ABSTRACT COMPUTERIZED PERSONAL SKILLS INVENTORY SYSTEM: A PROPOSAL FOR THE MICHIGAN STATE POLICE TRAINING DIVISION BY Ronald Andrew Soltis The purpose of this case study is to propose to the Training Division of the Michigan State Police (MSP) a practical method for inventorying the personal skills as a prototype model for every MSP officer. A computerized system is prOposed for replacing the current manual procedure. From 1966 through 1973, three Commanding Officers requested that their Training Division's manual procedure be computerized on the Law Enforcement Information Network (LEIN). The case study involves analyzing the current manual system for inventorying the various skills. The study takes into consideration the use of existing data processing equipment that is utilized for Michigan's LEIN system. A teletype terminal to be housed in the Training Division is the only additional piece of data processing equipment recommended. The intent is to develop the study to the point whereby the Training Division can submit the project to the Ronald Andrew Soltis MSP Data Processing Division. This division will have the. responsibility for further systems analysis, writing the appropriate programs, and physically implementing the project. The limitations of the study are threefold: (1) no effort is made to write a computer program; (2) systems analysis concepts are used but not to the extent performed by a Systems Analyst; and (3) no attempt is made for conducting a follow—up questionnaire to the national survey. A short survey was developed in order to draw a sampling from state and municipal criminal justice agencies. The questionnaire was mailed to forty-nine states and six municipal agencies. It basically inquired as to whether or not the agencies had anything resembling a personal skills. inventory system, and whether it was of a manual or computerized type. Only two agencies out of the thirty-nine that responded stated that they had a computerized personal skills inventory system. The survey data is incorporated in the thesis. The thesis endeavor does provide a case study suitable for adaptive replication by other criminal justice agencies. When the computerized system is implemented, it will also provide a beneficial service not only to the Training Division but throughout the Michigan State Police organization. When selective information is requested, the criminal justice agency will be able to provide updated data and respond quickly with that information. Ronald Andrew Soltis The formation of the study is analytical. The development follows the structure of systems analysis. Various lists are devised which contain many categories of personal skills and related information. The subject categories included in the study are: residence county, birth date, birth place, anniversary date, classification date, classification title, post assignment, law enforcement, military service, military draft, publication record, foreign language, education major, education level, academic rank, professional development, and special skills. The individual is expected to record and mark the Personal Skills Inventory Form and related subject categories. The Fixed Vocabulary technique is employed for the subject categories. All information is then transcribed into three types of cards: name card; address card; and data card. The cards are taped during a batch-process operation. The individual's social security number is the identification for the record. After all errors are corrected, the records are processed from tape to disk. The system is then ready for on-line processing with the data residing on disk. With the data on disk, records can be updated through the use of a teletype terminal. The terminal can be used to print selected profiles. It also can be used to print listings based upon data element code selection. The system will be quite functional for normal requests as well as for emergency situations. Ronald Andrew Soltis The next step involves printing a Personal Skills Inventory Profile for every MSP officer. This process will enable the officer to perform an annual audit of the computerized record. By marking the profile and submitting it along with a Personal Skills Inventory Change Form, data can be added to or deleted from the on-line record. In the future the computerized system could possibly be expanded to allow other Michigan criminal justice agencies to maintain their skills on-line. This process could evolve into a skills management information system to address almost any situation in Michigan. COMPUTERIZED PERSONAL SKILLS INVENTORY SYSTEM: A PROPOSAL FOR THE MICHIGAN STATE POLICE TRAINING DIVISION BY Ronald Andrew Soltis A THESIS Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE School of Criminal Justice 1977 ACKNOWLE DGEMEN TS Many people have contributed in their own way to the endeavors of this thesis. Although it is not possible to recognize everyone, I wish to acknowledge those who may be inadvertently.overlooked. A special thanks goes to Dr. Terence Dungworth, my committee chairman, who provided me with encouragement and proper leadership and guidance during these difficult times. Professor Louis A. Radelet, a distinguished scholar recognized nationally in the field of police community relations, assisted and supported me throughout my graduate education and thesis work. Dr. Larry T. Hoover provided constructive suggestions and encouragement as a member of the committee team. It would be remiss if I failed to mention that I have had a rewarding education through MSU's predominant School of Criminal Justice. My appreciation is extended to my professional typist. Irene Orr typed with diligence and, considering her busy schedule, always seemed available to assist me. Mr. Don A. Perrin, who has been both a boss and friend for many years and who is the Acting Director of ii MSU's Administrative Data Processing Department, supported my educational goals with enthusiasm and through encourage— ment. His understanding is deeply appreciated. The personnel from the Training Division of the Michigan State Police were extremely helpful throughout the thesis study. They were always ready to address my questions and supply the appropriate answers. They expended a lot of time to help make the study a reality. My thanks are also extended to my many friends and relatives who encouraged me through their prayers and warm friendship especially while working on the thesis. I would also like to thank my parents, Andrew R. and Helen C. Soltis, for their moral and spiritual support during my college years. Their dreams are once again being fulfilled. A special gratitude is extended to my son Michael, 'age ten, and my daughter, Renee, age eight. I was elated during the last few months by their attitude and endurance while I was devoting my time to the thesis rather than playing with them. Finally, I would like to acknowledge my wife, Marilee. She has more invested in this thesis than anyone will ever know. She has been at my side with encouragement, inspiration, and support. She was the "Florence Nightingale" of 1976, always available to nurse my needs. I dedicate this thesis endeavor to Marilee. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . ii LIST OF TABLES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vi LIST OF FIGURES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii LIST OF APPENDICES . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix Chapter I. INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Purpose of Study . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Scope of Study . . . . . . . . . . . l The Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Limitations of Proble . . . . . . . . . 3 Case Study Setting . . . . . . . . . . 4 Research Review . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Agency's Data . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Analysis of Survey . . . . . . . . . . 12 Definitions and Terminology . . . . . . . 14 Thesis Organization . . . . . . . . . . 14 II. REVIEW OF LITERATURE . . . . . . . . . . 17 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Background Information . . . . . . . . . 17 Personnel Information Systems . . . . . . 23 Skills Inventory Systems . . . . . . . . 29 Criminal Justice Skills Inventory Systems . . 36 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 III. METHODOLOGY . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 Theoretical Formulation . . . . . . . . 44 Problem Related to Proposal . . . . . . . 46 Conceptual Framework . . . . . . . . . 48 Limitations of Research . . . . . . . . 50 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 iv Page IV. PRESENTATION OF PROPOSAL . . . . . . . . . 52 Overview . '. . . . . . . . . . . . 52 The LEIN System . . . . . . . . . . . 53 Preparatory Process . . . . . . . . . . 57 Storage Medium . . . . . . . . . . . 63 Computer Procedure . . . . . . . . . . 66 Future Functional Uses . . . . . . . . . 74 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82 V. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS . . . 132 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . 139 Recommendations . . . . . . . . . . . 144 Limitations of Study . . . . . . . . . 145 APPENDICES O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 147 BIBLIOGRAPHY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 181 GENERAL REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . 186 LIST OF TABLES Page 1971 Michigan State Police Skill Categories . . 11 1973 Michigan State Police Skill Categories . . 13 Computerized Personal Skills Inventory System Questionnaire Reponses . . . . . . 15 Subject Category . . . . . . . . . . . 61 vi Figure 10. ll. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. LIST OF FIGURES Law Enforcement Information Network Target Personal Skills Inventory Form . . . . Personal Skills Inventory Change Form . . Personal Skills Inventory System Flowchart Residence County Category . . . . . . Birth Date Category . . . . . . . . Birth Place Category . . . . . . . Anniversary Date Category . . . . . . Classification Date Category . . . . . Classification Title Category . . . . Post Assignment Category . . . . . . Law Enforcement Category . . . . . . Military Service Category . . . . . . Military Draft Category . . . . . . Publication Record Category . . . . . Foreign Language Category . . . . . . Education Major Category . . . . . . Education Level Category . Academic Rank Category . . . . . . . vii Page 59 69 72 84 87 90 93 96 99 101 104 106 109 110 111 115 120 122 Figure ' Page 20. Professional Development Category . . . . . 123 21. Special Skills Category . . . . . . . . 125 viii LIST OF APPENDICES Appendix A. F. G. H. Michigan State Police Organization Chart . Michigan State Police Departmental Member Education Information Form . . . . . Survey Letter and Questionnaire . . . . Definitions and Terminology . . . . . LEIN Configurations and Interfaced Systems Skill Forms . . . . . . . . . . IBM Disk Comparisons . . . . . . . MLEOTC Minimum Basic Police Training , Curriculum . . . . . . . . . . MLEOTC Instructor Subject Areas . . . . MLEOTC TC-03 Form . . . . . . .' . ix Page 147 150 152 154 159 161 168 169 173 179 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Purpose of Study The purpose of this case study is to propose to the Michigan State Police (MSP) Training Division a practical method for inventorying the personal skills as a prototype model for every MSP officer on a computerized basis, rather than continuing the current manual procedure. Scope of Study It is my intention to devise a practical proposal for replacing the manual personal skills inventory system for the Training Division. This entailed analyzing the current manual system and offering a proposal for a computerized one. The proposal takes into consideration the use of the existing data processing equipment that is utilized for the Michigan Law Enforcement Information Network (LEIN). It also considers other data processing equipment where needed. It is my intention to develop the study to the point where the final copy of the thesis can be submitted by the Training Division to the Data Processing Division for further systems analysis, writing the appropriate programs, and physically implementing the project into their job stream as a routine job. The Training Division has a high degree of interest in my project and will pass judgment upon it after the thesis is complete. The study has mainly been conducted through the Training Division. The Problem The concept of a computerized personal skills inventory system is a practical project that involves a realistic problem. From 1966 through 1973 three Commanding Officers from the model agency requested that their skills inventory manual system be computerized. To date that request for computer implementation has not been granted. The significance of the problem can be pointed out in terms of timeliness. This study should provide the necessary impetus to help convert a manual system to a computerized one. Considering the attempts in the past toward conversion efforts, it can be safely assumed that the dilatoriness for conversion is found somewhere within the bureaucratic shuffle of priorities. This thesis endeavor should help stimulate interest in the apprOpriate ranks within the chain of command of criminal justice agencies. Limitations of Problem It is sometimes unfortunate that works of study must have limitations even if they are based upon a variety of justifiable reasons. On the one hand they convey a negative tone because boundaries are set for the study. But on the other hand the reader is made aware of further research that can be conducted concerning the subject matter. First, no attempt will be made to conduct another national survey to determine what inroads, if any, have been made in developing a computerized personal skills inventory system for a criminal justice agency. If there are any systems of importance and significance they will appear in the "Review of Literature" chapter. Second, there will be no effort made to write a program in order to implement the thesis material on a computer system. This endeavor itself could entail a complete and separate master's thesis research. Another limitation involves systems analysis. Systems Analysts are paid a substantial amount of money yearly to collect and synthesize information, collect Operational data, determine problem requirements, consider future requirements, design general solutions, select an operational system configuration, develOp system solutions, determine acceptability of solutions, prepare instructions, debug and evaluate, phase in systems, coordinate production, modify systems, and also maintain systems.l Systems Analysts usually have as part of their team systems programmers, and computer programmers. This thesis will encompass systems analysis concepts but not to the extent that is always performed by a Systems Analyst. Case Study Setting The Michigan State Police was organized during World War I in a rural environment. It was created and named the "Michigan State Troops" under Public Act Fifty- Three, 1917, which took effect on April 17, 1917.2 The State Troops provided state-wide police service and protected the interest of the military effort of World War 1. Following the war's end in 1919, the State Troops were renamed the Michigan State Police (MSP). The newly formed organization began to assist local criminal justice agencies in their law enforcement efforts, with its main mission to service non—urban communities.3 Traditionally speaking, the progressive MSP has been characterized as a rural criminal justice agency. ‘— 1Information by Mr. Alyn J. Rynbrandt, Marketing Representative, IBM Corporation, during personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, October 4, 1973. 2Oscar G. Olander, Michigan State Police: A TwentyFive Year History (Michigan: MiChigan Police Journal Press, 1942), p. 27. 3Information by Sgt. LeRoy A. Fladseth, Training Division, Michigan State Police, during personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, May, 1971. The 1920's saw the MSP involved with mobile crime, oil inspection, state boxing commission, penal administration, prohibition enforcement, fire marshal duties, and a police training school.4 From 1930 through the 1960's, the MSP was affected by two wars, and saw advancements in radio developments, communications technology, data processing, traffic safety, accident prevention, and airplane operations. During this period the organizational structure expanded. Michigan was divided into geographical districts! with designated MSP posts in each district. The officers were granted civil service status and were placed under the Michigan Civil Service Commission. The department was divided into sections and units within sixteen divisions within three bureaus. The MSP may be described as a complex organization. It is geographically decentralized, has an elaborate authority structure, detailed rules and regulations, over two-thousand members, and places emphasis on rationalism in decision-making.5 State Police activities have become increasingly specialized over the last quarter century. The process has resulted in numerous splinter specialized areas of responsibility and tasks, which collectively contribute to 4Olander, op. cit., pp. 44-47. 5Bruce T. Olson, "An Exploration of the Effects of Member Goal Preferences on a Basic Training Curriculum in a State Police Agency" (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Michigan State University, 1971), pp. 82-83. either or both of these principal functions. It is at this point that the department finds itself today.6 Research Review Over the past fifty-nine years the Michigan State Police (MSP) has evolved as a military type of organization and it has acquired a reputation as a highly progressive state law enforcement agency. Somewhat reflective of this is the MSP organizational structure.7 The department consists of three major bureaus. First, the Executive Bureau consists of the Administrative Division, Executive Division, Highway Safety Planning Division, and Public Affairs Division. Second, the Bureau of Field Services has the Administrative Division, Detective Division, and Uniform Division. The third is the Bureau of Staff Services. This bureau consists of the Administrative Division, Business Administrative Division, Data Processing Division, Emergency Services Division, Fire Marshal Division, Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council Division, Operations and Communications Division, Personnel Division, Records and Identification Division, Safety and Traffic Division, and Training Division. —— 6LeRoy A. Fladseth, "The Role of the Michigan Department of State Police in Urban Law Enforcement" (unpublished Master's Thesis, Michigan State University, 1972), p. 74. 7See Appendix A for the three—page organization chart. It was through the Training Division of the Bureau of Staff Services that this thesis subject matter originated. My interview took place with the Commanding Officer of the Training Division during May of 1971. He stated that: For the past five years the Training Division has maintained a thirteen volume, loose leaf, alphabetically indexed inventory of education, training and individual skills of all departmental enlisted members. These volumes are used by various commanding officers in their search for persons with unique and varying qualifications for certain specialized tasks and functions. Prior to Captain Halverson's reassignment to the Emergency Services Division in February, he urged that this collection of data be expanded and programmed for transcription to computerized equipment. Through an inquiry in the MSP Training Division a manual project was brought to my attention that was not computerized. The manual method of inventorying personal skills for all MSP personnel has existed for ten years. It was projected for computerization in the Michigan Law Enforcement Information Network (LEIN) for the 1970 fiscal year (see Figure 1).9 From 1966 through 1973 three successive Captains, who were Commanding Officers of the Training Division, requested that their Division's manual system be computerized for LEIN. 8Captain Charles Meyers, Commanding Officer, Training Division, Michigan State Police Inter-Office Correspondence, East Lansing, Michigan, June 8, 1971. 9"Law Enforcement Information Network: The Key to Effective Law Enforcement in Michigan" (unpublished booklet, 1967). P. 9. IIOIIIGAI yr gunman" monument gswonx LEIII ‘o ‘8 C a) o: 1— 3' 4 0 g 044' ’A ~. “$5 “I «*0 Ofl : 8‘50 ‘39 “if; 3’ <15 ‘94 t V‘ if c < <~ as? \ o L 5; vitas "“5"? OF co item 0? 5°C" "Etna as? m rum: em ARRESTS Itfi’r‘oflaAvL fig'Jk-"fif‘fi't‘f our: nu "Hagan..." courumrs star out": 25533? rumour. ear "'33:"cudii‘ncremo uoous "mm” CHIC! MOTOR VEHICLE OPERANDI COST ANALYSIS P RTY RESOURCE ALLOCATION PERSONNEL SKILLS INVENTOI ' TENT FINGERPIINT OEPART N INVENT PUBLIC INFORMATION FILM LIBRARY FIRE MARSHAL CODE SPECIFICATIONS R ME ATORY Shown above is the "TARGET” at which the Michigan Law Enforcement Information Network is aimed. Both user and application areas are projected over a four year period. The arrow “Phase One" represents a combination of inunediate service benefits to the Law Enforcement conununity and initial research towcds providing similar service benefits to other State agencies andgroups as their needs become identified. Priorities for future developments will be based upon broad systems research as authorized by theExecutive Office and the legislature. MASTER FINGEIPRINT SEAICN ScsIsr Applleulon/Ths (Fiscal Veer) Figure l.--Law Enforcement Information Network Target. Agency's Data From 1966 through January of 1973, the Training Division maintained a thirteen volume inventory of education, training, and individual skills for all Michigan State Police officers. The data in the volumes were typed on loose leaf paper that was pre-formatted. It appeared in alphabetical order by officer name. This inventory of information was originally recorded by the individual officer on pre-formatted paper which ranged from one to three sheets per officer. There was no practical method used to update the officer's record, other than through a conscientious effort. The volumes were used by the Training Division to search for persons with varying qualifications for certain specialized tasks and functions. A request for the search was made by any MSP Commanding Officer from any division. Those people who met the criteria from the manual search of the skills data were then personally interviewed by the Commanding Officers for the particular task or function. The person who passed the interview was selected for the special job. This job could involve a temporary duty, permanent assignment, or a selection for promotion. It was estimated during 1971 that each manual search through the thirteen volumes of skills data could 10 be as short as a few minutes or as long as three days.10 Not only were there many man hours lost for each search, but there also were no efficient means available to accurately update the data. The index used to cross reference and search the various skill categories appears in Table 1.11 On February 13, 1973, the thirteen volumes of skills data were updated and summarized in a forty-five page report. The report was submitted by the Commanding Officer of the Training Division to the Director of the Michigan State Police. This report was manually prepared using the ”Departmental Member Education Information Form" known as the TD-l9.12 The forms were filled out by each officer. The TD-l9 form was revised in July of 1972, for the report.. The complete study was conducted from.July of 1972 through February of 1973. The eight month study culminated with the forty-five page report.l3 loInformation researched by Sgt. LeRoy A. Fladseth, Training Division, Michigan State Police, during personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, June, 1971. 11Information provided by Sgt. George R. Gedda, Training Division, Michigan State Police, during personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, June 12, 1972. 12See Appendix B for the two-page TD-19 form. 13Information by Sgt. Timothy J. Baker, Training Division, Michigan State Police, during personal interview, Lansing, Michigan, June 2, 1975. 11 TABLE 1.--l97l Michigan State Police Skill Categories. Numbers Per Categories Category College 0-2 Years No Degree 502 Language Proficiency 134 College 2-4 Years No Degree - 93 Electronics 80 College Degree 75 Institute of Applied Sciences 46 Radio Operator 39 Automobile Mechanics 38 Delehanty Institute 35 Heavy Equipment 33 Welding 30 Pilot 28 Parachute Training 23 Teletype Operator 18 Photography 1? Fingerprint Course 13 Demolition Training 12 Breathalyzer School 10 Sign Language 10 Telephone Installation 10 Small Arms Repair 8 Artist 6 Drafting 6 F.B.I. Academy 5 Southern Police Institute 5 Carpenter 4 Data Processing-Computer Training 3 Cooks 2 LaSalle Law School 2 Northwestern Traffic Institute 2 BlackStone Law School 1 College Law Degree 1 College Master's Degree 1 Cornell University CorreSpondence 1 International Correspondence School 1 12 Table 2 summarizes the updated educational and specialty skills categories as of February 13, 1973.14 Analysis of Survey A national survey was conducted between the time that the 1971 and the 1973 skills categories were established. During May of 1972 a short survey question- naire was developed in order to draw a sampling from state and municipal criminal justice agencies.15 The questionnaire was mailed on June 19, 1972 to forty-nine state criminal justice agencies (excluding the Michigan State Police) and six municipal criminal justice agencies. The state recipients were selected because they had a data processing facility or had access to one. The municipal agencies selected were incorporated in a large metrOpolitan area, and they had a data processing facility. The questionnaire contained six questions. It basically inquired as to whether or not the agencies had anything resembling a personal skills inventory file or system, and whether it was of a manual or computerized type. Thirty-five state agencies and four municipal agencies responded to the survey for a 70.9 percent return. 14Captain Gene A. Rooker, Commanding Officer, Training Division, "Michigan State Police Enlisted Departmental Members Education Information" (unpublished report, 1973), pp. 1-45. 15See Appendix C for samples of the survey letter and questionnaire. 13 TABLE 2.--l973 Michigan State Police Skill Categories. Numbers Per Categories Category College 1-2 Years 235 College 2-4 Years 134 Bachelor's Degree 132 Associate's Degree 78 Language Proficiency 69 Pilots 41 Institute of Applied Science 26 Demolition Training 13 Photography 13 Northwestern Traffic Institute 10 Master's Degree 9 F.B.I. National Academy 6 Southern Police Institute 6 Draftsman 4 Arms Repair 3 Artists 3 Sign Language 3 Computer Training 1 Law Degree 1 14 Table 3 shows the responses to the six questions in the survey. It can be seen that only two criminal justice agencies out of thirty-nine that responded stated that they had a computerized personal skills inventory system (see question two). One agency was municipal and the other was a state agency. In other words, only 5.1 percent of the responders were affirmative. The state agency that responded to question two also replied "yes" to this question: Does your future plans call for creating and maintaining a computerized personal skills inventory system? No follow-up was conducted because the agency replied affirmatively to questions two and five. The municipal agency that responded to question two also replied that the personal skills inventory system was incorporated in the personnel file or system. This would indicate that the agency maintained an integrated system. A follow-up was not made with this agency because a letter and sample material were returned with the survey. Definitions and Terminology Appendix D lists the data processing terminology and definitions which are presented for a better comprehension of the thesis. Thesis Organization This chapter serves as an introduction to the study. The remaining four chapters are organized to present 15 OOH 00H ooa 00H ooa 00H mm mm mm mm mm mm m.m¢ «.mm m.vm m.mm 5H mm («H mm mm MH «.mm m.mv N.mm m.oa h.mm NN 5H hm mm mEmumMm muoucm>cfl maaflxm Hmoomumm ommwumpomfioo o mo choc: Hm>m so» m>mm maoummm amouoo>cw maaflxm Hooomumm UmNflumusmEoo m OGHGHMDCme pom mswummuo How HHMO madam mususm meow moon mamummm Ho mafia HmGQOmem Moo» :H pmuouomuoocw Seaman muoucm>cfl maaflxm Hooomumm H50» mH mEmDmmm pmuwumusoeoo poo oawm apnoea omcwnaoo o EcumMm muouoo>ofl mHHme HocOmHmm Moo» mH mamummm pouanouooaoo o Seaman muouco>cfi mHHme announce moo» mH mmawm Mosque m Ewummm auoucm>cw mHHme announce moo» mH .m .m unwoumm noncommom unmoumm noncommom unmoumm noncommmm annoy 02 no» .mmmcommom oHHMGQOHumooO Emummm macpcm>cH mHwam accomnmm vmuflHmpsmEOUii.m wands 16 as complete a picture as possible about the proposal for the Michigan State Police Training Division called a "computerized personal skills inventory system." Chapter II contains a lengthy review of the literature. The chapter will present and review what has transpired relative to the thesis subject matter. Chapter III is entitled "Methodology." It contains a rather short treatise explaining the analysis of the principles and procedures of the thesis inquiry. The presentation of the proposal is covered in Chapter IV. The chapter is quite lengthy because it presents the proposal in its entirety. Chapter V will summarize and bring together some of the major concepts of the study. Conclusions and recommendations will also be discussed. CHAPTER II REVIEW OF LITERATURE Overview This chapter reviews the literature relative to personnel systems in general and skills inventory systems in particular. It also covers background information, various sources of review, personal and personnel data processing systems, and a summary of the review of literature. Background Information The President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice in 1967 issued several reports and many recommendations regarding the challenge of crime. One of those recommendations centered around the concept of improved quality of law enforcement officers. The commission recommended that Each municipality, and other jurisdictions responsible for law enforcement, should carefully assess the manpower needs of its police agency on the basis of efficient use of all its personnel and should provide the 17 18 resources required to meet the need for increased personnel if such a need is found to exist.1 One point that the commission was raising was that some law enforcement agencies were requesting more officers while still assigning them to unimportant things or matters. The commission stated that In other words, increased investment in staff work or more SOphisticated equipment would do more to improve police work than investment in more men.2 An example here would be assigning law enforcement officers manual duties which could be handled by a computer system. Another recommendation made by the commission states in part that Every officer should be given incentives to continue his general education or acquire special skills outside his department.3 This idea is superb except that it should further recommend that a record of accomplishments be kept on each officer for future departmental needs. That record keeping system could be on a manual, unit record, or computerized basis. On the one hand the commission calls for sophisticated equipment to relieve law enforcement officers of mundane duties. The commission on the other hand encourages 1President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice, The Challenge of Crime in a Free Society (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967), p. 107. 21bid. 3Ibid., p. 113. 19 agencies to offer incentives to officers for developing their skills without recommending a labor saving record- keeping system. Needless to say a manual file would present problems in terms of expansion and growth. However it is very well known that many criminal justice agencies still maintain index files for one purpose or another. These files most generally contain file cards which are manually filed and manually searched. As the files grow they present increasingly difficult problems. Each mis—file becomes the basis for more mis-filing. The files are difficult to purge and therefore often contain a lot of old or redundant information. The manual searching process is time consuming and subject to errors. This is especially true where common names or events are involved.4 Another important problem stemming from manual files is that there is no convenient way for one agency to check the files of another agency. A computer could maintain the files and provide immediate access through inquiry terminals. Inquiries can be received and processed without interfering with other computer work. The cleansing of the computer files would require careful maintenance but the problem involved would be less dramatic than with 4R. E. McDonell, "Planning for Cooperative Information Sharing Programs in Law Enforcement" (unpublished paper, 1968), p. 11. 20 manual files.5 The management of data is extremely important to any system. A tremendous amount of information has been produced on the subject of management and managing data. The managerial staff in criminal justice agencies has had to adopt and use management information methods. One of these methods is called systems analysis. The theory of systems management is being used more and more for solutions to management problems. Management by systems has a few rules. One basic rule is that Each system must be understood and considered a separate entity within the overall structure of the organization.6 If the criminal justice agency has a computerized personnel system, it would be unfortunate to consider a skills inventory system as a separate entity because there would be many data elements alike in both systems. This would produce redundant information. On the other hand an interactive skills system designed without redundancy would work well with a personnel system. It is quite common for various files to interact with a major data base. These files usually exist because they are conceived after the major system is operational. However, if the personnel system does not exist, the management by systems' rule would work quite well for a computerized skills inventory 51bid. Eugene G. Columbus "Mana ement b S " Police Chief (July 1970), p: 14. g y ystems, 21 system. Since this situation exists with the Michigan State Police, an independent system can be considered. What has been presented so far are opinions by the President's commission and a few other authors. Although these authors are definitely interested in improving situations in criminal justice agencies through information technology, care must be exercised when recommending what method or process to use. The decision making process in many criminal justice agencies has usually followed a pattern of tradition and experience. That decision making process must be re-examined in light of data processing technology. Decision making should not be considered a simplistic process. It is a complex process involving, at least, systems considerations. Two outstanding individuals in the criminal justice field stated that Computerized information retrieval systems have opened new and brighter vistas to police chiefs and others charged with the basic police function; but the establishment of such systems has been accompanied by the emergence of disturbing phenomenon; the lack of understanding, awareness--and perhaps interest--on the part of the law enforcement administrators themselves.7 Tradition and experience have their merits in the decision making process by criminal justice officials. However, the analytical process must be improved when dealing with data processing in the criminal justice 7G. Hobart Reinier and Robert M. Igleburger, "Information Technology," Police Chief (May 1970), p. 28. 22 field. The two authors further expressed their concern when they wrote that Our hope lies in the application of techniques which have become available to us through the new information sciences. These include systems analysis, program performance budgeting, management by exception, and command and control. Systems analysis describes a new way for police administrators to examine a problem. It is inquiry into the nature of the problem by systematically investigating objectives: cost comparisons, effectiveness, risks inherent in the various alternative solutions, and development of new alternatives when necessary. Perhaps there have been good reasons or justifications for the lack of innovations in some criminal justice agencies regarding data processing applications. Mr. Vidatti felt some time ago that the reasons may be attributable to the criminal justice peOple themselves. He wrote For years, they have sat on their problems and frowned on outsiders delving into their operations. As a result, few outside of the law enforcement ranks were aware that problems existed in systems, inadequate equipment, and the like, and this type of atmosphere does not promote creativity or innovation.9 In other words The computer has Opened a door for the police administrator that has been tightly fit j.— 81bid. 9Joseph A. Videtti, "Application of Computers in Law Enforcement," Police (July-August 1969), p. 38. 23 sealed. If we fail to utilize fully this device, we are not operating at our full potential.10 The changing requirements for information and the demands for improved communications have forced criminal justice agencies at all levels to consider new approaches. Computers are playing a significant role as tools for improving the performance of information systems.11 Modern methods and techniques of data processing systems offer an opportunity to open the door toward further progress. If the technology in the data processing field is used to free men's minds from dull tasks, as industrial technology is used to free them from laborious ones, the future of the criminal justice field will look much brighter. The concentration in criminal justice data processing installations must continue toward the direction of reducing clerical costs and labor. When valuable time of a law enforcement officer is spent on clerical functions, that much more time is lost for the prevention and detection of criminal activity. Personnel Information Systems Data processing applications for the personnel area were slow to materialize. Although the personnel ——7 10Eugene G. Columbus, "Basic Computer Concepts," The Police Chief (September 1968), p. 39. 11Law Enforcement Software Package (Data Processing Division, Sperry Rand Corporation, n.df), p. a. 24 function was mainly dealing with changes, for instance, in manpower requirements and organization, personnel Operating techniques were timeworn and hard to change.12 John Dearden pointed out that data concerning employees in the personnel department usually consisted Of historical and internal information. He further stated that the personnel department in a business environment is concerned with the flow of information about people working in the organization. This information is mainly used for accumulating data for promotional purposes or obtaining available talents.13 The first application in most companies Of data processing to personnel work was usually an extension Of some manual record keeping system. This is not surprising since clerical labor is the biggest time consumer in the personnel Office.14 One of the earliest personnel information systems was a highly develOped punched card system used by the U.S. Navy's Personnel Accounting Machine Installation. Source documents on all new personnel were processed daily by 12Richard T. Bueschel, "Changing Nature of Personnel," Personnel Journal (January 1966), p. 20. 13John Dearden, "How to Organize Information Systems," Harvard Business Review (March-April 1965), p. 69. 14Richard T. Bueschel, "How EDP is Improving the Personnel Function," Personnel (September-October 1964), p. 59. 25 each district headquarters. Status reports and personnel files were updated daily. Various reports were submitted periodically to the main headquarters from this punched card system.15 The General Electric Engineering Personnel Register was one of the early computerized systems. It was developed to enable the General Electric Company to make full use of the education, training, and experience of its engineering and scientific staff. Employees were listed on the register which contained descriptive and historical information. When a position became available in General Electric, a request was submitted for a manual scan of the register for available and qualified candidates.16 Many companies have used the computer to develop personnel data for specific purposes. One manufacturing company maintains data on its employees for labor relations purposes. The Bureau of the Census in Massachusetts has a system called SPARTAN (System for Personnel Automated Reports, Transactions, And Notices) that provides information on employee changes. The system prepares and addresses memoes to managers alerting them of up-coming 15Paul Duks, "Personnel Records: Along the Road to Automation," Personnel (May-June 1959), p. 31. 16 Ibid., p. 33. 26 events such as salary step increases, retirement eligibility, sick leave limits, awards, and probation periods.17 The Columbia Broadcasting System (CBS) is an example of how the computer is used in business and industrial administration. In addition to preparing normal reports from the payroll and personnel master, the computer at CBS analyzes employment sources. CBS benefits from . . . the capability the system provides management for getting the kind of information needed, when needed, with full confidence in its accuracy.18 Wesley R. Liebtag felt that personnel responsibilities include development of manpower and employee benefit programs according to management's objectives. He also felt that the personnel department is much more than a repository of employee information. It is involved with such activities as training programs and management development. During 1970 Liebtag wrote an article about IBM's computer systems designed to assist in personnel work.19 Liebtag wrote that IBM's various systems evolved into a comprehensive personnel data system that became an effective tool for supporting corporate objectives. This l7Bueschel, Op. cit., pp. 60-61. 18"Personnel Reports--A CBS Special," Business Automation (March 1965), p. 53. 19Wesley R. Liebtag, "How an EDP Personnel Data System Works for Corporate Growth," Personnel (July- August 1970). P. 15. 27 was accomplished while it helped fulfill the more traditional personnel functions. The system kept personnel information on approximately 150,000 IBM employees in the United States. The system was used to produce a variety of reports including analyses and projections. It pointed out many skills that were available to management and those that were needed for the future.20 During 1971 the U.S. Department of Commerce produced a report about its computerized system for personnel management. It was developed in order that the Department of Commerce could have a common set of manpower data and a common set of personnel Operative processes. With the installation of the system, the major personnel paper-work processing operations became fully automated.21 The Department of Commerce's computerized system's benefits included: improved record quality; increased productivity in recordkeeping Operations: improved accuracy and timeliness of personnel reporting; more effective personnel management; and expandability to include other subsystems.22 Steven J. Mayer in 1971 stated that the computer was being successfully utilized as a tool within the zoIbid., p. 20. 21United States Department of Commerce, Computerized Personnel Information System (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1971), p. i. 221bid., p. 45. 28 personnel function. He conducted an extensive survey based on a random sample of three-hundred and seventy-five major corporations in the United States. Computer utilizations were not as extensive in personnel functions as other functional areas. Personnel applications ranked only fifth out of the seven major functional areas. Mayer further discovered.that skills inventory applications were ranked second in the manpower development area of the personnel function. He attributed this to the belief that skills inventory programs help lay the foundation for manpower development programs.23 According to Bassett and Weatherbee personnel data systems in the past have typically been devices for satisfying local, state, and federal laws relating to the retention of records. The personnel data systems of today, however, are shifting toward broader uses of personnel data and an expansion from this source.24 The authors felt that the principal criteria of an effective modern personnel data system are: High data reliability; Low cost, efficient storage; Fast, inexpensive access capability; Simple, fast, low-cost summary and analysis capability; 23Steven J. Mayer, "EDP Personnel Systems: What Areas are Being Automated?" Personnel (July-August 1971), p. 29. 24Glenn A. Bassett and Harvard Y. Weatherbee, Personnel Systems and Data Management (Boston: American Management Association, 1971). P. 215. 29 High degree of system flexibility; Availability of both current and historical data; and Adequate protection of sensitive data.25 Data processing applications in the personnel area were slow to materialize, and they typically were designed in the past to satisfy government requirements. During more recent times personnel applications were designed to meet management's requirements within the organizational structure. In some cases the personnel information systems, that evolved over time, spun off programs for various personnel status reports, manpower requirements, and skills or talent information. Skills Inventory Systems The concern about skills information did not evolve because of personnel information systems, per se. Throughout the last several decades automation has created the need for new skills and Obsoleted others. The changes in skills became the concern of the labor force and in turn were brought to the attention of labor unions. Further, the creation in the early 1960's of the U.S. Office of Automation and Manpower, and passages of Manpower Development and Training bills, brought more attention to the needs of maintaining information on skills.26 It was mainly during ZSIbid, p. 216. 26Ewan Clague, Skill Development and Job Training in an Automated Age (Waéfiington, D.C.: U.S. Department Of Labor, November 17, 1961), pp. 6, 13, 18. 30 the 1960's that skills inventory systems became available to meet some of the needs of labor and management. The majority of information on skills evolved from manual and computerized personnel information systems. In the recent past, as is somewhat true today, many business organizations could readily provide inventory information about floor space, office equipment, machinery, supplies, and parts on-hand. However, if someone approached the personnel department and asked about the number of people with certain types of skills, it may take a day or even a week to supply an answer. Large companies and business organizations were the first to develop skills inventory systems to save time in the selection of peOple for job requirements. The IBM Corporation was one of the large businesses that expressed what has been pointed out in other publications concerning personnel and skills inventory systems. If personnel management is to make sound decisions involving employees, meaningful information on all aSpects of personnel is required. However, this information is usually scattered, with salary data filed in the payroll department, employee history and appraisal data kept in the personnel department or in manager's files, and skills data usually known only to the individual employees. Thus, retrieval of personnel data takes hours or even days of searching, and the data is often incomplete, incorrect, and outdated.27 27Personnel Data System (White Plains, New York: IBM Corporation, 1968), p. l. 31 PrOper planning of a skills inventory system can produce savings by avoiding needless hiring costs. Identification of employees skills can help in the transfer of an employee from one job to another. The organization's awareness of its skills profile is important in planning for future develOpments as well as unexpected ones. In addition, the skills inventory system could provide such reports as a confidential employee skills profile. This profile could be marked by the employee for updating purposes.28 During 1963 United Air Lines made use of a computerized skills system to provide management with the names of United's employees who were qualified for promotion. Information was retrieved upon request by 29 The managers and supervisors who had job openings. U.S. Air Force Logistics Command in 1963 constructed a computerized system for identifying candidates for promotion. Data on each employee was stored along with the responsibility level and type of position. When a vacancy occurred a form with appropriate skills was submitted for matching the qualifications of the employees with the job requirements of the vacancy.30 281bid., p. 3. 29Charles M. Mason, "Computer Improves Promotion Opportunities," Industrial Relations News (September 21, 1963), p. 3. 30Charles Garlet, "How a Computer Can do Your Personnel Selection," The Office (September 1963), p. 109. 32 Ronald D. Olsen stated that The ability to pinpoint employee skills rapidly, has in fact been such a problem that few companies have done an adequate job of compiling the skills of their employees.31 Prompted by the need for better manpower planning, the General Products Division of IBM developed a catalog of skills for its employees. This division found that as a data processing application a skills inventory system did not necessitate a complex programming effort. The design of the data collection format and designating the categories of needed information were the major challenges in the development of the system.32 Two vocabulary techniques are mainly used in business to collect skills information from employees. The two basic techniques are the Free English and Fixed Vocabulary. The Free English technique allows the employee to write at will about his skills. An analyst reviews the narrative and underlines the key words. Eventually the key words are transcribed for the skills inventory system. The Fixed Vocabulary technique is much more concise and perhaps more widely employed. Lists of predetermined skills are provided for the employee to check off, rather than 31Ronald D. Olsen, "Skills Inventory--A Step Toward Better Manpower Management," Manage (March 1963), p. 5. 321bid., p. 6. 33 codifying the employees skills after the information is collected. The General Products Division of IBM used the Fixed Vocabulary technique.33 Olsen felt that management's needs will dictate what skills are relative to its objectives, The types of skills that can be included in a skills inventory system are almost unlimited. These could include aptitude scores, civic activities, hobbies, military experience, performance evaluations, professional accomplishments, and technical expertise. The General Products Division collected its skills data in group sessions led by a personnel representative. The collection of skills data averaged fifty minutes per employee. Analysis and review averaged one to five minutes for each employee.34 The IBM Corporation produced in February of 1964 a publication entitled "Skills Inventory System for the IBM 1401." The three-hundred and sixty-eight page document and its related programming effort was the creation of a few IBM employees. Although the skills system met a basic set of programming and documentation standards it was not program tested in any formal fashion by the IBM Corporation.35 The skills system was documented and 33Ibid., p. 7. 34Ibid., p. 9. 358kills Inventory System for the IBM 1401 (Yorktown Height, New York: IBM Corporation, February 1964), 1401-10.3.049, p. III. 34 programmed for first-generation computer equipment. The total system was Obsoleted in due time and was not systems supported by IBM.36 Interestingly enough Richard T. Bueschel made some Observations about skills inventory systems the same year IBM produced its skills inventory publication. He stated that computers were being used to implement skills inventory programs to speedily locate the organization's talent resources. This was primarily true where organizations experienced the shortage of skilled professionals and a high cost of recruiting. Companies using skills inventory programs also tried to reduce turnover among its professionals. Some companies developed their skills inventory information from data that were gathered specifically for skills prOgrams. Others used data that were genemflly collected for personnel administration.37 John E. Keefe wrote that in Pennsylvania a computer skills system uncovered a range of previously unknown teacher skills. It further led to the initiation of intern programs whereby teachers could receive on-the-job training. His summation was that By letting administrators know when teachers are qualified for other positions, teachers from within the system have Opportunities at new 36Information by Mr. Alyn J. Rynbrandt, Marketing Representative, IBM Corporation, during personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, November 1, 1974. 37Bueschel, Op. cit., p. 63. 35 jobs or promotions, and the expense and time of outside recruitment is minimized.38 The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) installed an "Executive Selection Inventory System" for filling positions at the GS-15 level and above. The computerized skills inventory system provided FAA with a quick means of inventorying its resources and identifying qualified candidates from among its employees. The system identified candidates for training opportunities.39 Bassett and Weatherbee defined a skills inventory system in the following statement: _ A skills inventory is (in theory, at least) a day-to-day Operating tool which assures that every employee is considered for every job Opening he may be qualified for, that special talents are quickly located to meet special business needs, and that management decisions which turn upon the kinds of skills available in the organization are fully and soundly supported.40 Bassett and Weatherbee further stated that one of the major pitfalls with a skills inventory system is this: A skills inventory can seldom if ever be a decision-making device; its principal usefulness will be as a data-handling and information- producing tool.4 38John E. Keefe, "Computer Skills Bank Uncovers New Teacher Talent," Nation's Schools (June 1970), p. 56. 39George T. Reeves, The Executive Selection and Inventory_§ystem (Washington, D.C.: Federal Aviation Administration, August 21, 1970), p. l. 40 Bassett, op. cit., p. 176. 411bid., p. 183. 36 Criminal Justice Skills Inventory Systems Thus far the review of the literature has been segmented into background information, personnel information systems literature, and published works on skills inventory systems. This section will cover the literature about published and unpublished endeavors relative to skills inventory systems in the criminal justice area. During the early part of 1967 a study of the "Personnel Records Management" system was documented for the New Jersey State Police. The thirteen-hundred individual records in the personnel record system was in alphabetical order and was updated manually. The recommendation was that a punched card system be established for the processing of records until the system could be 42 Very little in the way of skills data was computerized. considered. The task force on "Science and Technology" in 1967 conducted many survey questionnaires in the criminal justice field on a national scale. The state and municipal agencies throughout the country reported the types of punched card applications and computer applications they were using. Personnel data and records were mentioned but 42James R. Lindholm, et a1., "System Study of Personnel Records" (unpublished report, February 1967), pp. 1, 47. 37 43 The nothing was reported about skills information. criminal justice agencies also listed their current and planned data processing applications. None Of the state or municipal agencies reported information about skills applications.44 The Kansas Highway Patrol created a two-page "Personnel Questionnaire" form on May 1, 1970 for Obtaining skills data. The form was set up for keypunching but was not developed beyond that format stage.45 The Department of State Police in Oregon operated a unit record skills system about fourteen years ago, but it was dropped for 46 its lack of utility in Oregon. The City of Los Angeles in 1972 maintains a unit record skills system for its police Officers. A one page "Officer Employee Inventory" form is used to capture the skills data. The system is being considered for computerization.47 43President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice, Task Force RepOrt: ‘Science and Technology (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967), pp. 158, 160. 44 Ibido ' Pp. 162-1650 45Information provided by and mailed from the Kansas Highway Patrol, Topeka, Kansas, June 29, 1972. 46Statement from the Department of State Police, Salem, Oregon, June 24, 1972. 47Correspondence from Captain W. G. Brown, Commanding Officer, Management Services Division, Department of Police, Los Angeles, California, June 22, 1972. 38 McDonell in his discussion about computer applications talked about personnel files and skills data. He stated that A talent inventory containing the special knowledge, skills, and talents of police personnel can be maintained and made available for search on a moments notice. Such a file, maintained in a data center for a number of police departments could be an important asset to a chief who has a pressing need for some special skill or talent. The criminal justice agencies of Sussex, including Brighton, Eastbourne, East Sussex, and Hastings, in England, combined forces in 1968 to create a computerized personnel record system. This unqiue approach produced individual computerized records for each police Officer. The data content of each record included some Of the following subject headings: marital status, present rank, present position, constables, sergeants, scholastic, stops, retirement qualifications, appointment, first aid, children, promotions, duty requests, examinations, courses, life saving, sickness, gradings, and punishments.49 This record keeping system could with additional modifications produce skills information especially if more skills were captured from each police Officer. The St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department computerized its personnel file in the early 1970's. A 48McDonell, op. cit., p. 9. 49A. F. Hiscocks, "The Computerization of Administrative Records," The Police Journal (January 1969) ' pp. 10' 15—160 ’39 skills inventory was incorporated into the personnel system along with other pertinent data. The personnel file is updated through certain specified computer terminals. A one-page survey form and a two-page skills code listing are usedlx>obtain skills information from each police Officer.50 Sheppard and Glickman wrote a book describing their efforts for constructing career path programs for criminal justice agencies. They discovered that research covering career paths whether of the manual or computer type were generally over looked. They stated that there was a lack of analysis for jobs and tasks, criteria on performance, descriptive job related information, organizational effectiveness measurements, and methodical job evaluations.51 They hoped that their endeavors would give the necessary impetus for future efforts which could . . . establish more refined criteria for charting specific career paths through a police department so that develOpment and utilization of individual skills can be further maximized and overall organizational effectiveness further improved.52 Sheppard and Glickman developed a model career path system during the course of their research. It represented 50Correspondence from Mr. Richard A. Missavage, Manager, Computer Division, Metropolitan Police Department, St. Louis, Missouri, July 6, 1972. 51David I. Sheppard and Albert S. Glickman, Police Careers (Springfield: Charles C. Thomas, 1973), p. vii. 52Ibid., p. viii. 40 four major phases of career pathing. The four phases were career orientation, career placement, career mobility, and career development and planning. As regards the latter phase, they recommended that There should be provision for a Career Development Office within a police agency. This office should make and maintain an inventory of skills, training, and experience of the total commissioned force, as well as specific requirements of available assignments. In this way recommendations could be made to those divisions needing personnel that would draw from the largest available pool of qualified applicants.53 Many companies invested time and money in a computerized personnel information system to help trace and locate employee skills within their organizations. The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department during 1970 examined some of these companies. They were surveyed with the Objective of garnering information on their computerized systems for possible inclusion in criminal justice related programs. It was learned that in many companies emphasis was placed on developing the managerial staff and not the career growth of all employees. The conclusion was that the companies were aiming at developing managerial potential which was not that adaptable to career development needs of the individual Officer.54 53Ibid., pp. 98-99. 54U.S. Department of Justice, Career Development for Law Enforcement (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, June 1973), pp. 16, 26. 41 The Sheriff's Department was unable to identify any single computerized system suitable to the needs of criminal justice. It then was decided to extract and blend data elements into a system compatible with criminal justice needs. The Sheriff's Department expressed its disappointment by saying The awareness of this single most overriding condition--the lack of total systems directed at the development and utilization of police personnel--is the most challenging finding of the 'state-of-the-art survey.‘ 5 The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department designed and developed the Automated Personnel Information System (APIS) to provide rapid access to personnel records compatible with criminal justice needs. The Sheriff's Department expects APIS to be operational within six months following the acquisition of a computer.56 Summary Personal and personnel skills inventory systems have been developed in a variety of sizes and styles, of which there are three main types: manual; unit record or punch card; and computerized. The majority of the systems are truly personnel record files containing skills data without available reporting methods; few appear to produce skills oriented reports. 55Ibid., pp. 27, 34. 56Ibid., pp. 62, 7o. 42 The review of literature did not disclose any active, but independent, computerized personal skills inventory systems. Nor were there any computerized systems with interactive inventory files associated with comprehensive personnel information systems. Since the Michigan State Police does not maintain a computerized personnel system, an independent skills system will satisfy the goals and needs at this time. The ideal type would be a comprehensive personnel system with integrated skills data or with an interactive skills file. Both concepts must include the ability to input and output data to the comprehensive system. CHAPTER III METHODOLOGY Overview It appears as though personal skills information, in the majority of cases, is tucked away in personnel files or is known only by the individual. When unique skills are requested in most situations, manual searches are made in personnel files or it becomes necessary to make lengthy personal contacts. This procedure may work fine in some situations but is not adequate, for instance, in emergencies. It involves an industrious and time-consuming process. Even when a manual system exists, the feedback process is slow and the information usually contains errors and is out- dated. The thesis proposes replacing a manual system with a computerized one in a case study involving a criminal justice agency. The Training Division of the Bureau of Staff Services for the Michigan State Police (MSP) was selected as the case study. Since 1966, the Training Division maintained a manual skills inventory system. It included such items as education, training, and individual skills for all MSP 43 44 Officers. Tables 1 and 2 list the skills categories for the previous and current manual skills inventory systems. Today's manual system evolved out of the 1966 system. It exists even though it was projected for computerization for the 1970 fiscal year. Three successive Commanding Officers from the MSP Training Division requested that their manual system be computerized. As stated previously, the manual skills inventory system was used by the Training Division to search for persons with varying qualifications for certain specialized functions and tasks. During November of 1976 two requests for specialized skills were needed. In the Lansing metropolitan area a Spanish-speaking officer from the Michigan State Police was needed because of a particular law enforcement situation. An MSP officer who could translate Arabic was also needed in the Detroit area.1 These requests and others are made to the Training Division for searching the skills file on a manual basis. Theoretical Formulation It has been implied in the previous two chapters that this study takes the position that a dearth Of computerized personal skills inventory systems exists today in the criminal justice field. As the desire and 1Information by Sgt. Timothy J. Baker, Training Division, Michigan State Police, during phone conversation, Lansing, Michigan, December 17, 1976. 45 need increases, it is incumbent upon criminal justice practitioners and researchers to develop basic systems which will effectively serve as a catalyst for further research and development. It appears as though this has not been accomplished to date especially in reference to the review of the literature. It should be noted that this thesis utilizes the methods encountered in analytical research. This method of research has been defined by Carter V. Good as . . . research that has for its purpose the discovery of the composition and struSture of a given case, object, or variable. The problem facing the researcher utilizing this method of research is to at least define the area of improvements in an existing situation, isolate the factors, and propose a tentative solution. Good also stated that A comprehensive definition of the sc0pe of educational research served as a guiding principle for summarizing materials in the 1969 edition of the Encyclopedia of Educational Research, with research broadly conceived to incorporate all kinds of contributions to educational knowledge (not simply the results from formally designed experimental studies), including analyses of problems, critiques of educational practices, and reports of practical experiences. 2Carter V. Good, Dictionary of Education (New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1959), p. 464. 3Carter V. Good, Essentials of Educational Research (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1972), pp. 4-5. 46 Chester W. Harris wrote that Educational research is thus probably best defined broadly as any systematic striving for understanding actuated by a need or sensed difficulty directed toward some complex phenomenon of more than immediate personal concern stated in problematic form. Mr. Harris further wrote that Research appeals to reason, employs evidence, and is based upon the principles of sound thinking. It is systematic rather than incidental and casual.5 The purpose of the case study, as stated in Chapter I, is to propose to the Michigan State Police (MSP) Training Division a practical method for inventorying the personal skills as a prototype model for every MSP Officer on a computerized rather than manual basis. Problem Related to Prgposal Three Commanding Officers from the model agency have requested that their Training Division's skills inventory system be computerized on the Michigan Law Enforcement Information Network (LEIN). The manual system of inventorying the MSP skills has existed since 1966. The system was projected during the 1970 fiscal year for LEIN. It must have its merit and need for existence since 4Chester W. Harris, "Research Methods," Encyclopedia of Educational Research (New York: The MacMillan Company, 1960). p. 1160. 51bid. 47 the three Commanding Officers have persisted with the conversion concept for a decade. The thesis endeavor will provide a case study suitable for adaptive replication by other criminal justice agencies. The task of maintaining, searching, and updating a manual system is laborious. The problem is labor, and the need is accuracy, efficiency, and speed. The thesis study will be very helpful to the model agency. A computerized system would not only be beneficial during emergency situations and for the officer on patrol, but it would be helpful administratively as well. The Training Division periodically has to answer requests regarding birth date, birth place, and date a person joined the MSP. Personnel from the MSP Crime Laboratory make frequent inquiries for officers with two years of college or more in the sciences. The MSP Executive Division occasionally requests names of officers with college background for assignments in planning and research, crime prevention, legislative analysis, and community services. The Training Division looks at the academic credentials for selecting personnel for temporary or permanent assignment relating to training courses. During the early part of December Of 1976 a lieutenant, who was ready for retirement, requested a list of the schools attended since joining the mPOG 6Information by Sgt. Timothy J. Baker, Training Division, Michigan State Police, during phone conversation, Lansing, Michigan, December 17, 1976. 48 When the computerized personal skills inventory system is implemented it will provide a beneficial service not only to the Training Division but throughout the Michigan State Police organization. When selective information is requested, the Training Division will be able to provide updated information and respond quickly with that information. The prOposed computerized system is planned to be functional rather than esthetic. The intention is to devise a practical proposal for replacing the manual system with a computerized one. The proposal takes into consideration the use of the existing LEIN data processing equipment.' The prOposal will consider other data processing equipment where needed. The social security number will act as the control for the system, but is not intended as a connector with any present or future on-line application file or system. The intention is also to develop the study to the point where the thesis copy can be submitted by the Training Division to the Data Processing Division for further systems analysis, writing the appropriate programs, and physically implementing the project as a routine job. Conceptual Framework The formation of the proposal for the computerized personal skills inventory system will be analytical in nature and simplified in application. The proposal addresses aspects relative to an independent rather than 49 integrated system, because a computerized personnel file or system does not exist. The development will follow the structure Of systems analysis. This includes the under- standing Of the present Training Division's manual system and a good grasp of the requirements of the prOposed system. My data processing experience will be included. After analyzing for content both manual skills inventory files maintained by the Training Division, various lists will be devised which will contain many categories of personal skills including those researched in the Training Division's manuals. The categories to be included are: birth date; anniversary date; classification date; foreign language; military service; residence county; education level; education major; post assignment; classification title; birth place; military draft; law enforcement; publication record; academic rank; professional development; and special skills. All skills as well as other related data will be considered for the proposed system. A lot of time will be spent on operational information. Even though the proposal will include a voluminous amount of material, this does not mean that all the data need to be used to implement a skills system. The Fixed Vocabulary technique will be employed in the proposal. This technique is concise and is widely used. It includes lists of predetermined skills for the MSP Officer to check-Off. 50 The proposal is simplified in application. It will consider the input, processing, output, and other resources that impact the proposal. Hardware considerations, Of course, will be discussed along with the LEIN system. The proposal will take into consideration storage capacity. Flowcharting techniques covering various aspects will be used to clarify and explain concepts. The proposal will involve the application procedures for the skills inventory system. Sample forms for implementation and maintenance will appear throughout the proposal. The input and maintenance forms, for instance, will be constructed in such a way that the individual's data can be readily transcribed from the form to some type of data processing medium (hardware). Limitations of Research A follow-up survey of the national type that was employed in 1972 will not transpire. The reasoning is that the review of literature disclosed relevant published works on manual and computerized personal and personnel skills information systems. The proposal will not consider nor will there be any programs written for implementing the thesis study on a computer system. This idea itself could entail a complete and separate thesis endeavor. 51 The thesis will encompass systems analysis concepts but not to the extent that is expected or performed by a Systems Analyst. A full fledged systems study is not the intent of the thesis endeavor. Summagy In summary, the methodology will mainly be analytical. It will involve practical considerations in systems analysis, hardware, flowcharting, forms design, skills categories, the Fixed Vocabulary technique, storage capacity, and computer processing methods. The purpose of the study is to propose to the Training Division a practical system of inventorying the personal skills for every MSP Officer on a computerized basis. CHAPTER IV PRESENTATION OF PROPOSAL Overview This chapter is devoted to the proposed computerized personal skills inventory system for the Training Division of the Michigan State Police. The operational uses of the system are presented as two types: (1) the actual operational aspects of the system; and (2) the management information system concepts. Michigan's Law Enforcement Information Network (LEIN) is described in the next few pages. It is introduced early in the chapter as background information for identifying the environment for the skills system. The chapter addresses various concepts and variables for the proposed system. It uses the Fixed Vocabulary technique, and includes discussions about categories of personal skills, application procedures, storage methods, and forms design. Future uses of the proposed system are also discussed. 52 53 The LEIN System In November of 1965 an advisory committee was formed to discuss existing and future considerations of operating an information system for the criminal justice community of Michigan. There were many philOSOphical views outlined. Some of the needs established for a centralized system were: (1) cumbersome and slowly Operated manual files used in most police jurisdictions; (2) fragmentation of police powers; (3) pressure on present communications facilities; and (4) the police Officer's safety was compromised. The question of where the files should be located was also addressed. There were compelling reasons that dictated the location at the state level rather than at the local level of government. Those reasons given were: (1) most crimes committed violate state laws; (2) files exist in some form at the state level; and (3) standardization of individual department records.1 The proposed information system at first was known as the Michigan Police Information Network (PIN). The system was later changed to the Law Enforcement Information Network (LEIN). Michigan's LEIN system had its beginning during 1966 when the legislature appropriated the funds to the Michigan State Police (MSP). The funds were appropriated 1John R. Plants, "Statewide Computer Based Law Enforcement Information Systems," Law Enforcement Science and Technology (Washington, D.C.: Thompson Book Company, 1967). PP. 523-525. 54 "to establish a computer based central data bank of police oriented information."2 The system design and vendor selection was completed during August of 1966. Burroughs' B5500 computer system was delivered during March of 1967. The LEIN system was on the air on July 1, 1968. Prior to implementing the 35500, MSP had a modest unit record system which included an IBM 101 Statistical Sorter. Initially, there were well over one-hundred ASR28 Teletype terminals attached to the B5500. Appendix E shows the basic B5500 information during the earlier years of LEIN.3 The LEIN system was created to serve seven-hundred and sixty-eight criminal justice agencies in Michigan. These agencies included county, municipal, and state police departments. The teletype terminals directly connect well over one-hundred jurisdictions to the LEIN system. Those agencies without a terminal are within radio communications of a terminal. LEIN's primary mission is to serve the patrol officers.4 As stated previously the Michigan legislature appropriated the funds for the LEIN. According to John R. Plants: 2Fladseth, Op. cit., p. 191. 3"State of Michigan Law Enforcement Information Network" (unpublished report by the LEIN Policy Advisory Committee, East Lansing, Michigan, October 1, 1968), pp. 1, 8. 4Ibid. 55 The cost of the system from its inception in 1966 through the fiscal year ending June 30, 1969, totals $2.7 million. This includes $75,000 for the study and design portion; $344,000 for the first year of implementation; $1,000,000 for the first full year of Operation; and $1,250 000 for the present fiscal year (1969-70).5 Plants stated further that The Michigan LEIN has just scratched the surface of service to police agencies. There are many applications to be implemented and there are many applications to be conceived. And while the problems connected with police computers are tremendous, the rewards can be infinitely greater.6 Approximately eleven years ago Michigan's LEIN was conceived on paper, and it became a reality over eight years ago. In little over a decade the LEIN system expanded and progressed with data processing hardware and software. Appendix E lists LEIN's basic configuration for 1975.7 The equipment is supplied by the Burroughs Corporation. The LEIN system operates twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week, with COBOL used as the primary programming language. In less than a decade Michigan's law enforcement officers have seen information retrieved from a slow manual process to a computerized LEIN system.which provides 5John R. Plants, "Michigan's Law Enforcement Information Network," Datamation (June 1969), p. 108. 6Ibid. 7Information by James E. Kipp, Supervisor, Computer Operations, Data Processing Division, Michigan State Police, during personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, August 13, 1975. 56 instant data. LEIN is automatically connected with a national system, and many state and municipal systems. These systems give Michigan's law enforcement officers updated information on a state and nation-wide basis. Michigan's LEIN provides access to criminal justice information from such municipal police departments as Dearborn Heights, Detroit, and Saginaw. It has access to data from Michigan's Judicial Data Center and Secretary of State. The Secretary of State's computerized system furnishes information about driver's records and vehicle registrations. LEIN is directly connected with the Automated Law Enforcement Communications System (ALECS). The following states are associated with ALECS: Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio, and Wisconsin. Ohio's computerized system is known as LEADS (Law Enforcement Agencies Data System). The LEIN system is also linked with the National Crime Information Center (NCIC). The NCIC is maintained by the Federal Bureau of Investigation in Washington, D.C. The NCIC has such files as criminal histories, stolen and wanted vehicles, stolen property, and warrants. Michigan's LEIN system in turn supplies information about such data as impounded vehicles, traffic accident activity, and civil, felony, and traffic warrants. Since its inception the LEIN system has not only expanded internally but has been enlarged through interfacing other municipal, state and national computerized 57 systems. As additional systems are connected to Michigan's LEIN, more and more teletype terminals are available to communicate data to Michigan's law enforcement Officers. Appendix E8 depicts the current LEIN system and other interfacing systems. Preparatory Process The prOposed computerized personal skills inventory system is mainly designed to address those who are currently Michigan State Police (MSP) Officers. It does not specifically address those who will be going through the recruit school or those officers who are retired. The MSP Training Division's current manual system was not designed to collect information from the recruit or retired Officer. However, the proposed system could be adapted to handle them should the need arise. The prOposed system is oriented toward the individual MSP officer recording the personal skills. Inventorying the skills would be the responsibility of the Training Division which is where it has been for a decade. The various skill categories will be presented later. However, for the purpose of the thesis the word skills is defined as a developed proficiency in some particular activity. The activity usually requires a special training or knowledge for competence or expertise in its practice. 81bid. 58 In order to capture the skills data and its related information, each Officer must fill out a Personal Skills Inventory Form. The proposed form appears as Figure 2. The form is necessary in that it identifies the individual by social security number and badge number. The Officer is also expected to record the current date and supply information concerning the name, address, sex, and dependents. The form is also necessary because a computerized personnel file or system does not exist. In addition to the Personal Skills Inventory Form, the officer is expected to mark the appropriate information listed in each subject category. Some of the information for each category was accumulated from interviews with several MSP officers in the Training Division and material that was presented to me during the interviews (see Appendix B and Tables 1 and 2). Other information was extracted from the literature review and three police department's skill forms that are located in Appendix F. The subject categories are presented in Figures 5 through 21. These figures appear at the end rather than in the middle of this chapter in order to provide continuity for the reader. The Fixed Vocabulary technique9 is used for the seventeen categories. Each category is assigned a unique two-position alphabetic code. Every data element in turn is assigned a seven—position code consisting Of two alpha and five numeric positions. A coding scheme Of v—l 9Olsen, op. cit., pp. 7-8. 59 Please record or mark the appropriate information on this page. Last Name - 20 First Name - 12 Middle Name - 12 Apartment Apartment Name - 18 Number - 6 Street Street Name - 18 Number -6 l MCIN City - 20 State - 8 Social Security Number - 9 Current Date [[1 Month Male .L__., Number Of Dependents: One Five Two Six Three Seven Four Eight Badge Number - 4 Elli] Year Female Nine Ten Eleven Twelve Zip Code - 5 ' Thirteen Fourteen Fifteen Sixteen Figure 2.--Personal Skills Inventory Form. 60 this type helps eliminate the linguistic difficulties often present in describing information. Not only can the data elements be selected individually, but they also can be selected by subject category. The categories and their coding ranges are listed in Table 4 in the same order as they are presented in Figures 5 through 21. As noted each subject category is supplied with instructions. The instructions are self-explanatory and cover conditions for the individual to record additional data elements where needed. The majority of the categories can be readily updated and maintained by the MSP Training Division. An obvious example would be adding or deleting some civil service positions for the classification title category. The individual officer may have to add certain data elements for such categories as birth place, foreign language, education major, education level, and special skills. It makes no difference whether the Training Division suggests new data elements for each category or the individual Officer makes the suggestion. The data elements are coded with enough spread between them that adding or deleting data elements would not affect the logical sequence of the subject category. The data elements are incremented by twenty-fives. The military service category has examples of data elements that were added. The codes for these elements are MSlOl40, M820141, M810290, and M820291. 61 TABLE 4.--Subject Category. Category Data Item Coding Range Residence County Birth Date Birth Place Anniversary Date Classification Date Classification Title Post Assignment Law Enforcement Military Service Military Draft Publication Record Foreign Language Month Day Year State City Month Day Year Month Day Year Township Department Municipal Department County Department State Department Federal Department Another Country Enlisted Rank Officer Rank Papers Presented Articles Published Books Published Inventions Patented Translate Speak Read Write RC10025-RC12075 BD10025-BD10300 BD20026-BD20776 BD30027-BD31627 BP10025-BP11350 BP2____fBP2_____ AD10025-AD10300 AD20026-AD20776 AD30027-AD31627 CD10025-CD10300 CD20026-CD20776 CD30027-CD31627 CT10025-CT10875 PA10025-PA11650 LE10025-LE10650 LE20026-LE20651 LE30027-LE30652 LE40028-LE40653 LE50029-LE50654 LE60030-LE60655 MSlOOZS-MSllOSO M820026-M821051 MD10025-MD10475 PR10025-PR10500 PR20026-PR20501 PR30027-PR30502 PR40028-PR40503 FL10025-FL11400 FL20026-FL21401 FL30027-FL31402 FL40028-FL41403 TABLE 4.--Continued. 62 Category Data Item Coding Range Education Majors Education Level Academic Rank Professional Development Special Skills Certificate Majors Degree Majors Did Hold Currently Holding Honorary Degree Societal Association Professional Association Professional Award Professional License EM10025-EM13100 EM20026-EM23101 EL10025-EL11025 AR10025-AR10325 AR20026-AR20326 PD10025-PD10500 PD20026-PD20501 PD30027-PD30502 PD40028-PD40503 PD50029-PD50504 SSlOOZS-SSl4875 63 After completing the Personal Skills Inventory Form and marking the relevant data elements for all subject categories, the MSP officer would forward the information to the post commander or appropriate supervisor. The information would then be returned to the Training Division for transcription on cards, paper tape, magnetic tape, or disk. The officer's record would be kept intact and identified by a control number. This control or identification number is the social security number. If the MSP Data Processing Division cannot transcribe the data because of staff limitations, the data could be contracted to a data processing service bureau for the initial transcription. Storage Medium Storing the data is the next area for consideration. Less than a decade ago it was very popular to maintain data on cards even though other mediums existed. It was cheaper in the long run to process cards than utilize magnetic tape or disk. Storing data on paper tape is not as widely used today as is the case with cards. In most instances paper tape is used in connection with facilitating record processing in an off-line mode, rather than the storage of data. Magnetic tape processing has been and will continue to be a storage medium for data. The price for magnetic tape has remained relatively stable but the storage 64 capacity per tape has increased significantly. Within the last decade tape storage for a twenty-four hundred foot reel of tape, for instance, has increased from eight hundred bytes-per-inch (BPI) to sixty-four hundred BPI. Disk storage has become the most popular medium in recent years. Data stored on disk is extremely fast to access and update. Disk storage per pack has increased over ten times its capacity in less than a decade. The monthly cost for a million bytes of storage per disk pack has decreased from $179.00 in 1962 to $1.81 in 1975. (See Appendix G for the 0 In the near future the MSP Data IBM Disk Comparisons.)l Processing Division may be storing data on magnetic bubble chips. Perhaps the data bubbles will be reCOgnized as the official beginning of the fourth generation of computer equipment. The MSP Data Processing Division utilizes cards, paper tape, magnetic tape, and magnetic disk for the Law Enforcement Information Network and other types Of processing. It would seem appropriate to recommend that the initial transcription of the Personal Skills Inventory Form and subject skills be keypunched on cards. The data could be keypunched into these card formats: 10Information provided by Don A. Perrin, Acting Director, Administrative Data Processing Department, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, May 14, 1976. 65 Card Type Field Name Card Columns Social Security Number (9) 1-9 Last Name (20) 11-30 First Name (12) 32-43 Middle Name (12) 45-56 Badge Number (4) 58-61 Current Date: Month, Day, Year (6) 63-68 Sex (1) 70 Number of Dependents (2) 72-73 Apartment Number (6) 1-6 Apartment Name (18) 8-25 Street Number (6) 27-32 Street Name (18) 34-51 City (20) 53-72 Zip Code (5) 74-78 Data Element Code (7) 1-7 Data Element Code (7) 8-14 Data Element Code (7) 15-21 Data Element Code (7) 22-28 Data Element Code (7) 29-35 Data Element Code (7) 36-42 Data Element Code (7) 43-49 Data Element Code (7) 50-56 Data Element Code (7) 57-63 Data Element Code (7) 64-70 Data Element Code (7) 71-77 The numbers in parentheses by each field name represent the field length. The three cards are called: A = name card; B = address card; and C = data card. The word "Michigan" is not keypunched in the address card. The reasoning is that this eight-position field can be 66 inserted with program control if desired in storage and when needed for printing purposes. In fact the current year, which is keypunched in the card A, can be eliminated and put under program control. All three cards have card columns 79-80 Open. Although it is not necessary to code the three cards, the last two positions could be used for coding. The card type could be keypunched in column eighty. The first card would have an A in column eighty, the second would have a B, and all data cards would have a C. Another coding scheme Often used is punching sequentially the card number in columns 79-80 during the keypunching process. In both cases the social security number would still be the identifier or control for the individual's record. Computer Procedure Coding the individual's record is a safe practice but not necessary with today's processing methods. Under program control there are at least two methods available for controlling computerized records. First, the systems procedure could call for taping the cards in card image format. The application program can be designed to identify the name card because of the social security number in columns one through nine. The address card can be identified because column seven is blank. The data card is easily identified because columns one and two contain alpha information and columns three through seven contain 67 numeric: information. Every record would contain the minimum of three cards. If three cards did not exist, the individual's record would be rejected as an error and not processed any further. The above procedure would also apply for the second method under program control. The exception is that the cards would be taped but not in card image format. The first card read would be identified by social security number and that number would automatically be inserted for every subsequent card. As each card is read the application program would search for nine numeric positions in columns one through nine which is where the social security number is located. When the number is located, the prOgram would recognize the start of another record. When taping is completed, all records would be processed through a program edit routine. This routine would detect errors in records. If the badge number contained other than numeric information, this would be an example Of an error in the name card. An error in the address card, for example, would be numeric data in the city field. The data card would contain errors if for example the data element code contained other than alpha information in columns one and two and numeric information in columns three through seven. Error records detected during the edit routine and errors discovered during the taping process would be combined and printed on an error listing. The Training Division would have the 68 responsibility of rectifying all errors and re-submitting the corrected records for updating the tape file. When this process was complete, the tape file would be dumped on disk for on-line processing. The proposal thus far calls for creating a computerized personal skills inventory system in an Off-line mode. With the data residing on disk, the system is ready for on-line processing. The Training Division will need to requisition an ASR28 teletype terminal. This terminal should be the only additional piece of data processing equipment needed for the proposed system. The terminal can be used to update the disk file and print selected profiles. It can be used to print listings based upon selecting data element codes. The terminal also can be used for training purposes when recruit school or other training schools are in session. The next step is to create a feedback process for every MSP officer. .This would entail printing a Personal Skills Inventory Profile. The MSP Data Processing Division would print all profiles in alphabetical order by officer name. After receiving the profile, the individual would have the Opportunity to verify the accuracy of the complete record and make additions or deletions. These changes could be written on the actual profile. In addition to this the individual may fill out a Personal Skills Inventory Change Form (see Figure 3). The form is 69 .Euom omcmso muouco>cH waaflxm Hmeomummli.m shaman cofluocoamxm sumo mtou oumama wvou 66¢ Honesz Muensowm Hofloom 70 designed to add or delete data element codes that are listed in each subject category. As the corrected profiles and change forms are returned to the Training Division, the records residing on disk can be updated through the teletype terminal. After the initial feedback process is complete, profiles could be printed annually at the beginning of each fiscal year or around the individual's anniversary date. This yearly feedback in effect allows the individual to perform an annual audit of the complete record. The system is designed for the individual to monitor the record. Other means of monitoring must be considered as well. The ASR28 teletype terminal can be monitored through software. The terminal can be identified through software design so that it is the only terminal allowed to access the computerized personal skills inventory system. Along this same line Of thinking, every request for information must be scrutinized. The Training Division should insist that every request for information be put in writing. A Retrieval Request Form could be designed to handle written requests. The requests should be evaluated to determine whether or not they are in fact necessary and desirable. It is essential both for the success of the system and to assure proper adherence to security and privacy that access to information not be permitted without clear and compelling evidence on a need-to-know basis. 71 The computerized system can be monitored quite easily with the exception of emergencies. There will be times when information is needed immediately. A request may originate because of a long distance phone call. Another emergency request may be dispatched from a patrol car. It is quite conceivable that an MSP officer may get involved in a situation with, for instance, an escapee from the Milan Federal Correctional Facility, or, even worse, a hostile person. The officer may need to know immediately the location of the closest available officer who can translate Slovakian and who is also familiar with explosives. The teletype selection parameters would be: (1) closest available officer = select code PA; (2) translate Slovakian = select code FLlll75; and (3) explosives = select code 8811600. Profiles would print from the terminal for those who met the selection. There may be cases where the selection must be broader than this example. On the other hand, some selections may be so specific in nature that only one data element code is needed. Figure 4 illustrates the computerized personal skills inventory system in flowcharting concepts. The proposed system can be designed with more flexibility and criteria than has been emphasized. The phone number and area code could be included in the system. Other data element codes can be created for such administrative areas 72 muouum mcwmma .unmaoaoam Emumhm whouam>oH maaflxm Hosomuomii.v onsmam ween egos mpuou co .maflm coaucmuon muonomfimu ou monou II In .OHHM coausmumu muonomfiwu pmnossohox I once \ \moflmwm sOHmH>flo ou mmfluomoumo pounaSm nufl3 meuom WmRD u < nowuomouou pomflnsm cues mEHom >uoucm>cH maawxm announce In \ 73 :mew>wo measwmua menom wmsoco saws mmawwoum .pmscwu:00ti.v unamam .maee ghee some iilv mmoflunwa poo moafimoum pouooaom u m .meee xnep openness u m .mcwuotms How HoswEMou on mEMOm cocono suw3 moHHwoum u o .anm soflucouou unconfined on some n o VII/I amen mummsvom HOHHm Owuomaom pmucwum mHHex . D announce D muouum puma madcwoua‘ll. Wm\o.n..nmlow / mafia / Omen. mcwusom \ xmflo \ @1 Eonmoum 74 as deceased, disabled, dismissed, and resigned officers. The date fields can be reduced on the computer from six to five positions. Instead of using the traditional month, day, and year concept, the calendar year and julian date can be used. October 1, 1976 would print as 76275. The subject categories also can be computerized. This would be known as a Subject Category Table. The table could be updated easier and printed as needed. Future Functional Uses The MSP organization does not have a computerized personnel master. The proposed system contains items that normally appear in a personnel master. It was created with this in mind. If a personnel master existed, the study would have been constructed with that data base taken into consideration. The remainder of this section is devoted to other management concepts that are skills oriented. Before these concepts become a reality in terms of computerized files, the MSP Training Division must analyze its objectives. It is quite conceivable that a management information system (MIS) might evolve from the analysis. The proposed computerized personal skills inventory system was designed for the Training Division to control and monitor on-line. After approximately a year's experience with the on-line system, other teletype terminals located at various district headquarters could be connected to the system. These terminals would not need to have 75 access to the complete skills file. Their accessibility could be handled through software control. District headquarters, for instance, would access the file and receive only skills related information. The terminals would not be allowed to print a complete profile nor update the profile. If security controls and procedures were implemented in advance of releasing information via the terminal, personal records will be protected as they are now with the manual system. Other criminal justice agencies may have a compelling need to seek individuals with certain skills. If they had a contact point, such as the Training Division, perhaps solutions to immediate problems might save lives. There is no reason to think that the MSP officer on patrol and patrol Officers from other organizations do not run into the same type of problems periodically. Procedures could be implemented so that police Officers from other agencies could contact district headquarters or the Training Division to search for MSP Officers with skills needed at the point-in-time. These procedures should not be that difficult to implement once the Training Division gains experience in handling the skills system for itself and the various district headquarters. This process would foster good relations between the criminal justice agencies. There are going to be times when criminal justice agencies bordering MiChigan will need the immediate 76 assistance of the Michigan State Police. These contacts can promote interstate cooperation especially if the turn around to the needs is expedient. A good example here might be criminal activity involving migrant farm workers. Another situation could involve individuals living in Michigan but working in another state. The outstate agency may need assistance with translating. The circumstances could dictate the need for certain expertise to solve a particular crime. The demand for a skill might be as simple as requesting that some MSP Officers participate in a seminar or training exercise. The procedures for handling out-of-state requests from the skills system would follow the same regulations that exist for cooperating with interstate criminal justice agencies. Another functional use involves those Michigan criminal justice agencies that currently have teletype terminals connected to the Law Enforcement Information Network. Through proper training and well-defined procedures these agencies could inventory the skills of their own personnel. These skills could at first be entered into the MSP computerized personal skills inventory system through a batch process. Later, the profiles could be updated on-line from the agency's terminal. This expanded skills system would produce an inventory Of skills to handle almost any crisis situation imaginable. However, it may be wise to begin such a system as a pilot project before inviting all agencies to contribute their 77 skills data. A skills inventory system that encompasses all Michigan criminal justice agencies could identify, for instance, instructors for training purposes. There are many other functional uses that could be discussed in the thesis. However, this subject area will only cover one other future use for the prOposed computerized personal skills inventory system. It involves inventorying skills for the Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council (MLEOTC). Michigan's Public Act 203 provided for the creation of MLEOTC on July 16, 1965. Today, it is a division of the Bureau of Staff Services of the Michigan State Police. The Division's staff are guided by the Council's policies and programs.11 The Council members, who determine the standards for recruit selection and training, represent a cross section of police agencies throughout the state. The Council is composed of: The Attorney General of the State. The Commissioner of the State Police. Three members selected by the Michigan Association of Chiefs of Police. Three members selected by the Michigan Sheriffs Association One member selected by the Fraternal Order Of Police. 11Information by Mr. Wesley Hoes, Assistant Executive Secretary, Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council, during personal interview, Lansing, Michigan, November 2, 1976. 78 One member selected by the Metropolitan Club. One member selected by the associations representing Detroit Police Officers.12 There are fourteen regional training centers in Michigan. These training facilities are located in the major pOpulation areas. The primary purpose of MLEOTC is to provide training for police officers in all local jursidictions. The various training programs include: basic recruit training; advanced police training; police alcohol training; supervisory training; management training; 13 and instructor training. MLEOTC's goals are to support local law enforcement agencies by: (1) Providing and maintaining selection and training standards that contribute to efficient,effective and relevant manpower development. (2) Providing support for local agency training efforts through the contribution of technical and financial support where possible. (3) Developing and presenting career path training programs that can not be feasibly accomplished at the local level. (4) Maintaining liaison with other components of the criminal justice systems for the coordi- nation of training and educational efforts.14 12Know Your Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Trainingygouncil (Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training CounciI-MLEOTC, Department of State Police, Lansing, Michigan, n.d.), p. 2. 13Information by Mr. Wesley Hoes, Assistant Executive Secretary, Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council, during personal interview, Lansing Michigan, November 2, 1976. 14MLEOTC, Op. cit., p. 7. 79 MLEOTC has established minimum standards for training. Appendix H lists the minimum basic police training totaling 256 hours. MLEOTC states that Having as its Objective the preparation of the new officers as a functioning of the criminal justice system, the Training Council's Minimum Basic Police Training Curriculum provides the information, skills, techniques, and procedures to service in law enforcement. The curriculum serves as a foundation for future advanced and specialized courses, and now includes a mandatory 250 hours of instruction and 6 hours of administration time. Beyond this, the Council will fund up to an additional 24 hours of curriculum as deemed appropriate by the regional academy coordinator and his advisory committee. Consideration has been given in curriculum development to the experience encountered by schools conducted in the past, to curriculum development in other states, to the evaluation of training needs as expressed by police administrators and line officers, and to educational concepts concerning the adult 1earner.15 During March of 1973 a proposal was prepared for MLEOTC. This twenty page report was entitled "Information Retrieval System Design Guidelines." The prOposal calls for a set of index records to abstract data. The data actually exists in the MLEOTC files within individual 16 file folders. The methodology for the system was as follows: 5Policies and Procedures Manual (Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Traifiing Council, Department of State Police, Lansing, Michigan, n.d.), pp. i-ii. 16"Information Retrieval System Design Guidelines" (unpublished report for MLEOTC, March 1973). p. 17. 80 File queries as proposed would identify how many records and which specific records contain a certain characteristic. The actual determination would be made by simply sorting the index records to the specific entry or entries of interest. Preliminary ordering of the index records could be used to reduce both the size of the index file to be queried as well as the time required to acquire an answer. Each proposed index record would consist of one or more special file cards carrying the data to be abstracted and an identification of the file folder from which the data were taken. As presently visualized, the index records would be manipulated by mechanical means, possibly by using a marginal punched card system, such as the Keysort method. Keysort uses a sorting tray and metal needles to select groups of index records.l Although the proposal for the "Information Retrieval System Design Guidelines" reads fairly well on paper, it seems somewhat out of context with today's advanced data processing techniques. This is not to suggest that MLEOTC procure its own computer. It would seem if the need is justifiable that the data processing sources could be made available somewhere within the state of Michigan's structure. It does not make much sense today to propose converting a functional manual system to a more SOphisticated manual system. Thoughts about the proposal are expressed in the following viewpoint: However, a practical limit to index record data capacity can sometimes be established in terms of manpower available to encode the data and the relative importance of one data field relative to others. For example, there may be ample space available in an unused portion Of the index record to encode all examination grades for each trainee in a certain group. However, l7"MLEOTC File Problem Notes" (unpublished paper by MLEOTC, January 8, 1973), p. l. 81 the total cost of encoding (manhours and time delays) may preclude abstracting those data. Similarly, the total cost may be justified, but the value of output records generated from these data may be quite low particularly with regard to other output reports required. As a consequence, the total data capacity in this application would probably be restricted to other, more important fields.18 It would seem as though MLEOTC could find some uses for the proposed computerized personal skills inventory system when it is adopted rather than revert to another manual system. Among other things relative to the proposed system MLEOTC could use it for inquiring about skills for future instructors. Instructors for basic schools will be selected on the basis of their knowledge and qualifications relative to police training. Competent individuals from the legal and medical professions, as well as other organi- zations, should be utilized when their talents would enhance the SCOpe of instruction.19 Described in Appendix I are the subject areas taught by instructors and the qualifications for each subject area. MLEOTC has an instructor training program. Those successfully completing the program are issued police instructor certificates. Some of the skills required for instructors are already listed as part Of this chapter. If a management information system is developed in the future for the Training Division and 18Ibid., p. 4. 19Policies and Procedures Manual, Op. cit., p. 27. 82 MLEOTC, other instructor skills required by MLEOTC will have to be included in the skills inventory system. Another aspect of the system could be drawing upon a pool of certified instructors to teach new courses. Form TC-03 is the "Application for Instructor Certification." When the form is approved, the instructor is certified. This form appears in Appendix J. The skills inventory system could be expanded to include data element codes for certified instructors and their particular skills. When new courses are being considered, profiles could be printed from the teletype terminal for certified instructors based upon the type of certification. MLEOTC may have a need to search the complete skills inventory system for specialized skills for new courses. If the system contains integrated files, software can be designed to control what is printed. Profiles need not be printed on individuals not associated with the MLEOTC file. Summary This chapter concentrated on a proposed computerized personal skills inventory system. The model agency was the MSP Training Division. Other agencies were mentioned that could make use of the system in the future. Several forms were presented such as the "Personal Skills Inventory Form." The flow Of data through the system was expressed using flowcharting techniques. Subject categories such as 83 education level, classification title, publication record, military draft, and special skills, were included along with relevant data elements. A coding scheme was used for all the data elements. The Law Enforcement Information Network was discussed. Data processing equipment, including teletype terminals, was mentioned in relationship to the system. 84 Please mark with an X the Michigan County where you presently live. Alcona Alger Allegan Alpena Antrim Arenac Baraga Barry Bay Benzie Berrien Branch Calhoun Cass Charlevoix Cheboygan Chippewa Clare Clinton Crawford Delta Dickenson Eaton Emmet Genesee Gladwin Gogebic Figure 5.--Residence County Category. lllllllllllllllllllllllllll RC10025 RC10050 RC10075 RC10100 RC10125 RC10150 RC10175 RC10200 RC10225 RC10250 RC10275 RC10300 RC10325 RC10350 RC10375 RC10400 RC10425 RC10450 RC10475 RClOSOO RC10525 RC10550 RC10575 RC10600- RC10625 RC10650 RC10675 85 Grand Traverse Gratiot Hillsdale Houghton Huron Ingham Ionia Iosco Iron Isabella Jackson Kalamazoo Kalkaska Kent Keweenaw Lake Lapeer Leelanau Lenawee Livingston Luce Mackinac Macomb Manistee Marquette Mason Mecosta Menominee Midland Missaukee Monroe Montcalm Montmorency Figure S.--Continued. lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll RC10700 RC10725 RC10750 RC10775 RC10800 RC10825 RC10850 RC1087S RC10900 RC10925 RC10950 RC10975 RC11000 RC11025 RC11050 RC11075 RC11100 RC11125 RC11150 RC11175 RC11200 RC11225 RC11250 RC11275 RC11300 RC11325 RC11350 RC11375 RC11400 RC11425 RC114SO RC11475 RC11500 86 Muskegon Newaygo Oakland Oceana Ogemaw Ontonagon Osceola Oscoda Otsego Ottawa’ Presque Isle Roscommon Saginaw’ Sanilac Schoolcraft Shiawassee St. Clair St. Joseph Tuscola Van Buren Washtenaw Wayne Wexford lllllllllllllllllllllll RC11525 RC11550 RC11575 RC11600 RC11625 RC11650 RC11675 RC11700 RC11725 RC11750 RC11775 RC11800 RC11825 RC11850 RC11875 RC11900 RC11925 RC11950 RC11975 RC12000 RC12025 RC12050 RC12075 Figure 5.--Continued. 87 mark with an X the date that you were born. Please Month 01 _ BD10025 02 __ BD10050 03 __ BD10075 04 __ BD10100 05 __ BD10125 06 __ BD10150 07 __ BD10175 08 __ BD10200 O9 __ BD10225 10 __ BD10250 11 _ BD10275 12 __ BD10300 Day 01 ___'_ BD20026 02 __ BD20051 03 __ BD20076 04 __ BD20101 05 __ BD20126 06 __ BD20151 07 __ BD20176 08 __ BD20201 09 __ BD20226 10 __ BD20251 11 __ BD20276 12 __ BD20301 l3 __ BD20326 14 __ BD20351 15 __ BD20376 l6 __ BD20401 17 __ BD20426 18 __ BD20451 19 __ BD20476 20 __ BD20501 21 __ BD20526 22 __ BD20551 23 __ BD20576 24 __ BD20601 25 __ BD20626 26 __ BD20651 27 __ BD20676 Figure 6.--Birth Date Category. Year 01 __ 3330027 02 __ 3330052 03 __ 3330077 04 __ 3330102 05 __ 3330127 06 __ 3330152 07 __ 3330177 08 __ 3330202 09 _ 3330227 10 __ 3330252 11 __ 3330277 12 __ 3330302 13 __ 3330327 14 __ 3330352 15 __ 3330377 l6 __ 3330402 17 __ 3330427 13 __ 3330452 19 __ 3330477 20 __ 3330502 21 ___ 3330527 22 __ 3330552 23 __ 3330577 24 __ 3330602 25 __ 3330627 26 __ 3330652 27 __ 3330677 88 Month Day Year 28 ___ BD20701 28 ___ BD30702 29 ___ BD20726 29 ___ BD30727 30 ___ BD20751 30.... BD30752 31 ___ BD20776 31 ___ BD30777 32 ___ BD30802 33 ___ BD30827 34 __ BD30852 35 ____BD30877 36 ___ BD30902 37 ____BD30927 38 ___ BD30952 39 ____BD30977 40 ____BD31002 41 ___ BD31027 42 ___ BD31052 43 ____BD31077 44 ____BD31102 45 ___ BD31127 46 ___ BD31152 47 ___ BD31177 48 ____BD31202 49 ___ BD31227 50 ____BD31252 51 ____BD31277 52 ____BD31302 53 ___ BD31327 54 ___ BD31352 55 ____BD31377 Figure 6.--Continued. 89 Month Day Year 56 ___ BD31402 57 ____BD31427 58 ___ BD31452 59 ____BD31477 60 ___ BD31502 61 ____BD31527 62 ___ BD31552 63 ____BD31577 64 ____BD31602 65 ____BD31627 Figure 6.--Continued. 90 Please mark with an X the state where you were born and please print to the extreme right of the state the name of the city where you were born. If you do not find the place listed where you were born, please mark with an X the birth place category entitled Another Country and please print to the extreme right of this category the name of the country where you were born. Place Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Canada Colorado Connecticut Delaware Florida Georgia Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Figure 7.--Birth Place Code BP10025 BP10050 BP10075 BP10100 BP10125 BP10150 BP10175 BP10200 BP10225 BP10250 BP10275 BP10300 BP10325 BP10350 BP10375 BP10400 BP10425 BP10450 BP10475 BP10500 Category. City. BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 BP2 91 Place Code City Maryland __ BP10525 BP2 Massachusetts ‘___ BP10550 BP2 Mexico ___ BP10575 BP2 Michigan ____ BP10600 BP2 Minnesota ___ BP10625 BP2 Mississippi __ BP10650 BP2 Missouri ___ BP10675 BP2 Montana ___ BP10700 BP2 Nebraska ____BP10725 BP2 Nevada ___ BP10750 BP2 New Hampshire ____ BP10775 BP2 New Jersey ___ BP10800 BP2 New Mexico ___ BP10825 BP2 New York ___ BP10850 BP2 North Carolina ___ BP10875 BP2 North Dakota .___ BP10900 BP2 Ohio __ 3310925 332 Oklahoma ____BP10950 BP2 Oregon ___ BP10975 BP2 Pennsylvania ____BP11000 BP2 Rhode Island ___ BP11025 BP2 South Carolina ___ BP11050 BP2 South Dakota ____BP11075 BP2 Tennessee ___ BPlllOO BP2 Texas ___ BP11125 BP2 Utah ___ BP11150 BP2 Vermont ___ BP11175 BP2 Figure 7.--Continued. 92 Place Code City Virginia ___ BP11200 BP2 Washington ___;BP11225 BP2 Washington, D.C. .___ BP11250 BP2 West Virginia ___ BP11275 BP2 Wisconsin .___ BP11300 BP2 wyoming ___ BP11325 BP2 Another Country BP11350 BP2 Figure 7.--Continued. 93 Please mark with an X the date that you enlisted with the Michigan State Police. Month 01 ___ AD10025 02 ____AD10050 03 ___ AD10075 04 __ ADlOlOO 05.___.AD10125 06 _ AD10150 07 ___ AD10175 08 ___.AD10200 09 ___ AD10225 10 ___ ADlOZSO ll ___ AD1027S 12 AD10300 Day 01 AD20026 02 AD20051 03 AD20076 04 AD20101 05 AD20126 06 AD20151 07 AD20176 08 AD20201 09 AD20226 10 AD20251 ll AD20276 12 AD20301 13 AD20326 l4 AD20351 15 AD20376 l6 AD20401 l7 AD20426 18 AD20451 19 AD20476 20 AD20501 21 AD20526 22 AD20551 23 AD20576 24 AD20601 25 AD20626 26 AD20651 27 AD20676 Figure 8.--Anniversary Date Category. Year 01 __ 3330027 02 __ 3330052 03 __ 3330077 04 __ 3330102 05 __ 3330127 06 __ 3330152 07 __ 3330177 03 __ 3330202 09 __ 3330227 10 __ 3330252 11 __ 3330277 12 __ 3330302 13 __ 3330327 14 __ 3330352 15 __ 3330377 16 __ 3330402 17 __ 3330427 13 __ 3330452 19 __ 3330477 20 __ 3330502 21 __ 3330527 22 __ 3330552 23 __ 3330577 24 __ 3330602 25 __ AD30627 26 _ AD30652 27 __ 3330677 94 Month Day Year 28 ___ AD20701 28 ___ AD30702 29 ____AD20726 29 ____AD30727 30 ___.AD20751 30 ___ AD30752 31 ___ AD20776 31 ___ AD30777 32 ____AD30802 33 ___-AD30827 34 __ AD30852 35 ___ AD30877 36 ___ AD30902 37'____AD30927 38 ____AD30952 39 ____AD30977 40 ____AD31002 41 ___ AD31027 42 ____AD31052 43 ___ AD31077 44 ____AD31102 45 ___ AD31127 46 ____AD31152 47 ___ AD31177 48 ____AD31202 49 __ AD31227 50 ___ AD31252 51 ___ AD31277 52 ___ AD31302 53 ___ AD31327 54 ____AD31352 55 __ AD31377 Figure 8.--Continued. 95 Month Day Year 56 __ AD31402 57 __ AD31427 58 __ AD31452 59 __ AD31477 60 __ AD31502 61 __ A031527 62 __ AD31552 63 __ AD31577 64 __ AD31602 65 __ AD31627 Figure 8. --Continued . 96 Please mark with an X the official date that you were assigned or promoted to your current classification title. Month 01 _ CD10025 02 __ CDlOOSO 03 __ CD10075 04 __ CD10100 05 __ CD10125 06 _ CD10150 07 __ CD10175 08 __ CD10200 09 __ CD10225 10 _ CD10250 ll __ CD10275 12 CD10300 Figure 9.--C1assification Date Category. Day 01 __ CD20026 02 __ CD20051 03 __ CD20076 04 __ CD20101 05 __ CD20126 06 __ CD20151 07 __ CD20176 08 __ CD20201 09 __ CD20226 10 __ CD20251 ll __ CD20276 12 __ CD20301 13 __ CD20326 l4 __ CD20351 15 __ CD20376 16 __ CD20401 l7 __ CD20426 18 __ CD20451 19 __ CD20476 20 __ CD20501 21 __ CD20526 22 __ CD20551 23 __ CD20576 24 __ CD20601 25 __ CD20626 26 __ CD20651 27 __ CD20676 Year 01 __ CD30027 02 __ CD30052 03 __ CD30077 04 __ CD30102 05 __ CD30127 06 __ CD30152 07 __ CD30177 08 __ CD30202 09 __ CD30227 10 __ CD30252 ll __ CD30277 12 __ CD30302 13 __ CD30327 14 __ CD30352 15 __ CD30377 16 __ CD30402 17 __ CD30427 18 __ CD30452 17 __ CD30477 20 __ CD30502 21 __ CD30527 22 '_ CD30552 23 __ CD30577 24 __ CD30602 25 __ CD30627 26 __ CD30652 27 __ CD30677 97 Month Day - Year 28 ___ CD20701 28 ___ CD30702 29 ___ CD20726 29 ___ CD30727 30 ___ CD20751 30 ____CD30752 31 ___ CD20776 31 ___ CD30777 32 ____CD30802 33 ____CD30827 34 ___ CD30852 35 ____CD30877 36 ___ CD30902 37 ____CD30927 38 ___ CD30952 39 ___ CD30977 40 ____CD31002 41 ___ CD31027 42 ____CD31052 43 ____CD31077 44 ___ CD31102 45 ___ CD31127 46 ____CD31152 47 ____CD31177 48 ____CD31202 49 ____CD31227 50 ____CD31252 51 ____CD31277 52 ____CD31302 53 ;___CD31327 54 __ CD31352 55 __ CD31377 Figure 9.--Continued. 98 Month Day Year 56 ___ CD31402 57 ___ CD31427 58 ___ CD31452 59 ____CD31477 60 ____CD31502 61 ____CD31527 62 ____CD31552 63 ___ CD31577 64 ___ CD31602 65 CD31627 Figure 9.--Continued. 99 Please mark with an X your present Michigan State Title. Trooper 07 Policewoman 07 TrOOper 09 Policewoman 09 Training Specialist 09 Laboratory Specialist 09 Latent Print Specialist 09 Sergeant 10 Detective Sergeant 10 Training Specialist 10 Laboratory Specialist 10 Latent Print Specialist 10 Sergeant 11 Sergeant Specialist 11 Detective Sergeant ll Detective Sergeant Specialist 11 Aircraft Pilot 11 Laboratory Specialist 11 Latent Print Specialist 11 Lieutenant 12 Detective Lieutenant Specialist 12 Lieutenant Executive Officer 12 Aircraft Pilot 12 Laboratory Specialist 12 Latent Print Specialist 12 Lieutenant 13 Figure lO.--Classification Title Category. llllllllllllllllllllllllll Police CT10025 CT10050 CT10075 CT10100 CT10125 CT10150 CT10175 CT10200 CT10225 CT10250 CT10275 CT10300 CT10325 CT10350 CT10375 CT10400 CT10425 CT10450 CT10475 CT10500 CT10525 CT10550. CT10575 CT10600 CT10625 CT10650 100 Detective Lieutenant Specialist 13 Laboratory Specialist 13 Latent Print Specialist 13 First Lieutenant 14 Detective First Lieutenant Specialist 14 Captain 15 Captain 16 Major 17 Lieutenant Colonel 19 CT10675 CT10700 CT10725 CT10750 CT10775 CT10800 CT10825 CT10850 CT10875 Figure 10.--Continued. 101 Please mark with an x the Michigan State Police post where you are assigned.* East Lansing Department Headquarters Lansing District Headquarters and Post (11) Brighton Post (12) Ionia Post (13) Ithaca Post (14) Owosso Post (15) Detroit District Headquarters and Post (21) Romeo Post (22) St. Clair Post (23) New Baltimore Post (24) Flat Rock Post (25) Ypsilanti Post (26) Pontiac Post (27) Erie Post (28) Bay City District Headquarters and Post (31) East Tawas Post (32) Bad Axe Post (33) Sandusky Post (34) Flint Post (35) West Branch Post (36) Bridgeport Post (37) Lapeer Post (38) Jackson District Headquarters and Post (41) Clinton Post (42) Tekonsha Post (43) Blissfield Post (44) Jonesville Post (45) Figure 11.--Post Assignment Category. 3310025 3310050 3310075 3310100 3310125 3310150 3310175 3310200 3310225 3310250 3310275 3310300 3310325 3310350 3310375 3310400 3310425 3310450 3310475 3310500 3310525 3310550 3310575 3310600 3310625 3310650 3310675 102 Battle Creek Post (46) Paw Paw District Headquarters and Post (51) White Pigeon Post (52) Niles Post (53) New Buffalo Post (54) South Haven Post (55) Wayland Post (56) Benton Harbor Post (57) Rockford District Headquarters and Post (61) Reed City Post (62) Mt. Pleasant Post (63) Grand Haven Post (64) Newaygo Post (65) Hart Post (66) Traverse City District Headquarters and Post (71) Cheboygan Post (72) Gaylord Post (73) Alpena Post (74) Houghton Lake Post (75) Cadillac Post (76) Manistee Post (77) (78) Marquette District Headquarters and Post (81) Newberry Post (82) St. Ignace Post (83) Manistique Post (84) Gladstone Post (85) Iron Mountain Post (86) Wakefield Post (87) Petoskey Post Figure 11.--Continued. lllllll PA10700 PA10725 PA10750 PA10775 PA10800 PA10825 PA10850 PA10875 PA10900 PA10925 PA10950 PA10975 PA11000 PA11025 PA11050 PA11075 PA11100 PA11125 PA11150 PA11175 PA11200 PA11225 PA11250 PA11275 PA11300 PA11325 PA11350 PA11375 PA11400 103 L'Anse Post (88) Stephenson Post (89) Calumet Post (90) Munising Post (91) Iron River Post (92) Sault Ste. Marie Post (93) Capitol Detail Holland Crime Laboratory Plymouth Crime Laboratory Warren Crime Laboratory llllllllll 3311425 3311450 3311475 3311500 3311525” 3311550 3311575 3311600 3311625 3311650 *Post number appears in parenthesis. Figure 11.-'Continued. 104 .mnomoumu someoouOmsm 3MAII.~H mnemfim meeeemqll 88$.qu 8883!... 888.3! 8883...! oeeeemall when» m 8863qu $83.31!. 88331.1 2833' 2885.... memoflflll new...» 4 $86.3.qu emmommqll 88331 mmmommqll 3833.... 083qu when» m 0883.... 8833:... 8838!! 88...qu 3.8».qu 8833' new...» m 883qu 88331... 888311.. 888qu 8883!... 883qu 366» H 8868.... 2.83qu 8848:... 2883.1... 888.3! 2833...: masses 2 8893‘ 3834...... 8883i 8883...: 3.88qu 3883' nfieoe S 88631! 8883!... 8.83.qu 2823' £883! £83qu nfieoe m 888.31... 8883.... 8848.... 8883i! 88831 8883.... 3383 e 88631 2.8331... 884qu Seawall 6:08.31... 3.23qu menace e mmeoemqll 38..“qu 884.....qu 883.31 $83qu 3833' 93:83 e 8863.11 8833.! 883qu 2883.1... emeommqli 88841 menace m 8883!! 88...qu 881.8! 888qu 8883! 888qu nfieoe e 2888! 2.8.8qu 8833.... :88qu 6883...... 3833' 35.83 m 8088...... emoemmell 80381... amoemmell 3883...! 8883' messes N 0883'. emoommql... mmooemall Seagull @808qu m83mqll fines a anuosou womfiuummmo usefiuummmo #cOEuuome ucofienmomo ucmfiunmmmo tw>uom nonuoc< Hmumpom esopm mussoo HMQHOHGDZ mwnmo3oe OEHB .mEea mo pofiumo tmfimeomom 3 ROM HOOfimmo undemonomow 33H o no .Oowaom mumum smmfl£OHz on» How umooxm .50» tomonEm soap mmflocomm ucOEOOH0ch 33H Omonu mo Ham How mossHoo museumonmmm on» x cm sues gums Ommoam 105 .poosfluQOUii.NH ousmwm 8893' 8833' 8883' 8833' 8883' 8883' when» 3 0888' 8883' 8835' 8883' 3883' 8883' when» 8 8883' 8883' 8885' 8823' 8883' 8833' when» 3 8883' 8833' 8883' 2833' 8883' 8833' when» 8 8885' 8883' 8883' 8883' 3883' 8883' when» 2 0885' 8883' 8883' 3883' 8883' 8833' n83s 3 8883' 8833' 8883' 8883' 8883' 8823' when» m 8893' 2833' 8883' 8833' 8883' 8833' p.893 8 8883' 8884' 8883' 8883' 8883' 8883' when» e 8863' 8883' 8883' 8883' 8883' 8835' names 3 muucsou asufiuuoomo usefiuuoooa uoosuummmo ucoeuuomoa unusuuommo tw>nmm Hmnuocm Hometmm oumum mussoo HmmHOHCSZ mflnmssoa OEHB 106 Please mark with an X all of the appropriate columns that apply to your military service status to date, and the total years served in the military to date. PAST REGULAR DUTY STATUS ENLISTED RANK OFFICER RANK Air Force Honorable Discharge MSlOOZS M820026 Army Honorable Discharge MSlOOSO MSZOOSl Coast Guard Honorable Discharge ' MSlOO75 M820076 Marine Corps Honorable Discharge MSlOlOO MSZOlOl Navy Honorable Discharge MSlOlZS M820126 Other Country Honorable Discharge MSlOl40 M820141 PAST ACTIVE RESERVE STATUS ENLISTED RANK OFFICER RANK Air Force Honorable Discharge MSlOlSO MSZOlSl Army Honorable Discharge MSlOl75 M320176 Coast Guard Honorable Discharge MSlOZOO MSZOZOl Marine Corps Honorable Discharge MSlOZZS M820226 National Guard Honorable Discharge MSlOZSO M820251 Navy Honorable Discharge MSlOZ75 M520276 Other Country Honorable Discharge M810290 M820291 PRESENT ACTIVE RESERVE STATUS ENLISTED RANK OFFICER RANK Air Force ___MSlOBOO ___M820301 Army ‘__;MSlO325 ___M820326 Coast Guard ___MSlOBSO ___M820351 Marine Corps ___MSlO375 ___M820376 National Guard “__MSIO400 ___M620401 Navy ___MSlO425 ___MSZO426 Figure 13.--Military Service Category. 107 TOTAL MILITARY YEARS SERVED ENLISTED RANK OFFICER RANK Served less than 1 year in the military service MSlO435 MSZO436 Served 1 year in the military service MSlO450 MSZO451 Served 2 years in the military service MSlO475 MSZO476 Served 3 years in the military service MSlOSOO MSZOSOl Served 4 years in the military service MSlOSZS M520526 Served 5 years in the military service MSlOSSO MSZOSSl Served 6 years in the military service M810575 MSZOS76 Served 7 years in the military service MSlOGOO M520601 Served 8 years in the military service M310625 M820626 Served 9 years in the military service MSlOGSO M820651 Served 10 years in the military service . MSlO675 M820676 Served 11 years in the military service MSlO700 M52070l Served 12 years in the military service MSlO725 M820726 Served 13 years in the military service MSlO750 M820751 Served 14 years in the military service MSlO77S M320776 Served 15 years in the military service MSlOBOO M520801 Served 16 years in the military service M510825 M820826 Served 17 years in the military service MSlOBSO M820851 Figure 13.--Continued. 108 TOTAL MILITARY YEARS SERVED ENLISTED RANK OFFICER RANK Served 18 years in the military service ___M810875 M820876 Served 19 years in the military service ___MSlO900 M820901 Served 20 years in the military service M810925 M820926 Served 21-25 years in the military service M810950 M820951 Served 26-30 years in the military service MSlO97S MSZO976 Served 31-35 years in the military service MSllOOO MSZlOOl Served 36-40 years in the military service MSllOZS M821026 Served 41-45 years in the military service MSllOSO MSZlOSl Figure 13.-—Continued. 109 Please mark with an X your present draft status as is recorded with the Selective Service classification system. 1A ___MDlOOZS 1A0 ___MDlOOSO 1D __wMDlOO75 1H ___MDlOlOO 10 ___MDlOlZS 1w .__;MD10150 2A '__;MD10175 2c ___MDlOZOO 2D ___MD10225 2F ___MDlOZSO 3A ___MD10275 4A ___MD10300 4B .__;MD10325 4c ___MD10350 4D ___MD10375 4F '___M0104oo 4G ___MD10425 4w __‘MD10450 N/A ___MD10475 Figure 14.--Military Draft Category. 110 For those publications reaching publics outside the Michigan State Police Department, please mark with an X the appropriate columns that reflect the number of publications to your credit for each area. Publication Papers Articles Books Inventions Number Presented Published Published Patented 1 ___PR10025 ___PR20026 ___PR30027 ___PR40028 2 ___PRlOOSO ___PR20051 ___PR30052 ___PR40053 3 ___PR10075 ___PR20076 ___PR30077 ___PR40078 4 ___PRlOlOO ___PR20101 ___PR30102 ___PR40103 5 ___PR10125 ___PR20126 ___PR30127 ___PR40128 6 ___PRlOlSO ___PR20151 ___PR30152 ___PR40153 7 ___PR1017S ___PR20176 ___PR30177 ___PR40178 8 ___PRlOZOO ___PR20201 ___PR30202 ___PR40203 9 ___PR10225 ___PR20226 ___-PR30227 ___;PR40228 10 I__;PR10250 ___PR20251 ___PR30252 ___PR40253 ll ___PR10275 ___PR20276 ___PR30277 ___PR40278 12 ___PR10300 ___PR20301 ___PR30302 ___PR40303 13 ___PR10325 ___PR20326 ___PR30327 ___PR40328 14 ___PR10350 ___PR20351 ___PR30352 ___PR40353 l5 ___PR10375 ___PR20376 ___PR30377 ___PR40378 l6 ___PR10400 ___PR20401 ___PR30402 ___PR40403 17 ___PR10425 ___PR20426 ___PR30427 ___PR40428 18 ___PR10450 ___PR20451 '__;PR30452 ___PR40453 19 ___PR10475 ___PR20476 ___PR30477 ___PR40478 20 '__;PR10500 ___PRZOSOl ___PR30502 ___PR40503 Figure 15.—-Publication Record Category. 111 .mnommuwu mmmsmcmq cmwmuomll.ma whomflu 8833' 8883' 38833' 88333' 83353 3938 8833' 8833' 8833' 88333' 8.52 83-388388 8833' 8883'... 88333.... 88333... 839038385 8833' 8883' 8833' 88333' 8833 396 8883' 8883' 8833' 8833' 8833 803938 8883' 8883' 38833' 88333' 53833 263335 8883' 8833' 8833' 88333' $9338 8833' 8833'. 8833' 88333' 333933 838328 8883' 8833' 8833' 338333' 893.333 8833' 83833' 338333' 88333' 83.38353 8833' 8833' 83833' 88333' 8833 3833833 83833' 83833' 83833' 88333' 83553 8833' 8883' 8883' 338333' 8383 033333 8833' «8833' 8833' 08333' 03333 8883' 38833' 38833' 88333' 333333 muwnz pmmm xmmmm mumamcmue mmmsmcmq cmflmuom .x cm SUHB cEDHoo quHHQOHmmm on» meE can umwa msv mo cam on» on mommomcma msu DGHHQ mmmmam .pmumfia mHHfixm monomcma 390% beam uoc Op 50% MH .x cm Spas mchHoo mumaumoummm on» meE mmmmam .mmmmcmGMH man 30 Sam muHHS Ho Ummu Ho xmmmm maco can now «H .x cm suw3 GEDHoo mumamcmuu on» game mmmmflm .mommomCMH mmmcu mo mam mufluz pom .pmmu .xmmmm cmo 50% NH 112 .pmscfiucoo--.ma musmflm 3833' 3833' 8833' 8833' 83893 33.828033 8833' 8833' 38833.... 8833' 38.83 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3393 8833' 8833' 38833' 8833' 8,3838 8833' 8833...... 88 33' 8833' 83333 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 38.33 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 838.3 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3833 $63 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3383033 8833' 8833' 88 33' 8833' 088383 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 833883 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3883 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 338 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 393.38 88 33' 8833' 8833' 8833' 30333 8833' 8833' 8 8 33' 8833' 3835.3 8833' 8833' 88 33' 8833' 83083 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 33:3 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3853 muwuz pmmm xmwmm mumHmcmna mmmomcmn cmwmuom 113 .coscfiuaou--.ma madman 3383833... 3383m33.... 3383833... 3383333... 3m333=3 mmm3v33... ~m~3m33... 3883833... 0883333... 3333 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 3.3828 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 38833 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 83968 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 8833 808 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 833mm 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 838:3 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 838353 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 8833 383830 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 8883303 8333' 8333' 8333' 8333' 33303 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 8.8.83 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3333 $3333 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 88:3 396 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 882,302 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3332 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 883533 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' :83 mufluz cmmm xmmmm mumamcmua mmmsmcmq nmflmnom 114 .Umscflu300|n.ma wusmflm 3033333tin mo¢3m33lll 3oq3~33trl 0333333tnl 3333 3333333||| 3333333||| 3333333||| m3m3333||u 3333333 3333333||| mmm3mq3xll 3mm3~33||| 033333311: 33333 3333333111 333333311: 333333311: 333333311: 333333333> mom3vq3lll 303333311: 303333311: oom3333||| 33333333 mufluz 33mm xmmmm mumamcmna mmmsmcmq cmwwuom 115 Please mark with an X your major fields of study when you were working towards your certificates (through correspondence, craft, trade, or vocational schools) or college degrees. If you do not find your education major or majors listed, please print them at the end of the list. Certificate Degree Education Majors Majors Majors Accounting ‘ ___BMlOOZS ___BM20026 Advertising ___BMlOOSO ___BMZOOSl Aerospace ___BM10075 __BM20076 Agriculture ___BMlOlOO ___BMZOlOl Anatomy ___BMlOlZS ___BM20126 Animal Husbandry ___BMlOlSO ___BM20151 Anthropology ___BM10175 ___BM20176 Architecture ___BMlOZOO ___BMZOZOl Art ___BMlOZZS ___BM20226 Arts and Letters ___EM10250 ___BM20251 Astronomy ___BM1027S ___BM20276 Astr0physics ___BM10300 ___BM20301 Audiology ___BM10325 ___BM20326 Bacteriology ___BM10350 ___BM20351 Basket Weaving ___BM10375 ___BM20376 Biochemistry ___BM10400 ___BM20401 Biological Science ___BM10425 ___EM20426 Biology ___BM10450 ___BM20451 Biophysics ___BM10475 ___BM20476 Botany ___BMlOSOO ___BMZOSOl Business ___BMlOSZS ___BM20526 Chemicals ___EMlOSSO ___BM20551 Chemistry ___BM10575 ___BM20576 Figure 17.—~Education Major Category. 116 Certificate Degree Education Majors Majors Majors Child Development ___EM10600 ___EM20601 Civil Engineering ___EM10625 ___EM20626 Clinical Science ___EM10650 ___EM20651 Clothing ___EM10675 ___EM20676 Communication ___EM10700 ___EM20701 Computer Science ___EM10725 ___EM20726 C00perative Extension ___EM10750 ___EM20751 Counseling ___EM10775 ___EM20776 Criminal Justice ___EMlOBOO ___EM20801 Crystallography ___EM10825 ___EM20826 Dairy ___EM10850 ___EMZOBSl Data Processing ___EM10875 ___EM20876 Dentistry ___EM10900 ___EM20901 Dietetics ___EM10925 ___EM20926 Economics ___EM10950 ___EM20951 Education ___EM10975 ___EM20976 Engineering ___EMllOOO ___EMZlOOl English .__;EM11025 ___EM21026 Entomology ___EMllOSO ___EM21051 Finance ___EM11075 ___EM21076 Fisheries ___EMlllOO ___EMleOl Foods ___EMlllZS ___EM21126 Foreign Language ___EMlllSO ___EM21151 Forestry ___EM11175 ___EM21176 General Science ___EMllZOO ___EMZlZOl Geography ___EM11225 ___EM21226 Geology ___EMllZSO ___EM21251 Guidance ___EM11275 ___EM21276 Health ___EM11300 ___EM21301 Figure 17.——Continued. 117 Certificate Degree Education Majors .Majors Majors History ___EM11325 ___EM21326 Horticulture ___EM11350 ___EM21351 Hotel Management ___EM11375 ___EM21376 Housing ___EM114OO ___EM21401 Humanities ___EM11425 ___EM21426 Industrial Administration ___EMll450 ___EM21451 Institutional Administration ___EM11475 ___EM21475 Interior Design ___EMllSOO ___EM21501 Journalism ___EMllSZS ___EM21526 Kinetics .___EM11550 ___EM21551 Labor ___EM11575 ___EM21576 Landscape ___EMllGOO ___EM21601 Law ___EM11625 ___EM21626 Linguistics ___EM11650 ___EM21651 Management ___EM11675 ___EM21676 Marketing ___EM11700 ___EM21701 Mathematics ___EM11725 ___EM21726 Mechanics ___EM11750 ___EM21751 Medicine ___EM11775 ___EM21776 Metallurgy ___EMllBOO ___EM21801 Microbiology ___EMllBZS ___EM21826 Mineralogy ___EM11850 ___EM21851 Music ___EM11875 ___EM21876 Natural Science ___EMllQOO ___EM21901 Nursing ___EM11925 ___EM21926 Nutrition ___EMllQSO ___EM21951 Optometry ___EM11975 ___EM21976 Osteopathy ___EMlZOOO ___EM22001 Packaging ___EM12025 Figure 17.--Continued. EM22026 118 Certificate Degree Education Majors Majors Majors Parks ___EMlZOSO ___EM22051 Pathology ___EM1207S ___EM22076 Personnel ___EMlZlOO ___EM22101 Pharmacology ___EM12125 ___EM22126 Philosophy ___EMlZlSO ___EM22151 Photography ___EM12175 ___BM22176 Physical Education ___EM12200 ___EM22201 Physics ___EM12225 ___EM22226 Physiology ___EM12250 ___EM22251 Planetarium ___EM12275 ___EM22276 Police Administration ___EM12300 ___EM22301 Political Science ___EM12325 ___EM22326 Poultry ___EM12350 ___EM22351 Psychology ___EM12375 ___EM22376 Public Administration ___EM12400 ___EM22401 Public Health ___EM12425 ___EM22426I Public Relations ___EM12450 ___EM22451 Public Safety ___EM12475 ___EM22476 Recreation ___EM12500 ___EM22501 Religion ___EM12525 ___EM22526 Resource Development ___EM12550 ___EM22551 Restaurant Management ___EM12575 ___EM22576 Retailing ___EM12600 ___EM22601 Risk Insurance ___EM12625 ___EM22626 Secretarial Administration ‘__;EM12650 ___EM22651 Social Science ___EM12675 ___EM22676 Social Work ___EM12700 ___EM22701 Sociology ___EM12725 ___EM22726 Soil Science ___EM12750 ___EM22751 Figure 17.—-Continued. 119 Certificate Degree Education Majors Majors Majors Speech ___EM12775 ___EM22776 Statistics ___EM12800 ___EM22801 Systems Science ___EM12825 ___EM22826 Television and Radio ___EM12850 ___EM22851 Textiles ___EM12875 ___EM22876 Theatre ___EM12900 ___EM22901 Theology ___EM12925 ___EM22926 Transportation ___EM12950 ___EM22951 Urban Planning ___EM12975 ___EM22976 Veterinary ___EM13000 ___FM23001 Wildlife ___EM13025 ___EM23026 Wood Science ___EMlBOSO ___EM23051 X-rays ___EM13075 ___EM23076 Zoology ___EM13100 ___EM23101 Figure 17.-~Continued. 120 Please mark with an X all of the educational categories that you have satisfactorily achieved since graduating from the eighth grade. If you do not find all of the educational categories listed that you have satisfactorily achieved, please print them at the end of the list. General Education Development Test--GED College Level Examination Program--CLEP High School Diploma College One Year No Degree Licensed Practical Nurse --LPN College Two Years No Degree Registered Nurse-~RN Associate of Arts Degree--AA Associate of Applied Science Degree-~AAS Associate of General Education Degree-—AGE Associate of Science Degree-—AS College Three Years No Degree College Four Years No Degree Bachelor of Arts--BA Bachelor of Business Administration--BBA Bachelor of Fine Arts—-BFA Bachelor of Landscape Architecture—-BLA Bachelor of Music——BM Bachelor of Science—-BS Bachelor of Law--LLB Masters Graduate Work No Degree Master of Educationn-EDM Master of Law—-LLM Master of Arts--MA Master of Arts for Teachersfi-MAT Figure 18.—-Education Level Category. ___EL10025 I__;EL10050 ___EL10075 ___ELlOlOO ___ELlOlZS ___ELlOlSO EL10175 EL10200 EL10225 EL10250 EL10275 EL10300 EL10325 ___;Lloaso ___EL10375 ___EL10400 ___EL10425 EL10450 EL10475 EL10500 EL10525 EL10550 EL10575 EL10600 EL10625 I'l'lll 121 Master Master Master Master Master Master Master Master of of of of of of of of Business Administration--MBA Fine Arts-~MFA Landscape Architecture-~MLA Labor and Industrial Relations--MLIR Music-—MM Science--MS Social Work--MSW Urban P1anning--MUP Diploma for Advanced Graduate Study--DAGS Educational Specialist Degree—-EDS Doctors Graduate Work No Degree Doctor Doctor Doctor Doctor Doctor of of of of of Business Administration—-DBA Engineering—-DE Education—~EDD Philosophy—-—PHD Science--SCD ___leosso ___EL10675 ___EL107OO ___EL10725 ___EL10750 '__;EL10775 EL10800 EL10825 EL10850 EL10875 EL10900 ___EL10925 EL10950 EL10975 ELllOOO EL11025 I I l Figure 18.--Continued. 122 Please mark with an X the categories that indicate the paid teaching ranks that you "did hold" and that you are "currently holding." Rank Did Hold Currently Holding Teaching Assistant ___AR10025 ___AR20026 Research Assistant ___ARlOOSO ___ARZOOSl Teaching Associate __QAR10075 __4AR20076 Research Associate ___ARlOlOO ___ARZOlOl Assistant Lecturer ___AR10125 ___;AR20126 Associate Lecturer ___ARlOlSO __;AR20151 Lecturer ___AR10175 __;AR20176 Assistant Instructor ___AR10200 ___AR20201 Associate Instructor .__;AR10225 ‘__;AR20226 Instructor ___ARlOZSO ___AR20251 Assistant Professor ___AR10275 ___AR20276 Associate Professor .__;AR10300 __QARZOBOl Professor ___AR10325 ___AR20326 Figure 19.--Academic Rank Category. 123 .muommumu gcmfimon>ma AmsOHmmmmoumul.o~ 335033 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3 3883' 8833' 3883' 3833' 8833' 3 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3 8883' 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3 8833' 8833' 8883' 8833' 8833' 3 3833' 8833' 3833' 3833' 8833' 3 8883' 8833' 8833' 8833' 8833' 3 8883' 8833' 8883' 8833' 8833' 3 8833' 8833' 3388' 8333' 83333' 3 3383' 3833' 3883' 3833' 8338' 3 3338' 3388'. 8883' 8833' 8338' m 8383' 8833' 8883' 3388' 8338' 3 8833' 8833' 8883' 8833' 8833' m 3833' 3833' 3833' 3833' 8833' m 8883' 8833' 8883' 8833' 8833' 3 mmfiwgflq UHM3¢ GOHHMHUOmm¢ GOHflMHUOmmfi wwhmg Hmflgz HMGOHmmmmOHm HMGOHmmmeHm HMGOflmmGMOHm HMfiflHOOm WHMHOGOE .cowmmmmoum mo 09%» 0:» mo mmmaoummmn .mnommumo £03m Hem owcflmuum m>3£ so» 3333 mucmew>mwnom Hmsoflmmmmoum mo Hmnfisc may x :3 £333 £335 mmmmam 124 .Umscflucounl.om musmfim 8883' 8833' 8883' 8883' 8883' 8 8833' 8833' 2883' 8833' 8833' 3 3833' 8833' «3833' 3883' 8833' 3 8833' 8833' 2883' 8833' 8833' S 8833' 8833' 8883' 8833' 8833' 3 mmcmowq wnm3¢ GOHuMHUOmmm GOHpMfioommm mmnmmn Hmnfisz Hmaowmmmmoum Hmcoflmmmmoum HMCOHmmmmonm Hmumfloom mumnoaom 125 Please mark with an X the following specific skills acquired through practical experience. Do not include common hobbies or household skills where only fair proficiency has been acquired. If you do not find a special skill listed, please print it at the end of the list. Accounting ___3510025 Acting ___5810050 Advertising ___BSlOO75 Air Conditioning Technician ___5810100 Air Traffic Dispatcher ___SSlOlZS Aircraft Mechanic ___§310150 Aircraft Pilot ___5510175 Architect ___SSlOZOO Armorer ___5510225 Artist 5310250 Audio-Visual Technician :::§810275 Auditor ___5810300 Auto Body Mechanic ___SSlO325 Automobile Mechanic ___5310350 Bacteriology ___5810375 Baker ___8810400 Barber ___BSlO425 Bartender ___5810450 Biology ___5810475 Blood Analysis ___BSlOSOO Blue Printing ___SSlOSZS Boat Mechanic ___SSlOSSO Boat Operator ___fiSlOS75 Bookkeeping ___5810600 Botany ___BSlOGZS Breathalyzer ___BSlOGSO Bricklayer ___3810675 Figure 21.n—Specia1 Skills Category. 126 Budget Preparation ___SSlO7OO Burglary Alarms ___3810725 Bus Driver -___SSlO750 Butcher ___8810775 Carpenter ___5310800 Cartography (maps) ___BSIOBZS Cement Work ___fiSlO850 Chauffeur ___8810875 Chemical Analysis ___5810900 Chemist ___BSlO925 Chiropractor *__5510950 Clinical Laboratory Technician ___5510975 Communications Equipment ___BSllOOO Composition Layouts ___BSllOZS Compositor (typesetter) ___BSllOSO Computer Operator ___BSllO75 Computer Programming ___§811100 Cook ___SSlllZS Cosmetology ;__§SlllSO Counseling ___SSlll75 Criminology '___§SllZOO Culinary ___§S11225 Decorator ___BSllZSO Defensive Driving ___BS11275 Demolition ___5811300 Dietetics ___fiSll325 Diver ___fiSll350 Dog Handler ___5811375 Draftsman ‘___SSII400 Drug Analysis ___5811425 Editing ___5811450 E‘i-gure 21 . --Continued. 127 Electrician ___SSll475 Electronic Technician ___SSllSOO Emergency Medical Technician ___GSllSZS Engineer ___SSllSSO Entomology (insects) ___5811575 Explosive Ordinance ___5511600 Farmer . ___GS11625 Fingerprinting ___SSll650 Firearms Identification '___SSllG75 Firearms Repair ___SS11700 Firearms Training ___5811725 Fireman ___5511750 First Aid Training ___fiSll77S Food Analysis ___BSllBOO Gas ____8311825 Geography ___5811850 Geology ___5311875 Glazier ___5811900 Gunsmith ___5811925 Heavy Equipment Operator ___5511950 Helicopter Pilot ___5811975 History ___BSlZOOO Instrument Analysis ___5812025 Insurance ___§812050 Journalist ___BSlZO75 Judo ___§812100 Keypunch Operator ___5512125 Knot Specialist ___BSlZlSO Laboratory Technician ___5812175 Figure 21.--Continued. 128 Landscaping ___SSlZZOO Latent Prints ___GSlZZZS Lawyer ___5812250 Lineman ___§812275 Linguist ___BSlZ3OO Locksmith ___GSlZ325 Machinist ___GSlZ350 Mason ___BSlZ37S Mathematics ___5512400 Medic ___§812425 Metal Worker ___G812450 Microscopy ___5812475 Miner ___3812500 Minister ___5812525 Musician ___5812550 Nurse ___5512575 Nutrition _;_SSlZ600 Optical Repairs ___5812625 Oxygen ___BSlZGSO Painter ___§812675 Parachutist ___5812700 Pathology _é_§812725 Personnel Administration ___5812750 Pest Control ___5812775 Pharmacology ___§812800 Philosophy ___5812825 Photography ___5812850 Physical Education ___5812875 Physics “___6812900 Plasterer ‘ 8812925 I Figure 21.—-Continued. 129 Plumber ___SSlZQSO Polygraph Examiner ___SSl2975 Poultry ___5513000 Printer ___5513025 Psychology ___SSl3050 Public Relations ___SSl3075 Public Speaking ___SSlBlOO Pursuit Driving ___SSl3125 Quachery ___SSlBlSO Quadriplegics ___SSl3l75 Radar ___SSl3200 Radio Announcer ___SSl3225 Radio Operator ___SSl3250 Radio Production ___SSl3275 Radio Technician _;_SSl33OO Railroad Inspection ___SSl3325 Real Estate ___5813350 Recording Technician ';;_S813375 Recreation .__;SSl3400 Referee ___SSl3425 Religion '_;_S813450 Research Methods '___SSlB47S Roofer '___SSl3500 Safety Activities ___SSl3525 Salesman ___SSl3550 Sand Blaster ’_;_§Sl3575 Script Writing ;__S813600 Scuba Diver - _‘__;_SSl3625 Seamstress __;SSl3650 Shorthand ‘ ' $813675 Figure 21.-—Continued. 130 Sign Language ___SSl3700 Singing ___§813725 Small Arms Repair ___fiSl3750 Snake Handler ___SSl3775 Soil Science ___SSl3800 Solar ___SSl3825 Speech Therapy ___SSl3850 Statistics ___SSl3875 Steelworker ___S813900 Surveying ___SSl3925 Switchboard ___SSl3950 Systems Analyst ___SSl397S Tabulating Machine Operator ___SSl4000 Tailor _+_SSl4025 Taxidermist ___SSl4050 Teacher ___SSl4075 Telegraph Operator ___SSl4100 Telephone Installation _ ___SSl4125 Telephone Repair ___SSl4150 Teletype Operator ___SSl4175 Television Announcer ___SSl4200 Television Cameraman '___SSl4225 Television Production ___SSl4250 Television Technician ___SSI4275 Textiles ' __;SSl4300 Theatre ___SSl4325 Theology ___SSl4350 Tool Design ___SSl4375 Tours ___SSl4400 Toxicology ___SSl4425 Figure 21.—~Continued. 131 Training Specialist .___$Sl4450 Transportation ___SSl4475 Truck Driver ___SSl4500 Typist ___SSl4525 Umpiring ___SSl4550 Underwriter ___SSl4575 Vault Technician ___SSl4600 Vehicle Inspection ___SSl4625 Waiter ___SSl4650 Weighmaster ___SSl4675 Welder ‘___SSl4700 Writer ___8814725 Xray Technician ___;5814750 Xylography (wood engraving) ___SSl4775 Yachting ___SSl4800 Youth Organizations ___SSl4825 Zionism ___SSl4850 Zoology ___SSI4875 Figure 21.n-Continued. CHAPTER V SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS Overview Developments and improvements in reporting procedures and record keeping have made it possible to maintain more consistent and thorough analysis, evaluation, research, and statistics in the criminal justice field. Various records have always been important to the criminal justice's operating structure in the past and today. Information in the past has been collected, filed, processed, reported, retrieved, stored and utilized on a manual basis for many different purposes. But that information today is handled more accurately, faster, and with a wider scope because of modern data processing techniques. Criminal justice methods have changed over the past several decades and means of communication and inquiry have also changed. The law enforcement officer of today has at his disposal modern equipment designed to communicate relevant information when needed. When information is requested concerning a criminal or some other situation at hand, the officer can inquire and receive through the use 132 133 of a computer fast, timely, and updated information. The officer is then in a position to make decisions based upon current knowledge. This knowledge can be found in many different forms which includes available information from computer files. These files range in type from things of a material nature, such as vehicle files, to information about people, such as sex deviates and wanted persons. In the past information contained in manual files was not shared efficiently and on a routine basis with other criminal justice agencies. Today through the use of computers, information is made available to the majority of agencies. The data processing field has helped in the sharing of information with various agencies and their officers by making available a variety of computerized files on an inquiry basis. The sharing of information through data processing methods has undergone an increase in recent years and current indications are that it will continue its growth in the future. The application of data processing methods in most criminal justice agencies has followed a normal pattern of converting manual files to punch card files. With the evolution of electronic data processing equipment, files were handled as in the past, but with greater speed and more accuracy. This early electronic equipment was in effect a card computer. As technology improved, the computer system was upgraded by the addition of magnetic type devices and disk '134 storage devices. These improvements allowed criminal justice agencies more flexibility for processing more information and data. With the advent of the second and third generation of computers, the input and output of data were improved through accuracy, performance, reliability,and speed. Just as technology enhanced the processing of data, the processing of files evolved in time. Files created while using punch card equipment and first- generation computers were treated as separate entities even though they contained elements common to other files. As experience was gained with second and third generation computers, files with like data elements were consolidated. The consolidation of files through a refined technology helped lead the way toward sharing information between criminal justice agencies. The change helped broaden the base of criminal justice knowledge. One of the real justifications for data processing in the criminal justice field is the sharing of information. Modern methods and techniques of data processing concepts have offered an opportunity to open the door toward progress for the criminal justice field. This development was experienced by the Michigan State Police. Summary From 1966 through 1973 three Commanding Officers from the Training Division requested that their skills inventory system be computerized on the Michigan Law 135 Enforcement Information Network (LEIN). The manual method of inventorying skills has existed for ten years. It was projected for the 1970 fiscal year for computerization on the LEIN system. It must have had its merit and need for existence or the Commanding Officers would not have persisted for a decade with the idea of converting the skills manual system to a computerized one. The manual system continues to be a laborious task to update and search. The formation of the proposal for the computerized personal skills inventory system was analytical in nature and simplified in application. The development followed the structure of systems analysis. Fundamental to a practical systems design is knowledge. This included understanding the present Training Division's manual skills inventory system and having a good grasp of the requirements of a computerized one. Both were covered in detail in the preceeding chapters. The analytical process involved at least the collecting and synthesizing of information, collecting operational data, determining problem requirements, considering future requirements, designing general solutions, selecting an operational system configuration, developing system solutions, and preparing instructions. As stated previously, the proposed computerized system was simplified in application. The input to the system is oriented toward the MSP officer responding to the 136 Personal Skills Inventory Form and various subject categories. The form is used to identify the individual because a computerized personnel system does not exist. After recording the information needed on the form, the officer marks the appropriate information listed in each subject category. The subject categories included residence county, birth date, birth place, anniversary date, classification date, classification title, post assignment, law enforcement, military service, military draft, publication record, foreign language, education majors, education level, academic rank, professional development, and special skills. All seventeen subject categories used the Fixed Vocabulary technique. Each category is supplied with special instructions. Data elements are listed for each subject category. Every data element is assigned a unique seven-position code. The officer is asked to asked to mark those data elements that apply to his or her particular situation. The Personal Skills Inventory Form and the subject categories are eventually returned to the Training Division. The information is then transcribed into cards for batch processing. There are three types of cards created per record: name card; address card; and data card. A record may contain more than one data card. After keypunching, the procedure calls for taping the cards. The social security number acts as a control number for the 137 record and identification for the individual. The first output for the batch process is an error listing containing all errors. After the errors have been rectified by the Training Division, they would be resubmitted for updating the tape file. The next step would be to write the tape file on disk. With the data residing on disk, the Training Division is in a position to process records using a teletype terminal. Updating records can take place using the terminal. A single profile containing all record information can be printed. The system can print selected profiles for individuals with certain types of skills. Selections can be made based upon one data element or many data elements. With an on-line system and appropriate program design, the computerized personal skills inventory system can produce varied information when needed. This could involve an emergency or some other situation when an officer is on patrol. Profiles containing all data on disk could be printed annually for the MSP officer. The officer would then have the opportunity to make additions or deletions to the entire record. A procedure could be established to automatically print a profile immediately after the officer reports for a new post assignment. The officer would have another Opportunity to update the record. This procedure coupled with the annual printout would give the officer plenty of opportunities to audit the record. In both cases the 138 Training Division would update records using the teletype terminal. Once the computerized personal skills inventory system has been operational for approximately a year, the Training Division will gain enough experience to broaden the scope of the system. Subject categories and other data element codes can be created and added to the system. Different print formats can be established. There may be other skills selection criteria required based upon experience gained with the system. In due time the various district headquarters could be connected to the skills system through their teletype terminals. With the Training Division as a contact point, Other criminal justice agencies in Michigan may be able to utilize the talents of certain MSP officers. Those criminal justice agencies bordering Michigan may need the immediate assistance of the Michigan State Police. Their needs may be serviced quicker through an MSP skills search. It is conceivable that someday criminal justice agencies in Michigan with terminals connected to LEIN will be able to inventory the skills of their own personnel. The MLEOTC could use the skills system to inquire about skills for future instructors. The MLEOTC's certified instructors and their specialty skills could be an integral part of the system. 139 Conclusions The data processing technology for a computerized personal skills inventory system is known. The systems development for the proposal has been rendered. The application of the proposal is feasible. The expressed desire for converting the Training Division's manual system to a computerized one has existed for a decade.‘ The limitations of time and money may serve as major restraints for the rapid development of the proposed system. I A thorough research and review of the literature was conducted in relationship to the proposed computerized personal skills inventory system. The majority of the systems disclosed during the literature review were personnel record files containing skills oriented data. A few appeared to produce skills oriented reports. These systems were integrated or comprehensive personnel information systems. The review did not reveal any independent systems. There may be some underlying reasons for the absence of applicable literature. It may be a less intriguing area to write about than some other topic. There may not be many active applications about which practitioners wish to write. A good system results in a competitive edge which some organizations may not wish to divulge until proprietary rights are established. Some organizations may possibly have a computerized personnel or personal skills system, 140 but they may not wish to admit it. These organizations may fear some sort of backlash from their employees because of the ever increasing notion that organizations maintain doosiers which are often viewed as an invasion of privacy. The interest in the literature research was directed toward an independent skills system, since the Michigan State Police (MSP) does not have a computerized personnel file or system. The operation's aspect of the study was tied directly to LEIN mainly because of the dispersal of its terminals. The optimum solution for the MSP would be skills data integrated with personnel information in a computerized personal skills inventory system. The next best solution would be a computerized skills file or system interacting with a computerized personnel system. Ultimately, the MSP should have the computerized personal skills inventory system integrated with a comprehensive computerized personnel system. Regardless of the type of skills system, the important consideration must be the ability to input and output data for the skills related segments within the total system. Through methodic systems analysis the skills system can eventually expand into a comprehensive management information system (MIS) providing MSP management with an outstanding decision making tool. M18 is an accumulation of data. It serves as information usually on a need to know basis. Judgements are made from observing the processed information. MIS addresses the activities of 141 the organization especially where there is more than one alternative for the decision making process. It Offers the Opportunity for considering alternatives based upon such questions as "what if this" and "what if that." It provides input necessary to evaluate the success or failure of new projects. MIS also evaluates the affect of deci- sions upon existing and previous projects. The potential for developing a skills management information system is almost unlimited. The capability of establishing simulation models in forecasting, for instance, potential instructors is available with MIS. Using the computerized personal skills inventory system, the Training Division can select the data elements needed for teaching a particular course. Those meeting the desired criteria can be selected and listed. Others having all but a few skills can be identified for further training. Modeling techniques provide a flexible basis for specialized reports. Most models are designed with the ability to allocate and compute information resulting in a series of reports showing what was and is available and projecting future organizational needs. The capability of developing alternate outlines for probable courses might also be possible with MIS. These outlines sometimes exist because of short range goals, but they usually are established through long range planning. Once the course Objectives are known, skills needed for instructional purposes now or later can be prepared. Data 142 can be matched with similar course outlines using the objectives and skills segments. Sometimes the matching will indicate that with some modification to an existing course a new one is not needed. Established and potential instructors may only need to work on a few skills to meet the requirements as outlined for the course. Categories associated with training such as course types, course outlines, instructor skills, potential instructors, and established instructors, could be captured as part of the MIS function. These training categories should help offer insight into questions regarding implementation Of new programs or elimination of others. Such questions should be answered if training is to remain relevant to today's law enforcement officer. The various training categories and related questions provide the basic input data essential for MIS to function. MIS tends to quantify strategic data and can help identify the demands placed on training. A computerized personal skills inventory system designed to address MIS concerns can provide historical data for use in evaluating and establishing predictive service activity. Management can respond to changing conditions by allowing non-computer personnel to obtain specialized reports on a one shot basis. An example of this concept is printing skills performance indicators from quantitative data. This may include the individual's ability to perform various skills related functions. By 143 manipulating data, performance tasks of many types can be brought to management's attention. This MIS feature should draw management's attention to those officers who have unique skills besides those skills needed to perform normal duties. It may not be so far fetched as to envision reports showing whether or not individual or departmental performance has improved. Some of the major aspects of M18 include the ability to perform such functions as information retrieval and generating reports. Another important aspect is coupling together the functional elements of management. Many management information systems are inadequate from the users standpoint. This is true because MIS evolved as a result of the development of many separate applications. Many applications were developed because of departmental interests rather than the broader organizational views. MIS must somehow provide management with information needed to coordinate activities to achieve not only the same goals as were desired in the past but include the sc0pe of the total organization. If this is not achieved, the functional elements of M18 will result in user dissatisfaction. . MIS should aid the Michigan State Police as a decision making tool. MIS can be beneficial especially if it includes such functions as optimizing the utilization of management's expectations and addressing crucial time 144 elements. MIS can provide higher quality information for employing management techniques. Recommendations There are many operational processes which have yet to be identified and examined in depth. These recommendations can be presented in the form of questions. The answers to the questions must be addressed in the near future. Is there a need for an operation or procedure manual? Is a coding manual necessary? In addition to the LEIN identifier, is it better to establish access codes for the types of data that may be printed from a terminal? What is the print format for the profiles? What future reports are necessary for the success of the skills system? How often should the reports be produced? Can abbreviations be used with clarity? What is the average length of a profile in terms of printed sheets? Would pre-formatted forms better identify portions of the profile? Should priority codes be established for selecting data based upon the urgency of the request? What additional information is currently being used on a continuous basis that should be added to the skills system? 145 Should the incrementation of data element codes be changed to tens instead of twenty-fives? Is it necessary for the individual to sign the change form for an update to his or her profile? What is the average cost to print a profile? What is the average cost to make a skills search? Is the present body of profile data adequate for the next few years? Should profiles be created for those going through the MSP recruit school? Is it appropriate to eliminate profiles from the system after achieving a certain rank? Should a subject category be instituted for qualifying with different weapons on the firing range? Is it necessary to establish a city-card for the birth place category or should the computer program be designed to accept the city punched into the "data card" (e.g., BPMILAN)? Limitations of Study There are some definite limitations of the study which, in retrospect, would have increased its value. First, a different approach could have been used for the survey questionnaire. A preliminary survey should have been mailed to the state police agencies in the other forty-nine states. The survey would determine their type Of affiliation with a data processing facility and what major metrOpolitan police department in the state was also 146 associated with a facility. After all responses were returned, the survey in this study would be mailed to the responding state agencies and fifty metropolitan agencies (includes Detroit). Those agencies indicating that they had a computerized skills inventory system would be contacted. A letter of inquiry or phone call asking for documentation of the skills system would benefit the study effort. A further limitation is the fact that no method was implemented to determine the expectations of the MSP Commanding Officers. They may realize the need for other subject categories. They could make additional suggestions for data elements and skills not listed in the proposal. They may be very interested to know the average time it takes to record and mark the Personal Skills Inventory Form and the subject categories. Much has been presented and discussed in this study. Perhaps much more was left unmentioned which could have been a part of the study. This thesis endeavor will have served a worthwhile purpose if it challenges constructive thinking resulting in positive action. APPENDICES APPENDIX A MICHIGAN STATE POLICE ORGANIZATION CHART 147 umsmcmt new meow>tmm mwmpm mo ammtzm 3:3 :0. 3.8 =.=owmw>3o mcwmmmuora mama: op umttmemcmtu mm: =cowuumm mcwmmmuota upon: one; 80.5.0... — :33 .653 30.58 :5 1 8925.. 02332.3! :38! 80.58 _ :5 : r_'||....¢:'._ 10.2030. .- 1 93.2.2; fillet 32:38.... 30.58 I 5.3-: 30.58 5.. rags->3 a _ :5 _ 98.883. also; :30! l 391.5%... _ b‘l t 03.3. 3.3....354 _'on.ih.-J:o§ EUR-Jae; 30.58 .8. ul 30.58 30.53 3258 I 3:35.253 gfiuwol I .l .2235!!! 3.5.5213 55:53:54 . F lea->3 30.929 8.0;: «stand 03...: u’gouuu :Uhdu >1i9—8 “Edglgd 1 ........... J u 10.300 33504 .u ulncunuL Dan—_- ”Zhsouxu . 52.... :3: . >. _.---.. henna- -... .33.... T :2 h8g0 203(5—5‘20 . as up“ 3 g .81.. 3’ 148 ...co._um«>.3 09.0qu.. 0.3 v9.8.5.» an.» gnoHuoom 060m...— cmmgugs m5... 10.... 3 IO‘C:D:‘JD + .Uw..rwuw #" _ .l: L ml“? __ H oftnflwl’ .1 . 19:3 .51) 19.:- 5c. . guineao Gar». IOU .1.uv¢l: 1°:U-u u ‘°.pU¢. 1.5 .381). O p.23. -;.>ah.l'0¢ .>=1-‘.8.Dn( I ............ u ...--.......-; '91.: 10.3: . 0.13 . . p 45.3.; ” 3¢o< .2 1. 3.0 .53. .1. n. . 52:3. _ 325.5%:3 . .- ..-..-.uo...-. panama}. .55” 803;; 433.! II: 1°:u' firings-'0‘ 393;; I’th-srrluo. a 8800: 33.39 .- sugar: .03.); sgale'ld — 32:: :9: 3 :35. H 3! =33 29.—(52(030 E 3:5... 11...]. :0. 3.30 1.00 IIIII lu..o‘l r I _ .8314 T 2.. " Hr ilxliflmqr— —I:00000.3 — 00.2.00 _ 3i... .j 1...... l .Ii: L_ MILE _ ESEUJ. — .1... :1 1.0.0020 W. 10.00.10.3th c0.0lcolqu..rIl _ .3‘1I... .SHJ; .005 0...0-I‘I_ r .0... a fl .0100 ‘0 149 I..I....u.,. A. _IIIndIr HAHN]. 0: SI ‘01—.fi 0.1-...03.‘ JIL— fl IIIL_ I . r IA. ‘IIJ. . n . 0.3;: r . ¢ . L al.150- III I _ . . I I J I I a I wIIIIIIJ V I 000.... m I I 93:00 #1 MI :50 0|... .3 . at?! r 305.0... I. ..0.0 .w r .. 0.00. T. a 0.000..) I. , II I x _ . - IL . I III . C _ _ . 9... .SOI 3 . _ w -J. I ,. I I. I I . III -- . _ .0001... I. (Cenozu F 3.9 U.lru.0 —I 08 puss—IBEX fin OI '93:.MIT —.. OI PoirgII—u d r 3356 1.3 2.5 .48. I ‘33...._ [IIIKV _ .3. ‘hI- ‘0‘: I: J. _ _ :J m .D... _—'.I¢n»“‘ .TI .00....3Y055. . I II . . z 0300 00.2.3 .00. _ "unnumfl I :95: 5.63 . a 3. .3. a... . 32.93:... afloat... ,IIII _ - .. (D p. 0.00le .ED :0; . :3 1,. . .63 (a. . _ Jun-'03:“ 62.53.: to... I _ co. .3... . 7.0! I on. _.. 2.00. :0... _r._ I IL. ..oo»d.‘.0...IL. _ ova) :2:an :00 . III F..II.I. _II...SII. .iMII ngzm . I... 1... . . fico.iu;..sc! I .1 a 9.0.0 _IIIOonu. . :00... . 6 cu. .00 .01 __ v C. u..h¢.3.30_ _ .203 . to. .0_u...03..".. r. "-OUquIIUII . . . r l .. :88. _ _ £0.03... _ .55.. __ 2.5 3.502.... 3.0-. L . I 0350.0. " p_.iu . .2.) IL. bbvthflla _ll 0»... .0. :I . . 1. 30:.U3 . I 3 u.‘.-D¢.OltI.. ” _‘ u. 5 r 2.3 5:?- ” 10.0000 .2300! 00:03.0“. _. _ m I n so." . xi; 2.0) 41 2.300 lO.»u~n 00.3”“...“10: (0.»U3 00:030...." . I '33; .00. L (nan—WW“.— 130200-3 3.00582... 00.53 .2... 2:323 2:323 gut-6.3:... .00.... I ‘3'); . 1.... u I , 10.3: 3...... to. 80:9: 80:03 (0:93 6.: Cr: 0 l I 5C; :35: 30.5: 3.00: =¢u 00:! 2:332:53 I 3:35.230 .IOI‘J U...rl.—.Ufl 30.229 025.0959 sea—>5 ugggg a nun->13 can: no a;-—- .-r— 6. GENERAL CORRESPONDENCE COURSES ICNOOL LOCATION LENGTH OF COURSE YEAR! VOU ATTENDED CERTI'ICATE? 7. DE PARTNE NTAL TRAINING (Do NOT Inclmo locum on Tvoooov Schoon. Coconut-Cocoon“ Odom-Non. at any on.» oohool «M I... than 40 homo. DO Include ochoolo o! 4001 not. hows. whatnot taming by thin don-"mm 0: echo: school or agency.) EC HOOL SPONSORED RY LOCATION NUMBER HOURS COURSE CONTENT O. LANGUAGE ABILITIES ILIOI on lance-900. lncludbno Deal Nut. Sign Law) LANGUAGE READ WRITE CONVERSATION TRANSLATE NO. HERE LANGUAGE. LEARNED? [:1 AI Non CI At School NA“ OP EC HOOL 9. DO YOU POSSESS ANY SPECIALIZED SKILLS NOT PREVIOUSLY LISTED? GRILL HOW ACQUIRED LENGTH OF TRAINING PRESENT PROFICIENCY IO. HAVE YOU ATTENDED ANY SCHOOL ON YOUR OWN TIME, OR TAKEN ANY CORRESPONDENCE COURSES WITHIN TIIE LAST "ELVE NONTNS? IF SO, PLEASE IDENTIFY: II you Nov. «0 band 040de ”no In IIuIng my Decoupllohnoml, ploou UR. oddlflonol Ibo.“ oI pap", noun. nIomco to the IOCIIOR ”be! duh In Loin. “do! 00. Plus. Inha- IIn Puma-I DIvIqun ad Training Dlvhlon oI «Ito-”Mon" can.” u nodule cannon on you emplon III... 00 yo" wan-0| ad totals. and. will "II-co yew canon! and compluo flown. , APPENDIX c SURVEY LETTER AND QUESTIONNAIRE Data Processing Computer Section Detroit Municipal Police Dept. 1300 Beaubien Detroit, Michigan 48231 June 19, 1972 Dear Colleague: I have undertaken a project for the Michigan State Police (MSP) that relates to my thesis for a Master of Science Degree. I plan to develop a practical method of inventorying the personal skills of every MSP officer on a computerized basis. Expressing the project in its simplest form, my objective is to develop a practical method for the MSP to implement a computerized personal skills inventory system (CPSIS) that will replace their existing method of manually searching through a thirteen volume alphabetically indexed inventory of skills. Please take ten minutes to read the enclosures which explain more in detail the extent of my project than does this cover letter. The enclosures are c0pies of my thesis prospectus and the MSP correspondences relating to my thesis. After reading the enclosures, please take one minute to answer the attached CPSIS survey questionnaire, and then detach and mail the questionnaire to me by 07-11-72. Thank you very much for your time. Most Sincerely, Ronald A. Soltis 1219 Ivanhoe Drive East Lansing, Michigan 48823 Enclosures cc: Captain Charles Meyers Department of State Police 714 South Harrison Road East Lansing, Michigan 48823 152 153 Data Processing Computer Section Detroit Municipal Police Dept. 1300 Beaubien Detroit, Michigan 48231 Please detach this questionnaire and mail to: CPSIS SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE Is your personal skills inventory system a manual file? Is your personal skills inventory system a computerized system? Is your personal skills inventory system a combined manual file and computerized system? Is your personal skills inventory system incorporated in your personnel file or system? Does your future plans call for creating and maintaining a CPSIS? Have you ever heard of a CPSIS? Ronald A. Soltis 1219 Ivanhoe Drive East Lansing, Michigan 48823 June 19, Yes 1972 NO APPENDIX D DEFINITIONS AND TERMINOLOGY DEFINITIONS AND TERMINOLOGY The following data processing terminology and definitions are presented for a better comprehension of this thesis endeavor. Benchmark--a test designed to serve as a guide for the determination of future expectations. Cathode Ray Tube--CRT; a tube similar to a television picture tube containing a screen on which information may be stored and viewed. Central Processing Unit--CPU; the device that contains the main storage and arithmetic unit and also controls the interpretation and execution of instructions; sometimes referred to as the "brain" or "heart" of the computer system. QQEQLf-Common Business Oriented Language; a computer language for which business data processing procedures are processed on the computer. Computer--a device capable of accepting data for computation, including arithmetic and logic functions, for solving problems and supplying the results; a device that accepts input and supplies output using arithmetic, logic, storage, and processing functions. Computerized--to execute or manipulate or regulate or store with the use of an analog or digital computer. 154 155 Consolew-usually a display terminal or typewriter terminal that is a portion of the computer which can be used to control the processing of computer devices, data, and programs. Qataf-information in card, electrical, or magnetic form containing a collection of elements representing numbers, special characters or symbols, and the alphabet; information used for collecting or processing purposes. Data Processinq--the processing of information by unit record (pre-computer) equipment and computer equipment; that professional field that processes data using computer related equipment. EEEEST’the searching for and correcting of errors (bugs) found in computer programs. Device-~a mechanical medium designed for the processing of data. Diskf-a magnetic storage medium upon which information resides on a flat, rotating surface resembling a long playing record. Display Termina1--cathode ray tube (CRT); a device that shows data on a screen for inquiry and/or updating purposes; associated with teleprocessing systems. Display Tube--see cathode ray tube (CRT). Eilggf-records containing information that is arranged, classified, or collected in an organized manner. 156 Flowchartinge-a method or tool employing symbols which illustrate a sequence of steps necessary to process concepts and/or data; a procedure used in systems analysis for the processing of information in a logical order. Generation--a time frame for the purpose of distinguishing historically when computer equipment evolved; first, second, and third generation computer equipment is distinguished by technological developments. Hardware--the physical data processing equipment as opposed to computer programs. IZQr-input/output. InpuEf-data transmitted or transfered from one medium to another; a device or devices used to submit information to the computer. Inventorye-an accumulation, listing, accounting, collection, or cataloging of valued information. Job Stream--input stream; a series of tasks and jobs submitted to the computer for processing. Magnetic Tapeé-a magnetic storage medium on which data is stored-or used for processing usually one-inch wide and sometimes twenty-four hundred feet in length. Off-Line--unit record or pre-computer equipment; peripheral computer equipment not under the control of the central processing unit (CPU). 157 On—Line--on-1ine processing; ineline processing; peripheral computer equipment under the control of the central processing unit (CPU). Output--information transmitted or transfered from one medium to another usually outside of the computer in a readable form. agile-program language/one; a high level computer language designed to work in a business environment. Program--a set of specific instructions designed to accomplish a desired result; a complete series of instructions necessary to solve a problem. Programminqe-the arrangement and construction of the design, writing (coding), and testing of a program. Skills-~a developed proficiency in some particular activity; an activity requiring special training or knowledge for competence or expertise in its practice. Software--the programs and programming support necessary for the Operation of the computer system and the processing of computer jobs. Storage--the capacity of a computer system to save information until needed. System--a combination of things, parts, methods, or machines forming a united or intact unit. Systems Analysis-~the examination of an activity to determine how many Operations and what operations are necessary to accomplish the desired objectives. 158 Teleprocessing--data that is transmitted between computer devices using communication facilities; originally an IBM trademark; hardware equipment such as diSplay terminals, teletypes, and typewriter terminals. Teletype--associated with teleprocessing; a printer with two way communications with a computer system; a slow communication device designed for file inquiry and a printed response. Termina1--a communication device that provides input and/or output information; usually associated with teleprocessing. Tubgf-see cathode ray tube (CRT); a nickname for CRT's. Typewriter Terminal--associated with teleprocessing; a communication device, similar to an office typewriter, providing printed information usually for inquiry purposes. Unit Record-~punch-card equipment; pre-computer equipment; a device designed to process units of records according to specified procedures. APPENDIX E LEIN CONFIGURATIONS AND INTERFACED SYSTEMS 159 1968 Basic B5500 Configuration Number Type Name 1 B5280 Basic System 1 85281 Additional Processor 8 B461 Memory Modules 1 B124 Card Reader 1 8303 Card Punch 1 B325 Printer 4 B422 Magnetic Tape Units 1 B475 Disk File Storage Module 1 B477-1 Data Memory Bank 3 B477-2 Additional Data Memory Bank Modules 142 28 ASR Teletype Terminals 1975 Basic LEIN Configuration Number Name 2 B-6700 Systems (one megabyte each) 40 Disk Spindles Printers 2 Card Readers 1 Card Punch 10 Nine Track Tape Drives 3 Seven Track Tape Drives 2 Data Communication Processors 220 ASR 28 Teletype Terminals 1650 mamummm omommumucH com szA mm~¢OPm~2 4k¢wmoma zmgohm muouixw> awkz<2 a zmnopm Amincuiumtuxmo mtz<¢¢<3 mmhzuu zomp~mo monF mpmvuu< ucmuruu< uvmwmgp quIUHmzm mw Pv>wu cucwm Fo:_ewtu maomcoppmumw: OLCCML» Locum2mnmwz aco_md . mhz¥u=e2ux hzm2kmm mzo~hGRADUATE STUDY s 1,. 3w COUPLETED CERTIFICATES OR DEGREES (CHECK HIGHEST LEVEL cum) 0 L; Ctlrlrlcnz l L: ASSOCIATE IN ARTS 2 _; “canon 3 (_1 LI... 4 L_J was?" 5 L] DOCTORATE CERTIFICATES OR DEGREES IN: (CHECl run: uosr IMPORTANT) 0 DBL,- ACCOUNTING I ULU DIOLDCICAL SCIENCE 2 ULJLJ Dusmtss ADHINIS. 3 CL‘LJ CHEMISTRY 4 xuxnnnonI)oOwa COURSES STUDIED:I8 OR MORE COLLCCC LEVEL uuurs. CATE NUMIER OF UNITS IN SPACE AFTER aox cnccxco. (CHECK runs: nosr 0¢D\JanJbUl°-O DEL—JILL [.UCC LLBI-II[)CLI‘I[ ‘LL‘. Y J CL"CLILLCE‘BECLC.FCE [.CC I C C CCL L.LICCCC‘L.‘LLDCC|C C C] EFLJCCCCTETCLJ EcononIcs, INDI- Soclolo IMPORTANT) qy, ACCOUNTING Zoology, PsysIoIogl elctorlology,ctc.l (Anthropology, Geography, "Istory, PolltIcal ScIcnco, Psychology, otc.l L LJLJLJ --- STATISTICS cnumowcv A UQL} --- unnzunlcs ECONOMICS a ngg --- nunsmc (CHECK out) EDUCATION C Cr U --- °"°""& “”6"" 0 ’ " ..-,.I IA A ENGLISN '3 Pit—IE “‘ '"som‘u 153A 2(5):) JOURNALISI E dbu _-_ PHOTOGRAPHY 2 D ‘A 5 D 'Y L" r UUU . PHYSICAL SCIENCE LIBERAL ARTS (Astronomy, nuasms “nun“ ”“1“”, 6 D ornu--------.- ...... .. PNYSICAL EDUCATION C'HH'IOQNPM ’- PRESENT IIILITARY RESERVE POLICE SCIENCE PD’DICS. GOOI09’ DNA.“ POLITICAL sconce Illa-rule“, etc.) 0 - . . Anuv ,SVCHOLOG, I; LLU --- POLICE SCIENCE ,: My, PUBLIC ADHINIS. a ‘°“'"'5' 2 C] AIR FORCE SOCIOLOGY N LJL]D 'U'UC ‘0'"“5' 3 C] MARINE cons OTHER .............. ‘ LJLJLJ--- 5°C"L SC'E”CE 5 LjNAIIoNAL GUARD lO. RESERVE STATUS 0 C] uon I L] STAND-RV 2 [_j RETIRED li.PRESEIT RESRYE RUN . MILITARY SERVICE. EXTENDED k—J --- ”I‘m-"MUS” ACTIVE DUTY. (IDENTIFY 0' “mun" U --- ‘DVE’U'S'W MILITARY sunc: sum 0 DE-l/E-a (CPL., A/IC. L1 --- "CHIECTU'E FOREIGN GOVEInutuT IN can 6. no.3 on Long) .U °-- 'Us'"‘55 ‘°“"‘- out CHECK ONLY.) I [JE-S/E-Q (ssr.uAJ.,Cu/ L] --- ENGINEERING . scr. CPO on LOIER) [—1 0' “Gus" (”in") U' S. BRANCH' 2 UNA/v1.4 (IARR.OFCR ) .U "“"C‘ OD non: 3 [301 (2.0 u. -£Ns. I L! J°”"““5" IL] ANY 4 [Jo-2 (Isv LT. .J. c.) U'" “n SUM“ ZUNAVY 51:10.3 (CAPT.-LIEUT.) (Immunochcnlstry, 3 C]A|l Ponce 6 LJO-4 (MAJ.-LT.COIOR.) Biochemistry. Agunmz cons 7L;0-5 (LT.COL.-COIOR.) Entomology, 5 L] COAST GUARD 8 LJO- 6/8 (COL.OR mourn) °'°'°97v “In“ 6 LJ omen ........ .------.--- (NAVY cunon manta) S. SELECTIVE SERVICE QASS. PART II - OCCUPATION ANO SKILLS INVENTORY CNECR A MAXIMUM 0F ‘0 OF THE FOLLOIING SKILLS ACQUIRED THROUGH ACQDEMIC STUDY OR PRACTICAL EXPERIENCE. LIST ONLY mos: sleLi CHEMICAL ANAL YSIS IN INICN vou an: EXPERIENCED. Do NOT INCLUDE COMMON nouns on HOUscNOLD SKILLS IHERE ONLY nu PROFICIENCY ms SEEN ACOUIREDL on TNERE IS LITTLE unrzncsr. AOIINISTRATIVE SKILLS [_J 25. CLINICAL LABORATORY TECHNICIAN TRMSPORTATION r: [__J 26. EXPLOSIVES ._ Ol. ADUINIerunvc ANALYSIS (svsuus L127. ruunus 'Dunncn'o“ (“Lusflcfl [_ISI. AIR PILOT IITN LICENSE. STUDIES. IESEAIICH unuoos. rrc.) L128 rooo AND onus “unis rvn--.---------. .-. ------.- (_102. BUDGET PREPARATION. 29' msnwflunon (PRIVATE. CO-WERCIAL. C103. PERSONNEL IADIIINISTRATION. COUNSCL- ' Us“ CHROMATOGRAPHY 0‘ "‘6' 'uc‘ucm' ""U'THENT' ETC" {__1 sncraouuav HULTI-ENGINE. INSTR. Efc.) L’ 05‘ 'U':'CT"”T'°”5 L] OTHER--- ....................... [_J 52 HELICOPTER PILOT IITN LICENSE. L” ' s“ '5 Ics U 30. MICROSCOPY . PNOTONICROGRAPHY TYPE ............................ CLERICAL GROUP L] 3l roucnnu IOAT o'cnnon (SAIL on room) TYPE . [_1 32. sunvcvmc LICENSE IF ANY ..... .- ..... - U 06' 18:7:fzz'w' ‘CCOUH'W 0' (J 33. TOXICOLOGY L] 54. TRUCK. TRANSPORT 0R sus- OPERATOR D 07. TVPIST ENTERTAINMENT ARI) PROOUCTIM OCCUPATIONS HO SIILLS 08' '.'5cu""‘°”s Clu'c“ 6'0” [_J 34. ACTING on SINGING LJ urns? - CARTOON L’ ”Nun" ”CLONE Li 35. ANNOUNCING on PUILIC SPEAKING LJ curocnnuv on DRAFTING L] AUTOMATIC DATA noctssmc L] 36. “usmum TY" _________ . ________ --- u DIVER stIN on our sun) U ‘Ltcnomc 0‘” "OCESS'NG U 37. nAOIo a TELEVISION PRODUCTION L] GUNSNII'N COOIUNICATINS (lAOIO-TELEVISION-SOUNO {_j 38. scant IRITING (TV a MOT.PIC.) L] LINENAN (Po-u LINES) REPAIR AND MAINTENANCE) [_] LOCKSNITN - JOURNALIOI [_j 61. MEDICAL can: AND/OR TREATMENT L‘ 09' ”0'0 "NC“ "flaw“ """c') C; 39. EDITING D 62. YOUTH ORGANIIATION LEADER L) IO. IUDGLAIY ALARM svsrtns a MAINT. D ‘0 IRITING (scours. WU. ETC.) [3 ll. uooo (nun (women. arc.) ' D 12. TELEVISION (abut, ENGINEER, 4" "'scuu'mus J°U"‘“'5" saour LANNIACES (INDICATE UNETHEI spun. «no, GAMER-AN nc ) D ‘°""“5"‘° v r AND/OR IRITE.) PLACE X IN suct. ' ‘ up ITI N . A U 3. TELEPHONE (INSTALLATION a nun) U co 05 ° L o” s SPEAK READ IRITE L] ‘ "C°'°"‘° "CW'C'" PHOTOGRAPHY cmues:.............0l. ------~I- NISCCLLANIOUS COMMUNICATION GROUP -- [thLtan'N opgnAton LJ‘Z' '"orOG'A'"'C R""' KNENCH ....... .......02. -----I---- ...... U43. STILL morocnuuv alAOIO O'ETPTOP ‘L'CENSED 0' U44_ “07'0” '[cTURE pnofogpgpny GERMAN..............03. ..... .... ...... IxnnerCtO) OII C ”AU“ 04 IE‘ I now-OIDOICIOI - c-ODoL-oc- onus-a CNSTRUCTIM WEN L] '6 IRICILAYER “‘30" L345. "Avg TAUGHT JAPANESE............OS. .......... ...... U17. CARPENTER J‘G' "°' TEACH“ nussum. .....06. ......... . ' L147. VOCATIONAL CREDENTIAL (CIRCLE Int: DIS an" "“5““ cuss A a c on o) suNIsu... .......... 07. .......... 19 ELECTRICIAN . ' ' ' 820 rLUuou .LI‘B' ‘°””"5' c"‘°""'“ YIOOISN.............OB. .......... ' .449. TEACHING CREDENTIAL (£L£.,ssc.nc.) CIIRIIAUS‘I’ICS [3 50. TEACHING Pusouuu ADVIS.CR£O£N. ..............09. .......... C11] BLOOD ALCCNOL DINER (HAVE)........... ...... .. . .... D 22. ILOOD ANALYSIS - A IDMANCY LIPREAOING l0..... .. U23. DACIuIOLocv. GEOLOGY. IOTANV ~—] I I I I LDACHLDLOCV (our nun) ll....... ..-—.-...-- .,, --q_-_———..-‘__.-.-- NA ME CHECK YOUR ABILITY IN THE FOLLOWING LANGUAGES. USE EXTRA 164 METROPOLITAN POLICE DEPARTMENT CITY OF ST. LOUIS LANGUAGES SPACE FOR' ADDITIONAL LANGUAGES. I UIIC—Icr-v-k’“ - - H -— MPTWWH _u“ I -_---. Under» -- ”I "I" *m1._.'I_27_r.IL_I_a_gg‘.__sj;_cj.z)c1 read 91333}; write code La_ngL_Iagc stand read 593a}; (13:13 1:11P] mm 05 RUSSIAN > 35 CHINESE ‘ 08 SPANISH 38 1131mm}! 1 S I GEPJL-‘m 17 --.-...-_- .... .l 1'I';.L;I'I=.II 24 I JAPANESE 25 l CHECK EACH 01“ TIL". FOLIOI'JINS SKILLS THAT YOU I’OSSESS. 05” _‘__Aircraft Pilot 30 Fireman 07" __wArtist 3l___ _Hcavy anipt. Oporatw 08w._~._-_7‘.11d.1.0-Vjsual Tech. 42 ___Photographcr 14 ______ _BUS DrJ' .707: 60 __ __q 20” __(‘mfiputer Operator 6]. 23h____‘__"l)cxr.olition 62 29,—. Fingerprinting 63 .--- 165 S KI LL CODES Code Description Code Description 001 Accountant 042 Photographer 002 Adjuster 043 Plasterer 003 Advertising 044 Plumber 004 Aircraft Mechanic 045 Printer 005 Aircraft Pilot 046 Radio Announcer 006 Armorer 047 Radio Technician 007 Artist 048 Roofer 008 Audio-Visual Technician 049 Salesman 009 Auto Body Mechanic 050 Shorthand 010 Automobile Mechanic 051 Steelworker 011 Baker 052 Switchboard Operator 012 Barber 053 Teacher 013 Bricklayer 054 Teletype Operator 014 Bus Driver 055 Television Announcer 015 Butcher 056 Television Technician 016 Carpenter 057 Truck Driver 017 Cement Worker 058 Waiter 018 Chauffeur 059 Welder 019 Chemist 060 Typist 020 Computer Operator 061 Scuba Diver 021 Cook 062 Comptometer 022 Decorator 063 Polygraph Examiner 023 Demolition 064 Cosmetology 024 Driver 065 Bookkeeping 025 Draftsman 066 Seamstress 026 Electrician 067 Tailor 027 Electronic Technician 068 Bartender 028 Engineer 069 Optical Repair 029 Fingerprinting 070 Programmer-Systems 030 Fireman 071 Pest Control 031 Heavy Equip. Operator O72 Snake Handler 032 Journalist 073 Air Traffic Dispatcher 033 Judo 074 Air Conditioning 034 Keypunch Operator Technician 035 Machinist 075 Radar Repairman 036 Mason 076 Minister 037 Medic 077 Radio Operator-C.W. 038 Metal Worker 073 Glazier 039 Miner 079 Dog Handler 040 Musician 080 Taxidermist 041 Painter 081 082 166 Code Description 083 084 085 086 087 088 089 Referee—Sports 090 TV Producer & Director 091 Sand Blaster 092 Chiropractor 093 Lab Technician 094 Real Estate Broker 095 Blue Printing 096 Electr0plater 097 Physician APPENDIX G IBM DISK COMPARISONS 167 2 999 0252 330 031 07/05/72 1205 01 CSL QY HISSAVfiGF,DIFHAR“,A as" - 00229 AQSGH - 2u0 2&95 CHHR"”|L| nouns ST. LnUIf counTY 63033 00R - 0 w n 003 - 00/10/30 5-10 225 837-7000 MARRIED 00 DEPENDEHTS SOC-SEC 337-20-3175 CI”IL|AH APPOIH‘EU 00/00/05 RNK - MANARER COHPHTFR DI”ISIOH SPOHSE EMPLOYED - no Fu'L-TIMr EHPLOYFE CUSR'HT RA“K DAIE 09/17/09 CIVI'IAH AHHIVFRSARY DATL 00/17/70 EDUFATI'N: BAPHCLORQ - DUSI“ESS ADHIHISTQATIDH,AFCOUHTIhG,ZT0 I SKIL'S: .‘\C"0||.’.'"A.‘.'T.C”PTR OPFR.,KP'),TE/\CFIER DR‘FT ST‘TUS SA SE'WICF BR‘HCH - AIR FORCE RANK - Amrmu 1 0M) IZOHTI'S DUTY 3E9. INS. - FAHI Y ‘1 CA 168 Hm.Hm mo.mm vo.mm oo.mm mm.mm om.HHm H¢.~am oo.maam mouam comammz “mm umoo manages mamm mamm moo.mm «wem mmmm mqmm mmmm mmmm Axomm cam m>muoe find—OS Hmm 0mm3 mmH.H mmm mom mmm mom Nam mmH ma Accoomm Hmm monomsonev ovum Hmmmcmua mama mm mm om mm on om ma omH Amcaoommmmamzv mafia mmmoom aam 0mm oom oa 00H mm mm.a m Ammomaamzv mmmuoum Hopoe mama mama mama mama oamm mmma emmm mmmm “was pamsmoasocqa ommm evmm HH\ommm owmm ommm mamm Hana mama mama xmmn ZmH mZOmHm¢mSOU MmHQ SmH APPENDIX H MLEOTC MINIMUM BASIC POLICE TRAINING CURRICULUM II. III. 169 MLEOTC MINIMUM BASIC POLICE TRAINING CURRICULUM Administration Section 10 Hours Program Orientation 1 Classroom Notetaking 1 Examinations 5 Examination Review 2 Coordinator's Time (graduation, counseling, review, etc.) 1 Legal Section 54 Hours Introduction to Constitutional Law 1 Law of Arrest 4 Detention and Custody 2 Admissions and Confessions 3 Search and Seizure 8 Court Functions 10 Law of Evidence 10 Criminal Law - l4 Juvenile Law 2 Investigative Section 30 Hours Criminal Investigation 10 Vice Investigation 2 Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs 4 IV. 170 Crime Scene Search Collection and Preservation of Evidence Interview and Interrogation Fingerprinting and Latent Print Search Techniques Mock Crime Scene Stolen Motor Vehicles General Police Section History and Philosophy of Law Enforcement The Juvenile Offender Firearms Training Police First Aid Field Notetaking and Report Writing Blockade and Roadblock Procedure Police Communications Patrol Techniques Civil Disorders Mechanics of Arrest and Detention Domestic Complaints State Liquor Law Enforcement Emergency Preparedness (Disaster Control) Stopping Vehicles and Occupant Control Physical Training and Defensive Tactics Traffic Subjects Motor Vehicle Law Driver Licensing D.U.I.L. Enforcement 24 14 28 28 Hours 171 Motor Vehicle Accident Investigation 12 Traffic Direction and Control 2 Techniques and Methods of Traffic Law Enforcement 2 VI. Special Subjects Section 16 Hours Human Relations 8 Police Courtesy and Ethics 4 Handling Abnormal Persons 2 State and Regional Social Services 2 VII. External Relations v.5 Hours Jurisdiction of Federal Law Enforcement Agencies . 2 Michigan Corrections, Parole and Probation System 3 Recommended Courses in Addition to the Above Minimun 256 Hours: Precision—Pursuit Driving Alcohol Education (Understanding the Problems of Alcohol and Alcoholism) Vocabulary and Spelling Practical Exercises in Patrol Situations Public Speaking Proposed Courses to be Given to Each Recruit at the Local Level in Addition to Regional Recruit Training: Department Rules, Regulations, and Policies Department Forms and Reports Local Court and Prosecutor Procedure Local Government Departmental Emergency Plan NOTE: 172 Local Ordinances Local Blockade and Roadblock Plans Conservation Law Boat and Water Safety Additional Course Material should be given to Meet the Training Needs That may be Unique Within each Department. These Course Needs Can Best Be Determined by the Local Administrator. APPENDIX I MLEOTC INSTRUCTOR SUBJECT AREAS 173 MLEOTC INSTRUCTOR SUBJECT AREAS I. Criminal Law A. Includes authorization to teach the following basic curriculum subjects: 1. Constitutional Law 2. Law of Arrest 3. Detention and Custody 4. Admissions and Confessions 5. Search and Seizure 6. Court Functions 7. Law of Evidence 8. Substantive Criminal Law 9. Juvenile Law Qualifications: Applicant must possess either a L.L.B. or J.D. Degree. II. Criminal Investigation A. Includes authorization to teach the following basic curriculum subjects: 1. Investigative Methods 2. Crime Scene Search 3. Collection and Preservation of Evidence III. IV. 174 4. Fingerprinting and Latent Print Search 5. Interview and Interrogation 6. Mock Crime Scene 7. Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs 8. Vice Investigation Qualifications: Experience in a law enforcement investigative position. Police Field Procedures A. Includes authorization to teach the following basic curriculum subjects: 1. Patrol Techniques 2. Blockade and Roadblock Procedure 3. Domestic Complaints 4. Field Notetaking and Report Writing 5. Mechanics of Arrest and Detention 6. Police Communications 7. Stopping Vehicles and Occupant Control Qualifications: Three years of general police patrol experience. Less experience may be acceptable due to education or training relevant to police field procedures. Stolen Motor Vehicles A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Stolen Motor Vehicles." Qualifications: Experience with the Federal Bureau of Investigation, National Auto Theft Bureau, or three years of general police patrol 175 experience. Less police patrol experience may be acceptable due to education or training relevant to stolen vehicle investigation. V. Traffic Law Enforcement A. Includes authorization to teach the following basic curriculum subjects: 1. Motor Vehicle Law 2. Motor Vehicle Accident Investigation 3. Techniques and Methods of Traffic Law Enforcement 4. DUIL Enforcement 5. Traffic Direction and Control Qualifications: Three years of police patrol experience which included responsibility for traffic law enforcement and accident investigation. Less experience may be acceptable due to 7 education or training relevant to traffic law enforcement. VI. Driver Licensing A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Driver Licensing." Qualifications: Experience with the driver licensing section of the Michigan Secretary of State's Office, or three years of police patrol experience which included responsibility for traffic law enforcement. Less experience may be acceptable due to education or training relevant to driver licensing. VII. VIII. IX. 176 Police Community Relations A. Includes authorization to teach the following basic curriculum subjects: 1. History and Philosophy of Law Enforcement 2. Police Courtesy and Ethics 3. Human Relations Qualifications: Experience in a law enforcement position with administrative responsibility, or education and training relating to the relationship of the police to society. Social Problems 1;. Includes authorization to teach the following basic curriculum subjects: 1. Handling Abnormal Persons 2. State and Regional Social Services Qualifications: Experience, education, or training directly relating to abnormal psychology and social counseling. Juvenile Offenders A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "The Juvenile Offender." Qualifications: Experience in a position in which the primary responsibility involved juvenile casework. Civil Disorders A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Civil Disorders." XI. XII. XIII. XIV. 177 B. Qualifications: Training in the control of civil disorders. Emergency Preparedness--Disaster Control. A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Emergency Preparedness-- Disaster Control." B. Qualifications: Experience in a law enforcement position which included administrative responsibility for emergency planning and disaster control. State Liquor Law Enforcement A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "State Liquor Law Enforcement." B. Qualifications: Experience in a position with the Michigan Liquor Control Commission or as a law enforcement officer with special liquor enforcement responsibilities. Jurisdiction of Federal Law Enforcement Agencies A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Jurisdiction of Federal Law Enforcement Agencies.“ B. Qualifications: Experience as a federal law enforcement officer. Michigan Corrections, Parole, and Probation System. A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Michigan Corrections, Parole, and Probation System." 178 B. Qualifications: Experience either with the Michigan Department of Corrections or as a Michigan probation officer. XV. Physical Training A. Includes authorization to teach only the physical training classes of the basic curriculum subject "Physical Training and Defensive Tactics." B. Qualifications: Education or training in the instruction of physical education. XVI. Defensive Tactics. A. Includes authorization to teach all of the basic curriculum subject "Physical Training and Defensive Tactics." B. Qualifications: Both law enforcement experience, and training or experience in instructing defensive tactics. XVII. Firearms. A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Firearms Training." B. Qualifications: Both law enforcement experience and training in combat firearms instruction. XVIII. Police First Aid. A. Includes authorization to teach the basic curriculum subject "Police First Aid." B. Qualifications: Medical education or possession of a currently valid Red Cross First Aid instructor's certificate. APPENDIX J. MLEOTC TC—03 FORM 137E) mumm- us mall-Ir omcns mum: common. rc-os (rev 7/7‘) APPLICATION FOR xnsrkucroa crnrxrtcarlon (check one) [::] Original Application Return original and two copies (2) to tha school coordinator. . [:3 Additional Information Name: last first middle today a date Permanent as street or route no.. ty, 2 . County fnstitution Location not,qtr.or Major course ci sta f t Present employing agency Years 0 Service Explain nature 0 nor ive re Previous positions relevant to this application: Inst tor r inin 5 oo schoo o c it ‘fpcr Tra ' wfl BASIC (signature of regional academy coordinator required) ADVANCFD ( u n n u n u ) academy coordinator I. I. H ) SPECIALIZED ( " " H DUDE] 'DEPAR1MFNTAL IN-SERVICE (signature of agegey head required) airnrv ‘ 180 TV. SUBUECT AREAS Check the subject areas in which you desire certification. The necessary qualifications for each area are listed below. Compliance with these qualifications must be documented on the front. l I ] CRIMINAL LAN [ ] STOLEN MOTOR VEHICLES Constitutional Law [ ] TRAFFIC LAN ENFORCEMENT Law of Arrest Motor Vehicle Law Detention C Custody Motor Vehicle Accident investigation Admissions 5 Confessions Techniques 8 Methods of Traffic Law Enf. Search 8 Seizure D.U.i.L. Enforcement Court Functions _ Traffic Direction 8 Control Law of Evidence [ ] DRIVER LICENSING ' Substantive Criminal Law [ ] POLICE COMMUNITY RELATIONS [ ] CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION History S Philosophy Investigative Methods Police Courtesy 8 Ethics Crime Scene Search Human Relations Collection 8 Preservation of Evidence [ ] SOCIAL PROBLEMS Fingerprinting 8 Latent Print Search Handling Abnormal Persons interview 8 interrogation State 5 Regional Social Services Mock Crime Scene Narcotics 5 Dangerous Drugs Vice Investigation [ ] POLICE FIELD PROCEDURES Patrol Techniques JUVENILE OFFENDERS CIVIL DISORDERS EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS - DISASTER CONTROL STATE LIQUOR LAN ENFORCEMENT JURISDICTION OF FEDERAL LAN ENF. AGENCIES MICHIGAN CORRECTIONS,PAR0LEJ S PROBATION svs. PHYSICAL TRAINING DEFENSIVE TACTICS FIREARMS POLICE FIRST AID OTHER (specify): Domestic Complaints Field Notetaking 5 Report Nriting Mechanics of Arrest s Detention Police Communications Stopping Vehicles S Occupant Control I i I l E Blockade 8 Roadblock Procedure E l I l [ V. QUALIFICATIONS FOR CERTIFICATION iN THE RESPECTIVE SUBJECT AREAS CRIMINAL LAN: L.L.B. or J.D. degree. CRIMINAL iNVESTiGATiON: Experience In an investi ative position. FIELD PROCEDURES: Three years patrol experience or relevant education/training. STOLEN VEHICLES: Experience with FBI, NATB, or three years police patrol. - TRAFFIC ENFORCEMENT: Three years patrol experience with traffic responsibility or relevant education/training. DRIVER LICENSING: Experience with $05 or three years police patrol which included licensing responsibility or relevant education/training. POLICE COMMUNITY RELATIONS: Law enf. administrative position.or relevant education/training. SOCIAL PROBLEMS: Special relevant experience or education/training. JUVENILE OFFENDERS: Experience in juvenile casework CIVIL DISORDERS: Training In control of civil disorders. EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS - DISASTER CONTROL: Position with responsibility for emergency planning. LIQUOR LAW ENFORCEMENT: Experience with MLCC or experience as designated liquor enf. officer. JURISDICTION 0F FEDERAL LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES: Experience with a federal agency. CORRECTIONS: Experience as probation officer or with the Department of Corrections. PHYSICAL TRAINING: Education/training in physical education Instruction. DEFENSIVE TACTICS: Both law enf. exper. and trng. or exper. in instructing defensive tactics. FIREARMS: Both law enforcement experience and training in firearms instruction. FIRST AID: Red Cross First Aid Instructor's Certificate or medical education. Vi. FOR USE BY M.L.E.0.T.C. Approved for Executive Secretary date M.L.E.0.T.C. BIBLIOGRAPHY BIBLIOGRAPHY _Baker, Sgt. Timothy J. Training Division, Michigan State Police. Personal Interview, Lansing, Michigan, June 2, 1975. Baker, Sgt. Timothy J. Training Division, Michigan State Police. Phone Conversation, Lansing, Michigan, December 17, 1976. Bassett, Glenn A. and Harvard Y. Weatherbee. Personnel Systems and Data Management. Boston: American Management Association, 1971, p. 215. Brown, Captain W. G. Commanding Officer, Management Services Division, Department of Police, Los Angeles, California. Correspondence, June 22, 1972. Bueschel, Richard T. "Changing Nature of Personnel." Personnel Journal (January 1966), p. 20. Bueschel, Richard T. "How EDP is Improving the Personnel Function." Personnel (September—October 1964), p. 59. Clague, Ewan. Skill Development and Job Training in an Automated Age. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Labor, November 17, 1961, pp. 6, 13, 18. Columbus, Eugene G. "Basic Computer Concepts." The Police Chief (September 1968), p. 39. ‘7 Columbus, Eugene G. “Management by Systems." Police Chief (July 1970), p. 14. Dearden, John. "How to Organize Information Systems." Harvard Business Review (March-April 1965), p. 69. Department of State Police, Salem, Oregon. Statement of June 24, 1972. Duks, Paul. "Personnel Records: Along the Road to Automation." Personnel_(May-June 1959), p. 31. 181 182 Fladseth, LeRoy A. "The Role of the Michigan Department of State Police in Urban Law Enforcement." Unpublished Master's Thesis, Michigan State University, 1972, p. 74. Fladseth, Sgt. LeRoy A. Training Division, Michigan State Police. Personal Interview, East Lansing, Michigan, May 1971. Fladseth, Sgt. LeRoy A. Training Division, Michigan State Police. Personal Interview, East Lansing, Michigan, June 1971. Garlet, Charles. "How a Computer Can Do Your Personnel Selection." The Office (September 1963), p. 109. Gedda, Sgt. George R. Training Division, Michigan State Police. Personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, June 12, 1972. Good, Carter V. Dictionary of Education. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1959, p. 464. Good, Carter V. Essentials of Educational Research. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1972) pp. 1‘5. Harris, Chester W. "Research Methods." Encyclopedia of Educational Research. New York: The MacMillan Company, 1960, p. 1160. Hiscocks, A. F. "The Computerization of Administrative Records." The Police Journal (January 1969), pp. 10' lS‘lGe Hoes, Wesley. Assistant Executive Secretary, Michigan Law Enforcement Officer's Training Council. Personal interview, Lansing, Michigan, November 2, 1976. "Information Retrieval System Design Guidelines." Unpublished report for MLEOTC, March 1973, p. 17. Kansas Highway Patrol, Topeka, Kansas. Correspondence dated June 29, 1972. Keefe, John E. "Computer Skills Bank Uncovers New Teacher Talent." Nation's Schools (June 1970), p. 56. Kipp, James E. Supervisor, Computer Operations, Data Processing Division, Michigan State Police. Personal Interview, East Lansing, Michigan, August 13, 1975. 183 "Law Enforcement Information Network: The Key to Effective Law Enforcement in Michigan." Unpublished Booklet, 1967, p. 9. Law Enforcement_Software Package. Data Processing Division, Sperry Rand Corporation, n.d., p. a. Liebtag, Wesley R. "How an EDP Personnel Data System Works for Corporate Growth." Personnel (July- August 1970), p. 15. Lindholm, James R., et al. "System Study of Personnel Records." Unpublished report, February 1967, pp. 1, 47. Manson, Charles M. "Computer Improves Promotion Opportunities." Industrial Relations News (September 21, 1963), p. 3. Mayer, Steven J. "EDP Personnel Systems: What Areas are Being Automated?" Personnel (July—August 1971), p. 29. McDonell, R. E. "Planning for Cooperative Information Sharing Programs in Law Enforcement." Unpublished paper, 1968 , p. 11. Meyers, Captain Charles. Commanding Officer, Training Division, Michigan State Police. Intereoffice Correspondence, East Lansing, Michigan, June 8, 1971. Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council-- MLEOTC. Know Your Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council. Department OISState Police, Lansing, Michigan, n.d., p. 2. Michigan Law Enforcement Officers Training Council-- MLEOTC. Policies and Procedures Manual. Department of State Police, Lansing, Michigan, n.d., pp. i-ii. Missavage, Richard A. Manager, Computer Division, Metropolitan Police Department, St. Louis, Missouri. Correspondence dated July 6, 1972. "MLEOTC File Problem Notes." Unpublished paper by MLEOTC, January 8, 1973, p. l. 184 Olander, Oscar G. Michigan State Police: A Twenty Five. Year History. Michigan: Michigan Police Journal Press, 1942, p. 27. Olsen, Ronald D. "Skills Inventory-—A Step Toward Better Manpower Management." Manage (March 1963), p. 5. Olson, Bruce T. "An Exploration of the Effects of Member Goal Preferences on a Basic Training Curriculum in a State Police Agency." Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Michigan State University, 1971, pp. 82—83. Perrin, Don A. Acting Director, Administrative Data Processing Department, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan. Information provided May 14, 1976. Personnel Data System. White Plains, New York: IBM Corporation, 1968, p. 1. "Personnel Reports--A CBS Special." Business Automation (March 1965), p. 53. Plants, John R. "Michigan's Law Enforcement Information Network." Datamation (June 1969), p. 108. Plants, John R. "Statewide Computer Based Law Enforcement Information Systems." Law Enforcement Science and Technology. WashingtonT—D.C.: Thompson B06k Company, 1967, pp. 523-525. President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice. Task Force Report: Science and Technolggy. WEShington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967, pp. 158, 160. President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice. The Challenge of Crime in a Free Societ . Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967, p. 107. Reeves, George T. The Executive Selection and Inventory S stem. Washifigton, D.C.: Federal Aviation Administration, August 21, 1970, p. l. Reinier, G. Hobart and Robert M. Igleburger. "Information Technology." Police Chief (May 1970), p. 28. Rooker, Captain Gene A. Commanding Officer, Training Division, "Michigan State Police Enlisted Departmental Members Education Information." Unpublished report, 1973, pp. 1—45. 185 Rynbrandt, Alyn J. Marketing Representative, IBM Corporation. Personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, October 4, 1973. Rynbrandt, Alyn J. Marketing Representative, IBM Corporation. Personal interview, East Lansing, Michigan, November 1, 1974. Sheppard, David I. and Albert S. Glickman. Police Careers. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas, 1973, p. vii. Skills Inventory System for the IBM 1401. Yorktown Heights, New York: IBM Corporation, February 1964’ 1401-10e3e049’ pa IIIe "State of Michigan Law Enforcement Information Network." Unpublished Report by the LEIN Policy Advisory Committee, East Lansing, Michigan, October 1, 1968, pp. 1, 8. United States Department of Commerce. Computerized Personnel Infgrmation System. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1971, p. i. United States Department of Justice. Career Development for Law Enforcement. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, June 1973, pp. 16, 26. Videtti, Joseph A. "Application of Computers in Law Enforcement." Police (July-August 1969, p. 38. GENERAL REFERENCES GENERAL REFERENCES Bartram, John L. "Maintaining an Inventory of Applicants." Journal of the College and University Personnel Association—TFebruary 1970), pp. 43:44. Cohen, Bernard. "A Police Career Path Management Appraisal System." Police Chief (March 1975), pp. 62—65. Cragun, John R. and Ernest J. McCormick. Job Inventory Information: Task and Scale Reliabilities and7 Scale InterrelatIonships. LackIand Aif—Force Base, Texas: PersonneIfiResearch Laboratory, 1967. Cronkhite, Clyde L. Automation and Law Enforcement. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas, 1974. Crossman, E.R.F.W. Seminar on Manpower Policy and Program: Automation, Skilly and ManpoweriPredictions. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Labor, September 1966. Crowe, Robert L. "The Computer and Personnel Selection." School Management (August 1972), pp. 40-41, 52. Frank, Alan R., et a1. “Developing a WOrk Skills Inventory." Teaching Exceptional Children (Winter 1971), pp. 82-86. Hearle, Edward F.R. and Raymond J. Mason. A Data Processigg System for State and Local GovernmenEs. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1963. Hoy, William A. "Computerizing the Small Campus Placement Function." Journal of College Placement (February- March 1971), pp. 67-72. Lister, Charles. "Privacy and Large-Scale Personal Data Systems." Personnel and Guidance Journal (November 1970), pp. 207-211. 186 187 Magruder, Donald R. "A Model for the Utilization of Electronic Data Processing for the Retrieval of Educational Personnel Data." Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Florida State University, 1968. McKinley, Bruce. Oregon Career Information System: An Evaluation of Phases I and II of a Three Phase Development Project. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, March 1974. Moss, Alan L. "GI's Draw on Job Bank." Manpower (October 1972), pp. 26-27. Mumford, Enid. Computers, Planning and Personnel Managements. London: Lawrence Brothers, 1969. National Guard Bureau. Personnel Information Systems: Officer Personnel Reporting System. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1973. Nordland, Willis J. An Investigation of the Economic Impact of Computer-Assisted?Placement Systems. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department ofiLabor, August 1972. Rieder, Robert J. Law Enforcement Information Systems. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas, 1972. Roush, Fred. "Lansing Police Department Informational/ Operational Flow System." Unpublished Report, n.d. ~ Schoenfeldt, Lyle F. "Utilization of Manpower: Development and Evaluation of an Assessment—Classification Model for Matching Individuals with Jobs." Journal of Applied Psychology (October 1974), pp. 583-595. Seymour, W. Douglas. Industrial Skills. London: Sir Isaac Pitman and Sons, Ltd., 1966. Seymour, W. Douglas. Skills Analysis Training. London: Sir Isaac Pitman and Sons, Ltd., 1968. Skills Conversion Project. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Labor, March 1972. The Job Bank. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Labor, 1971. 188 Thresher, Craig L., et a1. "Computer—Aided Education Management: An Integrated Records and Counseling System." Journal of Educational Data Processing (July-August 1971), pp. 1-10. Ullman, Joseph C. and George P. Huber. The Local Job Bank Program. Lexington, Massachusetts: Lexington Books, 1973. Westin, Alan F. and Michael A. Baker. Databanks in a Free Societ . New York: New York Times Book Company, 1572. ”'IIII'IIIIIIIIII III II III III III III“