HIGH TEMPERATURE CONTINUOUS FLOW GRAIN DRYING WITH CONCURRENT DRYING AND COUNTER- CURRENT COOLING PART I: DESIGN AND TESTING Thesis for the Degree of M. SI MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY JAMES ALFRED CARRANO 1970 “F a Z‘IZ’ZSCIW ”BRA“ VI Michigan 5‘3“ ' ’IIIIIIII‘IIIIIIII‘I; W 00791 5394 “W ABSTRACT HIGH TEMPERATURE CONTINUOUS FLOW GRAIN DRYING WITH CONCURRENT DRYING AND COUNTER-CURRENT COOLING PART I: DESIGN AND TESTING By James Alfred Carrano A working model of a high temperature continuous flow grain dryer using concurrent flow heating and counter-current flow cooling was designed, constructed and tested. The dryer's performance was affected by the hot air inlet design, grain spreading at the inlet, and unloader design and position. Problems in these areas were resolved and satisfactory performance was achieved. Grain dryers of the type used in these tests will be capable of maximized output when temper- ature-time relationships for grain quality have been established. Approved Approved D partment Chairman HIGH TEMPERATURE CONTINUOUS FLOW GRAIN DRYING WITH CONCURRENT DRYING AND COUNTER-CURRENT COOLING PART I*: DESIGN AND TESTING by James Alfred Carrano A THESIS Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE Department of Agricultural Engineering 1970 *PART II: SIMULATION AND OPTIMIZATION by Daniel G. Elzinga ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My deepest appreciation is extended to Dr. W. G. Bickert (Agricultural Engineering) whose counsel and guidance led to the com- pletion of this study. He has been both a friend and advisor to me during the course of this study; -- my most sincere thanks to him. I would also like to thank Dr. F. W. Bakker—Arkema (Agri- cultural Engineering) and Dr. R. T. Hinkle (Mechanical Engineering) for serving on my guidance committee and for the education I received from them during the completion of my program. It was also a pleasure to work with Daniel Elzinga and I wish to thank him for the help he supplied on the portions of this project which were done jointly. To the memory of my deceased father, Alfred, who would have greatly appreciated it, I dedicate this work. James A. Carrano ii Also To: Mrs. A. Carrano Mrs. Minnie Wilson Mr. And Mrs. H. J. Thomas iii TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background on Continuous Flow Dryers 1.2 Principles of Air and Grain MOvement 1.3 Objectives II. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1 Design Criteria 2.2 Description of Apparatus 2.21 Dryer Construction 2.22 Control and MOnitoring Equipment 2.23 Summary of Control and Monitoring Equipment 2.3 Testing Proceedure III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1 Output of Dryer 3.11 Example of Mass Balance for Test 5A 3.2 Quality 3.3 Computer Simulation IV. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS 4.1 Summary 4.2 Conclusions V. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FUTURE STUDY LIST OF REFERENCES APPENDIX iv Page U) 10 10 18 22 24 27 27 34 37 38 39 39 4O 41 42 43 Table 3.1A 3.13 3.1C 3.1D 3.1E 3.1F 3.1C 3.1H LIST OF TABLES Grain Parameters for Tests 2 Through 6B. Heating Air Parameters. Cooling Air Parameters. Exhaust Air Parameters. Effect of Spreading on Drying Air Temperatures. Drying Air Temperatures for Tests 6A and 6B. Air Temperatures in Cooling Section. Drying Air Temperatures for Test 3A. Page 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 Figure 1.1A 2.1A 2.1B 2.1C 2.1D 2.1E 2.1F 2.21A 2.21B 2.21C 2.21D 2.21B 2.21F 2.21G 2.21B 2.211 2.21J 2.21K 2.23A 301A 3.13 3.10 3.lD 3.1E LIST OF FIGURES DRYER COMPONENTS SHOWING AIR AND GRAIN MOVEMENT GRAVITY FORMED RIDGES AND TROUGHS PLASTIC MODEL LAYER OF GRAIN ENTERING CHAMBER LAYER EXITING CHAMBER OFF CENTER UNLOADING STALL AREA ON LEFT ASSEMBLED DRYER WITH INSULATION REMOVED BASIC SECTION GRAIN STORAGE TANK HOT AIR INLET WITH ADAPTER REMOVED HOT AIR INLET WITH SPREADER, VALVE AND CYLINDER DRYING SECTION EXHAUST SECTION COOL AIR INLET AIR FILTERS COOL AIR INLET AND UNLOADER UNLOADER CONSTRUCTION CONTROL AND MONITORING EQUIPMENT EFFECT OF SPREADING ON DRYING AIR TEMPERATURES DRYING AIR TEMPERATURE VERSUS DEPTH FOR SEVERAL TESTS THEORETICAL AIR AND GRAIN TEMPERATURES COOL AIR TEMPERATURES VERSUS POSITION COOL AIR TEMPERATURE VERSUS POSITION Page 11 ll ll l3 l3 l6 16 16 16 16 16 23 3O 31 32 33 33 out LIST OF SYMBOLS Abbreviation for dry air (no water vapor present). Rate of dry air movement, pounds of dry air per hour. Rate of wet air movement, pounds of moist air per hour. Rate of grain movement, pounds per hour. Specific humidity of air, pounds of water vapor per pound of dry air. Moisture content, initial, Z dry basis. Moisture content, outlet, Z dry basis. Relative humidity, percent. Temperature, degrees Fahrenheit. Initial temperature, degrees Fahrenheit. Abbreviation for wet or moist air. Concurrent flow Cooling air Counter—current flow Cross flow Heating air Hot air LIST OF TERMS Condition when the air and grain have flow velocities in the same direction. Air from the air conditioning unit when used to cool the grain. Condition when the air and grain have flow velocities in Opposite directions. Condition when the air and grain have flow velocities in perpendicular directions. Air when used to heat the grain in the drying section. Air which has passed through the burner or heater. I. INTRODUCTION Each year, a part of some farmers' time and money is spent on drying grain. The most popular method for this has been the deep bed dryer using heated air. With farmer work loads increasing and yields per acre climbing, more and more time will be spent drying grain in larger dryers. Shortening of drying and handling time would enable a farmer to spend more time on other farm management functions. To shorten drying time, continuous flow dryers which operate with higher air temperatures have come into use. But, the practice of using hotter air for drying has an upper limit and exceeding it can cause losses in grain quality; although the damage may not occur due to temperature alone but to the length of time at that temperature. This principle can be demonstrated dramatically by merely passing one's hand through a flame, first very quickly and again more slowly. Thus, it seems feasible that if grain were in contact with higher temperature air for a short time, no damage would result. The answer is in how high a temperature and how long? 1.1 Background on Continuous Flow Dryers Much research has been done in the field of layer and batch drying but very little has been done in continuous flow drying. Continuous flow drying can be done with a number of different methods including cross flow, concurrent flow and counter-current flow. Cross flow continuous dryers and deep bed dryers produce an overdried condition in the grain passing or positioned near the air inlet and an underdried condition in the grain near the exit. More uniform drying results when either concurrent or counter-current air flows are used. There are a few patents on drying methods using both concurrent and counter-current flows. On July 19, 1966, Heinrich Tillmanns received United States Patent Number 3,261,109 entitled, "Apparatus for Drying and Cooling Particulated Material". This patent describes an apparatus sub- stantially vertical using an upper drying zone and a lower cooling zone. The material to be dried is fed in at the top and is discharged at the bottom. The cooling air is entered at the lower end and is partially exhausted in the center. The remainder of the air is heated in the central portion and is exhausted at the top. This system is a counter-current flow dryer for both heating and cooling. On February 7, 1967, Douglas L. Graham.was granted United States Patent Number 3,302,299 entitled, "Drying Apparatus and Method". This system also uses an upper drying section and a lower cooling section but the drying section uses concurrent flow and the cooling section counter-current flow. Air, both cooling and heating, is exhausted in the central portion. The Anderson's in Maumee, Ohio, have a large dryer which uses this same principle. The M & W Perfect Kern'l dryer is commercially available and is modeled after Graham's apparatus. 1.2 Principles of Air and Grain Movement Grain which is dried for wet milling is generally limited to 140° F kernel temperatures. Graham (1967) states, ".... high moisture corn can stand high drying rates without drying damage; while at lower moistures the grain can be damaged by high drying rates." Since concurrent flow drying is characterized by a continuously decreasing drying rate as drying occurs, it is ideal for higher temperature drying. Since initially the grain is cool and moist and the drying air very hot, evaporation of moisture from the grain is at a high rate. This high evaporation rate keeps the grain temperature below the air temperature and also drastically decreases the air temperature at the same time. As moisture is removed from the grain, the air and the grain theoretically approach the same temperature and the drying rate decreases. Thus, at the end of the drying section, the grain and air are ideally in equilibrium and moisture has transferred to the air. Cracking occurs when warm grain is cooled rapidly. It is there- fore necessary to cool the grain with air that becomes increasingly cooler as the grain temperature decreases. Counter-current cooling provides the proper cooling action for accomplishing this. If a vertical dryer is used, grain movement will be downward. By providing a cool air inlet at the lower end of the dryer, the grain temperature will decrease as the grain approaches the air inlet, optimally reaching the same temperature as the incoming cooling air at this point. It is necessary to have the cooling air move vertically upward through the downcoming grain. This is accomplished easily by providing an exhaust section immediately above the cooling section. An exhaust fan at this point would enable the heating air to move downward and the cooling air to move upward. The dryer constructed for this research uses the above principles and these are outlined in Figure 1.1A. FEEDS zHéu Qz< MH< UZHEOmm mHzmzomZoo mmwmn ¢H.H guHm * «I 28853 m2 .88 ZOHHom—MHQ ZH wmumasoamu R 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 4 .444 444. 444. .4444. 4444. 444. 444. 444. .4.4 444444 44 .44 4.444 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 444444446 .4444 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 4444446 .4444 4.444 4.444 4.444 4.444 444 444 4.444 444 444.4.4 44 .4444 444 4.444 444 444 4.444 4.444 444 444 444.4.3 44 .344 44 44 44 444 444 444 444 444 4. .4 44 <4 44 <4 4 44 <4 4 44amz<4<4 444242 4444 mumuoamumm 44< umomnxm nH.m maan 47 .lllfi» 144 .monocH .:0Huuow wchuw mo ecu 804m museumHQ H m.HOH mm Hz 92 mOH o.OOH om Hz 82 «OH wH 0.00H Hz OOH Hz 92 o.OOH Hz OOH 82 Hz 4H 0.00H mm 92 92 «OH m.NOH mm 92 Hz 40H OH 0.00H 92 «OH cm 92 c.00H Hz wOH 40H Hz m m.moH HOH Hz Hz oHH o.oHH oHH Hz 92 NNH c m.wOH mOH NHH NOH 4HH «.mmH NHH HNH HNH mmH q N.oHH 00H me mOH NNH m.mmH mHH 04H mMH me N m.o~H oHH NmH wNH omH m.HmH omH mmH «MH me H 0 mo .m>< mmn< MmauoucH oEHu ouscHeIem>me wcHuoo monouHcoa mmcmemu 0>Hm mo mwmuo>< N .mmva wsHaHOMvm 034 Scum monocH 404:4 wmumUOH essHou aumm H 0.4HH o.¢OH 92 Hz o.mHH wH a.HOH 4.44 92 Hz 4.00H mH o.~HH Hz c.4HH Hz Hz 4H «.mOH Hz N.mOH 92 Hz 4H o.HNH 4.4HH Hz 92 0.0NH 0H m.4oH ~.~oH Hz 92 4.mHH 0H m.mmH Hz c.o~H 4.04H mez m m.4HH Hz w.HHH w.oHH mHz m 4.0MH o.o~H 92 Hz m.~mH o «.mHH 4.0HH Hz 82 c.o~H o N.mMH ~.mmH w.4MH N.OMH c.o4H 4 m.o~H o.wHH o.mNH w.4HH 4.0NH 4 H.44H o.omH 4.0mH o.mMH o.HmH N o.~mH m.mHH w.m4H w.m~H o.~qH N 4.mmH 4.44H w.mmH c.44H w.NoH H o.~4H w.omH m.44H m.NMH No.mmH H Awmsoch AmonoaHv .m>< 4* m* we H4 :OHuumm .w>4 4% me we H4 QOHuuom wsHhuv a4 maHmuv GH aesHoo mHmmouosuona ecu Bonn sasHoo mHmdooosuonH no» scum cOHumUOH H eOHuHUOH 44 4444 <0 umMH .mo mam <0 ummH How mououmummewH HH< wstuQ MH.m MHHMH 49 .monoeH ««« .uHonsounmm mmmuwmm .mmGmeou m>Husommcoo 0>Hw mo mwmuo>< «« .munonH .umnamnu umamnxm mo Eouuon Scum mocmumHn * m m mH mH nH mH mH mH «semeuzmH H 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4w4m4uww «— 44.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 4.4 44.4 4.4 4444 “”hew 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 44444 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.444 4.44 4.44 4.44 44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.444 4.44 4.44 4.44 44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.444 4.44 4.44 4.44 4 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.444 4.444 4.444 4.44 4 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.444 4.444 4.444 4.44 4 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.444 4.444 4.444 4.444 4.444 4 4.44 4.44 4.44 4.444 4.444 4.444 4.444 444.444 4 44 <4 44 <4 4 44 <4 4 «44444444 444444 4444 ZOHHUMm QZHHOOU 2H mmMDHdmmmIMH.MH< GH.M mHde 50 .m ooom was umwuoomu :o ufiawa HmQQD «« .mmfiuaw .mcou wcfizuw mo mou 504w mocMumfia * w.m4H moa 04H mud 44H omH m.NH w.mmH Nwa mwa mwa nwa NmH m.w w.qma omH «ma mma oma mmH m.o q.wo~ now now HAN mow m.m m.¢ o.mmm can «mm «mm «mm 4mm m.m «.mmm mmm mmm «mm omm mmN m.N «.mmm mmm «mm mum cum «mm m.H ««oom 4m>o m.o *«oom 4m>o o mwm4w>< mwaavmmm m>Hu=umwcoo .mo .mmuaumummama «gamma «M ume 40m mmusum4maama 44¢ wa4%ua mH.m wanna PunisJIIu—uu- .En "THJWILITHT'JW'LWLWW