FOOD PREFERENCES AND SURVIVAL OF THE AGRIMI (CAPRA AEGAGRUS CRETENSIS) 0N CRETE Thesis for the Degree of M S. MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY NICOLAOS PAPAGEORGIOU 1 9 7 2 nnnnn ....... ........ LIBRARY (I, Mickisen sun, Unwed”, ABSTRACT FOOD PREFERENCES AND SURVIVAL OF THE AGRIMI (CAPRA AEGAGRUS CRETENSIS) ON CRETE by Nicolaos Papageorgiou A study was conducted on Theodorou Island, Crete, Greece during the summer of 1971 to determine the food preferences, range conditions and population densities of the Cretan wild goat or agrimi (gapga aegagrus cretensis). A survey of the 68-hectare island determined that 137 animals were present with 58 percent adults, 20 percent yearlings and 22 percent kids. The adults were nearly equally divided by sex. Shrubs made up 79.0, forbs 17.8 and grasses 3.2 percent of the animal's diet during spring to mid-summer. In late summer, however, the agrimi's diet changed to 39.9 percent shrubs, and 60.1 percent forbs. Grasses were not used. Highly preferred species for the agrimi from March to mid-July were: Teurium pollium, Cistus incanus, Cupressus sempervirens, Rheichardia picroides, Olea oleaster, Calygotome villosa, and Siderides sp. In late summer, preferred species were Olea oleaster, Rheichardia picroides, Asphodelus microcarpus, Cistus incanus and Scilla maritima. Euphorbia paralias, Thybra capitata, Helichrysum italicum and Anthoxanthum odoratum were widely distributed over the range but were not utilized. The present agrimi population was found to be causing serious range deterioration since the four highly preferred species were 68 and 98 percent utilized during spring and the vegetation consisted only of 11.5 percent preferred species, 38.1 percent less preferred, and 50.2 percent avoided food plants. FOOD PREFERENCES AND SURVIVAL OF THE AGRIMI (CAPRA AEGAGRUS CRETENSIS) 0N CRETE by Nicolaos Papageorgiou A THESIS Submitted to MUchigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE Department of Fisheries and Wildlife 1972 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The writer wishes to express his sincere appreciation to the New York Zoological Society for field financial assistance. Special appreciation is extended to Dr. George A. Petrides, chairman of my Guidance Committee, for support throughout the study and for editing the manuscript. Thanks are also extended to Dr. L. W. Gysel and Dr. K. R. Hudson, members of my Guidance Committee, for their helpful sugges- tions. I offer greatful acknowledgment to the Greek Forest Service, given all possible assistance, and especially to Mr. D. Sideride, Director of Research Planning, for his complete cooperation and assistance throughout the study. Finally, to my brother George, for his encouragement and assistance during the course of my studies. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction...............................................l Study Area............................................3 Methods...................................................ll Forage Availability and Utilization Surveys..........ll Food Habits Studies..................................14 Food Preferences.....................................15 Feeding Trial........................................17 Population Census Determination......................l8 Range Condition......................................19 Results and Discussion....................................20 Spring Food Preferences..............................20 Summer Food Preferences..............................24 Population Size and Structure........................28 Range Condition......................................3l Conclusions and Recommendations for Management............40 Summary...................................................43 Literature Cited..........................................46 Appendixooooooooooooooeo000000000.0.00000000.000000000000048 LIST OF TABLES Table Page 1. Analysis of 3 soil samples from widely separated sites on Theodorou Island, Crete, Greece, July, 1971.00.00.00.0.0.0....O...OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO....0. Basic data for the calculation of relative consumption and preference ratings for forage eaten by the agrimi during March-mid-July. Theodorou Island, Crete, Greece, l97l..............21 Consumption of and summer preference ratings for forage glants) offered to a captured yearling (1 1 kg.) agrimi. Theodorou Island, Crete, Greece, August 12-19, l971..................25 Results of forage analysis and feeding trial involving a single agrimi. Theodorou Island, Crete, Greece, August 12-19, 1971..................29 Sex and age composition of the agrimi population. Theodorou Island, summer l97l......................30 Body measurements of four captured animals (centimeters). Theodorou Island, summer 1971......32 Utilization by agrimi and the availability of highly-preferred forage species. Therodorou Island. Crete, Greece, March to mid-July, 1971....33 Food preferences and plant cover, frequency and density on 68 plots on Theodorou Island, Greece, July, 1971.000.00.000.00...OOOIOOOOOOOOOOOOO0.00.0.35 LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 1. Mp Of crateOOOIOOOOOOOO0.0000......00.00000000000l‘ 2. Topographic map of Theodorou Island...............5 3. Distribution of precipitation and maximum and minimum air temperatures during the year. Based on 1960-70 climatic data of National Meteorologic Service Chania, Crete, Greece........7 4. Percentages of forage classes available and eaten by the wild agrimi population. Theodorou Island between March and July 20, 1971.00.00.0000000000..OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0.0.26 5. Percentages of forage classes available and eaten by a captive yearling agrimi feeding trial. August 12 to 19, 1971....................26 6. Cover, frequency and density of avoided increasers, increasers, and decreasers found in 68 plots on Theodorou Island, July, 1971.00.00.00000000000.0.000...0.....00....37 INTRODUCTION The agrimi or Cretan wild goat (93233 aegaggus cretensis Schinz) is one of the world's rarest hoofed mammals and one of the four subspecies from which our domestic goat may have been derived (Sclater, 1886; Dolan, 1965). The species ranges from the Greek islands across Asia‘Minor and southern Russia to the mountains of western India. The agrimi is interesting from both historical and zoological points of view. Knowledge of the subspecies dates back 3500 years to when it was represented upon official seals and appeared in numerous early Minoan paintings (Dolan, 1965). The agrimi was still common on Crete as late as 1850 when a sharp decline began with the introduction of modern firearms and lack of protection (Butler, 1951; Farmar, 1952). Today it is a rare subspecies, being found wild only in rugged and inaccessible areas of the White Mountains of western Crete at altitudes of 3500 to 7000 feet. The agrimi population on Crete and introduced islands was roughly estimated several years ago to be 400 (Dolan, 1965). Interbreeding occurs freely between the agrimi and the 'widespread domestic goat (Danford, 1875; Hatzisarantos and Kanelis, 1955) and hybridization threatens the existence of the pure agrimi. Diseases and parasites of the domestic goat (Zervas, 1961) present a further serious threat to the agrimi. Considering these factors, the first major aim of the Greek Forest Service was to insure the survival of wild agrimia by capturing and transporting them to reserves acquired for this purpose. Sanctuaries for the agrimi were established on uninhabited islands off the coast of Crete. In 1928, the first introduction of the agrimi took place when a pair was released on the 68-hectare offshore island, St. Theodori, locally referred to as Theodorou. Agrimi were next introduced on two other uninhabited coastal islands off Crete. The 1350-hectare island Dias and the 40-hectare island Agii Pantes were stocked in 1957 and 1960, respectively (Schultze- Westrum, 1963). These islands serve as official reserves for the agrimi and belong to and are administered by the Greek Forest Service. This project was initiated during the summer of 1971: (1) to determine food availability, forage use and forage preference values, (2) to estimate present agrimi densities and their effects on range conditions, and (3) to appraise prospects for successful species preserva- tion. Previous Studies Intensive studies of the agrimi, especially with regard to its ecology, seem to be lacking. The few studies which have been made are related to taxonomic status (Hatzisarantos, 1950), life history (Hatzisarantos and Kanelis, 1955; Zervas, 1961) and distribution (Schultze-Westrum, 1963). The rarity and restricted distribution of the agrimi and the relative inaccessible habitat of the species in the White Mbuntains may partially account for this (Farmer, 1952). Study Area The portions of the investigation.which will be reported here were conducted on St. Theodori Island. Of the three islands on which agrimi have been introduced, Theodorou is the only one where wild stock still exist in pure form (Dolan, 1965; Schultze-Westrum, undated). The island lies about eight kilometers northwest of Chania, the capital of Crete, and is roughly triangular in shape. It is, at most, 1550 meters in length and 750 meters in width, with an area of approximately 68 hectares (Figure 1). At its highest point, the island rises 156 meters above the sea. Its north and west sides terminate abruptly in impressive near-perpendicular limestone cliffs (Figure 2), making access to the island from these sides difficult. Climate Climatically, the area is semi-tropical with yearbround high temperatures. Available data for the last decade 3.3.. I8 I SI 9 . o .3vo .Ho Ame-2 . Hmofiwwm 3.13m .3 .mm .1.“ wkmmv mm Slade. m2 .<.t manage you poms moasooooum esopoHMHe .haco apsoam psoan m.hoo> esophao one you one even .hopoa ohozvo ono Sumo .opoan oanaon mm seam oonaopno spot 8099 oovoazoaoo onoz oaopoos pom opsmao3_aopoa* oo.ooa 00.00H om.mm me.mem muflepoa oe.o Hm.aa oo.m mm.ma eo.o mm.as Hme.o eeoofiesee mascara me.o Hm.ea me.m em.n mm.~ em.eH oae.n usaeeooeoea esaeeoneme Hm.o oa.o~ em.me mm.mm mm.oe mm.nom mae.o msomeesea eeoeeeem sm.o sm.am mm.e mo.m ma.e Ho.ma mmo.u assesses eflaeom no.0 OH.¢N mm.m mm.n mo.m me.ma mmm.o eseoeepsn somonoeese mm.H ma.sm om.o mm.o mm.o no.0 Hom.o .ne eeeeseeem om.H mo.me mm.na mm.o om.ma om.mm Nee.o emoaaee esopoosaeo Ho.~ om.me me.o mm.m mo.e Hm.ma Hmm.o seeeeeao eeao em.m me.me mm.a mm.o ee.a om.m mmm.o meeeoeoem eeeeeeoeeem em.n me.Hm mm.m as.o mH.m sm.m mme.o meeeeeseesee assesseso em.m em.mm em.m mm.o ms.m mm.m Nem.o «sneeze mseeeo mm.m eo.mm Hm.oa Hm.m mm.m sm.m Hoa.o aseaaoe guesses weaves A.amxv A.hmxv oonopowoam Ho>oaoa soHpQBSonoo omoaom oaopoon oaopoon A.amv omoaom panda zpopoua oanwafio>< you »oHMMmewm WMMMQHMM .muo .mnm **ooaxmmum ooaxmmnm eeasweoo AH m a mmwaGmOhom *mvflwflma E mmwhmzq. moaomflm mama—“om .Hema .ooooao .opoho .osonH Sohoeoona .hHSbuoaausouoz mcahso «Beams on» up Gopoo owohom now mmnapoa oocoaomoum use GOHPQESmsoo o>uvoaoa Ho cofipoHSoHoo one pom memo oaoom .N oHnoa 22 picroides, 913g oleaster, Calycotome villosa, and Siderides sp. These species may be termed preferred or "ice cream" foods in the agrimi's normal diet on this range. Species ‘with high preference and low availability mainly occurred protected beneath thorny shrubs. Some were utilized to between 65.79 and 98.0 percent. Species which tended to be avoided (that is, for which low preference was exhibited) were: Pistacea lentiscus, Scilla maritima, Andropogon pubescens, Agphodelus microca us, and Phlomis fruticora. Species which did not show any feeding even though their abundance on the range was high were: Euphorbia paralias, Thybra capitata, Bromus sterilis, Dactylis glomerata, Plantago lagopus, Helichrysum.italicum, and‘giggg halepensis. A few additional plants did not occur on the study plots and were not sufficiently abundant to provide an appreciable portion of the agrimi's diet. Those which showed a considerable degree of utilization were: Arbutus ugggg, Caparis spinosa, and Figus carica. The shrub Poterium spinosum also showed a slight use of newly-growing twigs before the development of thorns. The calculated food preferences for the agrimi are based on the assumption that the low rat population present did not leave browse marks which resembled those of the wild goat. Rats are mainly seed-eaters and grazers and would seem normally not to be competitive with the mainly 23 browsing agrimi. Any error which may have occurred in hand- clipped samples is believed to have affected both utilization and availability data in similar proportions and the calcu- lated food preference ratios were not affected in their relative values. As evidenced by the data of Table 2, the most valuable species in terms of bulk contribution to the agrimi's diet on this particular range were Pistacea lentiscus, Calycotome villosa, Teurium pollium, Phlomis fruticosa and Q; g oleaster. These species comprised 82.43 percent of the diet. They were not highly preferred foods, since they comprised 85.33 percent of the forage and totaled 82.43 percent of the agrimi diet. Yet these species were of definite significance in that they formed the major foods eaten. Pistacea lentiscus comprised 53.84 percent of the avail- able forage and was the most abundant forage plant on the range. It is evergreen and made up 43.66 percent of the animal's diet from spring to mid-July and seemed likely to be used rather consistently throughout the year. It appears to be the most important plant species for the agrimi on this particular range. The agrimi's preferences for Teurium pollium, Cistus incanus and Cupressus ggmperuirens were very high; and for the species Pistacea gentiscus and Phlomis fruticosa were very low (Table 2). Yet in terms of total dietary intake, 24 the species Pistacea lentiscis and Phlomis fruticosa, were most important and the species Teurium.polium, Cgpressus sempervirens and Cistus incanus had little dietary signifi- cance. . The results of this study may not be applicable to establish broad regional references for preferred foods of the agrimi. This is because of the local diversity in plant communities, and because the preferences exhibited by the agrimi in any area are dependent on the plant species present. But it is believed that these data can be used to indicate grazing intensities and range trends for areas with similar vegetation types. Furthermore, these preference data may also be equally applicable to ranges where domestic goats are grazed since these livestock originated, in large part at least, from the agrimi. Summer Food Preferences According to the 7-day feeding trial, the agrimi's summer diet was made up of 60.1 percent forbs and 33.9 percent shrubs as compared with their 58.4 and 37.9 percent summer avail- ability, respectively. Grasses showed no use in spite of their 36 percent availability (Figure 5). In descending order of preference (Table 3) determined during the summer for a captive yearling agrimi, preferred food species were: Olea oleaster, Rheichardia picroides, Asphodelus microcarpus, 25 o.ooa mm¢.~ o.ooa oHH.m no.0 n.5H om: m.mH saw ooooapshu uaaodnm no.0 o.on mmb e.Hm emm muoapaod oooopmam Ho.H m.5H MNJ $.5H m¢m oaHvAhoa oHHfiow eo.a e.m we o.~ Ho anemone espnao mo.H m.mH nee m.sa can nanneccacHs enacecsana :N.H v.0 Hma ¢.m mod moeaoaoan owononoaonm mN.H N.e men o.m med aopmooao ooao one is mmcapoh pofic SH oHnoHHm>o oonoaouoag Poem cw moaoomm non oanoHHo>o mouoonn hoe noaoomm owonom paoonom pnmao3_hha pcooaom psmao3 ram mum a o m a .Hnma .mHnNH vosms< .ooooau .ovoao .ocoHoH sonoooose .Hawawo A.mx H.¢HV madahooh oousvmoo o op oopommo unmade omohom how omcwpou oocohowohn one possum Ho soflpnasmsou .m oanoe 26 100'] £1 Percent forage available .- Percent food eaten 75s 60 1 is 4 _£lL11 Shrubs Forbs Grasses Figure 4. Percentages of forage classes available and eaten by the wild agrimi population. Theodorou Island between March and July 20, 1971. 75‘ 50‘ ‘5‘ I—I Shrubs wa s Grasses Eéfieu’n'by 5.; cistffitgfiégfiiiég £23531 $1323; 3:: 32131.23. August 12 to 19. 1971. 27 Scilla maritima, and Cistus incanus. Species of low preference were Pistacea lentiscus and Phlomis fruticosa, while other plant species eaten during the spring such as Cupressus sumpervirens, Calycotome villosa, Andropogon pubescens, were not eaten during the late summer even though available. There was a conspicuous shift from browse species during the spring to a variety of forbs during the summer. The development of thorns in the case of Calycotome villosa and physiological changes in Cupressus and Andropogon species are believed to account for their unpalatability. Forbs which were not much eaten during spring, were far more important in the summer diet. Most shrubs were not as succulent as the forbs were. Though the plants offered during the feeding trial were presented in amounts which were proportional to their presence on the range, it is possible that the preferences displayed thenwere somehow affected by the captive situation. The evidence is that agrimi welfare is directly related to the quantity and quality of their food supply during the summer. Knowledge of food preferences and the nutritional values of range vegetation at that season is essential to the proper management and continued survival of these remnant agrimi populations. The average daily forage consumption during the feeding trial was found to be 347 grams (dry weight) (Table 3), which was nearly 2.5 percent of the animal's total weight. It was 28 determined (Table 4) that the average daily diet was made up of 4.51 percent proteins, 9.89 percent fats, and 25.3 percent crude fiber. The daily energy requirements were calculated to be about 1,467.80 kcal. The animal's weight of 14.150 kilograms remained unchanged during the period of the feeding trial. The daily water consumption of the captive agrimi was measured and was approximately 1.1 kg. without taking into consideration the (certainly minimal) losses due to evapora- tion from the container. Further feeding and primary production experiments must be carried out using representative animals of both sexes and all weight classes if data of this type are to be applied to the entire wild agrimi population in order to determine the carrying capacity of the island. Population Size and Structure The census on July 8, 1971, counted 137 agrimia on Theodorou Island. Comprising 42 adult males, 38 adult females, 27 yearlings, and 30 kids (by percentages: 30.7 males, 27.7 females, 19.7 yearlings, and 21.9 kids). The overall density was almost exactly two per hectare. The sex ratio among 80 identified adults was nearly even (Table 5). The yearlings and kids did not exhibit clear sexual dimorphism and were not sexed. Eighty to eighty-five .manon aaaoo o no onog covenaoe 939 A0 seafloov m oHnoa 80pm oped no vomom * eased ooESmcoo heapsosv nooz Apv .moaoomm owoaom Ho mammaoqo Mo mpHfioom on 29 am0.mmv Aa00.0v Aaam.ev 0.eem 00.e0ea eem.em eam.em meo.ma fleece m.0 mm.He Nem.e Nm0.o mNm.N mm.0m 00H.H om.HH one. mm0.e anemone nseoao 0.mm 00.00 mom.m m0H.e smm.e 0m.mm eem.a me.m me0.H who.e noeeoaoaa oaeaesoaoem m.mo 00.nmm mee.m 0mm.m e0e.ea 0e.mm mam.0 0m.0H eee.a Hnm.~ naoaeooaoea usaooosno¢ 0.N0 ee.emm meo.n 0ee.0H s0~.ma 00.0H 0mm.0 HN.0H eme.a are.m eeeeaaow oHHH m o.mm mm.wNH mma.m emm.m 0eo.e mo.om mmo.m mo.m smm.0 ome.m nopnooao ooao 0.00 mm.wem ema.e emm.e N00.0H mm.an N:0.0 em.HH ee0.m Nae.o onooaeshe naaoanm N.e0H 00.mme one.e eao.m 00e.nm em.mm ema.0a ee.0 0~0.e Hme.e noonepcoa escapees .pm .em .am Any \Hoox \Hoox *esmeos mmv on a Ase .am Ape a Aev .am any a Aev .aw Any a Amy aha homo oo5ho nos aonfim oospo meow oo5ho ecaopoam oozho mouoomm .Hsma .mHINH Pmsmsg .ooooao opoao .esonH :oaoeoona .aaaemo onsHm o mcH>Ho>sH Hodge wcavoom use mwmhaoso omoaow Ho mpHSoom .e edema 30 no. es. mm em 00 00 amm escapeeeonao . poohaa nonaovmomuhaSb om. on. on em mm we end o>aam nsnaoo Hemfl .o ease moaoaom vases pdso< moHoaom moan: hon hoax hoax mwcaapoo» nPHSb< maopoa mcoflvo>poono open .abmfl possum .osonH Schoooose .CoHpoaamom Haahmo one mo coapwmomaoo omo one Mom .m oanoa 51 percent of adult females were accompanied by young of the year and the number of yearlings was scarcely less than the number of kids (Table 5). Adults were about three times as numerous as yearlings. There was no indication from this of other than generally high survival rates. Some general body characteristics of the agrimi were summarized (Table 6) from measurements of four adult animals captured during the study. The age of agrimia is determined easily by merely counting the annual rings on the horns (Couturier, 1961). Range Condition The degree of utilization of accessable parts of edible species and the vegetation composition were taken as guides to range condition. Utilization of edible species: Although the proper degree of browsing of palatable species on agrimi ranges is not known, it is a general rule in temperate-zone range management that 50 percent of vigorous forage can be removed annually without harm (Stoddart and Smith, 1943). The exhibited degree of use on Theodorou by mid-July was determined to be far in excess of this limit for the preferred species (Table 7). The utilization of preferred species on the study area indicated that these species were in serious danger of total 32 Table 6. Body measurments of four captured animals (centimeters). Theodorou Island, summer, 1971. Age (years) Sex Weight (kg.) Total length Height at front shoulder Ear length Tail length Front hoofs length width Hind hoofs length width Horns length along curve of front ear tip to tip spread mean circumference at base 1.5 14.1 51 9.5 9.2 4.5 3.2 3.8 2.0 20 15 12 4.5 16.0 90 45 10.0 7.2 5.5 3.0 4.0 2.5 19 7.5 5.5 16.8 92 45 10.0 7.4 6.0 3.0 4.0 2.5 20 7.5 5.5 so . 5 110 74 12.0 10.3 7.0 5.1 5.0 2.7 90 10 12.0 33 Table 7. Utilization by agrimi and the availability of highly-preferred forage species. Theodorou Island. Crete, Greece, March to mid-July, 1971. Degree of Original Food Plant Species Utiliéation Availability Teurium pollium 98.0 2.61 Cistus incanus 82.5 0.89 Cupressus sempervirens 81.6 0.71 Rheichardia picroides 64.4 0.58 Olea oleaster 49.8 3.23 Calycotome villosa 48.7 6.82 34 extermination. Furthermore, these species tend to be replaced by less palatable plants. At the end of the growing season their contribution to the total forage supply was only 15.8 percent and many were quite rare indeed. Vegetation composition: The vegetation analysis of the range revealed that the contribution of the preferred forage species (decreasers) to the total floristic composition was extremely low. The avoided and less-palatable (increasers) species made up most of the island's vegetation. The percentages of vegetative cover were found to consist of decreasers 11.57, increasers 38.16 and avoided-increasers 50.27, respectively. The percentages of density for decreasers, increasers and avoided-increasers were calculated to be 19.22, 35.12, and 45.66 and of frequency were 19.29, 33.96, and 46.75, respectively (Table 5). Among further signs of intensive overuse of the island vegetation'were: l) A high proportion (84.2%) of relatively unpalatable species in the agrimi's diet (Table 2). 2) A total-vegetation cover of the island of only about 54.38 percent (Table 8). 3) A lack of soil development, an absence of decaying organic matter on the ground surface, and an exposure to erosion of surface soils (Table 1). These data show clearly that heavy utilization of forage NN.mH mm.ma bm.HH e0.e ome.0 me.m 0H 00.0 m0.0 0m.H .ae nooaaoeam 0m.H mom.0 00.m 0H em.m mm.e 00.H ewoaawe oaopoohaeo em.H HOH.0 me.m m H¢.N me.H H0.N poveeoao eoao no.0 Nmm.0 00.0 mm on.0 mm.0 00.N eoowoeoaa ewoae£OHonm mm.0 0N0.0 em.0 N 00.0 «0.0 0N.m eeoafl>aomaoe eseeohaso em.a HOH.0 mo.H o 00.0 Nm.0 em.m eseeoea envewo 0:.H boa.0 m0.H 0 00.0 Hm.0 mm.m ESHHHom sewesoa “mnoeeoaoom eaopoa a oswa eoaoone useam pcoeoam oaoz. a oma hoes: wean eoaooae eofioone eoHooae *mewpea a hoe epneaq X soar: ea epoan hon ao>oo peeam eon oocopowohn Ho nonasz no ponssz sowpevomo> ooaoboo eone eoom hpaecon hosesooae omeno>oo anoneo .oseHeH eoeoooose so epoaa we so hpfiesoe one hoeosooem .ho>oo pseda one eooeoaomopm pooh .Hema .aase .ooooau .m oHQeB .N oHnea aohm* .mwn.em eoae po>oo soapepowo> 36 00.00H 00.00H 00.00H fleece 00.me me.0¢ em.0m 00.ns m~.HH 0ea.w Hm.0 mm em.H a0.H 00.0 esoeaoeo senesoxoees< me.m mem.0 0H.m 0H me.0 mm.0 00.0 .an aseaoeaae 00.m. sa0.0 0e.m ea no.0 0m.0 00.0 eaaoaofi omopoam -0m.e 0ee.0 He.m Hm mH.0 0H.0 00.0 oeeaoaoam eaaaeoem me.e Nee.0 mn.0H em NN.0H mm.ea 00.0 sanoeaan seahoeoe em.a HeH.0 Ne.m 0H ee.m ee.a 00.0 ssoaaoea asaseaoaaom 0e.0 0e0.0 e0.e 0N 0N.ea ee.ma 00.0 epeeeeeo ethane 0H.N 0mm.0 me.m 0 Ne.e me.0 00.0 neaaoaoa oepeoeasm u mhmmweoglflmdfioawd. NH.mn 00.nm 0H.en e0.e mee.0 m0.e ea mm.e 0m.m 0e.0 oeooaeshe eaaoflnm e0.m 0me.0 0H.m 0H me.H 0N.H me.0 nsaaeooaoea naaoeoeane e0.e ome.0 0e.e 0N 00.e~ H0.ea He.0 naonaeaoa ooooeeae Ne.e HH0.0 00.0 mm 00.0 0N.N . en.0 eeaeeeoa eaaaom ~0.ea mmm.a m0.0a em ee.a m~.H e0.0 ncoooonsa soeoaoa0s< "eaoeeoaosH A.p.coov e wanes .Hbma >H50 .oneHeH nonoooona no epoan 00 na endow enoeeonooo one enoeeononfi .enoeeononH 0o0Ho>e Ho upwenoe one honosoonw .no>oo .0 onSMAm 04 0d sasseeaoeq 37 sasseeaoaq sassaeaoeq on SJQSBQJOUI saeseaaoul saeseeaoul 0m smesaadoul papIOAv saeseedoul papIOA 9.1899319 papIOA hpnnnoo nonoeoonm no>oo 38 by the high population of agrimia must be limited in order to enable restoration of the range to its normal productive ability. The low availability of desirable species on the range because of their continuous overuse indicates that their gradual replacement by plant species of low palatability is occurring. (This will be further confirmed by observations on the tiny ungrazed islet Theodompoula, which will be reported in a later publication.) It is obvious that the plant-animal interaction on the island is a result of the high agrimi population density. The current density of two animals per hectare obviously is highly detrimental to both plants and animals. A balanced use of the range resources, in terms of ‘proper numbers of grazing animals using the range is urgently needed if the range-animal complex is to be saved. As Taylor (1930) points out, the problem of grazing management is one of proper handling of the total biotic community. The restoration of a suitable plant cover on the island at this late stage of depletion may be difficult now. The actual length of time required to restore the island in its various stages of depletion will depend in part upon the degree of depletion of the most important plants and upon soil moisture-penetration conditions. All of these factors require further study in order to more completely understand the situation. But enough information is now available to 39 show the serious situation.which now faces the program of species preservation for the agrimi and its vegetative habitat. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR MANAGEMENT Theodorou Island is severely overgrazed as a result of an agrimi density of two animals per hectare. If the agrimi is to be preserved as a wild species in a secure habitat a reduced herd size is essential. Unless that policy is adopted, severe range deterioration will continue on Theodorou Island and all hope for the last pure strain of agrimi will be lost in its most favorable habitat. One of the biggest obstacles to establish proper manage- ment practices on Theodorou Island is the lack of information on the island's carrying capacity and on the agrimi's sur- vival and productivity characteristics. This information is essential in order to determine the herd size which can be supported in harmony with the range on a sustained basis. The carrying capacity of the island must be estimated and a reduction in agrimi numbers must be made in order to reduce the grazing pressure on the habitat. Because of the badly depleted condition of the range the agrimi population should be lowered somewhat beneath the actual carrying capacity of the vegetation in order to allow for recovery of the range. A program of trapping and transporting surplus animals to new favorable reserves should be undertaken especially on uninhabited islands if prior ecological studies indicate that 40 41 range conditions on such islands are suitable. Removals from Theodorou should be undertaken at least annually until the determined carrying capacity of the island has been reached. The White Mountains National Park, the original native range of the agrimi, would be a preferred site for restora- tion of this valuable species except for the danger of hybrid- ization with domestic goats. This could destroy the agrimi as a wild species there. Only if the park could be completely and adequately fenced, should this area be considered as a possible refuge for the species. Though desirable from other standpoints as a natural area, almost certain hybridization there, however, makes the White MOuntain National Park deserving of consideration only as a secondary site. Measures which should be undertaken for habitat improve- ment on Theodorou Island are: 1) The investigation of aritficial control of undesir- able plants by chemical and non-chemical means since the established and vigorous woody plants there, such as Thybra capitata, Euphorbia paralia, and Poterium spinosum, cannot be eliminated by release from grazing alone within a practical time period. 2) The testing of a program of seeding desirable plant species such as 912g oleaster, Calyotome villosa, Cistus incanus, Teurium pollium, and Cupressus sempervirens on 42 favorable sites in order to increase the island's potential for forage production. 3) The control of rats and hares and possibly other seed eaters should be appraised. 4) The provision of an automatic supply mechanism at the cistern to insure that water is available at all times. 5) Annual censuses and range surveys as a basis for a continuing management. 6) The establishment of several exclosures of suitable size so as to enable continuing assessments of the effects of agrimi, and possibly rat and hare, numbers on the vegetation. 7) A continuing research program to study the effects of management recommendations and to enable their modification if necessary. SUMMARY In an effort to ascertain the ecological factors basic to the preservation of the agrimi or Cretan wild goat.(§§pr§ aegagrus cretensis Schinz), an investigation was undertaken to determine its population densities, food preferences, habitat relations, and prospects for species survival. The study was conducted in the summer of 1971 mainly on Theodorou Island, a costal islet of 68 hectares just off Crete, Greece. It is likely that this site is the only one where a wild agrimi population still exists as a pure stock. Yet an overpopulated condition there is causing severe over- grazing and habitat deterioration. The agrimi population on the island was found to total 137 animals, exactly two per hectare. The herd consisted of 58 percent adults, 20 percent yearlings and 22 percent kids. The adults were nearly equally divided by sex. From analyses of browsed vegetation on the islet, the preferred food species of the agrimi for the March to mid- July season were calculated to be Teurium pollium, Cistus incanus, Cupressus sempervirens, Rheichardia picroides, 912g oleaster, Calycotome villosa, and Siderides sp. To determine summer food preferences, one agrimi held in captivity from mid-July to mid-August was offered samples 43 44 of island vegetation. 912g oleaster, Rheichardia picroides, Asphodelus microcarpus, Cistus incanus, and Scilla maritima were calculated to be the plant species which were consumed to a greater extent than would be indicated by their abundance. The species Euphorbia paralias, Thybra capitata,lggli7 chrysum italicum, and Anthoxanthum odoratum were widely distributed over the island but were not utilized during either study period. Although not a preferred food species, the most important forage plant for the agrimi on this range from the standpoint of bulk was Pistacea lentiscus. The twigs and foliage of this shrub comprised 43.66 and 30.0 percent, respectively, of the animal's diet during the spring and summer, respectively. Two other shrubs, Calycotome villosa and Teurium.pollium contributed 13.38 and 10.31 percent, respectively, to the spring diet of the agrimi. The agrimi's food from spring to mid-July was composed of 79.0 percent shrubs, 17.8 percent forbs and 3.2 percent grasses. The availability of these plant groups indicated no marked preference for plants of a particular growth form and was calculated to be 68.1, 28.5 and 3.4 percent, respec- tively. In late summer, however, the agrimi's diet changed to 39.9 percent shrubs and 60.1 percent forbs, in contrast to their 58.4 and 37.9 percent availability. Grasses were not consumed in spite of their 3.7 percent availability. The agrimi thus changed from being mainly a browser during the spring to performing as a grazer of forbs during the summer. The daily food consumption of a yearling held captive in summer was determined to be 347 grams forage dry weight or approximately 2.5 percent of the animal's weight. The present agrimi population was found to be causing serious range deterioration. The four most highly preferred forage species were 68 to 98 percent utilized during the March-July season and were being replaced by plants of less food value, or by those which were totally avoided by the agrimi. Preferred food plants have been reduced to only 11.6 percent of the island's total production of edible forage and 4.8 percent of the total vegetative cover of the island. The prospects for survival of the agrimi on Theodorou Island are good in view of the present attitude of the Greek Forest Service to accept these findings and to adopt measures for limiting agrimi population densities. LITERATURE CITED Buruldsen, E. T. and A. Morgan, 1934. Notes on botanical analysis of irrigated pasture. Imp. Bur. Plant Genetics, Herbage Pub. Ser. Bul., 14:33-43. Butler, A., 1951. A Wild Goat of Crete. The Field. London, 1971, 127 pp. Casebeer Robert C., 1948. A study of the food habits of the mountain goat (Oreamnos americanus missoulae) in Western.Montana. MbnE. SE. UfiIv., M. S. In Forestry Thesis, Unpub., 99pp. Chatzisarantos, C., 1950. Disoription of Cretan agrimia one of the World's rarest creatures. Press Release E. C. A. Mission to Greece No. 700. Chatzisarantos C. and A0.Kanellis, 1955. Capra aegagrgs cretensis: Vouno, 187:143-164. Athens. Couturier, M. A. T., 1961. Determination de 1'age du bouquetin des Alpes (Ca ra ibex) a 1' aide des dents et des cornes. IIa (Paris), 25:453-461. Dolan James M. 1965. {Ca ra aegagrus cretica. éoonooz: 38, (7) 10-111“. """'""'" Danford, C. C., 1875. Notes on the wild goat Ca ra aegagggs Gm. Proc. 2001. Soc. London, 45 - pp. Farmer, Hugh, 1952. The protection of the agrimi. Oryx, 1:327-337. Gain, A. S. and G. M. Castro, 1959. Manual of vegetation analysis. Harper and Brothers, Pub. New York, 325 pp. Petrides A. George, (in prep.). The calculation and significance of food preference versus dietary importance ratings. Typed manuscript, Michigan State University. Schultze-Westrum, Thomas, 1963. Die Wildziegen der agaischen Islen. Saug. Mitt., 4:145-182. 46 47 Schultze-Westrum, Thomas, Undeted. The New National Park in the White Mountains of Crete, Greece. A Report of its Conservation Status (mimeo). Stoddart, L. A. and A. D. Smith, 1943. Range Management. New York, 548 pp. , 1955. Range Management. New York, 433 pp. Taylor, W. R., 1930. Methods of determining rodent pressure on the range. Ecology, 11:523-542. Zervas, P., 1961. Wildlife in Greece. Department of Agriculture. Athens, 333 pp. APPENDIX Definitions Since a number of different terms are widely employed to express similar concepts, those used in this report are defined briefly: Availabiiiiy: the amount of plant parts available for use expressed here in dryaweight grams. Utilization: the degree to which animals have removed forage from that available. Overgrazing: excessive cropping of range plants by animals with consequent damage to the soil and with effects on both flora and fauna. Carrying Capacity: that population or biomass of animals which can be supported by a given habitat without damage to it and on a sustained basis. Forage: all vegetation, harvested and unharvested, that is available and possibly acceptable to animals (except mast seeds and fruits of woody plants). Browse: the leaf and current twig growth of shrubs, vines, and trees available for animal consumption. {232: any herb or flowering plant, other than grasses, which lacks persistent above-ground woody stems. 48 49 Shggb: any plant with persistent woody stems and relatively low (under about 5 meters) form which generally produces several basal shoots instead of a single bole or stem. Rgggg: land producing native forage available for herbivorous domestic or wild animals. 92323: the degree to which plants, by overhanging, protect the ground surface from rainfall. Density: pOpulation number per unit area. Frequency: the regularity with which a species is distributed throughout a community. HICHIGQN STRTE UNIV. LIBRQRIES 31293103189357