concentrations of 5 per cent Of the weight of dissolved chloride salts, even though the data indicates marked leveling Off in corrosion rate at about 1.5 per cent. Phpgphate Inhibitors In studying the phosphate inhibitors, the tests were performed with.a twofold purpose: First, to evaluate certain commercial glassy sodium phosphates for use in reducing the corrosiveness of sodium chloride and calcium chloride brines. Second, to compare the aerated method of test to the alternate immersion method being used by some phosphate manufacturers. Three proprietary products were studied primarily and used as a guide in evaluating the other phosphates. These products may be identified as follows: 1. - Micromet - A slightly soluble complex sodium-calcium hexametaphosphate used for rust prevention in household water systems. 2. - Calgon - Sodium hexametaphosphate, containing about 67 per cent P205, used extensively for feed water treatment. 5. - Banox - Reported to be a mixture of Calgon and calcium chloride, it is used as a corrosion inhibitor for surface treatment of steel prior to painting and for addition to -18- IcOO fl I400 / f 3 / \ L E G E N D W ’ {'Izoo NO INHIBITOR / IA” " ' —--— Iv. MICROMET ’/ ”””” l./o CALGON I z / —'— './. BANOX I 2 I000 / ,A’ J o / I, O I [I I! / A’ I 0 “ BOO “AMA '4 1 o z u // II / I .I ’ -<> § \ \\ \ \ CUMULATIVE ‘ 3 \ \ \ .I‘\ I\ \ \ \ \ \\ I ’/ zoo ’ I .' I /.* 7 T I M E AERATION a AGITATION AT 75°F SERIES NO.8 EFFECT a/ GLASSY PHOSPHATES ad CORROSION INHIBITORS [,2 5% C.CI -M,CI BRINE Io GAUGE SAE ‘IOOS SHEET STEEI. \ Figure 7 -19- I 600 I400 % :2 / \ L E G E N D W I AL {I200 N0 INHIBITOR / I " —-— I‘lo MICROMET ll ——-- Iv. GALGON /’ z —-— l'/ BANOx , ° . L / ’ j - IOOO I; .- o'I / I / o , / I 3 Z J’ ’ U “ BOO ______ 1 O // I / U I ’ i . I ’ 0 fl ” / I 600 F— ’, CUMULATIVE 2| 26 AERATION a. AGITATION AT 75°F SERIES No.8 EFFECT a/ GLASSY FHOSPHATES M CORROSION INHIBITORS [,2 5% C.CI -M,CI BRINE Is GAUGE SAE ‘Iooe SHEET STEEL ¥ Figure 7 -19- 100 - coo a LEGEND \ 9 N0 INHIBITOR ------- w. GALGON z —-—w. MIGROMET O ” 400 O C K O U 300 In] > g... < 200 J D x a U I00 .I' l o "'"l 7 0 7 I4 2' 28 T I M E ‘ o A Y s ) SERIES NO. 7 BFFBCTufGLASSY FHOSFHATES as CORROSION INHIBITORS m 5% CaCIz- M,CIZBRINE ALTERNATE IMMERSION AT M, I9 GAUGE SAE'IOOO SIEET STEEL - I Figure 8 -20- SERIES No.8 EFFECT 47/ GLASSY FHOSPHATES ad CORROSION INHIBITORS 02 5% ROCK SALT BRINE IO GAUGE SAE'IOOO SHEET S Figure 9 -21.. 700 ,‘000 " T x LEGEND o \ O NO INHIBITOR > 1 500 --——--I% BANOx /4 - -------- w. CALGON ——~—deaIMGROMET Z O n 400 . O C (I: O U 300 ZOO CUMULATIVE IOO SERIES NO. 7 EFFECTuf CLASSY FHOSFHATES 44. CORROSION INHIBITORS m 5% ROCK SALT BRINE IO GAUGE SAE'IOOO SHEET STEEL,ALTERNATE IMMERSON AT 75" g ¥ Figure 10 -22- rock salt for use on highways. A glance at the data of Tables 8 and 9 and Figures 7 and 8 show that in concentrations of 1 per centIthe above-mentioned phosphates were ineffective in reducing the corrosiveness of calcium chloride brine. In sodium chloride, however, (see Figures 9 and 10) it is evident that the behavior of Micromet and Banox was about the same as in calcium chloride, while Calgon stood out as being very effective. The data Of Table 10 are in general agreement with the preceding data. HOwever, disodium phosphate and trisodium phosphate were ineffec- tive in rock salt brine. Nalco 519, a commerical sodium septaphosphate, deserves mention as being very effective with rock salt. The behavior of these inhibitors can probably be explained on the basis that the sodium hexametaphosphate prevalent in these materials forms a relatively insoluble calcium phosphate complex in calcium chloride. This would remove a large portion Of inhibitor from solution by precipitation before a sufficiently protective film could be formed on the metal surface. In the case of sodium chloride (rock salt) the basic reason would probably be the same, with.the calcium.ion being furnished by the inhibitors themselves (Micromet and Banox) on being dissolved, along with a small amount of calcium ion present in the rock salt as gypsum. The calcium present in the rock salt was apparently not sufficient to affect the inhibitive properties Of the plain sodium hexametaphosphate. The results of the alternate immersion test, series 7, and the sierated test, series 8, were in qualitative agreement with each other. Iiowever, the degree Of corrosion Obtained in the aerated test was much -25- higher than in the alternate immersion test. Apparently, then, the aerated test would be a more rapid means for laboratory evaluation of the properties of corrosion inhibitors. From these data it appears that the presence of considerable amounts of calcium ion relative to the amount of phosphate is undesir- able when the phosphate inhibitors are used. This is in general agree- ment with the work Of Hatch and Rice.(15) These data show that the phosphates are not suitable inhibitors for calcium chloride salts. However, Calgon and Nalco 519 show promise of being effective for sodium chloride. The continuously aerated test seemed to be more severe than the alternate immersiOn test, although their correlation was fairly good. All the inhibitors included in this study may be classified as anodic inhibitors. It is a characteristic of anodic inhibitors that they sometimes cause the pitting effects shown in Figures 15 and 1459) This would be especially true at the crevices and corners under an automObile body where access is difficult. It would, therefore, seem that use of these inhibitors, particularly in low concentrations involves a certain amount Of risk. If these data are plotted to show the cumulative loss in weight (corrosion) versus time, as in Figures 2, 5, 4, 7, 8, 9, and 10 the length of time any given inhibitor retains its effectiveness may be ascertained. As the inhibitor loses its efficiency, the slope Of the corrosion curve for the inhibited solution becomes steeper, until it is approximately parallel to the corrosion curve for the same uninhibited solution. In other words, the rate Of corrosion gradually increases -24- until it becomes about the same as that of an uninhibited solution. W In series 5, 15, 14, 15, and 16 an attempt was made to shed some light on the question as to whether solutions of chloride salts were more or less corrosive than water. This was deemed necessary in view of the volume of seemingly contradictory data to be found in the literature. Whitman, Russell, and Davis(l7)show that dilute solutions Of chloride salts are more corrosive than water, with a gradual de- crease in corrosion as the chloride salt content is increased. Spell— er(18)reports Richardson as showing distilled water less corrosive than a 10 per cent salt brine for six different irons in both the stag- nant and aerated alternate wetting and drying type tests at room temperature. Richardson also shows distilled water as being more corrosive than a 10 per cent salt brine for the same irons in both the stagnant and.aerated continuous immersion type tests at r00m.temperature. Friend and Marshall(19)indicate tap water as being only very slightly less corrosive than a 5 per cent NaCl solution for a three month conti- nuous immerSion test. Friend<20)later reports tap water as being more corrosive than a 5 per cent NaCl solution for three different steels in a one-year continuous immersion test at 50° F. Friend and.Brown(4) report that at about 15° C. dilute NaCl solutions and distilled water are about equally corrosive. .At temperatures above 15° C., dilute solutions of NaCl are more corrosive than distilled water, while at temperatures below 15° C. dilute NaCl solutions are less corrosive than distilled water. Corrosion gradually decreases for higher concen- trations at all temperatures. .25- I20 I00 I ' L E G E N D CaCI, 75" """ NaCl TSTF ---- NaCl JS'F - ‘ "' CLCI. 35°F (Maldwl DAY) CORROSION RAT E O S IO IS TOTAL CHLORIDE SALT CONCENTRATION (Wt-A) ' CONTINUOUSLY AERATED AND AGITATED SERIES I4 a I5 ‘ ‘ EFFECT u/TEMFERATURE wz t/zE CORROSIVENESS u/C.Ct_ ans/NaCl BRINES R—_‘_ _ _ (Mal JM'IOAY) CORROSION RATE .‘fi-II 0 5 IO IS 20 as 30 TOTAL CHLORIDE SALT CONCENTRATION (V1170), STAGNANT, LIMITED ACCESS To AIR SERIES ISSIO g 4 EFFECT ufTEMPBRATURE U72 1%; CORROSIVENESS (yam: and/NaCl BRINES Figure 12 -27- The results Of series 5, l5, 14, 15, and 16 given in Tables ll and 12 contain some Of the above-mentioned discrepancies. In these tests it is believed that the variations were due to difficulty in control of the rate of aeration. However, the general trends shown in Figures lland 12 are fairly well indicated. The results Of the aerated tests, Figure 11, exhibit the same trends as those Of Whitman, Russell, and Davis,(l7) and of Friend and.Brown for temperatures below 15° C. However, the relation between the corrosiveness of dilute salt solutions and water did not reverse with change in temperature as reported by Friend and Brown, even though the temperatures used were in the same range. The results of the unaerated tests, Figure 12, follow the pattern of Friend and Brown at temperatures above 15° C. The overall corrosion rate of series 5, Table 11, follows the same pattern as does Figure 11 for Ca012 at 75° F. However, the weekly rates show considerable variation for dilute solutions. The character of the corrosion which took place in series 15, 14, 15, and 16 is illustrated in the photographs Of Figures 15, l6, l7, and 18. There were two distinct layers of corrosion products formed on the surface of the metal. The outer layer consisted of a hydrated ferric oxide mixture varying in color from an orange-red for distilled water and dilute brines to a redébrown fer the more concentrated solu- tions. The darker colored products seemed to adhere to the metal more firmly than did the light colored scale. A.dark blue-black layer of ferrous oxides and hydroxides was found underneath the outer layer. This dark layer was particularly noticeable in series 15 and 16 where the air supply was limited, indica- ting insufficient oxygen to convert the ferrous products to the ferric -23- state. Plates 1a, 1b, 10 of series 14 for distilled water exhibited very little corrosion as may be seen in Figure 15—1. However, these plates seemed to have a rather peculiar yellow—green film over the surface at conclusion of the tests. This film was not present in the other dis- tilled water tests. For this reason, the results Of plates 1a, lb, and 1c were discarded.and the results of plates 6a, 6b, 6c substituted. The results of the unaerated series 15 and 16, Figure 12, show distilled water at 55° F. to be more corrosive than any concentration of either NaCl or Ca012 at the same temperature. However, at 75° F. dilute CaClz solutions appear to be more corrosive than distilled water, while NaCl exhibits the same characteristics as at 55° F. The increase in corrosion by the dilute CaCl2 over that for distilled water was about 25 per cent. The corrosion rates shown here appear to follow very closely the same pattern as the oxygen solubility curves for solutions Of various salts given by Speller.(21) Increasing the temperature from 55 to 75° F. did not appear to affect the corrosiveness Of NaCl appreciably. Figure 11, series 14 and 15, shows that at 55° F. dilute solutions Of both.NaCl and Ca012 increase corrosion over that for distilled water by about 20 per cent. At 75° F. dilute NaCl solutions continue to be more corrosive than distilled water. However, the behavior of dilute CaC12 solutions at 75° F. is not understood. Increasing the temperature from 55 to 75° F. resulted in a marked increase in corrosion for all but the most concentrated solutions. At 55° F. no concentration of either CaC12 or NaCl showed as much corro- sion as did distilled water at 75° F. .2 9... Furthermore, it can be seen that the corrosion rates are much higher at either temperature under conditions of aeration and agitation than under limited air supply and quiescent conditions. The combined effects of agitation and air supply produced a corrosion rate from 50 to 80 times greater than in their absence. Apparently the presence or absence Of oxygen at the metal surface is Of prime importance in the corrosion reactions taking place. Hewever, the mere presence or absence of oxygen does not explain the results shown in Figure 11. There appear to be several variables which contribute to the results shown and greatly complicate the situation. Speller shows that for water with free access to air corro- sion increases with temperature up to about 175° F. and then decreases with further increase in temperature.(22) This is eXplainable on the basis that oxygen solubility decreases as temperature increases. How- ever, the increase in temperature affects those factors which increase the transfer of the dissolved oxygen to the metal surface as follows: (1) The viscosity of the solution decreases, resulting in more effi- cient distribution of oxygen throughout the liquid. (2) The rate of diffusion of oxygen across the liquid film at the liquid-metal inter- face increases, thus carrying the oxygen to the metal faster. (5) The liquid film at the liquid-metal interface decreases in thickness,'thus decreasing the time required for diffusion. In addition to these factors, the c0rrosion reactions take place faster at the higher temp- eratures provided there is enough Oxygen present to permit the reactions to take place. It is, therefore, apparent that the corrosion will increase with increasing temperatures, until the factors tending to -30... increase corrosion can no longer compensate for the decrease in oxygen solubility. Beyond this point corrosion will decrease as Speller has demonstrated. It seems that these conditions would also be true for solutions of salts, with the additional condition that oxygen solubility decreases with increasing salt concentrations.(22) There should, therefore, be an inversion temperature similar to that for water in the case Of salt solutions. However, this temperature may be different for each concen- tration and type of salt. FUrther work certainly seems to be indicated on the effect of temperature on oxygen solubility in various concentra- tions of different salts, and on the corrosiveness Of these salt solutions. Generally, these data show that oxygen is of major importance in the corrosion reactions. Under identical ordinary conditions, dilute chloride salts were about 20 to 25 per cent more corrosive than dis— tilled water. However, distilled water at 75° F. was nearly twice as Corrosive as any chloride salt solution at 55° F. CONCLUSIONS Although these results must be interpreted cautiously until confirmed by tests under field conditions, the following conclusions may be made: 1. - In order for an inhibitor to be considered satisfactory, it must reduce corrosion without setting up pitting conditions; and it must do so at concentrations that are economically practical for highway usage. 2. - 0f the inhibitors studied, only three appear to merit further -51- consideration for use. The chromates should be considered for use in either sodium or calcium chloride, while Calgon and Nalco 519 should be considered for use in rock salt only. NO inhibitor should be used, however, unless it has been thoroughly tested, since it may actually increase the corrosion in localized areas by setting up pitting conditions rather than reducing the damage due to corrosion. 5. - Although there appears to be strong indications that hydro- 50" quinone, quinone, or quinhydrone may have some beneficial action on the effectiveness of the chromate inhibitors, this is not conclusive. Further work on this point is indicated, including study of the effect of chromous ion as an inhibitor. Under the same conditions, chloride salts are generally from 20 to 25 per cent more corrosive than distilled water. Hew— ever, distilled water is much more corrosive at ordinary spring and summer temperatures than any solution Of chloride salts is at ordinary winter temperatures. Chloride salts probably do not contribute nearly as much to the corrosion of automObile bodies as is popularly believed. 6. - Although the inhibitors tested may possibly reduce the corrosiveness of the chloride salts, inhibition of these salts cannot be justified on the basis of present information. -52- APPENDIX A 2h _54- l- - . , - .. ... -. a - A H - i ._ Lia: .L l- M , . I I I I ... I- n.5- oéon A can l -.S ... o..- .H I u L - - I I I I I . .. .- SAHI- 3.3-3. [weoMWImQS-wu- :8 novel r 4 ..u . -.- I I- 0.8 I Taco; 0.: ...-ad” .... o; . .. I I I .. I I I I a 8A,” 3833.53..- WIm-IxH-H-Iwadlmioo-LIH I Iw n .. u. L. - .-.. - mun-.3 “III-.63 . «.2 A. 042 H J. m6 . I . I..:.I.. II» n. I . 8a” rein: lax. H m was-5 :8 Nos- . m. - - I 4(- ...I..-- . To 7 «.3. m; , on“ H H o.~ .- I I I - .. .. I I I I. H ...-.2“ Mantis mus-eon. I.” ...m. ”2.55.: ion--.H- - -..: ---. ELM 0.8. To adv“ Hoduoau ..---...H8fi3IE-o8l58... mwGJ-ezuoflu fl a we .-n-+HWue-H--h-qt.h ea H.23 H.9m-M wk H ”as H--H .w-.-.-.n 8d.2l2:elss H mwssyzlisew M I v.0 +I.-I...;+- Hut: -IIIIYIII-III m.v affine I - «.o A TE” .....o.« M on“ IIIIIIII 03H. floral-8o.” mwnue-Vaae-zu H Icema- I. - - . . .. .. - - -..-....Iv- . - «II-3 .AIL-esaeuqu-sy“was-n I - “13 H - - - u - - - - - - - H 81- 3125 gr... II.- “ Mae..- .3 ...: . .. new» I o I I I I I I I I I I IImONlIIOUVWIT I-noa TI u.mnIIH I I - leé N I I . .I I I I I I I I .. 03” 5318.26 liven H m “Anus-V ans- 3 .. - A CIII r I It I h - t .. . . - . .. . - ...-o-.mr-flwINN-TIMINHARU....x LI...“ errand-h...“ swam-L- - ”we,“ 5.5.. an.“ .. . - - . . . . . I H- .. .- . - - . .. . I .- Mes-s5 .3 a: . . . . _ . jun- TWEIunwmgm-r uroVLBWQJJY uporrwodIamw- ares-elm... 5qu n mm nan-me. nezuzoe-awu cox-s- -Svuefms-zuzOce-OOJOWWWI «mm u a>._. (.55 mic s rte-SOC mic a axis 920-. ozouum Tie a. ewe-u. :65; . «mm zo-Emon-rou Imwu. ---II . Shoo LEIeonmIoE-B Isms-owed! I III-.....szf; I--- . IIIlhmDWHeI-emtm—erI - {Ice-...».Boe Somme-p e- > C ( 2 I D m ( ... ( o I n lawnnu Nam)!“ " - IININON 53m): U531 I H mama; . . -55- F» I I I I I I a 1 A a 1 fl . I . .. h # a o 4 II I. I c H o .IY F I. II I v I fl . o o c . o II II o I 9 II .I. I IItI ’ I I «IIIMI I...I ,9 [I'- l . W . Von ~ moi I beg . 1.5 M uoNO w hon w OIOH H N00 I f Hod I I. I .. V90 I I I . I I I I I I I I I . 8d I “fish's lag II I 8 I ”"0“: I HI-Cv . N .- n.— v . n . H V I In I v o I I I t! I. III “II“ ...II I - I 1 f “on H 90“ h meg . ‘OF . mono W COfl H NINA w “0° "0% I. I. '00 I U U I -I- l I I I I I ' I 8“ . alga '80. 90 8 9 ”H0: N08 I N T 0d - m o o . . I I I o . o .. . a u v o. 3” 9m «...-o 1. . TS H m4 k W: . «.o n.” . .. n6 . I I. I I I I. I I I I I . 8n . 3183.8 I58 rImm- So- I ScIu-II IIm.-._ m. h . ‘ o I . a O I. II 0 I a . I . OI o N 0: ~ I I ‘ ..c ,3. 05: 9a .23. . 5.0 4 do . «.0 ma . .. «0. II. IIIIIIInh.8~. ...-838...? I 8. a I 88 . u I o . I a o H 1 h I I .I O . I o o I II III”.— I IIINI III-... .I . It ll! .3 . to . «in . o.» _ «.2. __ a." . ta fl ”6 f o m I I a o . I I. I I I I I I I I I . 8“ I 3112.8 I58 I. I3 . own I 38 I. « ... - _ . «8 . 9m . 3.: . «.0 . tom + c6 M E. H «.o n.” _. .. m6 . I I. I I I I I I I I I . 8“ . 31-56 I58 I 8 «Sun I .38 u I o o o a o . _ - I I . . ..I I I - W a . M 3; ... H 2f H 3 H I... H ...... --H H a: 3.2.3....” 3” €7.35 i. o _ _ n.m H 3: .. 3.: H as M «.2 n; fl m4: H «.o _ a; H .I. «.0 I I” I I I I I I I I I H 02 Ioalahu I58 M 8 «.8»- I «.88 u H v o I. II . . o I 3 m N . o- «a . “.2 . mg: M a; I o.$ 3. M ...3 w o... 4 fin «6 I I I I I I I I I I I 8‘ 3.820 I58 8 3»- I «88 u n Q V v I ... | I. to o I I I II o I .I I I I._ r . . v I - + - I + -I I . . . . .. . . I I 0.0 I -12. . mISu H n4. . m.oc fl. «J H $3 . 1.“ ¢ «.3 I .- 1° . I I. I I I I I I I I I 03 . 3.0.3... -3 co . «down I «3‘0 - N I u 1 L y w h « v I . . . . .. . v N00 _ WONH MOMFH » Mos. » Nomo * Mo" “0'“ F MON v M00." I I. I I I I I I I I I U I I U - u U U u U I - I O C - I n 8 «do, - ““08 N n H ‘ a « . I .. I. u n u n . I“ 0.3! . ox...) . 1c 93.... .Iu \ I .810 :93: a ... I on M Enrarxol .lo\ 8. g I 1M. It ...) I. A) N V S I. «WWW “1 .Iquwx I .utuqaaaau. » at”. I u>.>33!u+ u.» ¢ - bus-Failau“ u» «a 32:38:“. Jumuwwd me.mppwa nkzuzoagu «02.! aroma. n»2uZO;IOU «Ow-(”I “mm m a > h MM M m MM 3ft)? m> m. ( I I D m ( Ir ( O N @493. nrn I I I I I I I 4 I .1 I--- T H. H I * w H . . I .. . .--I----I--; I I .I ..HI II I I fIIIIII- .I .I II.I I II. . II-.. I I A l- . I I. .CII I .I .III .0 I I . I o » II .. . . I L I II If IIII .v .. I A 3% I I I.” ...”-IIIH . MJnIfi egg-WItomo ..«2 fl 0.2 A mg? .- I m6 , I I H Inn-I IIu I I I , .8”. 32 .1058 I w- . Jun-I N88 _ a_ o IWI II - I IIII ‘‘‘‘‘ . III .-I I .. h . . .. -LjITIII-IIL. f! ; Imam“ I I I, I I I _ 06m 7 oésn o.$ 0.1.9 is .. m.§ . I “.0 + I I + .I I I I I I I I H-8HIJHn-1IJ8IMIM. T Info-III TH . a I , man 4 -I I IH I III :3? fi 0.“? f .3. L. 18 . o; 4 «.3 I I m6 H I I“ I I I I I I I I . 8H“ .20 .593 H u H «I83. «88 H -m- H o u u o I II - I II T I: Ié! I. .I II F O II II .. I , T - A a s I I. flu-II; 1... H I I J I-I.... I To; H??? v-1“, H .32. It 1n . a...“ I. I as; m I 8898.83 . mas: 3195-588 .. m I mace-4 macaw-I.“ ..-IM- f. IuII. p . I L II A I. I Y I , Y I - I. . I I - r. I; I .. .. H II méH. IIIH III Ton H 0.3“ I Hm I 12. m... Ton . I m... _. m , I883 IdeaH mm. 31.25 I58 I m I «831% a 4 c . «H Tm I I L I I I I 0.8 93“. Y 3. . 0..qu 4T 0.. LIQwfiIIi I... m6 4 m . 3.35.8. I53- . "Ia-I. .IowlfigI-III l3 1W m. «Ga-I «38 I- m ., -n: H u . .I H III -I f I I: , II I II III I I III IIIWIJTIL I I I . .II -I I . I , I I - II, II, I F I : y N II III!“ . A1 I HII Hmm I. - - -M..- - - Maw-IIOEWIIna.II».2.-§I-I-o.m ..YImfl H II” -3 HI m. I.--I I Iago. IwII .31....» I3. I m a a... «as . u T“ I I. I VI I I I I. I L I I I? III I II I. I . I III 0. 0 II h. A w 9.2-” IIIIuIHI I-III I}: .W “aw: Aflloél fiw-A: AT «.m-IUH «.2. In - a mo H w TI 353.38. “fima H- oil-ho In... w M H «So-Iran“. H g H I" + ML :5 3.. $3.303: .aoxoa Hint-03.. ...o I... 2 22. 3 u: a 3 . 3 a. I. ..3 ts. .2... A w mm N v s I. um: I u» . .. Iruziaazau up .2. 9:33.54 ”In: mum‘sgu : .fi-a_->.u.3!oaa.w.mwwud Mmm 3n“; 322.213 ‘02.: 30mm“ 3529.13 «023 m Iva-i u a > h _ mm m m mm . I- III - I . I I I II . III I - II. I - IIII IIIIIII I I I A I .233. mic p 1:58 9.20 s 3:: min: 0283. min K. Eur: 3 non 20:59.28 mom mm a w on Lr » I. PIG—U3 v “H. II I . IKIN III IIIIIIINIE. 3.... 3w IIII III-IIVMMIOIHIP3~I-zo._ImIouzou-Iwul K ( I I D m ( F < O m “Sam. ~57 nth I I I I H I I I I I I I .IIIIIII «I. I w 0. H H a . . I . I o o I‘ II IITI.II IITIIIII fiI- I.‘ I I . 9 w ._ o I 1 “Hm-mow}: .I.I 7.6 . 0&2. inn I méd I IIwHIIm + ....S H 84 .. c4. I 9; m . Bong—8.8? ma. 318.2..3 93o» I m . «3»... «Cam . m H H 3 , H _ I III . H . o I IdaquIHII a! .I Ida“ no: I ,mqon I: . nmom IHI no: H no." H «.H. I m6 m 33.33...th mm 3.92:8 533 I m . «S»: I «38. . n ... IH. . o— . noIN H .14.. H «.8 H 3.... H 9mm H m1... H 7: mad H 70 o4 m . 8933.3 ma 2.1856 I53 m . «Hou- I «38 n .. o 2 H mm.» H 2%. H “.3 H at... H m. an H &.H H 1%. H. S; H «.H. H I o.H m 332.3 mm_ 31.9.3 I53 m H «HouHHI «Hus . n I m 3 t w .0 r H .. o I I V . T 3.... H R: H 72 H 93 H «.9 mo.“ H 3.... ._ an; H 3H .. m6 m 332:3 ma . 31-56 .38... m . «S... I «38 n I c 2 34 Ht «mm. H “Hm 2.4% - . RH mH..H mar..-” on; H o; . o.“ m . 1835 mm . 339:8 .38» m «How- I N n .. oH WWII......4-IWochIIIsIHfiIo-H4II9. ... ..II I06“ I an."- I._ . n. R I 3.... H .1: H I o." . m . 88:5 mo . 3.8.20 533 m «Hon: I «86 n H ... 2 H «finifIaJIII 5.8+ mH. n-I- H. R H 3% H 3% H a; H H.HH .. “.0 m 32:3 mm . 3.8.5 52.8 m Hrs. I «8.0 H ...- 2 H w u H I a .. .. u u . I. I. H 0 I3 3 QM! .loxgl o as: in x a ask-:95: a n . ...... _ in var}...- .aa\ a! 330 K I, ADI. I a. y; . % .IO M. V S I. in? ca .. anxm c. 15:533.? 3%”... unfinJESUH . at: $52533 a»: 522333 ixuwwu “Mm 30mg Cruanon «02.! 3pm.. rzuzo..:ou «9,4: 9 mm m a > » mm M M. NH III . Ina: 1.5 I w- «I I.I. (-53 9.20 “III-:30“ 980 s 01:: alas OZOUUm n> c ( I I D m ( ..r ( o Iv ”ma-93. 2n H H IH H!!! w! _ III II! III .III - II! II! I! | !t !! III! III! I III! LT!I-I I - .I .I I T 3+ I II IIII III 11 - I I I II! 4.; ---H H - W. -H- -H-.--I- L- -- - III-LI A IIIII iv I!.I| I! I? I!!! Y !!I I7 ill -I H III II 1.! II!!! !| .fIl I? + H r H II I - .. -I--LII! H-IIIIHMMI-H. II --.I -II - - - I I I . I I- I I II I. W lI-IIHHIII .II II I. + -» I . . . H I!-II-!. It I II I. - I I . I IIIH II II I I I A H H H .- I. I I. I I . . .I III III H. H VI! II! I! If I. I A. I Ha I A I . I I. II .o . H III! II! HHH I H I I q H M x H II Ill-1r I II I! H A . H ... 8 I. o . H to .7 III! I- - - . . . - h H H I - _.I II.- .. .. . H .. II. i 1 . I. «an L 3m 33 «.3 3:: «Am 04% a. “an I .. u... . 81 8833.3. H . .. 8 «a! .88 lngI 3| T g damn I. - Cong I "com 0063 It com? -.-Oom-.nn .. I moo I a H 5.0.6, H3 H 3‘55 '3 HH ON ’0’ I ”undo III. I- v I IH-III - I . 1 .. o , H H. o :08 I- . I131- .Imfi- I 0.3: 3“ 0.3. “.3 H a...“ . an .. ...“...- - mo H 2 k ...-1.23. H8 H-331“... HI. 2H .8... h .H : - - I ..-! ..IIII- -..... I .- .. .I.. - - . 3 N - INK ----cI&LHI-I~.w~-II oIXoL. Iain-.II-HTIoII? H - «Imm- H 25 ..- “a L 98 .I I m... H om -. grakHomIH -3135]: H. 2H «So-m 88- _ TIII -IIII.II I I -. - . . I I . H ... . mu. .--dfil!dflI-I3fi-LT 31.1 I.“ 73 H. 7:. ... can I I -m-a II: . I ...-.93.... .a H- slag In... I 8V .8».-. .88 . - . I !. -I.! - ..-! - I . I - I . H -- I .- .III . .I--I! -I _ - TII - --.-I H. - I 3 Non «.3 oIIu v.3 -rII-«o-NI I-flI-o-o-mIol-IJIUI 1h HII ~39 .- .. “Io H -3 . 3 H8 H - 3.0.30 '3 H.- o.~ HIdaoul quucw I INH- III! -! III I I II _-II I I -I. _I I a I a.“ 3 1914!} ,-!To..n1 IH-c-JIIIfi-Ifiwdllal14.4.2., I II M 3 LI 2 . - Iéw 8- 7.31.85 lac-III.- .I--SIN}; 88 . .....Id . II- I. III IIIIIIII -I. II-IIII-S II - I - I. I. I1 -- .I I..- - II 4? I Av IAIN 1 «I.» .3!!an 3 H 31.--de .. 3m- ? 5. LINN"... I I I ma . w ._ Ilia-.5 .1HIUluaida-T12IHGR .88 H 1.. .I.. 1|!!!IIIIIII ...I I :III'II !! I I I I I . - I . -I 3 II... b I o I! II II I III-I! I4 § III ti .7! Iv 5°.” “III I... “.2. LIE-II 3.!!44. ..I can. -.H in H was . I m... H I H .2 -...gi ...-«H «an... Jaw-I 1.. TI! III-III.- -! -II.. II. II . I I I; I! -I-IT I I .. I. . . I I I I M J I. IllddmmrlHll-QINWIIJ-glw dam“ 6184” f 00““ 6&0: law's OoVNQM -I .I. “.0- H 8H . gun-g, Hill . Ill-ill HIIIIIIIHIII Hog «undo kw n a m H 0! ! II!L l...- A I I: 69- I .69 I|#.I | | I .. - T . I !$. . .- Y)!!! 15.. «.1 ...-83 “an .. aqua 92. 0.81.! “SI-H aqua... I I m... H om HII luau-8k 3 . Blobs la... I m .8.- cSco H n H a In I .. x o H I I.- - 4 .. IIIILI-In H IHI o IlaIIfilII-fljqaaIIIddn! . .Iwéflllafin H 13 H 78 I I mo H 2. H gnaw HIIonIJ 3.8.3» In... IHI In - H H I «4.1 1% 4.3 Ind-GIL! ~41 Ian... H. 10 H m.# .I. m6 H on H 8.5.69.1.- on 31556.3...- H. n - H.Im..I-Io.l+!o.-I- II! I! .I.. III! II- I I - I“!- III - . II: I .I u I .III-I I I «In—.JTIAISI- IwJflII I «In 1...: «In “I“! II.-....w..M..wI-fiII--ve.om I -- - .I - IIMIPWR- ...-.- 318213 “Io-H..- I_I Han-Juno In... I m. IISum wan-m. ITln- .fi IMI H - IN! Tl III! III LVI I II Ibo I”. Y -. 9 III f I... 4: h I + H. Y Ill III...» flu- H -w&o L, w: - H 0.? . “III-UNIX I I H1... . oi" I I m6 H on . rung IH8 H Bloke Illa-8 .- m H «Sn- ags.- .T n H c- I a; o: d... I -15 w.“ -3.“ .I--Mum!- e.3 !-w-..¢.I! NINWIIMIHIII “aIII Main-I Hrflrwm-IromIH Swim-mafia m H rowmI muchHIInIIHI ImI MI ! . _I ! I I.I|IIII! -I-! - H: II - I I IIquqIIJJW 0.5. o. a... 18 oé SIM I I I-w..oIH m- H w“ 31.2831. w w. H can. Imago H n H ..u. IP- I . - .I It. I I III ? - r U H _. Ill chum «Inc-o! o. “é: .I.“...me-IWIMJIMILW-IéfloH-MW + II-wmaIIn-I-IIo-IIWHI-IM I ---Wm H II . IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ..... III-HR: 3HI.I.I-..m.-l.ao l-m... w» maH anom- - «Memo-I I. n I; .IMI: FNuu >323: phat-ox“. ...-om“.- - 399.32. .30on >¢£Qoa can: 2. pat-22H .I.: I. 33...: N up Wu, H «5.8.230 (08.! _ >0 9:520:30 (03:: % "WH M M N Mr... 9:: a»... .5333. :3. 9:15.59 up: 35533 are. .5453w .1qu . mmw «#1st 3.2L !- .nun ua>h m _nn. IL 42-5.6 925 s 1230.. mic - oEx» mics 0208... v.55 .- Sac 59°; _I um MMfiI I I : zetmoaIdou WMwfl H n . mm mm .304 #23 20305.0.» uo< 45:2. ! ”#3522 «050.12. I. ZOE-30m uE_ > C ( 1 1 D 0 ( Ir ( O !!||IIIII!! 2 m «.33 , II-I.‘ ~-59- D.“ x a < A 4 I a 4 1‘ 4 .1 4 .. III - I e + I 0 I .- L I I . .. I II I- I EIII IIIIIILII. I. I 04 H 1qu m0... IINJA .88. 0.0 47-0.3 4 m.0 0.? I I o.« S . 8833f 31.25.5250,... .mI adv: nifimqo “I fl ,J. 3 I- I. . II -.- . L f I I A . 4 . IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII .IIIIIII. - IIIII .. T .I: II M... II «.1WINQWMi I»... .. fi «.03 U. “é - Lfi 0.50 «.0 I «A. H I m... L 2 . .83....qu 8 H 3-856 5:3... .1. m H «80: «..IuaIIw n J 0 3 III NIolhII +.HI|WIol¢I LTIHIOIQgIIIMILvTIIMHWM .ILfi IOHIQOIHIIII. “Mot I .Lfi hog UT “.0 II LII 19$ IL. I t Goa;LVM .qu I I I aongmhvhm 4 Gaol . :3ng 1.3 ... I W I980. I «.840 . M 1 IIW HIIj II .I II. III I t .. I I .III ..II - II I I II .I. III IIIIIIIII IllIllIW'I .. III. . vllll.s|||+" IIIIII II ..II. IIIAVIII I IILVI! Y'. IIIII: III I .v I .Y I oil I to 6 o I I III III‘ II I 9!} IL? IIIIIII 0 III . ., I T I . «.0 a.“ . ...: 40 04.. «.amaA .2 # 0.2. «.0 I, 0.? I I m; M 2 . 889ng 8 , 3.8.8 I508 .. mI Io»..- NSJI I. n. r 0H 3 I ..LIJIIT I... .I. .I.... .53 .I.. .IIfiIIquIIMIIIIIHIWFH 2-.“ 3230+ .....a .....mIII i .....Iwfit Ir LII HIP .190 NA: .334 13 .133 1% o 4: 0.3 W404 S III IIBoafiI §~ III-«.5331? II r3 0‘?”on I d N :I III ILWIIIIII II a! I on o I o . H. , a .I o... I [0.81: 0.8%. I1j|dafiq 0.0m ofiIII : S . I I 8338.0... + 90 ,I 3.186.103 .. m H «So..- «88 . n I a w 3. wHIII II II lIwIIIIIIIIHIIII IIAwI I In? III- 74.. I jIIIIhIIIuI I I ..I | I ...IIIL.II.3+ I JIIIIIIII I I :II,» -I m3? IIIEII II flaw...) I I IN ; .I » NV;IIIusI.IIIq. .3992. Sofas... .332. 5:532. .32 a 53:20.. .232. .3303... 1.30.. Snub). % o" n uzoszou 02 L n 520.. cu 9.1.530 L N N3 at... a... .2532...” u:- Vgcggu u:- chsgo u:- 725.5331 .35... mmw 3mm... FRI .. ... I02“... .— .. x (J mmm mm)... mm mm“ mm j......26 920 .. IEDOL 0.20 5 9:5 020.. 028.0 050 5 5...: 2mm; Mwflv 20:58:90 mwu mm mm; nu » J V . I III I I I I IIIIIII J'IKIIII L I .000. :3 20.0928 uo< I .222. “.3522 «02913 I 29.2300 mamogou qu an. > a ( 1 I D m ( h < o w ”39:. -40- I. . .I- H .fl .- H J I I. I: cum. IrIlIou-fil Imamfl I MAI, 0 0.03 L fiq o.mfiIIIIIIH.I«Im III a. IITII TOA WWI-If”. IIHI-IIIII..- I034? 31.920 .533 NIH-UMIIIIINSMIIHIIM . L. flan-I HI H» ... 4.8. ... 3m. 3 ongIIIIeaiIIId IIWIIIIIIII..- .I.. ......I. ...-IIIIJ. IIHIIIIIIIII LI. 8..“ ......56 as... .3... I «a... II n I 0 LII: “I n.0-ILIIII0.nI. ..w.. ... ...“. ... 0.... .... .... III MMIm.mI+.-.IIHHI.ummmwmmmmImInmw.HImwmnIuwammumw.mI ...... fl I.....I IImmmmmIIIIInIIfiIIUmwawa I a.” oJI WEI-L2.-. 0 «6.2-; I0..Iv-IL-I0.Mm.IIIIIIoI...I.I ILI Ions-WI. --.IMIIMw Lib HIVHIILI-IIHIMIImSMIsgo DEW-MWJIINGR Wflmaen In J c MIMI J «ALfil- .... . ..in 1. IQIIIadIIISfi 1: 1.171 w ... I... Inn-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIM EM Isl-....IusILI- m .L. «Is... I. HAL InILrIIm Tm; [Inca alum c491. qalllalLlIaLlaaa 4mm mug—I I fidIIunIuHLJIIIIIIII-IIIIIIIIIIII 4T3". - if“ gflwawflw .III'NWIINIAIU Influflfiufiw We: 3% ...: ....I 3% II IIwu...IMIII-IIIIII HII-II I 3:, I...W£I..I§ .aLII .....L x... Mm... b... ..--....me “News“: ..wfiwas wrung“. Janna... Ego .0300... hwbuo, .aufixuarhuubnufinl Mmmfiwmah. npzuzgaou ..oz... 0...! 322.2200 «2.4L MmmL u a >Ip L mm mmL mm infinuuo 0.20 s 5.50.. min .- 05.; 0.20.. ozouum 05o .. 5...: 5mm; L mmfi . 29:033qu l. LImmqu mm LInmL um. .0004 F23 20.00mmou uo< 45:2..I I III: IIIImeIrEIzII-aotmliz. H 29 F300 0285.8 u u. an I > C ( 3 I D m ( Ir ( o \- mam-2. -41- 9n I a J I. I I A I A a I II.-- - J g J - I . . - . I I I I I IIE I IIIImdd I WEI-1w.- 10 - I £93 .I....“ J 0.9.. J I T... 0.: .. I o.” q 3-.. --.------.EIIII..- . 8“ . coma-o .. m . 240 goes . n W [I III - y I. In; . I I III. II .. IIIIIIIII I . .I. I I .. .. . o I IIIIOI . I a . J? I a a. I. 12 17 as... $-92 I13: 0... 93. I .. 3 4 -... .I....IIIIIII .8.H . II- 4.3-.” :0 TIdiuuu-EI-MI n I . 04 f- odIU. 0.5 T10 I. .184 3 . 0.00 0.0 0.3. I. .. o.“ . 2... 2.3.2.3!!! .8” I £8.3- .. m a :8 ~93. . n .- f «.3 0.3 I. 903 060 h a I. I 34 0.5 I. ad. I. 200 . I o.“ . I... . ......2.......... .8" . 0.8.3:. .. m I. 8:... «.84 n . 3.-.--93. :15 I105 I. 0.3.. IIIEI-IIJ Item-II in . ”A... .I I 3 J -... III}!!! .8" -III. -33 .. m“ :13 H n .I 0.3;. 0.2 . 33 a A 90% I «.3 Jr «damn-I- 10 II..- 0.3 I I. o; .. -...- -IIIIIIIII... .03 . 83. .I m "on..- «$8 . n fl II . -I I'll [II'IJT'IIII I? I l .0. I v I o - I 0 I c I I. II - r I IL. . .0 v «.2 0.: cad. «.3 0.30142 QfihIL-Itfi IT .....3 I I -I. IIIII » II I IIIILIIIuIIIL ”II M IIIIIIIIIIIII H m J I :1 ~8- H . n I 1% 0.3 can. «.00 .33 05 0.8a 4.3 II. 0.2. I I I I. .. -... . III. I... ...! . .. m . 8... .. «8.6 a n . VII II IMw-II I-Iw JWHIIIIIIITIIIII If. IWII IILWWI .I r - II" I I" n )1)” 3. u w). n)..3m I » Nv‘ .3903 30‘033 .130: 55.990: .203: 33.33: :32. .3 3.. .3on ...-390 I p o. I r... TI.I.I: :53?st :.mI-rzésuIII.I...ILILEH§I .flmlromvsé 5...“... Mmm 3...“. ..uuzmaWUIWz... ...?IM;§°§®-.AH Mm» ”EC mm j..-..u>onh0> C ( I I D m < h ( o w-a‘ F N; -7bo—0u9 l L. nownn lQIUJS U531 'ulennN NJNIDZHS m ”592. w «.3 TI‘ c.om «.u m.nv . n.mo . «.vm . . m.n~” _ 04m . mi“ _ u.no . a U»(.‘ w 43.55 m>¢o s OEIP I y L: . ‘ Yl m.co «.mm 3 m.nv m.m~ «.00 o.um can - 3m :NJQ, .3953: 22303.. u h c .. 3.2333,. .———.0 + F 4 o n .in o.m¢fl_ H .o.ooo« . 0.3 . § o.m¢m~ o.-ma o.mo~« exam" I a § 1 v-—+ ~+-+—o-——¢—-o-—o~o«-o—-—~o— re — a.ommwl+ .loxoa fl Jade Csvw-z.ol_.mo‘aao.uxvaau>< ! 31'. Eh?" .I IL! I'll - 4"___1 f ! I A -+—‘ f—+-—o— -~o—-Q—.-+H...9.__+-H-n¢ ‘ 1 4 i W 4” 29902.1 .30 x ..i 13 o.vm F.“ n.«m. # «so mucm o.m¢ «.mc Tl! -‘rllll|3iq 040." lTl!;,i-cl 1.3- + :Q-lnxoa -m».wL m> ...< cc ‘5 «a.mn 1‘ h. I‘ an m @493. —43— 9a A 4 a « fl 4 I I I I I I II I I .. . _ ~ _ r A E h f a. n J H F 9,0 . * I I I I r h TIE“. --.flIJIiImaRI I?“ -.Afgzl IIwAIjé III 3 :4. 1:. - . I- E . -..- . II---..I.,----- . 03. I ......3 .. m 4 .3 .3“ . .I. 0 TI I .I I“ I III é I III II II + IQ I III: I. I I. . .Il . I. ll Illl lIllA . . 4 . fl I damn I- NAIoIILqumoH .7 6.3 241--“qu IIIII.V.«II.In&n «.c r n.m« I I. m6 . I... . oolIlIIIIIIII. I 8a . 3m 37- .. m .I -I IIawmexng I no. __ IN IA .. .I . . .I I I III I I-I tIIII .. . . t . 0.8" IINI.&I 7°53-” dag 0.33.” o.& fi 983 I “.5 995 H H m6 H I-.. _ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII H 8‘ “3193.. I583 H m H a... 3.1% .o-.. I 22 “.3 Iv aoIeQII...I§ Ur exam. I..._:JI.§III “.3 A I as, H I .III 3 ... H ..............I. I H .2 was»... 5.... H m “w I-:..Iw..I.II-Iu I.“ . 000“ + I Cob“ I 0.0%“— éI non“ II“ I OoSHHWT {dog a IOohHO- : mos - A. Old? H... .2. “90 M Oil H IODIIIOIOIOIIIUI H 8H . I I838 ”9 M M :0, O NAG-0 H n H“. G _ o I I I. 0 V m A? | o I o I o . o ILfl I 0 é o I If 8 o 4 II. . OOIIIOIOOIUIIII: o o 1 . N I N . H I n 2 I ‘ aITOIOIMNI. In. aiIfimfi m. ...LIoIeFTm awITIOIE I I I, I: , - I. I I- as; I I E .333 m . s... as .n _I .n Team 4 Immm Emma Ea 9m: 3. emsifi mi II Ioém -. I II. -3. .I. .. IIIIIIIIIIIIIII .. 8" {Iain .585 H m H «a... I. «38- .I - dIflI IN , ’ I I III I- II YIII' I I]. III I II c Afi dc I o c a o .. o a _ m «Kw I ”.ISI “I922 4T do“ 4“ 3.3;j 0.? % .32. A “.2 III 93. I. n m6 I I. . IIIIIIIIIIIIIII « 8a ”33%.!— lzzaa u m w «8»... ~88 . n W H. I o o -3 22.. . 32. o a; 03.. n a; 03.. 3 3... . 39.. gm IL: is ts II.) NV 5 inn“... .. ...“. .. Mutuggaafi inn:a_u>fi;§o+. we”. bin-$33M can“. Taniaaao 43¢“: Mum ...»me 3320.33 «oz... flown ...»zuZngou «02:2 Mum u n. >h mm m m M I II -III II I I I I . I - I I - I. . I I I IIIIII u j<-..u>oIHIm> C < 3 I 3 n ( P ( o Gunmen: °‘ OH @493. 2h 4 a I I I a I I I .II Iw I; III: II . I .I II IIAT IIII: . I. I II 4 III. I III. R I I II I.-. . I M II ~.anIIIII~HU.I®IH-fi.oR-erfloI-temffi c.3433; 3U H ...IIIHIIHIIIIIIIIIIHIIM IIIIIIIIIHS H «szsta. If. .m +1-.IJII..IIIIILI.I . ATII...IIIr-..--,+-.. I... III I- IIIIIII.IIIIIIIIII.II.IIIIIIIII.. .... I... h - I- am If: 17on“ 03 fi-w-ImISIIIIIIm..~. VII-m «BIT-II: groom I: I: . . . -- .. on . ,3»: 86 .Im _. m Y CINILfI I. I, II .I- IILY IIIILTII .. I¢ oul I I.’ . d o . 0 I .IIII. I. .I I . II oéffi £068 3 13 .93“. 92 A. “.2.“ 13 1m: I -III.II.IIIIIIIIII.II.IIIIIIIIIIoN. «837$?» mm m - I- oIIII .. I. I - I, III-I I .I I- I .I-- IIIII. - . . . .- .. ... TIRQL 0.0% 8: .I.-“.9 93:1. 3. 0.3 fiflIflSIfIIII-HIITII.-n..-----..q---.. --.-”--.---II 3 . «a..- as . n H. m 1R 3. 9:: 3a 0.32 9% ...th 33- files? I I WIIIMw-.- VIN-.--...IIIIWIW .I.... .I.... H m H N3.... «38 In ....-- w I LIgzii. - . . . . . _ W NSIIIIMIVIMII 9-224 RE. Team-Iofiivbéof .$IIo.§ I I "III «I..- .. .I......... II. IIIIIIIIII .. 8“ 5133.8 I. a“ a “L ..m. 8.. )3 22: .33.. 3 92. 03.. Z 03.. ungafiqm- 3... aoxigm ....3 is I...) NV 5 I. and... H a“... Lanai? ut»... .5239 ”A... 292.533 . you“. 3.551%. Jimmy“: MWM ...»Wma npzuzoazou «02.: Some npzuanzou «02:2 “Wm ua>h mm“ mm mm III - I. I II- I III III. . iffismio - 1:39 920 s emf» 93s oonumr mic \- hma; Sow; «my 2.0.23.“on 3% mm. mm” mm 1 IR 3 I 3.0.0.. :3 2030:.qu uoIkImKHIIEII; i.I».Iz.I - $3522 comm-52. . II. 201.38 uzmomIq Io“: WINE-MP >¢v CORROSIVE EFFECTS OF HZO,CaCI-‘._~?/3(;IZ AND NaCl AT 75°F (NOT AERATED) FIGURE [8-2 r-—-v—- SERIES I8 ,-._, ___...... M x CORROSIVE EFFECTS OF HZO,CaCIz-MSCIZ AND NaCl AT 75°F (NOT AERATED) FICLJRE I8-3 -7'- l SERIES I6 CORROSIVE EFFECTS OF HzO,CaCIz-—M3CI1 AND NaCl AT 75°F (NOT AERATED) FIGURE Ia-4 -72— C . . . .4- An>o~— ng-~..-. o~ -..-...“. IO-A a--- ._ -7 CORROSIVE EFFECTS OF HzO,CaClz-M3CI,_ AND NaCl AT 75°F (NOT AERATED) HGUREIB-S -73- APPENDIX B LABORATORX PROCEDURE 1 II The solutions were prepared by weighing out the amount of chlor- ide salt necessary to obtain the desired concentration and adding enough distilled water to bring the volume up to 500 m1. In the event that the chloride salt was in.brine form, the brine was measured volumetrically and diluted to the desired concentration with distilled water. The salts used were, in all cases, the technical grades used in highway applications. Inhibitors, when used, were 'weighed out and placed in this solution. All inhibitor concentrations 'were based on the total chloride salt content of the solution. e at o Plat The metal used was 19 gauge, S.A.E. No. 1008 sheet steel, which I- Figure 19. Freshly prepared test plates. -75- was the same as that used in the 1947—1949 Oldsmobile bodies. The metal was cut into plates 2 in. by 2 in. A l/4 in. diameter hole was drilled through the plates near one edge in such a manner as to leave no burrs around the hole. The plates were then polished with No. 280 wet and dry emery paper and finally with crocus cloth to produce a uniform surface, (see Note). The plates were then cleaned in carbon tetrachloride or trichlorethylene to remove any grease or oil from handling, dried in an oven at 220° F. for one hour and weighed to constant weight . Note: Sand-blasting may be substituted for the above polishing method, providing it is used throughout the experiment. Tests The tests were run according to one of the following cycles. Since pH control on the highway did not seem feasible, no attempt at pH control was made in the laboratory. However, the pH was checked periodically throughout the tests. The inhibitor was not replenished during the test, since it was desired to learn how long a given application of inhibitor would remain effective. Triplicate samples [were run in all cases. The amount of corrosion was calculated in milligrams per square decimater and in milligrams per square decimeter per day, using the equations given on pp. 80. WM 500 m1. of prepared solution were placed in a 400 ml. beaker and the weighed metal plate suSpended in the solution by means of a glass hook. The solutions were kept saturated with oxygen by continuously bubbling filtered airthrough the solution, which also supplied agita- tion. The beaker was kept covered insofar as possible, to reduce ~76- evaporation losses and to keep dust and other foreign material from entering. Any evaporation losses were made up by adding distilled water periodically in order to maintain the solution volume at 500 m1. Tests were run at 75 1 5° F. and at 55 : 2° F. The metal plate was removed from the solution at 7 day intervals, cleaned, dried at 220° F. for one hour, weighed to constant weight and returned to the solution. The cleaning was done by thoroughly brushing with a stiff bristle or brass brush under a stream of water in order to remove as much of the corrosion products as possible. The duration of Figure 20. Detailed Set-up for Corrosion Cycle No. 1. -77. Figure 21. Battery of Tests for Corrosion Cycle No. l. 'the test was 28 days. Corrosion Cycle No. 2 500 ml. of prepared solution were placed in a 400 ml. beaker and the weighed metal plate placed in the beaker with one edge resting on the bottom of the beaker and the top of the plate leaning against the side of the beaker. The beaker was covered with a glass plate to exclude foreign matter, but in such a way as to allow air circulation over the beaker. The plate was alternately immersed and exposed to air as follows: 16 hours - immersion 2 hours air exposure 4 hours - immersion 2 hours - air exposure The plate was removed from the solution at 7 day intervals, cleaned, weighed, and returned to the solution as in Cycle No. l. The duration -73- of the test was 28 days. Temperature was 75 : 5° F. Corrogign ngle Hg, 5 The solution was prepared as previously stated, except that the distilled water was freshly boiled for 15 minutes to remove dissolved oxygen before preparing the solution. The prepared solution and weighed metal plate were placed, as described in Cycle No. 2, in a 16 ounce specimen bottle and the cap tightened to limit the oxygen supply. The plate was cleaned and weighed at the end of the test only, using the cleaning method of Cycles No. l and 2. Tests were runat 7515° F. andat 55:2‘1“. Figure 220 Detailed Set-up for Corrosion Cycle No. 5. -79- ECUATIONS USED FOR CORROSION CALCULATIONS General Eggtions Corrosion Rate = 1000 W" in mg/dmZ/day A t Cumulative Corrosion = 1000 W in mg/dm2 A W Corrosion Rate = 1000 W = 1854 W 0.54 t t Cumulative Corrosion = 1000 W = 1854 W 0.54 For Series 15 to 16, Inclusive I . Corrosion Rate = 1000 W = 2085 _E; 0.48 t, t Cumulative Corrosion = 1000 W’ = 2085 W 0.48 A == Average total surface area of test plate. (dmz) W == Weight'loss which occurred during time interval "t". (gms) t == Time during which corrosion took place. (days) ~80— TABLE 13 ANALYSES OF CALCIUM CHLORIDE BRINES USED FOR CORROSION STUDIES No. 1 No. 2 No. 5 Calcium Chloride, per cent by weight 57.48 40.57 59.78 Magnesium Chloride, per cent by weight 1.54 1.76 1.47 Sodium Chloride, per cent by weight 0.99 0.51 0.56 Specific Gravity 25.0/25.0° c. 1.599 1.451 1.422 Sum of Calcium and Magnesium Chlorides 59.02 42.55 41.25 These brines were obtained from Michigan Chemical Co., St. Louis, Michigan. Analyzed by the Solvay Method. The Rock Salt used in these tests was obtained from the Michigan State Highway Department, and was identical to that used on highways. -81- TABLE 14 CHLORIDE CONTENT OF WINTER ROAD SLUSH Sample Location ' Sample Temp. CaCl No. (° F.) (Wt. %) 1 Cr. River-Abbott Rd-center of intersection 52.0 0.28 2 " " " " right gutter, east bound 51.5 0.50 5 " " " " left gutter, east bound 52.2 0.59 4 " " " " right gutter, west bound 51.5 1.52 5 Mich. Ave.-De1ta St-right gutter, west bound 51.8 0.41 6 “ " " " -center of intersection 51.6 0.24 7 5 " Beal St.-right gutter, west bound 50.8 1.47 8 " " " " left gutter, west bound 51.9 0.50 9 " " " ” center of intersection 50.7 1.24 These samples were taken about 6 hours after application of a calcium chloride-sand mixture to the streets of East Lansing, Michigan. Air Temperature = 28° F., February 16, 1949. Pavements. Concrete. -32- TABLE 16 MEASUREMENTS TO DETERMINE AVERAGE TOTAL PLATE AREA FOR CORROSION TEST SERIES NO. 15—16, INCLUSIVE Dimensions of Sampled Plates Length . Width Thickness Hole Diameter (in.) (in.) (in.) I (in.) 1.86 1.86 0.044 0.250 1.91 1.91 0.044 0.250 1.91 .1.90 0.044 0.250 1.91 1.90 0.044 0.250 1.86 1.86 0.044 0.250 1.91 1.91 0.044 0.250 1.91 1.91 0.044 0.250 1.91 1.90 0.044 0.250 1.88 1.84 0.044 0.250 1.90 1.91 0.044 0.250 Mean 1.90 1.89 0.044 0.250 Face.Area = 2(1.90)(1.89) - (0.g§)2 = 7.08 in.2 4 Edge Area = 2(1.90 + 1.89)(0.044) + (0.25)(0.044) = 0.55 in.2 .Average Total Area = 7.08 + 0.55 = 7.41 in.2 2 - 2 2 1 in. - 0.0645 dm Average Total Area = 0.48 dm ~84- dkk A $8.0 II... at. 884. 0:10 ommmImA GIN I A 003.04 .I.... nu .8010 5.010 300.5 0.A A W , 00A... I... .I. a 0.3.0 a $8.0 seats? 00 . .A 1 i 83.0 3.... ...... $3.0; A310 39.2 0.... A dc : 55.9 ...... .... 13$ 0.; A340; 134.8 04 A f 0A8; I S I! 82 0 094.101 4188.2 4.10 1 «1 3A0; In... 38 1.4..ch 05.0.0 .0A 0 A. A 53.0 .8... I... 0 ~10 «:10 03043 AA A A1 0.4.3.0 . I. 1% SS 0 «310 E: m... A SANA. Sol I... 53.0 001.0 g 04 A 0310 In! ...! 002 o 0310 A803 0.4 A Am «510 -I.. 0310 13 W0 A IA $010 3... I! om 11 002.0 A305 04 I A ‘ 33.0 .8... I! 05.10 3010 an}; 04 . A .0 in! II «80.0 «mend Mméu W90 m Ioofifiobum I I I A. In 8... .0 I... ...... $2.0 33$. 2.3 0.“ . I I . A AA $28.0 all. I“ A510 002.0 $.00 0.A I I I I A 00.00 I... I... 31:51 [85.3 0.9 m 4.1.35 . . . A 1% 800.0 .I...- -I.. 0910 «was. 3.0.003 0.... I I I I I A 002.0 .I.... II 0110 @031 lat [j I . I I I A 0A 008.0 I... I... Amado 50101 [05.5 0.0 m 3 . I . A IA 005.0 ...: .... «Amalia 7033A. . . . . . . A a AAAuqc III «#1an «5.6 a: 11H I I I I I d WHOM III-II III. Nani-Gig “an. NH % I I I I “QMNIO IIIII IIII SAHI "mum m mm“ M" N I I I I I I I d flNIfi IIIII IIII .OONHIO . a n I I I I I I I H Home N. «c IIIII II «0 FNMA IO mid W hi I I I I I I A. addllgd meAAd aqua-9L Jaw I I I I I I I A gONIO IIIII IIII “Add «G I "Maw-Mn Id #1 I I I I I I J as... .I.. .... 55.0 . [0813. .I31 T344557 . . . A Quoqo I‘ll III. omwmIo [fidddl mu: «4.. a M I I I. I I I I u NQQWIO III-II III. QGH 0 'gqu [lg a . OJ I I D D I I D N I ll mm: 0 32.0 A20 0. A... w Ila-auger I I I I I I A mg .0 IIIII II!- 83 o gao ago“ OI~ I I I I I . I I 1 add. «A010 Idem.0A 04 I I I I I I A damn-all“. III :20... A Md u a I I I I I A m aflmaa [Sufi-«AI [ICIN I I I I I I I I ifi “A Tadmuddllolllrolll 00' 1.3un AAiAcc E I I I I I I I I .1 Ad “00“ IO II" III. IO M” IO 3%” GO“ W _ a w 8 '3 I I b I U H Yugo IIIII IIII fldoo &WHIO “UHHNH a N I I I I P I b L. C H .1 III “I A210 13 I I I I I I I I flII [mound .I.. 2.1.0 AaAAIal 1| J10 m 3 I I . I I I . I _ . I . ulna F§1 GIN I I H I I I I I I A III II 13 T3 I L— I I I I I I H U ASN.0 all 1'3! 0:10 . 0.0 A 5% h I I11 I. .I I I A. i... ldmwflo lull nil vAAAd a“. JJ I I — I . b» I .I 4. I I R d «3.0 I... ll Aalflflqlo 04 I . I I Fig I A 5 00:4: 11: all £31013 W10 W Til-HI! u . ., . |-:| ; . l.--| rill ISLE." .I'il’ i .I. . .. \j‘l1lj‘ . . an a x I ,- 1-3-; . - i. 1 WI .. A , .. . 1- I 1 _ . _ . I .. WW . . .Ih 800.0 .I.. .I.. 0.3.0 3.0-. [090.3 .I.. I . II I I A1 . GNHVIO I'll. Illtllllvllgd 321a l I I I I d.‘ WHNMIO IIIII III-III [a II II ‘ I I I - ARA-0 cool 10.1.. Acne-0 dad. MA. I. fills]: I I A . .... m .I.. ...- 008.0 law-AA 0.0 .- UIIIILIIII all: . . .. 8.8.0 I... -...- aaaL Ina-0110.0 In Jun." III-0.5.1 . . . A. III-o“... I... 1.949013% 0.0 I I I I I I I 1 . . 0 . «2.0.0 I... .I.... $0.0:ng 0-A I I II I I I I M II .. — . U 1134A nil. fall” 2.00.0 dad. 1.10 d. A. I I I ..h t .. 000.0 LII-.... gala-00.0.01 ..0-0 . . . . . . 1. Wm 010.0 ....- -..-. gal—0000110411. . . . . I -A _. .. 0A 0. ....- I... 031-0000. 0.0 m .505 ... . . . A _. 1L 00.0 -I.. ...-113010000013- :01 . . . . . . A . .. . -.4. .. 0108.0 Jada-0 2.8-0 GAE-0A 04 I I I I I I JI. My . i . 1.00.0 mflc-c «13.01% m-le 1 I I I I In... ,lu1. V . . 4 I «018 L [dud-0.. 0-0 I I I LI I I . I I _ .... . 0.40.0 ....- -.. rdaélg 0.A . . . . . . I .. . AA “AIM 5 w 1 H0 2.8.0 ...-r... ...... Inna-0.. m0 0 I I I I. I - HF .11 53.0 ...- ....- lnflaaqlalfifidu 0.0 .. I I I 1. I I A h a .F 1.— amQId Ill till I 3000 3% a.” I I I I I h I I . J H .H 0:00 ....- --..t 138.110.050.151 A . . I . ., _ ....A. . .. Til-I «Ame-0 .....- Ifladg I . I . I I I . 0A ....- .-.- glad. T011. . . I . I I . . 8 .I.. I... 100010 2.00.0 0.0 m .0!“ I I. 1.x .. III... II. alumna 0.0 I I I I I I «k H3000 II... ......l ch10 1g «A I I I . . I I I w ...- fl fax-0.102 0.0 A. dig . I. I. .I - .I ...... Iifiig 0.0 I I I .I. ... . ...-I - I . I 05.0 ....- ....-. 00. I031 mu“ I... 1.59.51 . . . . ... ill-I'llaé . . 3.0.0 . - .I.! . . 11 I . ill... - , .. ...... up , J .. :00 .220 II... III-0. IIIIIII . I! . ..- -5 , 4:2 :5 0.0... 0020 I» 0.3.... 083.5... . . ...: .. I. m x c < 2 u c «£30» 5.10;! IO ans — a!!! . . ... ... If... __ I . . .. 5.09? 1030813.]. [II . 330333 m. .3. - —87- " 1.. 1: T 1 4 11111 - . “NIH. - I d IIliv‘I if ATIIIIHH I IJIAY 111v H t dHL.11 1 4 d In A I I .7 111. 0 . 00- I .0. I11 I 1 I I. I. , u 6 ix“- I. 1H1 .141 1 1 ILAfiII 1. 1 I a II V @0061 a V G; - 0 I I. V- I , A II 008$. .. 0., : .--. In. A . 5325*? T3800 g# I I I I .I I I . H H “A A 1 111 0 I III :1 I . 03 I I ..- O T fialfiufihmfi $10.10-}??wa ...-III... ISIS. . .3 0 1111. 1 I | .1 If 111.7-I I C II , I I - 1 .... 1.5.4.020 . . L I Y . - a In 4 . IIm mHIIBuImmIqulfgIJI-IIIQAH 3.8.13.0. 83$ .011-” . . 1I-I IIIIIT11n, u 1: I. ”1 m fi+fl§1 A. II -- ISM-OLIIIIIII 7? Hand-01306 TING"; I . I I II... 1 I I . I V i .111 11.1111 11 14111;.1 1 I I 1 Ifl1AI Uw1$i I :I- 1 IL 1- . .0 .30.? 50.01 I I I II I I I I - I 0 0.0L fla-§d«ia%§. 003.043.1003.: 800.01 0.0 n Ilia-'1 mu 0 III-III! m 0.80- 088 a A: 07...? a... 4:0» 0:00 9:0 _ 3:00 0.20 7899:): “a: Skrmpwgg 951W -u 89.5.. H” u0>h 02 mu 0.; I¢.m0¢¢8 In ub_WO¢¢8 d “m1 Uh‘o 09200 0.1053 .3 mac-0 0“ 41:2.H 00352.2 «0:912. : 0 IA ..II.oz 3.000. 0.3» 29000000 I0 . . 5 4:0» 3‘ ...»:«w _ rhea can.“ fiormnm Madman...“ »§H.flsou0H0n»qu0000-0Illzo;aou0 325?: «Sultas .325. ”n mt; . oz n. 00mm 02“. _. :35 m I C (5 w ¢ .00- n W s a 6 h s _ >105! :02u ZO_F.mOQ.20U _m¢(n0 «0:2(0 “M F. nmzo. :35; mo 30.. 43:21 #3pr motmiz. F 20:33. u>.mom¢8m an ”.53 4.02 muEmn .23» 20:35.00 0:3 33 :55; I 0 Q 6 6 9 I I——o——‘ -4v+- 9— 6 o , —._ +-—+-~1 ...“ ~k .% ... «is; I I - 4 Q o . L—+.3. § U \Ifl I oI o H o v I H 43I o y _+ i. I l o u“ I If IIIIIY 4 II + . . . . o <. I I . w 4 . I . . q . H . a F .f - . . H I. * , I * * + . . d I I I” - * 4 .w d IIIIT I I .. I4 I I IIIIIIIOI III III oI M Q # H a . + w a f .. fi H + * . . F . I k + I M H H M W , , a II a . I I I -I I II. _. * I . I . I I if- I H I + . I fl 7 F v I | I I I o A I I I A. I III F If ¢ II IVIIIIA I I.I+-I IIHIIIII . I¥I IIIIWIII I I- IflIIII v I I f M I I II I I III I .: I I I. AIII . + A I Q .. .I I;- . I I- a. I. I- .I a.“ I. -.E 8.“ II .3 4 - .3 H 3.. I Ia... Ira; n. I .3.-- IuGI-.-.II Ii.“ .. uni I. am.“ -3.“ H 2% “to 8-6 a: H I .. 3:..- I an“ . atm- Qfi _ so.“ A I 9.0 i 86 I 3... ‘ 2:. E 8.» a.“ «an 4 8... H 8.0- 9.9-.. -- a; 02 8.» a.“ a.“ M a.“ 9.» MEL 3; Tm?» IIfiI III- .... “II ....- f - - I. mm...» Nab-.I....w lag-4 - _- m?»- .I 8.» w 2.» H 26 H onwa- H I 36L I R6 . a; a... I -Ifiuo; .. 9.» + .3.” g - 86 ..I 3.0 . I ImadI I INN-NIT. nu... .- I I I .1. w .3 IIaIs. H -.m..I I- who. fi- -I.I..I.IIIW.. I .... .2 I ; MIMI .I.-Ian..- HI .5 .h- we.» a} a.» H a.» 3.» . .3. a... . mm“ more _ 8.0 3.» 2.6 2.3 8.0 8.0 86 V. I I am. $ 23. I -8: I In... HI 8.. .fi ISM T- Re I a... -IIIIIINIme I Ia.» * I -8.o- Ah I a... “I -8.» H 8.... fl. 3.» 84. 8.... . goo “FOO H000 8.0 4 800 I a.” 800 r SOP -900 I I “EV II I IMo-é H 2.6 _ Eu» 6+ .56 %- as H as I R6 + 8H. , _ A I- III II I23 -I--3:.I 2:. a IIde .II mw. .MIIII8.m _ I144 was f-II. II 8.4.I IfiIWuJI III-ImwéI IQ.» . 3:. :I..I ImméI-HI 3..» “EMIII LII III-34». - :uflH IIImImHNI ...IIImé IIHII$.~.I I IH.I.I .wmoI JII-hIquw R‘3_ cud-I3» .32. 93:. K‘s Isiah {JufizoFBOn II III . II II II II Iafi .1 I 1.44 #33 I I .— Q» +—+ 0 ,JJ. 4%: ° fi o—~v»o—O “IE-.... I.... I : :7... ax.» H H J 66 986 6366 @86IV.§6 mam . n I b P u I p p a _ I1 n no. 8816 $86 886 186 336. , 8 a3 1111I1 . 1 “61-11%6 386 as; :86. an... an. . w V11HI11T61I- -H1ou11 ...-"£111.? IaIumvawin- . ... V 1-1 #13 886 6 mmfladfiuau Inflamma- 11IIII III-“-I. H1 .11 IIIH1I H 81IIb-I1H . .3 I UrII as... as... has .367336 figs-11H» .I 11 II. 1 I- b p a II. H 5 I- T EEEEIEIEIP m 11 -E 131 Ina-183331 IBIJS... E1LHL-fi1. 1V Ifiao 8361:81Inol1 6 366 .3 .II1I.IH 11.1.141U1MII 11.1.1. I 1 1 MI. 1-871 - 1-11 n .3. , - 11 H.366 «686 886 :86 N86 .8 Lur cl llllllIIWIP II “1 1 .pr 161.17-?- WIHVIn :3 1 11H - 3186 818.. «M86 EEI? 1.1 -.1.II...I 1:: - .I.-1.6!! - 8 armies n .3 .11 . - -1 1 | 'III II II¢II1I I 1111 . . L 63“..." 3.86 R36 #615 E . P b 1I11P1---111H11|11-1 1.1.11.8...IHJHIIM I u- u -« a“ 1 H 6 n - I lid-1.1”“ I 1 1I 1 .. ... 3 38.1-93.1 .. ..-!.-I.1.. m as». . «an. a a1 I 3:6 $36 38.16111636- N1m61141w1.wmm.~m11-11 .11, M1.- .. 1 - .- 1 IV I 11.I1. 1-w111 11 I111 I1.“- MIIIII 3.... afiflIaas 1a.... .81....- aaas 1 1.1.1-”.-1 -I--p:- , V n: “Wm-49.1w- 1 -.11 Puma. .61.- I1.- I 816.1... .33 EmfIfimsV sss..-.:...s a». a ...-La} 1 2|. ale-mm: M morass. n ...1-1I. 1 Ir1 1 IIII. VIIII . I II IiI 11:- IIf I II+I1 6 66 n6 m «6 “”6 fish. 1 b I b 1 P m I P M .1 II 8.6 36 66 6 6 3 .3 b ... 1 p M I - 6H. NI~N~I6 “E6 3&6 % RS6 386 8c . Imapo 9. lit-1m on a 3:6 Imo- w .JIoom. J66 n 1 I ...II 1H 11. r V III-L. II I II III I 1 1 r II affix? #13361. 3-1- ”61 8I611i~mmm1mpm - - i. - b 1 u 1 - 11- II I .I--n 0P I .. 8&611Imm61a6 §6V 6LI 866 886a u u H I” 111.: I 1 1-. IIM1:m‘11 v 5.1.15 H I I 1 IE ,1 WW6 836? 336 V 386V1 986 922% m6 8 V é on V .3 I58 m ”flu-1?. 88 n J I III1,I..I1H-- V1§smasaHss.sH- as1s flag-ass . 1 ,. -..1 . . . a 1. . . n 1s H- 1 H 1 11. v 1 I 1 I HI8¢6U oM-wmho1mcnmo6 986 12%;: -. . - . 1 .1 .. - .1 M u . n 3 .1 II -1 I: I 11 - ..V .1831 as"? 826V- 56.6WusssImsE1; 6.1.1113 111mm? , H £11,133]- F €6-61 n- a 1 1 ”II. M. I111 I 63311 “21...... .6661... V1- -HIOVIWIMI SW61. .. -.1 1 1.“ 1 11... 11 . . H w .. .. 1 n 6- H1 1 II 1 II 11.. $86 163.61%. aw1861 .6139». £3161 .. .- . .. .. .H -..- .. V m n -p n C 1 II I II $1616.36 $1316.16 1 E mow-61171-2.3w61. .236: n6 8 . g 8 31!...» I38, m . «8!. «88 H. n I III. 1 1 1 “M61 mnmnom.o.XK6.V $6 1ofi86 “MMSV .. u u .1 u u w u u M “an r - :61 -1 , 6.118831. . 6 86, .3 . - I - . : -111 IIII VIv-mfi61 mmoono1686.m_ 886 8.8% 95.36 mac «3 .I.-int} on Slabs In»... m «Sn-nus”. n A -.ahaonoflmlta 1| 1? I1. V V . V . - . III “ankmgass 36.61%...16I3731 -.111 . 1 -. . - . 1 . . H a .- .. 1 «1.6--- -1 - 68.3... 6 «6 836 $86 386 336“ 1a H. n am . 1 -ildflmiIa-Iaaqflg V .1337656; WWWH. 1161 -.M1 Ewarbk . H, W. .mmrwm la... 11w «3?- :6». n .6. I” - duh-1.1! 8.1.1518! 386 635% EH61 W 61H 6136 MmBPI p 1.1, IthI-I-.1.. .INI I -I..-- p 1w 1 -- p ... V. 31......1m1111I -- -m- - I I 3340 $2.6 Ian... .0 I amuon I m6 I. . {annulus-.I.. - . 1 1 1n n an . 1 - saymfifilflH‘fi IE1 ”MaofifimujV fin” $6 «68.131 m“ ..I lull-Ill $1 1'96 I? m 8?th n H J u VB .2 :66 2:3 V 2:3 223 3.362s 5‘ upzuzeaoo «9...: @5118 32:. .2. as: .0... 3» 46:: ..o (9.13... >0 can :3- m x a (.2 u a » :va s .ocn_ a InaugIman p105! ... 20:32:00 93¢. V533 3.29 profits to $0.. 41:... manta: «0.50.12. 29.516» 2:35.00 u “:45 6 .02 main» hawk zo.n0¢¢8 |(.r(o was #1053 I II. I III II- IIrIII II I I II - .I II I _.I IIII I I I_ I I I llllllll I Lt I I f II II II II 4| .IJI II I II % I H III I II I IIHH I III IiTIIL II + H t H- + I . . IIIIII- I . . - III- . 7 - . . . III II I VI I I; IIIT ITII III . a J I II II A I I I _ . I * fl H II I IIIII TIILIII :4 I . I W _ III? III III - AI I III -I U. I . . > v II VII II IIII I I I I II IA v I 7 I“ I :. II I I II III LIATII II A . ---.»II M I I -I --Hflgi..- IN .I.I I... I I . ‘ LI - -9 I + L. I; IIII III I. I .I v I . I v L H I H 4 -4 I III III . - .. . I II? IIIIII I+III III III III II v I V II I H . I .v | I. W I I a I IIV I II I I A I -II T I III- - II ATII II III I4 I I II . IIII I I 4 T -III I II I I I II I- LI- I -II III II HI WIII I II .I. I I IIIII II ..I I . III _ _ L J ,fi §I§I§3+§I§If Suwa— IIu; r35 .. II I I I: OLIII. I . Ia .5: II . §I§§I§I§IT§4II§ .-..-..II...I . IIIIIIIUIIIIIIIII LISIIIL -I-..I_IId_ I42 III I éééé I I4 84 «laugIfiIIII II “I. IIIIIII LI amusirhasi ...I I1: II .IIIIIIII. II- . II I.III . I I 4 I I I II I I I . IIIIILf I H I... “I -I.;I In- I ow... III,I. --IIIIM.-+,IWI um; I.» I I. I I v .+.I I I 8 I I n 4 fiHL 7 I I - -- . p stagnajImIi; .Iusa.-.fi «I .5- I I. I. géfgraL 18.—TIE . I..... .I- Ir-.I...I I.I.IIMII... -IIMIF Io,«.III-.II II.II. In 23;- LTII 43mg IggfilgdfitI. . I .. -..,..I. .-.. To; . .. n .SJII I. §§§H§§4I§é . “J 2 II .33853 on 3.8.5 .58 a I «so: I «38 n .3 I i 4. A III. grlI I. IIII I 1 II I . . II I. I . + . I III; II II I II I I III IT I IrIII II. III I I II It ”WWI—I. quad? and 396938... 8.3m; I..- .. If I I I. I I- .. . a _. t 2. .. .. n I am: I- III II II 11I; I300. §6HIM§&I~ Omgoo ‘Fa‘ I A_I I I I I , gv I If I. , 1 I I O. f I 2 LII I I I I I IMI ‘7me r IIII I .34 use IBI .oIsmfi .Ixafiéé u- up. a. - says... a e. is: I... a. a? E .3 I» I II II §4II§II§ 884 .734 I834: ... ._ - II II. - - I - . 4% - I , n 81 I I I . . I TIII I IILI II +TIIIIII.IIII IIIII - .LIIII 3’ vIIILI II + I I W flaw: 0:4 3.5341984 I433: -..IITI...“ . .. r . .. I 8 .. .. n I 3L 4 III idéggi SuqufaaaI; 4318 mg... onI I 35833 I 2.; : Slam was.flouufl1«ao§...¢38. n 3:- III I . I I..I TII I I-.I Y. I I T I. I IIIII I II III I I I I I f I I gaging. Lag . .. .. I. u .. MINI. I am. ..II ..III HIIIJSI I II I $3.3 ggfig; I994! .. . .. .. I . .. on .. . IpI pWIT Ifi . ......IIIIEJ .433 ”$.4Iwmmm w§IoI®meI§é f}: a; I .5333 la I I313 533 78. «do..- 53 I .n .9 .372 ”1.4% U . . a . 41.0» «>40 :40 _ 930 «.30 guzflmnzfiuu mp“ npzuzeaogngmfiv ”Emma‘smw «02.5 ”n at; .02 m can :3; m x C ( 3 u 1 p .5. p can» ”ozflL, n 5:? JthWMoHIz 20:.«0Q20U 3...... 55¢ um 3.28 :35; ...o .30.. 42:2. $3.522 motmiz. 20.348 ”2,505.00 an ut‘o 31-31; .02 3:5» p3» 2935.3 I53 30.. :66; é igl'l'l 6 h! L l M 1 '_ i I? ’I, x 1 1 r ¢ l I > 1 | I ‘ T'iLrII é " I l f { ! v: 83 8.. 5 mulINALllflal mm.» KB 8.- .3 :3... II. V -83 L 5 - -l; mg ...l 1&4! :3 1' llill Tudor III 8.0 d: a... Ll Ba 4% 34. ll RN .3 m.” I’ATI n-80 5 LI ,1 I- mm~1,fllnlll'17l- EL Li IT L - 84-4 --.r... w- tailwflui - - WINEIJJJfilaflLla L «2. 3A .83 +1.8 Ilium; a: dual ,zlmfllllqflwlrldal J I - . .m _. u v an E IE w uaqw Alon» IalWl god i. ‘NL 147! In .I; 11¢-l 3:; 18..” AT 8.. 3 n --.w..f--...m§ 4......“ A a; 7 . .3 F, 3 : WNW uLJIU - 793.111..”3 a.“ #744?! 11 L! flip. a; L 8.. a if J . GR. f IQJILI -3 . ‘ fl 9 p 3:. nmé f 814 ..... I r h! . - GA 1 9; Ah «3. f a 47 fl 1&1. infill. #3111? lair? M 0.2 «3:: 8.1.»; .n . SON QIMIOHIIA. 3w v'q LYII. I ' '1 -‘ouhl +11 -woh [I 3.0.. fl- A. a A . ...... A .3 A_ :fl.fi...mka L -- . H11 E. 73 fi a w [lg - p - .‘1L 2; V Erik; v; Mm.» H: m.» ...... 8; I “a? a W I -- . - TIHJJT 2.h LIlaL! a .4 A . 4 . .... . - 2: mm... Mw o .I.: , fivL .3 a H 20.» .6» .oz _ .0: Vin}, w- s I -- w rig fin. g p I H . . I . . . . h - ,- I IIIII . . w + 6 6, 6 u I o o. I .II II I ill I1 . . + . 6 . “I . I II I I III II o I I o I I . H I. .I . 6 6 k 6 I I .. IIIII+ I . . u 7 . . . 4. .. 6 . II; I. o 4 . 6 6 o 6, . . W o T 6 + I I o 6 o I» AI II IIIOII I II4IIII 6 a I II II II I II+ II .I >40 AI . a w 6 6 . a 6 r v I o 3 oII I I+ IIII 6 . q . 6 . w o. 6 X I OIIII & I II . . . I I . . II I -6 I II- - I III-"II w . 6 H w 6 . I + I h I . . a A . 4 . . . . I I . I . fl I I . fl 6 . 4 6 . T . . . + d . - II.II- .IILv III . _..I .I II I . 6 9I M q ,. 6 A 4 I a IT II ?IIIII o I II . . . I I I ‘ I I . I I--:+ -III-IIII 6 F . 6 A . v 6 II I A II I II 4. II I I IIIIII III II I III 6 6 a I 6 I + I“ F k c o I .f I I AwIII III: III 0 . 6 6 6 + . . . . I I I LT - II . I «III I- III-II v 6 q 6 q + .— I II 6 6 II II 4 I II IIA r I II Av I II III I w I . 6 - a I 4 6. I b q 6 . . x . . w w 6 H a I . a .6 o 46 III 6 T IIIIIIIIoIII I II . . 666 . 2.6 F. 2.6 26. I H .I.. 2.6 2.6 I 666 I 6T6 I I H 8.6“, 63 ., I. 6 . 8.6 II 3.6 d 2.6 66.6 I h I h 2.6 . 2.6 I 66.6 I III 6 I. I664. III-62 I6 I I .I II II- . 66.6 4 66.6 6 66.6 66.6 I . II _ 2.6 H 66.6 . 3.6 66.6 I 63. I: 66-6 I I I o o . o 9 III I k II. I+II o . 616 M 3.6 a I 66.6 66.6 H II 6 :6 . v.6 . 66.6 66.6 I 66.6 .2 .. . -- V . 36 -6 :6 II III . . 1.6 an.” 6 I IrIImIn6 .I._I I I96 III 66.6 vm6 . I 96.6 p: I I I II . I666 IIIIIImnI6EI.I ..I 6 I 96 I I 6.6.6 .I I; 1666 I I-6Ic.-6I .II-om.m III-«m-M - III ”IIMaIIPuéI .2 I I I w 6 6 6 . . . L «I w I I I. 2.6 . ~66 . II I“ «66 666 I I W 666 6, $6 om6 IT 36 I II 616 6 66% + . h cmé F «6.6 . II I. S6 omé . I IM 36 I I 8.0 ...-II no. 6 I6 I «6. 6I IIIII-HI maoo IjT 03 T - _ 6 I I L I . I 6.6.6 I I 66.6 T .I.-... ..- 3.6IIIII6~.6 LI III-I I666I II?.6 I "6.6 I66.6I I 616 .66 I I o k I 6 6 6 6 . I I I I A b >6 I 666 I «66 + I M 86 666 . I 3.6 k, 666 . «66 Q6 II In- WI-WJI : om“ Iu-I FI- I14 . «m6 . 9.6 I I «m6 66.6 p I «6.6 . <66 36 666 I «n6- 6m" h .. I 6.66 . 9.6 6 II 66.6 9-6 p I 9.6 # I «6.6 IN I 666 «6.6 IIIIIII I «6.6; I 166- 6- I . . h - h .. I I I I p I L 66.6 66.6 . I «6.6 66.6 I -I.. a; H 66.6 H 66.6 6 :6 I 8.6-:I3WI. ._-I I . 3.6 5.6 I “m6 omé M II ~64. . $6 .3617-- 3.6 II - 3.6» 6 I I «awe and 6 r I I . I 66.6 . I 66.6 . I- N 66.6 I7 I66 I II II 2:.- 6_-I 666 H I «66-6- 66.» III IIS6I “II 2.6-; 53W-.. M I -I w o I I I IbIII I III-I . I I+III . iIIII II. I'- II I h P H . I 6.6 I- 6.6-. I I... I. 66.6. I 6-.6IIIIHH II- . I666 _ 6.6 I 63 ”.6 waI 2.. 6: IN 96 I 66.6 .. III 66.6:II ”6.6 I:6.6I I96 I 6.6 1.6 I .6 .I :6. 69 38.x I I .. 6.6I I 66.6 H ..I II -I66.~IIIIIIII- 66.6 III-... I- . --6I6.I6I.I + 66.6 66.6% I- 66.6 I 6% ImaIr- 66 26-36.: .3 6... .3 66 .3 s m .3 a I .3 2 6 :JI : .3 a I .56 3- 6 I56 6. _ .3 6 H .3 a p 3:38. .62 6 2.3236 v o .- r 6 I I I I I s I l I I I I I .5 III I I II I I “U.0 can “2.2.3.ng z.» I I ha: 6:3 ID I 1 s+l'J j .1 I m I I 4.. ‘ . H I. g a ,, m L1 3 w _._- L v6 1 ‘14 . Va 9 II I 1| ! r + I H v." l‘ .1? i . -. .fa. . i 4+ . I I W L4 ¢ , L- 1 -Amfla.o..§.o ,qmaaidadir HI . . . Ti. 18.“ -- 11 3386433 .i . .‘ . . .. H8 4 3.13 mi :1 and! + «11+1IL: 1 Y1 . . ‘olql II- o A; l . o o A 1' H31 - .fi I H I I I i C“ H A %,It A , u I _ I I I q“ + A 4. m+ 83...qu n «m . * I J a . T I h C U U H. q M L ., . _ . . . a + . . a m“ an! 3 n ml I H ‘ a 3 . . . t I a I I I fi & 4 o . H a H. I h I I . I . a . . . + . 4 u guru]. . n “A . a I I . o . r . _ ...“ ”is... T. ...: H I. M - , . . . . . I: . . ‘|il Y1 ‘ w u . . §§§i§434 TL- - ......i... I.......................... : .I . . 4 .1 . 41.1.1134; $961 ’35-; Eli £4- E- E Iii! - AT .. H . . . . ,. fl , . réflfliw§6;§Hgd?§ -836 188.3; .leh 81...!!! MIN m_ Son-«88. n #8H3.3. __ fire» «.30 _ 9:0 330 #— n>(o £wu_m0¢¢oo uni ut‘o .... .02 3.5» +3» 20.35.00 like 33 :65; V\ .. I I I h I O o 4. O I- .I . m * ., I I J + I k .9 o I I. III II .I. . I t I . I . L ~ I I . .., I I I I I II A I r . _ If I” . a I H ...—I"! I I g I I I | 8‘. » if I H I. I I I I. W a." IIIIII I . 8: as! m o?- .18 I A: H II...I. I III _III II 4 I I I A I I w I IO N I000.-,IIIOII III. II. I H I I A I A UNI OHI I “ m §III I I I . 847 ISI u IIIIIqu _ n I II II _ III . o I + I I gfi I II + | _. 8H « A ...i . . 9 '0 A. Ia I I4 I I I I I I I I. A I+ . L I II .81 .53 “I :43.le _ III IIIII II I... I I I II II II IrI . I . A I I I I; II I o I I- III IIIIHII. I I . I III. IIII.IIII.--I w. III“ M. i I I I I I I + I 81IIJI38: I Iw _ Jun-4.83 I .n fidf III I I I I I . _ T I I III .I . l. I I: , I; w IIWIW IIunIhO 'w'hIOID # Av I o 9 §.fiII€NHIQa g dHIII .. II II I + II I _ I I I . . WI T IDOI I II+ I I I I L§I§J§ g; .3 I I HI III. I I . 8.— ibi m M an! xln l 8* I I. Isa-ulna? II I I . q . a . fl h I 753134517931 I . . ...: I“ I . I . . H . . . I .n Iiggvliflaclu I§IT . . can . al N I I r , I I . I n A“ H L I - - I III IIITISIII - 3. I. I § «I52 wwwxulzss n L.“ I I Iii. -- I I . II .I I M 334311 3: I“ III . t I . .. In... IIIII IIf I o t . o I . I331 W? I _ I . I 6 III 5 3 mood I. IIIIIII aS all n ww .38 anon ....m 8. H IIIEIII‘IDQI‘II'AHALTII I . t H . I Y . .I x 3H 0. ~ '0': I . I I I I I I .I. In. I IIIIDqu-llfid Aqlflfl $2.... 236 I56. 226.. $36 38.8 4 “a” I M I _ . I . .4, w .. . m I an. M I Aida-III: 381886 «83 manna.&n1o.q§d 38.2I “6, I III +87 In! a 1.89.733 A. 544.1. g 31. I . . U . W H L M w . all-Sauu‘vi-«uco 384,81awuan6. 3.26.03... 2813 IL II III «I_ IIIIII .. . . . I*.~. IIIQIIuflAfla-u §II§I§4957§3 Wacd«#IIHI_ IIIIIIIqu I1.; . . IV»: I; r§+I«5.a+ Rand» 3.9.3 836 «5.2 I. I III I 4 III I“ m H 38 .18 I I a. . TIifllJ-aliI II.II . II .I SIA I : I q. q - IIIdflgfiIgIg I836. 83.: nomad: 3. III: II III II I I II III II I .. fl .. .. .4. 1.4 H I TgauIIaud -836. u§_I~§I g II. III -IIIIIIIIIII- - + III III .I I .. . ~ 5 I III-Iguassu? I386.§«a 3.336le3 $3.3. .l% I IIIWII IIIII “Mason-«88 H cit-Tahfiuuéfl ., . S . I I ...I _I 43.0... n>h oz mu. can; pa.m0¢¢8 INF. uhh .02 MM Ola h¢(hn m x a < .2 0 m L . E. . o: 1. p e; s :1 4..nwmn°._.z 20:32:00 as: 5:: mm 095. F1010; ..0 30.1 43:21: 0.3.52.2 «050.12. 20.»..30...” mimommou an “:13 w. .02 «0.5... ..nu» 20305.00 I553 30495.03 4 4 I4 .4 I4 4 4 H. + 5.4 + + I . a I .4fI I I .I -I- II IIIIFIIIIIIItII I q o 4. 4 4 It A v I I o IIIII I I II IIW. IIIII I I 4I I- .. I I f I. 4 I I-4I I . ., .4 I. II II- III. I I 4 4I I I « I4 » I .OI 4 + I o I II «I I IIIIIfII I44.- I I + . H H 4 44a 4 A 4. . 4 4V I I4 I I I 7 II +4 III “II--4.- I , I.-4III4 II 4-: 4 4 4 4 - H 4 - - 4-- 4 4 I I. I I -4IIIIIIFI II II I. IIII 44IIII. I. I I ._ 4 4 I 4 4 I I 4 4 .4 II 4| 4 4r II % I + IIIII .I 4 + 4 II I 4 ... I 4 4 I 4 I I I H I 4 I I IIIIIIII III+4II II II 44..II- I+I.I II4. II I- 4.! I -4-I III4III 4--- III- I - I .4 . _ I 4 I I I I-.. I II4.III44I ..-III IIII II +II .4. IIII I+IIIII II+_I I III .I I I 4I II I I+ I | . I II 1.: I I . II I .I .4. II I III . II+IIII I I III I Av I I I1 I II WI III I I+ I 1.9 I I L III I IIIIH . I I 44 I | _ I 4 . . I- IIAII IIHH.III+ IIIIII4TIIII IIII II ITIIIIILYIIIIIIJ III I I It II I I II I .l I -..III .4 I I I II «I I 4 44 4 I k- I I. I 4Y .II II I f I I .4 . .4 ,1 . 4 m 4 4 I III I I I I. 4 .4- 4 4 I I 4, I .I . 44 IIIIIIII--. IIIIII ..I I I 4- I 4 -4 4 4. 4 4 4 4 T I I III I f I 9. I II _- I II 4 I I I4 II I. I II I I 449I 4 I I1 .I I III. III 4 I- I. 4 I 4 44 I 4 , I I I4. I -.II4I I 147 I I- III I- {WI IIII4 I I o I I 4 II II 4 II ; II? II I I II4 I I I I4 I I I .. I 4vI II II , III 54.. I II I ? I I I II I I I I- II. | 44.1II I .4IIII II I I I I + II. I. + I I II. I 44 I I 4 I I I I I I? I -+ I I I I I III IITI I III- I IIIII4T4.I t I I-I 4TI II II II II - I4. I4 -IIIIII-I44IIII III--I- I II II-.II_III I4II IIIIIIII 4.4 4 I I-F 4 II I II II I III IIII4IIII I III - 4. I . 4 I 9.4. -4. I v.4. 4. -443. I 4 «1 I4 I. a“; I4II- IwcflI..TII.mc.FI44IIIII§-I. ., I 2.”. II: .II II 4 .I II I I I “I- I I II I IIH I 4-- I 44 I «E. 4 I .417. I II oak-III «3.4 9; 4 d2. 4 43 I. IadeIIISdJ II-4II I I III II I I I I ._I. IIII . .II I II. I IIIII III. 0 o o o o .o o a I 4 4 + w .4 I “mm LII I .O'IF I II QIF I44 I Q. F 47 IOMIF III‘INIL II I‘llfiI I IIIIWMIIN I4 IIOIdIH‘IIIiII‘IFI IIII I+ . I IL . 4 I ... - 4I - I I. I «3 44- al.- I9.HII4IIII«.Iq-.HI.. - fl.” III 94 Iflqfi .I--d3 .IIII2I.44 4T .94-. .4. I I II. III I. I I. I III4I-II . I43. 4 I ”E... I «1.--.- INZ-.. 9; 4 3.4. .. :4... . «fir 4 I- ”if In.» 4 I 4 I. I- I I IHI I ..--.4 ..-III- 4 9.4 44I QE- . I443 4Imu; H 45.74.. I9.4. I 3.4.II I a..." 443 44 I6 4 4 . I . . I 4 4 I I I I III4 II 44 I 4 . 4 :1. 4 . =4. 9.4. «v.4. m1. 4 3.4. v.4. I am... a... M 4 4 . . .II .I . 3.4. on; T on; L I 9.4. 8.4. #4. «<4. a .4. 36 II II I. II I I II I. II III. I III - M II I. IIm II I 0 II TIIOII III-.I. .IIIO 4r I IIIOI II 0 CI I I|+.I III I. I I II II - IIII4.III I I .-IomeLrIIomImII. IIIom-FIL.IoIq-m I9 4.III 2 4. «In-I4"; Iom 4.I III: .4 44 cm I -4 I II .I I . 4 . 44 I «3 «3 44 .3 4 3.4. 4 v.4 4 443.-.: .43 . «.4. 8... ... 4 4 I . , 4 I 4.III&.4.I T “2. 4 I an; 4 o3. - 3.4. I 9.4. 4 9.4. 4III om; . Imoé 8. 4 I4 I II . I I I4 I I I . 44-1." #1 I .43. 4I “3.4 I «l 4?-“1” I I-8I.HI-I$4I agI as i 4 4 IIIIIII I- I I III IIIIIIIIIII-I - -. I4 .I III. I. . . I 4 4 I . I- 4 4 Iona- 4II «E _ 4.2. .2. . “I. 4 2.4. 4 2.4.. «3. ..I 8.44 .n 4 4I . - .. 4 4 I 03- I. 03. 4- 42 443 m3 .3. 9.4. 4 a; 8... an 4 4 . .4 «.3. 2.4. 4 on... 3.4. 3:. 4 I «a.» MEI. I R... 4 8... A 4 4 I I I I I I I4 I 4 I 4 4 . I as 4 s.» 4 86 .4 I- 3.0 4 - a.» 4 -8.» 8.4. . R4. mo.» 4 8 4. 4 4 I I 86 .III as 4 8.» 8.» . as 4- as- 23.4... 3... 8.44 e. 4 4 ..... . I ., I- . I I I 4-143 .--...4444- 4 Is... 4- .43 4. -2..- I4 I .42 M41 -42 .. 3.. .... 4 . I I III II IIIIIIII I II 4%IlfiquIS.q II as I I83- 8.oI.II-8I.~.II $6.1 WWI-WINK 4 II-III 4 I - II - IIW - I- .I I4 IIIgaI4Itga- I 4.4.4.4.... .I-“.Ifl4m I03 r- 3.? sf: “GI -3 4km .I- I4 - I I H I I“ I - I - I I: w H.- 4-..IMaI.WI-II3I4 I4IIImM-I4I-Ie.» I m: 4 w 2.4-4 I-oI44.-III.IImmI-.IImI.4.4I 44 I: In 4.1.3 I I I I I I 4 E... o... _ .5... ma 4 .3 a :8 5 S... n4 . B... 24 .3. o 4 B... u 4 20.3484 .02 4 oz 3:2: 1 Y. I I I I L o I H I .I a II I I I ~II I I r p 4 .. . I . . nU—Cwn4 I I I I I 2.2szro 4.1; I I I III I I. IIIIII III 4398b 5: 2.3 ~103-. « q _ m . . .I A H . I a. II... I I II I o v I I I IIJILVI I I III l k a .F d ‘ o. I II I IIIY H .. . fi ” ~ I . 4 8. I I III AT L I II III .7 I LT a a n “ fl . * I I I Lfi I II I II I r I k > h o wII tIIII I A II IIIIIIII IIATIIII. II 4 I Y I * I v M Y .:I I A I .4 # III-II I III II-ITI I I. I .IIII H I I g A 8 « I g I IIAI I I I oI II v a I v k L VII lo I I o 4 L? I A I TII II I . IIII I fi I wI I I .IfI II + I4 YI II f k i I IIJfiwIIiI II._I I.. -I.-III II I g I IIIIII IfiII I H «II II 8 III I I fi II I IIIII IvI III I I ..- III . 4 ..-IIIII I II I I TI I II I I IH IH+HII I 4r # I IIII I ? III+II « I III. II II I+- I III I TIIJTIIIrI IJT III rIIIIIIII II II I II 4 I8. . o o. I I . I I III VIIIIrI I Aw I I I I v T IIIIIIIII- ..il. IJIIIIII+-IIII%II I4 .I IIIIII I: I fiI II- I . fl . I III! III. I I i JYIIII? I-I ATII I *5 I .HIII II I h I . II II? I A I I I :III . I IIIII II IIIIII I v IIrI III I I I: I. III I I? I II- I I I. III . «mIIaII- $6,. 886 HmanJWITInmII ImmmnmuI IWI III I. I III-lo- : - IJIIHIWIIIIM- -IHI n III I .p. I. I JI-umf I.I. I I II n. 6 886 m86I 566 836 “a...“ I III L74 I p L I I P e. If I. 226 886 H8866I 886 b 2.86 88481 o I III 68 31.88 Ia...- “ Ia I 488 1. A? II I 43 decOI MMHOJO~MMMMJOW ”Humane w fioo $8“ 3 A I r IIIII..I.I|.. ... u I -I IIII flIu I III I II 00L #8 III, I 88.; d 86 8on o 6 - .8. I - .I II- I I II II I I I -III I IIIIIII III IQ I I I IIIIIIIIII I . .4831 86.34%888 §§II$IJfiIIII 8&1 EIIgIIImfiu—wrdxmr I I. II . I I -I #. “mun” “M66Hanwflo6 88...... “ fiuwouoIr WWIJJI . .IIL. I I .... I I- I g. . ..I .. . .I.,fiI .I I .. I. I I.“ I -I‘.III I IIIII I - I I I- II.I,--- - a 6.6. 66 .886 . 2.86 8.8 . I I . . .. . v .. I . IT I I - - I- 8%. 836. 8.86. 886 “886. H .886I 886: .....Iu IWIIWIIIIIMIIIIII .8; EJSAL mi- «8'- «88 H 7 8. I“ III I I- I - I 8IoI~6I 286* 886 ..886 F- 8&6 «288+ .I I I I I Ah 8 III- III I I -- LII . III I P- III II I I I. PT .I.- p o I .I P -.I .I. I L I . I I EWWQIIA. 88% 88°on #8on. H8de + I . gal; I I. I... . .wII I. vI.r .. J. g C + 63 6 IMMSII6 Tam-.6 8361 .386 5.8.8 8‘ I I 8 old-I3 w j «So-u 08 t VIIIIlI-IIIxIIIIIAI .. +I I ATIIfiI I . I r A I I II F 4 A III I I .168“..ng6 £3686 W886 886 :86; . I . . . . . . I .n I. . III I h 2.8.: 886 836 .886 886 9.8.8 , .. I. I IIIII .I. I I .. . f A I % 8:6 886 836 386 w .886 88.: _ o.“ I -.II 8n Sly—.6 I58 m as»... ~88 # A W I: III Rune-.86 88...? 886 8 :36 . 836 88.8. HI- m HIII I I .- I ... . _. . . k .... fl ...AINIquoho Ion-05.80 a gMoITImQI—ob mmeuo-o. . «Ins-«o0 386 “Came: I u I III. I IJIIIIIIIIIIIII. II... II I - b: I In a . c k I on I .35.qu IEIR» I3... .5... 39... fig mam-Wm: Immo- IL III-IIIHIHIH a: jaw-1.3.. I“ I «83-58, a. I .I.. ...... gay I . I I I. 4 . I 8 JaungéfluIfia 841.. Ian QM . I III I_.III HAWAII- . . H I243...” 6338 «86 N86 86 I886 W86 -I 8.. a II I. I .I ... 3 A. I- $1..sz: 38...... I a...» ......aIéwaIaI 9.8.... 8a... 8:». “5.:- uuo I I 8 5&1 3'5... In: a m .8»..- .88 A «13 .. 35.3.4. . . 4 «L 4 I 4.30» «+40 95.3% «.30 «>48 45%.».(wu Draught! Esau .82.... IRE! «Eugen. 32.41 H” u 8 fr _ 02 mm. 0.; 2.5» m x a < .2 u a p x: . oIISF-Wmflm. . S. :35: .... zo.Itno.:20u 3.... 3:2 auF 3.29 :35; .3 30.. 2:2: waste: «6:95.: 20:38 mimomcou {WI 2» $.62 3...: ......u... 20.35.00 I40 A 2:3 32.3 A «:3 fimufim fink-ckfi npzuzmfiflofldfcaufiflmu .32.: "u at; .02 mu 0.5 2.5.... m x a < s. u m _ A. Ethoa-n r A. ozu . p.51 2.an fizz 20:50.“.on 9:2; .932 am 8.28 235;- no .mwg 43:5: #3pr «2.9:! 20:33 ”$3058 I». PCS 9302 3.5.» pm“: 20.35.00 l(c n>Z( II FIG—U; k0 mWOJ . J‘.F.2_ H UCDFX-i mo _ . p r 9:2. 20:33. “2858 3 oz 3.5» ham... 20.35.00 I <26 33 ...:ofi: V\ .I.. ..... I . . ”A . .. .A. A .4 I I I I . 4 4 . 4 . t . . I I I II.. . w . A A . n H . H H H I I .xAII I I I. 4 4 . . _ . A. A .. . . I.I IIII I I . . . J _ . o . A III I. IHI . . _ . 4 . a . 4 a . fiII I I III 4 m 4 . . . 4A. . t . Ifl II 4 4 I c 4 44 . x . . IIIIII 4 A I. 4 4 A. . . . 44 . I .0 IfI I III... 4 4 .I g . 44 4 "£6 I - - vII “II“.IIHIWIfiQH IlI.IIId .IIA IgfidI “AT. .I . fl- . I o - - - - - . I C U - H . AI - C - I U - U I O I .4 8 8‘ M @ --- -.. fl» --- 030““ .-.- -.- ---.---- --4.--'II-I-- C C I 6&4 4 n 0° .-. ---1 n 001 “.IHI. IImIIIIAdYII “I. 4III- I IIUIOIIH.-P- C- I'I..--I- a '31“ 8M . I34 4 II IBIéIII #4 IQBA—I: I I . 4 . . 4 A I I I III . I I I I I I r I I . 4 ga .--.1 --.I—IgOO» III'4 OaI44IIHIIO Illfl- IIOOIIII-._--4|I--II-I. I O I . 4CG4 .3... --.. ---Ucaa --- :Jmflwn..--wI...I--4---.I- .-..4.-..Iu.l.q..-q .A. A. .. a. A a .o I-.. IIIInanAIIIIIII. 12.8 ---IIIII ---..I..-I_.I.. .IPVIIIIIIIII.-. 8 Minsk I. I& . I I. TI --- I.I-“4I I.II -rui4lIlm AI...I -.-4 -------' -.I4 I--------. .4 HI fl 4 . ““3617 I.I.IHLT I.I.IHI’ “SI “JII.I.IFA I ”MOM“ AIL I..- 4- ' -4. . I - U U U - - 4 - -I. U . - . ..- O ' - f” I44 C II 4.. I- . I“ O I I I-III I I.I..vIIIjIII.” IwnImHJaImwmIHIIIIIIAIwIaflm“Mn-fi..I.I.AA ..-III..II..I.HIIII-MH -I... .I.II..---II. MIAA- I231“..- -.TJIM- H A I «afiévIIIIIIWnuIa.--uw.IfiwI.fiLJIIA.TIIHrIIIIII----..IIIIIuII-ImeIHquIWAfiI. AI I I.I.IIII.I .I IATéIHI "do ---w -IUIE .I.--LA NFH‘I‘IG II-%.I- -IIUOII- w-‘ I-.IUI|-- I I II IgYIIIILflhIoIIllv o .o ..-.I --- 0564 .I. $8.2 ---IIII4 ------IIIIIIIIIIIIII a .3385 I-.- IIIIIA II .12.... A... ....-AIaa.AAA-.-.-:. :-:---I.A--IA:-....---:.--. . .. ”III, M I T- I II 3%.... IIqWAIMnhIzmaIIIIIquTmfiws .--..IuquIu-.I-r.----- A.-... I-I.--II: A. .- I In I I.I. - I a II I 4 I IIII - .936 I-IAIII .3?) .I. mmWAWMIIIIIHII. I---I-II.-IH-IIIII-II48~ 0 323.8. 4 I I-I I 38...: 1.4.1.3213 I.-- o8~.3.---A---_. ..------- Mafia ....... - I . A. A.” sun“ ”I .A I I53. :-§. 3.5:}--. . . .. AAA . I 4.9%.... --..A ---.flmo.oA_..--. I§.c;-IIHIII4 ----IIIIIIIAJII ......... Ion; £3-58. Am. A A . .I _ . 4 IIIIII -w -I .IIII .IIaa.m-AI.-.IA ---..32. ---4 23.2.14! ....... - ”-IIH ......... AA. H . .. A; .... I I I- I I 4.44.1311) {$3.3M --- IR9.3.A---.--- ...... --.--.-----...---... a. .. .e. A I III I “JOIN-04 III“ 000 ““300. III OOMAoQHLIOIhlllh IIIIIII I .I-” IIIIIIIII TON HOUIINAOCO4 ‘4 4 A - ....Aszgo II.-. . .A a. :-:.. ........ ....... --.. . A .1 IA 44$RO ll 4 III moFMO. '0 N ”AHA h 4 . . 1 4 I I. «A. 4 + 433.5%“... ---. --- «$3. .I. $5.23--.-i. ..... ---.--.----I---_. A «of ~.. . . A I§£I.3£a?§. 886 --- .I. 38.0 .I. $3.51-)---” ....... I --.---IIIIIIqm. An -88 ..an v I I I 4 a A a _ o 9 _ . I I ..omum435»_ 53... I--. --- Ra...” --- 54.2.---AII. ---IIIIHIHIIIIIIII A. A . _.A..I. H A -...rs-3.-3w:..~......h 88... 38° as...;---.-- ....... . «4. ~.. .a . ..to..3aflio&:2..c€n.o. --- I..- 133...--- 83.3 ......I.; -----III I- ----..III- a- 8 I88 4.“. 4| II I I 4 I o v . c o o _ o H I 060039;. .4 -3 IIIH III WNMWoOH IlliI WNHWoNd IIIHIII IIIIIIIIOIIIWI HI04 IIIIOIOIIn I- .“ I I I H HIIOMIHIIII .A TacomtooINu-agasoz‘: «2.0.0. In-“ In: ”2.0.0” I..- Nznoou I-.. In“ nnnnn an- 4..-” Innnonooom .. . 0mm - a . 454 A 3‘5: .2» Ba :30;- AH‘ QMNOOOH IIII Oll QMSoOI. Ill (MNNQQA III II I» IIOIIIII pl-» IIIIIIOII 8H” gdddfloa b (A I? GINIW A A a . I I 4 ..I, . ...:o» _ :40 at; 350 . m>