THE ROLE OF THE ENTOURAGE ON ELITE ATHLETES’  RETIREMENT  TRANSITION By Tshepang Tshube A DISSERTATION Submitted to Michigan State University In partial fulfillment of the requirements For the degree of Doctor of Philosophy-Kinesiology 2014 ABSTRACT THE  ROLE  OF  THE  ENTOURAGE  ON  ELITE  ATHLETES’  RETIREMENT   TRANSITION By Tshepang Tshube The  primary  objective  of  this  dissertation  was  to  investigate  elite  athletes’   retirement transition experiences, including its psychological impacts, and postsport career adaptation of elite athletes in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, and Zimbabwe. The secondary objective was to investigate the role of the entourage on  elite  athletes’  retirement  transition. A total of 17 retired athletes (12 males and 5 females) from various sports (athletics-6, swimming-2, Boxing-2, rowing-2, field hockey-2, gymnastics-1, triathlon-1, biking-1) in Southern Africa and their entourages (n = 35) participated in the current study. All athletes had competed at the Olympics except one athlete who had competed at world championships and the commonwealth games. The study observed three major themes (type of retirement, dual-career, and challenges) consistent with the primary objectives as crucial  in  elite  athletes’  retirement  transition  and  post-sport career and an additional major theme (social and financial support) consistent with the secondary objectives. The first major theme of type of retirement was derived from interviews with athletes and entourages to explain reasons for retirement and post sport career adaptation. Sub-themes observed under type of retirement were voluntary and involuntary. The second major theme observed in the study was dual-career. This  finding  reflected  the  athletes’  balance  between  school  and  sport   as primary in preparing for a post-sport career transition and adaptation. Sub- themes observed under the major theme dual-career were graduating from university, full-time  job  during  one’s  career  in  sport  and part-time job during one’s  career  in  sport. The last major theme observed in the primary objective was challenges. It was clear from the respondents that athletes faced challenges including lack of financial resources to maintaining an elite sport career and support during retirement transition. Sub-themes observed under the major theme of challenges were financial resources, lack of trained coaches, lack of facilities, and lack trained medical personnel. The major theme consistent with secondary objectives was observed across the three phases of data collection indicating athletes receiving social and financial support from a variety of entourage members in their elite careers in sport as well as during retirement transition. Keywords: Retirement, Career transition, Entourage, Elite Athlete, Olympians, Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, and Zimbabwe I dedicate  this  dissertation  to  my  daughter  Angela  “Unami”  Tshube.  It  is  her   unconditional love that gave me the courage and perseverance to continue on this long and winding road towards personal and professional improvement. iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to express my gratitude and appreciation to all those who gave me the possibility to complete this report. The International Olympic Committee Postgraduate Research Grant Programme deserves special thanks for funding this project. My completion of this project could not have been accomplished without the support of my advisor Dr. Deborah L. Feltz– thank you for great mentorship. I would like to thank my dissertation committee members, Drs. Daniel Gould, Reitumetse Mabokela, and Kristen Renn for their guidance on this dissertation project. Finally, to my caring, and supportive friend, Christel Lea Virginia Beverly. I would also like to thank all participants that took part in the study. v TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES.………………………………………...……………..………….....viii LIST OF FIGURES.……………………........……..…………………….……..………..ix KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS..………………………………………………………........x Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION.………..……...……………….…………….……………..1 1.1 Nature of the Problem……………………………………….…………………….1 1.2 Statement of the Problem…..……….………………………………..……………6 1.3 Objectives of the Study…………………………….……………………………...8 1.4 Significance of the Study.…………………………………………………………9 1.5 Definitions……………………...………………………………………………...10 1.5.1 Athletic Career…………………….…………………………………………………..10 1.5.2 Athletes’ Entourage …………...……………………………………………………10 1.5.3 Transition……………………………………………………………………………….10 Chapter 2: REVIEW OF LITERATURE….…………….………………………………11 2.1 Countries Background………..……………………………………………...…..12 2.2 Literature Review  on  Southern  Africa……………………….……….………….15 2.3 Gerontology and Thanatology Models of  Retirement  Transition……..…..……..18 2.4 Social Gerontology Models  of  Retirement  Transition……………...…...…….....19 2.4.1 Activity Theory……….....……………………………………….......19 2.4.2 Continuity Theory………...………………………………………….20 2.4.3 Subculture Theory………………...………………………………….20 2.4.4 Disengagement Theory……...……………………………………….21 2.4.5 Social Breakdown Theory…………...……………………………….21 2.4.6 Exchange  Theory……………….…...…………………………….....22 2.5 Thanatological Models of  Retirement  Transition…….……...…………………..23 2.5.1 Social Death……………………………………………….……...….24 2.5.2 Stages of Death……………………………………………………....24 2.6 Summary of Gerontology and Thanatology Models...……………..………..…..25 2.7 Athletic Career Transition Models………………………………..……………...26 2.7.1 Athletic Career Transition Model………...………………………….29 2.7.2 Lifespan Model of Athlete Development…...……………………….32 2.7.3 Conceptual Model of Adaptation to Career  Transition…...………….36 2.8 Factors Affecting Retirement Transition..…………..…………………………...39 2.8.1 Athletic  Identity………..….…………………………………………41 2.8.2 Coping  Processes…………………………………………..………...42 2.8.3 Social  Support……………………..………………………………....43 2.9 Summary: Factors Affecting Retirement Transition …………...……...………..44 Chapter 3: METHODOLOGY………………...………….………………….…….…….45 3.1 Research Design...………………………………..…………………...….45 vi 3.2 Participants……………………………………..………………….……..46 3.3 Procedure………..…………..……………………………………..…….46 3.3.1 Phase  I……..………………...……………….………………...47 3.3.2 Phase  II……..…….………………………………….……..…..47 3.3.3 Phase  III…….….…….…….…………………………..………47 3.4 Instruments...…………………………………………………………....48 3.5 Pilot  Study…………………………………………………………...….49 3.6 Data Analysis.……………..……………………………………....……49 3.7 Trustworthiness  of  the  Data……………………...…………………..…51 Chapter 4: RESULTS and  SPECIFIC  DISCUSSIONS…..……………..……………….52 4.1 Research Participants Brief Profiles (Athletes)…..……...................…….……….…52 4.2 Results by Primary Objectives…..………………………………........................…...61 4.2.1 Major Theme #1: Type of Retirement from Sport……………………...62 4.2.2 Summary: Type of Retirement from Sport…...…………………..……..70 4.2.3 Major Theme #2: Elite Athletes’  Challenges………………....………...71 4.2.4 Major Theme # 3 Balancing Sport and Other Careers.........................…73 4.2.5 Summary: Balancing Sport and Other Careers …………….…………..79 4.3 Results by Secondary  Objectives…..…………….…………...……………………...79 4.3.1 Major Theme #4: Social and Financial Support……………………..….81 4.3.2 Summary: Social and Financial Support ……………...…….……….…89 4.4 Comparisons  Across  Countries……………………….……………………………...89 4.5 Minor Themes by Primary and Secondary Objectives……………...………….……90 4.5.1 Athletes Patriotism……………………………………………………...91 4.5.2 Lack of Retirement Transition Programs and Federation  Politics……...91 4.5.3 Bias and Racism………………………………………………………...92 Chapter  5:  GENERAL  DISCUSSION..………………………………………………….94 5.1 Dual Career: Balancing Sport with Another Career Outside Sport……......…….99 5.2 Elite Athletes Challenges in Elite Sport and Post-Sport  Career……………......102 5.3 Entourage Support and  Type  of  Retirement………….………………………...104 5.4 Summary: Entourage Support and Type of Retirement..……………………….107 5.5 Comparisons between Southern African Countries…..………………...….…...108 5.6 Southern African Context……………………......…........…..…………….…...110 5.7 Limitations………………………………………………………...…………....111 5.8 Potential Future Research Directions…………………………………………...111 5.9 Suggested  Solutions  for  Elite  Athletes’  Career  Assistance  in  Southern  African   Countries ……………………………………………………………………….112 APPENDICES………………………...……………………………………………..…116 Appendix A: Demographic Questionnaire……………………………………...117 Appendix  B:  Athlete  Interview  Guide…..……………...…………………........121 Appendix C: Entourage Interview  Guide……...……………………………….123 REFERENCES..………………………………………………………………..………124 vii LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Demographic Data and Themes……..…………………...………......................60 Table 2: Athletes’  Retirement  Planning  by  Country..….……………..…………….........66 Table 3: Athletes’ highest Academic Qualification…...…….…..………….....................76 Table 4: Athletes and Entourage members Interviewed…….……..........….....................80 Table 5: Athletes Entourage Profiles………………….…...……………….....................81 Table 6:  Summary  of  Athletes’  Stages  and  Raw  Data…………………...…....................82 Table 7: Athletes’  Marital  statuses  by  Country………..………………………………...86 viii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Athletic Career Transition Model.…………………………………..................31 Figure 2: Lifespan Model of Athlete Development.…..……………………………........36 Figure 3: Conceptual Model of Adaptation to Career Transition…………......................38 Figure 4: Paths to Post-Sport  Career  Adaptation...…………………………....................98 Figure 5: Cross-National Comparisons....………..……………………………………..109 ix KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS Botswana National Olympic Committee-BNOC Botswana National Sports Council -BNSC Fédération Internationale de Football Association-FIFA International Olympic Committee (IOC) Namibia Sports Commission-NSC National Olympic committee -OC South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee-SASCOC Zimbabwe Olympic Committee-ZOC x Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION 1.1 Nature of the Problem Sports federations across the world work hard everyday to develop sport programs that enable elite athletes to have the ability to compete in the top echelon of international sporting communities across a wide variety of sports. National sports federations and club teams, particularly in professional and international sports invest considerable resources in an effort to identify exceptionally gifted youngsters at an early age in order to accelerate their developmental process into elite sport (Holt & Mitchell, 2006; Walker, 1990). Coaches spend a significant amount of time creating training plans that will accord talented athletes the opportunity to excel at international and professional sports. Individual athletes together with their coaches must discipline themselves to train and practice for many years over their athletic careers (Aquilina, 2013). Usually they need to dedicate most of their days in pursuit of their athletic dreams. Some of these dreams are to compete at the Olympic games and/or compete in professional sports. There is no doubt that governments, sport federations, sport clubs, and sponsors have put pressure on athletes to excel at the international level more than ever in the history of sports. For example, sociology of sports literature demonstrates that sport continues to be used as an instrument, to fulfill foreign policy goals. Governments sport funding and participation at the Olympic games has significantly increased in the past twenty years. Even though a significant amount of resources has been spent on athlete development, it was only in the late 1980s that even industrialized countries started developing programs to help athletes’ transition out of competitive sport. There is no evidence in the literature of such programs in developing African countries. 1 Research in higher education (Aries, McCarthy, Salovey, & Banaji, 2004; Henry, 2013) and sports psychology (Kim & Moen, 2002; Lotysz & Short, 2004; Wylleman & Lavallee, 2004) demonstrate that elite athletes compete at the highest levels of athletic performance as a result of a long-term psychological and physical commitment to training and competition. Further to psychological and physical commitment, elite athletes dedicate a significant amount of time to sport, sometimes, at the expense of education and other avenues of life (Meyer, 1990; Parham, 1993). Wylleman and Lavallee (2004) affirm that elite athletes do not only strive to reach the top but also to remain at the top elite level in competitive sport. The commitments to reach and stay at the top require elite athletes and those around them to invest at different levels (e.g., physical, social, financial) during a long period of time. The aim of this dissertation was to look at Olympians’ retirement transition experiences and the role played by entourage members in elite athletes retirement transition. The researcher purposively selected Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, and Zimbabwe to participate in the study for two primary reasons. The first reason is that, athletes from the selected countries are among the least studied in the sport psychology literature. Most theoretical models and constructs that have been development on retirement transition were carried out mostly in industrialized nations in Europe, North America, and Asia which raises questions of generalizability of these existing models and constructs. This calls for a need to test the applicability of these theoretical models and constructs in other populations such as Southern Africa. An online search using the 2 keyword;;  “Botswana  sport”,  “South  Africa  sport”,  “Zimbabwe  sport”,  and  “Namibia   sport”  on  ProQuest  databases  produced  a  total  result  of  18,967 studies. These results were of varying types of literature relating to sport in Botswana, South Africa, Namibia and Zimbabwe. At least 2,519 of the studies were from scholarly journal articles. Most of the scholarly journal articles were published in the African Journal for Physical, Health Education, Recreation and Dance and other international journals such as International Journal of the History of Sport and International Review for the Sociology of Sport. It is worth noting that additional literature can be found in respective national libraries, archives, and other online databases. However, ProQuest is one of the most popular online database providers in the world. The last reason for carrying out this dissertation in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, and Zimbabwe is informed by concerns made by retired athletes in the media regarding post-sport career adaptation. For example, even though the South African boxing legend, Baby Jake Matlala, was a four times world champion in the flyweight category, he was considered financially down and out at the time of his death (“Boxing   legend Baby Jake Matlala dies at 51 - Times  LIVE,”  2013). His friends and church colleagues had to raise funds to cover his medical expenses. In a similar scenario, an athletics legend from Botswana was quoted in The Midweek Sun, (2012) newspaper expressing concern over neglect of retired athletes. It is an inevitable reality that all athletes will face retirement from elite sport at some point in their sport career. What is of primary importance is the athlete’s  post-sport career adaptation. In addition to the above two reasons, the rational for the selected counties is to test the applicability of western models and constructs in less studied populations. In addition to testing models and 3 constructs, differences in sport budgets, sport structures and national populations accorded the researcher the opportunity to make cross-national comparisons. Wylleman and Lavallee (2004) depict that termination of a high-level athletic career is an emotional experience, not only for the athletes themselves, but also for those in their close environment (e.g., parents, children, friends). Research findings (Blinde & Greendorfer, 1985; Du & Tsai, 2007; Lavallee, Grove, & Gordon, 1997) are consistent that retired athletes may experience a sense of loss and regret. For example, Blende and Greendorfer (1985) observed that in addition to retired athletes missing their favorite sport; these individuals felt that they lost the glory of being a famous athlete having to make a transition to being just another person. Most elite athletes retire at a young age as compared to the general population, which requires athletes to not only redefine their social identity but in some cases to also realign their career goals. Sport psychology literature (Aquilina, 2013; David Lavallee et al., 1997; Maseko & Surujlal, 2011; Park, Tod, & Lavallee, 2012) demonstrated the need for elite athletes to have a 'dual career' and or long term goals to prepare for a post-athletic career while still participating in elite sport. In the United States, approximately 1% of collegiate athletes become professionals, and the average professional sport career lasts around three and a half years (Beamon, 2010). The athlete is  “forced”  upon  retirement  to  find an alternative career to support her/his family. It is therefore important for federations and other stakeholders in these countries to understand factors (sport related and non-sport related) that impact elite athletes’ retirement transition and post-sport career preparation. 4 One of the primary challenges faced by most elite athletes and their entourage (e.g., parents, coaches, teammates, and federations) is the ability to manage the elite athlete’s  intense  exclusive  focus  in  sports  and  still  build  resilience  and  capacity  to  meet   the many transitions and demands required in both elite performance and life (Anderson, 2009). Imbalance in time and interest allocation may disrupt the normative developmental stages of life and or events such as identity development, educational career, long-term career planning and other socially related developments like spending time with family. Elite junior (athletes under the age of 20) and senior (athletes over the age of 20) athletes tend to form a foreclosed identity (Brewer, Van Raalte, & Linder, 1993; Pearson & Petitpas, 1990) due to a high investment and exclusive focus in sport. As suggested by Peterson (1994), young athletes obtain a foreclosed identity when they exclusively identify with the role of an athlete at the expense of other roles, which may be crucial in their retirement transition ( i.e., role of being a student). Young athletes competing at elite level are more susceptible to an exclusive focus on sport, hence exclusive athletic identity with most of their self-definition and self-worth based on athletic career success (Beamon, 2010; Brewer, Van Raalte, & Linder, 1993). As presented earlier in this chapter, exclusive athletic identity does not only negatively affect elite athletes’  self-definition and self-worth but also their transition out of athletics as they struggle to redefine their identities (Beamon, 2010). Blinde and Greendorfer (1985) observed that even though 75% of retired college athletes did not experience any trauma and continued following their teams, 25% of the athletes did, some who exclusively identified as athletes experienced crisis and trauma. Authors further explained that coaches and sports administrators are more likely to put pressure on athletes and coaches 5 to win/and or focus on sport at the expense of being a student because the public clamors for a winner and success. It is evident that not all athletes who compete at professional levels are able to successfully make a living out of professional sport. Nevertheless, most athletes are able to make a living from their sport only as long as they are engaged in it, while others will never reach an athletic standard that would ensure them a livelihood (Samuel & Tenenbaum, 2011). The primary objective of this dissertation looks at elite athletes retirement transition and the role of the entourage in athlete’s retirement transition. This dissertation also assessed theoretical models and constructs on post-sport career transition. Participants include less studied members of the entourage such as federations and spouses. These samples give a different and unique perspective to theoretical models of career transition. For example, results from this dissertation indicate that they spouses play an instrumental role in providing social and financial support during retirement transition, which is new to sport psychology literature. 1.2 Statement of the Problem Even though retirement transition occurs across all ages, careers in competitive sport are usually shorter than other occupational careers (Park et al., 2012). For example, North and Lavallee (2004) found that elite athletes from gymnastics, diving, swimming, ice skating, and judo planned to retire in the 24–30 year age category, while those from sailing, golf, equestrian, and shooting planned their retirement well after age 40. The  concept  of  athletes’  retirement  transition has experienced a significant growth in the literature the past decade. Most research looks at the nature and causes of retirement (Cosh, Crabb, & LeCouteur, 2013; Du & Tsai, 2007; Lavallee, 2005; Stambulova, Stephan, & Jäphag, 2007; Stephan, Bilard, Ninot, & Delignières, 2003), and 6 there is also a significant growth in recent years on literature that looks at intervention programs for retired athletes (Baillie, 1993; Constantine, 1995; Lavallee, 2005; Smith & McManus, 2008). The nature of retirement from elite sport is often not only accompanied by an initial sense of loss (Stambulova, 2000), and a period of re-orientation growth, but a re-adaptation into the community (Alfermann, Stambulova, & Zemaityte, 2004; Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994; Wippert & Wippert, 2010). Given the challenges that retiring elite athletes face, it is crucial for them to have the ability to cope effectively with retirement transitional challenges in order to progress and make a successful transition to the next stage in their development (Wylleman & Reints, 2010). Athletes who are unable to cope effectively are confronted with a crisis transition, which may slow down or restrict their progress (Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994; Wylleman & Reints, 2010). This dissertation provides a unique, holistic and multifaceted approach to elite athletes’  retirement  transition. As presented earlier in this chapter, about 18,967 studies have been found on the ProQuest database on Botswana, Namibia, South Africa, and Zimbabwe. Search  keywords  used  in  the  online  search  are;;  “Botswana  sport”,  “South   Africa  sport”,  “Zimbabwe  sport”,  and  “Namibia  sport”.  Literature gap filled by this dissertation include assessing theoretical models and constructs that have been development in the industrialized nations in Europe, North America, and Asia. Participants included unique and less studied members of the entourage that include federations and spouses. In addition to a unique set of participants, the study had a large pool of entourage members from four different nations. Even though research on elite athletes’  retirement  transition  is  being  conducted  around  the  world,  the  majority  of   7 research targets specific national samples, cross-cultural studies are limited (Alfermann & Stambulova, 2007; Huang, Schmidt, Hackfort, & Si, 2001). This dissertation tested theoretical models and constructs that have been developed in industrialized nations and specifically looked at less studied populations in the sport psychology literature. The dissertation made cross-national comparison, specifically looking at the impact of budgets, population size, and sport organizational structure. For example, even though the four countries have ministries of sports, the South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (SASCOC) was formed in 1994 to assume the functions of high performance sport which were previously carried out by other sport bodies such as National Olympic Committee of South Africa, South African Commonwealth Games Association, and South African Student Sports Union. In other three countries, National Olympic committees (NOCs) are specifically designed for elite high performance sport while National Sport Commissions/Councils (NSCs) are charged with the responsibility to develop grassroots sport and promote nation wide sport participation. 1.3 Objectives of the Study The primary objective of this dissertation was to investigate elite athletes’ retirement transition experiences, including its psychological impacts, and post-sport career adaptation of elite athletes in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa and Zimbabwe. A subobjective was to examine the coping strategies used by retired elite athletes during retirement transition. The secondary objective was to investigate the role of the entourage on elite athletes’  retirement  transition. A sub-objective was to examine the availability of 8 retirement transition services for elite athletes in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa and Zimbabwe. Lastly, the dissertation made cross-national comparisons, looking specifically at budgets, population size, and sport organizational structure impacts on sport development. 1.4 Significance of Study In the past decade, a few studies have advocated for a holistic approach to the study of athlete development and retirement transition (Henriksen, Stambulova, & Roessler, 2010; Wylleman & Lavallee, 2004). A holistic approach to the study of elite athletes’  retirement  transition,  taken  by  this dissertation accords the researcher the opportunity to study elite athletes and their entourage members as opposed to studying only one sample. The significance of studying different entourage members provides a multi-faceted approach that looks at the concurrent, reciprocal, and interactive nature of athletic retirement transition. . In addition to studying a large sample, this dissertation examined events that occurred in and outside sport to understand elite athletes retirement transition. For example, the study observed that even though some athletes may not be satisfied with their post-sport career jobs, having a job facilitated retirement transition. The current study adds to the literature, a reciprocal interaction between elite athletes and their entourage members. Results from this dissertation demonstrate not only that athletes should prepare for a post-sport career, but also provides specific recommendations on what athletes from southern African countries should do in preparation for a post-sport career. The dissertation further provides the type of career support that elite athletes need from their entourage members during retirement transition. Specific examples, including lifestyle management services, lifestyle skills, and transitional skills that are used by 9 athletes. Lifestyle management enables elite athletes to balance elite sport, education, vocation, and personal/family life in such a way that they are able to develop, sustain and maximize their wellbeing and level of performance throughout as well as after their elite career (Wylleman & Reints, 2010). 1.5 Definitions 1.5.1 Athletic Career: A term for a multiyear sport activity, voluntary chosen by the person and aimed at achieving his or her individual peak in athletic performance in one or several events. 1.5.2 Athletes’   Entourage: The entourage comprises all people associated with athletes including; Family; Agents; Coaches; Sport Federations; and any person identified as promoting  the  athlete’s  sporting  career. 1.5.3 Transition: An event or non-event, which results in a change in assumptions about oneself and the world, and thus requires a corresponding change in one’s  behavior  and  relationships  (Schlossberg,  1981). 10 Chapter 2: REVIEW OF LITERATURE The primary objective of this dissertation was to investigate elite athletes’ retirement transition experiences including its psychological impacts of elite athletes retirement transition. The secondary objective was to investigate an in-depth account of the  role  of  the  entourage  on  elite  athletes’  retirement  transition.  Lastly, the dissertation makes cross-national comparisons, looking specifically at budgets, population size and sport organizational structure impacts on sport development. This chapter starts by presenting countries’ background information to contextualize theoretical constructs and reviewed literature. Gerontology and thanatology models that have been applied to sport to explain  elite  athletes’  retirement  transition  will  follow  the  background  information. Lastly, the chapter presents literature review on retirement transition and models that further explain elite athletes’ retirement transition and factors that affect retirement transition. It should be noted that theoretical constructs and models used in this dissertation might not be applicable to Southern Africa context. Models and constructs on elite athletes retirement transition have been carried out in industrialized nations. These models and constructs are made to fit industrialized nations cultures (i.e., sport organizational structure, customs and size of the economy). Historians and economists have demonstrated the relationship between sport, economy and society (Tranter, 1998). For example, sports in the United States is highly commercialized and primarily funded by private companies while sport in developing countries is heavily dependent on government funding and nongovernmental organizations such as the International Olympic Committee and Fédération Internationale de Football Association. These differences in sports systems may have implications for the services available for retired 11 athletes. Sport psychology literature (Côté, 1999; Gould, Lauer, Rolo, Jannes, & Pennisi, 2006; Wylleman & Lavallee, 2004) demonstrates a significant youth sport parental involvement in industrialized nations, yet in developing counties particularly in Southern Africa, athletes are more likely to perceive a lower parental involvement (Malete, 2006). It should be noted that differences in parental involvement might also vary by socioeconomic statues. For example, inner city youth in the United States may perceive parental involvement differently compared with youth who live in suburbs. 2.1 Countries Background Botswana-The Republic of Botswana (581,730 sq km,) is a landlocked country in Southern Africa, bordered by South Africa to the south and southeast, Namibia to the west and north, Zimbabwe to the northeast and Zambia to the north. Formerly the British protectorate of Bechuanaland, Botswana adopted its new name upon independence in 1966 from Britain. Botswana is hailed as one of most peaceful countries in Africa with a record of more than four decades of uninterrupted civilian leadership, progressive social policies, and significant capital investment that have created one of the most stable economies in Africa. Even though Botswana tourism industry experienced a significant growth  in  the  past  two  decades,  Botswana’s  economy  is  dominated  by  mineral  extraction,   principally diamond mining. Botswana has a population of 2.004 million est. 2012 with a GDP of $14.50 billion ($ 7,191.44 per capita) and GDP growth rate of 4.2%. Botswana has one of the world's highest known rates of HIV/AIDS infection, but also one of Africa's most progressive and comprehensive programs for dealing with the disease. The most popular sport in Botswana is football (soccer), and other mainl y played sports include netball, volleyball, athletics (track and field) and 12 Boxing. It should be noted that even though Botswana started participant in the Ol ympic games in 1980, the country won its first Ol ympic medal in 800m at the London 2012 Ol ympic games. Botswana National Sports Council (BNSC) was established in 1965 as an independent organization entrusted with the mission of raising funds to construct sport facilities and source equipment for athletes . Botswana National Olympic Committee (BNOC), incorporating Commonwealth Games Botswana, was formed in 1980 and charged with the responsibility to facilitate the development of high performance athletes to compete at the Olympic and Commonwealth Games. Botswana National Sports Council and Botswana National Ol ympic Committee (BNOC) are the two principal sports organizations in Botswana. Namibia-Republic of Namibia (825,615 km2) is a country in southern Africa with a population of 2,113,077 million, it shares land borders with Angola and Zambia to the north, Botswana to the east and South Africa to the south and east. Its western border is the Atlantic Ocean. It gained independence from South Africa on 21 March 1990, following the Namibian War of Independence. Namibia is a low middle-income country with an estimated annual GDP per capita of US$5,155 but has extreme inequalities in income distribution and standard of living. The most principal sports in Namibia include football (soccer), athletics (track and field), rugby, cricket, and fishing. Major achievements in Namibian sports include 4 Olympic medals in 100 and 200m at the 1992 and 1996 Olympic games respectively. Other highlights include reaching final stages at world games in cricket and rugby in 2003. Namibia Sports Commission (NSC) is charged 13 with the responsibility to ensure that opportunities for sports are made available to all people throughout Namibia. Consistent with other National Olympic Committees in Southern Africa, Namibia Olympic Committee promotes high performance sport throughout Namibia. In addition to high performance sport, it leads the Olympic movement and promotes Olympism throughout Namibia. South Africa-South Africa is the 25th-largest country in the world by land area, and with close to 53 million people, is the world's 24th-most populous nation. It is located at the southern tip of Africa. It has 2,798 kilometers (1,739 mi) of coastline that stretches along the South Atlantic and Indian oceans. Countries of Namibia, Botswana and Zimbabwe boarder South Africa to the north; to the east are Mozambique and Swaziland; and within it lies Lesotho, an enclave surrounded by South African territory. South Africa is an upper-middle income economy with the largest economy in Africa, which accounts for 24% gross domestic product in terms of purchasing power. This makes the country one of only four countries in Africa in this category (the others being Botswana, Gabon and Mauritius). Since 1996, at the end of over 12 years of international sanctions, South Africa's Gross Domestic Product has since almost tripled to $400 billion, and foreign exchange reserves have increased from $3 billion to nearly $50 billion; creating a growing and sizable African middle class, within two decades of establishing democracy and ending apartheid. There is no doubt that South African is a key player in sport development at Africa level. South Africa is a host to a variety of high performance centers that serve athletes from African counties. South Africa demonstrated to the rest of the world that it has made economic and political progress that accords it to 14 host world-class sporting events. South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (SASCOC)  is  South  Africa’s  national  multi-coded sporting body charged with the responsibility to ensure that South African teams perform at all the multi-coded events (i.e., Olympic games, Paralympic games, Commonwealth games, and All Africa games). Popular sports in South Africa include football (soccer), rugby, cricket, swimming and Boxing. Zimbabwe-The Republic of Zimbabwe is a landlocked country in Southern Africa with a population of 12,619,600. It is bordered by Botswana to the southwest, Zambia to the northwest, Mozambique on the east, and South Africa to the south. Zimbabwe got independence from the United Kingdom in April 1980, following 14 years as an unrecognized state under the conservative minority government of Rhodesia, which unilaterally declared independence in 1965. An economic summery of Zimbabwe: GDP/PPP (2011 est.): $6.474 billion; per capita $500 (2011 est.). An Act of Parliament created the Sports and Recreation Commission in 1991. The Sports and Recreation Commission (SRC) ensures that all people of Zimbabwe have access to sport and recreation programs. In addition, the SRC oversees the general running of sport and recreation programs by National Sports Associations (NSA). Popular sports include football (soccer), cricket, rugby, and athletics (track and field). 2.2 Literature Review on Southern Africa Areas in sport that have attracted most attention in Southern Africa literature include the impact of political history on current sport particularly in South Africa and Zimbabwe (Allen, 2011; Anderson, Bielert, & Jones, 2004; Chaulia, 2003; Chesterfield, 15 2007; Novak, 2012), the role of sport in national identity development after independence (Amusa & Toriola, 2010; Keat, 2011), and the use of sport to fight HIV/AIDS (Biddle, Akande, Vlachopoulos, & Fox, 1996; Clark, Friedrich, Ndlovu, Neilands, & McFarland, 2006; Fuller, Junge, Dorasami, DeCelles, & Dvorak, 2011). African colonies began to attain independence from their colonial masters in the late 1950s. African leaders who assumed power were charged with the responsibility to build nations and restore values that were lost during the colonial era. As young nations, it was important for political leaders to forge a national identity and build national pride. As they had used sport before to build a sense of nationalism, they used sport again to galvanize a sense of shared identity and destiny (Amusa & Toriola, 2010; Keat, 2011). For example, the shifting race relationships in post-apartheid South African sport literature indicates the crucial role sport played in building the rainbow nation and social integration in post-apartheid South Africa (Anderson et al., 2004; Booth & Nauright, 2003; Chappell, 2005a). Pelak (2005) examined the extent to which netball changed in the post-apartheid South Africa in order to accommodate cultural diversity in South Africa. The researcher observed that netball athletes and administrators construct new collective identities across a variety of cultural differences. Keat (2011) explained that African national leagues and the African Nations Cup were developed for the specific purpose of promoting national identity. It was also in this era that African nations gained memberships in international sports federations like the Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA). Sport also became an important tool for African nations and international organizations to build peace and unite 16 warring nations or ethnic communities across (Anderson  et  al.,  2004;;  “United  Nations   Sport for Development and Peace - Sport  and  Peace,”  n.d.). Gaining membership to international sport federations accorded African nations to bid and host international sporting events both at continent and world level. South Africa had the opportunity to host the first FIFA World Cup on Africa soil. In hosting the 2010 FIFA World Cup, South Africa became the first African nation to join industrialized nations that have hosted one of the largest sporting events in the world. South Africa demonstrated to the rest of the world that it has made economic and political progress that accords it to host world-class sporting events. The 2010 FIFA World Cup budget was R15 billion ($2bn) with R8.4 billion ($1.1bn) spent in building five new stadiums and upgrading existing facilities, while R6.4bn ($800m) was invested in public transport initiatives and supporting infrastructure (“S  Africa  unveils  World  Cup  budget,”  2006). South Africa has the largest economy in Africa with Botswana ranked 18th, Namibia in the 25th spot and lastly Zimbabwe ranked 31 (“Top  12  Largest  And  Strongest  African   Economies,”  n.d.). In the past 25 years, there has been a significant growth in partnerships between non-governmental organizations (e.g., UNICEF) and national governments to use sport to curb the spread of HIV/AIDS epidemic. National athletes and celebrities have been used to teach and send messages on HIV/AIDS education, particularly to youth in African countries. According to UNICEF, Eastern and Southern Africa is home to half the world’s  population  living  with  HIV.  Today  the  region  continues  to  be  the  epicenter of the HIV/AIDS  epidemic,  with  48  %  of  the  world’s  new  HIV  infections  among  adults,  55%   among children, and 48% of AIDS-related deaths. According to the World Health 17 Organization 2013 report on HIV/AIDS in Eastern and Southern Africa, the Southern Africa sub-region, experiences the most severe HIV epidemics in the world. Nine countries - Botswana, Lesotho, Malawi, Mozambique, Namibia, South Africa, Swaziland, Zambia and Zimbabwe have adult HIV prevalence rates of over 10%. The report estimates 26 %, Swaziland has the highest HIV prevalence rate in the world, followed by Botswana (23.4%) and Lesotho (23.3%). With 5.6 million people living with HIV (17.3%), Southern Africa  is  home  to  the  world’s  largest  epidemic  (UNAIDS, 2013). Sport has therefore been found to play a crucial role in teaching HIV/AIDS messages to students and young people across Africa. In a study that used professional football (soccer) players to provide HIV education in an interactive curriculum for 7th grade boys and girls in Zimbabwe, students in the intervention classrooms demonstrated significant increases in knowledge and attitudes using pre-, immediately post- & five-month postintervention surveys (Clark et al., 2006). 2.3 Gerontology and Thanatology Models of Retirement Transition Research on the concept of transition in the past decades has been linked to a wide range of topics that include individual life span development (Erikson, 1963), career planning (Hopson & Adams, 1977), educational processes (Newman, Lohman, Newman, Myers, & Smith, 2000), social support (Cutrona & Russell, 1990), and the processes of aging, retirement, and dying (Cummings & Henry, 1961; Kubler-Ross, 1969). Popular reports on the incidence of distress experienced by athletic career ending for youth and professional athletes were initially explained in terms of a singular, all-ending event Wylleman et al., 2004). For example, In the 1960s, theoretical frameworks that were used 18 to explain athletic career ending were derived from thanatology (i.e., the study of the process of dying and death) (Kubler-Ross, 1969) and (social) gerontology (i.e., the study of the aging process). Thanatology and gerontology models will be briefly explained below. 2.4 Social Gerontology Models of Retirement Transition Social gerontology is a multidisciplinary field grounded in the sociology of aging but informed by psychologists, policy and public health researchers, medical and social work practitioners, and economists other fields. Research in social gerontology addresses many domains of social life and behavior, including family relationships, health and disability,  and  older  adults’  social  participation  (Putney, Alley, & Bengtson, 2005). There are numerous transition theories based on Social Gerontological models that could be applied to athletic retirement transition, such as activity theory, continuity theory, subculture theory, disengagement theory, social breakdown theory, and exchange theory. 2.4.1 Activity Theory. Activity theory asserts that an individual's life satisfaction is directly related to his degree of social interaction or level of activity(Knapp, 1977). Havighurst and Albrecht (1953) were some of the first researchers to suggest an association between social activity and adjustment to retirement transition from the work force looking specifically at old age. The theory suggests that individuals should maintain a homeostatic level of activity throughout their lifespan. When applied to athletic retirement transition, the theory suggests that athletes should substitute the active role of an athlete with new roles during retirement transition (Havighurst & Albrecht, 1953). Even though the activity theory received empirical support in the gerontology literature (Rosenberg 1981), it was criticized for assuming that sport retirement is similar to 19 occupational  retirement  where  individuals  are  “forced”  to  withdraw  from  the  labor  force   due to chronological age (Blinde & Greendorfer, 1985; Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994). Several factors such as deselection, injuries and change of career are some of the primary reasons for retirement from competitive sport. 2.4.2 Continuity Theory. Continuity theory suggests that individuals seek to maintain role stability throughout their life course (Atchley, 1989). Behaviors and attitudes are often the single most significant predictors of present or future behaviors (Utz, Carr, Nesse, & Wortman, 2002). The application of this theory to sport suggests that continuity theory can predict the level of adjustment to retirement by examining the significance of sport in the lives of athletes (Lerch, 1984). Rosenberg (1981) asserts that if  one’s  athletic  role  is  seen  as  more  meaningful  than  other  roles;;  athletes’  may   experience some difficulties in distributing them during retirement transition. One of the challenges of the continuity theory application to athletic retirement is when sustaining the athletic role is not a priority for the athlete in transition, the reallocation of time and energy to remaining roles will not create problems in the adjustment process (Lavallee & Wylleman, 2000). 2.4.3 Subculture Theory. Hart (1976) defined subculture as a segment of society embracing certain distinctive cultural elements of their own. Shared subcultural elements include a set of identifiable beliefs, values, and means of symbolic expression. Sport provides a highly visible, easily accessible, and particularly salient setting for the formation of subculture and the resulting expression of subcultural values (Green, 2001). The theory suggests that continued social interactions among individuals might enable the retiring athletes to be less active and adjust well during retirement transition (Rose, 20 1962). This hypothesis was affirmed by Rosenberg (1981), who asserts that prolonged social interactions among individuals leads to the development of a group consciousness, and that people can be less active and well adjusted even if the situation is different from overall social norms. Even though athletes have fairly distinguishable (sub) cultural characteristics, and although it assists in revealing potential adjustment problems experienced by athletes in ending their athletic career, there was no empirical support to use this theory because retiring athletes are moving out of the proposed subculture (Wylleman et al., 2004). 2.4.4 Disengagement Theory. Disengagement theory suggests that as adults’ age, they gradually withdraw from society (Cumming & Henry, 1961). When the theory is applied to sport retirement  transition,  the  theory  suggests  that  athletes’  retirement   transition is a necessary manifestation of mutual withdrawal of athletes and the sport structure. The mutual process of disengagement makes room for younger generations and prevents unnecessary disruptions in the social system caused by deaths among the older population (Utz et al., 2002). Given that athletes can involuntarily and suddenly leave the work place due to injury and deselection, retiring from elite sport does not fit this theory. In addition to involuntary retirement, athletes do not only retire due to chronological age. Athletes can retire as early as 20 due to an injury or lack of interest. 2.4.5 Social Breakdown Theory. The social breakdown theory suggests that an individual’s  sense  of  self,  his  ability  to  mediate  between  self  and  society,  and  his   orientation to personal mastery are functions of the kinds of social labeling experienced in life (Kuypers & Bengtson, 1973). The theory incorporates elements from activity, 21 subculture, and continuity theory and proposes that athletes become vulnerable to social judgments upon retirement. The theory further suggests that athletes are exposed to unfavorable redefinition, which may lead them to withdraw further from their sport and become susceptible to more negative evaluation (Kuypers & Bengston, 1973). For example, athletes may lose their celebrity status upon retirement and be relegated to a common figure in society, which “forces”  athletes  to  redefine  their  identity.   Some athletes may fail to redefine their identity hence isolation. Rosenberg (1981) applied this theory to athletes and affirms that the withdrawal cycle demonstrates how elite athletes are vulnerable to social judgments upon retirement. Edwards and Meier (1984) observed a relationship between adjustment to retirement from sport and several variables proposed to be significant in social breakdown theory, including socioeconomic status, preretirement planning, and health. Athletes who have access to services that provide employment and stable financial opportunities are more likely to use these support services to facilitate their retirement transition hence a healthy retirement transition than athletes who do not have access to such services. 2.4.6 Exchange Theory. The exchange theory was proposed by Homans (1961) to explain how aging individuals rearrange their activities so that their remaining energy generates maximum return. When applied to sport, Johns, Linder, and Wolko (1990) demonstrated in a study carried out with former competitive gymnasts in Canada that the examination of factors that contribute to retirement from sport through a social exchange perspective has some merit. Rosenberg (1981) has suggested that this theory is the most applicable to elite sport as it is often the inability of an athlete to create these new networks that contributes to a difficult adjustment. In a different study, Koukouris (1991) 22 challenged the processes associated with exchange theory that they do not stand up because they deny the possibility of the development of a career after sport. Gordon (1995) suggested that resources such as physical talent might be able to be exchanged for meaningful rewards from the sports system. These resources are finite and their inevitable deterioration will affect the degree of control over the sports relationship (Gordon, 1995). Social gerontology theories provide a multidisciplinary approach informed by psychologists, public health researchers medical, social work practitioners, and economists other fields. Even though these theories address many domains of social life and behavior, they did not fully explain retirement from competitive sport let alone preparation for a post-sport career. These theories did not look at factors such as reasons for retirement and goals that athletes have achieved in their career in sport. Research (Du & Tsai, 2007) has shown that reasons for retirement influence retirement transition and post-sport life experiences. 2.5 Thanatological Models of Retirement Transition Thanatology is the study of the process of death and dying. Park (1912) outlined thanatology by demonstrating the biomedical causes of death. Disciplines of psychology, anthropology, sociology and theology have made significant contributions to the thanatology literature (Rando, 1986). Thanatological models were used to suggest that retirement from an athletic career is comparable to loss of social functioning, isolation, and ostracism (Kalish, 1966). The application of these models has been criticized because athletes continue to function even though they may face challenges. 23 2.5.1 Social Death.  Social  death  approach  was  used  to  explain  that  after  athletes’   sports career termination, athletes are treated as if they were dead even though still biologically alive, bringing about the loss of social functioning, isolation, or even ostracism (Wylleman et al., 2004). The concept was used to explain the psychodynamics of athletic retirement, which in some cases athletes, might be isolated (Lerch, 1984). This approach failed, among others, due to the obvious fact that athletic retirees continued functioning in society, albeit in a different social role (Wylleman et al., 2004). 2.5.2 Stages of Death. In describing retirement from sport, a more popular use of thanatology was developed to describe athletic retirement in the series of stages experienced when facing death (Kubler-Ross, 1969). The stages of dying as applied to retirement from sports, include denial and isolation. Retired athletes in denial and isolation initially refuse to acknowledge the inevitability of their career termination; anger, in which retiring athletes become disturbed at the overall changing situation; bargaining, in which they try to negotiate for a lengthened career in sport; depression, in which they experience a distress reaction to retirement; and acceptance, in which retirees eventually come to accept their career transition (Wylleman et al., 2004). The application of the stages of death theory was a topic of interest in athlete retirement research. For example, theorists employed this model to describe the psychological consequences experienced by athletes during rehabilitation from injury (Wiese-Bjornstal & Smith, 1994). The  model’s  narrow  approach  to  retirement transition calls for caution in its applicability to athletes’ retirement. For example, the model assumes that retirement from sport is always involuntary (i.e., through injury). Recent research (Du & Tsai, 2007; 24 Lavallee et al., 1997) demonstrate that athletes can retire voluntarily to take new roles in their lives. Even though the models were instrumental in stimulating research in career transition issues and appealed to some researchers in sociology of sports and sports psychology, thanatological models were criticized especially because of the lack of analogy between terminal illness and career termination (Gordon, 1995; Taylor & Ogilvie, 1998). Thanatology models remain limited for explaining sports career termination from a non-sport specific character; the model also presumes that career termination is inherently negative and requires considerable adjustment (Wylleman et al., 2004). 2.6 Summary on Gerontology and Thanatology Models The universal application of the retirement concept justified the use of theoretical perspectives underlying sport retirement from social gerontology and thanatology given the period they were used. A discussion of these models stimulated research in sports psychology, sociology of sports and clinical psychology, which ushered a new understanding of elite athletes retirement transition, which will be discussed below. Social gerontology and thanatology models inability to adequately address the complex nature of athletic retirement, theorists suggested that alternative perspectives are needed to explain athletic retirement transition (Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994). Researchers further suggested that athletic career termination might serve as an opportunity for social rebirth rather than a form of a social death (Coakley, 1983). The shift in studying retirement transition not only ushered new transitional models but also presented interventions necessary for retired athletes (Kadlcik & Flemr, 2008). 25 2.7 Athletic Career Transition Models In counseling psychology, the concept of transition is presented as an event or a non-event, which results in a change in assumptions about oneself and the world and thus requires  a  corresponding  change  in  one’s  behavior  and  relationships  (Schlossberg, 1981). In sport psychology, transition was introduced to study how former athletes coped with the event of retirement from high-level competitive and professional sports (Haerle, 1975; Mihovilovic, 1968). Recent literature (Henriksen et al., 2010; Kadlcik & Flemr, 2008) and models (Wylleman & Lavallee, 2004) advocate for a shift from studying retirement transition as a single event and or in isolation but focus on a holistic approach to  athletes’  retirement  transition.  A  holistic  approach  to  retirement  transitions,  incorporate   athletes’  experiences  that  occur  at  athletic, psychological, psychosocial, academic/vocation level, and their ability to cope with these changes (Wylleman, Alfermann, & Lavallee, 2004). Even though theoretical models and constructs have been developed to help researchers explain elite athletes’ retirement transition, these models and constructs may not be applicable to Southern African populations. Transitional challenges that retired athletes have to deal with include, among others, adjusting to a new life and a new lifestyle following the sport career (Wylleman & Reints, 2010). Retired athletes have to deal with missing the sport atmosphere and competition, as well as bodily changes that come with retiring from competitive sports. Some of the changes include a subjective wellbeing and, or adapting to a new social status and vocational responsibilities (Cecicerpic, Wylleman, & Zupancic, 2004; Stephan et al., 2003). It is therefore crucial for development programs to understand transitional challenges experienced by athletes during and after retirement form elite sport. Wylleman 26 and Reints (2010) observed that former elite athletes need motivational readiness and interpersonal skills to integrate back into non-sports professional settings. The study provides evidence that elite athletes are confronted during and after retirement with transitional challenges that impacts the course and progress of their development in and outside sport. The authors further argue that several former elite athletes may in fact turn to their family-of-origin for support (i.e., due to lack of financial stability), or even ‘‘return  home’’  to  live  with  their  parents  and  may  then  also  experience  interpersonal  (or   intergenerational) problems. Two models that guide this  study  are  Stambulova’s  (2003)  athletic  career   transition model and Wylleman & Lavallee's (2004) lifespan model. The primary reason for selecting these models to guide this dissertation is that they complete each other in addressing issues relating to athletes retirement transition. A further in depth elaboration on each model and evidence of empirical support is presented in this chapter. Consistent with the two models that guide this study, athletes describe highlights in their athletic career in terms of specific moments or situations that occurred throughout their career. For example, a specific moment might include their first-training day with a coach, their first competition, being invited to join the junior team followed by the senior team camp, and eventually the retirement press conference. Some of these highlights are very specific like winning first medal at All Africa games or the Olympic games. What is also consistent in these highlights is transition within the athletic career from a certain point to another. Wylleman and Reints (2010) depict that athletes face two types of transitions throughout their athletic career, namely predictable and anticipated or ‘‘normative’’  transitions  (e.g.,  from  junior  to  senior  level,  from  amateur to professional 27 status, ending the athletic career) and more or less unpredicted, unanticipated, and involuntary  or  ‘‘non-normative’’  transitions  (e.g.,  a  season-ending injury, unanticipated de-selection from the team, loss of a personal coach). Even though there is need for a thorough understanding of career transitions in sport and empirically supported data in Southern Africa, the Wylleman  and  Lavallee’s   (2004) lifespan model provides developmental stages that athletes go through in their career in sport. This model is one of the widely used models in sport psychology literature. For example, the initiation stage is characterized by specific moments that are the main highlights specific only to the beginning of  athletes’  careers in sport. One of the primary highlights is the development of passion and love for participating in the activity or disliking the activity leading to withdrawal. Parents take a leadership role by providing young athletes with the initial opportunity to participate in the domain and sought out their  child’s  first  formal  teacher  or  coach  (Wylleman et al., 2004). Parents are also crucial during retirement transition for providing both financial and social support in athletic and non-athletic contexts. Some of the more specific highlights may be scoring their first goal in primary school. Sports programs in African schools provide the opportunity for athletes to play sport. Once athletes have moved to an upper phase like development, they look forward to a normative transition from junior team to a senior team. This transition is in athletic contexts. Outside sports, athletes may be transitioning from junior secondary to senior secondary school. It is important to emphasize that each stage is characterized by shifting demands on the athlete and entourage members (Baker, Horton, RobertsonWilson, & Wall, 2003). In a similar study carried out earlier, Côté (1999), observed comparable transitions occurring between stages of sampling, specializing, investment, 28 and mastery in the development of deliberate practice. 2.7.1 Athletic Career Transition Model Stambulova’s  (2003)  athletic  transition model (Figure 1) presents the athletic career transition as a process of coping with a set of specific demands and or challenges necessary for athletic career success or adjusting to a post-sport career. A detailed explanation, including steps of the model is presented below. According to the model, developmental conflicts and challenges stimulate the athlete to mobilize resources and the support system required to cope with challenges and demands during retirement transition. This model is important for providing an understanding on the influence of circumstances surrounding athletes’ retirement and the support system to post-sport career transition and adaptation, which is pivotal in discussing results of this dissertation. The ability of the athlete to effectively cope is dependent on the balance between transition resources (internal and external factors, which facilitate the coping process) and barriers (all internal and external factors, which interfere with effective coping) (Kadlcik & Flemr, 2008). If the athlete effectively manages to cope with the challenges he/she will have positive consequences and the inability to cope leads to crisis-transition. Crisis in an athlete’s development may be caused by a set of transitional problems (contradictions, or inner conflicts) that he/she has to resolve, but is not able to resolve without qualified psychological assistance (Stambulova, 2000). The author provided three types of athlete crises that are identified and described as (a) age-related crises, (b) sports career-related crises, and (c) situationrelated crises. Success or goal achievement has also been associated with a smooth 29 retirement transition. For example, if the athlete’s  goal  was  to  compete  at  the  Olympic   games, that may give closure for the athlete to focus on a new career. Sinclair and Orlick (1993) explored transition experiences of high-performance athletes and observed that athletes who adjusted smoothly tended to retire after they achieved their sport related goals or because they had achieved their goals in sport. Even though there is empirical data supporting the athletic career transition model from past research (Kadlcik & Flemr, 2008; Park, Lavallee, & Tod, 2013) and the current study, the model does not provide empirical evidence on what athletes need to do, in preparation for retirement. This dissertation provides empirical data to support the model on the type of retirement and circumstances surrounding retirement transition, and in addition, this dissertation provides recommendations on what athletes should do while at the peak of their careers in preparation for a post-sport career. 30 Figure 1: Athletic Career Transition Model Transition demands Crisis prevention Interventions Dynamic balance between transition resources and barriers Coping Effective Psychological crisis coping (= positive transition) Ineffective (= crisis transition) Interventions Need for Intervention Effective Ineffective or no intervention ‘Costs’  for  failure   to cope with the interaction Psychotherapeutic interventions 31 2.7.2 Lifespan Model of Athlete Development Wylleman  and  Lavelle’s  (2004)  descriptive  model  (Figure  2)  approaches  athletic   career transition from a holistic and lifespan perspective. The model discusses how athletes move through stages of athletic development that are tied to their ages and developmental levels. The model is considered holistic because it incorporates many aspects of life such as education, sports, and social life. Incorporating sport and events occurring outside sport such as education is not new to sport literature. The ancient Greeks' worldview advocated the development of both mind (e.g., educational programs) and body (physical training programs) through sport (Pavlidis & Gargalianos, 2014). Recent research (Borggrefe & Cachay, 2012; Corrado, Tessitore, Capranica, Rauter, & Topic, 2012; Pavlidis & Gargalianos, 2014; Wylleman et al., 2004) in sport psychology, has taken keen interest in issues occurring in and outside sport as athletes move through stages of athletic development. International organizations such as the European Commission (EC) and the International Olympic Committee (IOC) have also take keen interest in this approach. The European Commission acknowledged the importance of dual career (balancing school and sport) for young elite athletes by promoting policies that promotes good physical and psychological health. These policies are made to ensure the reintegration of professional sportspersons into the labor market at the end of their sporting careers. The International Olympic Committee runs a program that guides Olympic athletes into education with the goal of a better postretirement life. The primary reason for choosing this model to guide this study is that it considers transitions occurring in the athletic domain as well as those occurring in other domains of athletes’  lives. In addition to the fact that this model is widely used in sport psychology 32 literature, the model has significant empirical support (Debois, Ledon, Argiolas, & Rosnet, 2012; Stephan & Demulier, 2007; Wylleman & Reints, 2010) from studies carried out around the world. For example, Aquilina (2013) demonstrated that events occurring in and outside sport (i.e., balancing school and sport) plays an instrumental role in the understanding of athletes retirement transition. The author depict that some athletes' time may be dedicated to developing their sporting career, with very little time left to develop other aspects of their lives outside their sport such as education which may result in more severe retirement transition challenges. In order to get an understanding of the development of talented elite athletes and how they cope with the transitions in their athletic development, it is crucial to also get an understanding of the other developmental transitions (e.g., at psychological level, at psychosocial level) faced by elite athletes (Wylleman et al., 2004). The lifespan model reflects the  concurrent,  interactive,  and  reciprocal  nature  of  athletes’  development  in  four   domains (athletic, psychological, psychosocial, academic/vocational). The athletic domain consists of four stages that depict normative progression from initiation, development, mastery and discontinuation. These stages are similar to those observed by Bloom (1985) and Cote (1999). The initiation stage introduces young athletes to organized sports from 6 to 7 years of age. From the initiation stage, athletes are recognized as talented in the development stage. Training time and level heightens to prepare athletes for the next stage. Athletes who reach the mastery stage compete at the highest-level of competition in their respective sport. Athletes in the mastery stage compete at national, international, and elite level. The mastery stage coincides with higher education. The last stage is the discontinuation stage where athletes withdraw 33 from competitive sport. It is worth noting that discontinuation can occur earlier in the athletic career. For example, it can occur at initiation if the athlete loses interest in the sport at 7 years old and withdraw from sport. The psychological domain consists of childhood, adolescence, and adulthood. It is crucial for coaches to be aware that development stage in the athletic domain coincides with adolescence in the psychology domain. It is important for adolescents to continue involvement in physical activity and sports, which contributes to achieving and maintaining good emotional and physical health. The psychosocial domain represents the changes that may occur in the social development of an athlete. The psychosocial domain also denotes individuals who are perceived by athletes as most significant during that particular transition or stage (e.g., parents,  coach,  peers,  life  time  partner)  in  the  athlete’s  career  (Wylleman & Reints, 2010). The final domain is the academic/vocational domain, which represents the stages in the academic and vocational development of the athlete (primary education, secondary education, higher education, Vocations training/ professional occupation). The academic development of athletes is influenced by the education system in respective countries. For elite athletes, vocational development may start after secondary education or after higher education. In some cases, elites athletes may engage in parttime/ full time work. Even thought the model is widely used in sport psychology research, this is the first study to test its applicability of Southern Africa population. For example, the psychosocial component of the model suggests that parents play a primary role of introducing their kids into sport (mostly organized sport) as early as six years of age. Horn (2008) affirms that the sport involvement of children takes place in a social context, and parents, peers, and siblings can strongly influence the psychological 34 outcomes of this involvement. However, in the context of Southern Africa, this dissertation observed that even though parental involvement is important, school sport programs provides an  environment  that  support  children’s  participation  in  sport and parents are not as engaged as it is the case in industrialized nations. Results from this dissertation are consistent with Shehu and Akpata (2008)’s  findings  that  teachers in many schools  in  Southern  Africa  volunteer,  and  it  is  also  part  of  a  lot  of  teachers’  jobs  to  coach,   be umpires, and organize intra- and extra-mural sport events. As a result, teachers in most African countries are not only in a position to widen youth sport participation but to inspire life-long physical activity and encourage attainment of self-directed sport aspirations. Malete (2006) affirms this statement, given the cultural context and perception in Botswana. It is therefore likely that young athletes may perceive lower parental support than their counterparts from industrialized nations. This lifespan model does a great job in explaining how athletes move through stages in their career in sport but may not fully explain some specific components of athletes’ psychosocial development particularly in African populations. The model does not account for the role of extended family members which may be significance role given the family structure in many African countries. 35 Figure 2: Lifespan Model of Athlete Development Age Athletic Developmen t Psychological development Psycho-social Development Academic / Vocational Development 10 Initiation Childhood Parents Siblings Peers Primary Education 10 20 15 Developme nt 25 Adulthood Peers Coach Parents Secondary Education Family Coach Peers Partner Coach Vocational profession Professional Athlete Higher Education 15 35 Discontinua tion Perfection Adolescen ce Puberty 30 20 25 30 35 2.7.3 Conceptual Model of Adaptation to Career Transition Drawing from previous theoretical frameworks, both within and outside of sport, and current empirical research, Taylor and Ogilvie (1994) proposed a five-step model (Figure 3) that examines adaptation to athletic retirement. The model examines the entire course of the career transition process. According to the model, the first stage identifies the causal factors that initiate the retirement process (i.e., age, injury, and free choice). Depending on the cause of withdrawal from competitive sport, the second stage presents developmental factors related to transition adaptation. Factors related to transition that are emphasized in the model include developmental experiences, self-identity, and tertiary contributors. The third stage describes the available resources that affect the response to retirement. The resources required (i.e., social and financial support) for coping with retirement are crucial for athletes. Research (Bloom, 1985; Côté, 1999; Wylleman et al., 36 2004) demonstrates that members of the entourage (i.e., family, peers, and coaches) provide needed support during athlete development and retirement. The fourth stage assesses the quality of adjustment to career transition, and the final stage looks at possible treatment issues for distressful reactions to career transition. The quality of retirement is influenced by many factors that include among others, social support and nature of retirement. 37 Figure 3: Conceptual Model of Adaptation to Career Transition Causes of Career Termination: Age, Deselection, Injury Free choice Factors related to Adaptation to Career Transition: Developmental experiences Self-identity Perception of control Social identity Tertiary contributors Available Resources for Adaptation to Career Transition: Coping strategies Social support Pre-retirement planning Quality of Career Transition Career Transition Distress: Adjustment difficulties Occupational/financial problems Family/social problem Psychopathology Substance abuse Healthy Career Transition Intervention for Career Transition: Cognitive Emotional Behavior Social Organization 38 2.8 Factors Affecting Retirement Transition The quality of post-sport career transition and adaptation is influenced by athletic and non-athletic factors. Some of the greatest contributors to a difficult transition include involuntary retirement (i.e., injury, deselection, and age), a strong, exclusive athletic identity, and lack of pre-retirement planning and support services (Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994). Retired athletes are faced with financial, occupational, emotional, and social adjustment challenges during the athletic career transition (Grove, Lavallee, & Gordon, 1997). Factors influencing athletic career transition can result in a successful, relatively smooth transition, or in more or less intense difficulties at the psychological, physical, psychosocial, and/or occupational level (Cecić  Erpič,  Wylleman,  &  Zupančič,  2004). It is therefore crucial to pay attention to preparing elite athletes for retirement transition and post-sport career. Athletic identity issues, coping processes, support network, and career planning have been identified as fundamental factors that influence adaptation during an athletic career transition (Cecić  Erpič, Wylleman,  &  Zupančič,  2004). Cross-cultural research indicates that transition out of elite sports is a dynamic, multidimensional, multilevel, and multifactor process in which nationality/culture plays a crucial role in post-sport career transition (Alfermann et al., 2004; Stambulova et al., 2007). Even though retirement planning regardless of nation is associated with more favorable emotions and coping behaviors in the transition (Alfermann et al., 2004; Stambulova et al., 2007), it is not associated with perceived quality and long-term consequences of the transition (Stambulova et al., 2007). This dissertation provides an understanding an what athletes need to do for a long-term post-sport career quality. For example, research (Aquilina, 39 2013) suggests that dual-career can be a good long term post-sport career plan for elite athletes. In a cross-cultural study between Russian, German, and Lithuanian retired athletes, German athletes showed more positive and less negative emotions after retirement than Russian and Lithuanian athletes. Though Russian and Lithuanian athletes were accepting the reality of retirement, Lithuanian athletes showed more signs of denial while Russian athletes used distraction strategies more than athletes in other nations. In a similar cross-cultural study comparing French and Swedish athletes, Swedish athletes showed more positive retirement transition than French athletes. Starting a new professional career was perceived as difficult regardless of a nation (Stambulova et al., 2007). It is worth noting that most theoretical models and constructs that inform elite athletes’ retirement experiences are carried out using quantitative research methods. For example, Biddle (1997) reviewed papers (n = 529) published in two major sport psychology journals (Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, JSEP; International Journal of Sport Psychology, IJSP) between 1985 and 1994. The researcher observed very little diversity in research methods. Over one-third of the papers used cross-sectional survey methods and less than 6% used qualitative methods. In a more recent review, culver, Gilbert, and Sparkes (2012) reviewed qualitative research published in three leading sports psychology journals (Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, The Sport Psychologist, and journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology) between 2000 and 2009. Researchers observed a 68% increase in qualitative researcher papers published between 1990 and 1999 (from 19.3% to 29%). In addition to the fact that there is need for more diversity in the research method (Biddle, Markland, Gilbourne, Chatzisarantis, & Sparkes, 2001) , the applicability of these theoretical models and constructs needs more 40 empirical support with participants from Southern Africa. 2.8.1 Athletic Identity. Athletic identity is one of the well-studied areas in sports psychology and one of the main predictors of athletic retirement transition (Fraser et al., 2010; Lavallee & Robinson, 2007; Warriner & Lavallee, 2008). Brewer, Van Raalte, and Linder (1993) defined athletic identity as the degree to which an individual identifies with the role of an athlete. High athletic identity is associated with strong commitment to athletic goals (Lally, 2007), particularly during adolescence a period demarcated for the pursuit of an identity (Warriner & Lavallee, 2008). High athletic identity has also been found to contribute to less positive reactions to retirement transition and to more problems in athletes’ retirement adaptation process (Grove et al., 1997; Lally, 2007; Warriner & Lavallee, 2008). Even though athletic identity is related to retirement difficulties, some studies argue that it is not related to overall life satisfaction and athletes’  anticipated  disrupted  identities  upon  retirement  (Lally, 2007; Webb, et al., 1998). A proactive diminishing of athletic identity prior to retirement is associated with positive effects on retirement transition particularly, precluding a major identity crisis or confusion upon and following athletic retirement (Fraser et al., 2010; Lally, 2007; Lavallee & Robinson, 2007; Webb et al., 1998). Looking  specifically  to  gymnast  retirees’  adjustment  to  retirement,  problems   pronounced in gymnastics were due to the young ages at which participants began and ended their competitive careers (Lavallee & Robinson, 2007). Identity loss is salient upon retirement from gymnastics and physical changes associated with retirement are some of the challenges that gymnasts face (Caine,  Lewis,  O’Connor,  Howe,  &  Bass,  2001; Lavallee & Robinson, 2007). Athletic retirement challenges also intensify due to the fact 41 that athletes invest heavily in sport during adolescence; a period that coincides with a time when adolescents typically undergo profound changes physiologically and in identity development (Emmert, 2012; Lavallee & Robinson, 2007; Warriner & Lavallee, 2008). 2.8.2 Coping Processes. Coping is defined as constantly changing cognitive and behavioral efforts to manage specific external and or internal demands that are appraised as taxing or exceeding the resources of the person (Lazarus & Folkman, 1986). Authors further proposed that there are generally two ways of coping with stress. The first way is problem- focused coping, which is aimed at problem solving or doing something to alter the source of the stress. The second strategy is emotion- focused coping. Emotion focused coping is aimed at reducing or managing the emotional distress that is associated with (or cued by) the situation (Lazarus & Folkman, 1986). Although most stressors elicit both types of coping, problem-focused coping tends to predominate when people feel that something constructive can be done, whereas emotion-focused coping tends to predominate when people feel that the stressor is something that must be endured (Folkman & Lazarus, 1980). Using coping strategies, Sinclair and Orlick (1993) demonstrated, through an exploratory study, that specific coping strategies such as having other interests, keeping busy, and or continuing to exercise are positively correlated with adjustment to retirement from sport. In a similar study, with a sample of 48 retired athletes, acceptance and positive reinterpretation were the most frequently used coping strategies during the career transition process (Grove et al., 1997). Social support (i.e., family and friends), engaging in pre-retirement planning, and a subsequent control of the transition out of sports by 42 reducing participation gradually and finding a meaningful replacement has been found to be crucial in managing retirement transitions (Fraser et al., 2010; Lavallee & Robinson, 2007; Warriner & Lavallee, 2008). Even though dual career is a challenge to a lot of athletes, it is associated with positive athletic retirement transition because athletes move form one career to another instantly (Borggrefe & Cachay, 2012; Corrado et al., 2012). Dual-career is viewed as a valuable tool for promoting an important contribution to the development of policy actions in the area of sport and education at national and European levels (Corrado et al., 2012). 2.8.3 Social Support. Social support has been identified as one of the most important factors in both nurturing athletic talent (Gould et al., 2006; Wuerth, Lee, & Alfermann, 2004) and managing post-sport career transition (Park et al., 2012; Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994). Parents  and  other  family  members  involved  in  athletes’  athletic  careers provide family environment that affects the quality of performance and retirement transition particularly starting a new career. Consistent with the literature, Du (2008) studied Hong Kong retired elite athletes and observed that the quality of placement of elite athletes in Hong Kong after retirement was affected by their sports achievements and "personal support" gained from family members, coaches, and friends during retirement transition. A similar study revealed differences in the psychological states, retirement awareness, retirement plans, self-regulation, social support, and life contentment between the successful retirement cases and the failed ones (Siekanska, 2012). Successfully retired athletes were often aware that they were going to retire and made plans to start new careers, but athletes who failed to start new careers after retirement often used avoidance coping mechanisms (Du, 2008; Siekanska, 2012; Yang, 43 Peek-Asa, Lowe, Heiden, & Foster, 2010). Family members and the network gathered during  athletes’  careers  are  significantly  helpful  to  the  quality  of  athlete  retirement   placement in terms of getting new jobs. Du (2008) argues that the society and sports organizations should not use medals as the only achievement measure. The author suggests that the society and government should provide elite athletes with occupational training or learning opportunities, thus enhancing the quality of placement of retired athletes. 2.9. Summary: Factors Affecting Retirement Transition The research reveals that the circumstances surrounding withdrawal from competitive sports significantly influence the quality of retirement. Some of the coping mechanisms used by athletes are to engage in other activities while other athletes may opt to avoid their challenges and hence be isolated. Family support and other members of the entourage provide the much-needed support that may be social and or financial. Having a dual-career like going to college is also a crucial factor in retirement transition. Greater emphasis should be directed towards the psychological, social and physical transitions experienced by elite athletes prior to and after retirement to ensure a positive adaptation into post- sports life. 44 Chapter 3: METHODOLOGY The primary objective of this dissertation was to investigate elite athletes’ retirement transition experiences including  it’s  psychological  impact,  and post-sport career adaptation. The secondary objective was to investigate psychological impacts of elite athletes retirement transition and the role played by the  entourage  on  elite  athletes’   retirement transition. Presented in this chapter are methods and procedures used in the conduct of the research. The following format is followed in the presentation of this chapter; research design, participants, procedures, instruments, pilot study and data analysis. 3.1 Research Design To address the problem stated above, this study used a grounded theory research approach. The notion of grounded theory approach was developed by the work of sociologists Glaser and Strauss (1967). Grounded theory can be described as a systematic, yet flexible methodology for collection and analyzing qualitative data to construct theories that are grounded in the data themselves (Sparkes & Smith, 2014). The grounded theory approach was chosen to explore the experiences of retired elite athletes and their entourage members because it accords the researcher the opportunity to generate theory rather than impose theory on the data. Although the components of a grounded theory appear in linear sequence, it is worth emphasizing that the grounded theory approach is a recursive process. In practice, the researcher consistently shifts in the data collection and analysis process largely due to a constant comparison method required in the grounded theory. What makes theory developed in the grounded theory profoundly different from other psychological theories is that in the grounded theory 45 method, the theory is created during data analysis, and the validity of the theory is “grounded”  as  the  data  supporting  it  increases. Unlike other methods of qualitative research where theories are generally cemented in the original hypothesis and therefore have the possible of change during the research process, in grounded theory the research theory is developed throughout the research process and as more data is received and analyzed, the theory continues to change as the data dictates. 3.2 Participants A total of 17 retired athletes (12 males and 5 females) from various sports (athletics-6, swimming-2, Boxing-2, rowing-2, field hockey-2, gymnastics-1, triathlon-1, biking-1) in Southern Africa and their entourages participated in the current study. All athletes had competed at the Olympics except one athlete who had competed at world championships and the Commonwealth games. A total of 35 entourage members participated in the study and included parents, coaches and spouses. 3.3 Procedure National Olympic Committees of Botswana, South Africa, Zimbabwe and Namibia were contacted to facilitate the recruitment process. Personalized recruitment letters were then sent to each individual retired athlete recruiting them to take part in the study. Participants were awarded a $50 gift card or cash for participating in the study. The researcher was granted the research permit by Michigan State University Institutional Review Board and National Olympic Committees of participating countries. Data collection was carried out in three phases. 46 3.3.1 Phase I. The first phase comprised a 15-minute online demographic survey that was emailed to athlete participants after they agreed to participate in the study (Appendix A). The demographic questionnaire sought information such as age, type of sport, time of retirement and if athletes were ready for retirement. The primary reason for Phase I data collection was to focus interviews and give the researcher more information about the participant prior to the interview process. 3.3.2 Phase II. The second phase involved in-depth online (via Skype/phone) interviews. Each in-depth interview lasted 45 to 55 minutes. All athletes and their entourage members were interviewed separately. Given the distance and time difference between where the researcher lives and where participants live, Skype/telephone were the most viable way to conduct interviews. The researcher also traveled to the site to conduct interviews with participants who were not available for a Skype/telephone interview (athletes n=2 and entourage n=17). 3.3.3 Phase III. The third phase of data collection consisted of focus groups with the same retired athletes from South Africa, Botswana and spouses of athletes from Botswana. Focus groups were conducted separately for each set of participants and they were conducted on separate dates. Botswana focus groups were conducted at the University of Botswana (UB) and for South Africa, they were conducted at the South Africa Sport Confederation of Olympic Committee (SASCOC). Focus groups were used for triangulation purposes as a data quality control measure as well as to follow-up on questions that were not answered or emerged during the interview process. Interviews and focus groups with multiple samples (athletes, parents, spouses, coaches ad federation) accords the researcher the opportunity to triangulate data and use different 47 data sources as a quality control measure. Retired athlete focus groups were conducted first  and  followed  by  spouses’  focus  group in Botswana (athletes n=6, spouses n=3) and (South Africa athletes n=2). 3.4 Instruments The conceptual model of adaptation to career transition (Taylor & Ogilvie, 1998) and the lifespan model (Wylleman & Lavallee, 2004) were used to guide the interviews. Demographic information collected in Phase I was also used to further guide the interviews for this study. A total of three data collection instruments were designed for this study: the online survey (Appendix A) and two semi-structured interview schedules. Two semi-structured interview schedules were designed for individual athlete interviews and  the  focus  groups  respectively.  Athletes’  interview guide (Appendix B) was influenced by the lifespan model on athlete development, the role played by the entourage  in  athletes’  careers,  circumstances surrounding career termination and retirement transition. The conceptual model of adaptation to career transition influenced some questions particularly on circumstances surrounding retirement. Entourage interview guide (Appendix C) focused on the same areas as athletes interview guide but from the entourage perspective. A sports psychology professor examined the instruments, and revisions were made where necessary. A follow-up instrument was designed after interviews to enquire further and provide clarity where needed during focus groups. Even though instruments in the appendix show question on athletes entire career in sport, questions that were of primary interest to this dissertation are those relating to retirement transition and the role of the entourage. 48 3.5 Pilot Study A pilot study with two retired athletes was conducted and data from the pilot were transcribed and analyzed to test the validity of the instruments. Revisions were made accordingly. Retired athletes who participated in the pilot study were not recruited to be part of the study sample. 3.6 Data Analysis For the demographic survey descriptive statistics (e.g., means, frequencies) were calculated for Phase I data collection. Grounded theory was used to provide the philosophical understanding and guidance of the interview protocols. The basic tradition within the grounded theory approach involves a specific mode of analysis in which the researcher  generates  or  “discovers”  a  theory  from  the  data  (Sparkes & Smith, 2014). The
 researcher
 generated abstract
 concepts from numerous manuscripts and created a theory on elite athletes retirement transition. To
 accomplish
 the objective of creating a theory, 
 Miles, Huberman, and Saldaña (2013) explained that the
 researcher
 needs
 to
 be
 flexible
 and
 open 
 to criticism
 while
 portraying
 appropriateness and
 authenticity throughout the research process. Following data collection, all recordings were transcribed which is an obvious first step in grounded theory data analysis process. For reliability and data quality, the researcher adopted a blind coding approach. The researcher and an independent academic with experience in qualitative research independently listened to all recordings of the interviews and read the transcripts several times. The blind method is part of a scientific method used as a quality control measure to prevent research outcomes from being influenced by outcomes from either the placebo effect or the observer bias (Creswell, 49 2012). Reading and listening to all audio recordings accords readers the opportunity to judge whether the phenomenon of interest has been illuminated from a particular perspective. Consistent with ground theory data analysis (Sparkes & Smith, 2014), transcribing data was followed by an intense line-by-line manual open coding using the participant’s  own  words  by  the  researcher and his independent colleague. She is a doctoral student in the kinesiology department with experience in qualitative research methods. During the open coding process, researchers consistently engaged in a comparison method. The concept of open coding and constant comparison is described as finding key phrases or words in documents and experimenting with meanings (Miles et al., 2013). This process accorded researchers the opportunity to ask specific questions such  as  ‘who  interacted  with  elite  athletes  in  their  athletic  careers?’  ‘Under  what   circumstances  did  they  interact  with  athletes?,  ‘how  did  retired  elite  athletes    and   entourage  members  experience  the  interaction?,  and  “when  did that interaction take place in  athletes  careers?’.  Consistent  with  the  (Sparkes & Smith, 2014), the researcher remained open minded throughout the data analysis process. Open coding was followed by axial
 coding
 , where the researcher created subcategories
 and related them to main categories and specified properties
 and
 dimensions of a category (Sparkes & Smith, 2014). The last stage of data analysis was 
 selective
 coding. The researcher linked all categories and sub-categories to the core category in order to create a story of theoretical propositions. 50 3.7 Trustworthiness of the Data The researcher made efforts to ensure that data reduction and analysis were rigorous, authentic and trustworthy. For reliability and data quality, the researcher adopted a blind coding approach. The researcher and an independent academic with experience in qualitative research independently listened to all recordings of the interviews and read the transcripts several times. The blind method is part of a scientific method used as a quality control measure to prevent research outcomes from being influenced by outcomes from either the placebo effect or the observer bias (Creswell, 2012).  The  role  of  an  external  reviewer  is  also  to  “keep  the  researcher  honest,”  by  asking   difficult questions about methods, meanings, and interpretations (Creswell, 2012) of data. Reviewer and researcher analysis were compared, and discussed during a three-hour meeting. Consensus regarding core themes was achieved. 51 Chapter 4: RESULTS and SPECIFIC DISCUSSION The primary objective of this dissertation was to investigate elite athletes retirement transition experiences including its psychological impacts and post-sport career adaptation in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa and Zimbabwe. The secondary objective was to investigate the role played by the entourage on  elite  athletes’  retirement   transition. Lastly, this dissertation made cross-national comparison looking specifically at sport budgets, population size and sport organizational structure. This chapter begins with a brief profile of each athlete participant including his or her retirement transition experience. A demographic table providing more detailed information on athlete participants in this dissertation follows the profiles. This chapter concludes with a detailed explanation of the main concepts discovered and subcategories in this dissertation. Results are presented consistent with primary and secondary objectives of this dissertation and specific discussions are made in the context of Southern African populations and models used in this dissertation. Pseudonym names have been assigned to all athletes and their entourages to protect the participants in this study. Additionally, pseudonym names have not been associated with specific countries because of potential identification of the participant. When it was relevant to describe the country of a participant, a number was used to refer to the participant. 4.1 Research Participants Brief Profiles (Athletes) Mod started gymnastics at the age of 8. He then went on to represent (country name) at the world championships, commonwealth games and world university games. His coach, parents and extended family members provided him with the social support he 52 needed in his career in sport. Mod did not complete university, with an attempt to focus on gymnastics but involuntarily retired around the same time he left university at the age of 22. He was married and self-employed during data collection of this study. Thato competed in the flyweight Boxing category at the (city) Summer Olympic games. He started boxing at senior secondary school after playing other sports that included volleyball, track, and tennis. Thato had a brother who was also a boxer and a great inspiration to him. Thato won a silver medal at the (city) Commonwealth games. Thato is currently a teacher and he is actively involved in sport development in (country name). Teachers and his teammates provided support at the beginning of his career. His job and family played a crucial role in his retirement transition. Thato had a smooth transition because he had a job during his retirement transition Ellis started boxing by accident at the age of 16. He joined a workout group with the motive to manage his weight and ended up competing at the (city) Summer Olympic games. Before joining boxing, the 35 year old played Badminton. The 35-year-old former (country name) Olympic boxer got support from his club, teammates, and family during his athletic career. Ellis mentioned consistently in the interview that teachers were crucial his development in the boxing career. He voluntarily retired to pursue his new career and also work as a coach for young developing boxers. Ellis shared with the researcher that he had a smooth retirement transition because he had a job upon retirement. Trice represented (country name) at the (city) Olympic games and other major world championships such as International Associations of Athletics Federations (IAAF) world championships, commonwealth games and world university games in 100 and 53 200m. He started participating in his sport at the age of 10. His coach/teacher and his parents provided him with support at the beginning of his career. The federation provided him with financial support during his elite career in sport. Trice retired at the age of 28 to focus on his teaching job as well as spend time with his family. He consistently mentioned during the interview that even though he missed his sport, he had a smooth retirement transition. He also mentioned that retirement accorded him more time with his family. Daniel is a retired middle distance runner who represented (country) at the (city) Olympic games and other major tournaments. The 36 year old former middle distance runner was recruited by a teacher whom they have had a father-son relationship with since then. His former teacher becomes a crucial mentor both in sport and outside sport. Daniel had to go back to school after retirement and is currently a teacher and lives with his wife. Daniel involuntarily retired from competitive sport and he was quick to mention during the interview process that he was not ready for retirement. His wife played a crucial role is his elite career as well as during retirement transition. One of the factors that  played  a  pivotal  role  in  Daniel’s  transition  was  studying after competitive sport. Joe is a retired long distance runner who represented (country name) at the (city) Olympic games. One of his major achievements includes being ranked fourth in world cross-country rankings. Joe started his athletic career as a high school student competing for his school. A university official who spotted him competing in track races at the age of 18 recruited him to train under his guidance. Even though his family was not forthcoming in supporting him at the beginning of his career in sport,  Joe’s  family  played   54 a crucial role in his elite athletic career and retirement transition. Entourage members who  were  profound  in  Joe’s  athletic  career  include  the  university  official  who  recruited   him, his teachers and his wife. The university official did not only train Joe, he provided him with meals, training shoes and other needs that Joe had before he had a job. During Joe’s  elite  career  and  retirement  transition,  his  wife  played  a  crucial  role  providing  him   with social support. Joe retired involuntarily due to a career ending injury. Mmoloki is a retired (country name) sprinter and Olympian who started track at 19 years of age in senior secondary school. One of his major achievements includes competing at the (city) Summer Olympic games, winning a silver medal at the (city) world in-door games and a gold medal at the All Africa games. The 34 year old had a career ending injury a few months before the (city) Olympic games. His peers, teachers and siblings provided support during his career in sport. His retirement transition was not planned hence he lacked employment and had other related challenges. He strongly believes that God provided solace during his retirement transition. Bill is a retired (country name) sprinter who competed at the (city) Olympic games and made the final in 100m at the (city) Olympic games. He also represented (country name) at several world championships. When Bill was 6, he started playing different sports because it was required at his school. He specialized in athletics when he got to high school and college. He went to college in the United States where he competed at several championships. People and organizations that played a crucial role in his athletic career include his parents, coach and the federation. Even though Bill had a career ending injury, he was ready for retirement. He had planned for retirement by going to graduate school and starting a real-estate business. Some of his worries during 55 retirement transition included the uncertainty of whether he had fully planned for his retirement  from  elite  sport  or  not.  Bill’s  spouse  played  a  crucial  role  in  providing  him   with social support during retirement transition. Nick is a retired triathlete who represented (country name) at the (city) and (city) Olympic games. His parents taught him how to swim at the age of six. Nick was also competing in school cross-country races around the same age. His friend invited him to a swimming meet and he brought his bike with him, to put the running, swimming and bike together.  At  the  age  of  18,  Nick  specialized  in  triathlon  and  never  looked  back.  Nick’s   parents and his siblings played a crucial role in his athlete development by providing financial and social support that Nick needed throughout his athletic career. Other entourage members who played a crucial role in his athletic career include the federation and  his  wife.  Nick’s  wife  was  instrumental  in  providing  social  support  during  his   retirement transition. Nick voluntarily retired at the age of 30. He was employed and satisfied with his retirement transition. Anne represented (country name) at the (city) Olympic games in rowing singles. She retired after the Olympics games at the age of 36. Other major highlights in her athletic career include placing fifth place at the world junior championships. Anne credits her parents in supporting her athletic career from as early as six years old when she started participating in rowing. Entourage members who played a supporting role in her athletic career include friends, teachers, coach, siblings, extended family and the federation. Even though Anne was not ready and did not prepare for retirement, she moved into a new career upon retirement. 56 David is a 30-year-old (country name) retired middle distance runner. He won a silver medal in 800m at the (city) Olympic games, (city) Commonwealth games, and the (city) world championships. Even though his parents provided social support, they were not fully  involved  in  his  athletic  career.  People  who  played  a  crucial  role  in  David’s   career in sport include his senior secondary school teacher/ coach and his coach at elite stage. David was recruited at the age of 15 to compete for his senior secondary school and joined professional sport after his senior secondary school. He involuntarily retired from elite sport at the age of 29 due to an injury. Brad is a 31 year-old retired (country name) track cyclist. He represented (country name) at the (city) Olympics. Before specializing in his sport, he played football (soccer) at university level. People who played a crucial role in his career in sport include his parents and his sister. He retired after the Olympics games. Brad planned his retired and was happy with his retirement transition. Brad shared with the researcher that he was ready to focus on other aspects of his life when he retired from competitive sport. Helder is a retired (country name) rower and Olympic medalist. Helder won a bronze medal at the (city) Olympics in the coxless pair with his partner. He started rowing at the age of seven and his parents and teachers were crucial at the beginning of his athletic career and his coaches were more profound at the elite stage of his career in rowing. Helder graduated from the university when he was at the peak of his career in sport. He shared with the researcher that even though he missed his sport, he had a smooth retirement transition. Missy is a 32-year-old retired field hockey player. She was a member of the (country name) squad that represented (country name) at the (city) Olympics. Other 57 major achieves include competing for (country name) at several world championships. Even though Missy had support from her coaches and teachers, she considers her parents to have been behind her success in field hockey throughout her career. She did not complete university and she is currently employed. She retired involuntarily from competitive sport. Julie is a 38-year-old retired former (country name) field hockey player. Julie started playing field hockey at the age if 12 at her primary school and went on to represent (country) at various international competitions including the (city) Olympic games. She also represented (country name) at the Commonwealth games and the world cup. Even though field hockey was introduced to Julie in school, her parents played a crucial role in supporting her socially and financially until her retirement at the age of 29. Julie retired due to a career ending injury and tried to return to sport but eventually retired. Even though she was disappointed for deselection after her injury, she moved on in her new career in marketing. Jocy is a 39-year-old retired (country name) swimmer. Her parents taught her how to swim at the age of six. Jocy participated in several other major world games including two Olympic games. Her parents supported her financially and socially to the point she retired at the age of 22. She voluntarily retired to focus on her studies and start a family. She had a smooth retirement transition and is happy to have made a decision to retire from competitive sport. Thabo is a swimmer who represented (country name) at the (city) Olympic games. She started swimming at the age of 10 and retired 2 years after the Beijing Olympic games. Before she specialized in swimming at the age of 14, she took part in 58 other sports including track. Thabo was introduced to swimming by her parents and started competing in primary school swimming galas to the point of winning a national championship and competing at world swimming championships and the Olympics. People who were most profound in her athletic career include her family, coach, peers and husband. When Thabo learned that she had qualified for the Olympic games, she chose to withdraw her university registration to focus on training for the Olympic games. She voluntarily retired to start her swimming school and also give back to her parents after many years of support. Table 1 presents general demographic data on athletes that participated in the study and some of the major and minor variables observed in this dissertation. A presentation of the primary and secondary objective results is presented following Table 1. 59 Table 1: Demographic Data and Themes Athle te Gend er Marital Status Sport Dual career Jocy F Married Swimming Yes (university) Julie F Single F-Hockey Helde r Brad M Married M Anne Retirement type Prepare for ret? Voluntary Think of ret (when senior athlete) Yes Yes Ready for ret? Yes Involuntary No Yes No Rowing Yes (university + part-time work) Yes (university) Voluntary No No No Single Biking Yes (university) Voluntary - Yes Yes F Single Rowing Yes (university) Involuntary No No No Nick M Married Triathlon Voluntary Yes Yes Yes Bill M Married Athletics Yes (university and part-time work) Yes (university) Involuntary Yes Yes Yes Joe M Married Cross country Involuntary No Yes Yes Trice M Married Athletics Yes (full-time work) Yes (university) Voluntary No No No Ellis M Single Boxing Yes (university) Voluntary Yes Yes Yes Thato M Married Boxing Yes (university) Voluntary Yes Yes Yes Mod M Married Gymnastics No Involuntary No No No Thabo F Married Swimming No Voluntary No - No Missy F Single F-hockey No Involuntary No No No David M Divorced Athletics No Involuntary No No No Mmol oki Danie l M Single Athletics No Involuntary No No No M Married Athletics No Involuntary No No No 60 Education Ret age University degree Graduate school University degree University degree University degree University degree 22 Graduate School Secondary School University degree University degree University degree Did not complete university Withdrew university registration Did not complete university Secondary school Secondary school Diploma (after elite sport) 31 29 36 36 30 36 28 28 28 22 23 28 35 29 33 4.2 Results by Primary Objectives The primary objective of this dissertation was to investigate elite athletes’ retirement transition experiences, including its psychological impacts, and post-sport career adaptation. A sub-objective was to examine the coping strategies used by retired elite athletes during retirement transition. The study observed three major (see Table 1) themes (type of retirement, dual-career, and challenges) as  crucial  in  elite  athletes’   retirement transition and post-sport career. The first major theme of type of retirement was  derived  from  interviews  with  athletes’  and  their  entourages’  to  explain  athletes’   experiences during retirement transition and post sport career adaptation. Sub-themes observed under type of retirement were voluntary and involuntary retirement. Elite athlete experiences during retirement transition varied by type of retirement and circumstances surrounding retirement and post-sport career. The second major theme observed in the study was dual-career. Athletes and their entourages shared with the researcher during the interview process that finding the balance between school and sport was primary in preparing for a post-sport career transition. It was also clear during data analysis that, dual career significantly influenced athletes’ retirement transition and postsport career. For example, as presented in Table 1, a total of 10 athletes managed to balance school and sport in order to have another career outside sport hence positive postsport career transition. Other  crucial  factors  that  influenced  athletes’  experiences  include  the  availability   of support during retirement, preparing for retirement as well as being ready for retirement were crucial in athletes’ experiences in retirement transition. Sub-themes 61 observed under the major theme dual-career were graduating from university, full-time job  during  one’s  career in sport, and part-time  job  during  one’s  career  in  sport. The last major theme observed in the primary objective was challenges. It was clear from retired athletes and their entourages during the interview process that athletes experienced challenges during their career in sport as well as during retirement. Some of the challenges shared by athletes and their entourages include lack of financial resources to maintaining an elite sport career and support during retirement transition. Sub-themes observed under the major theme of challenges were lack of financial resources, trained coaches, facilities, and trained medical personnel. Each of these major themes and subthemes will be discussed in detail below. 4.2.1 Major Theme # 1: Type of Retirement from Sport. It was clear across the three phases of data collection that the impetus of sport retirement transition is a function of two primary factors: voluntary retirement (making a decision to voluntarily retire) and involuntary retirement (forced by circumstances to retire). Consistent with sport psychology literature (Lavallee & Wylleman, 2000; Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994) on retirement transition, reasons for involuntary retirement shared by athletes and their entourages include injury, deselection from the team, and failing to qualify for the games. Involuntary retirees experiences psychological distress of felling stressed, devastated and in some cases, isolated. Athletes who voluntarily retired from sport shared with the researcher that they had planned and knew when they will retire. Data analysis showed that voluntary retirees used events such as major games to mark their retirement from competitive sport. For example, athletes would make a decision that they will retire after their next Olympic games. Reasons for voluntary retirement shared by athletes include 62 focus on studies, start a family, and career change. Even though voluntary retirees missed the sport and had to navigate life without competing in their favorite sport, they moved on their new career. Data analysis also showed that voluntary retirees had thought of retirement when they were senior athletes. Participant # 16 from Namibia shared with the researcher that even though she retired after the (date, city) Olympic games, she had been planning and thinking of her retirement. I  had  made  up  my  mind  even  long  before  the  Olympics.  I  knew  I  couldn’t   combine both my studies and my sport to the extent that I would want to. I was happy about my decision and looking back I still am happy about my decision. It was clear in the data analysis that voluntary retirees were “switching” from competitive sport to join a new career. Participant #16 consciously made a decision to end her career in sport because of the conflict between school and sport. She also shared with the researcher that even though her new career did not immediately replace her passion for sport, she had something meaningful to look forward to. Similar to participant #   16’s   comments, other athletes retired from competition to a new job. These athletes used words   such   as   “smooth”,     “automatic”   or   “transfer”   to   refer   to   the   ending   of   their   competitive sport and transition to a new career. Participant #3 from Botswana voluntarily retired to start a career in teaching. I must say that mine was actually automatic transition because I was a student when I was (sport). That meant that when I finished schooling, I started working. I was concentrating on my teaching career. Being a retired athlete did not frustrate me because sport was not paying us much. We were not benefiting financially so retirement did not strain me in any way and I didn’t  need  to  prepare  anything  special  for  retirement. 63 Participant #3 makes reference to the fact that he did not have significant financial benefit from (sport) and as a result, he did not feel any financial loss from quitting competitive (sport). Nonrevenue sports such as boxing, swimming, and hockey did not earn athletes significant amounts of money except in cases where the team had a sponsor or they were exceptionally talented to have a sponsor on their own. The commitments to reach and stay at the top of elite sport require elite athletes and those around them to invest at different levels (e.g., physical, social, financial) during a long period of time (Baker et al., 2003). At least three athletes (2-Botswana 1-Zimbabwe) shared with the researcher during the interview process that they chose to retire because of lack of financial support to continue with their sport. All athletes were asked the same question on circumstances surrounding their retirement and shared their thoughts and experiences on retirement. Even though circumstances of financial support led to their retirement, these athletes made a conscious decision to retire from competitive sport. These athletes also used major events such as the Olympic games and or world championships to mark their retirement from elite sport. Participant # 13 from Botswana shared with the researcher that even though he was ranked 8th in the world, he did not have enough support to prepare for international games and decided to retire and focus on developing young athletes. I felt I was not getting enough support to achieve what I wanted to do. I was one of great (sport) in Botswana, ranked 8 in the world. I needed more international exposure. For example, to take part in competition such as the Olympics and the World Cup, you have to go for a few months to prepare for the competition but in Botswana you have to go direct to that competition. I was also looking at my knowledge of (sport) that if I retire, I can assist our senior national team in any way. 64 Participant # 13 is one of the athletes from Botswana who successfully completed university studies and voluntarily retired from competitive sport. It was clear during the interview that if participant # 13 had financial resources to continue, he could have continued with the sport. Wylleman and Lavallee (2004) affirm that elite athletes do not only strive to reach the top but also to remain at the top elite level in competitive sport. In addition to lack of support, participant # 13 shares that he was also looking at giving back the knowledge he acquired through his sport over the years. The sentiment of giving back to the nation and or other young athletes was consistent across at least 6 athletes expressing a sense of patriotism and love for their country. During the data collection of the project, participant # 13 worked with (sport) development teams at junior and senior level. He shared with the researcher that he was happy with his retirement transition experiences. Consistent with participant  #  13’s  statement about lack of support, participant # 2 from Botswana shared that she did not enjoy playing her sport anymore because of lack of support and also decided to retire from competitive sport. I   got   to   a   point   where   I   wasn’t   enjoying   it.   Like   I   told   you, I   wasn’t   getting   any   financial support from anyone but my parents. I had enough of that and I wanted to start giving back to them. I was an adult now and they had to continue to pay for my  studies,  and  coaching.  It  just  didn’t  feel  like  it  was  fair.  So  a  lot  of  my  decision   was based on no funding. As presented earlier in this chapter, it is important for athletes to prepare for a post-sport career and also plan for retirement. Data analysis across the three phases indicated that a small number of athletes (n=8) had prepared for retirement. Athletes shared with the researcher that savings, buying assets (particularly a house) and graduating from university were their primary approach to preparing for retirement. A distribution of 65 athletes’  preparation  for  retirement  by country is presented in Table 2 show that only two athletes from Botswana though of retirement when they were senior athletes. Table 2: Athletes Retirement Planning by Country Country N Think of retirement at senior stage Prepared for Retirement Planned for retirement Botswana Zimbabwe South Africa Namibia 7 4 4 2 2 3 1 2 2 2 0 2 2 2 0 2 Zimbabwe had the highest number of athletes who planned for retirement. None of the athletes from South Africa thought of retirement in their senior stage. It is not surprising for elite athletes not to think of retirement in their careers in elite sport. The conflict between motivation for success in sport and preparation for a post-sport career (or retirement) is evident throughout athletes’ careers in sport. It is important for athletes to focus and have high motivation to achieve significant success (e.g. winning an Olympic medal) in sport. Some entourage members (i.e., coaches) may influence athletes to exclusively focus in sport (Blinde & Greendorfer, 1985) even at the expense of education. Athletes’ focus on other factors of life (e.g., education) may be viewed as distraction from success in sport. Past research (Brewer et al, 1993) affirms that high athletic identity and an exclusive focus in sport may force athletes to neglect other aspects of life in order to fulfill the athlete role. The conflict between high motivation for success in sport and a focus on planning for retirement may also force athletes to sacrifice spending time with family and friends, and other important aspects of their life such as proper career planning, which may be detrimental in athletes retirement transition. It is 66 therefore important for educators, federations and sport programs to consider developing more flexible programming for gifted athletes without compromising the time and quality requirements as established by education departments in each country. Consistent with sport psychology literature (Alfermann et al., 2004) on retirement transition, psychological impact of involuntary retirement included sense of vulnerability, panic, nervousness, and lack of control during retirement transition. In some cases, some athletes (n=4) presented a sense of feeling denial of the circumstances that they had to retire from competitive sport. All involuntary retirees showed similar experiences regardless of country of origin. These athletes made an attempt to return to elite sport but could not continue for a period of not more than a single season. Participant # 12 from South Africa shared psychological experiences of not making the team after working hard to return to playing. I was devastated. I was desperate to make the team, I was training really hard. I thought I made a good enough recovery to be at the level that I needed to be to play. But the coaches in the selection thought differently. I was in a bad place. Similar to participant  #  12’s  experiences,  participant # 6 from Botswana shared with the researcher that he was more concerned about returning to athletics than planning retirement transition when asked about circumstances surrounding his retirement and services available for athletes who retire from competitive sport. No, when you retire they do not give you anything, not even money. For me I never really fought on the side of money. I was fighting to return. I was hopeful that I will come back to athletics. 67 It was clear during the interview process that Participant # 6 wanted to continue competing and was not ready for retirement. His retirement was due to a career ending injury. The quotes presented above demonstrate typical examples of athletes who retired involuntarily and worked hard in anticipation that they return to competing. Even though all athletes shared sentiments of worry, disappointment and missing their sport, it was clear during the data analysis process that involuntary retires without job a or university education (n=6) were more concerned about source of income to support their families. Consistent with statements shared by participant #6 (athlete from Botswana), there were no services available specific to athletes who retired from competitive sport in all the four countries except an International Olympic Committee career-planning program in South Africa. However, even though a South Africa federation official shared that the program had recently been implemented, athletes did not have much information on the program. Participant # 10 from Zimbabwe explained to the researcher that unavailability of retirement transition services was a problem in Zimbabwe. Participant # 10 also shared with the researcher how he prepared and coped with retirement transition. That’s  a  big problem in Zimbabwe. Most athletes  don’t  prepare  for  life  after   sport. A lot of them are unemployed and struggle with their lives despite the fact that they did very well in sport. For me, I can say I was fortunate because I prepared myself for life after sport. I had passed my high school exam and I have a good job. During my athletic career, I took sport management courses. Most  of  my  colleagues  in  sport  didn’t  have  basic  education.  They  cannot  find   jobs or do sport courses because they do not have basic  education.  So  that’s   the  major  problem  with  other  athletes.  But  for  me,  I  don’t  have  a  problem.  I’m   comfortable with what I have. Completing secondary school accorded athletes the opportunity to further their studies during and in post-sport career. Participant # 10 affirmed that, passing secondary school 68 exams accorded him the opportunity to take advantage of short sport management courses that are offered by local and international sports federations to further his studies. Completing university education did not only accord athletes the opportunity to further their studies but also to seek employment in a variety of disciplines such as teaching, finance, and marketing depending on their university qualification. Completing secondary school and university positively facilitated athletes’ experiences, particularly in post-sport career adaptation. As indicated earlier, financial challenges during retirement transition were most evident in athletes (n=6) who did not complete college education and or source of income. Upon retirement, athletes realized that they needed another source of income because they heavily relied on appearance fees and allowances from competing internationally for their countries. Athletes used words such  as  “facing  life”  to  refer  to   their experiences in transition from competitive sport. Such experiences brought a sense worry, panic, and nervousness. Their immediate worry that athletes had was supporting their families financially. In some cases, athletes had to live with friends or family members because they did not have a place to live since they had lived abroad in their career in sport. Participant # 6 from Botswana retired after a career ending injury. He shared his experiences with the researcher after retirement. At that point when you retire, there are things that you face in life. You get challenges. You need to have a source of financial support. So what happened with me was that, I was just about to break through into making money.  I  can’t  say I was making enough to rely on yet. What I could do next was either look for a job or do some courses. 69 Consistent with participant # 6’s  comments, participant # 13 from South Africa shared similar comments with the researcher during the interview process that his immediate worry after retirement was supporting his family. My immediate worry was the ability to support my two boys. When you're (sport) you're make money and paying your bills. But when you stop, there's nothing that's coming. You're used to the lifestyle that money is coming in and out but when you retire, it's only going out. My worry was if I was able to get a good job and to be able to get back to the South African society. In addition to lack of financial resources, one of involuntary retirees felt isolated. Participant # 5 expressed a sense of isolation after his retirement from competitive sport. If you get injured today or you retire without anything nobody will even think of you or where you are. We will meet you at the bus rank (bus station) looking very old, tired and without anything. I had a similar situation but I was lucky to go back to school just before it happened to me. Returning to school and finding alternative sources of income are some of the strategies athletes used to cope with financial challenges during their retirement transition. Athletes also joined federations, became coaches, did public speaking (only in South Africa) and engaged in other sport related activities for income and to remain within sports circles. 4.2.2 Summary:Type of Retirement from Sport It was clear during the data analysis that athletes’ experiences upon retirement were more crucial in understanding their type of retirement and post-sport career. For example, all (n=6) athletes who did not complete university education experienced financial insecurities during retirement transition, regardless of their nationality. It is worth noting that South African athletes had support resources such as sponsors and or part-time jobs, which played a crucial role to prepare them for a post70 sport career in sport. These athletes were able to have post-sport careers emanate from their part-time employment when they were elite athletes. A further discussion of challenges that athletes face in their career in elite sport as well as during transition is presented in the next paragraphs. 4.2.3 Major Theme # 2 Elite Athletes’ Challenges. Athletes experienced a variety of challenges in their careers in sport. The most profound challenges that athletes faced include lack financial resources to compete at an elite level, lack of training facilities, lack of trained coaches, and lack of trained medical personnel. Athletes experienced most of these challenges in their senior stage and retirement transition. Athletes and their entourage members explained to the researcher that in some cases, they did not have access to information, which resulted in more challenges. A spouse of an athlete from Zimbabwe summarized some of the challenges that her husband and other elite athletes from developing athletes experienced during their career in sport. I think when you come from an underdeveloped country you have a lot of other challenges that come your way and I think, never mind financially, its logistically, its lack of internet, its not being able to communicate, its hearing about things at the last minute. For example at the Olympics, no one communicated the rule with regard to the kits logs until last minute. (Athlete name) literally was with (coach name) taping over his logos and changing his bike and covering logos with tape. You know those kind of rules   weren’t   communicated   effectively   to   (athlete   name).   First   world   countries  athletes  don’t  have  to  deal  with  these  challenges,  they  come  with   the best equipment, and the best bikes. I mean, there were people in (city name) who had to weight their bikes because their bikes were too lite. And now you have a little third world (country name) arriving and his bike weighs  double  anyone  else’s  bike. Data analysis showed that even though athletes from South Africa experienced financial challenges, they had local sponsors to give them financial support and part-time jobs. Athletes from Botswana, Namibia and Zimbabwe did not have local sponsors hence 71 relied primarily on their government and international sponsors. Participant # 11 from Zimbabwe also affirmed that financial challenges were profound in his elite career in sport. To address financial challenges, Participant # 11 explained to the researcher that he raised money to support his (year) Olympic games qualification tour. The last 2 to 3 months trying to qualify for (city) were really hard for me from all points. I was always trying to fight always trying to raise money to get to races. I got it but I had to fight really hard to get it and it took a lot of energy. Lack of training equipment and other resources posed a lot of challenges for athletes from Botswana,  Namibia  and  Zimbabwe.  Participant  #  16’s  coach  from  Namibia  explained  to   the researcher that they have a 25m-heated pool. However, when participants# 16 was an elite athlete, they did not have a heated pools for swimming in winter. In order to train in winter, they focused on endurance, weight lifting, and some mental exercises. The coach also shared with the researcher that in some cases, they used wood burning stove to heat their swimming pool. We did a more all rounded training with a lot of endurance training, and weight lifting. To avoid being bored in the longer sense, I would give them quizzes or riddles to solve. Sometimes we would heat a pool with word-burning stove, what we call a donkey. It should be noted that a lot of athletes from Botswana, Namibia Zimbabwe consistently mentioned that they trained in South Africa and industrialized nations (i.e., England, Germany and Norway). Access to world-class sport facilities and medical treatment are some of the reasons shared by athletes for training abroad. Major races that athletes took part in took place mostly in Europe. Competing in Europe also created some challenges for athletes who were in school while competing in major world competitions such as the 72 Olympics. The next chapter will discuss athletes’ experiences and the importance of balancing a career in and outside of sport. 4.2.4 Major Theme # 3: Balancing Sport and Other Careers. The researcher learned that even though a variety of factors facilitated retirement transition, education, part-time and or full-time job, and engaging in other activities played a crucial role in facilitating retirement transition. Completing secondary school accorded athletes the opportunity to further their studies during their career in sport as well as in post-sport career. Completing university education did not only accord athletes the opportunity to further their studies but also to seek employment in a variety of disciplines such as teaching, finance, and marketing depending on their university degrees. Athletes who were employed part-time or full time were only observed in South Africa and Zimbabwe (an athlete from Zimbabwe living in South Africa). Athletes who had part-time jobs suggested that it was a great way to learn skills that were useful in their post-sport career and also to give them an opportunity to be employed full time upon retirement from competitive sport. Athletes did not only share the benefits of dual career but they were also visible in athletes who had jobs and/or completed higher education. These athletes were quick to mention to the researcher that they were teachers and/or worked in other fields of their post-sport career. Participant # 12 from South Africa shared with the researcher that she had a job during her career in elite sports. I had a job, which was kind of in the marketing field. The company I worked for understood my needs as an elite athlete. They hired me fulltime and also gave me extra time off to train in the morning and at night, which did not affect my leave time. I was paid most of the time at competitions. 73 As presented in Table 1, at least athletes (n=10) successfully completed a university degree while competing in elite sport at the same time. Even though the study did not look  into  the  type  of  jobs  and  athletes’  income,  all  retired  athletes  (n=17) were employed during the data collection of the project. It is therefore important for future research to focus on the type of jobs that retired athletes do. Competing at the elite level and working part-time jobs accorded athletes unique skills and experiences that they used in their postsport career. In South Africa, some athletes had an arrangement of part-time work with their sponsors. These athletes were able to use such skills efficiently and their social network as resources for a post-sport  career.  An  athlete’s  employer/sponsor  from   Zimbabwe (they lived in South Africa) shared with the researcher that they discussed what was best for the athlete when he retired from competitive sport. So (name) had been working for us part time since 2009. We also supported him financially in terms of some of the events he needed to go to last year over the salary we gave him. So when he was coming up to his retirement, we  sat  down  and  he  said  “look  I'm  retiring”  and  we  had  a  very  open  dialogue   on what his career aspirations were. I think there was a lot of support just like when anyone is coming to work for you full time and the career conversations and so on. Yea, it was very involved between us. The  sponsor/employer’s  company  was  based  in  South  Africa  but  sponsored  a   Zimbabwean athlete based in South Africa. Athletes who worked part-time in their elite sport mentioned to the researcher that the skills learnt were useful in their post-sport career and it was not challenging to get such part-time jobs in sport industry companies. Participant # 12 shared her experience of working part-time while she was an elite athlete. I guess sport people like to work with other sport people. They know the 74 dedication and commitment that it takes to be an elite athlete and they can relate that back to their work at their job. In marketing my field is relatable to sport and some people like to hire those that know what it takes to be an athlete and relate that to their job. It was clear during the interview with Participant # 12 that she learned to transfer her sport-learned skills, such as commitment and determination, to her part-time job in marketing. The ability for athletes to transfer sport-learned skills is crucial for post-sport career adaptation. Athletes who are able to transfer their skills are more likely to adapt to their post-sport career faster and be able to use sport-learned skills such as teamwork, resiliency, and positive thinking which are taught in sports. Even though it was clear that balancing school and sport facilitated retirement transition, athletes experienced a lot of challenges balancing school and sport. Athletes (n=10) who successfully completed a university degree during their elite career in sport also shared challenges they came across in finding the balance between school and sport. Data analysis indicated that it required patience, resiliency, time management skills and social support to successfully balance school and sport. In some cases, athletes made a conscious decision with their parents to withdraw from university in order to train for the Olympics but in other cases, athletes were dropped from university by their respective institutions. Participant #2, an Olympian from Botswana had moved to study overseas when she learned that she had qualified for the Olympics and decided to focus on training for the Olympic games instead of starting her university studies. Participant #2 explained to the researcher the decision she made. I actually had moved to the UK. My (extended family member) lives there and I moved there with them to go study. I registered to study psychology, but about four months before I started I got a call that I had qualified for the Olympics. I had to talk to my parents and they told me that it was 75 entirely up to me but if it were them, they would definitely go to the Olympics   and   not   give   up   an   opportunity   like   that.   That’s   where   I   am   today. Upon  Participant  #  2’s  retirement  from  competitive  sport, she completed a swimmingcoaching course in the United States funded by her parents. Table 3 shows athletes highest academic qualification during data collection by country. Table 3: Athletes’ highest Academic Qualification Country Botswana Zimbabwe South Africa Namibia N 7 4 4 2 Athletes highest academic qualification Senior secondary Diploma University degree school 3 1 3 1 2 2 1 0 2 Graduate degree 1 1 In a similar case, the university dropped participant # 15 from South Africa after 6 years. The  quote  below  is  Participant  #  15’s  response  from  the  researcher  when  she  was  asked   about her experience when she was at the university while competing in elite sport. Ooh f*** well, we are all growing and learning how to make sports more professional.   I   was   there   for   six   years   and   I   didn’t   qualify   or   I   still   don’t   have a degree. I will never blame anyone because I was an adult and I made my decisions, hockey was my thing, my number one thing and its difficult to play for the national team and get a degree. I would miss lectures because of training. It came a time where it was almost pointless for me to be in a lecture because I would go in to the Gym in the morning from six to seven, then go to lectures before lunch-time. I would then go for a 30 to 40 minute run. Now I am tired. I go to lectures in the afternoon, then in the evening  I  have  a  skill  session  and  that’s  my  day.    “You  are  in  class,  and  its   just showing up. Your mind is everywhere and you are literally napping in your  mind”.   76 Participant # 15 also made suggestion on the best possible way to help students who compete internationally for their countries to cope with balancing school and sport. They should say you are here to do (sport), your degree takes three years but from history, you will take five or six years. No way I would juggle that, its almost impossible. Maybe just take half of each semester load then you can cope. No one tells you that when you apply for varsity and when they   give   you   a   full   scholarship.   No   one   tells   you   that   it’s   going   to   be   difficult  and  they  help  you  where  they  can  like  missing  class  and  you  can’t   substitute  that.  You  can’t  substitute  for  time  in  class. Participant # 11, an Olympian from Zimbabwe shared his experiences of competing internationally. He goes further to share his concerns regarding support from his university in balancing school and sport. So basically growing up through senior secondary school, I was fortunate enough that I went to two world championships. With that, then university got  in  the  way  and  I  didn’t  think  I  would  really  be  continuing  with  the  sport   that   much.   I   went   to   (university   name),   which   wasn’t   really   renowned   for   sports such as (sport). It was in the end of my second year at university that I really wanted to give it a go again. Participant #6 from Botswana shared that he had a choice and did not consider balancing school and sport to be viable at the time because he was doing well in sport as early senior secondary school. There was a choice. I could have maybe tried to focus more on academics and try to balance it with athletics. I did not consider it to be a viable option at that time. Maybe I should go back to re-write some of the subjects so that I can be admitted to a college or university. Participant  #  6’s  comments  are  consist  with  research  (Blinde & Greendorfer, 1985) that suggests that athletes may focus on sport at the expense of being a student because the public clamors for a winner and success. 77 Challenges of navigating elite sport and higher education were also shared by  coaches  and  other  entourage  members.  Participant  #6  and  Participant  #  5’s  coach  from   Botswana shared with the researcher that the system or structure of sport makes it difficult for students to balance school and sport. The coach also shared that coaches and parents should encourage athletes to find balance between school and sport or else, athletes would choose sport over school. It is very difficult to balance school and sport especially in our system here. I think it is the role of parents and coaches to encourage athletes to balance school and sport otherwise the players would drop from school and go elite. Three athlete participants had enrolled in the university and one did not start while the university dropped the other two. What was most common in these athletes decision was that they both chose sport over their university studies. The role played by universities, coaches, and parents in supporting athletes through elite sport and higher education is crucial. Participant #3, a retired Botswana (sport) shared that the most challenging times of his career in sport were juggling sport and education. The athlete further shared that sport also provided an opportunity to refresh from schoolwork and come rejuvenated. The challenge with me would be juggling sport and education. It proved to be very difficult because sometimes I would miss classes and exams. I would miss out on a lot of content and when I come back, I have to really work hard to cover up. In a way, I would benefit because I would have refreshed and study well. That was a big challenge. Sometimes I would not attend international camps because I was a doing school work. But it did not stop me from working hard to achieving results. The university and my coach were very supportive. It is therefore very improtant for athetes to have career guidanve and academc support diring their career in sport and school. Athletes inability to balance school and sport may 78 pose some challenges leading to atheletes being dropped from university or choosing sport over education. 4.2.5 Summary: Balancing Sport and Other Careers The theme of dual career revealed that even though balancing sport with other career such as school and employment is a challenge to a lot of athletes, it is important in facilitating long–term post sport career transition and adaptation. Completing university education accorded athletes the opportunity to further their studies and also seek employment in a variety of disciplines such as teaching, finance, and marketing depending on their university degrees. 4.3 Results by Secondary Objectives The secondary objective of this dissertation was to establish the role of the entourage on elite athletes’   retirement   transition and also make cross-national comparisons, looking specifically at budgets, population size, and sport organizational structure. In addition, this section provides general results on factors that facilitate elite athletes’ involvement in sport observed in Southern Africa. Table 4 provides athletes and entourages that were interviewed in this dissertation. A sub-objective was to examine the availability of retirement transition for elite athletes in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa and Zimbabwe. 79 Table 4: Athletes and Entourage Members Interviewed Athlete Jocy Julie Missy Helder Brad David Anne Nick Bill Mmoloki Joe Daniel Gender F F F M M M F M M M M M Trice M Ellis M Thato M Mod M Thabo F Federation officials Total entourage members Marital status Married Single Single Married Single Divorced Single Married Married Single Married Married Sport Swimming F-Hockey F-hockey Rowing Biking Athletics Rowing Triathlon Athletics Athletics Cross country Athletics Married Single Married Married Married Botswana -3 Athletics Boxing Boxing Gymnastics Swimming Namibia-1 Entourage members interviewed Parent and coach Coach Parent and coach Parent Spouse Parent, spouse, coach and sponsor Coach Coach, spouse, and family focus group (father, mother, 3 siblings) Spouse Parent and coach Spouse, coach, and parent Spouse, parent and 2 coaches South Zimbabwe-1 Africa -1 35 80 4.3.1 Major theme # 4: Social and Financial Support. This dissertation observed that in addition to having university education, entourages played a crucial role in facilitating athletes’  retirement  transition.  Financial  and  social  support from family (i.e., spouse and parents) and other entourage members (i.e., coach and federations) played a crucial role in facilitative retirement from competitive sport. As presented in previous chapters, Athletes shared with the researcher that they did not have any retirement transition services from federations and or their respective governments. Research (Beer & Pretorius, 2011; Côté, 1999; Gould et al., 2006) on parental involvement and other members of the entourage suggests that different members of the entourage play different  roles  at  different  stages  in  athletes’  careers  in  sport. This dissertation (see Table 5 and 6) observed that parents and teachers play a crucial role in supporting athletes at the beginning of their careers while the federations and the coach were observed to play a profound role at senior and late stage in athletes careers. Table 5 presents  elite  athletes  entourage  profiles  across  the  four  stages  in  athletes’  careers.   Table 5: Athletes Entourage Profiles Age 11 Start Teacher Parents Siblings Ext family 14 Junior Coach Teacher Parents Federation 18 Senior Coach Federation Parents Friends 33 Retirement Family Coach Federation Friends Members of the entourage that were introduced for the first time in the literature particularly in Southern Africa include the role played by spouses, federations, schools 81 and extended family members. It is not surprising that schools play a crucial role at the beginning of athlete career in sport given sport programs in school across different African countries. The next paragraph and table (table 6) provides more details on the role of the entourage particularly school and parental involvement in the early years of athletes careers in sport and the role of spouses and coaches during retirement transition. Table 6: Summary of Athlete Stages and Raw Data Athlete Phases Start School M age 11 I took part in sports because there was sport at school My parents gave us the opportunity to play sport right from the start. Sport is a general requirement in Zimbabwean school School Junior Parents 14 Coach/Teacher Senior Federation 18 My parents were supporting me because I was also getting an education In terms of support, my high school coaches were the ones that used to push me. They provided the vehicle with which to develop They provided a good relationship with international sporting bodies Had a passionate athletics and swimming coach I got support especially from my coach Coach Retirement Family Federation Raw data 33 I had my family and my wife Probably my fiancée because she encouraged me a lot but sometimes she would  just  say,  “  go  ahead  and  get  a  job  and  start  working”.   They gave me a really great send off and felt being appreciated; it made me feel great about the transition and the position I was taking. Playing a variety of sports before specialization provides youth athletes with a wide base of movement skills before they specialize in the sport of their choice. School systems in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa and Zimbabwe provided athletes with the opportunity to play structured sport at the beginning of their careers in sport. Participant # 11, an athlete from Zimbabwe who was introduced to swimming buy his parents and had a lot of support from his parents explained to the researcher that the Zimbabwean school system 82 accorded him and others the opportunity to play a variety of sports before specializing in his sport of choice. Growing up in Zimbabwe school system, you go through a lot of sports. Some afternoons in winter you have to play rugby and hockey, which I did. I was also a competitive swimmer. I was a captain in both junior and senior school. I did cross-country running in junior school and I loved it. Even in senior school up until my third year in senior school I still played rugby and hockey. I stopped rugby and hockey because I was focusing more on (sport). Parental involvement is crucial in supporting athletes in their career in sport from the beginning to retirement. Participant # 16 from Namibia shared with the researcher that her parents gave her the freedom to make decisions on her practice sessions. Her parents did not force her to attend  practice  sessions  if  she  didn’t  want  to  attend.   They  were  always  there,  but  there  wasn’t  pressure  from  their  side  for  me  to   do  anything  I  did  not  like  or  didn’t  enjoy.  It  was  more  of  a  supporting   structure  than  anything  else.  If  I  didn’t  want  to  go  to  the  training  session   they  said,  “then  don’t  go,  stay at  home”.  But  I  went  anyways.  They   respected decisions of what I wanted to do. When we had training camps they made arrangements that we could be there. They were more in the background more than anything else, but for me it was an absolute foundation. Consistent with Participant #16 comments, Participant #2 from Botswana indicated that her parents introduced her to swimming and went further to share that her parents enrolled her to a club. Participant #2 also acknowledged that the school organized competitions that accorded her the opportunity to compete with other students. My family, I was taught swimming as a life skill at that age. At that age we did a few little competitions at school. It came around then that I actually had talent because I was winning races. At about ten years old my parents took  me  to  a  club  and  that’s  when  it  started.  Basically  it  was  my  parents  and   83 coach  that  really  got  me  involved  and  I  was  talented  and  I  shouldn’t  throw  it   away. Participant # 11 from Zimbabwe also shared with the researcher the role-played by his parents created a family environment that accorded him and his brother to play a variety of sports. It was definitely my parents. I was very fortunate to have my family. I have 2 brothers, my older brother played cricket, I did swimming and rugby, and my younger brother also did swimming and water polo. My parents were very passionate in making sport a part of our lives. So they did give us the means to do that. So growing up in Zimbabwe, it was definitely my parents who gave us the opportunity to do that, right from the start. In addition to parental and school support at the beginning of athletes careers, it was evident in the data analysis that close entourages such as parents, siblings, and spouses availed themselves to spend time with athletes during retirement transition. Entourages and athlete participants shared with the researcher during the interview process that in addition to financial and social support, engaging in multiple roles (having a life partner) and activities (continued active life style) and spending time with family kept athletes engaged in something meaningful. Spouses of retired athletes shared with the researcher that retirement from an elite sport was an opportunity for their life partners to focus their energy  on  their  relationship.  Participant  #  11’s  spouse  shared  her  experiences  and  ideas   on  the  role  she  played  in  her  husband’s  retirement  transition  as  well  as  providing  some   positive outcomes after retirement. Obviously  it’s  been  quite  a  change  but  I  think  it  helps  if  you’re  proactive  with   other  activities.  For  example,  now  we  can  go  to  the  gym  and  it’s  not  this  athlete   who runs 3 minutes a K and his wife who is running 5 and half minutes a K. Now we can do things together you can stay active in a different way. For example, (name) and I do a lot off road and obstacle courses so we race 84 together almost every weekend. He may do 18 K and ill do the 12 K but we go together and we do different things so we are still keeping active. So I think instead of putting all that energy into himself and his progress we now put that energy into our progress and us together. So I think that helps, we put a diary together  of  things  to  keep  us  active  which  is  fantastic  and  that’s  been  key  to  the   transition. Participant  #  5’s  spouse  also  shared  similar  sentiments  with  the  researcher  that  in  addition   to providing financial support the family, she provided social support to her husband during retirement transition. I had a job so I made sure that we had food all the time. What my son and I also did was to make him understand that the best thing he can do to “survive”  (deal  with  retirement)  is  to  focus  on  his  family  and  most   importantly start training our son; he was around seven years at the time of his (participant # 5) retirement. We also made him realize that there are a lot of young athletes he can help develop to the level he did. In addition to the role played by the entourage in providing social support, Participant # 11 from Zimbabwe shared with the researcher that even though there are no retirement transition services, he felt recognized and appreciated by his federation when they staged a send off ceremony in for his retirement. There   isn’t   really   any   support   for   anyone   who   retires,   but   the (federation name) really went out of their way to give me a really good send off in my final (sport). They awarded me with a gift of an awards function in my name. So they gave me a really great emotional thanks and an emotional send off. I also had a full time job that I could get into. I was working part time for (Company name) and it was a stepping-stone into something else. My fiancée and I already had a wedding planned for December. It was all these factors. Participant #11 provides evidence that even though there were no retirement transition services, recognitions from the federation, having a job, and a life factors were crucial in supporting his retirement transition. Table 7 presents the number of athletes who were 85 married, single and those that were divorced during data collection. Only six athletes were single and one divorced. Table 7: Athletes’ Marital status by Country Country Botswana South Africa Zimbabwe Namibia Total N 7 4 4 2 17 Married 5 1 3 1 10 Divorced/separated Single 2 1 2 1 1 1 6 It should be noted however that even though parents provided social support to elite athletes’  retirement  transition,  some  athletes  (n=8-Botswana-6, Zimbabwe- 1, and South Africa-1) shared with the researcher that their parents were less involved at the beginning of their careers in sport. When Participant #3 was asked about his parental involvement, he explained that his parents were not forth coming in supporting his career in sport particularly at the beginning. His parents were not against his participation in sport, but they were mostly concerned about his schoolwork. My   parents   didn’t   care   much   about   what   I   did   except   my   school.   They   saw   sport as part of playing. They were not against it, but they were not coming forward to provide some specific support towards sports. I will chat with my father  and  he  would  say,  “I  hear   you   fight   people  and   you  are  so  tiny.  They   will  kill  you.” Consistent   with   Participant   #3’s   experiences   with lack of parental involvement at the beginning of his career in sport, Participant #10 from Zimbabwe shared similar sentiments and made generalizations in Africa, parents are more concerned about school and fear that sport may temper with progress in school. 86 You know in Africa, our parents normally want you to concentrate in your schoolwork first and after that you can do sport. They think that sport is playing.  My  parents  thought  that  I  was  playing  and  I  wasn’t  concentrating   on my schoolwork. They were worried that maybe I was going to fail in school. It is important to note that for both Participant #3 and Participant 10, their parents may have considered sport as part of play not a profession that can be undertaken for a career. Parents confirmed during the interview process that their primary concern was for their children to get the education they need from school. Consistent  with  Participants  #3  and  10’s  comments,  past  research  (Chappell, 2004; Malete, 2006) in Southern Africa shows that Batswana (People of Botswana) and some cultures in Southern Africa may view sport as mainly play for fun and enjoyment. For example, in Setswana (language for Tswana speaking ethnic groups in Southern Africa), the term sport is loosely translated as tshameka, which means play that is not serious and that cannot be considered for anything serious. This may have an influence in the parents perception of playing sports as waste time and not engaging in something serious with their lives. In Ikalanga, (another language in Southern Africa) sport is also loosely translated as zana, which means playing and the word can be used to refer to someone who is not serious with whatever they are doing. It is worth noting that the use of such words implication may only be applicable in Southern Africa and may not make sense to other culture. The researcher used these examples to provide more context and understanding of parental involvement to athletes in Southern Africa. A federation official from Botswana affirmed that entourage involvement varies, but parents are the least  engaged  in  their  kids’  sport. 87 That's absolutely right, the level of engagement varies from the involvement of teachers, spouses to parents. I easily agree with them because their parents are the least engaged. Here in the (Federation name), we would like to see a change in that for greater parent involvement because in our view the greater parental involvement the better the athlete does. In cases where parents were not highly involved in supporting their children at the beginning of their careers, teachers played a crucial role in supporting athletes by providing them with resources to play sport even outside school. Participant # 3 from Botswana explained to the researcher that his teacher/coach supported him financially at the beginning of his career in sport. He shared with the researcher that his teacher/coach bought him his first ticket to Europe to compete in professional sport. The relationship that Participant # 5 had with his teacher/coach properly fits the description of a parentchild relationship, even though they are not biologically related. Teachers in several schools played a parental role once they identified a talented athlete with the potential to succeed  in  professional  sport.  Participant  #  5’s  teacher/coach  provided  him  with  sport   gear, running shoes and supplements as well as transport to competitions even those outside the school calendar. He bought me shoes. If you remember very well, I use to run barefooted. He introduced me to spikes, bought me trainers and supplements. There is nobody who can do that for you. He also drove me to competitions. Research (Carron, 1978; Forde, McMahon, Gronn, & Martin, 2013; Gilbert & Trudel, 2004) in sport psychology on coach-athletes relationship  indicate  that  coach’s  role  goes   beyond the technical and tactical instruction in the field. Coaches are considered parents and mentors to athletes. 88 4.3.2 Summary: Social and Financial Support It was clear across the three phases of data collection that different entourage members played different roles in athletes’ careers in sport. Parents and schools were crucial at the beginning of athletes’ careers in sport but federation and spouses were more profound at the end of athlete’s careers in sport. In addition to providing social support, spouses also provided financial support to athletes that did not have jobs during retirement. Spending time with family and engaging in a variety of activities were observed to also play a crucial role in facilitating retirement. There were no available retirement transitions services for retired athletes. 4.4 Comparisons Across Countires Even though there may be cultural similarities between South Africa, Namibia, Botswana and Zimbabwe, the South African economy, population size and infrastructural development gives South Africa an edge to compete with industrialized nations such as the United States, Germany and Russia. Even though the researcher was able to find the South  Africa  annual  sport  budget,  SASCOC  ‘s  budget  for  the  2016  Rio  de  Janeiro   Olympic games is estimated to about R400 million (about $37, 710, 912), which is by far less that Botswana, Namibia and Zimbabwe budgets. For example, Botswana National Sport Council Olympic games budget is small given that they send about four athletes on average to the Olympic games. Botswana National Sport Council 2013/2014 budget was P71, 158,990 ($810,469.26), which is smaller compared to the South Africa budget for the 2016 Olympic games. Botswana National Sports Council is responsible for reviewing and coordinating National Sports Association budgets and distributing the government grants to the 34 89 associations and Botswana National Olympic Committee. Even though the researcher could  not  find  sport  budgets  for  Namibia  and  Zimbabwe,  the  nations’  GDPs  indicate  that   they have lower gross income compared to Botswana and South Africa. As presented in chapter 1, The 2010 FIFA World Cup budget was R15 billion ($2bn) with R8.4 billion ($1.1bn) spent in building five new stadiums and upgrading existing facilities, while R6.4bn ($800m) was invested in public transport initiatives and supporting infrastructure (“S  Africa  unveils  World  Cup  budget,”  2006). South Africa was the first country in Southern Africa to have the capacity to host the football world cup. South Africa has the second largest economy in Africa while Botswana ranked 18th, Namibia in the 25th spot and lastly Zimbabwe ranked 31 (“Top  12  Largest  And  Strongest  African  Economies,”   n.d.). 4.5 Minor Themes by Primary and Secondary Objectives Minor themes observed in the study-included patriotism, entitlement, federation politics, and race related politics. Athletes shared with the researcher that, even though there were no services for retired athletes, it brought a sense of patriotism, pride, and love for   their   countries.   Athletes   used   words   such   as   “ambassador”   to   refer   to   representing   their countries at international competitions. Athletes and entourage their entourages consistently used the politics to refer to some ways in which athletes used to navigate federation experiences. Participants consistently mentioned that federation officials were insecure   that   athletes   would   take   the   officials’   positions   upon   the   athletes’   retirement   from competitive sport. The theme of race and politics came up only in South African athletes. Three retired athletes shared with the researcher that they were unfairly judged 90 because they were black. Athletes also shared that they had to work harder to impress their white coaches in order to be in the team. 4.5.1 Athlete Patriotism. Data analysis indicated that athletes exemplified patriotism and expressed love for their countries in many ways. During the interview process, athletes talked passionately about their countries and what should be done to improve sport in their respective countries. They consistently suggested that their countries should emulate industrialized countries and also implement the long-term athlete development models implemented in Canada. The researcher learned that athletes felt entitled to be supported because they represented their countries abroad. They used the  word  “ambassador”  in  reference to representing their countries abroad. Participant # 5 from Botswana suggested that the government should have a plan for retiring athletes. Let me use this analogy for you. Parents of kids in pre-schools already know which primary schools they will send their kids but here in Botswana it’s  something  else.  You  have  to  represent  your  country  and  when  you  are   done, there is nothing for you. 4.5.2 Lack of Retirement Transition Programs and Federation Politics. All the four countries studied did not have retirement transition programs or post-sport career training programs for elite athletes. Athletes could join federations and or chose to coach after their elite career. Federations also employed some athletes, particularly those who had tertiary education. In some cases, athletes and their entourages shared that federation politics impacted their participation in Sport. For example, three participants raised concerns that they had problems with federation officials during their elite career in sport. Such problems included athlete choice of the coach, funding from the federations, clearance to 91 compete internationally and qualification rules interpretation. For example, some athletes shared that federation officials did not provide enough support but expected athletes to contribute 10% of their earnings to the federation coffers. Participant # 10 shared with the researcher his experiences with his federation. I have to be honest that there was the problem in my federation. There was friction in my federation. Some of them were power-hungry and jealous. That was the problem with my federation. They thought maybe if you became successful you take over the positions of the management of the federation, so at times we used to have some friction. At times, they wanted about 10% of our earnings for nothing. I was sponsored by (two sponsor names), so they used to fly me to different competitions. The federation didn't give me enough support. If the federation had supported me, I would've achieved a lot. I used to miss some of the competitions because my federation failed to buy me flight tickets. 4.5.3 Bias and Racism. South African black athletes shared that white coaches treated them unfairly. Athlete participants from South Africa shared that they were subjected to more scrutiny than their white teammates. For Example, Participant # 15 consistently mentioned that the quota system in South African (sport) team during her time subjected her and other black players to stereotypes that they did not earn to be in the team but were brought in to meet the minimum number required by the policy. The quota system in South Africa was implement to encourage black South Africans in sports such as rugby and cricket continues to be discussed in South African media. Participant # 15 shared her experience watching men (sport) with the researcher. I have sat in the stands watching the men (sport) team player in RSA and players will go on and off the field and a non-white player will make a mistake and you could hear this murmur around the stands. I know its not everybody but if the player makes the same mistake and they would be like haahaaa   a  “quota  player”.  Not  ever  thinking  that  this  guy  is   having   a  bad   day today. A white player would make mistakes all the time but they won’t   92 see it that way, they will say John is off today. It should be noted that the quota system and representation of black athletes is currently being discussed in South African media to increase participation of black athletes in sport such as hockey, rugby and swimming. 93 Chapter 5: GENERAL DISCUSSION The primary objective of this dissertation was to investigate elite athletes’ retirement transition experiences including  it’s  psychological  impacts and post-sport career adaptation. The secondary objective was to establish an in-depth account of the role  of  the  entourage  on  elite  athletes’  retirement  transition.  Lastly,  the  dissertation  makes   cross-national comparisons, looking specifically at budgets, population size and sport organizational structure impacts on sport development. To address the objectives stated above, this dissertation used a grounded theory research approach and development the to post-sport career adaptation model (figure 4). The grounded theory approach was chosen to explore the experiences of retired elite athletes and their entourage members because it accords the researcher the opportunity to generate theory rather than impose theory on the data. The study observed three major themes in the primary objective (type of retirement, dual-career, and challenges) as crucial  in  elite  athletes’  retirement  transition and post-sport career and two major themes (social and financial support) in the secondary objectives. Brief summaries of major findings are discussed in the following paragraphs. The first major theme of type of retirement was derived from interviews with athletes and entourages to explain reasons for retirement and post sport career adaptation. Sub-themes observed under type of retirement were voluntary and involuntary. The second major theme observed in the study was dual-career. This finding reflected the athletes’  balance  between  school  and  sport  as  primary  in  preparing  for  a  post-sport career transition and adaptation. Sub-themes observed under the major theme dual-career were graduating from university, full-time  job  during  one’s  career  in  sport  and part-time job 94 during  one’s  career  in  sport. The last major theme observed in the study was challenges. It was clear from the respondents that athletes faced challenges including lack of financial resources to maintaining an elite sport career and support during retirement transition. Sub-themes observed under the major theme of challenges were financial resources, lack of trained coaches, lack of facilities, and lack trained medical personnel. Consistent  with  literature  on  retirement  transition,  the  study  observed  that  athletes’   experiences in elite sport are crucial in explaining not only their retirement transition, but also their post-sport career adaptation. The three key findings from this dissertation are that there is a need to balance school and sport, it is important for federations and other major stakeholders to provide services for athletes in retirement transition and lastly, athletes should be provided with medical care to help them deal with injuries. Even though there are some reports (“Retiring  Olympic  Athletes  May  be  at  Risk  of  Substance   Abuse,  Studies  Suggest,”  2012) that some athletes in retirement transition may fail to adapt into the community and resort to drugs, this dissertation did not observed any maladaptation to that level in Southern Africa. Athletes who did not have jobs made an attempt to find employment and seek support from entourage members to adapt to the community. Results from primary objectives of this study are discussed within Wylleman and Lavelle’s  (2004)  Lifespan  Model  of  Athlete  Development  and  Taylor  and  Ogilvie   (1994)’s  Conceptual  Model  of  Adaptation  to  Career  Transition.  The  primary  reason  for   choosing these models to guide primary objectives results is that they incorporates transitions and experiences occurring in the athletic domain as well as those occurring in 95 other  domains  of  athletes’  lives.  In  order  to  understand  elite  athletes’  career  paths,  it  is   crucial to take into account developmental transitions occurring outside sport, such as athlete psychological, vocational/academic, and psychosocial development (Wylleman et al., 2004). Results from this dissertation extend theory and the understanding of elite athletes particularly on the role of the entourage on retirement transition. For example, the Lifespan Model of Athlete does not have federation and teachers as entourage members in athletes’ careers but this dissertation observed that in cases where parents are not fully involved in their kids’ participation in sport, the federation and school played a crucial role making sure that kids have access to playing sport. The Lifespan Model does not take into account the role played by extended family members, but discusses the role played by close family members. Results from this dissertation are able to extend the Lifespan Model to include extended family members and other members of the entourage as presented in Table 5. Results from this dissertation were consistent with the Conceptual Model of Adaptation to Career Transition. Consistent with the model(Taylor & Ogilvie, 1994), causal factors that initiate the retirement process (i.e., age, injury, and free choice) were crucial in explaining athletes retirement transition. Depending on the cause of withdrawal from competitive sport, developmental experiences and tertiary contributors either facilitated retirement or because a challenge for the athlete to overcome. For example, involuntary retirees made an attempt to return to sport but eventually retired. There were no available resources/services for retired athletes, which created a deficit in athlete’s retirement transition, particularly in those that did not have university education to be 96 immediately employed. The resources required (i.e., social and financial support) for coping with retirement are crucial for athletes. Research (Bloom, 1985; Côté, 1999; Wylleman et al., 2004) demonstrates that members of the entourage (i.e., family, peers, and coaches) provide needed support during athlete development and retirement. 97 Figure 4: Paths to Post-Sport Career Adaptation New career Voluntary retirement • • • • • Change of career Start family • • • Identity shift Missing sport Rediscovery Dual Career Type Retirement Path to Post Sport Career Adaptation • Return to school • Employment • Social support • Patience • Resilience Challenges • Identity shift • Missing sport • Rediscovery • Unemployment • Financial challenges No new career yet • • • • Involuntary retirement • • Teacher Coach Public speaking Injured Deselection 98 Try to return to sport Try to maintain sport identity Unemployment Isolation Post Sport Career Adaptation The Path to Post-Sport Career Model was developed through the grounded theory approach using major theoretical constructs observed in this dissertation. Major themes in the model include circumstances surrounding retirement (type of retirement), dual career, challenges, support from entourages and athletes’ ability to find paths to post sport career adaptation. It should be noted that involuntary retirees who did not have university education were immediately looking for jobs to support their families after retirement. Even though some of them were not satisfied with their new jobs, athletes preferred to have jobs than roam the streets. Athletes shared with the researcher as presented in this chapter that supporting their families was a priority. Given unemployment rate of about 60% in Zimbabwe, 37% in Namibia, 25% in South Africa and 17% in Botswana, athletes may not necessarily have a choice in selecting jobs and seeking for satisfaction. A further discussion of the major themes is presented in the following paragraphs. 5.1 Dual Career: Balancing Sport with Another Career Outside Sport Wylleman and Lavallee (2004) explain that even though athletic factors (e.g., achievement  in  sport)  have  a  significant  influence  in  athletes’  within-career transition as well as retirement transition; there are a lot of factors occurring outside sport (e.g., athletes’ education, and social support) that impact within-career transition, retirement transition, and post-sport career life. The current study observed that graduating from university, and part-time and fulltime employment positively facilitated retirement transition. Results from this study demonstrated that athletes use dual-careers (job/education and elite sport) to prepare for a post-sport career. Pre-retirement planning has been found to broadly and positively influence retirement transition (Coakley, 1983; 99 Schlossberg, 1981; Yeung, 2013). Results from this finding  are  consistent  with  Cecić   Erpič,  Wylleman,  and  Zupančič  (2004)  who  observed  that  quality  of  sport  career   termination  process  depends  on  the  voluntariness  of  career  termination,  participant’   subjective evaluation of athletic achievements, education status and the occurrence of the negative non-athletic transitions. One of the primary challenges faced by most elite athletes and their entourage (e.g., parents, coaches, teammates, and federations) is the ability to manage the elite athlete’s  intense  exclusive focus in sports and still build resilience and capacity to meet the many transitions and demands required in both elite performance and life (Anderson, 2009). Even though at least 10 athletes in this study had university education, the conflict of sport  and  school  was  evident  in  athletes’  careers  particularly  in  the  early  stages  of  their   careers in sport. There is no doubt that governments, sports federations, sports clubs, and sponsors have put pressure on athletes to excel at the international level more than ever in the history of sports while most universities adhere to high academic standards for their students, regardless of their athletic status. Pressure to succeed in sport and exclusive focus may lead to athletes dropping out of school to focus in sport. Some of the factors observed in research (Fong, Lin, & Chi, 2003; Lang, 1988; Whitley, 1999) that play a crucial role in influencing student-athletes to dropping out of school to play sport include secondary school grades, repeating a year in school, feelings towards school, and mother's education. This study observed that athletes perceived graduating from college as a positive way to prepare for a post sport career. This finding is consistent with most literature on retirement transition. Even though dual career is a challenge to a lot of athletes, it is 100 associated with positive athletic retirement transition because athletes move from one career to another instantly (Borggrefe & Cachay, 2012; Corrado et al., 2012). Research (Aquilina, 2013; Grove, Lavallee, & Gordon, 1997; Park, Tod, & Lavallee, 2012) further demonstrated the need for elite athletes to have a 'dual career' and/or long term athlete development to prepare for a post-athletic career while still participating in elite sport. For example, the United States Olympic Committee has arrangement with some of American universities to officer online classes to athlete. This is an approach that African universities can take. Instead of offering online classes, they can offer part-time classes and provide more flexible time for athletes. Professional sport is one of the shortest careers that one can undertake; most competitive athletes retire at a young age, which requires athletes to redefine their sense of self and social identity (Baker, Koz, Kungl, Fraser-Thomas, & Schorer, 2013; Witnauer, Rogers, & Saint Onge, 2007). In the United States college sport, approximately 1% of collegiate athletes become professionals’  athletes,  and  the  average  professional  sports  career  lasts around 3.5 years (Beamon, 2010). The athlete and entourage members have to find an alternative career path that would last beyond playing in professional leagues. In addition to education, it is known that sports might offer alternative career paths and relief athletes and their families from poverty. Athletes can be encouraged to save and invest their money in the early years of their career. In the west, dual-career is viewed as a valuable tool for promoting an important contribution to the development of policy actions in the area of sport and education (Corrado et al., 2012).International organizations such as the European Commission (EC) and the International Olympic Committee (IOC) have also take keen 101 interest in this approach. The European Commission acknowledged the importance of dual career (balancing school and sport) for young elite athletes by promoting policies that promotes good physical and psychological health(Pavlidis & Gargalianos, 2014). These policies are made to ensure the reintegration of professional sportspersons into the labor market at the end of their sporting careers. The International Olympic Committee runs a program that guides Olympic athletes into education with the goal of a better postretirement life. It is therefore crucial for federations and governments to support athletes to find balance between school and sports. Research (Borggrefe & Cachay, 2012; Corrado et al., 2012; Pavlidis & Gargalianos, 2014) demonstrates that dual career maximize  athletes’  contributions  to  society  by  building  on the capabilities athletes have developed during their athletic careers. Athletes who succeed in sport and other careers are great role models to young athletes who may aspire to be play sport professionally. 5.2 Elite Athletes’ Challenges in Elite Sport and Post-Sport Career In addition to lack of retirement transition programs, data analysis indicated that elite athletes faced challenges that include lack of financial resources to compete and remain at the top of their elite career in sport. Athletes also experienced injuries that required specialized trained to work with athletes. Reasons for retirement among some of the involuntary retirees were either due to injuries, deselection and or failure to qualify. Some voluntary retirees shared that they did not have financial support to continue with the sport and opted for retirement from competitive sport. Challenges experienced by athletes in several African countries are a subject of discussion in the literature. Some studies have looked at barriers of participation in sport 102 (Amusa, Toriola, Onyewadume, & Dhaliwal, 2008), challenges faced by elite athletes in high performance centers (Gizaw, 2014), and challenges faced by student-athletes navigating school and sport simultaneously (Burnett, Peters, & Ngwenya, 201 0). Consistent with challenges observed in this study, studies (Amusa et al., 2008; Burnett et al., 2010) carried out in Southern Africa affirm that low socio-economic status, sociocultural factors, facility inaccessibility, and lack of student-athletes support were primary barriers of athletes in developing countries. Amusa and colleagues suggest that planning and delivering sport and recreation services as well as implementing intervention programs are crucial for communities in Botswana. In a study that looked at studentathletes needs in South Africa, Burnett and colleagues observed that student-athletes came from relatively impoverished backgrounds and that they needed tutoring and more flexibility in completing assignments. Authors also depicted that student-athletes expressed a need for medical coverage and professional rehabilitation services due to constant injuries that comes with training and competing in elite sport. Sport-related injuries were perceived as the biggest threat to the continuation of a sporting career, and, despite being socialized into accepting and even competing with minor injuries, athletes perceived that injuries remained a real threat to their careers (Burnett et al., 2010). Gizaw (2014) suggest that limited role of the community in sports, the decline of sports in schools, shortage of sports facilities, sportswear and equipment, as well as the lack of trained personnel are some of the challenges faced by elite athletes in high performance centers. African federations should market their athletes more for sponsorship to generate more revenues. In addition, it is important for federations to 103 understand their athletes value when they seen sponsorship. Africa has retired legends in a lot of sports that can be used to market and generate funding for African federations. 5.3 Entourage Support and Type of Retirement Sport psychology research (Bloom, 1985; Côté, 1999; Debois et al., 2012; Wylleman et al., 2004) demonstrates that elite athletes’ career in sports can be organized into four main stages from the initiation, development, mastery, and discontinuation. Even though this dissertation focuses primarily on retirement transition, athletes’ experiences at earlier stages likely impact athletes’ retirement transition. One of the primary differences observed in this study and the previous literature is the types of challenges that athletes face in their careers in sport. For example, athletes in the industrialized nations, particularly middle class families may face challenges of parental over-involvement (Heinzmann,  2002;;  O’Rourke,  Smith,  Smoll,  &  Cumming,  2011) while athletes in Southern Africa may perceive lower parental involvement (Chappell, 2004; Malete, 2006). Athlete participants in this study did not always expect parental involvement and in some cases, parents had never travelled to watch their kids compete. In middle class industrialized nations, it is almost expected that parents will travel to watch their kids. Elite athletes’ career stages (i.e., initiation, development, mastery and discontinuation) are discussed in the literature showing that athletes continuously advanced from one stage to another in their career in sport. The role played by different institutions varied by stage. For example, in this study, athletes related most of their early careers to the role played by schools and parents with no or minimal mention of the federation. It was clear from the data analysis that athletes were dependent on financial 104 and social support from the school to play sport at the early stages of their careers. Even though parental involvement varied, school programs had resources to accord athletes the opportunity to play a variety of sports throughout the year. Horn (2008) depicts that the sport involvement of children takes place in a social context. Parents, peers, and siblings can strongly influence the psychological outcomes of this involvement. In the context of Southern Africa, even though parental involvement varied, school sport programs provided an environment that supported children’s participation in sport. Shehu and Akpata (2008) explained that teachers in many schools in Southern Africa volunteer, and it  is  also  part  of  a  lot  of  teachers’  jobs  to  coach,  be  umpires,  and  organize  intra- and extramural sport events. As a result, teachers in most African countries are not only in a position to widen youth sport participation but to inspire life-long physical activity and encourage attainment of self-directed sport aspirations. Malete (2006) affirms this statement, given the cultural context and perception in Botswana. It is therefore likely that young athletes may perceive lower parental support than their counterparts from industrialized nations. However, because teachers were found to play such a central role providing them with information about developing athletes on and off the field might be particularly important. Athletes used age, and level of performance to indicate progression from just playing for their schools to a national junior and or senior nation team. For example, athletes  consistently  mentioned  qualifying  for  the  “under  21”  world  junior championships or joining the senior national team and the role-played by the federation to give them access to international competitions such as the Olympics. At the elite stage, participants also shared with the researcher that they started earning income that showed that they had 105 advanced to a stage of independence. Transition from junior to senior stage and experiences within each stage posed within-career transitions that athletes coped with advance to a higher stage. For example, an athlete may make the youth Olympic team but fail to advance to senior Olympic team. Stambulova (2000) depicts that within-career transitions can be normative (expected), or non-normative (unexpected). Research in sport and other careers (Cabello Bonilla, 2012; Kosugi, 2012) demonstrated that withincareer transitions are common among young athletes as well as young employees that just joined their professional field. Normative and non-normative transitions observed in the study were consistent with studies that have looked at within-career transition (Lorenzo, Borrás, Sánchez, Jiménez, & Sampedro, 2009; Stambulova, Franck, & Weibull, 2012; Wylleman et al., 2004). Normative transitions were determined by age (e.g., qualifying for the Olympic games or qualifying  for  “U21-team”)  and  in  contrast,  non-normative transitions were unpredictable experiences (e.g., injury and de-selection leading to retirement) that athletes coped with in their athletic career. Data analysis showed that involuntary retirement due to cutting, injury, and failing to qualify for major games was associated with non-normative transition. Athletes had expected to continue with their sport but rather got injured and ended their career. Reaching and staying at the top in elite sport requires the need to train more intensively (e.g., increased physical and psychological commitment) as well as cope with higher competitive levels (Wylleman et al., 2004). The model of human adaptation to transition, Schlossberg et al. (1995) suggests four primary fundamentals of managing transition. Schlossberg and colleagues identified personal control over the transition, self106 efficacy in dealing with the transition, availability of social support during transition, and the individual’s  coping  strategies  as  crucial  in  understanding  and  explaining  one’s  ability   to cope with transition. Wylleman and colleagues affirm that, a supportive psychological network (e.g., coach, family, peers), attention to injury prevention, and a gradual developmental athletic career may provide athletes with the possibilities to progress towards high-level competitive sport. The study observed significant challenges that will be discussed further in this chapter. Some of the challenges observed include lack of resources and specialized trained medical personnel. According to Stambulova and Alfermann (2009), the universal knowledge about "athletes in general" seems insufficient to explain the behavior of athletes’ transition from different cultures. It is therefore crucial to incorporate not only culture but also transitions occurring outside sport (i.e., school) particularly in Southern Africa where there are no transition support services for athletes. 5.4 Summary: Entourage Support and Type of Retirement Athletes began their athletic careers in school with the support of teachers and parents. The school system in Southern Africa accords athletes to play a variety of sports before specializing in their sport of choice. Different members of the entourage play different  roles  in  athletes’  careers.  Federations  expose  athletes  to  international  sports as well as provide developmental programs for junior teams. Graduating from high school and college is an important factor in preparing athletes for retirement transition as well facilitating retirement transition. Engaging in multiple roles during retirement also facilitated retirement transition such as continuing training as well as being married. Close entourage members such as spouses and parents spent time with athletes during 107 retirement transition. All athletes had full-time jobs during data collection and did not express financial insecurity. Promoting dual-career does not only prepare retirement transition, but also facilitates retirement transition because athletes engage in multiple activities and roles. 5.5 Comparisons Between Southern African Countries Given the cross-national comparisons made in this dissertation, the Ecological model of human development (Bronfenbrenner, 1979) was used to discuss comparisons across the four countries. The model takes into account the social context of human development as consisted of macro-social factors (laws, traditions, policies on level of society), and micro-systems (e.g., family, peers, schoolmates/teachers, teammates/coaches), in which a person is involved. This model has been used to make cross-national comparisons by past researchers including Stambulova and colleagues. For example, it was clear during the data analysis that South African athletes reflected some obvious macro social factors in their social environments such as population and economic size. Even though there were differences at macro-social level (i.e., population size, sports budgets, and structural sports system across the four counties), there were no major differences across the four countries at micro level (i.e., family). Even though South Africa is  a  developing  country,  it’s  economic  size  and  the  private sector accorded South African athletes part-time employment and sponsorship that were not available for athletes from Botswana, Namibia and Zimbabwe. South Africa is the only country in South Africa that has hosted the FIFA world cup and has shown interest in hosting the Olympic games. There were more similarities between Botswana, Namibia and 108 Zimbabwe in sport structure than there are differences. National Olympic committees are responsible for elite sport while sports commissions and sports councils develop wide participation in sports. South Africa is the only country in the region that combined its federations in to confederation. A lack of paid jobs and or support programs in sport available for former athletes and higher requirements to employees’  educational  level  might  more  favorable  to  athletes   with university education and less favorable to those without college education. Figure 5: Cross-National Comparisons Macrosystem Population size and economy rank Botswana-about 2 million Namibia-About 2 million South Africa about 53 million Zimbabwe-about 12 million South Africa-2nd Botswana-18 Namibia-25 Zimbabwe-31 Education and corporation policies Exosystem Botswana-not available Namibia South Africa-athletes part-time employment Zimbabwe As presented earlier in this dissertation, in all countries, retired athletes are not 109 provided with financial and or any organizational support programs except part-time employment and IOC career assistance program in South Africa. Sport systems in all the countries give athletes a free choice to decide about their termination from sports and about  what  to  do  afterwards.  South  African’s  large  economy  increases  employment   possibilities for elite athletes compared to the other economies of Namibia, Zimbabwe and Botswana. Through these factors, together with an absence of financial support and or any special support programs for retired athletes, the sport systems places complete responsibility of the transition to the post-career on athletes themselves. Athletes and their entourages across the four countries are responsible for making their own retirement plans and decisions and decisions on ways to cope with retirement transition. 5.6 Southern African Context Even though African communities have always played a variety of games including some form of football (soccer), the British colonials in the mid-1800s introduced organized football. The first documented game on the continent was played in South Africa in 1862, a year before soccer's official rules were codified(Alegi, 2006). Traditional games were primarily meant for recreation as well as for educational purposes but not as a form of employment. It is a historical fact that it took time for African communities to view sport as a form of employment and it is still in that transition phase. Recent research (Chappell, 2004, 2005b; Malete, 2006; Shehu & Akpata, 2008), carried out in Southern Africa including findings from this dissertation affirm that even though socioeconomic status may have an influence in parental involvement is kids participating in sport, culture plays a crucial role in explaining parental involvement. As presented earlier in previous chapters, the use of certain terms and the context in which 110 they are used perpetuates stereotypes on participation in sport including parental perceptions of participating in sport. Chappell (2004) affirms that the use of the term tshameka (loosely translated as play) may have an influence in parents’ perception of playing sports as wasted time and not engaging in something serious with their lives. 5.7 Limitations Readers are encouraged to exercise caution in drawing conclusions from theoretical constructs derived from this research and applying them in industrialized nations. Results from this research can only be applied to Southern Africa populations. Athletes who took part in this dissertation are exceptionally talented, hence their participation at the Olympic games. Results may not be applicable to amateur athletes and/or athletes who do not reach elite sport. 5.8 Potential Future Research Directions Findings from this dissertation affirm that retirement from sport is a complex and multifaceted process, it is therefore important for future research to consider validating research  tools  on  athletes’  retirement  and  transition  to  post  sport  career. In addition to instruments,  research  that  looks  at  athletes’  retirement  transition  should  be  “holistic”  to   incorporate factors in sport and those occurring outside sport (Wylleman et al., 2004). Most  studies  that  look  at  retirement  transition  trace  athletes’  retirement  transition  after   they have retired. Future research should consider different research methods such as mixed methods and longitudinal research. Engaging in qualitative and quantitative research methods increases the validity of research findings and promotes greater understanding of the phenomenon being studied. The use of longitudinal research will 111 accord research to follow athletes’ careers in sport to retirement. For example, even though this dissertation observed that all athletes were employed, it is important for future research to investigate further particularly on the type of jobs that retired athletes do. An investigation into the type of jobs that athletes do accords researchers to understand if retirement athletes are satisfied with their post-sport careers. A further look on the role of universities on student-athletes particularly in Southern Africa would provide more specific recommendations. Consistent with research in sport psychology (Stambulova & Alfermann, 2009), future research should incorporate culture in the study of athletes’ retirement transition. In was evident in the data analysis that cultural context is crucial in explaining athletes retirement transition. 5.9 Suggested  Solutions  for  Elite  Athletes’  Career  Assistance  in  Southern  African   Countries Many countries around the world have, in the past 20 years, developed programs to help their retiring athletes. The Canadian Olympic Career Centre was created in 1985 to assist Canadian athletes with their careers after elite sports. This was one of the first programs for elite retired athletes in the world. The United States Olympic Committee Career Assistance Program followed in 1988 to give athletes the much needed assistance during their athletic career transitions (Pearson & Petitpas, 1990). The Athlete Career and Education (ACE) in Australia and the United Kingdom were established to provide elite athletes with career, education and personal development guidance. National Olympic Committees and federations in Africa should develop similar programs for their athletes so that retiring athletes can make better post-career transitions into life as productive members of their society. The next paragraph provide specific possible solutions 112 In conclusion, even though there are programs across Southern Africa that introduce athlete to sport, schools provide the most obvious platform for athletes. Teaches are already trained in different disciples, it is therefore important to provide additional (e.g., life skills) to enhance their skills hence athlete development. The introduction of physical education in Botswana, South Africa and Zimbabwe provides training for coaches, teachers and students. This also accords schools the opportunity to build sport facilities, which are also used for sport. There is an urgent need for retirement transition programs for retired athletes. It was clear in the data analysis that that athletes should at least have a place to go if they needed help with going back to school and or seeking employment. 1. Provide additional training to teachers and coaches, particularly in primary and secondary schools. Based on the findings of this research, it is crucial for teachers to have adequate technical (sport skills) training as well also life skills (skills (e.g., decision making, team work, public speaking, leadership) training. Teachers and coaches ability to teach life skills accords athletes the opportunity to learn skills that are transferrable to post-sport career. Seminars, workshops and educational modules should be used to train teachers and coaches. Collaborative conferences attended by teachers, coaches and federations should be stages at least annually. 2. Federations introduce programs that attract parents to not only provide social and or financial support to their kids but also attend practice and competitions for their kids. Introducing incentive programs (i.e., best parent award) may encourage 113 parents  to  be  involvement  in  their  kids’  sport.  In  some  cases,  parents  trivialized   their  kid’s  participation  in  sport.   3. Provide tutoring service and more support for student-athletes. Flexible study times, coach-teacher interaction and mentorship for student-athletes until at least university level. Athletes who successfully balance school and sport are likely to have a better transition than athletes without university education. a. Provide scholarship programs tailor-made for student-athletes unique challenges (e.g., longer university degree for athletes) b. Provide scholarship programs for retired athletes (e.g., open scholarship for Olympians) 4. Introduce part-time employment/attachment for athletes (e.g., five hours a weeks). Part-time employment accords athletes the opportunity to learn both soft skills (communication, creative thinking, work ethic, networking, problem solving and critical thinking) and hard skills relevant to their field of interest. 5. Provide  vocational  and  professional  occupation  training  for  elite  athletes,   including  vocational  guidance,  soliciting  (e.g.  resume  ́, interview, curriculum vitae), knowledge of the job market, networking, and career advice. 6. Federations/governments provide relevant career transition training to athletes (through workshops, seminars and provision of pamphlets). Include topics such as, possible advantages of retirement, perceived and expected problems related to 114 retirement, physical/physiological aspects of retirement and decreased levels of athletic activity. a. Pre-retirement counseling b. Career planning/information on jobs and education opportunities c. Financial help/advice d. Readings on how other athletes have dealt with retirement e. Physiological and dietary detraining programme f. Seminars with other retired athletes 115 APPENDICES 116 Appendix A: Demographic Questionnaire The purpose of this questionnaire is to obtain a comprehensive view of the factors that have been important in your athletic career from your development to retirement. This includes the role of your parents, coaches and federation to your development and preparation for retirement. The researcher will use the information you provide in this questionnaire to create an interview guide. 1. What was your main competitive sport? a) Swimming b) Track and Field c) Rowing d) Hockey 2. What is the highest level of competition you have participated at in your sport? a) b) c) d) e) f) Olympic Games World Championships World University Games Commonwealth Games All Africa Games African Championships 3. In your opinion, who do you think played the most important role in your achievements? a. b. c. Lets now talk about your elite level. This is when you competed at the highest level in your athletic career. It includes competitions in Europe and other parts of the world. Example Africa Championships and the Olympics. 4. How old were you when you competed at elite level for the first time? a) 17-20 b) 21-23 c) 24- 27 5. In your opinion, who was your main source of support at this stage? 117 6. Please rank in order of importance the following people in terms of support and role they played during your ELITE years of sports. a) b) c) d) e) f) g) h) Parents Coach Federation Siblings Sponsor Agent Friends Extended Family 7. Did you ever think of retirement at this stage? a) Yes b) No 8. Indicate the amount of support you received from each of the following people during your ELITE athletic career. Very Small Small Support Support Average Support Enough Support A lot of Support Parents Coach Federation Siblings Sponsor Agent Friends Extended Family Lets now talk about retirement from competitive sports. This is the stage when you did not continue to compete in sports. 9. How old were you when you retired? a) 20-25 b) 26-30 c) 31-36 10. Were you ready for retirement? 118 a) YES b) NO 11. Who was there for you during retirement transition? a) Parents b) Coach c) Federation d) Siblings e) Sponsor f) Agent g) Friends h) Extended Family 12. Did you plan for your retirement? a) YES b) NO 13. Indicate the amount of support you received from each of the following people during your RETIREMENT transition. Very Small Small Support Support Average Support Enough Support A lot of Support Parents Coach Federation Siblings Sponsor Agent Friends Extended Family 14. Please rank in order of importance the following people in terms of support and role they played during your RETIREMENT transition. a) Parents b) Coach c) Federation d) Siblings e) Sponsor f) Agent g) Friends h) Extended Family 15. How long before your retirement did you start pre-retirement planning? 119 a) b) c) d) 0-2 months 2-5 months 6-11 months 12 and more 16. Were any of the following services were provided to you in preparation for your retirement from elite competitive sport? (Tick all that apply). a) b) c) d) e) f) g) h) Pre-retirement counseling Financial advice/advice Career planning/information Readings on how other athletes have dealt with retirement Physiological and dietary detraining program Seminars with other retired athletes None Others (Specify) 17. Which of the following conditions were most difficult during transitioning out of competitive sport? a) b) c) d) Financial (changes in financial status, losing contacts, making new friends, etc.) Emotional (Feeling confusion, anger, depression, loss and fear) Occupational (finding a job, new career, adjusting to new working hours, etc.) Physical (changes in body shape, adjusting to new level of exercise and new diet, etc.) 18.  Are  you……….? Single Married Divorced or Separated Widowed 19. Which of the following best describes your current occupational status? Employed Unemployed Student 20. Gender Male Female 21. Age a) 23-25 b) 26-28 c)29-32 d) 33-36 e) 37-40 120 Appendix B: Athlete Interview Guide Thank you to have agreed to participate in this interview. We will talk about your involvement in elite and the support you got from different people. 1. Tell me about your initial involvement in sport and some of your major achievements. 2. Who provided you with support when you first got involved in sport and what type of support? 3. How  do  you  characterize  your  parents’  involvement  in  your  athletic  career  when   you first started? 4. Did any other person influence you significantly when you started? (Coach, agent, sponsor, federation, friends and extended family) 5. You indicated in the survey that you did not think of retirement while in your elite stage. Tell me more about that. 6. How do you characterize your parents, federation coach and spouse involvement when you were an elite athlete? 7. Let’s  talk  about  your  retirement  transition. 8. What were circumstances surrounding your retirement from competitive sport? 9. You indicated in the interview that you were not ready for retirement, can you tell me more about that? 10. You also stated that you did not plan for retirement, can you talk a little bit more about that 11. What were your immediate worries when you retired from competitive sport if you had any? 12. How much thought did you give to your withdrawal from elite sport? 13. What other activities or roles were you involved in during your professional career? work? marriage? 14. What transition and support services are available for elite athletes in retirement transition? 15. What would you say you needed after your elite career ended to give your life meaning and satisfaction? 16. Who provided you with support during retirement transition from elite sport and what type of support? 17. How do you characterize your spouse, parents and coach involvement during your retirement transition? 18. Did any other person influence during your retirement transition? (Coach, agent, sponsor, federation, friends and extended family) 19. Final Thoughts 121 20. What have been the hardest things about achieving the athletic success you have? 21. If you had the opportunity to make recommendations to talented athletes who want to achieve what you have, what would you suggest? 122 Appendix C: Entourage Interview Guide Introduction-background Information 1. When did you first meet athlete X? a. What was he or she like? b. What do you remember about him or her? 2. How long did you coach (if coach) him or her? 3. When did you first realize this athlete was talented? 4. How would you characterize your relationship with him during his/her athletic career? 5. Given your entire coaching career, what was your greatest thrill relative to working with this athlete? 6. Who provided athlete X with primary support during his elite athletic career? 7. How   would   you   characterize   his   or   her   parents’   involvement   during   his   or   her   athletic career? 8. Did any other events or individuals (siblings, friends, federation, sponsor, spouses, and extended family) influence his or her participation in sport at this period? 9. What were the circumstances surrounding his/her withdrawal from competitive sports? 10. What role did you play during his/her retirement transition? 11. Who  is  responsible  for  athletes’  transition? 12. In your opinion do you think your relationship had changed from when he/she was an elite athlete? 13. Who  do  you  think  played  a  primary  role  in  athlete  X’s  retirement  transition 14. What should be done for retired athletes? 15. Anything to add? 123 REFERENCES 124 REFERENCES Adams, J., Hayes, J., & Hopson, B. (1977). Transition: Understanding and managing personal change., xiii, 241. Alegi, P. (2006). The Football Heritage Complex: History, Tourism, and Development in South Africa. Afrika Spectrum, 41(3), 415–426. Alfermann, D., Stambulova, N., & Zemaityte, A. (2004). Reactions to sport career termination: a cross-national comparison of German, Lithuanian, and Russian athletes. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 5(1), 61–75. Amusa, L. O., & Toriola, A. L. (2010). The changing phases of Physical education in Africa: Can a uniquely African model emerge? African Journal for Physical, Health Education, Recreation and Dance, 16(4). Anderson, D. (2012). A balanced approach to excellence: Life-skill intervention and elite performance. Reflective Practice, 13(4), 609–620. Andrews, D. L., Mason, D. S., & Silk, M. L. (2005). Qualitative Methods in Sports Studies. Berg. Aquilina,  D.  (2013).  A  study  of  the  relationship  between  elite  athletes’  educational development and sporting performance. International Journal of the History of Sport, 30(4), 374–392. Atchley, R. C. (1989). A Continuity Theory of Normal Aging. The Gerontologist, 29(2), 183–190. Baillie, P. H., & Danish, S. J. (1992). Understanding the career transition of athletes. The Sport Psychologist, 6(1), 77–98. Baker, J., Horton, S., Robertson-Wilson, J., & Wall, M. (2003). Nurturing sport expertise: Factors influencing the development of elite Athlete. Journal of Sports Science & Medicine, 2(1), 1–9. Baxter, J., & Eyles, J. (1997). Evaluating Qualitative Research in Social Geography: Establishing  “Rigour”  in  Interview  Analysis.  Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 22(4), 505–525. Beamon, K. (2010). Are sports overemphasized in the socialization process of African American  males?  A  qualitative  analysis  of  former  collegiate  athletes’  perception   of sport socialization. Journal of Black Studies, 41(2), 281–300. Biddle, S. J. H., Markland, D., Gilbourne, D., Chatzisarantis, N. L. D., & Sparkes, A. C. 125 (2001). Research methods in sport and exercise psychology: quantitative and qualitative issues. Journal of Sports Sciences, 19(10), 777–809. Blinde, E. M., & Greendorfer, S. L. (1985). A Reconceptualization of the Process of Leaving the Role of Competitive Athlete. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 20(1-2), 87–94. Bloom, B. (1985). Developing Talent in Young People. New York: Ballintine. Borggrefe, C., & Cachay, K. (2012).  “Dual  Careers”:  The  Structural  Coupling  of  Elite   Sport and School Exemplified by the German Verbundsysteme. EJSS. European Journal for Sport and Society, 9(1/2), 57–80. Boxing legend Baby Jake Matlala dies at 51 - Times LIVE. (2013, December). Brewer,  B.  W.,  Van  Raalte,  J.  L.,  &  Linder,  D.  E.  (1993).  Athletic  identity:  Hercules’   muscles or Achilles heel? International Journal of Sport Psychology, 24(2), 237– 254. Britten, N., Jones, R., Murphy, E., & Stacy, R. (1995). Qualitative research methods in general practice and primary care. Family Practice, 12(1), 104–114. Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). THE ECOLOGY OF HUMAN DEVELOPMENT. Harvard University Press. Cafruni, C., Marques, A., & Gaya, A. (2006). The Importance of Sport Results During the Long-Term’s  Athlete  Development.  A  Study  with  High  Level  Brazilian   Athletes. Revista Portuguesa de Ciencias do Desporto/Portuguese Journal of Sport Sciences, 6(1), 55–64. Caine,  D.,  Lewis,  R.,  O’Connor,  P.,  Howe,  W.,  &  Bass,  S.  (2001).  Does  Gymnastics   Training Inhibit Growth of Females? Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine, 11(4), 260–270. Carron, A. V. (1978). Role Behavior and the Coach-Athlete Interaction. International Review of Sport Sociology, 13(2), 51–65. Cecić  Erpič,  S.,  Wylleman,  P.,  & Zupančič,  M.  (2004).  The  effect  of  athletic  and  nonathletic factors on the sports career termination process. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 5(1), 45–59. Chappell, R. (2004). Sports development in Botswana, Africa. The Sport Journal, 7(2), unpaginated. Coakley, J. J. (1983). Leaving Competitive Sport: Retirement or Rebirth? Quest, 35(1), 1–11. 126 Constantine, M. G. (1995). Retired female athletes in transition: A group counseling intervention. Journal of College Student Development, 36(6), 604–605. Corrado, L., Tessitore, A., Capranica, L., Rauter, S., & Topic, M. D. (2012). Motivation for a Dual-Career: Italian and Slovenian Student-Athletes/Motivacija Za Dvojno Kariero: Italijanski in Slovenski Studenti Sportniki. Kinesiologia Slovenica: Scientific Journal on Sport, 18(3), 47–56. Cosh, S., Crabb, S., & LeCouteur, A. (2013). Elite athletes and retirement: Identity, choice, and agency. Australian Journal of Psychology, 65(2), 89–97. Côté, J. (1999). The influence of the family in the development of talent in sport. The Sport Psychologist, 13(4), 395–417. Côté, J., Ericsson, K. A., & Law, M. P. (2005). Tracing the Development of Athletes Using Retrospective Interview Methods: A Proposed Interview and Validation Procedure for Reported Information. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 17(1), 1–19. Cox, R. H., Sandstedt, S. D., Martens, M. P., Ward, D. G., & al, et. (2004). Development of the Student-Athlete Experiences Inventory. Journal of Sport Behavior, 27(3), 243–259. Crook, J. M., & Robertson, S. E. (1991). Transitions Out Of Elite Sport. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 22, 115–127. Crust, L., & Nesti, M. (2006). Review of Psychological Momentum in Sports: Why qualitative research is needed. Athletic Insight, 8(1). Cumming, E., & Henry, W. E. (1961). Growing Old, the Process of Disengagement. Basic Books. Cutrona, C. ., & Russell, D. W. (1990). Social support: An interactional view., xvi, 528. Dale, G. A. (1996). Existential phenomenology: Emphasizing the experience of the athlete in sport psychology research. Sport Psychologist, 10(4), 307–321. Dawes, N. P., Vest, A., & Simpkins, S. (2013). Youth participation in organized and informal sports activities across childhood and adolescence: Exploring the relationships of motivational beliefs, developmental stage and gender. Journal of Youth and Adolescence Debois, N., Ledon, A., Argiolas, C., & Rosnet, E. (2012). A lifespan perspective on transitions during a top sports career: A case of an elite female fencer. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 13(5), 660–668. 127 Du, M. (2008). Quality of retirement placement for elite athletes in Hong Kong China and countermeasures. Chinese Journal of Physical Education, 15(9), 45–48. Du, M. M., & Tsai, E. (2007). Reasons for Retirement and the Influence of Retirement on the Life Adjustment amongst Hong Kong Elite Athletes. Journal of Physical Education & Recreation (Hong Kong), 13(1), 29–35. Edwards, J., & Meier, K. (1984). Social breakdow/reconstruction and athletic retirement: An investigation of retiremnent and retiremenet adjustment in National Hockey League plaers. Presented at the Olympic Scientific Conference, Eugene, USA. Emmert, M. (2012, June 6). An Olympian’s  life  after  gymnastics.  Des Moines Register, p. C.3. Des Moines, Iowa, United States. Erickson, R. W. (1967). Some Historical Connections Between Existentialism, Daseinsanalysis, Phenomenology, and the Wurzburg School. Journal of General Psychology, 76(1), 3–24. Erikson, E. H. (1963). Childhood and society. New York: Norton. Falk, B., Lidor, R., Lander, Y., & Lang, B. (2004). Talent identification and early development of elite water-polo players: a 2-year follow-up study. Journal of Sports Sciences, 22(4), 347–355. Fentin-Thompson, N. (2012). Identity development and athletic participation among female adolescents with physical disabilities. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, 72(10-B), 6382. Folkman, S., & Lazarus, R. S. (1980). An Analysis of Coping in a Middle-Aged Community Sample. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 21(3), 219. Forde, C., McMahon, M., Gronn, P., & Martin, M. (2013). Being a Leadership Development Coach: A Multi-Faceted Role. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 41(1), 105–119. Fraser, L., Fogarty, G., & Albion, M. (2010). A longitudinal analysis of the transition to retirement from elite sport: Athletic identity, life satisfaction and career indecision. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 12, e174. Gaotlhobogwe, M. (2008, October 16). Botswana: Dube Chased From Classroom. Mmegi/The Reporter (Gaborone). Garcia, B. (2009). Sport governance after the White Paper: the demise of the European model? International Journal of Sport Policy, 1(3), 267–284. 128 Gayles, J. G., & Hu, S. (2009). The Influence of Student Engagment and Sport Participation on College Outcomes among Division I Student Athletes. The Journal of Higher Education, 80(3), 315–333. Gilbert, W. D., & Trudel, P. (2004). Role of the coach: How model youth team sport coaches frame their roles. The Sport Psychologist, 18(1), 21–43. Gizaw, A. A. (2014). Challenges of Tirunesh Dibaba National Athletics Training Center Field Event Trainee Athletes’  in  Assela  - Ethiopia. Ethiopian Journal of Education and Sciences, 8(2), 87–101. Goldman, J. P. (1991). Balancing School Sports and Academics. The Education Digest, 56(8), 67. Gordon, S. (1995). Career transitions in competitive sport. In Sports Psychology:Theory, applications and issues (pp. 474–501). Brisbane: Jacaranda Wiley. Gould, D., Lauer, L., Rolo, C., Jannes, C., & Pennisi, N. (2006). Understanding the role parents play in tennis success: a national survey of junior tennis coaches. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 40(7), 632–636. Gould, D., Tuffey, S., Udry, E., & Loehr, J. (1996). Burnout in competitive junior tennis players: II. Qualitative analysis. The Sport Psychologist, 10(4), 341–366. Green, B. C. (2005). Building Sport Programs to Optimize Athlete Recruitment, Retention, and Transition: Toward a Normative Theory of Sport Development. Journal of Sport Management, 19(3), 233–253. Grove, J. R., Lavallee, D., & Gordon, S. (1997). Coping with retirement from sport: The influence of athletic identity. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 9(2), 191–203. Haerle, R. K. (1975). Sport and social order: contributions to the sociology of sport. In Sport and social order (pp. 461–519). Addison-Wesley Pub. Co. Havighurst, R. J. (1948). Developmental tasks and education (Vol. iii). Chicago, IL, US: University of Chicago Press. Hellstedt, J. C. (1987). The Coach, Parent, Athlete Relationship. The Sport Psychologist, 1, 151–160. Hellstedt, J., & Tofler, I. R. (2005). Invisible Players: A Family Systems Model. Clinics in Sports Medicine, 24(4), 899–928. Henriksen, K, Stambulova, N., & Roessler, K. K. (2010). Successful talent development in track and field: considering the role of environment. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 20 Suppl 2, 122–132. 129 Henriksen, Kristoffer, Stambulova, N., & Roessler, K. K. (2010). Holistic approach to athletic talent development environments: A successful sailing milieu. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 11(3), 212–222. Henry, I. (2010). Elite athletes and higher education. Henry, I. (2013). Athlete Development, Athlete Rights and Athlete Welfare: A European Union Perspective. The International Journal of the History of Sport, 30(4), 356– 373. Holt, N. L., & Mitchell, T. (2006). Talent development in English professional soccer. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 37(2-3), 77–98. Homans, G. C. (1961). Social behavior: Its elementary forms. Oxford, England: Harcourt, Brace. Hycner, R. H. (1985). Some guidelines for the phenomenological analysis of interview data. Human Studies, 8(3), 279–303. Johns, D. P., Lindner, K. J., & Wolko, K. (1990). Understanding Attrition in Female Competitive Gymnastics: Applying Social Exchange Theory. Sociology of Sport Journal, 7(2), 154–171. Jonassen, D. H., & Rohrer-Murphy, L. (1999). Activity theory as a framework for designing constructivist learning environments. Educational Technology Research and Development, 47(1), 61–79. Kadlcik, J., & Flemr, L. (2008). Athletic Career Termination Model in the Czech Republic A Qualitative Exploration. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 43(3), 251–269. Keat,  L.  H.  (2011).  African  Soccerscapes:  How  a  Continent  Changed  the  World’s  Game.   Canadian Journal of History, 46(2), 447–448. Kerr,  G.  A.,  &  Stirling,  A.  E.  (2012).  Parents’  reflections  on  their  child’s  experiences  of   emotionally abusive coaching practices. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 24(2), 191–206. Kim, J. E., & Moen, P. (2002). Retirement transitions, gender, and psychological wellbeing: A life-course, ecological model. The Journals of Gerontology, 57B(3), P212–22. Kitzinger, J. (1995). Qualitative research. Introducing focus groups. BMJ  :  British   Medical Journal, 311(7000), 299–302. 130 Knapp, M. R. J. (1977). The Activity Theory of Aging An Examination in the English Context. The Gerontologist, 17(6), 553–559. Koukouris, K. (1991). Quantitative aspects of the disengagement process of advanced and elite Greek male athletes from organized competitive sport. Journal of Sport Behavior, 14(4), 227–246. Kubler-Ross, E. (2011). On Death and Dying. Simon and Schuster. Kuypers, J. A., & Bengtson, V. L. (1973). Social Breakdown and Competence. Human Development, 16(3), 181–201. Lally, P. (2007). Identity and athletic retirement: A prospective study. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 8(1), 85–99. Lavallee, D., & Robinson, H. K. (2007). In pursuit of an identity: A qualitative exploration  of  retirement  from  women’s  artistic  gymnastics.  Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 8(1), 119–141. Lavallee, David. (2005). The Effect of a Life Development Intervention on Sports Career Transition Adjustment. The Sport Psychologist, 19(2), 193–202. Lavallee, David. (2006). Career Awareness, Career Planning, and Career Transition Needs among Sports Coaches. Journal of Career Development, 33(1), 66–79. Lazarus, R. S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, appraisal, and coping. Springer Pub. Co. Leff,  S.  S.,  &  Hoyle,  R.  H.  (1995).  Young  athletes’  perceptions  of  parental  support  and   pressure. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 24(2), 187. Lerch, S. (1984). Athlete retirement as a social death: An overview. In Sport and the sociological imagination (pp. 257–272). Fort Worth: Texas Christian University Press. Letswamotse, P. (2014, February 6). Matambo presents a bittersweet budget | Botswana Gazette. Lotysz, G. J., & Short, S. E. (2004). “What  Ever  Happened  To....”  The  Effects  of  Career   Termination from the National Football League. Athletic Insight: The Online Journal of Sport Psychology, 6(3). Malterud, K. (2001). Qualitative research: standards, challenges, and guidelines. The Lancet, 358(9280), 483–488. Martin, S. B., Richardson, P. A., Weiller, K. H., & Jackson, A. W. (2004). Role Models, Perceived Sport Encouragement, and Sport Expectancies of United States 131 Adolescent Athletes and Their Parents: [1]. Women in Sport & Physical Activity Journal, 13(1), 18–27. Maseko, J., & Surujlal, J. (2011). Retirement planning among South African professional soccer  players:  A  qualitative  study  of  players’  perceptions.  African Journal for Physical, Health Education, Recreation and Dance, 17(4), 157–171. Mcknight, K., Bernes, K., Gunn, T., Chorney, D., Orr, D., & Angela, B. (2009). Life After Sport: Athletic Career Transition and Transferable Skills, (13), 63–77. Meyer, B. B. (1990). From Idealism to Actualization: The Academic Performance of Female Collegiate Athletes. Sociology of Sport Journal, 7(1), 44–57. Mihovilovic, M. A. (1968). The Status of Former Sportsmen. International Review of Sport Sociology, 3, 73–96. Morgan, D. L. (1993). Successful Focus Groups: Advancing the State of the Art. SAGE. Newman, B. M., Lohman, B. J., Newman, P. R., Myers, M. C., & Smith, V. L. (2000). Experiences of Urban Youth Navigating the Transition to Ninth Grade. Youth and Society, 31(4), 387–416. North, J., & Lavallee, D. (2004). An investigation of potential users of career transition services in the United Kingdom. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 5(1), 77–84. Osborne, J. W. (1990). Some Basic Existential-Phenomenological Research Methodology for Counsellors. Canadian Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy / Revue Canadienne de Counseling et de Psychothérapie, 24(2). Parham, W. D. (1993). The Intercollegiate Athlete: A 1990s Profile. Counseling Psychologist, 21(3), 411–429. Park, R. (1912). Thanatology. Journal of the American Medical Association, (58), 1243– 1246. Park,  S.,  Lavallee,  D.,  &  Tod,  D.  (2013).  Athletes’  career  transition  out  of  sport:  a   systematic review. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 6(1), 22–53. Pavlidis, G., & Gargalianos, D. (2014). STRUCTURAL SUPPORT OF HighPerformance  Athletes’  Education  Supporting  Dual  Careers  in  Greece.  Strategies, 27(1), 42. Powell, J. H. (1996). Gifted athletes balancing sport and school (M.Ed.).  Queen’s   University (Canada), Canada. 132 Powell, R. A., & Single, H. M. (1996). Focus Groups. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 8(5), 499–504. doi:10.1093/intqhc/8.5.499 Putney, N. M., Alley, D. E., & Bengtson, V. L. (2005). Social Gerontology as Public Sociology in Action. The American Sociologist, 36(3-4), 88–104. Rando, T. A. (1986). Loss and anticipatory grief. Lexington Books. Retiring Olympic Athletes May be at Risk of Substance Abuse, Studies Suggest. (2012, August). Partnership for Drug-Free Kids. Rose, A. M. (1962). The Subculture of the Aging: A Topic for Sociological Research. The Gerontologist, 2(3), 123–127. Rosenberg, T. (1981). Rosenberg (L.), Schwab (K. H.), Zivilprozessrecht, 13o ed. Beck ed., München 1981 (Book Review). Rivista di Diritto Processuale, 36. S Africa unveils World Cup budget. (2006, October 25). BBC. Samuel,  R.  D.,  &  Tenenbaum,  G.  (2011).  The  Role  of  Change  in  Athletes’  Careers:  A   Scheme of Change for Sport Psychology Practice. Sport Psychologist, 25(2), 233– 252. Sayed, I., Meyer, C. D. P., & Monyeki, A. (2004). Barriers to sports and recreation participation in three communities in Botswana. African Journal for Physical, Health Education, Recreation and Dance, 10(4), 306–316. Schlossberg, N. K. (1981). A Model for Analyzing Human Adaptation to Transition. The Counseling Psychologist, 9(2), 2–18. Siekanska,  M.  (2012).  Athletes’  Perception  of  Parental  Support  and  Its  Influence  on   Sports Accomplishments - a Retrospective Study. Human Movement, 13(4), 380– 387. Sinclair, D. A., & Orlick, T. (1993). Positive Transitions From High Performance Sport. The Sport Psychologist, 2, 138–150. Soud, H. A.-, Abuzama, A., & Atiyat, K. (2010). The role of olympic committee and sport associations in the job satisfaction of Jordanian national team coaches. Dirasat: educational sciences, 37(1), 138–271. Spaaij, R., & Anderson, A. (2012). Parents or peers: Which is it? Sport socialization and team identification in Australia: A rejoinder to Melnick and Wann. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 47(4), 526–530. Stambulova, N. (2003). Symptoms of a crisis-transition: A grounded theory study. In 133 Årsbok  :  Svensk  idrottspsykologisk  förening (pp. 97–109). Örebro. Stambulova, N., Alfermann, D., Statler, T., & Cote, J. (2009). ISSP Position stand: Career development and transitions of athletes. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 7(4), 395–412. Stambulova,  N.  B.  (2000).  Athlete’s  crises:  A  developmental  perspective.  International Journal of Sport Psychology, 31(4), 584–601. Stephan, Y., Torregrosa, M., & Sanchez, X. (2007). The body matters: Psychophysical impact of retiring from elite sport. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 8(1), 73–83. Stephan, Yannick, Bilard, J., Ninot, G., & Delignières, D. (2003). Bodily Transition out of Elite Sport: A one-Year Study of Physical Self and Global Self-Esteem Among Transitional Athletes. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1(2), 192–207. Stephan, Yannick, & Demulier, V. (2007). A dynamic model of transition out of elite sport. In 12th European Congress of Sport Psychology Sport & Exercise Psychology: Bridges Between Disciplines & Cultures 4-9 September, 2007, Halkidiki, Greece (pp. 125–126). Top 12 Largest And Strongest African Economies. (n.d.). Homecoming Revolution. Retrieved from http://homecomingrevolution.com/blog/2013/09/04/top-12largest-and-strongest-african-economies/ Tranter, N. (1998a). Sport, Economy and Society in Britain 1750-1914. Cambridge University Press. Tranter, N. (1998b). Sport, Economy and Society in Britain 1750-1914. Cambridge University Press. UNAIDS. (2013). Getting to zero: HIV in Eastern & SoutHern Africa. UNAIDS. United Nations Sport for Development and Peace - Sport and Peace. (n.d.). Utz, R. L., Carr, D., Nesse, R., & Wortman, C. B. (2002). The Effect of Widowhood on Older  Adults’  Social  Participation  An  Evaluation  of  Activity,  Disengagement,  and   Continuity Theories. The Gerontologist, 42(4), 522–533. doi:10.1093/geront/42.4.522 Valle, R. S. (1978). Existential-Phenomenological Alternatives for Psychology. Oxford University Press. Von Eckartsberg, R. (1998). Introducing existential-phenomenological psychology. In Phenomenological inquiry in psychology: Existential and transpersonal 134 dimensions (pp. 3–20). New York, NY, US: Plenum Press. Wang,  L.,  Wang,  K.,  Feng,  L.,  Guo,  H.,  Li,  X.,  Wang,  F.,  …  Zhao,  D.  (n.d.).  On  the   Reform of Local Sports Federations in China. Shoudu Tiyu Xueyuan Xuebao/Journal of Capital Institute of Physical Education, 21(5), 534–537. Warriner, K., & Lavallee, D. (2008). The Retirement Experiences of Elite Female Gymnasts: Self Identity and the Physical Self. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 20(3), 301–317. Webb, W. M., Nasco, S. A., Riley, S., & Headrick, B. (1998). Athlete identity and reactions to retirement from sports. Journal of Sport Behavior, 21(3), 338–362. Why  Nigeria  is  about  to  become  Africa’s  biggest  economy.  (n.d.).  GlobalPost. Wippert, P.-M., & Wippert, J. (2010). The effects of involuntary athletic career termination on psychological distress. Journal of Clinical Sport Psychology, 4(2), 133–149. Wuerth, S., Lee, M. J., & Alfermann, D. (2004). Parental involvement and  athletes’   career in youth sport. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 5(1), 21–33. Wylleman, P, & Reints, A. (2010). A lifespan perspective on the career of talented and elite athletes: perspectives on high-intensity sports. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 20 Suppl 2, 88–94. Wylleman, P., Alfermann, D., & Lavallee, D. (2004). Career transitions in sport: European perspectives. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 5(1), 7–20. Wylleman, Paul, Alfermann, D., & Lavallee, D. (2004). Career transitions in sport. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 5(1), 3–5. Wylleman, Paul, & Lavallee, D. (2004). A Developmental Perspective on Transitions Faced by Athletes., 503–523. Yang, J., Peek-Asa, C., Lowe, J. B., Heiden, E., & Foster, D. T. (2010). Social Support Patterns of Collegiate Athletes Before and After Injury. Journal of Athletic Training, 45(4), 372–9. Yoshida, T. (2012). A sociological study of the process that athletes overcome the challenges and difficulties over retirement: The life history of a former J-League soccer player who accomplished a career transition to wheelchair basketball. Taiikugaku kenkyu/Japan Journal of Physical Education, Health and Sport Sciences, 57(2), 577–594. Zim govt challenged on sport funding. (n.d.). NewsDay Zimbabwe. 135