WI 1 §§ \HHIIWIWHHWWWHWUIIHW THS mam! Lump - > Michigan St as University This is to certify that the thesis entitled ISOLATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF TABACCO RINGSPOT VIRUS FROM PEACH presented by CONSTANCE L. WI NANS has been accepted towards fulfillment of the requirements for M.S. degree in Botany 5 Plant Pathology MgoMessor 12-20-78 Date 0-7639 OVERDUE FINES ARE 25¢ PER DAY PER ITEM Return to book drop to remove this checkout from your record. ISOLATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF TOBACCO RINGSPOT VIRUS FROM PEACH. BY CONSTANCE LARUE WINANS A Thesis Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science Department of Botany and Plant Pathology 1978 ABSTRACT ISOLATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF TOBACCO RINGSPOT VIRUS FROM PEACH BY Constance L. Winans A virus was isolated from dormant buds, blossoms, and leaves of root suckers and top growth of declining Prunus persica. Trituration of the tissue in 3% nicotine buffer and rub inoculation of cucumber cotyledons induced local chlorotic lesions on cotyledons followed by systemic chlorosis in primary leaves. Transfers were made from the infected cucumbers to a host range of Chenopodium quinoa, Nicotiana tabacum, Phaseolus vulgaris, and Vigna unguiculata. All inoculated plants developed typical tobacco ringspot virus (TRSV) symptoms within 7 to 10 days. Sap from infected cucumbers reacted with TRSV but not to tomato ringspot virus antiserum. The peach isolate of TRSV was purified from cucumber and antiserum was produced which reacted specifically to the peach TRSV isolate. Electron micrographs of purified virus showed the particles to be isometeric, (ca. 28mm in diameter). Leaves of etiolated healthy peach seedlings were mechanically inoculated with the purified TRSV isolate. After 10 days triturated tissue from inoculated peach seedlings induced TRSV symptoms in cucumber and expressed sap from the cucumbers reacted with TRSV antiserum. This is the first complete report of TRSV infection of Prunus persica. TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES... ...................... . ....... . ........ . ......... iii LIST OF FIGURES...... ............. ............ ...... . ............ . iv LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS.......... ........ . ..... .. ......... .......... v MATERIALS AND METHODS......... ............ . ...... ... ....... . ...... 4 Field Study00000000000000000000000000000000000.000000000000000 4 Description and Identification of the Virus.......... ...... ... 6 Reintroduction of the Virus from Cucumber into Peach.......... 8 RESULTS .............. . .............. .............. ....... .. ....... 9 Field StUdy000000000000000000 ..... 00000000000000000000 ....... 0 9 Description and Identification of the Virus................... 11 Reintroduction of the Virus from Cucumber into Peach.......... 14 DISCUSSION ........... . ........ .. ........... . ..... . ..... .... ....... 18 REFERENCES 0000000000 0 ........ 000 ..... 0000000000000 ..... 00000000000 20 ii Table LIST OF TABLES Page Host range inoculated with tobacco ringspot virus isolated from peach and symptom development....... .............. 12 Effect of inoculation method on infection in peach seedlings using tobacco ringspot virus isolated from peach................... ....... ......... .......... . ........ 17 iii Figure LIST OF FIGURES Cucumbers showing local lesions on cotyledons and , systemic chlorosis on primary leaves 7 days following inoculation with sap from peach infected with tobacco ringspot Virus0000000000000000000000000.0000000000000000000 Reactions of Common cowpea plants to inoculation with the isolate of tobacco ringspot virus from peach........... The three componets of tobacco ringspot virus isolated from peach, separated on a 10-40% sucrose density gradient.. Electron micrograph of a density-gradient preparation of tobacco ringspot virus isolated from peach and negatively stained with 0.5% ammonium molybdate ............ iv Page ..... 10 ..... 13 ....15 ..... l6 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS TRSV ........................................... Tobacco ringspot virus TRSVpi .................................. .......Tobacco ringspot virus, peach isolate TomRSV........ ........ . ................. .......Tomato ringspot virus INTRODUCTION A declining peach (Prunus persica) orchard has been studied in southwestern Michigan beginning in the spring of 1977. The decline did not appear to be caused by either a fungus or a bacterium however the nepovirus tobacco ringspot was consistently isolated from the declining trees. This thesis is concerned with the isolation and ident- ification of tobacco ringspot virus from declining peach trees. Tobacco ringspot virus was suggested as the cause of a disease of sweet cherry (Prunus avium L.) by Stace-Smith and Hansen (ll). The symptoms of the disease were a'lighy-green zonal discoloration and irregularity in leaf shape. TRSV was isolated from a sweet cherry bud but the isolated virus was not returned to sweet cherry: Three years later Uyemoto successfully isolated TRSV from sweet (3. avium) and flowering (P. serrulata) cherries and returned it to healthy Mazzard seedlings (14). The seedlings developed symptoms corresponding to those described by Stace-Smith and Hansen (11) in sweet cherry. After two dormancy periods TRSV was still transmissible from the test plants. In subsequent isolation trials, TRSV was not uniform in distribution in the tree nor could the virus be consistently isolated from all infected trees. Tobacco ringspot virus has also been reported as the causal agent of a disease in grape (Vitis vinifera) (4). TRSV could easily be trans- mitted from roots, leaf tissue and callus of infected grape vines, which 1 2 contrasts with the difficulty of isolation from Prunus. The symptoms could in part be reproduced in healthy grape by mechanically inoculating seedlings with the TRSV from grape. Xiphinema americanum, a TRSV vector, was found in the soil around infected vines, and cucumber trap plants became infected with TRSV. Fulton, in 1962, reported positive evidence that tobacco ringspot virus was transmitted to cucumber by Xiphinema americanum Cobb (3). However attempts to transmitt TRSV or tomato ringspot virus (TomRSV) into peach using 5. americanum have been inconclusive. A great deal of work has been done with TomRSV in peach, the causal agent of Prunus stem pitting. Stem pitting was described on Prunus persica in detail by Barrat gt a; (2) in 1968. Mircetich gt al_(7) reproduced stem pitting symptoms in healthy peach by grafting infected material onto healthy peach seedlings. TomRSV was associated with stem pitting symptoms in 1969 (10). Since that time TomRSV was isolated from a Prunus stem pitted tree (6) and using cucumbers as bait plants, TomRSV was found in soils around infected trees (9). In a report by Smith and Stouffer (8) healthy peach seedlings were mechanically inoculated with soil isolates and standard strains of TomRSV and TRSV. The TomRSV inoculated seedlings developed pitting symptoms while TRSV inoculated seedlings developed no symptoms. TRSV and TomRSV were recovered from the mechanically inoculated peach seedlings up to three weeks after inoculation. This was the only previously reported case of TRSV in peach but as already pointed out, they did not detect any symptoms of disease nor did they carry the work with TRSV any further. In this paper we report the isolation of virus from tissues of 3 peach buds, blossoms and leaves; identification of the virus according to three critera; and reintroduction of the TRSV isolated from declining peach trees into healthy peach seedlings. MATERIAL AND METHODS Field Study In the hope of determining the cause of the decline of some 12 year old Glohaven peach trees in southwest Michigan, and attempt to isolate a virus was undertaken. Young peach leaves were collected early in the summers of 1977 and 1978 from the tips of suckers arising from the base and from terminal and lateral shoots in the upper part of the trees of apparently healthy and declining peach trees. Dormant flower and leaf buds were also collected on April 12. 1978 from the suckers and from the shoots of the declining trees. Flower petals were collected at the full bloom stage of blossom bud development from the declining trees. The leaves were triturated in 3% nicotine buffer at pH 7.0 (5) and the extract mechanically inoculated onto cotyledons of Cucumis sativus (var. National Pickling) and onto young leaves of Chengpodium quinoa and Nicotiana tabacumfvar. Wht. Burley). Dormant buds were tested in the same manner after removal of the bud scales, as described by Davidson and Rundans (2). Flower petals were ground in 0.5 M potassium phosphate buffer, pH 7.0 and the sap rubbed onto cucumber cotyledons. The inocu- lated plants were kept in the green house at 20 to 22 C. The virus was maintained in cucumber and transferred every 10 to 14 days to maintain a high titer. The virus isolated from peach was tested serologically against tobacco ringspot virus (TRSV) antiserum and tomato ringspot virus (TomRSV) 4 5 antiserum using double gel diffusion. The center wells were charged wj4fl1the antisera and the peripheral wells contained either buffer or extracts of cucumber which had been inoculated with TRSV peach isolate (TRSVpi), TRSV (Gooding), TomRSV (Uyemoto), healthy peach sap or 3% nicotine buffer alone. Partially purified extracts from leaves of trees suspected of being infected with TRSV were also tested serologically. Leaves were ground in 3% nicotine buffer (pH 7.3) in a waring blender, :hi homogenate expressed through cheese cloth and the sap placed the a freezer overnight. Thawed extract was centrifuged on Sorvall RCZ-B with a no. 30 rotor at 10,000 rpm for 30 minutes. The supernatant fluid was dialized against an ammonium sulfate solution(200g/1) for 24 hours, then centrifuged for 10 minutes. The resulting concentrated peach sap was tested in double gel diffusion plates against TRSV and TomRSV antisera. Similarily pre- pared extract from healthy peach leaves was used as a control. Soil fibrous root samples were taken from the upper root zones of apparently healthy and declining peach trees and assayed for nematodes. The samples (about 2 Kg in wt) were divided and a portion of each sample was examined for the presence of the nematode Xiphinema americanum. The remaining portion of each sample was placed in sterilized eight inch clay pots with 5 to 6 cucumber seeds planted per pot as trap plants. A11 clay pots were kept on a greenhouse bench that was designed to prevent nema- tode movement from pot to pot. Sap was expressed from cucumber plants that developed virus-like symptoms and was applied to the cotyledons of healthy cucumbers. Five days after the application of the sap from the suspect plants, these second cucumber plants were tested serologically for the presence of TRSV and TomRSV. 6 To complete the field study all trees in the area of the TRSV infection were examined for Prunus stem pitting symptoms. This involved removal of soil around the scion and rootstock union to about 1 meter below the soil line and checking the bark for the thickening character- istic of stem pitting. Following removal of outer bark the exposed cambial layer was then examined for pitting and grooving symptoms. Description and Identification of the YEEEE. Sap from cucumber seedlings infected with the virus isolated from declining peach trees was passed through a 0.45 u Millipore filter and rub-inoculated onto the following herbaceous test plants: Cucumis sativus, Chenopodium quinoa, Nicotiana tabacum, Phaseolus vulgaris, Vigna unguiculata (S), and Z, unguiculata (SY). Plants rubbed with buffer served as controls. The test plants were examined daily and the sequence of symptom development was recorded. Return inoculations to healthy cucumber were made from all test plants. The peach isolate of the suspected TRSV was partially purified by a modification of the procedure developed by Stace-Smith ES a1 (13). Infected cucumber plants were harvested two weeks after inoculation and the tissue (lKg/liter) was homogenized in a waring blender with 0.5 M borate buffer at pH 6.8. The homogenate was expressed through cheese- cloth and frozen overnight. The thawed sap was centrifuged in a Sorvall RCZ-B at 9,000 g for 30 minutes. The supernatant fluid was dialyzed against 5 volumes of ammonium sulfate solution (200g/1) for 24 hours and centrifuged at 9,000 g for 10 minutes to remove precipitated plant protein. The dialyzed solution was centrifuged in a Beckman Model L ultracentrifuge with a no. 30 rotor at 28,000 rpm for 120 minutes. 7 The pellet was resuspended by shaking for 12 hours in 0.01% EDTA, pH 7.0, and was then centrifuged in a no. 40 rotor 15,000 rpm for 10 minutes and the pellet discarded. The remaining solution was further centrifuged in the no. 40 rotor at 38,000 rpm for 60 minutes. The final resulting pellet was resuspended and clarified as before by another low speed centrifugation. The suspended partially purified virus was layered on 10-40% sucrose density gradient, centrifuged in a SW 27 rotor at 23,000 rpm for 150 minutes. The separate bands were collected in a ISCO density- gradient fractionator and infectivity for the bands was determined using a local lesion assay on cowpea half-leaves. The bottom band was dialyzed against 0.01 M tris acetate buffer, pH 7.0. Antiserum to the bottom component was produced in a New Zealand white rabbit by dntra-muscular injections of 0.5 ml of 0.8 mg/ml virus emulsified in 0.5 m1 Freund's incomplete adjuvant at seven-day intervals for 6 weeks. Antiserum was obtained starting two weeks after the initial injection. Its titer was measured by determining the dilution end point when it was tested against the antigenic peach virus at 0.252 mg/ml in double diffusion plates. Particle size and shape of the peach isolate virus was determined by layering purified virus on formvar-coated 300-mesh grids, staining with 0.5% ammonium molybdate and examining the grids in a Philips 300 electron microscope. Biophysical characteristics of TRSV were determined by usual methods with crude sap from cucumber. The dilution end point, thermal inactiva- tion and longivity in_vi££g_were determined using infected cucumber sap and cowpea half-leaves to assay for infectivity. 8 Reintroduction of the Virus from Cucumber into Peach Thirty virus-free peach seedlings (var. Siberian C) with an average height of 250 cm were placed in a light-proof chamber and exposed to 10 minutes of light each hour to stimulate growth. The inoculation of seedlings invloved three treatments. Inoculum for two treatments was purified TRSVpi, undiluted and diluted 1:2 in phosphate buffer and inoculum for the third treatment was expressed sap from cucumbers infected with TRSVpi. For each of the first two treatments, seven carborundum-dusted Siberian C seedlings were rubbed with virus inoculum on etiolated leaves only. In thethird treatment seven seedlings were removed from the soil, the whole seedling rub-inoculated with TRSVpi infected sap and then returned to sterilized soil. Nine seedlings were rubbed with buffer solution to serve as controls. Ten days after inoculation two samples from each seedling were collected, inoculated and non-inoculated new leaves. The peach tissue was triturated in 3% nicotine buffer, rubbed onto cucumber and in four days the cucumber sap was tested against TRSVpi antiserum. This assay for infection was continued for 90 days. RESULTS I - Field Study Leaf extract from three trees induced local lesions on cucumber cotyledons (see figure 1) followed by a systemic mottling of the primary leaves. No symptoms developed on Chenopodium quinoa or on Nicotiana tabacum when they were directly inoculated with peach extract. In one tree extract from 23 out of 25 leaf samples induced TRSV symptoms when rubbed on cucumber with isolation of the virus from suckers being equal to isolation from top growth. For the remaining two trees extract from 10 out of 20 leaf samples were shown to be infected with TRSV. The high infectivity of the peach isolate was easily maintained in cucumber. In isolation trials during spring of 1978, the virus was also obtained from 14 out of 30 bud samples and 7 out of 10 flower samples from the main source tree. Virus was not recovered from the buds and flowers of the other trees sampled. Partially purified leaf extract from the virus-infected trees and sap from cucumbers inoculated with the peach virus gave a homologous reaction with antiserum to TRSV (Ramsdell) but no reaction with antiserum to TomRSV (Uyemoto). Soil from around the roots of declining peach trees was infested with Xiphinema americanum. Cucumber trap plants grown in subsamples of soil developed chlorotic local lesions within 14 to 24 days, followed by systemic symptoms. Serological tests on expressed cucumber sap indicated 9 10 Figure 1. Cucumbers showing local lesions on cotyledons and systemic chlorosis on primary leaves 7 days following inoculation with sap from peach infected with tobacco ringspot virus. 11 that both TomRSV and TRSV were present. Soil from an adjacent peach orchard without declining peach trees was not infested with §. americanum nor did cucumbers planted in the soil develop virus symptoms. Five peach trees exhibited stem pitting symptoms that is, develop- ment of spongy bark at the ground line and pitting of the cambial layer. This group of trees included the two which were minor TRSV sources while the major source tree for TRSV did not, as of summer of 1978, have stem pitting symptoms. Description and Identification g: the Virus, When a limited host range was inoculated with sap from cucumbers infected with the virus from the ailing peach trees all genera developed symptoms which are characteristic of TRSV (see Table 1). In cucumber, chlorotic lesions were followed by necrosis of the cotyledons and systemic mottling, stunt, and systemic necrosis develoyed on the primary leaves. Chenopodium quinoa developed necrotic lesions but none of the expected apical necrosis. Nicotiana tabacum developed yellow, local lesions with necrotic rings. Leaves of N, tabacum which developed after inoculation were symptomless but back inoculation to cucumber showed that virus was present. Necrotic local lesions developed on several cultivars of Phaseolus vulgaris. Common cOWpea developed necrotic local lesions with yellow halos (see figure 2) in 4 days followed by apical necrosis. Cow- pea strain (SY) did not exhibit symptoms and back inoculations to cucumber were negative. Check plants rubbed with the buffer remained symptomless. The purified preparation of the TRSVpi was infectious. It was obtained with a yield of 60 to 70 mg virus per Kg tissue. Separation of partially purified virus on a sucrose density gradient produced two 12 Table 1. Host range inoculated with tobacco ringspot virus isolated from peach and symptom development Host Symptoms Chenopodium quinoa Cucumis sativus (var. National pickling) Nicotiana tabacum (var. Burley) Phaseolus vulgaris (vars. Monroe, Coche, Scotia) Vigna unguiculata (S) Vigna unguiculata (SY) Sparse necrotic lesions Chlorotic local lesions, systemic mottling, dwarfing, necrosis Yellow, local lesions with some necrotic ring formation Local necrotic spots Apical necrosis, necrotic local lesions with yellow halo No symptoms 13 Figure 2. Reactions of Common cowpea plants to inoculation with the isolate of tobacco ringspot virus from peach 14 visible bands. Examination of the ultraviolet absorbance pattern from the 1800 fractionator indicated three bands (see Figure 3). The bottom band was the major component containing 90% of the infectivity, the middle band with 10% and the top band was non-infective. The dialyzed bottom component's 260nm/280nm ratio was 1.78. Antiserum produced from intramuscular injections of the purfied virus into a rabbit yielded a single band of precipitate to the antigenic preparation from cucumber sap. There was no precipitate formed between the antiserum and healthy cucumber extract. In double diffusion plates the TRSVpi antiserum titers ranged from 1:64 to 1:256. In electron micrographs of the purified virus, isolated from peach- infected cucumber, the particles were polyhedral and 28 to 30nm in dia- meter (see Figure 4). For the properties of TRSV in cucumber extract the dilution end point of the virus in crude sap was 10-4, the thermal inactivation point was 64 to 66 C and the virus remained infective is crude sap for 10 days at 22 C. Reintroduction of the Virus from Cucumber £3 Peach Within ten days, leaf extract from each TRSVpi inoculation treat- ment, but not buffer control, induced local lesions on cucumber cotyle- dons. Expressed sap from infected cucumbers reacted with TRSVpi anti- serum. In the first two treatments, if the etiolated growth was infected the adjacent new growth was also infected and in the third treatment virus was transmissible from the whole seedling. The virus continued to be transmissible for 90 days following inoculation. 15 unwaomuw zuwmcmv mmouozm Noqloa m :o vmumHonm comma Eouw moumaomfi maua> uoamwcfim ouomnoa mo mucosomaoo wwHSu use .m shaman mmouuom mo mumufiaaaafifi on 2 2 m ca 32:: stouuom mu ygz is Aoueqxosqe earners; 16 Figure 4. Electron micrograph of a density-gradient prep— paration of tobacco ringspot virus isolated from peach and negatively stained with 0.5% ammonium molybdate. 17 Table 2. Effect of inoculation method on infection in peach using tobacco ringspot virus isolated from peach No. TRSVpi infected/ 'Treatment No. inoculated Mechanical inoculation of etiolated leaves Purified TRSV(.82mg/ml), undiluted 6/7 Purified TRSV(.82mg/ml), diluted 1:2 in phosphate buffer 4/7 Mechanical inoculation of entire seedling Expressed sap from cucumber infected with TRSV 7/7 DISCUSSION Tobacco ringspot virus was isolated from buds of Prunus persica by Smith gt El (8), but the isolate was not characterized nor was the isolation repeated. We have confirmed the presence of TRSV in peach by isolating TRSV from a mature peach tree, by identifying the virus with host range, serology, and electron microscopy, by purifying the virus and producing antiserum, by mechanically inoculating peach seedlings with TRSVpi and by isolating TRSV from these inoculated seedlings. In cherry, sweet cherry and grape, TRSV was not consistantly distributed in the plant nor could it be isolated consistantly from season to season (4, 11, 14). Our findings demonstrated that the TRSV distribution in peach was relatively equivalent between buds, blossoms, and leaves, with leaves being the best source of virus for transmission to herbacious indicators. The TRSV isolation from these peach trees was repeated throughout two growing seasons with all trees infected the first season still being TRSV transmissible the second season. This is a sharp contrast to tomato ringspot virus which has only been sap transmitted from peach to herbacious host on one occassion (7). Smith 35 a1_mechanically inoculated healthy peach seedlings with TRSV and could isolate TRSV from these seedlings up to three weeks after inoculation. In our study TRSV was isolated from inoculated seedlings for 90 days, up to the time when they were put in cold storage. The inoculated seedlings did not develop consistant leaf symptoms upon 18 19 inoculation, as did TRSV when inoculated to cherry (14). Our evidence demonstrates fairly conclusively the presence of TRSV in declining peach trees but it is still unproven that TRSV is the cause of the decline. The answer to the latter question must await demonstra- tion of the development of the decline symptoms in TRSV-inoculated peach seedlings. In other words, this virus must persist in the seedlings over several dormant periods and cause a similar decline to that origi— nally observed before the virus can be determined as the cause of decline. However TRSV has already been shown to be pathogenic in other fruit crops such as cherry, sweet cherry and grape. Therefore those working with nepoviruses in peach probably should anticipate that TRSV is indeed a cause of disease and a potential hazard. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. REFERENCES BARRAT, J.G., S.M. MIRCETICH, and H.W. FOGLE. 1968. Stem pitting of peach. Plant Dis. Reptr. 52:91-94. DAVIDSON, T.R., and V. RUNDANS. 1972. Detection of necrotic ring- spot and prune dwarf viruses by indexing dormant cherry buds on herbaceous plants. Can. J. Plant Sci. 52:915-920. FULTON, J.P. 1962. Transmission of tobacco ringspot virus by Xiphinema americanum. PhytOpathology 57:535-537. GILMER, R.M., J.K. UYEMOTO, and L.J. KELTS. 1970. A new grapevine disease induced by tobacco ringspot virus. Phytopathology 62:1294-1302. KIRKPATRICK, R.C., P.W. CHENEY, and R.C. LINDER. 1964. Mechanical transmission of plum line pattern virus. Plant Dis. Reptr.48:616-6l8. MIRCETICH, S.M. and E.L. CIVEROLO. 1972. Relationship between stem pitting in peach and in other prunus species. Phytopathology 62:1294-1302. MIRECTICH, S.M., H.W. FOGLE, and E.L. CIVEROLO. 1970. Peach stem pitting: transmission and natural spread. Phytopathology 60:1329-1333. SMITH, S.H., R.F. STOUFFER, and D.M. SOULEN. 1973. Induction of stem pitting in peaches by mechanicalinoculation 'with tomato ringspot virus. Phytopathology 63:1404-1406. SMITH, S.H., and R.F. STOUFFER. 1970. Isolation of tomato and tobacco ringspot viruses from soil around stem pitted Prunus trees. Phytopathology 60:1017-1018. SMITH, S.H., and J.A. TRAYLOR. 1969. Stem pitting of yellow bud mosaic virus-infected peaches. Plant Dis. Reptr. 53:666-667. STAGE-SMITH, R., and A.J. HANSEN. 1974. Occurance of TRSV in sweet cherry. Can. J. Bot. 52:1647-1651. STAGE-SMITH, R. 1970. Tobacco ringspot virus. no. 17 in Descript- ions of plant virusesl Commonw. Mycol. Inst., Assoc. Appl. Biol., Kew, Surrey, England. (Unpaged). STAGE-SMITH, R., M.E. REICHAMAN, and N.S. WRIGHT. 1965. Purification and properties of TRSV and two RNA-deficient components. Virology 25:487-494. UYEMOTO, ..K., M.F. WELSH, and E. WILLIAMS. 1977. Pathogenicity of TRSV in cherry. Phytopathology 67:439-441. 20