Ir"— »V V \x F t \ {CNDENSATZ'ON OF TERT-BUTYL - ALCOHOL WITH PHENOLE‘N THE ‘JFESENCE OF ANHYDROUS ZINC CHLORELE UNDER THIRTY. DEGREES TEMPERATURE T333515 for the, Degree of M. S. MECHEGAN STATE. COLLEGE Albert H Agett I938 k... W! ' "a" Eu"; 7 M 1.. I R M 12 y n 1»/M(‘11:-7).W;S!a.2 g University CONDENBATION OF TERT‘BUTXL ALCOHOL WITH PHENOL IN THE PRESENCE OF ANHYDROUS ZINC GHEORIDE UNDER THIRTY DEGREES TEMPERATURE THESIS Submitted to the Faculty of Michigan State College in partial fulfilment of the ffeguirements for the gegree Master of Science by Albert H Agett Organic chemistry 1938 Lat? ‘ >5}! AQKHOWLEDGMERT The writter takes this opportunity to express his aineere appreciation for the assistance and guid- ance given by Dr.R.c.Huatan. 331595 -1- INTRODUCTION In 1916 Huston and Freedman (l) condensed benzyl alcohol and benzene by useing anhydrous aluminum chloride as the condensing agent. In 1920 (2) henzyl alcohol and phenol were condensed by the same method. In 1929 (3) benzyl alcohol and parapcresol were also condensed by the use of anhydrous aluminum chloride as the condensing agent. In 1934 Huston and Fox (4) condensed tert—butyl and tert-amyl alcohols with benzene.(same method) In 1936 tert—butyl and tert-amyl alcohols were con- densed with phenol.(5). To investigate the use of zinc chloride as a conden- sing agent below thirty degrees temperature the author has attempted to condense tertiary butyl alcohol with phenol. I. II. III. IV. fiBLa OF GDNTLfiTS Introduction Historical Discussion Experimental A. C. :ertiery butyl alcohol with phenol in the presence of zinc chloride and aluminum chloride mixture 9 Bare tertiary butyl phenol with zinc chloride and aluminum chloride Tertiary butyl alcohol with para bromo phenol in the presence of zinc chloride and aluminum chloride Tertiary butyl alcohol and para tertiary chenol.in the presence of zinc and aluminum chlorides. Tertiary butyl alcohol and phenol in presence of zinc chloride Tertiary butyl alcohol and phenol in presence of aluminum chloride Para Tertiary butyl phenol on the pres nce of aluminum chloride. Tertiary butyl alcohol with para hromo phenol in the presence of anhydrous aluminum chloride. Tertiary butyl alcohol with care tertiary buLVl phenol with aluminum chloride Pare tertiary butyl phenol with tertiary butyl alcohol with zinz chloride. ll. 12. 12. 12. 13. 14. 14. 15. 15. ‘I’ ' V1. VII. TABLE OF CONTEfiTS cont. 3. lertiary butyl alcohol 71th phenol in pr n:nce of ghosphcric acid. ‘2‘. L. I roiary butyl alcohol Wluu yore brom phenol with phosphoric acid. ‘f‘fia '.‘.ir~1°;; 131151 bro-.1101; and oil-ens]. in presence of metallic sodium. 5. cromination of para tuft-butyl PhSnOl. u. cromiuation of ortho t rt.bu1yi phenol. Tables of Results 15- 16. 16. 17. 18. 20. 23. 25. -2- 11 HISTORICAL Previous workers have used anhydrous ginc chloride as a condensing agent and as a catalyst in many instancec.In all cases that were investigated on eleVated temperature was required to bring about the desired reaction. Liebnann (6) condensed benzyl alcohol with phenol in the presence of anhydrous zinc ohloride.The reaction took place rapidly and with a fair yield. Kippernberg (7) brought about the condensation of an alcohol and an aminc.herc again an elevated temper- ature was requireato bring about the reaction in the presence of anhydrous zinc chloride. Fisher and Roser (8) (9) condensed alcohols with aromatic bases.rhis reaction took place only at elevated temperatures and required a long period of time. Liebermann(10) condensed butyl,benzyl and amyl al- cohols with phenol.Finding also that the higher homolo- guea of phenol failed to give the ferric chloride tests. An elevated temperature was required to initiate the re- action. -3- here and Weith (11) also produced diphenyf other by the action of anhydrous zinc chloride at 110° on phenol. Auer (12) prepared ethyl phenol by heating absol- ute alcohol (ethyl) and phenol in the presence of an- hydrous zinc chloride. In the crotonizetion of aldehydee and ketoned Perkins (13) discOVered that in a liquid medium acet- aldehyde was converted into crotonaldehyde Iith zinc chloride at a temperatzre of 97°. Prieb (14) condensed benzaldehyde with nitro— methane in the presence of anhydrous zinc chloride to give the nitro derriVativee of phenyl ethylene. Frank and Kohn (15) found that hot parscalde- hyde was converted into mono-molecular aldehydes at 1309. Knownagin (16) acetylsted aldehydes in the presen- ce of anhydrous zinc cholride at a very high temperar ture. Sabateir and Msilhe 917) used zinc chloride as a dehydrating agent,especially in the dehydration of alcohols to give ethers and unsaturated (usuallyo -_4_ hydrocarbone.lt was also found that it was impossible to use zinc chloride to dehydrate methyl alcohol to" give di—nethyl other as gaseous products are produced through a very complicated reaction and a certain our out of hexanethylhenzene is also formed. The author use mobile to find any references in which anhydrous zinc chloride had been used suc- ceesfiull: as a condensing agent at reduced temperatures. --50 DISCUSSION The candensation of tertiany butyl with whenel was attempted by the sauna: (19).no alkylated phanel '88 isolated by this method.nnny diffltenz methods were uaod to bring about this reaction a} the~desired temperature but they were all unnuacessrul.1t raI fbund,houavar,tnai by the addition or a small quaaimy of anhydrous aluminum ehlaride to tan reaction mixturo that the zinl ahloride was activated'gnd the reactiah took place.Tbe percent yield of the para isomer oom- pares favorably with that at the aluminum chloride condensationa with less gummy material being formed. Upon purifying the para 18639? it was noticed that there was a 10! and a high boiling fraation that could net be any or the original reactants.nuring tbs course of tho investigation these traction: were prcven to be the crib» and the dialkylated phenols rhich apparb eniiy exist in equilihrun with the para iaamer,but in very small quanitieo.Atten§ts were made to produce the ortho and the dialkylated isomer: by heating the para iconar in the preoence of the aluminum chloride zinc chloride mixture (same amounts as used in condensationa} but only the ortho~tertiary butyl phenol was iso— latcd.in very small quanities.The dialkylated pro- duct was not obtained in this procedure although it was found in small amounts when tert-butyl alcohol and phenol were condensed in the presence of the zinc chloride aluminum chloride mixture.When the same method was used with aluminum chloride alone (20) both the art? and the dialkylated phenols were isolated in small quanities (see tables).When the ortho isomer was treated with aluminum chloride only the para tertiary bytyl phenol oculd be isolatod.The same procedure was also followed uaeing anhydrous zinc chloride as the equilibrum producing agent,but no ortho or dialkylated phenols were. isolated.With phosphoric acid as the equilibrmm producing agent no oriho or dialkylated phenols were ioolated.flow— ever when tertiary butyl alcohol and phenol were condensed in the presence of phosphoric acid (21) a small yield 08 ortho tertiary butyl phenol was found but no dialkylated isomer was isolated . The structure of the alkylated phenols were provcn by comparison with thooe produced by Perkins,Dietzler,and Lundquiot(20).1n addition -7- Souszoe (22) condensedortho bromo phenol with tert- butyl alcohol useing the aluminum chloride methodtTho author upon the brominetion of the t-tertiary butyl phenol found that the product formed was identicli in melting Point and Boiling Point to that of Swayzea’s above.A mixed melting point was run with no depression. A bromine determination was made (23) (see tables) on both compounds and close agreement with the theoretical were obtained.0ne atom of bromine being attached to the ring. A carbon and hydrogen determination (24) was run on the ortho alkylated phenol and the calculated results agree favorably with the theoretical (see tables).The orhto terti ry butyl phenol was then bromine determination made (23).It was also found to have only one atom of Br attached to the ring.51nce the melting point and the boiling point of this compound does not agree with that of 2-bromo 4—terttary butyl phenol and since there are no other likely poesibiltieo it can be safely stated that it is 2-tertiary butyl phenol.Also when the ortho tertiay butyl phenol was treated with aluminum chloride it rearranged almost quantitively to the 4-tertiary butyl phenol. Carbon and hydrogen determinetions(24) were made on the 2,4 ditertiery butyl phenol and tho calculated re— sults were in agreement with the theoretical (see tables) .itulw‘il‘ii {1.1111 -8- who author also attempted to alkylate para- broso phenol with tertiary butyl alchhol in the presence of anhydrous aluminum chloride,anhydrous zinc chloride and aluminum chloride mixture,and in the presence of phosphoric acid.I n all three cases no alkylated phenols were recovered.Apparently ~the ortho position under these conditions is not receptive to alkylation. Tertiary butyl bromide and phenol were condensed in the presence of metallic Sodium (25).The only alkalyated phenol that was isolated was the para leaner and no ortho or dialkalyated were abstained. In order to fiiilitate the separation of the ortho isomer from the para isomer it was found that it was very conveinient to use a 5% solution of KOH.The para tertiary hutyl phenol being soluble and the ortho tertiary butyl phenol insoluble in this solution (see tables). A. EXPERIMEHTAL Condensation of Tertiary Butyl Alcohol with Phenol. in the Presence of Zinc Chloride and Aluminum Chloride Under Thirty Degrees Temperature. Eighteen and five-tenths grams (.25 mole) of Tertiary butyl alcohol and 23.5 grams {8.25 mole) of phenol were treated with 80 ml. of petroleum ether in a five hundred ml. round bottomed three necked flask equipted with mecury sealed mechanical stirrer,and a condenser which carries both a therometer Which reaches into the reaction mixture and a bent tub. for the outlet of H01 gas.This apparatus was placed in the hood.Thsn seventeen grams (.135 male) of Zinc chloride was added to the mixture and stirred for one half an hour.Then to this mixture was added three grams of anhydrous aluminum chloride.No rise in temperature was noted.£rter the addition of the aluminum chloride the stirring was continued for four or five hours.During this time only a very little amount of HCl gas was given off.The contents became a slight pink in color and upon standing overnight became quite dark. at which time it was decomposed with ice water and HCl.The hydrolyzed product was then extracted three times with ether and dried over 03012.The ether was removed by distillation and the residue fractionated.The first fraction was collected from 90°-120° @ l4 mm.pressure and was found to be mostly unchanged phenol and ortho tertiary butyl phenol.The second fraction was collected at 1200-1350 e 14 mm. pressure and was found to be almost pure para tort-buyyl phenol.The third fraction was collected at 135°-150° t loom. pressure and was found to be mostly 2,4 ditertiany butyl phenol.fhese three fractions were purified by fractional distillation.The para tertiary butyl phenol was recrystallized from petroleum ether and was to be a 38% yield .M.P.97.5°;B.P.l2$:122° e 14 mm. pressure.The ortho tertiary butyl phenol was found to be a slightly yellow colored liquid upon purification.Yield 1.5%;B.P.115°-117° e 23 mm pres- sure.Ehe 2,4 ditertiery butyl phenol was purified by fractionation.lt crysatllized as a white solid with M.P. 53° and B.P. 1430-1450 e 23 mm pressure.Less than 15 yield was obtained. -11- Reaction of Para Tertiary Butyl Phenol with Zinc Chloride and Aluminum Chloride. Seventy-five grams (.5 mole) of pure tert hutyl phenol (para isomer) were placed in a 500ml. modified Clathen flask fitted with a capillary, thermometer,and a condensing flask.Thirty-four‘ grams of of anhydrous zinc chloride and six grass of anhydrous aluminum chloride was added cautiously to the warmed para tertiary butyl phenol.l small amount of HCl was given off at this time and some iso-butylene.ghe r;»ction was carried out under reduced pressure,water pump,and the mixture was heatsd for three hours at 35 mm pressure.At the end of the three hour period the heat was gradually in- creased and about twenty grams of phenol was distil- led fraotionally from the mixture.s solution made up of five m1. of distilled water and eleven grave of scales carbonate was then added to the residue and filtered immediately,wnile hot.Upon purification by fractional distillation obtained 54.5 grams~{73%) yield of para tertiary butyl phenol MgP. 97°.One and five tenths grams {2%) of 2,4 ditertiary butyl phenol was obtained M.P.54°. D. -12- Condensation of Tertiary Butyl Alcohol with Para Bromo Phenol in the Presence of Anhydrous Zinc Chloride and Aluminua Chloride. {he procedure the same as in A above and upon purifiaction obtained 35.5 grams (82%) of para bromo phenol and 5 grams {3%) of an unidentified compound.B.P. 1250-127O ol4mmm pressure. Condensztion of tertiary Butyl Alcohol and Para Tertiary Butyl Ehenol in the Presence Of Zinc Chloride and Aluminum Chloride. The procedure the some as in A above.Upon‘ purification recovered thirty grams (EOiO of para tertiary butyl phenol.No other alkalyated phenol was isolated. Condensation of Tertiary Butyl Alcohol and Phenol in the Presence of Anhydrous Zino Chloride Under Thirty Degrees Pemperature. -13. The procedure the same as in A abOVe with the exception that 17 grams of anhydrous (fused) Zinc Chloride was used as the condensing agent.No alkolyated phenols were isolatgd.Ninety % (21 grams) of para teritary butyl phenol was recovered. Condensation of Tertiary Butyl Alcohol with Phenol in the Presence of Anhydrous Aluminum Chloride. The procedure the same as in A above. Upon purification a 41% yield oi para tertiary butyl phenol was obsained.9.'-..P.97.5°; B.P.12-J°-122° o 14 mm. pressure.The ortho tertiary butyl phenol upon purification was 1.52 yield of a slight yeloow liquid with a U.P.115°-117° L23 mm. prea- sure.The 2,4 dibertiary butyl phenol was purified by fractional dbstillation and crystallized as a white solid with a 2.5.2. 53. 5° and B.9.143°—145° @23 mm pressure.A 5 % yield of the pure product was obtained. v ‘ tit! ISI‘ . 0 A 4. . .nlrh .4 .‘ . I n In I 11“,..bv ,nclfll. ‘ ‘yl ‘ ,... y 5.0:» : I .1. r . u! )I l ‘ y I ‘ ‘ I r' 1' . . l ‘ ‘ . ‘ I'll-D! ‘ Ii; ‘ A “1%. v v r ‘ l . ‘ I‘ ‘ ‘ l ’1 Alf p l 1‘ l ‘ ‘ Ill: III I l ‘ ... y 5‘3!!! ‘ III I , l ‘ ‘ II ,'.' ‘. 5- v I . [I . AM-I ‘ G. H. 314- Reaction of Para Tertiary Butyl Phenol in the Presence of Anhydrous Aluminum Chloride. The procedure the same as in B above. Thirty-four grams of anhydrous aluminum Chloride was added.d great deal of H01 Was evolved at this time.The filtrate was fractionated and obtained 58% (43.5 grams) of para tertiary butyl phenol, five grams (6.6%) of 2,# ditertiary butyl phenol, two grams (2.6;) of ortho tertiary butyl phenol. Reaction of Tertiary Butyl Alcohol with Para Bromo Phenol in the Presence of Anhydrous Aluminum Chloride. Eighteen and fiveotenthe grams of(.25tnle) tertiary butyl alcohol and 43.5 grams (.25 mole) of para bromo phenol was treated with 80 m1. of petroleum ether in a 500 m1. round bottomed three necked flask.fhe procedure th same as in A above. Upon hydrolysis.extraction,and purification obtain- ed 39 grams of para bromo phenol and no alkalyated product was identified. -15- Condensation of Tertiary Butyl Alcohol and Para Tertiary Butyl Phenol with Anhydrous Aluminum Chloride. The procedure is identical to that in A above.Upon hydrolysis,extraction and purification twenty grams (80%) of para tertiary butyl ph n01 were recovered.Five grams (1.5%) Of 2,4 ditert— iary butyl phenol were obtained m.1>.53. 5°. Reaction of Pare Tertiary Butyl Phenol with Tort. Butyl Alcohol in the presence of Anhydrous Zinc Chloride. The procedure the come as in A above .25 mole of the reactants being used.No dialkalyated phenols were iaolated.Twenty-two grams (92%) of para tertiary butyl phenol recovered. CondenSation of Tertiary Butyl Alcohol with Phenol in the Presence of Phosphoric Acid. (26) Eighteen and fiVentenths grams (.25 mole) of tertiary butyl alcohol and 23.5 grams (.25 mole) of phenol and 200 grams of phosphoric acid were placed n a ?00 m1. roung bottomed flask fitted with a ecur -16.. mecury sealed mechanical stirrer and reflux con- denser.The flask was then placed on the steam hath and heated for eight hours at lOO° with constant stirring.At the end of this period the phosphoric acid was siphoned off and tie residue was fraction- ally distilled.0btained 19 grams (83%0 of para tertiary butyl phenol,H.P. 95°; .5 grams (2%) of 2,# ditertiary butyl phenol,m.P.53.5°. Condensation of Tertiary Butyi Alcohol with Fara bromo Phenol in the Bresence of Phosphoric Acid The procedure the same as in K above. Fourty-three grams of para bromo phenol (.25 mole) was used.Upon purification 95% (41.5 grams) or para bromo phenob was recOVered.mo alkalyated phenol was obtained. Reaction of Tertiary Butyl Bromide and Phenol in the Presence of Metallic Sodium. Tleven and fiveatenths grams of (.5 mole) metallic sodium w as suspended in one hundred mls. of toluene in 500ml. round bottomed three necked flask fl. -17- fitted with a mecury sealed mechanical stirrer and reflux condenser.Fourty-seven grams (.Smole) of phenol were rdded carefully and the mixture stirrered until the r?action was completed.Then 68.5 grams &.5 mole) of tertiary butyl bromide added slowly by means of a separatcry funnel.The reaction mixture was stirred for six hours and allow d to stand ovornight.Jpon purification 42.5; (20 grams) of para tertiary butyl phenol were isolat~o,i.r. J7.5°.No other alkalyated phenoh was obtained. Brominetion of Sara Tertiary hutyl Phenol ?wenty-thre' grams (.25 mole) of para- tfrticry butyl nbcnol was displvcd in sixty file of c r:on uttrn chloride in a two hundred ml. ro*nd bottomed three necked flask,t~ which was fitted a mecury see #1 mechanical stirrer,reflux condens:r fitted with a tharometir reaching below fhv surface .0“ the liq1‘£,and a ecprrotory funn:l.fiourty grams (.25 mole) of Bromine was adicd by use of the separatory funnel.During the addition-of the Bromine the mixturv was cooled with an ice and salt mixture ~nd kept around 10°.The mixture was tgen allowed to come to room t m; raturc 21th stirriun for four ho rs aft r the “remine W’s 0. -18- added.It was allowed to stand overnight and then it was purified by fractional distillation und r reduces p;rs:ure.0btained a white crystalline solid, .3. 121-1230 L l6mm/prossure and £.P. Bromination of Ortho Tertiary Uunyl Phenol xhe procedure indcticol to that of fl above. Upon purificati;n a waits colorluss solid H.P. 55- - o a , w _, _ 56 sum 2 J.:.145-i48° o 14mm. pressure was obtainou. ebmfim 0d mmmcfieu _ bhoomOH m fimmwofi GOZUMEMHZQ bnfiza WMMUGOH «HMHU govt w.m. gunk srsmfiéago sagas lummmule oqqnnfisuwumno" ."oumummwposs . gig Essa. msoumfiqmfiffiowuamui N.» $333.33 gasp Lon use :uLssoxsmss osaousgwofiaw wwooow +H.o& prswa Hymapwq 0\mmss ulwmud.w¢dwp bydofie‘aoamp wwobow Nu.ofi mo: 0 HwOIHmma\Ho§B Eases. 398 m.» "ossmsfgdfi Emma. yon firm psuLsuoxmoE ouno&¢.5¢e<~ wrobOH 235m $335.3. «53.080 ,fiwodo Hound noose moons“. mmkfl mmzm. muooxqmo as. .r. .. P fiasco \ Eoossssoma 33$ 3% mops Hmm-w.,,.qo Hosp . eon&.dda%H unamH¢.vcawH onwmtd .csw H osmoov an. mm.ma Hmwawwuo.woss wowbow moose m.m unwnad.ccnmp mbmuow 20mm ...l... oumesiégw wages Zoom awwaxwodaw unnold. ooaww womaow ww.a& ofi.mo Hmo:Hmao\Hosa wfimflow bHOHu “Homo «Hmm Ev m.»&w+od¢.us av wwouow 3.0fl m.mo HPGIHP@O\HNEE ondnisfifi. Essay was 555 5,95% mag Tzdmm«.ccwww womsow mm.o? mo HMOthm Hogs a ... whawmabfiww Ego. Emu bums. .s aimsmoib Emacs ma WM 3.00 wmlpswkmuss , mam m Jams .5?pr mass. $335.3. unufiflao ododm unaaoso gooey ow. s as 0 mac .30 as wwobow 20 oouoommofion unlit: . «84.5633. uuaogtasdep odoqo bufiogéogw gong. . 8.8“ mfmol. HmonpmuMoHQE m.» figs? 2:. p H. 3.00 atutIIIIII ut¢oa¢.daa%w. Nbowm Awqmav .bvdowdqcudKH wwobown mm.o‘ mq.0a , 20 cos mummies, 2.2.x-.. mouandmamw E25» N58.» ”SEW." 2o oogosmomg , V . . n ‘ androgen. E650“. memoo moo Housman egg“. urge“. meg 9.3.”ng Hmofimmmuwg was 333.3%, Emma. P9.“ moon Kropmfwusa ll 01mm”: ..UEHH mossy mhmm 333:3} H1385 mag» Fog“. p we 00395330“. ‘23.... gtflfifiw 0:33.. LES; mow—25H . , wagons Essay 535: an “133.3%. 333 moan omqoo wmoémuobofi m...» mugs» adagw gone“. 13...... _ ‘ m W 1 p-brumo 0¢tartabu$yl phenol insoluble Ortho tert.buty1 phenol . insoluble . fif’ ' , . ‘éa bbrm" risen .butyl phenol - soluble ' ' ‘ Pita tert,buty1 phenol 1 soluble PIECE-1T CARBogef an mismsmz 7'3 0 73 C % 3 £1 E + comm ammo. 031.04 % cm, , P~tert.buty1 phenol 30.00 '1 79.85 9.233 10.250 O~tertobuty1 phenol | 80.00 78.55 9.33 10.305 L 2,4 d11ert,tertabutyl PERGENT BROMINE Cale. imam; 0015mm) * % B}; % Br 2 bromo 4 tert.butyl ‘ “E . 34.93 phenol am. 36.36 2 tert.bubyl 4 bromo 91181101 MoP'o 35.85 34.93 -23- SUMMARY 1. Tartiery butyl alcohol will not condense in the presence of zinc chloride at or below 30° as with aluminum chloride. 2. Tertiary butyl alcohol and phenol will con- dense in the presence of zinc chloride and alum- inum chloride mixture to give para tertiary butyl phonol,ortho t rtiary butyl phonol,and 2,4 ditertu lary butyl phenol. 3. Ortho and 2,4 ditartlanybunyl phenol apparant~ 1y axial in aquilibrum with para tortiary butyl phenol when in the presence of zinc chloride and aluminum chloride mixturc.It is possible to isolate them from tfiig reaction mixture. 4. Ortho tertiary butyl phenol 1n the presence of aluminum chloride rearranges almost quanitatively to give para tertiary buflyl phenol. 5. Para bromo phenol will not condense with tertiary butyl alcohol in the proacnce of aluminum chloride, zinc chloride,21nc chloride and aluminum chloride mixture,or 1n the presence of ghosphoric acid. m -24- SUMMARY Cont. 6. Appare ntly the para position is ctr ngly favored whcn both tho ortho and para positions are Open for alkalyation. 7. 1h; ortho alkalyat.d ph;nolo are ins lubl: in 5; ion whilc the para alkalyated loomiro are oolubla 1n bhie solution. VII (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) -25. BIBLIOGRAPHY Huston and Friednmanp J.A.O.S.‘3§,2527 (1916) Huston and Science _§g_. 206 (1930) Huston and Lewis- J.A.C.S. 51 2379 (1931) Huston and For» Masters Thesis Michigan State College (1934) Huston and Iiseih- J.A.O.3. 2; 439 (1936‘) Huston,Lowia and Grotemut-J.A.C.S. $2,1365 (1927) Huston and Goodomoot-J.A.C.S. 56' 2434. (1931;) Huston and Bindergggggggig.zgg§;§,Michigan State College (1935) Huston and Anderson— Masters Thesis Michigan State College (1936) Huston and Hedrickanoctgrs ghesis Michigan State College (1937) - Huston and Petty- master's Thesis nichigan State College (1937) Liebmann~ Ber. 15 152 (1888) Kippernborg- car. 19 1140 (1897) Fisher «and Racer- Ann 11.}. (1880‘) Fisher ind Roser- Ber l3 674 (1879) (10) Lieberman Ber. lg 1842 (1881) (ll) Merz and weith. Bar. 187 (1881) (12) Ausr Ber. ;Z_ 669 (1889) (13) Perkins Ber. ;5_2804 (1882) <14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (23) (23) (24) Eri-bs Annalin (1884) 3.3125 3:25 frank and Kohn monatcsh Chem. 12_ 354 (1889) Inoswn gone Annnlin 402 111 (1913) Sabaticr and noelhe Bull. 500. Chem. 411 524 (1907) (1835) College (1935) Dumas and Beligot ann.chcm.phys. (a) 58 19 8.5. Thesis Lichigan fitsts Author- P"rkins; Di tzi:r and Lundquost- C.§. g§ 6532 (1935) U.:. 1,972,599 Tchitchibabinn- Comptcs Esnuuss 1:5 1239 91934} hull.d& La boc. Uhom de franc" 59 oar. 23b1 Swsyzcs- uorL unfinishsd- nichigsn Ghats Collqgs (1936) nattsrfi=n and -sinlnno,lst od.o.o%-58,i934 laid mustnna an; 1.133.111- IJ o .541. (1.33. 2. (1936) WE)Willi?) ,, , ~ ' ' ‘I A men-317:4; :LT-': : @2519? t 3- V ‘ ' H <