4} 7 :2 t]: .5 x O :1 P"! : .—i 31 c 2 ”II 5°: C. I I I I I I I I THE EFFECT UT ACIUITY UR KEEPING QUALITY RE BUTTER WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TU SWEET CREAM BUTTER THESIS FOR DEGREE OF M. 8. ROBERT EDWARD VINCENT 1928 If $5 0 :61 ”HA 3 [H\ UBRARY Michigan State Universii‘y fi'_._- PLACE IN RETURN BOX to remove this checkout from your record. _ TO AVOID FINES return on or before date due. MAY BE RECALLED with earlier due date if requested. DAIEDUE DAIEDUE DAIEDUE 5/08 K'lPrqlAcc8PreleIRC/Date0ue Indd THE EFFECT OF ACIDITY on KEEPING QUALITY ' or BUTTER WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE To SWEET exam BUTTER The Effect OfrAcidity 0n Keeping Quality Of Butter With Special Reference To Sweet Green Butter Thesis Reapectfully submitted to the Faculty of Michigan State Gollege in partial fulfill- nent of the requirements for the degree of Hester of Science . BY Robert Edward Vincent “a 1928 ACKNO'IILEMLHBNTS rho author wishes to express his appreciation to 0. 3. Reed, Professor of Dairy Husbandry and P3 S. Incas, Associate Professor of Dairy Manufacture, for their guidance, valuable suggestions, and criticisms in planning this work and the preparation of this thesis. The author also wishes to eXpress his apprecia- tion to c. D. Ball, dssistant Professor of Chemistry, for information, generous cooperation, and criticisms on the chemical analysis of this thesis. 10%023 TABDB OF CONTENTS Page Introduction Review of Literature .A. Sweet cream butter 1 B. Starters 6. Summary of Review of Literature 7 Experimental Work A. Procedure 1. Object of Experiment 9 2. Part I (a). Preparation of Starter 10 (b). Preparation of Bream for churning 11 etc). The Churning Process 12 (d). Preparation and care of - samples 13 ' (0). Judging the butter 15 3. Part II (a). Analysis of cream. 15 (1:). Analysis of buttermilk 15 (0). .Analysis of butter Eil). Preparation of sample 16 (2). Determination of moisture, (3). butterfat, salt and curd. 15 Determination of amino- nitrogen 15 P389 (4). Determination of total nitrogen (d). IAnalysis of butterfat (1). Preparation of sample. (2). 9etermination of Reichert Meissl Number (3). Determinatinn of Iodine Number (4). Determination of Acid ’ Number (5). Test for oxidized Fat (Kries Test) Results and Discussion A. 30' O. D. B. I. G. H. Curd Content .Amino Nitrogen Total Nitrogen Rsichert Meissl Number Iodine Number Acid Number Test for Oxidized Pat (Kries Test) Scores 1 ‘ 1. Summary of results on Flavor 2. Summary of results on Keeping Quality Conclusions Bibliography Appendix 16 16 17 17 17 18 19 21 23 $8 41' 46 47 4B 51 55 INTRODUCTION The art of buttermaking originated in Asia and Burcpe and from there was communicated to other parts of the world. Records from the Bible show that butter was used before 2000 B. C. (1) Butter was held in high esteem and was used for the holiest sacrifices. (2) Buttermaking was confined in this country to the farm dairy until the middle of the nineteenth century, but about this time the factory system of buttermaking was introduced. inbout the time of the establishment of the early creameries many revolutionary inventions and investigations were given to the dairy world. Among these were pasteurization and the use of pure cultures for the ripening of cream and developing of desirable flavors and odors in the butter. It is quite interesting to note the existing differences that have developed between what we term quality today and that of centuries ago. In mediaeval times peOple thought that butter should be stored for long periods to develop all sorts of odors and tastes before it was usable. Today the market demands a butter of dis- tinguished quality. Danish butter which is given first consideration by the critical English butter buyers is made primarily g4 from sweet cream slightly ripened by the addition of a starter. With the use of starter Danish buttermakers are enabled to control and maintain a uniform flavor in their butter. ‘ rho manufacture of sweet cream butter was begun in the united States about forty years ago. In recent years there has been an increased interest in the manu- facture of sweet cream butter. A.group of creameries in the State oerinnesota are making sweet cream.butter, to which.no starter is added. The cream must be sweet to the taste and the acidity not over 0.2 per cent by test. (3) rho specifications used by this group are simply modifications of those drawn up by the Bureau of Dairying, Uhited States Department of Agriculture to'be followed in the manufacture of butter for the navy. With the increased interest in sweet cream'butter, the question arises as to its flavor and keeping quality as compared with that of sweet cream.butter to which starter has been added. .Ln attempt to answer this question is made in this thesis. L. REVIEW OF LITBnATURE Sweet cream butter In 1890 G. W. Curtis (4) of Texas made comparisons between sweet and sour cream butter. The sweet cream was divided equally, one-half churned immediately, while the other was allowed to become slightly acid before churning. The results showed that nearly like amounts of butter were obtained from each and that there was scarcely a notice- abli difference between the two kinds of butter, the difference, if any, being in .favor of the sweet cream butter and this due chiefly to the flavor. During the same year 0. E. Patrick (5) of Iowa State College repeated the experiment of Curtis. He concluded that there was no very marked difference in the keeping quality of the two butters, what difference there was being in favor of the sweet cream product. As to flavor, for the first two or three months most of the scorers preferred the ripened cream butter declaring that made from sweet cream to be comparatively "flat", "insipid" or flavorless", but the longer the butters were kept, even while both were still sweet, the less marked became the difference between them in this respect. In 1892 Patrick (6) made nine comparative trials, by dividing by weight a quantity of sweet cream into two equal parts. one of these parts was churned immediately while the L4 2 other part was ripened at 60° 1. for 24 to 48 hours. The sweet cream butter suffered less deterioration by keeping five months (50° F.) than did the sour cream product. The former acquired in a measure the flavor and aroma of ripened cream butter. In 1895 Patrick (7) repeated the same experiment and the results agree perfectly with the results obtained in 1892. In 1904 (9) Dean compared butter made from sweet cream with butter made from sweet cream to which 20 to so per cent starter was added. The butter made by the latter method was superior in quality to that of the sweet cream butter. He also reported that when sweet cream to which 27.5 per cent starter was added at the time of churning, better results were obtained than from ripened cream. Gray (10) of‘the United States Department of'Agricul- ture in 1906 found that when butter was-made from sweet cream, the product kept well while stdred at ~100 to 100 F. and, when removed from storage, this butter kept well, while butter made from sour cream kept well in storage at ~10° I to 10° F. but deteriorated rapidly after removal from storage, giving on the whole, results which were very un- satisfactory. Charron and Shult (11) in 1907 found that when they compared sweet cream.butter with ripened cream butter, the keeping quality of the sweet cream butter was superior to the keeping quality of the ripened cream butter and that by the sweet cream process there is no greater loss of butterfat than when churning ripened cream. Rogers, Thompson and Keithley (12) of the United States Department of Agriculture in 1912 found that the scores of various samples of butter stored for 40 days at 0° P., 150 days at 0° P., and 150 days at 20° P. respectively, ranged with two exceptions, above 90 for the butter made from cream with an acidity below 0.3 per cent, while those fromicream testing higher in acidity were variable but usually scored below 90. The deterioration of the sweet cream butter at 200 P. was slight. The de- terioration in the pasteurized, ripened cream butter stored at 0° 1., was four times as great as that in the pasteurized, sweet cream butter at the same temperature. In 1916 R. 0. Potts (13) stated that the experience of those who have stored southern creamery butter indicated that it had about the same keeping quality as other creamery butter of the same grade or quality; and that low acidity, good quality of cream used, and good quality of butter were factors causing it to hold up better. in storage. He recommends that butter for storage be produced from pasteurized, sweet cream. Nortensen (14) did considerable work with sweet cream butter. He divided a quantity of cream into three lots, one lot of which was cooled immediately to a temperature of 40° P.. held for three hours or longer, and then churned sweet. .1 _second lot was cooled to 400 F., but from 10 to 20 per cent starter was added and then was held for three hours. The - third lot was cooled to ripening temperature. Starter was- added and the cream allowed to ripen until the desired acidity was reached. The butter made from ripened cream deteriorated faster than butter made either from sweet cream, or from sweet cream and starter. Where low ripening was employed, the ripened butter at the end of a two months cold storage period was of about the same quality as the sweet cream.butter, and the sweet cream and starter butter. He stated also, that unless a creamery has a special demand for sweet cream.butter, it would seem to be most advantageous to produce butter from cream ripened to a low degree of acidity. The work of White (15) is the most recent on sweet cream.butter. .A quantity of sweet cream was divided into three equal parts. The acidity of “A" was 0.15 per cent; "B" was standardized to 0.25 per cent; and "C" standardized to 0.51 per cent acidity, using a good lactic culture for standardizing. In this series the acidity was standardized before pasteurization. In a second series the cream was pasteurized sweet, acidity averaging 0.15 per cent, divided in three lots, and each lot standardized to the same degree of acidity, as in the previous series, using a good lactic culture for standardizing. A.third series was run in which cream was pasteurized sweet and two of the portions ripened to 0.35 and 0.45 per cent acidity, respectively, then churned. \— Samples of'all churningawere scored when fresh, then were stored at 0° P. for eight months and rescored. The con- clusions drawn from these experiments were: there appeared to be no material difference in the keeping quality of the butter due to standardizing the acidity of the cream before pasteurization as compared with standardizing after pasteuri- zation. Butter made from.cream.of 0.25 per cent acidity kept practically as well as that made from cream of 0.15 per cent acidity, while that from cream of 0.31 per cent acidity kept nearly as well. That from cream of 0.36 per cent acidity showed a materially lower score after storage, and that from cream of 0.45 per cent acidity a still lower score. STAETERS .Starters were first used in 1776 when the Mcngclian Ialmucks (16’ added a natural starter to sour milk intended for churning: In 1887 a description of the method of using "lands wei" as a starter for Edam cheese was published in a pamphlet by Boekel (17). This starter was th ought to exert a favorable effect on cheese defects and especially to pre- vent swelling or bloating. Before the development of arti- fical cultures buttermilk from.a churning of good butter was apparently extensively used for starting the acid fermentation in cream intended for buttermaking. The definition of a starter as given by Hunziker follows (18): "As used in the manufacture of butter by a starter is meant a mixed culture in milk or skim milk of lactic acid bacteria and associated species capable of develOping in milk, cream, and butter the flavor and aroma character- istic of good butter." The use of pure cultures for the purpose of ripening cream was the result of work done by Storch (17). He studied organisms from sources such as buttermilg butter, and ripened cream, and found that different acid pnducing forms induced very different flavors and aromas. Butter made from pasteurized cream with pure culture had a very normal, clean, mild acid flavors. The first commercial starter cultures were made about 1890 (17). Conn, (19) answering an inquiry, stated that the question as to whether lactic acid bacteria themselves produce the aroma of butter or whether in addition other bacteria are important was not settled, but he pointed out that the so- called pure cultures are not all alike and that while most are pure cultures, some are mixtures of different organisms and that one culture contained no less than ten or twelve different species mixed together. Hammer (20) found in a number of starters, of very sat-- isfactory quality and from different sources, that more than one organism was present. Two organisms were isolated from starter which in combination gave a volatile acidity, approxi- mately, the volatile acidity secured from the starter, although each of these organisms alone gave a volatile acidity con- siderably below the volatile acidity produced by the starters. Hammer's work (17) showed that organisms in addition to Streptococcus lacticus are necessary in a good starter. The importance of these forms is evident from their ability to produce a satisfactory starter when either one or a mixture of the two are grown in combination with Streptococcus lacticus. The names of these organisms, as prOposed by Hammer, are Streptococcus citrovorus and Streptococcus paracitrovorus. The productian of a desirable starter seems to require the action of Streptococcus lacticus and one of the associated organisms.- The variation between starters and pure cultures of Streptococcus lacticus, in the per cent total acidity that is volatile at various times during the ripening period, offers another method of proving that starters are not pure cultures of Streptococcus lacticus (17). It is thought that the failure to maintain such a balance in practice is undoubtedly one of the reasons why unsatisfactory results are so frequently secured. SUMMKIY'OF REVIEW OF LITERATURE Cream ripened to a high degree of acidity is no longer tolerated by manufacturers of quality butter. Results from investigations show that butter made from unripened, pasteurized, sweet cream will maintain its quality during storage to a high degree, while butter from ripened, pasteurized cream usually deteriorates materially. As to flavor, investigators find that for the first two or three months ripened cream butter is preferred to sweet cream butter, but the longer the butter was kept, the less marked becomes the difference. OBJECT OF THE EXPERIMENT The object of this experiment was primarily to determine: 1. The effect on the keeping quality of butter when starter has been added to sweet cream butter at the time of working. 2. The effect on the keeping quality of butter when starter has been added to sweet cream Just before churning. 3. The effect on the keeping quality of butter when sweet cream has been ripened to 0.3 per cent acidity. 4. The effect on the keeping quality of butter when sweet cream has been ripened to 0.5 per cent acidity. 5. The effect of acidity on the composition of the butterfat. 6. The effect of acidity on the nitrogen-cue substance in the resulting butter. 10 PLAN OF EXPERIMENTAL WORK Preparation of'Starter Mother Culture._ To find which organism was best suited for use in this work a number of different cultures were ob- tained. These were propagated for about two months. At the end of this period it was decided that the culture furnished by Professor Hammer of the Iowa State College was best suited for the experiment. Clean quart bottles were filled two-thirds full of skim milk, heated to 190° F. and held for one hour at that temperature. The bottles were then cooled to 70° F. At about 4:30 P. M. the cultures were examined and the best was transferred to the bottles of skim milk by means of spoons which had previously been boiled in water for an hour. Enough of the culture was used so that the milk would be curdled the next morning. The cultures were allowed to ripen over night at a temperature of 720 F. .As soon as the cultures were curdled they were placed in a refrigerator, the temperature of which was 40° F., and were held at that temperature until time for trans- ferring the cultures in the afternoon. The skim milk to be used for starter for the problem was heated in a glass lined starter can to a temperature of 190° 1. and held for an hour at that temperature. It was then cooled to 72° F. and inoculated with one per cent of the mother culture. As soon as the skim.milk was curdled and the curd sufficiently formed it was stirred and then cooled with water. 11 Preparation of Cream for Churning As soon as the cream was received it was weighed and mixed in a 200 gallon Wizard vat. A,test was made to deter- mine the degree acidity of the cream. A vat test was also made on the cream to determine the butterfat content. It was then pasteurized by heating to a temperature of 145° F. and held for 30 minutes. degular observations of the thermometer were made so as to keep the temperature as constant as possible. The cream was cooled by water until it reached a temperature of 60° r. and ice was used to cool the cream to 40° F. at which temperature it was held over night. The following morning the vat of cream was agitated so that the cream was thoroughly mixed, after which it was divided into five lots, each containing 256 pounds of 40 per cent cream. The method of treating each was as follows: Dot 1. This creamtnas churned sweet, and a sample of butter saved from it to be used as a check. Dot 2. This cream was churned sweet and starter was added to the butter before working at the rate of three per cent of the weight of the butterfat. The starter was mixed with the salt. The salt was then added to the butter and the working process continued. Dot 3. Starter at the rate of three per cent of the weight of the cream was added to the sweet cream just before churning. Dot 4. The sweet cream was warmed to 70° F. in the vat 12 and starter added at the rate of twenty per cent of the weight of the cream. The cream was ripened to an acidity ranging from 0.3 to 0.35 per cent and then cooled to churning temperature and held for at least two hours. Dot 5. The sweet cream was warmed to 700 Fa.in the vat and starter was added at the rate of twenty per cent of the weight of the cream. The cream was ripened to an acidity ranging from 0.45 to 0.52 per cent. It was then cooled to churning temperature and held for at least two hours. The Churning Process A.8implex churn of 125 pounds capacity was used. The churning temperature was reguhsted so that it would require from 50 to 60 minutes for churning. The temperature ranged from 46° F. to 56° F. The butterfat content of Lots land 2 was 40 per cent; Lot 3, 38 per cent and Lots 4 and 5, 33 per cent. The churn was stopped when the butter granules varied from the size of wheat to corn kernels. The buttermilk was then drawn off and the butter allowed to drain thoroughly. The wash water was sprayed over the butter using as much water as there was buttermilk. The temperature of the water varied from two to three degrees below that of the buttermilk. The butter was washed twice in all churnings. The amount of salt added to the butter was four per cent of the weight of the butterfat. The wet salting method was used, the salt being sprinkled over the butter. The 13 butter was worked until it had a compact body and a tough, waxy texture. Axmoisture test was then made and the butter worked so as to have, as near as possible, a 15.95 per cent moisture content, care being taken not to injure the body of the butter. Preparation and Care of Samples When the working process was completed, five one pound samples of each churning were taken and placed in pint Seal- right containers. In taking the samples care was exercised to obtain as uniform a sample of the butter as possible. The samples were marked for identification and were dated. The samples were placed in cold storage at a temperature averaging 0° F. during a twenty-four hour period. Judging the Butter The butter was scored by Professor P. 3. Lucas and the writer. The hatter was scored after a storage period of one day, one month, three months, and will be scored again at the end of a six months storage period. The score was made of flavor only, 45 points being allowed as a perfect score. The other points in the score card were allowed as perfect, hence in the tables, scores are given completely. Chemical Analysis In addition to scoring the butter a number of chemical 14 tests were made to determine if there is a relationship between these tests and the keeping quality of the butter. The following analyses were made: amino-nitrogen content, total nitrogen, acid number, iodine number, Reichert Meissl number, and the Kries test. The amino nitrogen content of butter was run to determine the change, if any, in the nitrogenvous substance of the butter after a storage period of three months. The amino nitrogen content of butter is eXpressed as the per cent of the total nitrogen. In order to express the amino nitrogen in per cent of the total nitrogen, the total nitrogen content of the butter was also determined. The acid number, iodine number,.Reichert Meissl number, and the Kries test were run on the butterfat after a storage period of three months. This was done to determine whether or not the numbers had changed any from those determine when the butterfat was fresh. The acid number is the number of cc. of .l N. Na.OI required to neutralize the acids in 100 grams of butterfat. The iodine number is the per cent iodine absorbed by the butterfat. The Reichert Meissl number is the number of co. of’lfl. NaOH required to neutralize the soluble volatile acids in 5 grams of butterfat. The Kries test is a measure of the oxidative rancidity in fats. Because this test is only qualitative, the results of this test are determined by the intensity of the color which is obtained. 15 Allof the following tests were run in duplicate. Analysis on Cream As soon as the cream was received the Babcock test for determining the butterfat content of the cream was made. it the same time a Mann's acidity test was made of the cream. “I Analysis on.Buttermilk n.3abcock test was made of the buttermilk to determine the butterfat content. Skimmilk bottles were used, and when the butterfat content was too high, milk bottles were used. Analysis of Butter Preparation of sample. The same of butter was com- pletely melted by placing the closed jar in water at 100° to 1100 F. It was then removed from the warm water and stirred until the butter solidified. Determination of Moisture, Butterfat, Salt and Curd The butter was analyzed for moisture, butterfat, salt and curd by the gasoline extraction method (21), which is a slight modification of the Kohman method (22). Determination of Amino Nitrogen For the determination of the amino nitrogen in the butter the procedure suggested by Ferris (23) for the prepara- tion of the sample was followed. ‘A 50 gram sample was weighed 16 in a 250 cc. glass stoppered bottle while the sample was of such consistency that it could be poured and yet not have any separation of the fat and curd. The bottle was next filled to the shoulder with petroleum ether. The fat was dissolved by shaking vigorously and the curd allowed to settle in a compact mass at the bottom by allowing it to stand for twenty-four hours. The other layer containing the fat was siphoned off. To the residue was added 2.5 cc. of ten per cent acetic acid, 15 cc. of a saturated solution of picric acid, and enough distilled water to make a volume of 50 cc. The mixture was then filtered and the amino nitrogen determined by the use of the Van Slyke micro apparatus. Determination of Total Nitrogen The method followed in determination of total nitrogen was the Gunning method as given in Methods of Analysis (24) with the modification suggested by Scales and Harrison (25) for the absorption of the ammonia evolved. This involved the use of four per cent boric acid solution for the absorption of the ammonia and the use of brom-phenol as an indicator when titrating with standard sulphuric acid. The sample used was a portion that one prepared for the amino nitrogen determination. .Analysis of Butterfat Preparation of sample. About one-half pound of butter was placed in a beaker and kept in water at a temperature I yv K. . . V ¥. . M ‘. . \, 17 not higher than 1100 F. When the butter was melted, the layer of melted fat was filtered through a dry filter paper held in a hot water funnel at a temperature not higher than 100° F. Determination of Reichert heissl Number The Leffman and Beam method was used, as given in Methods of Analysis (24). Determination of Iodine Number The Hanus method was used as given in Methods of Analysis (24). The sodium thiosulfatc solution was standard- ized against potassium bromate, potassium dichromate, and electrolytic c0pper. Determination of Acid.Number About a ten gram sample of the melted fat was accurately weighed. Fifty cubic centimeters of a mixture of equal parts of neutral alcohol and benzene was then added. The mixture was next titrated with standard sodium hydroxide using phenolphthalein indicator. The number was calculated so as to be expressed as a number of cc. of .l N. NaOH in 100 grams of butterfat. Benzene was used with the alcohol because Steele and Sward (26) found that this combination was preferable to alcohol alone in that the end point of the titration was much sharper. 18 Test for Oxidized Fat (Kriee Test) (27 a 28) Ten centimeters was measured into a test tube and ten centimeters of concentrated hydrochloric acid was added and the mixture shaken for thirty seconds. Ten cubic centimeters of a freshly prepared one per cent ether solu- tion of phloroglucinol was added and the mixture shaken as before. The mixture was allowed to stand. .A recognizable red or pink shade in the acid lever was regarded as a positive test and a faint orange or yellow color was re- garded as a negative test. 19 REJULTS AKD DIJCUJJION Curd Content Casein, albumin, ash and lactose are commonly, though incorrectly called "curd" by the buttermaker (21). The curd content of butter is determined and ex- pressed in one or the other of two entirely different ways, which yield results in per cent curd, that differ from one another. One method is to determine the nitrogen content of butter, and by multiplying the analysis by the factor 6.38, the result is taken as per cent protein. This represents the true curd content. The other method is to determine the per cent curd by difference, that is by deducting the sum of the per cent of fat, moisture, and salt from 100. In this case the per cent curd so obtained embraces, aside from the pro- tein, also the traces of ash, acid, and lactose contained in butter. This is termed physiological curd (38). The results in Table I are expressed as physiological curd. The average results show a range from 0.96 to 1.09 per cent curd in the different lots of butter. The sweet cream butter had the lowest average curd content while the butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added to the butter at the time of working had the highest curd content. The average curd content of the different lots showed only a slight difference. The range is so small that no fear need be held that any method discussed herein will affect the curd con- tent of the resulting butter. mm. Ho.H om. mo.H mm. oo.H mo.H mm. om. mm. OH.H mm. oo.H mm. 3. oo.H OH.H mm. on.” oo.H mm. no.H oo.a oa.a no. em. N0.H mm. mm. as. mm. ¢oea 0m. oo.a mm. ¢O.H um. mm. OH.H Hm. OH.H oo.H mm. oo.H no.H mm. oo.H meoa hm. ¢O.H Ho.H mo.u do.a mo.H oo.a mm. mm. hm. NM.H oo.H «Coa neon ¢O.H H5.H mo.H m 909 6 non n #09 N van H 90A ameouem «soouem paoouom pseoumm pneoumm encouom unease .HHN .HN .N QMH .HHHb omdeobd newmcm ueHMcm amHMeMi.oo«uom eoaamm season common seamen H'Hli .HHb .Hb .enoesoo when .> .H mamwa .bH .HH m vsoonnmwaseenom encouom uncouem aneonom «see no .HHH noanom no new no new no new .H 21 Amino Nitrogen Determination The Van Slyke method for the determination of amino nitrogen depends on the fact that nitrous acid reacts with free amino groups liberating nitrogen gas which is measured in a special burette. This method determines the amino ni- trogen and also some of the free ammonia. It is found that the amount of nitrogen displaced from a protein by nitrous acid is a very small fraction of the total nitrogen but that as hydrolysis proceeds and the amino groups become free, the amount steadily increases. The most common linkage by which amino acids are held together in the protein molecule is that involving their amino and carboxyl group and is called the peptid linkage. During the hydrolysis of a protein decomposition product, this linkage splits, giving rise to a carboxyl group and an amino group. Ferris (23) found that the amino nitrogen content of sweet cream butter was 1.4 per cent of the total nitrogen while buttermade from neutralized sour cream had a content of 3.3 per cent of the total nitrogen. The average results of the amino nitrogen determination showed a slight increase with the exception of lot 4, but the increase in any case is too small to show any significance. The average results in terms of ascending values of the amino nitrogen and ammonia determination are lots 1, 2, 3, 5 and 4. 5N.N Hp. na.~ ¢O.N mm.H mm.m N>.N m¢.N nm.m. mo.N no.m b».H um.N meow nm.n mb.m mN.H dn.a mm. bo.H Hu.¢ mn.a op. om.N ¢N.N No.» 0N.N ¢¢oa OH.N Ho.u mn.a on.“ «God bn.N coca Np.N mo.a ma.n m¢.n me.~ a~.~ as.« em.” as.” an. an.” e~.n ee.s en.m as.e em.H 0H.h OH.“ #u.H nmou heed muoa Ho.a dmoa mo.N NH.N om.» we.“ um.N No.“ nmoa mo.n om.a H¢.n hm. nH.H on.” noon on.d mood nb.N adod n¢.H used am. «mod vhoa mm.a mm.H Hp.a mb.H m¢.a ob.a hH.N co.“ am.H mm.a «N.H up.a m¢.m mm. meod ho.a pN.N on. Hp.” oo.N Nn.H mo.a mh.H amen mm.H mm. HN.H mo.H Hm.» mo.H 0N.N hm.H mn.N Nn.H mmoH om.n owed mN.H nmod an. am.a mm. Na.a who mm.» mu. OH.H nh.N demon»: done». no name you so does... and 55» we was .3 emahchd .HHN .HN 9N .MH .HHHb .HHP .H> .b .bH .HHH .HH .H anoouom soonom £398 £833 «soenom pneoumm pdoouom $8.8m 0395.» 930qu .aee om ee a . as cm as a ease om see H uses cm were H same om .awe a .oanom eweuovm 5. .159 germ 5 can. omeucvm 3 3.3 ewuuovm 3 can. emeucvm a.“ .59 LE e as E E 2% .flowvgeven 39.3.3 and: He nude-ea .HH an. .H. 23 Nitrogen Determination Nitrogen in butter is found in the non-fatty portion and also in the portion of the butter that contains the lecithin. The lecithin content is very small and, therefore, contains only a very small amount of nitrogen. The larger portion of the nitrogen is found in the non-fatty portion of the butter. . Richmond (31) found that the average nitrogen content of sweet cream butter was 0.1000 per cent while that of ripened cream butter was 0.1320 per cent. The results of nitrogen determination are given in Table III. The average of each lot for the nitrogen content are shown in Figure I. The average results of each lot showed that sweet cream butter has a lower nitrogen content than that of ripened cream butter. The results also show that the nitrogen con- tent of the butter is slightly higher after a storage period of three months. 24. $00. 0000. 0.80. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. H000. 90.834 4000.. 0000. 0000.. .300. 0000.. 0000. 0000.. 0000. 0000. H000. .HHH 3.00. H000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 300. 0000. H000. .HH 0000. 0.000. .0000. 0.80. 02.0. 0000.. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. .H .300. «000. 000.”. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. H000. «000. .NH 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 030. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. .39 0000. 0.80. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. H000. 0000. H000. 0000. .25 0.30. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. H000. 0000. .9 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. .b 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0.30. 0000. .5" $00. :00. 0000. .0000. 0000. 0400. 0000. 0000. 0000. 0000. .HHH 000.". 0.30. 0000. 0000. 300. 0000. 0000. 0000. 00.00. 0000. .2" «000. 0000. 0000. 0000. 300. 0000. H000. 300. 0000. 0000. .H 69.8. 50.3. «Econ 33qu £898. .5930 noon... noon? «80qu noon... ...om 8." ....8 ....n 9.38 .3: .088 .3” .038 .3" 3.2.0 .9330 a 05.0 00.330 5 .50. 00.9300 3 I50. 0033.0 a clue 230 a 35.0 IIIIIE v 3P E E 000.0% .uouadnuauooon #909300 no .3300 .HHH a MICHIGAN STATE COLLEGE ' V f v—fi *Tv' * VT' va vv 'Y' v “MW>¢ --¢ L“...._._-.. +4 0 - 0w 0 - -.- . 0 . 07-. o—o MH;o—v+ Mo—fl—o‘w Yw .. #4 A V ...—0.0 “-0.4 W-—_a-p.—.+o-<.l ..--. - . -. . .0—0-«-4—0f00-0-0—004444740-0—00—0—0—0o4 ;.— A A 4‘ V; A ....-.; .-. -. ,.,- - --‘<—.—~~—--»-- “00—0-44 - f .0.. - L -.. .7-“ . . ‘ A... -.-. .-. 0. . . .. . ,4 t . . ~ ~ c 0 . - « r . ~ . . -—_JL—._.—0-o—o-o—o-+—o—§ .__..._.._~..70-1 .--.-.n..-”.-.--_-.,_...._ .... I _,.-,., , ... ..... ._ . ... ....._ .. .. . . ... }-. ...0 --....--...._0. i. .-0. 0. ..07-----=.-__.‘..---._0._,......--.H—o—roq .. . ...... -o.7--.——7---L--.-a-....-0....4.-.0....7 .--..a-._0..i.-.-_.......-. "4.,.--.._.--..,_._.,-......-.--4 ' 0 0 . . . ._ . . a 4 ...-- ... ‘ O ‘ .. u - on e j .....--_. t ....--... , ..- ..- . O --<‘rv—-- . -—Oo‘§--v—-.-o<-0- o+-——+-0—oo-~o.¢ov~o--.o0»4}—-.+050--§-0‘-—~—~4- -—~——-—- -.-». o~---—o .7o—o—0—.—---->~o .——-—~}-.—0»¢—9 --.—~—.-.v.—-—--——o——-—< a ....-... - ~~-—-~o—.—.’< - ~-~.-.~.—- »t~. —-—.—»b-~~+ -~-.-.7~—H.-.. —.-_. »—-—0-.$~.-.—- -—-—-——-- 0-—-—---.—-——-~-. --—----.._ ... ..-. . . .... . . ... .‘.._--- -..- , )-..._-.,._f.__ .‘h._,,n.+_.__--‘__,.-.._.,._-,-.’,‘P___H.......,--,.___.-_4 .. ...--l.- .. . . m 7...” .7. . 7....-7... 0--...-..-000..7.--...0.-. 7--.---.-.,7‘. --..- V . -..n.-....,.----.__._-.--4 L- -- _. . . - . . . . . . . . . ‘ i. . . . . . .7. - - u. . - -7 ....—. H -- .7k._--._...._.. -..-4 -7..- 0+0 ..- . .7-_...._...._._- ... . .-.—..- ... _ -. , - ...—‘77-.- - ... ...—.... ._- -.. . . ....--n-k-..‘ . - - - . . . . - . . - - . . - - - . . . . . . . . - . - -. s 0 . . 0.0-. - . - -.---40- 9 H “#0 -.--{0u ...—0+. 0.000. --0—0 . ---. - -_._‘_-..—. ... fr --- .., F.--” ‘+-_...,._._,.,.-.. ,. y-h—‘yw-04 . y..---... _- _ . .. . . . . . . .. ..0......... r-._._._...--_. ._._-.._.---_...4 5.-.. . . - . . . . . . . . . . . . +3»- .- f... . --a... -.-—.7‘._.... ...... -..—.-_+ >—.---—~‘.--...--.- .-.. -. ... . . 04-—0.--.\_§--—._._..-- .---o—WHH .-.- - . . 7 . . . . . , . O-.. L 00,“- --.-..ll... “-..... 5...--- . - . . . - . . 7 . . . . . . . .A A- . . . . If . - . - .~-—-- .-. ._._..- t-.--.-.._0__._. . — --.—o .~._.._4.- .-.... o . ..h... o-.- -r.--_~-—.—- -.~.—.-+..—.—o—.—o—. L~0~~ »o v- . . < . - - . - - - ~~ 4 . ~ . - Q - 7_ . 07.7,. ...._....r y. ..7-.----_.0 ....»-._---_,. -~....0_-.._-. .7- ~f-.----—. ._.-.. .-- 9—. 0H. -—0——.~—4 .- ....p, .4 . 0 ._... --. .-...- 0-00- .. -H » A > u v . v \ 5 n . I n I v T y—o-o-o—o—f‘ . . o-v—Qv—y—ovo-H . . f f 1 . b 1 1 t I 1 Y 0 Y t i i ! O . '1 YTY 5 . I r . Y 3 i l . ----...--.- 4... ....- .- . ... ... .7-- .. .0004 4—. >«»0...—.-.~-—.—. >.0-..-..—--- ..-... a..._._ .--- .-.--...,_ ....... . . -.. . .. _- . .--- -.y.-.-.a-_.-. .0..... - ....... . L r A V ’ ’ ' 1 0.0... --. . 4 ... -- .-----.$-..--.-..-.. .0—0—«s- >-H.-.—ik-~u---7.-.... .c >7H-0—.----..-..-. .. . . .7-. ~-.—.'.- 00-4.07... *-.--0- ...... -- 9.---.7- -7.+- - a“-.-.4~..b-_ .. .0. . k -. ‘ .¢.o—-—¢400.—-.—p~-—- -7-+0-.— L~o—o—.—.._.—..~y-.—.-.4‘H—4-. F-.. o—. 0- -+-. . l . - . . . . q -0 & .-.7H. -..-.0—0- 00—07“ .—..—.0 i-..._.._¢ '0 H Q—o 00-1-0 o—o—o—o L- -fi—c-< - - . . . . a . . - - ~ 7.‘ v - 7. «Ha—.— .-. L0 ._0 ..-.——.—-—04 o—o ...—00-- ....-.-_4 ".0 .7-_..,_. --. - - -. . . . . - - - . . .a - . . .—- '0. a ".0. . >4 .—. ..----. 9 00—4 L4 H—._._.. ...-_- 9—.4_. -—.—o_..4 - .-. ---.----. .. -. . -. -.-.-.._o 04’0—0b--~.—.-. >.-.—._..4—o—oo—.- >-H4—0....——§_--._.0-_-.-.... r7-4 - . -..” . - . . . --. . . . . +- --. -- . ...—... - .—.—.——..- . . . “4—. -..--_..—.—_. H-0--¢-—. ‘u—-—~—4—.~—.—4§~— .-....»h-‘ -- . - . - . » .7. . . 7 . . y- .- . -4070. L ...—o H.0—-._. r--‘ .7.-. -_0 -4 a. .—- 0+4... ...- .....- . 0....-. WwM-0—_._._- -.. _ fl-.- -_._. 1, ¢ . A a U'V'VV fr ? ymHFQ-n oQ—oo—o»o V'va ,__ v L ‘ ... -- -.-... ‘. . ..-.._.__._._... - .-. v b - . 70v-_._. -.. pa '4 4 -.- p- --....4 4—.—..'.0+._._4+_.+. 4 0 }0 0—0 HH—o—O +< . . { “o7- qa§~ owp‘Vo—ov—o—HH7—o 00W §-o-.—o-HV—.+o—. yo-H>-.H0.§—o-~.4 000-L’A‘0.7H¢- . - A' A ' A_. .. -’_..7._. 5- 000—.00—‘+,. l , v7 4 ...0-. .—00a-§—.‘< ~o..-.~< t—q< 0. coo-0»- - - »--—o—-7—. {£0 o—o—H—o —-—. 60—04 ‘Q-OrG—o—‘ 4 -+. .9- 0 o—o—H $.40»- -. -H a—--{}— A‘-‘O—‘~Q'h»‘—LO—H«-‘.~HV 4 O»~'-O-fl‘§‘*0—4‘¢OO~ ~0~ .._._......- +7uo-0—w..—.0. p...... -.—+.—-.. NH—H- 04 .—0. . ~.—.—o< o—o.+ .— v' - +Qip—o—o 0.. Q . -..—W H y. 0—0.—0—0—.—fl—+—-~——0-0~—.< +J » ~ 00-.—- .---.—. 4.. .... .—. 0% *‘Y‘ ...... o - —-o $+—->~+~0—.--- H —-a~—.—-——~.—0.~vu 0--—-¢o~.—-,— .H-.--A.0—. o 00+0~0H ~r .. -—o—. H7 .0 -.... .—--.. L_._._..-.. l4--.._-.-_._._._-_._ . ..--.. - .-¢ . ‘ .4”. 4. .¢.. 0 'P -. -...... . 5 . 5--.0.._0.0-..04y... ..--..‘vv . 0 --.._—_.-. -- -¢~ov—o.—.7.—o+~.—u. 4--o< - . V 0.7-... -;- .-.. .—+—o—-——- --¢—-—A——¢~—o—-o--+-o--->-o-—--o—'—{ 7‘ .-. --- ._... . ,.-.._._._.-.. . . 4 . -..---0... . ..-.-.__.._...{ A f v o-...a.~.o-~4 A - - a..0‘—._... A .4... . b.7070 - 0 -.-...._.__.._._. - v} t. q} .. vv .. 0! cl . .. .. ,. .. w—po .. .. .. a. 'r' ’Y .. ID .. i ,, o. I . -..* 0 .... a—fi' . 0. .-.----.qu i- ._.._. .. -_. , -...l.-._...... .4-..-...- ”00—. . ..- 9 0 v T’T'H y V~H“-+.—b‘ 0 vv 0 ... ........._g .9, .__._‘>_ i ... .00-». .....Y 0.: .-40H.-..........-- ~7-7-.~-—.--—..-.- 777..-... ....V--m-+—4—o—-o~ A>1 4' -. .-nl.... . .. .... A ..0.......... -..... 7. ...-..----.-,._-_-.,...,...01 ......---.... L.._._-7.7....i4_----..-.. .~-.-a..-7-0.§...-4_. -0- ...-Pa . - y - . ..--—.—— . -~~-»7v.0——~y-»~—-———v—~.—-~A4 ., r. can ,, . roaen.-- --- A V ' ._.__¢._-_ .- ...- -.-..-.-. o4 -‘- .<--- >0o0-..-.tk-0¢0..--l.‘.-.---.. -. ...7-.-...n ... 740.0 '—-——_-—.-¢--.1 ; .....- --.-.. . .----H.V...--._._-_-.--. 1 . . ... . . .7'. 00--.-.. -. 4—0-00—0 —--—4—0~-. 0- .........i. .---___.._. .-0-<—-—$o—o—~0—-¢-.—-V:1 -40 - - . . . .? .. - 0 ¢ .-..-_-_ -.- ...~,. ¢ 6 0+70-0-o-0—.—o—._... ..HF.A7.-.—‘ . 0 0 _-*‘,‘_ . 0 .-. 0 0 .0 0 4—9 4 0 o 0 o-owA-b—Q—f 1.0—. 00—0-0-04—0 70+F-O--4‘.b- +.+...‘..+..._ _ A A A AA A A A A L L A A A *+'~4 40.... «.——.—¢—o-¢—¢o- 0 AAAAAAJALAA A A..- ALA“ AAAAAA‘AA. DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS Reichert Meissl Number Since the method used in securing the Reichert Mbissl Number is only an arbitrary one, it is essential to adhere strictly to the conditions of Operation as laid down, it comparative results are to be obtained, and, by so doing, over 80 per cent of the soluble volatile acids in butter can be secured in the distillate. I Jensen (32) states that the Reichert Meissl process yields with butterfat 85 to 88 per cent of the total butyric, 24 to 25 per cent of the caprylic, and 85 to 100 per cent of the capric acids. The amoint of soluble volatile acid is likely to increase with the age of the sample (32). Butyric, valeric, caproic, and capric acids are the only acids present in fats that can be distilled without decomposition under ordinary pressure. These acids have comparatively high boiling points, but owing to their vapor pressure they can be readily distilled from aqueous solutions with steam and are termed "Volatile" acids (32). The quantity of soluble volatile acids is influenced to a notable extent by the seasons of the year, the nature of the feed, the period of lactation and the idiosyncrasy of the cow (33). The results of the Reichert Meissl determination are égiven in Table IV. All of the results fall within the (ordinary values obtained by other workers. The minimum and Inaximum range of the Reichert Meissl Number given in 27 Fundamentals of Dairy science (34) are 23 and 36 respectively. All of the samples showed a slight decrease in soluble volatile acids at the end of a three months storage period. Figure II shows the average number for each lot at the end of a one day storage period and also at the end of a three months storage period. The.average of each lot gave a lower number at the end of a three months storage period than for a one day storage period. This is the reverse of what was ex- pected since it has been found generally that the soluble volatile acids increased with the age of the samples. However the differences are so slight that they may be due to esperimental error. It is nevertheless interesting to note the slightly lower values in each case after a storage period of three months. 28 88.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 3.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 .8384 88.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 3.8 3.8 8.8 .888 88.8 3.8 8.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 88.8 80.8 3.8 3.8 .8 8.8 8.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 .8 88.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 3.8 88.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 an 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 .8888 8.8 88.8 88.8 8.8 88.8 88.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 .88» 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 88.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 88.8 .88 8.8 8.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 88.8 88.8 88.8 88.8 88.8 .8 8.8 88.8 88.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 .8 8.8 8.8 88.8 88.8 8.8 3.8 8.8 8.8.8 8.8 88.8 .82 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 88.88 . 88.88 88.88 .88 8.8 88.8 88.8 88.8 3.8 8.8 8.8 8.8 88.8 88.8 .8 338 8.88 888 8 888 in .828 08328 5 259 owuuovm 5 8.3 oweuoam 3 839 088.83%. 5 8.2. ¢ we“) n #3 Lmfloca H Forum .8988 5 nag ”mow 53.339.3on Hauaatonoaom Ho avgom .bH a IEthb-uuu.-u-. 4’ MICHIGAN STATE COLLEGE - DEPARTM ENT OF MATHEMATICS 30 Iodine Number (Hanus) The amount of unsaturated fatty acids in a butterfat is greatly influenced by the kind of oil or fat given to the cow with the food (53). Heineman (35) found that the iodine number was irregular in the beginning, then increased gradually to within two or three months of the end of lactation, with a rather sharp rise during the last few weeks. The coincident increase of the melting point is probably due, as Eckles and Shaw (35) suggest, to a decrease in volatile acid such as butyrio which has a melting point below that of oleic acid. The unsaturated acids and their glycerids assimilate halogens with the formation of saturated compounds, and tLis' property serves as a basis:br their quantitative determination. The structure of unsaturated acids, particularly the position of the double bond in relation to the carboxyl group, influences the iodine absorption. If the double bond is located at a considerable distance from the carboxyl the results are generally normal but when relatively close together, the iodine number is likely to be below theory, although lengthening the absorption period increases the results (32). The minimum and maximum iodine number, as given in the “Fundamentals of Dairy écience" (34), are 26 and 38 respectively. The results of the iodine number are given in Table V. The iodine numbers for the first five series are very abnormal. Precautions, such as using acetic acids which showed no reduction with dichromate, were used. The sodium 31 thiosulfate solution was standardized by three different methods. The samples of butterfat were weighed into clean, dry, iodine flasks. The reason for the abnormal numbers for the first five series is unknown. The possibility of its being due to feed could not be determined because the source of the cream was unknown. All of the samples showed a slight increase at the end of a three months storage period. Figure III shows the average iodine number for each lot at the end of a storage period of one day and also after a storage of three months. The average of each lot gave a higher number at the end of a three months storage period. 52 bo.mn om.¢n o¢.¢n em.nn mm.¢n hm.dn mm.mn hn.mn «m.hn no.0» hH.Qv so.o¢ ne.o¢ .g. hm.mn p09¢n Hm.¢n ¢O.¢n Nb.¢n m¢.mn «0.0» dd.mn mm.mn n¢.mn om.m» ma.en ma.¢n ma.nn 2.3 me.mn mfl.mn He.on na.an oo.mn mo.o. «e.mn mn.o¢ an.bn mm.nn «con» Hm.nn Nd.¢n no.0n ph.mn OH.mn ma.mn ¢m.on 0H.nv mmomd oo.m¢ na.mn nnpdn omodn Hm.nn No.6» meow» #a.mn mu.pn NN.mn ea.mn no.0d ouoqv mm.o¢ «pom! 53033008 Pace—5h 33H no and—mom N¢.hn kn.¢n bmonn moon» meomn Ah.nn cdonn on.on nm.mn firoon Hd.N¢ mh.H¢ no.n¢ am.mn ou..» os.en a~.«n oo.¢n ao.¢» mm.on am.on sans» mm.an am.m» em.mn mH.Q¢ 99334 . HHN .Hu 9H .NH .HHHP .HHb .Hp g .bH .HHH .HH .H LHIWAHT Ab MHNdH hmm A aHumoa Ham H muflm on name A weaken nwauovm me «use omauoam :4 «may MICHIGAN STATE COLLEGE - DEFARTM ENT OF MATHEMATICS Acid Number The acid number of oils and fats varies with the purity, age, amount of hydrolysis, and oxidation they have undergone, Contact with fermenting or decaying matter, such as animal tissue, casein of butter and the mare of fruits, tends to rapidly increase the amounts of free acids due to fat splitting enzymes. Acidity in fats is not always a measure of rancidity, as hydrolysis may result from the action of enzymes in the presence of moisture without accompanying oxidation, which appears necessary fro the production of strong smelling, acrid tasting bodies that usually characterize rancid products (32). However, in the case of butterfat the development of free acids has fre- quently been termed rancidity; hydrolytic rancidity accord- ing to the terminology used by Palmer (36). The limit of error in the determination of the acid number as given by Holland (32) of the Massachusetts Ex- periment dtation is 0.10 milligram. The acid number of butterfatqgiven by Palmer (36) is 0.56 milligrams of potassium hydroxide per gram of fat, or eXpreSSed in cubic centimeters of 0.1H sodium hydroxide per 100 gram of butter- fat, it is about 10. The results of the acid number determination are given in Table VI. The acid number for lots 1, 2 and 3 showed very little difference during a storage period of three months. Figure IV shows the average acid numbers for 35 each lot at the end of a one day and also a three months cold storage period. The average of lots 1, 2 and 3 showed a slight decrease after a cold storage period of three .months. The acid numbers for lots 4 and 6 are very much higher than for the first three lots. Lot 6 is higher also than let 4. The lines on the graph of the acid numbers would lead to the belief that a relationship exists between the acidity of the cream and the acid number of the butterfat. The correlation between the acidity of the cream and the acid number was 0.428't 0.067. In this case the correlation has a value of 6.4 times the probable error. The relationship between the two factors is slightly significant so that the conclusion may be drawn that there is some relationship be- tween the acidity of the cream and the acid number of the butterfat. It may be concluded from the results of these numbers that an increase in the acidity of the cream causes a slight tendency towards a higher acid number for the butter- fat. 36 .psmuopesp mo madam 00H ma «Heads a H.o no so no seesaw as vemmcumuc suogapa an. me.mH Ha.na na.ma Aa.- «m.oa an.HH me.ofl mm.HH ma.o~ mH.HH .meunne mm.eH mo.ms He.ea ms.eH a~.ns «m.~H oe.~H am.ma am.~H no.~a .HHM ne.na mH.eH mo.na an.nm mo.ma H¢.NH mH.mH ne.ma mo.ma mm.ma .Hu ¢H.ea oa.efl eo.eH cages HQ.HH mm.HH mo.m~ H0.HH em.HH mm.HH .n an.es ea.oa m~.oa am.efl ea.ns ~a.na oH.nH me.na oa.m~ «m.mfl .MH eH.nH mm.nH oo.n~ an.nfl H».HH H¢.HH mo.HH we.HH an.HH me.~s .HHHp eo.mH eH.mH em.nH em.ea Ha.ms en.na em.~H ma.n~ me.md n~.nH .HHp «a.» mm.oa ae.m mm.m eo.m mo.m na.a Ho.m ma.» oa.m .Hs an.mfl an.nH em.ad ma.n~ «H.0H mm.aa ao.ofl as.HH mm.m mm.oH .s oH.m Ho.oH no.0 oa.m ma.m om.m am.» me.m «a.» mu.» .sH ma.ma mn.nm ne.~a as.nH ma.o~ en.HH am.ofl an.HH no.0a eo.HH .HHa ee.0H an.o~ me.m an.oa an.» m~.m ao.m oa.m oa.a em.m .HH «H.0H me.oH mm.m am.m ne.m sm.a mm.» mo.m em.a «e.m .H ease as (Imamnmllmumw,om has H ease cm are H nausea name A uses om are a ..«nom .935 3 83 .986 3 .59 sweat 3 .55 cannot 3 .59 $308 3 ofia ....unulenmmmw e mmmw, mmnwmmfl Miwmmw Huang .2 5388898 teased no .388 .E as MICHIGAN STATE COLLEGE V fi—v Mo—o—Q‘Aqwu—o—o—H a +~o—o 'o- - o A A A ...-H..—.. o . . Lee—”>4 -o-~¢—o_¢4—H.-c—¢-- A -+—o—. a¢¢ . ..- --v~ 0-4 m W . .-. WH‘O «H ~Hw ‘4 o~£-A+~—H+¢+ .-4 vv vyfi Hoo H¢¢o+¢+e --- ...—1 A 7.‘1 . f, ~ 4.4 9%. r L _. ..-. -.---.wy---.v.o4-.-4. --..---<.-O--.---H.. y-‘H—o&++.b.« . .H»< D-G.“>refiuooo-~* O-‘--‘-—--+4---Q—H70‘-Ov h-Hwo—“npfl 4 ..-. o-<-§-o.—A.-.~-- . 95¢»..-A‘v'-O*~VVV‘ v4 44—.- e-e—l - -‘OOI-A.O;O*Qd.~&<‘— ...-- ..-.|.-.4‘...V-. L...——‘-¢-o-.—~4 .-A-“-»qeo..-.,..-.----.r- ..§-—_-.-.-a-4 o.o——.-¢e.o~v~vv—w—-- r f . . v a . --.-----.--..v-<_._-.v--._._4 L .-—.-—o-~..-—..-...o—o—.a-->-+v-—-H—~-1-<.--+.--.-1-.....H-..a-~~----<.y-~.»-H_—._ao-a-. .—-..—.—~—.—. A VO—oo—~4—O~-6oo—-——~—o ..- «Q~4-- H»¢--o- ‘~-—..vv- - uv~--—----~.v-—~o-o—v+§- t-.--—.—o—.-vQ-o—o—.—o -~~--O—LO—-—4 ' ‘ ~O¢»e‘.--&r-..--. -'_- ._—..- . ._ ~y‘-<-—r-’- . ev‘---e¢v.- p-...._'—._._~-_ .............i.......... ..4--.“ .-.,- +.i . - -..-‘4y---—.l-.-- -L- 4..-.-- --+-a._.-,._._‘g. --....l). f o—~.—.—.1L-+.~_-A. .--;4---.. .a-_. t--..----.-.,__-......._...,a e .¢--—o.4—~—.—.—..;-.—..._._._~-. ._o_._.--.*.—-#..-.-.iar.___ .-.—.--..- .-,.-....>._A<- v ¢._..-_~.__.__ >4 ..., . -~- I.- -»o¢:o-~ ~-- H». —. an. -.. 9 - ~ — h..-.... . 4 - - - P- ~ ~ " - sp< - -¢¢ 9--0—t-4y . o->—u—+-o—a~$-~ >-—~.—4—H-— -- . ._..‘ < ‘P"‘—""" .--..1}«--.. --—. .—- f .~-—- 5—7 -.- ‘b—7H7H«.—o ...._. t-4 o—ya—ko—o .- u . .— - . - . .. . -.. o a—u- . ---—”.-...- '_.._¢._..-.._...~..._.. . o-~H—.~o- $»-¢ . . . -.._.. . .—.-...-.-¢—. .---.- . - ——.——1 voovro-e-L- - -+o+c—y ~o .3 v - . .6 > a - . ...-...- .--4 t..- H . .- §.. . a~-—o-A—o—> ~ >~-—~.—.—-—c—v~-¢--—4 - >.- «0 v hy—e-o—-~- ~H .-.. < -- 7-- 3.. ~ -ooioo-oq»o—}oo—o-a—o—- ~-s-..._._._-._.__._i A --H—~-~o-o6-- ”-...-.” po—o—->A.—.—-++..—o—~oo—.-.—. }97H7-—.—Q-0v9-6 +4 wee—v“ 9-9- f'v' r fiv v v * ‘f . . .. »‘ - -—- - - -.— -«h--. .-.—-..--.F- b44o-o —.—-H_f -->-.—~~—.-A . . (r- ...—..h. —- -J . . . -.-,.,_- . ...H‘___,, . y. --...- __A,. - «...—H. -.--..i c .-.-. -.- - -- -- - -._o-—.—~-~~.-—‘-»«H< f—.—.—._._._--- - L_‘------.g- L. -..-HVL..- iv- ...“-.. ) .~+-‘.......9—»a_....v-o—._~4 9 "" ‘ " " **‘ 1 b t ,-... .a. ... - t... |. . .. .+-- H i I. .. .... --. I _. . . v----- - »---- . .. . ... .4.-...- .......... ..-. A A _ _ b—c-— ... we §-~4--e ....- aaoo«—---" -.~.o~-~O--oo-.—.~-y. -*P-~. >.>->-¢---» .——- ~ ..-—-- .-.—9 -- e¢~-¢~-‘—' .HP-¥- -——-.-~o-vo»-—-4 «.-...- ..-.--....>-. .-....y-.. 9‘- .‘l ... » . so--.—>oo~p>co—Qo—o o—---—~« ,._-_-. Fo—w ‘«--< ea-Moo-o-ve-er-“-6-H#¢+----—+—‘o. ycc-b-A—oro-o-v—ot-4o—o—u-oO—O—1 --.-..-.,......, .....J-..... ... . B . . .-fia-a.-. ..-..¢.a._... ..--LAV-...a.a—.. -...-.....¢--(L..£ $-4_....—.—..a_._~..~ ~.———.4e-.-—v'r4.-..-~~o—~—e->- )——-+««-----tr>--r>~e-o~a-0. f‘O—-¢~e-OH y----....-..i.. ---~---t<-~--‘---f»->.-.-~—~—-4o.- ---oo‘--+«-—oo+—>—o.- y—..-.-. -.- --+-.»o—Q—~t—o—o-—‘f-H——4Ho— ‘O*‘ . a--y~o—+4—‘Oo.-o-~¢-F-fi+—o~¢*—. ."--§r-¢W 5-. ~n ~ - - - » 1 - - ~ - — « . l . . - . . - ..-t- . o— - F+-. . -». +-—.—...o §-. ‘4—o~<—--- ~ . > -¢4*. ...-. . ».—*~-~~—.-o.. .—.~+—. eo-Iao—o—v‘ L .4 —§--—.—-o--—. ~9~-+—-Ao >.vo—o—¢—.o—o~ o*++o~o*v+o1 b—o>§«o~~.e- .-- -.-.‘. ..»--o_.'.‘-~..—o-. «o o-uuhe-~Q-v—o—e >4e---— y.+¢->. 7. Fa- w-L...-.~oe--—»~LJ..<--—--~- LA.¢ >or»<-"-~—--~—+--< b—c >$e‘+—>—o—'9A.o'->o—o-o—g—o~.—O-‘~1‘ — a .--. . ~ -n . . . -a . - +s . . ,, . . —~ - he -., . HpoH—a—«fua ve-u-c-Ht»v Lao---- t—a—a—a- MA-Jb- be—+¢—o—%“9vt—O—H~—4-H to a- ...—-..- '—-- -..-.--. >ujHa—Q H-OH'O-‘QO-Q-‘w-HO-V‘ -' ---~ - .I . - -.- ——~»- 9 . - -. --+4 {4 o—- ... O—o—Q—o y—o a... pa—HH LotQHH< . y‘H ,. H‘-.—H pooa y. H—Ho-. -. y—rH-b-e40-oe—c . ..., «'7 a..- ..-,- -- M—F‘ »- HH-QH o—-)---A—v—«o-~0- ‘H 1 Lin #— >~— «..-..I. .. 5... .. ... ......- .........__.L--_..a-....-..i _._.........._. .n........-.._..L....-.,_.-. (...... .-.rni.-,..-,...k-.p ...._._._._._.r-._»._-.. .--... >---.o~-.-e """"§"“""‘ -.-..—.—.s._- ...—..+..—-4t-...H—.~._¢._) ...- -..—.....- >ao~~fi~_._.. ....-.._.+. (.-...'-_._.. .-.—.-._._....r.._._._..._-v-.—AHo-..--v—.-¢-- >v-~ -- . +1.-- . -- . L. . - -. . . . .. o._. -.. . a..~ ~ 0 “<7 ...—L... r>r¢§+H—.—O—.-‘Q< o.-- .- -.. >< v~‘- - >70 ¥~v¢—>«+4 . .—<—p.»~~.-. -+—.—{L . o—v~»——o—o—¢-a-~4 H~‘>-¢-- --......+‘ ---.....i +040‘rOeOiL4fi—AOG‘O-H‘¥~<’Aho-.v—Q--0 — L A o-o-&~¢r A.._,___.-.,, }.'--3-0—0¢—#4—0—5A~9'-+-b ...‘._ o>1 FO- .-.—.~-4«. ->0~v‘4~~{.0<~. ~.—¢-»~[-~o -_.,... t..+otHH1y¢Ho—oa—~pa« L- .‘ i..-_._._..1,-..,.-._.i.,.fl, -—¢-~-v¢o—-.—.-o >ee¢ iv" <~u ~v—‘-<-—¢~-o )0... —0—H-94>—¢—¢+0 9-0—9-0—1 5+.-o—o-<.-—e—» ..--.- ...7-7...o-0L*-- -44-.--(‘aw -—.>- b-O “who” -.. A~L-L-.—.—.—LH .+ o~<—-r-'.vo*y—v—460 to.~.-.—o—Ho~e—o—o-ooao H-a-‘~eoo--‘e ... .---'..-» .. .-¢~'.-.Q-o-va-.)».o—-o.fir».77§~w-.._54—‘—‘470~ ...—o-‘Fo— -—o—o—.—. 970+H._._~ o- t.‘ ~‘a—‘ovo «VH4-¢.y. )0H4a~o~>—o—¢v-—Q-v~~>v rose— >H-‘ o~—.L-¢..---_ '6‘D0-~V+O—OQQDO--vv+--oe )oeo—9A04Ho oo—o~‘-+-o—¢—+. , .HfH4— HH4+O-O+~‘ *6—0—-A*QO~A .4 w-o—oo-o—JL +<+~fiOo-o .7)..HN-.—-++.-....+.-—..4 -.....---.,.....,. ..J.» .-....e..-...-.~.y.a.-...... .--—.-.-...I A._. .e-.. .-..--.--.--a-.--~e........-. -- -¢.'..-¢-..o.-o>< --.ve---.--¢...+—.—H+-d A A A A LA A A v r y vv—rv—r ——v L‘-“-""*' .--~»-.§.--.-...- nv‘»o-O§ vfi—OOOHil—‘FOFODO —.7vo>.-oco- OeoeLoeoovo—OQO .--A-o—.o ;- .-o-.o—<+- ---‘rv'~ .f-ooocom.-.Lvo—a-Hsh-‘eOH-‘v-«o—beer1 &<-o i-QODO~-vtb>~ss‘ ~-.....-. +aeyeooo—c nHQ—ooov-v -o-—¢.—4—Hu.¢p.>vA fifif..ov._-.—q*- H~oH>-.Q¢.~—H+H«~)e-.+.or>.$oQ-¢Hoo—e~ove oe—e—«e—e-OOO—OO->HA*oo—o—v—v Fw»»r-...¢.....-.--‘.-...-.--Q-.-..>‘.-.J .Ao—oo.-. pope-bo-‘eb-o y+~+o ere-o‘o- ‘eW-d >M0~bo~.+b‘—A—A¢+uO—oov )c. d;.....o++~¢---..-¢ HHo—oeao—reo—ahon—o—‘Tr t 7.- 0 v. -r‘—tw»- L4 . o-c o—‘o—a—a L — o—av L~o—.-. ‘uo—o OrkH-O-e )9 a~¢ a—‘o—o—HA»- L4 -..- &-..q y>..- . ~ -.-—..- 9 oo oo—o—~——o——o++o~4—. ~++Ho—Q—~o .a--—H 'u- k t )¢—.»o—..... t.Ho—o—>~o_o>ocoo s“+’}—._.— nae—4+. yeo—o—e—te—A->~‘oeo—o-~—O<-OA¢ VQ-v- >o—p—.—1-§-o-aoao—~—¢—< 3 >o......r.. .--J 4...--. .9 A A A‘.- o-.~o+4v—.—Ho—oe-< ~-~.-.4o—.r.~~. ;—o~+-»o9s.. 'H’%%0-9 £ F‘*.O—Od-O ...e ..—+ ”-6...“ -¢ 0 ~«c—0_ -- u-wuae—ckq. -ao—ebJ—oa—o -o-o-oeoo— y ~dwoe-v--H p. ”...... “O‘)—>O-‘Qi‘r.-H.-‘ .o-qo.‘-—.—.t. . -4-H o—- ’rrf—orHfi—O“ --OO.—os-OAA a ., «o‘er—o—o—o‘ ; - 1 , L I ,....-....- ...>-.o+o—o—. b .....¢.- >ro4—«o4 -....e.o-.+.~o—4+.... »— -.. ...—... ooO¢>~~~o )oH+r»o—o—o- b ~ooo—0Fbo ‘4vo—4Q. o..v¢~b—~—O—A +<-o->~-o-- h-O ---o. :< i y---.-..-r~>—..‘-...-. } -¢A+——pa-e-A0‘4*HQQ eebon—ko—o—>~>-O .....r—r ' >¢o—v« ........,.,--. ¥ ¢—.>oo‘- -..¢¢5~+4 .-&-~..~<‘-v+-H--~i , >~.r—.—o—~-4.—4-oo—¢~o—>O—4—4r4-b—e—~e—vebeP—fihAQO-u—ve— L‘ .-o¢o 0.0 . - .e o—~ HO—O—b-c o o-< o—vL- - b-“ - c .. ---..4. >~o+—< o—.—H o o o~~ ‘f ‘—v-O———o-—o f-a o—b—o—o—H—u. p—a-o - .4 9—47”, o—o—o ——c—>v+v—( ‘ .HH—O—b-OA- . O~¢—O—o—.¢—v H 9—.— wo—o—oH 4 4 . .~._4_$—. L4 7» . k'H H‘vr ‘ '4 «......H H-4_.§+._H p-Q . -H—o—o-a. I ~-—--...oocoe.v—o»vo~Q—Hr - —¢—H.o e-t. ->79~+A79+~~4H—.-o¢--¢..~ ooeH-e—ao-v oJo-ov—ove—kvieo—og-eooo. >OH-e—#—.+-~ vH—o—Ou9"{ ""*‘““0-0"‘49“'“'O--¢a‘-a¢~-to-be--4.~§Lo+--v-~-»-.e -.-...... ""“"Y"""""' -..—........I...._.+.-- r-.— P»>O&§Ie ..-.. - ov—V~..-i.-_-..-...-.>.{y -,_,.,. ..4-...-.. -..--—..-- +>>o...v—o " "H"“'— --‘-¢ 0‘ ‘°-<‘--' >~Q~ ‘~Ob~»»~. ‘ -< +‘ L H*‘-§* o—A-b- -- *~-‘>Oo>-ol -e‘.~>e¢l oeoo.>oerur-~>o- 0.0 o>e>o-6¢- vO—va-O-O—eh >¢e-c¢.+Q-..-d-.~oeo—n+—< .Ao--o~.e—o .-.—.-oo- -.oq-‘c~.-- QQ—QQ—OV‘OOO ‘OO—HO‘O. .....E...-e~---~~—~».-- ...,..--... .9..4-...fa-.o.-.Hl.v.Hv—... _.‘—.A-.4>o-t O-0 5 «...-.....4-. .....- ..... ... .--—..-..t- .......I.>->.»_»-. ..4.~~-—I) -........4_...-_-.. ........“.....--.-r-.-.—-_-.A.¢7»H».¢—A-. a....-....,.- 9 )~--. A.--_4 o—... s . .... “.-...L-... --........._....e ....a.... -.4oc.-.-4‘Q )—-.~..--.-......-. -.a-..... ...-...... .-..-....§-...--7._--- ........-l Lo ..7-.. . ... ._ 4—. ...—..y-yo-v+—...~..*.oa—47>r-~o ... ..—.-A¢.~~l -‘~“HQ9‘ --——o-v~--v—Ir4~-~»v———v—-o §-°---O-‘*H—‘-H -...-.. -...-- . ..-7- -« .-— -.—--—..—- tr.-—~—.~A._-.-_H-_...--rho” 4- ..-”-.«e 9A~H<4~-- ...-4.4+»4—V ......._-_... t .*OrarH+h'—h—O—b—O~—‘A-OI -A...-.-._o_— L— 4.. ..-A.,.--c~-.-..- . ... ... ....-..... ....-...-‘.-..-...... . ....--.... . .>-ALF.L.-‘-- ). ....9 --..n‘..--..-.-a.,7..-v-_..—-,._._._‘—-7*-o_--- - -.............. ..... .----..i..-l...-n.---i . --.-.... ..-..... .-.-.....I...-r-<..' -.-....-...-. >"r‘~fr~*-v‘-'—‘-*O*~"-’-‘ - .i......_.......,.. ‘.n ... ..‘4-.-...p....t..-.. ...---.. . -............... ...¢.¢»»->—»77.7-a‘ . ..-... o$~-«~~——+—‘o->----~—~—~+4-t--.---- -v...... ........ . -- ......, ..... . i----.-...,..-..._.- . L...-4....ea...... L4—--.. .--..... .. i~e . -..o- once-e . )....--.........».. - +-_.-—-.-e-~~-.... _. L-..... . .---»--r— - L.— -..; -.._ -7; L _- -.. .-.. .. . .. I-.-...--.. . ......p )...... .. ..-.....-‘- .--- ..-- ,.......-.I. +..-.- .....-....l. >-.....,..,.- ...... t..-4...... .....,--. . 4‘. .i .. ...-4-..- . .-. . .. _ __...._ _ '., --.-r....e...-.---- ..-+»~-—-b—---~- ~ A__ L 1 ...“-.. . . . ....-. .-5 y... -... ... -.. .i - .._-..-.. w..q ---....- ...... ..-... ...-..._. -.e. l—‘--~~-...- ....._.... . .....--. $9. -.. . .. ... . - .-...- 6pc .-...-..-. ... ...... . ..-... ‘4»; i......i.i.:.-..,.,.. — IDQOO>¢Ooi+~OHkH—O«‘ .—.-.~~ 1 ‘-'-‘ »-....--- ......—...»._.*-¢‘-»._47L-7.4y.e—a...—o.o’-.§..—ooe>. .... - ‘ 4. I . -..-.. ........n. L..*._..... L-~_.>.-..- ..-..--.-e.. ..--.F»..- J 4 fl . .—_.__...-_._. L.“ A_._I_‘7_ 1 g ml g --.-..-. .........f........... -,,-,,-.....,,,_,_.--,.+_.-__--._ ,,-.-,-...._ ....--a-~--o‘-A-—--<» .47 -----—-—-+«er+-»~<-—0—‘k+* ._._.-.........._-...-.~. -—-- -.., . . . ...-. - -~.A'.....-.+._. >~a».o-.oooot.-....-.a-e ,-._.._,-.._.-_ ._ .....—-.L.... ... - i._--.---.......,._.r- ---¢—~—r~—~--»-el-o-O~-»—o.p— {‘-«- .,.....,,,,_,_,,, ..........-....-i-..........+._._..‘-._._-.-_....-a_-..--..... _. .-_._._.._.+-(4n4+--.~-...-.... .- Liana----.5.....-.... .-...-._.,-_..,.......-.._.... --.--.- .»-.-..-..) ..... .-..-.--...,.-p...ooan.e e¢&-0—+o-»>~o~.0vnne ‘ .--_-A-.. -¢-o—’.—o-fi—.'r- 0" H,,,,,4 . 4...--.4... ...+.._n-., -,,.rn-,.i.... }._._-...,_-.- .....-.._... L..-.... ~‘-""*-‘“‘-)“"‘°""‘ ..- " , ‘ --v .-...-.. ~.......-.a ~.-¢.-...»- poo-ovoworo c»..o-.>-oo>>.-‘—-»>r..—. 44‘7J—AAO—H"‘Jti"-O—.-*—"~Ct .-.—. ‘vrc- . o..-..-... ...-..-.. .-..eou. oo—e-..e.......>+-ro—o->...-..o- It'OOQO*O~O—Q+vr-v0—%*ro—‘—‘—‘ -—>-o--.— wan-o .~--..oo....r -.-...-- ....-- o—o -...-¢v>-. «..A-..»seA -ro—o—6*< >~ ......-.-. . a---~o-‘ - a ,- ~ ...-... .. . ..»-..... -........ .L.,-‘~L>7.L.---..o-a.-.—o—-~- -—.I-..-..-.. .-.-...--e ... . .t >— ... . A .- .. . . ”... ..-. -..-.-... . -. ..- .-..-- . T....~..-- _,,,U§OO¢—Ovrb‘heb‘-O‘-O-r~—O—O—~+H—‘O‘v ).,..o.. -....—>M.e—.-.. v .-- F*-‘k---~-.---+-.... -......-.$..---»a..>-.--...-.>-.o....-.g.«. ...._.<.. n.A.- .- -... 1 0"— "' ' "‘~—'—°—‘v——~ -. VO’OUOJ-ee>bo-Ooobn-O—O-o-O-Oo-l-6qb-oooo t—.-.e—A-— ‘7H‘O-‘q-Or-ut-n ...-.—.-.AI ——O—¢->~4-‘ ¢-*-»A--~» .....F-.... y.»h%-ohur+‘FO-->Qv‘r‘oF¢.—->~UO..‘—.¢—é‘l.—¢-v-oL}.-—A-.—‘A ....-..~.—..—o—.~- ~o¢.-..-.a§ ‘ “<—‘—o--.- .‘—-... -~."~‘-'6~—¢O4—~°Prer'-»V‘-v"-etes~~‘-~o>>¢‘~-~-r . t...-.-_. - ...—o ‘ ‘-- ' 54'~ -~-~.ao~- -..---....) >.»--*4 ...}-..-._.... ..‘ er -—v--~ - +->o_.—¢—— -.--..H-- -._......... L.>.g»‘g-.g... .-a-.....’ —e ~ *fi .....- ..g... . .. o< ....-. . e. . .... a .v. ore-or—e+. . , ...—. ‘ '5 F-*->~-o-~o-.-...---... . v-—‘+—>-———~->—4 >-‘.-‘..4.Q..-¢‘k‘.t¢ h--*‘ )e-Oco-—-r-.'_‘,_‘i.._‘..- roe-o b—o<.+.-.-. .......-.., -«.. L‘--..-g-‘.t.-,..*,.__.-4 ..r.a.»-.._-..». [e a—e-s +e... .. __._... . I r—4*r.r.~..-.Q-p—.A.—-—o—.—_.. "“ -——~‘--t~o.—.->—~—-— 0-*‘--fi-—*O-o -—.. . .--74)k-.---o-. ..-—..-aa... -....---.h-~ ....a..-.. >.—.-.L.. .. ~—¢~—‘}~-v-- ~~vs-.— )-'*'~-v'<~-.-eo-.4».-.. . .-a.._-VHV A_..-.ea_a.- -.-..AH. .».47-...... ..-‘.a_._.r.s»i <--A L " ""-"' ~‘-‘0--~ ...e.—o-c~ ...-...-.-) 1 v—~-~-«-v-~ ot.o“-.a-. >0.—.->5.t—‘Fiq~’4¢r.....g). or».——r—o—roo-+—o..~o—-4—-—#‘— 4‘-0~«..-~1-.+.—oo.e. ..l-.... O 7»H+‘*--0‘-¢~-o—~ -§~ -.o..-e—. y..-.4¢v-..o ~. «.--..4. .-.-.-- t-‘h”""“.‘""'*" ...—...-fi.f..._._.*--.- -v----4—‘~- popcoo..<.—+-.-o-~..e...t-- -.-~-.-O ----.—~«»$--- “"‘-Ov~0~oo~ ¥-+->Hr.oo)o4 .—-.-o-- ..--.4---...._-.-_¥~.vi'~ ......_. .—-7-7~.—--~-§A.>o—4~..y.. ‘-.s_.-A-_._ ,._....-.‘ .. ,.-.. .‘zlil,; ....._.,....... .... .-......—._—.oqo ..a.—..~v—..+eA-e.-e> -.—o— -)--.--. -y........-o..V.—...-.- .......-.H a.....-_. . -.---.o’.....- .-. ...... -.--.- .-.. .. s - __-7._, . ____,-‘4,7,,,H,,.‘, ...._..,. .... .. ......... A. .. ...,»-#,-,,.-,_-.., ¢_ A 5 A “"-"0‘O--4_A.---V,4A.--.,.-.. ......p..} 3.». i...§.......a.l.-.....-< w— - - ~ - e - I . . . . .. ,. . .-.-..., . ...g -.h. ..- _. . r 1- ~ .-. ~ >7»- - - - --~ ... - .....7. —-° - - — «4 ‘ ' ....a-.. - t .a ......w . . . . .-- -.--..4 ...—.-r --. --.. -,.,., a- ~ ~ . - - a4-.. - o .---..-...,...__.. ......-... .-....--- L -..—«-.., . - )‘--*-‘.~--4¢~-+-4-...- .....‘l-.. -.-g-..“ - .--... ...-.A. - i..A_‘.-..—4.-..-§-. _;.,..-.....L--.----.. ...-r...‘_._..~...~-..-._- ”"“'““"1 '4voe-.. eo+oo+§->~4ieb-eeebofl4~¢ -.—. --o4'¢--.... . L-H- ..e -.-4~. . L«+o--—.. ~ y. a ..k- «..A o #*-‘—‘* ‘ ° ‘ '4) . ‘1 - ‘ HM» WM... . ems ef-ibut Ms L L L —- 5+eV—‘04o~t -...-‘ , , 7 . .--...... .-.... .. .....-F-.....t..~-...- ”*a-o—o—aoaav—F.-.>~+— ..— I+.-4..--... -..-.,,,_ F,,,,-J,, ,.,---. .. r*_._.---_..1,*,-.. .7... G—O-hWtoOfO—o .—..—>4 Poa .-.... -¢a-- a--. ..-.....L~~.++ n..—-—.—~—o-. ; """""‘f—‘ ._- ——.—-o..>r-»e—~o.—e~vQ--r ..- s~~r>~—o—1 r---‘g.-_. ~+o-......_... ...,..-_.._.-».-.»._...._.L ,...-.,-.;.,.._-...-.. >o~ o~0*>+~L-0-¢>‘~Vo——+v- >““‘ “-“~o—.¢... .....a.... 7«-~o-ko—-L -.. .~._.~.-¢e.—.—.o—..-. r-O ....a-QH..J.o—~¢+....-t1 *0 ‘0. -~-~o e. e++a..... .4 ....g , . . .. .4 ...W.) - . -.. “.-.-n ‘47. “-..-.4 .- to er-Q-Q—o—o-o—c +¢+oa.—~—. ..¢. "‘ ‘ -* e - — ~ 6-. - aaa:.;._.4kn a-4-++, . .4‘0-4 >~“.—) .. LH‘._._.._._-...._.. .....o—o A~~.—)—. HH +Hvo H». "“"’*'+‘e—ao..-.- ....s..s-o ¢o«-+o«.~{)..e.ui n.‘..... - ..o‘+-._.-. >oo-o-Aee—oo~--{L—4——Q—H*«OH o»¢e—.e-v-+ "‘ ' ‘j'j’fl‘ ‘*—*-‘~9+-& --—.-. ..-4 o—oo-i— . «we-«94>» re~¢~oe L++t e ro—o—o-wo‘ n-Lo— .—»» —. a ”a ~+-b+¢74+~ —‘ ‘H H-t-‘W+*‘*-‘ "" **+9‘*IW*~' - ‘A A A.‘ A A A—A—AALA—AA. AAAAA AA MA AAA AA- A ALLA. A A A A Lag“ k DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS 38 Text for Oxidized Fat (Kries Test) The intensity of the Kries test of samples of an oxidized fat is proportional to the amount of oxygen it has abosorbed, or, the amounts ofht necessary for equiva- lent color intensities are inversely preportional to the volume of oxygen absorbed (27). The intensity of the Kries test is not preportional to the oxidative rancidity or tallowiness of a fat. A ran- cid fat will give a Kries test but many fats that have ab- sorbed large quantities of oxygen show only faint traces of rancidity,or none, yet give intense Kries tests.‘ Some evidence is;found to indicate that oleic acid when autoxidized, may be the only unsaturated acid in fats that gives the Kries test (28). Powick (8) found that the constituent of rancid fats responsible for the Kries test,is probably a derivative of 61p- hydrin aldehyde. It is certain that this constituent gives rise to epihydrin alehyde when the rancid fat containing it‘ is brought into contact with the concentrated hydrochloric acid used in the Kries test. A.positive reaction in the Kries test, when the test is performed in the usual manner, is not always a reliable indication of rancidity in fats. ‘A large number of compounds react with phloroglucin hydrochloric acid to give a red color, that with the unaided eye cannot be distinguished from the toolor obtained with rancid fats. When the test is modified :in such manner that the color obtained is examined spectro- 39 loopioally, however, the modified test becomes a reliable index or the rancid condition (37). The results of the Kries test are given in Table VII. {As this test is a qualitative test only, a comparison between the five lots of eachsieries could be made. .All of the tests were very slight. It is interesting to note, however, that from the results of the qualitative test, the lot scoring the highest showed no increase in the average I value or the Kries test, while the lot that scored the lowest showed the greatest increase in the average value. 440 .HOHOO #mmflbdmfl .- .9 f i .7 am a men» “353 a snap noises .oousgsoo snob moHuom nose §e++om +4.4...v m den» uoabsma + + .n 3.8» 23H... ....m mess» on o .H .Ho 33 33 2» sons to» .Ho fiancee» 833$ 3.. so.» 8...“. 84.. 8.». 8.». mm.“ mmé 34 mm.” 8H swamps +.+.+. + e e. +.t .+.+ e +_e . o .e o +.+ .HHN +e+e+ + 1 +_+ e ++e++ ++_+ + e e +.+ + +_+ + +_+ + 1 .HH e.+.+ +.+_ +++++ .e +_e_+ + e e 4 + + +_+ +.+_ + t + + + 1N + +_+ e e +.+ +++++ e_+ e_e + e + + + + + .HH +++++. +.+ +. +. +t+ .+_+ +. e e.+ e +.+.+ e + .HHHP e.+ + 4.+.+. e.+ + + + + + + % +£§++ +. + 4. oHHP ++r++ 4.4. _+ +. + +.+ + + + + + +.+ + + + f .Hb +.+.+. + +.* t + e.+ e + +++++ .e +.+.+.+ + 1b +++++ +++++ e +.+.+ +.+ + + + +.+ + e + + + +.+ + e. ohm .1... ... +4 + ... ....v... ...... ... its. ++ .HHH +.+.+ e +.+ e +.+ + + + +. + + + + + + +.+ .HH +.+ + +.+ +.+ +.+ .4 + + + + e e + t + +_+ .H ease om me H “see om a3 H name 8 H3 H 93o 8 as H «Mae 8 a3 H 32mm seesaw 5 sea omsuopm 5 sea cassava 3 8H9 esteem 3 sea $888 3 .33 a momI e pom m1 “BMW a semi H ohm apnea madam. new dmNHdHNo you name we unaduom .HHb mqm¢9 .H. It. [i ‘ [1| ‘1 [-1 .l .I ‘II I ll 9‘ III III III 'e ‘5 I. IQ! III ' ' 1| It el‘ 1.. l I‘OI‘ «II. I. ' [It I.‘ I .3 ‘I it Ilt (I I.- Ill I... I II. I '1. VII [ ’I l .l IO: 9| ‘l 1' 0‘01]. ‘l-.|i 1‘ '0 I ' VI . 0' . '1 I.) '1‘ Y} 5' ch. ch 0‘ ‘3 II 1|! t ‘ " II! I‘ 'II 1x '1; «I. '. ..“l‘lll -\ :‘n ll 11. pl. [I ‘ - 1; il- l.- ..u .0. I! nII 0' II III ‘I .t ‘1 'I II. ll . Isl ‘I ‘I II III III I. .| .l 'I! -I’ 'II II ' I ‘l ‘ l I. ' k I 'I '| £11.10- .II ‘t nlv I l. .'I III" I‘ ... ‘l l: 10. (I. Q! t ..I [1| 1 0| '0 - ‘ f ' ll It 'I e o e e e e e O I‘ -‘ I ale 1.. 1‘ (ll 41. nn.mw Hb.om «domm mo.mm o¢.Hm mo.nm em.mm mmomm mm.nm ecomm Neomm eo.nm mm.om HN.Hm nH.NmmMsuo>4 .mm .Hm .mm m.mm m.Hm .nm .nm .nm .nm .mm .mm owm .Hm .Hm cum .HHM .mm .Hm .nm n.0m .mm .wm m.mm .nm .em m.Hm .nm .nm m.mm .H@ .mm .HM .mm. .mm .3 .3 .mm 35 .8 9.8 .em .3 .3 .g .8 .Nm .3 .H .mm .om momm .mm .om m.nm n.mm .nm m.nm .mm m.mm .em .Hm .Hm .Nm .MH n.5m .om m.mm .mm .mm .em .mm .mm m.nm m.~m .nm m.mm .Hm .Hm m.mm .HHH> m.mm .om memm .mm .Hm .em .nm .mm .em .mm .mm .nm .Hm .Hm m.Hm .HHb m.mm .om .nm n.mm .nm .em .nm .nm .em n.mm .nm m.nm m.om .mm .nm .H> .mm .Hm .mm .mm .mm .em .nm oem oem .mm .nm .em m.Hm .Nm .mm .b .mm .om .mm .mm m.Hm .nm mama .nm .em .Nm m.Hm m.mm .Hm .mm .mm ebH .mm .Hm .nm m.mm m.mm .nm .om .mm m.mm .om .Hm m.Hm m.mm .om mon .HHH m.mm m.Hm .mm .mm .mm .em .mm .mm m.nm .mm .mm momm .Hm m.Hm .Nm .HH .mm .Hm n.Hm .om .Hm .em .nm .mm .mm .mm .mm .mm .Hm .Hm .Nm .H .sc om .su on .sd H .sc om .sc on one H .sc om .so on .66 H .su om .sd on .su H end cm .sd on .sd H moHuom mmsuoam.na «SHE omduovm sH asHa owsMOpm sH osHa ewsqum_nH esHe omsnoam nH ssHa ullllllmwpbn w you .mwvoq N poH . H won .mouoom “spasm no ansnem. .HHH> MAM¢H MICHIGAN STATE COLLEGE ‘ *H¢QM»W~HI.-A o -9 0+ ~L. ~A—— ' O<—o - . me---—>§—:- .. “...—a; H+o~v+o-.o—W-+.—~HH+ ...-----.§, - ..-.eep-.- 4L --++- - o Hw—H ....+- o—. i.4_. o-o+- -H..‘..a—o—o—o+.—~.+._._o_-.. - ... .g . -H. -- - . . . .—.——H. .4 - - ..- .. M-_ >—- -fi-m+vQ+H—oo—-o—o—~4 - — - ~ . o . . . ;-4 h-.. 0 H7- .- . -.—..-._. . H .—+..-...-+._..-.-. H~-»raseueo.-¢-—H.-H-H§~-+—-... 5 ..-.-H-.. ..-..-.-k-......_..u--.- «O'Hs-..+ ...-._.H._-§--. -.. 3....... ....--sad ...,--.---. >4.u—aoo..»I¢H+.ou—r-Q.-a.-—..—.- --.—.--- ....+...,..._-....._... .-...-. . .--....--..§ .....--.. .. H-.. ......-..- ..l.-- ...-.. .... .. .. i... .....--. ... .r.-.,..---....._-. h—o—www»--- -‘--.-—- I . -- A 1 r b—.>--.......- ~-v—-.a—---.A-_-$..-..-..4.i ...--e».--»‘7--..—HH .-.-.~-o-~-o.?».am-—‘_—-- ->--—-—o—o-‘v«--—.uovov>-;<---4----—-----4b‘&~‘—‘1O—"do"O’H4’H—<-fi“*"".4 ;_-_.._.-. .._.......-.-._4 ..-.....- .-A.-.----- . y—--—.—-....----..~~o .. .....- it..-..-—»-.t .-.--....¢ ......__...-_._...._-. ..-.--H...g ...-...-......_-.-....-} . .-.. _. ......g Ino~‘.~-A'9'—.s ... . ...§. .... -- i..--._-_..--} y..-. -.... .. ...... .... v4 + .n ......._.... ... . ....i i.---.-.-. ...--.r. r.._..-AH_-.. ... .. ..... --i ------ . ...-..H“ .. .. ..3 s-.---.-.-‘..--.........._ *3. >~--.- -...-v r..roh.-. , , r—-—.. .. -. ..—._.. . —v n Y A t . 1 . U . . 1 . . >- ....r..........».... y-..,-.....-. kk.-... ......yn cl;.:v06 >~o—-.-»..HH.4 - .-. ! '0 . . v OH-Qwom ca v . u u o O . u v ' a y--~»--~--.-..... . ', yHHH--... -.. -.... L W... ——.¢~-c—~~—-——-a— - 0*” -—-~ ‘ . ........ . .-.... u ..- ..--k..-.. i v 0 O O . . ? u ‘. 7. o v e . O . V . , . ~4¢re w. «or—Hue "..., 04> Ov‘e-to-fl—o ‘ . 8 <~ - -. . . . .4 . V y--.~-—. —>y~r~ . g H .... ..-.-.--.y~~.-e....-.¢....-—~.—HH—oo- "HH.—--O-‘.“~--O—---.>w—‘ L.-.oo-'.—o—-.-.-‘o »». ....H v' . ..vfi-H’H *QOVO>-O—Ov-?»o—Q--“-9-.—>IN7*‘—.‘—.~ r~~H-¢—9+-ooo—Q-o-o—4—q—o—o¢4 p-H.Head-g....—..-.-.6._.....‘... o--o-4—O—4—‘o>¢}e++—O—O {a-o-oysv-v-oro—ouv o-u‘9.» HawH—wH4—a. ~~H+-o—o—e—~p«~ AMMH—v—Ov wMW~Hlej y. ..-...-.... g...- ..~.t.._.._. ..-HFH .—~.—4.-.-¢+~ ._.._..-._..- ...-oo-ow—v o “--....” . 4-.----”s. .-.--h.....-.an--.-..T...-...H-. .... -. r .L.-- . .-‘ ...--- -.- . i..-. ..... .-. ... . .-., skis. .... ... al..._..._._.._._44.._._....‘. >~o+—~—44—.—.—.—.,--4_- w..-‘ -- -. - ... 5- --.., . ¢.- ....- e—c ~ ~ ‘ .-oo-~-«.-»4—‘- -s-—..-.o7*.—$_.VH..-_4.-..-4 v-v»H§o—Q—~O—o~ H—+¢—H~4+o+-Ho—o-H—o.4 LH. . -H l. - .. . . . e .7. ... . . L... ...A ... . r+ .... , . . ... ....»v. o --., k....‘ . L . - p—o o+o—04-.—QJ*444A§—‘Q-Q-v .4 A4. .' -H .--....,,_ .. .-.»-.i.....H‘Ao.'.‘-~~oea---y..—e-.-.H- <‘§—¢.-OOO—40.—.¢O‘—.H+ .o«~+a~o -—-—o-.o.4 [~--.;.a...y—..-... .4...«-..,....«.... ...+-+.VH.:.. t..~._.+._§.~ .- a... . .._..._...._-——.-$ ~n—..o- - ......... ~v—rc—.—__-_.-a..v. t H A y——._.—-v..7"..4 _. -..-- .{....-.A-v§-H‘.va-..-- .<-~-.>a.§-.H.v—._..-_... +-e....-~‘-H+-.1>H—A———.—A——- ..-¢H- -~-o—.—.__._H - - -...-._....._-.-.-.-,_ . § #— A e..+—+4—o——e-o- "'“‘* ""’ "‘ "' ‘-"'~ '§ 'Otw.*‘~HV~—~‘~ b—w-Aaw-‘eovro-fwwfiwM-awq—q 7.--. i.H-._o_...-;...-..__._.-4 .—- A 4-..--. g.—g—._..-.--.~ -.—.. ._.¢—. c4.H4. _. AAH-4~-.y—< -~--} >+o¢+qa~oy~hHo+o-ot -+-oo—o-O—o—H o. +OHn< { ’ ‘- A‘O‘-Q.O ~044-Oovu .9-4—M—b-94A-t- ‘OOW-O-" A v v - « ...-.. ...- L ...-Ho»-ro4...-....-¢o. vooaH—~§—AA4 1 7.4.7-7.. -.t..---..-. .._HH_.-_.. ,_,.--.. --.,--,._.. . .4 . t .. .--.-. ..» *o—H-‘u .3 ..-. ...- -..e.-7.H.e-+_.....-.. -.*+4 .. . --. .* ..- -..-...oa “*w-, ...»o—ov—H ‘w-’ e- --4 o . ”....-A‘H. 1 --.-..A-‘...‘..-...,... -..---oeo .--.-..-.§.H...H...- ...-....H... ...........F*W#_.¢._.-_._-___-.. ,--+._.-._._. .4 - +-+.~—_ a.-. . v y . «...—...___._¢.. 4 «---- ... ..- . . L. .-.—.AW . ......-—.—._- .. ... ._- . - . 9. n. . . . . _. o—«oo—Qvoe ......me—o‘j -o.¢4q flew—HaneflsaqH—HH444. -o—o-v4--‘-.+.-H_.._~-n .-._.-.- _. -.....n. { .-.. ._.-+_._..‘_a._.._._._._._ ‘ 4H 7 a . .... 4 H.._.-._‘._._- ._ -.au h... . own—$-44 o .4 ---_-—o‘ .4 too-.-c+._H*—oo—o—o—o—H—o-~H yo-.--¢-. ..-H.---.‘-. .. .-...H--..{ ..‘_--».. .--. ..H.... -...-H. i... .l._ «09-- 0+H-4L4‘+*~~An-p- . ,7- Fob—H-‘ —ev . heh- . - >' '- 4~~-.H.... ...He-..$- ~4..-._.>_+F4 .-.—..-».H“... .-_---_»— A -“» . o. ....... ._ ..~.<-‘... . . ,_._-.,.,_..-_._4 >—‘ " ‘ ’ ‘ ‘4‘ -—-~ v- --o... ... .- .. .___...-_.+. —.—.———-—.—+—»-—.- —.——-—< )—--*"~~-v ..-..—.... ...-.....o... ......s-e. .-..H—H—H—HH—HJ...¢_.—4~_H.~~.< >--—- ~ -- :-- ‘ ..-. . >4 -...-. -H»-1H_.._-+---g.4 .-.._._--.-..‘.--..._.-_---—. ~ - — ‘— - - .--.-_ .-. o- -- ... ... .4 .. ..- .-4 .44...{ p--~----«~——H—+ .-.—..-___- .— ,4 . « ». « ~-< .- - -... .4 .a..-._. ... .. . . ...-.+..v.. -....... ..-._--.._...... -. -.. “J r ...»...“b. _;... -o-—o-. . -qu... o . . [...—.mi._.,. 4» k.“ .--..... . I -..._.._._..-_. ..‘_.~-.. ....-.fin477 ..H%o-..r. .4.-+..-.. ...-...-_... ..-H.....V.l...--..-.. o..._..-.._-. -....-H.‘ Iv.§~o.._._*..'....-_.+vH- in-...._..._._ -...-.-_.—._. .-_._-.i.-. .«l... . ..-4. . -..—a. --.. 4 Han - . . - . T v a ....4-.... .-.-.. «$..H...-..-s- ‘6 .....r -..-VHH-o-H. }_.7_ --H . -4 . Q ..~_4_-—H .... . - .4 ‘70—». L < e e . .-.-k-—“®--§--—.o.e.¢~<~—--¢-¢o-oo- Ho‘re ..._._e.'e..1-........--.L.....+._.-. ...- ..T. r' ,.A—.--~4- --.—-....L..-. .~--u--_.4 ...—H h— ' "‘"' L.a—~O~v'*~~¢+~e~entos¢. [....¢.-.»‘1 -H—v- “"’Y""M*‘"‘_‘m "T""‘ T‘.-'“h*'-flfl- }...H¢+O»O*---.-so—&~-...- L'“"“"‘ . .... «.--... ...”.-.H ,_...._,_,-.-..,,,-_..__M_.,,__‘ .-.- .--...--....... -....H.-- .. —-m ~+~~M~~v~n~~n~+ —¢— ‘ _,4., ---.L.... .-.. ......h... ,‘l..- ‘-—-~"-“"""‘ "‘ """""" "’ H -7» A--- a .VA... e . k...‘ 4 s . - -H—‘~M e . . H - ...+¥._.l-l.__l - .->—..- - »- -~—.- - H4. .—.—-—o— n 0 v - ...s o-e- u o e 44. - v—Q—‘v—' ._ .- e ew—e—«A-o-v rw‘e-o—oww 4 - A AM A . - V in- L7 7v -W AAAAA In[._1r.i.. DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS 43 DISCUSSION of SCORES Sweet Cream Butter The average score for the sweet cream.butter was the lowest of any of the lots of butter after a storage period of one day. The butter when scored was criticised as having no distinct flavor. Liter a storage period of one month the sweet cream butter was placed in fourth place. The sweet cream butter scored a little lower than that of butter made from ripened cream which had been ripened is an acidity of about 0.3 per cent but scored higher than.butter made from cream which had been ripened to an acidity of about 0.5 per cent. After a storage period of three msnths the sweet cream butter scored higher than either of the two different lots of ripened cream butter. The average score of the sweet cream butter at the end of a one day storage period was 92.13; at the end of one month 91.29; and after a period of three months 90.66. The sweet cream butter had better keeping quality than that of the ripened cream butter. Butter Made rrom.Sweet Cream.To Which A Starter Was Added-are The Butter At The Time or Working .Atter a storage period of one day the average score of the butter to which starter was added at the time of working was third highest. tartar a storage period of one month and three months the starter butter scored second 44 highest of the different lots. The average sco re after a storage period of one day was 93.04; at the end of one month 92.42; and after a period of three months 92.04. The flavor of this butter (lot 2) was not as well develOped as that of butter to which a starter was added Just before churning. The keeping quality of the above two lots of butter were the same. Butter made From Sweet Cream To Which A Starter Was Added Just Before Churning Butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added Just before churning scored as high after a storage period of one day as butter made from sweet cream which had been ripened to 0.3 per cent acidity. When.the starter butter was scored after a storage period of one month, it was given the highest score. The flavor of the starter butter was well developed. .After a storage period of three months the butter was scored again. This time it received the highest score of any of the other lots. When the starter butter was fresh the average score was 93.58; after a storage period of one month 92.96; and at the end of three months 92.54. ffls butter besides having the best flavor also showed very good keeping quality. The starter butter after a storage period of three months lost only 1.04 in points while the butter made from ripened cream lost 4.58 points. .. flail}. . inu|i 45 Eur a creamsry using sweet cream in making butter, these results would indicate that it is best to add starter to the cream Just before churning. Using this method, the flavor of the butter would score the highest when fresh or after a storage period of three months. Butter'nade Prom Sweet Cream Which.Was Ripened To.An Acidity Of 0.3 éer Gent fhe butter made from cream ripened to 0.3 per cent acidity received the highest average score of any of the other lots of butter when fresh. The difference between the ripened cream butter and the butter to which a starter was added Just before churning was very slight. '.After a storage period of one month the ripened cream butter again scored higher than the sweet cream nutter but lower than the starter butter. After a storage period of three months the ripened cream butter scored lower than that of sweet cream butter. The average score Eafter a storage period of one day was 95.66; at the end of one month 91.46; and after a period of three months 89.08. If the butter is to be consumed soon after it is made, the cream can be ripened to an acidity of 0.3 per cent but from these results the butter should not be held any length of time. Butter Hide Prom.3weet Cream which Was Ripened so in Acidity or 0.5 Per Cent ‘- The butter made from cream ripened to 0.5 per cent 46 acidity higher than that of sweet cream butter when the butter was fresh. “fter a storage period of one month the ripened cream butter scored the lowest of any of the lots. When the butter was scored the flavor was criticised as being slightly off and in some cases slightly unclean. When the butter was scored after a storage period of three months it again was scored the lowest. This time the butter was criticised at the time of scoring as being slightly fishy. Summary of desults on Flavor When fresh the untreated sweet cream butter (lot 1) scored the lowest. Butter made from.sweet cream to which a starter was added to the butter at the time of working (lot 2) scored higher than butter made from sweet cream which had been ripened to an acidity of 0.5 per cent (lot 5). Lot 2 scored lower than butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added Just before churning (lot 3) or butter made from sweet cream which had been ripened to an acidity of 0.5 per cent (lot 4). Lots 3 and 4 scored the highest. The flavor of lots 3 and 4 as shown by the average score. showed very little difference. This slight difference could be accounted for as being due to eXperimental error. Lot 5 scored higher than lot 1 but lower than lot 2. .After a storage period of one month lot 1 scored slightly lower than lot 4 but higher than lot 5. The average illi'i.l rail. , u 47 score of lot 2 was lower than lot 3 buthigher than lot 4. Lot 3 scored the highest. Lot 4 scored slightly higher than lot 1 but this slight difference could be due to eXperimental error. Let 5 scored the lowest. .After a storage period of three months lot 1 scored lower than let 2 but higher than lot 4. Lot 2 scored lower than lot 3 but higher than lot 1. Lot 3 again scored the highest. The average score of lot 4 was lower than lot 1 but higher than lot 5. Lot 5 scored the lowest. Summary of fiesults on Keeping Quality At the end of a storage period of one month, the difference between the average score of one day and one month for the untreated sweet_cream butter (lot 1) was 0.84. Butter made from.sweet cream to which a starter was added to the butter at the time of working (lot 2) and butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added Just before churning (lot 5) showed the best keeping quality. In both lots the difference was 0.61. The difference for butter made from sweet cream which had been ripened to an acidity of 0.3 per cent (lot 4) was 2.20, and for butter made from sweet cream which had been ripened to an acidity of 0.5 per cent (lot 5) was 1.71. After a storage period of three months lot 2 and lot 3 again showed the best keeping quality. The difference between the average score of one day and three months for lot 1 was 1.47; lot~2, 1.00; lot 3, 1.04; lot 4, 4.53 and lot 5, 4.09. 4e CONCLUSIONS 1. The flavor of butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added Just before churning is superior to that of sweet crram butter after a storage period of one day, one month, and three months. 2. The flavor of butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added to the butter at the time of work- ing is superior to that of sweet cream butter after a storage period of one day, one month and three months. 3. The flavor of butter made from.sweet cream ripened to an acidity ranging from 0.3 to 0.35 per cent is superior to that of sweet cream butter after a storage period of one day. “fter a storage period of one month there is no difference in flavor of the two butters. The flavor of sweet cream butter is superior to the ripened cream butter after a storage period of three months. 4. There is no difference in flavor between sweet cream butter and butter made from sweet cream which has been ripened to an acidity ranging from 0.45 to 0.52 per cent after a storage period of one day. The sweet cream butter is superior in flavor to that of ripened cream.butter after a storage of one and three months. 5. The flavor of butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added Just before churning is superior to sweet cream butter to which a starter was added to the butter at the 49 time of working, after a storage period of one day, one month, and three months. 6. The keeping quality of sweet cream butter to which a starter was added to the butter at the time of working is superior to that of sweet cream butter after a storage period of one and three months. 7. The keeping quality of butter made from sweet cream to which a starter was added Just before churning is superior to that of sweet cream butter after a storage period of one and three months. 8. The keeping quality of sweet cream butter is superior to butter made from sweet cream ripened to an acidity ranging from 0.3 to 0.35 per cent after a storage period of one and three months. 9., The keeping quality of sweet cream butter is superior to butter made from.sweet cream ripened to an acidity from 0.45 to 0.52 per cent after a storage period of one and three months. 10. The keeping quality of sweet cream.butter to which a starter was added to the butter at the time of working is the same as butter made from.sweet cream to which a starter was added Just before churning after a storage period of one and three months. 11. The acidity of cream does not effect the Reichert Hkissl number. iodine number, amino-nitrogen content, or the Kries test. 12. A.re1ationship exists between the acidity of the If, 5O cream and the acid number of the fat. The higher the acidity is developed in cream, the higher the acid number of the fat will be. 1e 2e 3e 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 51' BIBLIOGRAPHY Genesis 18:8 and Proverbs 30:33. Judges 5:25 What is sweet cream butter? New York Produce Review, Vol. 57, No. 4, (1923) page, 131. Curtis, 9. w. ‘ Quality of sweet cream butter as compared with butter made from acid cream. Texas Agricultural Experiment Station, Bul. ll, Aug.,1890. Patrick, G. E. Keeping quality of sweet cream butter. Iowa Experiment Station, Bul. 11, Nov., 1890. Patrick, G. 3. Sweet versus sour cream butter. Iowa Experiment station, Bul. 18, 1892. Patrick, G. E. Sweet verSus sour cream butter. Iowa Experiment 3tation, Bul. 21, 1895. Powick, W. C. ” Compounds developed in rancid fats, with observations on the mechanism of their formation. Jour. of Agr. Research, V01. 26, (1923), page 323. Dean, R. H. Sweet cream with cultures versus ripened cream. Ontario College and Experiment Farm. Thirtieth Annual Report 1904. v - L z e 9. 3v r t f . e. 0. ' Q C .. L I . D H . . — . ' . a no 0 O O Q U 0 . \ _ . . _ O . '\ Ix ? . e! v _ o O O . . U ‘ . I . o. e 9 II \ ' ' f. e‘ 9t 0t . . O . V . C 9 f O. 0 e w I f D O O c a v N. I O 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 52 Gray, 0. E. The keeping qualities of butter made under different conditions and stored at different temperatures. U. S. D. A.; B. A, I. Bul. 84, 1916. Charron,.A. T., and Shult, r. 1. Sweet cream butter. Sept. of Ag. Ottawa, Canada. Bill. 15, 1907. Rogers, L..A., Thompson, S. 0., and Keithley, J. B. The manufacture of butter for storage. U. S. D. A.; B..A. T. Bul. 148, 1912. Potts, Roy 0. Suggestions for the manufacture and marketing of creamery butter in the South. U. S. D. A. Cir. 66, 1916. Hortensen, 11. Influence of acidity on flavor and keeping quality of butter. Iowa Exp. dta.‘Bul. 207, 1922. White, M.‘ Effect of acidity content on keeping quality of butter. The Creamery Journal. Vol. 38, No. 23 (1928), page 5. Heineman, P. 6. Milk. (1921) page 21 Hammer, 3. W. Volatile acid production of Streptococcus lacticus and the organisms associated with it in starter. Iowa sxp. Sta. deeearoh Bul. 63, 1920. \_\ 18. 19. 20c 21c 22. 23. 34c 25. 53 Hunsiker, 0. F. The Butter Industry. Second Edition (1927), page 248. Conn. H. W. Bacteriology in buttermaking. Storrs Agr. Exp. Sta. An. Rep., Vol. 11 (1898) page 85. Hammer, B. W. and Bailey, De E. The volatile acid production of starters and of organisms isolated from them. Iowa.Exp. Sta. desearch Bul. 55, 1919. Gregory, E. w; tucas, 2.8.; and Spitzer, Geo. .A comparison of methods of estimating fat in butter. Purdue Agr. Exp. Sta. Bulletin 244, 1920. Kohman, 5. F. A rapid and accurate method for butter analysis suitable for factory control work. J. of Ind. and Eng. Chem. Vol. 11 (1919) page 36. Terrie, I.W. Some determinations on the soluble nitrogen compounds of cream and butter. J. of Dairy Sci. Vol. 5 (1923). page 323. .lethod.of Analysis of the Association of Official Agricultural Chemists. Second Edition (1925), pages 260 to 293. Scales, P. n; and Harrison, A. P. Boric acid modification of the KJeldahl method for crop and soil analysis. J. of_Ind. and Eng. Chem. Vol. 12 (1920), page 350. 26. 27c 28. 29. 50 e 31. 32. 33. 34. 54 Steele, L. L. and Sward, 8.0. The determination 5f the acid number. J. of Ind. and Eng. Chem. Vol. 14, (l922),page 67. Helm, G. B. and Greenbank, G. R. Test for oxidized fat. J. of Ind. and Eng. Chem. Vol. 15, (1924), page 1051. Holm. 0. E. and Greenbank. G. R. Test for oxidised fat. J. of Ind. and Eng. Chem. Vol. 16, (1924). page 518. Hathews, A. P. Physiological Chemistry. Second Edition(1920), pages 123 to 137. ierris, I. w. ' A method for the determinatiwi of amino nitrogen and ammonia in cream and butter. J. of Dairy 301., Vol. 5, (1922), page 403. Richmond, H. D. ' Dairy Chemistry. Third Editinn (1920), page 336. Holland, E. 3.; Road, 3.0. and Buckely, J. B. Improved methods for fat analysis. Hess. Agr. Exp. Sta. Bul. 166, page 1915. Dewkowitsch, Dr. J. Chemical Technology and Analysis of Oils. Fats and "axes. ‘ rourth.Edition,(1909t pages 667 to 694. Fundamentals of Dairy Science. American Chemical society Monograph (1928). page 80. 55 35. Heineman, P. Q. Milk (1921). page 121. 35. Palmer, L. S. Laboratory EXperiments in Dairy Chemistry. (1926), page 25. 38. Hunziker, 0. F. The Butter Industry. First Edition (1920) page 546. APPENDIX 56 5.3.. an. en . on He _ 9 me «e. m «6H 23. cm. on. en em on on H». 4 e8 28 on. as .3 «a on 9 3H. m e3 3.8. on. he an an 8 He 2. ... a3 3.8 2.. an 3 he on He 2. . . H as HH 82% H.Hm ma. 2 an an en 3 3. e ..8 .«m H.H on an we on an on. e 33 3.3.. e. 3 an. en me on 5. n ..8 .m... e. on me he he on 3. a pen .2 e. or. en .3 . he on 2. . H a3 . m 3.28m «see new iflax. new! W91 Mn so»; mun awe... How» 233 secs 53.358 33.86 ‘ sense 3.9 senses . co .3 «e .969 no sense.— E Huang—wan 33m Hamish .95? .9269 95m spam—b ~33: é Mll‘ .uHrHooom Mag .H a 57 m.nm a»... an no no om 3. . .3. m #3 5.3 om. on no .3 mm 3 an. ¢ 03 Qua mm. 3 mm on on an 3. n «on Qua on. 3 mm mm. cm on 3. N «3 ....nm 3. 3 mm on 3 Mn 3... H 93 >H 330m 93 on. on .3 3. oo 3 3. n #3 0.3 on. an on no 9. ad on. d #3 ~33 on. 3 «m .3 no on ma. 9 a3 0.3 3. on on .3 om 3 an. a non néw on. 3 mm mm mm on 3. H #3 HHH :Huon anon ham ago now up an Wong Mb «50 um ~33 Aunt Magvflfi M3358 3.3.6 . :8. 68725 no no no .3 no hog Echo pagoxdmkaoa 930.5%. .malomh .E 835. g hanged SAD 3.383 £28832qu 4% 58 coda on. av «m on on m¢ ad. _ m «on . n.n~ av. oe mm on on an an. ¢ pan n.nu ad. ad $9 on Oh Hm ha. a van N.¢m om. me mm mm cm on an. m 90A noun on. ad ¢n an mm mm Ha. a pan Hp uoauom o.¢m om. ow «m «m an an ad. n «on n.nm on. n¢ ¢n an on on on. d van comm an. m¢ «m em m¢ «m «H. n non mom“ on. an «m ¢m no an «a. N van n.m« on. me on no cm on . NH. a non m common 8 a £30 ”ShW LP hp .335 MP mnoo nmh nonma.nuua gadauovenm madnnunv nacho woos cauupb no no no .gaya Ho uéaspm gumbo fiaovvfiw 3393 93M :36» .959 Sam 5% bags 9"an .6.enoou .aduoonm mndnuflnb .H mamaa 59 no 3 On an. m 09H 0.3 mm. 00 3 Qua mu. 3 3 mm 3 on an. d «3 0.3 on. 3 .3 mm on an 3. a van Coda on. nd 3 on mm. mm in. a v3 9%.. an. 8 . no on o... S 3. H as an: :28 dodw mm. 3 no pm 0d .3 an. m #3” 0.3 on. on on an 3 «m .3. o #3 1.8 on. 3 3 mm mm on 3. n 93 .73 on. 3 3. on on mm «H. u no." ”.0“ 3. 3 3 pm 2. no «A. A no.” wdoo pom P53 "8% MP moon Edna trimnoo EE .833 fig “35398 3986 33.8 «89 328 «a no no .92 go neg Euobuor fiaofiflmn «nowadaobom .qawa! .g album 936 53304 551.5. 3:303 3.9303 Madge Jug 60 3n 3. 8 . no 3 2. 8 S. o .3 can on. 3 no on on 3 an. a non o.n~ on. co no on no on on. » non can on. 8 no on no on 3. a «on aim on. a. no 8 3 no 3. H «on H oonnom Emu on. on 3 on 8 .8 S. o as 13 on. 8 on on on on 3. o «on 23 on. 3. .3 8 3 on 3. n «on oém on. S no 8 8 on 3. u o3 dam on. 3 no on 2. no 3. a non m oomuom anon now B30 90% up hp .38»; no ”boo new not.» no»: finanonofi 338 :88 V :8 23.8» no no no .3 no gas: gape flange-Mn 339333.“ .968. .959 IMP! é} hanged 3mm “yahoo. oadkooom 39350 .H g 61 Coda ON. ad am pm on on on. 0 van aofim mm. an mm mm 3 .3 in. .v #3 o.nm on. o¢ no mm cm on ma. n van co¢m ca. no no mm mm «m ea. N no: o.nm an. m¢ no no om mm «a. a «on HHH cannon o.mm on. an mm mm on me an. n non o.m~ mm. oe an on on on an. d non 0.3 on. 3 mm B on do 3". n as conm on. on «n mm co an ma. a non comm on. ow no on om an an. H van . L Hwhuomnoa pqoo awn «goo now ho an no» nuoo awn 9343 nook Man-£33m €28 Icon... «39 canon no no no .3 no n35: .nunnobb MHfianovvumwnnonvflopom .gamm .gamw, .lafir guano hpmmnoq. gummy .uoeuoo. oaduooum_wnwnuuno .H manda 62 mm. odom noona ooooo m «on ma. «com mm.mn neoam a van ooou on.“ ou.na. «moon ¢ «on on. upon mm.na mnoam ¢ «on meoa anon om.nu ahoom a and an. no.” mmoma acoao n «am pm. «u.m omoma mmoom N van «mod 0%.” om.ma nwooo N «on ¢ooa mm.“ oooma meoam a can OOoH on.~ oo.na oa.ao a van bu nounow HH cannon acoa «uom cm.ma mmoom a pod ¢ooa mnou omoma mmooo m and meoa mnom among hoooo d van scoa neon osond oooom ¢ van #o.a av.“ omoma smooo n «on «coa mnom omoma anon» a non meoa on.“ mm.mn anooo N «on Hood anon anoma ovooc a van meoa no.“ shone Hoooo H van meoa meow osomd ”boom a van HH noauom H nomnmm a nom «moo nom «zoo mom hogan: noeapm E mHMIm chafing wanna «55.0 E 1:3 9333: lvduhr 9.3mm. .833 no «838 28 o5 .38 .2333. .oon 93.2% .2 fig 65 on. #n.m mm.mn Hmooo 0 non ¢o.a en." om.na «moon 0 «0A «con mn.~ mm.mn noooo ¢ «on mm. on.“ oo.ma wooom ¢ van mm. ma.m nmoma mo.Hc a non om. on.~ «mood aboow n non no. n¢.~ mm.ma mpoom . m «on oa.a mmom ooomn no.0m N «on as. anon om.na 0H.Hm H van Hm. ma.“ on.nn unoao a non "HHb nownom Hp coauom mm. nu.“ mmoma mooom n pod o~.n an.“ omona mnoom 0 non Qo.H anon omoma mmooc d van OOoH nmom mmoma upooo 0 van cm. on.“ omoma oo.ao a won «0.: an.“ oo.oH Hmoom n «on coca anon om.ma ooooo N van econ «mom nmoma Hmooo N non mm. mH.m om.nH 0H.Hm H veg mo.H p~.m mmoma aboom H wag HH> moauom b uoanom «goo you «duo pom «goo upm «non you an. anon hum undo ham vuoo now anon «on uoaanz “wanna undo vain onuvuana «um guano undo pawn onuaoana ash mmmmw £33m no 232.8 28 as. .38 $55.33 .3“ gm .HH Handy 64 8... 38 8.3 8.8 ... 8.3 8.3 88 8.3 8.8 m 83 8... 88 8.3 8.8 e 83 3.3 88 8.3 8.8 e 83 8. 88 8.3 .8.8 n as 8. 88 8.3 8.8 n «3 8. 88 8.3 8.8 8 9.3 8.3 88 8.3 8.8 8 83 . 8. 88 8.3 8.8 3 83 8.3 88 8.3 8.8 3 «3 3x .388 u 838 3.3 88 8.3 8.8 a «.3 8. 88 8.3 8.8 n «3 8. 88 8.3 3.8 a. 93 8.3 88 8.3 8.8 e 83 8.3 88 8.3 8.8 n ...3 8.3 88 8.3 8.8 n ..3 8. 88 8.3 8.8 8 £3 3.3 88 8.3 8.8 8 £3 8. 38 8.3 8.8 3 «3 8. 88 8.3 8.8 3 a8 - HM ammuom , MM oomuom W50 Mom moo HR uufloo ”WNW £00 himdfll ”GOO HON .900 MON 80 832 g ......“me wadm 0.3938» mum} 9338 E wdom Egan «WW 5% 3.283 .833 8 8388 88 an» .38 .2333. 83 8338 .3 38.3. (Ki- [loll ? ‘A‘t‘n~fi - - _ _ .