LIBRA R 1’ L5 Michigan 35355; a Universiey This is to certify that the thesis entitled THE EFFECT OF DIET AND SODIUM BICARBONATE INGESTION UPON ACID-BASE BALANCE AND PERFORMANCE CAPACITY presented by SHOKR FALIAH-BOSJ l N has been accepted towards fulfillment of the requirements for _M.A,___degreein—44ea4+hr—2hysical Ed. 5 Recreation ' u. ‘4 Major professor Date 7'9- 79 OVERDUE FINES ARE 25¢ PER DAY PER ITEM Return to book drop to remove this checkout from your record. THE EFFECT OF DIET AND SODIUM BICARBONATE INGESTION UPON ACID-BASE BALANCE AND PERFORMANCE CAPACITY BY Shokr Fallah Bosjin A THESIS Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS Department of Health, Physical Education and Recreation 1979 ABSTRACT THE EFFECT OF DIET AND SODIUM BICARBONATE INGESTION UPON ACID-BASE BALANCE AND PERFORMANCE CAPACITY BY Shokr Fallah-Bosjin The purpose of this experiment was to determine the effects of sodium bicarbonate (NaHCOB) ingestion (.06 g/kg body weight) under either high carbohydrate or high fat-protein dietary ccmditions , upon acid—base balance and performance capacity. Eight male marathon runners (average age 30 years) under four treatment conditions (supplement carbohydrate , supplement fat- protein, placebo carbohydrate, and placebo fat-protein) were used. The subjects performed a graded treadmill test under each of the four dietary conditions. Length of run time was recorded and taken to be indicative of performance capacity. Arterialized blood samples , taken frcm a pre-wanmed fingertip, determined the acid-base status of subjects. The results of this experiment indicated that the change in lactic acid, pH and base excess (BE) concentrations observed under the supplement conditions were statistically significant. The pH was significantly higher under the supplement condition. The P002 values were affected on the dietary treatment. Performance times were not affected by either diet or supplement conditions. DEDICATION This thesis is sincerely dedicated to my mother, Fatemeh, who sacrificed much to impart an incentive for education to her only son and to my father, whose continu- ous love and support have given me courage to pursue my goals. ii Accepted by the faculty of the Department of Health, Physical Education and Recreation, College of Education, Michigan State University, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Master of Arts degree. / x . ////<:/ J ‘ ’~——— / Direc or of Thesrs . . I . ' ,/ A , Guidance Commrttee: fizz/@797 2? W740 flair/i 7AA ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The investigator would like to express his most sincere gratitude to his academic and thesis advisor, Professor W. D. VanHuss for his guidance, earnest encouragement and invaluable direction throughout the study and in the writing of this research. The author wishes to express his sincere appreciation to his committee members, Professor William Heusner and Professor Kwok-wai Ho, for their help and constructive suggestions. Special thanks are due to Asghar Khaledan for his generous assistance in the programming of this study for computer analysis, and many thanks to Ali Motaghi for his cooperation and time. Finally, I am most appreciative of my wife, Fatemeh for her understanding, cooperation, patience and encouragement during the years of graduate study. iii LIST OF LIST OF Chapter I. II. III. TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLES . . . . . . . . . . . . FIGURES . . . . . . . . . . . INTRODUCTION TO THE PROBLEM . . . . . The Purpose of the Study . . . . . . Research Hypothesis . . . . . . . . Research Plan . . . . . . . . . Limitation of the Study . . . . . . Definition of Terms . . . . . . . . REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE . . . . . The Relative Contribution of Carbohydrates Fat and Protein to Energy Metabolism at Rest and During Exercise . . . . Effect of Diet Upon Acid—Base Status . . Physical Performance in Relation to Diet . The Effect of Alkalization Upon Acid-Base Balance and Performance Time . . . . Alkaline Reserve . . . Buffer System and the Acid- -Base Status of the Blood . . Relationship of Lactic Acid, Blood pH and Their Roles as a Possible Limiting Factor in Performance . . . . . . . . . RESEARCH METHODS . . . . . . . . . Research Design . . . . . . . . . Preliminary Screening . . . . . . Exercise Test . . . . . . . . . Testing Procedure and Equipment . . . . Dietary Recall . . . . . . Sodium Bicarbonate (NaHCO3) Ingestion . Blood Sample . . . . . . . . . Lactic Acid Analysis . . . . . . . iv Page mmnnw l—' \J 10 13 15 20 21 24 26 26 29 31 33 33 35 35 36 Chapter Page pH, Partial Pressure Carbon Dioxide (PCOZ), Bicarbonate Concentration (HCO ) and Base Excess (BE) . . . . 36 Heart ate . . . . . . . . . . 37 Energy Metabolism . . . . . . . . 37 Respiration Rate . . . . . . . . 38 Parameters of the Study . . . . . . 39 Statistical Technique . . . . . . . 39 IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . 40 Lactic Acid Results . . . . . . . . 41 pH Results . . . . . . . . . . . 45 Base Excess (BE) Results . . . . . . 49 PCOZ Results . . . . . . . . . . 49 Performance Results . . . . . . . . 53 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . 59 V. SUMMARY, CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATIONS . 65 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . 66 Recommendations . . . . . . . . . 66 APPENDICES . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 8 BIBLIOGRAPHY . . . . . . . . . . . . . 81 LIST OF TABLES Page The Normal Values and Ranges of the Acid-Base Parameters of Blood . . . . . 12 The Two Experiments are Compared with Two Other Experiments . . . . . . . . . 18 Physical Characteristics of Subjects . . 27 Specifications for the Multi-stage Tread- mill Run . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 Mean, Standard Deviation (SD) and Percent- age of Carbohydrate, Fat and Protein under High Carbohydrates and High Fat-Protein Dietary Conditions . . . . . . . . 34 Statistical Results, Lactate (mMoL/L) . . 42 Changes in Lactate (mMoL/l) and Statistical Results . . . . . . . . . . . . 43 Statistical Results, pH . . . . . . . 46 Changes in pH and Statistical Results . . 47 Statistical Results, Base Excess (mEq/L) . 50 Change in BE mEq/L and Statistical Results . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 Statistical REsults, PCO (mmHg) . . 54 2 Changes in PC02 (mmHg) and Statistical Results . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 Basic Data Performance Time (Sec) and Statistical Results . . . . . . . . 57 vi LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 2-1. Metabolic Integration of Carbohydrates, Fat and Protein . . . . . . . . . 8 3-1. Sequence Treatments . . . . . . . 28 3-2. Single Bipolar V5 Configuration . . . 30 4-1. Lactic Acid Results . . . . . . . 44 4—2. pH Results . . . . . . . . . . 48 4-3. Base Excess Result . . . . . . . . 56 4-4. PCO2 Results . . . . . . . . . 53 4-5. Performance Results . . . . . . . 58 vii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION TO THE PROBLEM The data related to the effects of diet on the acid-base balance of the blood are not clear at present. An increase in blood pCO2 values of 2-3 mm Hg have been reported in subjects on a high carbohydrate diet (58,59, 91). No consistent changes have been observed in blood pH or base excess after meals (31, 35, 118). On the other hand, a 2-3 mEq/L increase in standard blood bicarbonate concentration may result from a very high protein diet (96). During mild exercise the blood pH remains fairly constant, but it declines as the intensity of the exercise increases (24,47,58,70,127). It is believed that lactic acid production is a function of exercise intensity (93). An increase in lactic acid production changes the acid-base status of the blood (102) which, in turn, becomes a limiting factor in maximal muscular exertion (100). Lactic acid dissociates into lactate— and H+ ions very quickly. A direct linear interrelation- ship has been reported between the lactate- level and the H+ ion concentration of the blood (66,117). Therefore, 1 if the formation of lactic acid is so quick that the buffering mechanisms in the body cannot maintain acid- base homeostasis, the competency of the muscle cell to maintain an elevated yield of ATP via the glycolytic pathway may be impaired. This is due, in part, to a pH- related inhibition of the rate limiting enzyme in anaero- bic glycoysis, phosphofructokinase (19,57,90). It is well known that endogenous glycogen storage in the working muscle can be increased by a high carbo- hydrate diet (73). An elevated endogenous glycogen content has been shown to be associated with an increased endurance work capacity (3,16,17,56,53,58,65,73,126). Other than simply increasing the availability of a ready energy source, the high carbohydrate loading may have effects on the acid-base balance in the body. Hunter found the arterial blood to be more alkaline in subjects on a high carbohydrate diet (>60% carbohydrate) and more acid in subjects on a high fat-protein diet (about 50% fat and 30% protein) (75). Oral ingestion or intravenous injection of sodium bicarbonate in sufficient amounts also will increase the alkalinity of the blood (21,22,42,72). This increased alkalinity may elevate the potential buffering capacity and thus enhance performance. Dennig (41) has reported that oxyten debt capacity and the ability to do strenuous work of greater than 20 minutes duration are markedly increased in alkalosis, whereas both oxygen debt capacity and performance are lowered in the acidotic state (41). More recently, Jones gt a1. (79) and Sutton gt al. (124) also found that pre-exercise acidosis reduces the post- exercise antecubital venous blood lactate concentration and decreases the performance time of exhaustive exercise. Conversely, in the alkalotic condition the lactate concen- trations are relatively high and the performance times are relatively long. There are additional studies which indicate that blood lactic acid and oxygen debt capacity are higher and work performance is better under alkalotic conditions (69,79,97); however, there are several studies which do not support this position (77,92). Therefore, the area of bicarbonate supplementation and performance must be regarded as controversial at this time. Additional research appears to be needed. Little is known about the interrelationships between diet, alkalizer supplementation and the capacity to perform exercise to exhaustion. The present study was designed to contribute new information in this area. The Purpose of the Study The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of sodium bicarbonate ingestion (0.06 grams/kg body weight), under either high carbohydrate or high fat—protein dietary conditions, upon acid-base balance and work performance during strenuous exercise. Research Hypotheses This investigation was designed to test the following research hypotheses: l. Pre-exercise sodium bicarbonate supplementa- tion produces increased metabolic alkalosis and improved exercise performance capacity. 2. As compared to a high fat-protein diet, a high carbohydrate diet produces increased metabolic alkalosis and improved exercise performance capacity. 3. The metabolic and performance effects of a high carbohydrate diet and sodium bicarbonate supplementation are synergistic. Research Plan A Latin-square design with eight subjects and four treatments, with replication, was used. The subjects were marathon competitors from the central Michigan area. The scheduled treatments were as follows: 1. High carbohydrate diet + NaHCo3 2. High carbohydrate diet + Placebo 3. High fat-protein diet + NaHCo3 4. High fat-protein diet + Placebo The subjects' energy metabolism and performance time in an exhaustive, multi-stage treadmill run were measured under the four treatment conditions. Prior to exercise and following each stage of the run, arterialized blood samples were taken for determination of the acid- base status of the subjects. The data were anlyzed using the two-way, repeated-mesures analysis of variance (51) and the non-parametric sign test (114). Limitation of the Study l. The results of this study can be applied only to athletes with characteristics similar to those of the subjects used. 2. Although standard precautions were taken, psychological and physiological fatigue may be concomitant variables in any repeated measures study involving exhaustive work. 3. The investigator was not able to control the amount of sleep and daily exercise of the subjects. These factors may have affected their performances during the testing. Definition of Terms Acid-base balance - The relative proportions of acids and alkali (H+ and OH- ions) in the blood and tissues. Blood pH - A measure of the acidity or alkalinity of the blood. Aciodsis - A shift of the acid-base balance such that the acidity of the blood and tissues is increased (pH decreased). Alkalosis - A shift of the acid-base balance such that the alkalinity of the blood and tissues is increased (pH increased). Alkaline Reserve - The amount of alkalizing salts (mainly sodium bicarbonate) that is available in the blood for buffering. Lactic acid - An organic acid and an end product of the anaerobic metabolism of carbohydrates. Base excess - (BE) - the Base concentration of whole blood as measured by its titration to pH 7.40 at a pCO of 40 mm Hg. BE is equal to buffer base minus normal 2 buffer base; therefore, normal BE = 0. CHAPTER II REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE A review of literature with some discussion is presented for six pertinent areas: (1) the relative contribution of carbohydrate, fat and, protein to energy metabolism at rest and during exercise, (2) effect of diet upon acid-base status, (3) physical performance in relation to diet, (4) the effect of alkalization upon acid—base balance and performance, (5) buffer system and acid-base status of the blood, and (6) the relationship of lactic acid, blood pH and their roles as a possible limiting factor in performance. The Relative Contribution of Carbohydrate Fat and Protein to Energy Metabolism at Rest and During ExercISe The relative contribution of the three fuels (protein,fat, and carbohydrate) to energy metabolism is dependent upon the rate of the biological energy cycle, the availability of the substrate, the intensity of exer- cise, and the physical condition of the subject (84). The general scheme of carbohydrates, fats and proteins as energy sources is represented in Figure 2-1. All three Glycogen CARBOHYDRATES glucose-lophosphate QIUCOSE z glucose-S-phosphate FAT I 5, .1 m; glycerol acetoacetate CoA NAEROBI a , ‘ GLUCOGENIC AMINO ACIDS ‘. PATHWAY C9 Catienc acnd Q'vcme alanine l , KETOGENIC AMINO ACIDS / 5,6342%“ 2:;IZTne i) —. pyruvlc aCld phenylalanme l methnomnej /; i / tyrosme aCGIYI COA Ieucme lactlc acnd Isoleucme Iyyne aspamc aCld —0 oxaloacetlc Catnc aCld Cld I KREBS CYCLE GLUCOGENIC 2-ketoglutanc “PAINO ACIDS ac'd ! prOIlne I3 I IYSlnB 9 U '0 ac'd histidlne hydroxyprollne Figure 2-l.--Metabolic Integration of Carbohydrates, Fat and Protein. diets can serve as energy sources via the different pathways (85). During heavy muscular exercise of short duration the muscles obtain their energy from endogenous phospho— gen and glycogen (99). In 1896, when Chaveau reported a rise in the respiratory quotient (RQ) toward unity in exercise, it was generally accepted that the primary source of energy for muscular contractions was carbo- hydrate metabolism (26). Many investigators claimed that exercise RQs were similar to resting ROS and that fat was being metabolized (5,84,95,120). From these data, it was concluded that carbohydrate and fat are the major sources of energy for muscular contraction. Most of the findings have indicated that carbohydrate and their resulting glycogen stores are the influential fuel for endurance exercise (3,16,52,56,65,126). There are two important sources of fat in the body for use during muscular activity: (a) intramuscular triglycerides and (b) free fatty acids (FFA) that are derived from the trigly- cerides in the adipose tissue (131). During exercise, approximately 50 percent of the fat-derived energy comes from each of the two sources (119). Fat does have a primary role in energy production during certain types of exercise. At very intensive work levels, it has been shown that glycolysis is the primary lO mechanism for the anaerobic output of energy and fat can- not participate in this process (6). Part of the reason may be that lactic acid has been shown to suppress FFA mobilization (55). It is not completely clear why fat is not involved during high intensity exercise (111). There is a controversy regarding whether or not the intramuscu- lar triglyceride pool is used during strenuous activity (103). During moderately heavy exercise fats contribute about 30 percent of the energy (61). In prolonged endurance exercise the contribution of fats and blood glucose to the energy output increases (19,34,104). The oxidation of fats in the metabolic pathways is dependent upon the cxidative capacity of the individual and the intensity of the work (9). Protein does not contribute significantly to ATP synthesis during exercise and is not used as a fuel to any substantial extent when the caloric supply is suffi- cient (26,86,105). Effect of Diet Upon Acid-Base Status It has been claimed by Siggard-Anderson (117) that, after a heavy meal the base excess concentration rises by 3-4 milli equivalents per liter (mEq/L). The standard bicarbonate concentration of blood tends to increase by 2-3 mEq/L after a very high protein diet (97). (The normal values and ranges of the acid-base parameters ll of blood is illustrated in Table 2-1 (1). Jansen and Karbaum (76) found a rise in the pH of blood after a meal. However, Shock and Hastings (113), and Cullen and Earle (35), were unable to find any constant change in pH of blood after meal. Ingestion of a vegetable-based diet has been shown to result in PC02 values 2-3 mm Hg higher than PCO2 values when on a meat-based diet (59,60,97,ll7). However, the pH of the blood was not significantly altered on a vegetable or a meat-based diet (59). In addition, Lundbaek (90) found that a high carbohydrate diet tended to raise the PC02 of blood by about 3 mm Hg compared with a low carbohydrate diet. It has been shown that diet can affect the concen- tration of lactic acid in the blood during exercise of the same intensity (130). It has also been found that serum lactic acid levels are influenced by different diets, i.e., the concentration of lactic acid was less on a low carbohydrate diet, high fat diet under standard work con- ditions of 70-75% oOZmaX (65,107). If an anaerobic exercise is based on glycogen stores, a rich carbohydrate diet should enhance endogenous glycogen levels. The lactic acid concentration in the blood provides an index of glycolytic work relative to diet and performance (7,46,74,9l,l30). The blood lactate values were greater during supramaximal work bouts when 12 comm um mm mm l we q\cme mmmm Hmwmsm 00mm um mm m.m+ l v.ml H.ol A\WME mmmoxm mmmm comm pm we m.am I m.e~ m.~m a\ems mumconumoflm cumccmum m.am he . mm ~.Ha mm as Ncom mme.a . mam.a moa.n oma.a . oem.s com.» me mmcmm Uonm um csHm> mmcmm 00mm Dc mus> Hmumamnmm .coon mo mumumemumm mmmmlcflod may we mmmcmm 6cm MODHM> HMEHOZ OSBII.HIN mam¢8 13 muscle glycogen stores were "loaded" as a result of a high carbohydrate (CHO) diet, with decreased muscle glycogen stores, lactic acid appears to have an inhibitory effect on glycogenolysis (4). Physical Performance in Relation to Diet The relation of physical performance to diet has long been of interest to nutritionists, exercise physio- logists, medical doctors and coaches. Zuntz (1901), Krogh and Lindhard (1920) and Christensen and Hansen (1939) were among the first researchers to establish a relationship between diet and work performance (5,28,30, 49,84,86,95,120,133). A number of studies have shown that the capacity for prolonged exercise is enhanced after eating a high carbohydrate diet. It is possible to increase capacity to store energy in the form of glycogen in the muscle and liver cells (l6,20,56,65,78,80,103). By applying muscle biopsy technique of Bergstrom, Hultman and Bergstrom determined the glycogen content in the leg muscles of subjects following exercise under various dietary conditions. They found that a CHO diet will raise muscle glycogen stores above normal levels following exhaustive work of the muscles involved the subjects exhibited a signifi- cantly longer performance time on the CHO diet (2,9,16, 73,111). It seems that although carbohydrate is not 14 main fuel for endurance activity the reduction of glycogen stores in the working muscle is still one of the limiting factor primarily in those endurance activi- ties which are of relatively high intensity and long duration (ninety minutes or more) such as distance running, bicycle racing and cross country skiing (19,33,65). The phenomenon of glycogen supercompensation has been utilized by having the individual work to exhaustion and then to load with carbohydrates for several days prior to competition. The performance could be continued longer than any other dietary procedure (2,9,16,19,73,lll). In 1965 Asmussen (4) presented several theories as to have high fat diets may adversely affect endurance capacity. First, resultant low levels of blood sugar may deteriorate performance through effects on the central nervuos system. Secondly, there is a higher energy requirement, per calorie of energy when fat is oxidized. Finally, when fat is metabolized, the intermediate meta- bolites created, such as acetoacetic acid and betahydroxy- butyric acid, which produces an acidotis condition. The early experiments supported the concept that work performed was more economical when carbohydrate was the source of energy. When fat was utilized as a source of energy, instead of carbohydrates, there was 10 to 12 percent decreased in efficiency (81,86,94). It has also 15 been experimentally reported that fatigue occurred earlier on high fat diets (27). Russian investigators claim that high protein diet enhances the excitability of the nerve system, elevates reflex activity and, increases the speed of reaction and ability to concentrate (110). The Effect of Alkalization Upon ACId-Base Balance and Performance Time It is logical to assume that an artificial increase in the quantity of alkalies in the body should enhance the level of muscular performance by buffering the lactic acid produced. Dennig gt. gt. (41) first reported that a runner starting from an alkaline state, as compared to a normal or acidic state, may be able to accumulate a greater oxygen debt. In the alkaline state, a greater CO2 content and higher pH were found when compared tx> the normal or the acidic state during rest and work. Dill, Edwards and Talbott (42) found that "a runner in an alkaline state ran 6 minutes and 4 seconds to exhausion in comparison with 5 minutes 22 seconds starting from normal state." They reported that intake of sodium bicarbonate resulted in a 20% increase in 02 debt, 40% increase of blood lactic acid (measured 3% minutes after the run) and 40% increase of alkaline reserve (42). l6 Dennig (40) later reported (in 1937) significant increases in treadmill endurance times of subjects after alkaline ingestion. His refined dosages included sodium citrate 5.0 gm. sodium bicarbonate 3.5 gm. and potassium citrate 1.5 gm. This represented a daily dosage taken after each meal for two days before and after a test to avoid an acidotic reaction. No dosage was taken five hours prior to exercise. The limitation of the study was that the only moderately-trained subjects were used. Dennig also cited a similar study by Albat, who applied a blind test to an unstated number of subjects who per- formed to exhaustion on a bicycle ergometer. During 35 days of testing without treatment the average performance time was 10.9 minutes. In 13 days by applying combination of potassium bicarbonate and potassium citrate, the average performance time increased 42 percent to 15.9 minutes. On 2 days when ammonium chloride was administered to produce an acidotic state the performance time decreased to 4.6 minutes (40). Karpovich and Sinning (82) reported that Dennig's formula had no significant effect on performance of college swimmers. In 1933, Margaria, Edwards and Dill (93) reported two experiments on a moderately trained male subject running to exhaustion on a treadmill. The speed was 18.7 kilometers per hour on a 5 percent grade. In Table 2-2 17 two experiments are compared with two other experiments performed in the same conditions but without previous ingestion of alkali. In both experiments, the lactic acid concentration increased and the oxygen debt decreased after alkalization. The investigators concluded that the "performance was better" after alkalization. In 1953, Johnson and Black (77) studied several blood alkalizer and glucose. The subjects were eleven male members of champion high school cross-country run- ners (age 16 to 19) during a competitive season. They were divided into four experimental groups and performance times were measured for the 1.5 mile course eight times during the competition season. The subjects received either a placebo or experimental compound prior to each competition except one. The dosage was administered 2.5 hours before the event. Each group obtained one of five substances: (a) glucose, 2 ounces; (b) sodium citrate, 5 gm; (c) sodium bicarbonate, 3.5 gm; and potas- sium citrate, 1.5 gm, and (d) sodium acid phosphate, 3 gm, and glucose, 2.4 ounces. The placebo was composed of 1 gm lactose (capsule). The substances were rotated so that each group ingested each substance twice. The result indicated that the time of the performers were not significantly affected by any of the ergonic aids under study. However, the investigators stated that the 18 m mmo.o «\H m ee.ee owe oommz m om mm umbEm>oz omo.o m\m m oe.ee oee In- mm umhouoo emeo.o M\H m em.ee eme moomoz em om Hm umhouoo mmeo.o a on.~e HNH Ill we umnouoo Ammuseflz. Amhmpeq. Loo ooe hue aces :«d mo mogomhwm Him .>.¢ you: coflumuucmocou ucmcbmmhm. mama dogmnwmmmmmflc mo were concaaamu :«d Exes magmum Lo amumccu usxamo co_wmam .mucmeflummxm uccuo 036 cufla cwummeoo mum mucwEHummxm 038 m:BII.NIN mqmfie 19 temperature range throughout the fall session (39 to 91°F) may have influenced the study results (65). Limited information is available about an experiment conducted by Dawson in 1935 (37). He reported that a runner ingested 10 grams of sodium bicarbonate dissolved in tea. A negative effect was observed upon endurance performance. During the run, the alveolar CO2 of the subject rose and then fell. An increasing diffi- culty breathing was attributed to the exhaustion of the runner. In 1936, Hewitt and Callaway (69) reported a study on the effects of alkalization (orange juice, tomato, tomato juice, which contained potassium citrates and tartrates) upon college swimmers. The investigators concluded that swimming performance was improved. In 1971, Margaria, gt.gt. (92) studied the effect of 3.24 gm sodium bicarbonate, sodium citrate and potas- sium citrate ingestion upon supermaximal exercise per- formance (10 mi/hr, 10% grade) of twelve normal men. No significant effects upon performance or blood lactic acid levels were found. With ingestion of 12 gm sodium bicarbonate, performance times increased up to 5.8 percent which was not statistically significant. Atterbom (11) using a dosage of 0.13 gram/kg body weight NaHCO during high-intensity work (about 2.5 minutes) 3 20 found increased base excess levels (4.1 mEq per liter) in the extracellular fluid before exercise. Improved, but not statistically significant, performance times were recorded. Simmons and Hardt (122), in 1973, administrated a mixture of 0.715 gm sodium citrate, 0.50 gm sodium bicar- bonate, 0.215 potassium citrate and placebo 1.43 gm sucrose. The results indicated that the supplemental alkali in contrast to the placebo, had appreciable influence on performance capacity of the swimmers. Alkaline Reserve The alkaline reserve is important during exercise in that it extends the time to observe lactate in the blood. The studies of Full (48), Wissing (132) and later Ewing (45) indicated that training increased the alkaline reserve. Coupled with an increase of the O2 debt, the capacity to withstand the lactic acid produced during moderate and heavy exercise was also increased. The preponderance of experimental evidence, however, indicates that training does not change the alkaline reserve in man and animal (108,109,123). Reduction of the alkaline reserve during muscular exercise places a limit upon performance (112). The limit appears to be fatigue, or accumulation of unbuffered acid (including lactic) in the muscle tissue (125). 21 Ingestion of sodium bicarbonate (oral or intra- venous) in sufficient amounts, increases the alkaline reserve of the blood (15,22,21). The capacity of the blood for buffering acid metabolites is raised (42). Buffer System and the Acid-Base Status of the Blood During lower steady state activity, lactic acid levels hold constant during work. Marked increases in both lactic acid and pyruvic acid are observed during maximal or near maximal exercise (9,38,89,129). The pH of the arterial blood during rest is about 7.40 while the pH of the venous blood is approximately 7.37 (9). The differences between the two values results from acid metabolites which have invaded the venous blood from the muscle tissue. The range of blood pH is betwwen 6.8 and 7.8 (22,62,87). Exercise, diet, and respiratory changes create variation in the pH level; the range, how- ever, tends to remain between the 7.3 and 7.5, well within the tolerance limit (62). Bock, et a1. (23) found that the more physically fit men had a smaller increase in acidity of the blood. The pH of the blood is related to the intensity and duration of work effort the fitness of the subject and the temperature of the environment. There is a general consensus that the pH of blood remains more or less the 22 same during mild exercise, that it falls slightly during moderate exercise and it falls steeply during severe exercise (24,47,58,70,127,l30). Heusner and Bernauer (68) concluded that trained subjects are able to perform a given task at a lower level of stress (higher pH) in an exhaustive exercise. Cureton (36) stated that very few athletes, even among superior high level runners, are capable to drive themselves until the blood becomes acid in reaction. There has, however, been controversy over the effect of exercise on the pCO2 of blood. Some experi- menters (39,71) produced evidence that upon exercise the pCO increases, other authors (24,49) have found that 2 the pCO falls, and still others have established no 2 change in the pCO2 upon exercise (12). However, Teraslinna and McLeod (127) found that the pCO2 decreased during the early stages of exercise, and then increased as the exercise continued. These differences in findings may be attributed to differences in the kinds of works used, and difference in experimentally and measuring technique used, and to sampling errors (71). There is an agreement that the concentration of standard bicarbonate, the base excess and buffer base concentration of blood decrease slightly with mild and moderate exercise, and decreased more steeply with severe 23 exercise (24,39,58). The primary buffer in the plasma and tissue fluids is sodium bicarbonate (22). The bicarbonate buffer system depends upon carbonic acid (HZCOB) as the weak acid and sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3) as the buffer salt. In this system, lactic acid (HLA) reacts with sodium bicarbonate to form sodium lactate (NaLA) and carbonic acid (HZCOB) as follows: HLA + NaHCO + NaLa + H co I CO2 (19). 3 2 3 Since HZCO3 is a weaker acid than HLA, the buffer system has an alkalizing effect upon the blood. In severe muscular exercise, acids which concentrate in the blood results in an uncompensated acidosis (9,66,102,106). During this process more buffer alkalizers are a require- ment. The capacity of the blood for buffering acid metabolites will rise by ingestion of sodium bicarbonate (oral or intravenous injection), in turn will raise the alkaline reserve of the blood (15,21,22,42). Thus, the buffering capacity of the blood is directly related to the continuation of muscular work. 24 Relationship of Lactic Acid, Blood pH and their Roles as a Possible Limiting Factor in Performance Simonson (121) reported that Pernow, et al. (1965) found a decrease in pH in femoral venous blood to a mean value of 7.09 in 19 healthy young men during strenuous exercise. A linear relationship was found between decrease of pH and increase of lactate. After maximal exercise of short duration, lactic acid was found to increase to values as high as 32.1 mM. The consequent changes in the acid—base balance decreased the blood pH to 6.80. There was a straight-line relationship where lactic acid and blood pH and base excess (102). Hermansen (64) established that the limiting factors in anerobic work depend on: (1) approximately low glycogen store, (2) the high concentration of lactic acid in the muscle cell, (3) the lowered intracellular pH, and (4) combination of these and other reflections. Bergstrom, et a1. (18), proposed one possible process by which glycolysis is inhibited is the rapid build-up of lactate which causes a marked decrease in the intracellular pH. A decrease in pH is recognized to inhibit phosphofractokinase activity and enhance the inhibitory effect of ATP (128). Costill (32) found that in highly trained distance runners the increase in blood lactic acid in competitive races is related inversely to the distance of the race. 25 It is rather well known that one of the main limiting factors in prolonged severe exercise is the maximal amount of oxygen which can be transported to and utilized by the muscles. The amount of glycogen decrease and lactic acid increase during continuous stimulation of isolated muscle (64). Astrand, et al. (8) measured blood lactate con- centration from cross-country skiers at l to 3 minutes after the finish of races of distances from 10 to 85 km. After 10 km race of times of 35 to 36 minutes, the average concentration of lactic acid was 139 mg/100 ml of blood; at 30 km, with times of 1 hour and 50 to one hour and 56 minutes, mean lactic acid value was 68 mg/100 ml. At 50 km, with times of 3 hours and 6 to 18 minutes the mean lactic acid value was 39 mg/100 ml. The interpreta- tion for the low value after prolonged work is consistent, i.e., the greater the intensity of the work the greater the lactate value. CHAPTER III RESEARCH METHODS The following methods and procedures were used to determine the effects of two diets and sodium bicarbonate supplementation upon acid-base status and work performance in an exhaustive, multi-stage treadmill run. Research Design A Latin—square design with eight subjects and four treatments was used. The subjects were male marathon runners (average age 30 years) from the central Michigan area. (Physical characteristics of subjects is shown in Table 3-1). The treatments consisted of oral doses of NaHCO3 or a placebo administered blindly to subjects who were on either high carbohydrate or high fat-protein diets. The sequence of the four treatments is shown in Figure 3-1. The subjects were assigned numbers randomly and then were rotated to a different treatment condition each week according to the sequence indicated in the body of the figure. 26 27 TABLE 3-l.--Physical Characteristics of Subjects. Subject Age Weig?t Height Feet Inches SF 20 69.7 5 11 BR 26 66.5 5 10 DA 27 71.5 6 00 D5 28 54.5 5 6 SC 29 54.9 5 5 BM 31 73.5 5 7 BK 37 68.4 5 11 GS 40 73.5 5 7 28 mucofiummua mo mocmsqmmll.alm musmflm mucmsummne onmomem moommz r oncomem moommz + + n + + aflmuoum aflmuoum m lame seem lumm seem _ omo amen omo hoe: m m w H a .n w v m m H .m H a m m .m m H a m .H 29 Preliminary Screening Each subject was required to have a recent physical examination and medical approval for participa- tion in the study. In addition, a standard informed con- sent form was completed. A modified Bruce stress test was used to determine if the subjects had any difficulties under heavy exercise conditions. Electrodes were placed on each subject in the single bipolar V5 electrocardiograph configuration recommended by Ellested (44). This electrode placement is shown in Figure 3—2. Each subject was tested with the following protocol: lst level: 3.5 miles/hour, 8% grade, 3 min duration 2nd level: 4.2 miles/hours, 12% grade, 3 min duration 3rd level: 6.0 miles/hours, 12% grade, 3 min duration 4th level: 8.0 miles/hours, 12% grade, 1.5 min duration Blood pressure (BP) was measured immediately following the exercise at each level. The electrocardiogram (ECG) was monitored throughout the test as well as between exercise levels. The test was continued as soon as the BP was recorded. The following criteria were used for terminating a stress test before all four levels were completed: ./- \ I , A ”\J /J .I .\ '_/ Figure 3.2.--Single Bipolar V5 Configuration. 31 l. Systolic blood pressure over 220 mm Hg. 2. Diastolic blood pressure over 110 mm Hg. 3. Depression of the ST segment of the ECG greater than 2mm. 4. Premature ventricular contractions (PVCs) in pairs or with increasing frequency. No individual who had any PVCs, any ST segment depression, or an abnormal blood pressure was used as a subject. Exercise Test After the stress test, all subjects who were selected for the study were assumed to be reasonably familiar with running on a treadmill. A brief descrip- tion of the study and the required work task was given to each subject before the experiment began. The exer- cise test involved a six stage treadmill run. The speed and grade used for each level is shown in Table 3-2. Each level consisted of three minutes of work followed by three minutes of recovery. Blood samples were collected during the recovery period at each level. The subjects continued through the stages until they had run to exhaustion. The timed (15 min) recovery period was then initiated. A light-weight safety harness was worn by the subjects to protect them from falling and to make them feel more secure while running. 32 wooeh nuoe m ll .. m wooed sum m ll l- m UOOHQ sum m II II b menace: ma wnm>oomm UOOHQ new m NH 0H m cooHn cum m m ca m eooHn sum m m a a eolo new m A m m cooHn cum m m n m cooHn cum m m m H cooHn uma II I: ll wmfloumxm cucumm mHmEmm coon masses mocha ASQEV ACME my pmmm coflumusc accoumm commm Hmnfisz Hc>mq .csm HHHEGMOHB mmmgmlfiuasz may now mcoprOHMflommmll.Nlm mnmde 33 Testing Procedure and Equipment The following procedures were conducted after the subjects came into the Human Energy Reserch Laboratory (Department of Health, Physical Education and REcreation, Michigan State University). 1. Dietary recall 2. Blood sampling 3. Placement of electrodes on subject's chest 4. Exercise testing-gas collection for energy metabolism 5. Recording heart rate (HR) during run and recovery 6. Recording respiration rate DietaryiRecall The diet was divided into two categories: (a) high carbohydrate and (b) high fat and protein. Lists of common carbohydrate and fat-protein foodstuffs were given to each subject prior to the commencement of the study. These lists are shown in Appendix A. The subjects were required to record their dietary intakes during meals and snacks for three successive days prior to each test. A sample recording sheet is included in Appendix A. The technique of Bowes and Church was used (29) . The percent carbohydrate, fat, and protein obtained in diet procedure used to obtain high carbohydrate and high fat protein conditions are shown in Table 3—3. 34 aeoo. u c *eoo. u leoo. u m w :Hmuoum w pom H omu mm.m~ u m Hm.om u om.mm u m ua>oza e.m om.e e.m em.m mm.m m.o o.e He.m m.HH m.m H.a m.oH .um o.m~ o.ma s.em 5.5H m.em «.mm m.e~ o.me e.mm m.ae o.am ~.~m _m :Hmuonm umm omo :Hmuoum umm oeo cemuonm been 020 cemboum yam emu w w w w w w w w w m w w .mmmc .om. lemme .om. cemuoumlpmm omo :Hmuoumlumm one + + m+ m+ onmomem chmomem oommz comma .mcowuflccoo mumuwwa aflmuoumlumm swam paw mmumucmnonnmu swam Hopes cflwuoum can umm .mpcucmsonumo mo mmmucmonom can Acme GOwu0H>mQ pumpccum .cmlel.MIm wands 35 Sodium Bicarbonate (NaHCO3) Ingestion Since this was a blind study, the NaHCO3 and the placebo (dextrose) were administered in indistinguishable gelatin capsules. The oral dosage of NaHCO was 0.06 g/kg 3 of body weight while that of the placebo was 0.05 g/kg of body weight. These dietary supplements were taken two hours before the tests were given. Blood Sample An arterialized capillary blood sample (120 Ml) was taken before the exercise test, immediately after each level of the test, and at the 5th, 10th and 15th minutes of recovery. Each blood sample was taken from a finger tip which was pre-warmed in 48°C water. In order to maintain finger warmth during running, each subject wore a plastic glove one-third filled with warm water. Once the treadmill was stopped, the subject was seated on a chair, the hand was withdrawn from the glove, and the following procedures were followed: 1. A finger was thoroughly dried, sterilized with alcohol and again wiped dry with a sterile gauze pad. 2. A finger was lanced with a sterilized long- point microlance. 3. The first drop of blood to appear was wiped away and then a large pool of blood was allowed to form. 36 4. A capillary tube was immersed in the center of the blood pool and was filled by capil- lary action and gravity. This technique was used to insure that the blood sample was not taken from the surface of the pool. Lactic Acid Analysis One-hundred ul blood samples were collected in unheparinized capillary tubes for the determination of blood lactate by the enzymatic method (98). A Sigma lactic acid chemical kit1 was used for the enzymatic reaction, a Gilford Stasar II spectrophotometer2 was used for the analysis. pH, Partial Pressure Carbon D1oxide (PCOQ), Bicarbonate Concentratiofi (HCOQ) and Base Excess (BE) “ The 120 pl blood samples collected in heparinized capillary tubes were used to determine pH, PCO and PO 2 directly by means of a Radiometer.3 Then HCOS and BE values were determined by employing the Astrup 2 Equilibiration Method for acid-base balance variables (9,115,116,118). l . . S1gma Chemical Company, P.O. Box 14058, St. Louis. 2 . G1lford Instrument Laboratories, Oberlin, OHi. 3 . Rad1ometer, 72 EMDRUPVEJ, Copenhagen, NV, Denmark. 38 every two minutes for the next six mintues, and once every three minutes during the final six minutes. The percentages of CO2 and O2 in the expired air were determined using a Beckman Medical Gas Analyzer (Model L82) and a Beckman Oxygen Analyzer (Model OM-ll),7 respectively. The volume of exhaled air was measured by pumping the gas in each bag through a calibrated American Meter Company Dry Gas Meter (Model DTM-llS)8 at a constant rate of flow (50 l/min). Helium was used to determine the zero points of the analyzers. Room air and a known standard gas sample (17.78% 0 and 4.13% C02) 2 were used to calibrate the analyzers. The oxygen and carbon dioxide concentrations of the standard gas sample were checked using a Haldane9 chemcial analyzer. All energy metabolsim calculations (ventilation, O uptake, 2 and RQ) were made as described by Consolazio, et a1. (31). Respiration Rate Respiration rate was detected using a Sanborn 10 pressure transducer (Model 268A) connected by plastic 7Beckman Instruments, Inc., 3900 River Road, Schiller Park, Illinois. 8Singer American Meter Company. 9Arthur H. Thomas Company, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. loSanborn Company, Cambridge, Massachusetts. 39 tubing to the Otis-McKerrow respiratory valve. The changes in intravalve pressure during the respiratory cycle were recorded on a Sanborn Twin-Viso Recorder once every minute for ten seconds. The average respiratory rate was computed for each treadmill run. Parameters of the Study The following parameters were selected for this study: (a) performance time, (b) lactic-acid before exercise, (c) lactic-acid after each level of exercise, (d) lactic-acid during recovery, (e) change in lactic- acid from before to after exercise, (f) pH before exercise, (g) pH after each level of exercise, (h) pH during recovery, (i) change in pH from before to after exercise, (j) base excess before exercise, (k) base excess after each level of exercise, (1) base excess during recovery, (m) change in base excess from before to after exercise, (n) PCO before exercise, (0) PCO after each level of 2 2 exercise, (p) PCO2 during recovery and (q) change in PC02 from before to after exercise. Statistical Technique The data were analyzed using the two-way ANOVA repeated-measures technique (51). Time-related repeated- measures data were anlyzed utilizing the Sign test (114). CHAPTER IV RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The purpose of the study was to investigate the effects of sodium bicarbonate ingestion under either high carbohydrate or high fat-protein dietary conditions upon acid—base status and performance time in an exhaustive, multi-stage treadmill run. The data are presented in the following order: a. Lactic acid before the run, lactic acid after each level of the run, lactic acid during recovery, and change in lactic acid from before to after the run; b. pH before the run, pH after each level of the run, pH during recovery, and change in pH from before to after the run; c. Base excess before the run, base excess after each level of the run, base excess during recovery, and change in base excess from before to after exercise. d. PCO2 before the run, PCO2 after each level of the run, PCO2 during recovery and change in PC02 from before to after the run; e. Performance time 40 41 Lactic Acid Results The statistical results for lactic acid for the various experimental conditions are presented in Table 4-1, 4-2, Appendix B, and Figure 4—1 (a through f). Only the differences in lactic acid production between those taken after fifth level of exercise and those taken after the 3rd levelcmfrecovery (AL5—R3) were statistically significant. The greatest differences between the lactic acid values occurred with bicarbonate supplementa- tion. There were no other significant differences among the experimental conditions. In Figure 4-1 a-f in which all items were considered, no significant differences were observed when the Sign test was utilized. In Figure 4-1 a, b, and f in which the dietary conditions were comparied, no observable differences were demonstrated. There were substantial differences in Figure 4-1 c, d and e in which sodium bicarbonate and placebo supplementation were compared. Under the placebo condition the lactate change point occurred at level 2. With sodium bicarbonate supplementation, there were lactate change points at both level 2 and 3. Furthermore, after level 3, the lactate values with supplementation were higher at level 4, at level 5, and during recovery. Although no statistical analysis were used to test the differences between the 42 TABLE 4-l.--Statistical Results, Lactate (mMoL/L). Cominjcns . ANOWA Narxh DEMDO3 Plamix> Phxebo + + + + CED Fabikc CEO Fatikc S D I varfiflfles (83 GE?) EC) GT?) P P P (a) PW x 1.07 1.04 1.04 1.24 0.74 0.76 0.69 so 0.9 0.7 0.7 0.5 (b) L1 34' 2.23 1.41 1.57 1.61 0.65 0.44 0.40 so 2.4 0.4 0.6 0.8 (c) L2 2 1.88 171 2.33 1.80 0.45 0.32 0.60 so 1.3 04 0.7 0.9 (d) L3 x 3.08 3.36 476 3.12 0.37 0.40 0.23 so 2.3 1.3 24 1.8 (e) L4 SE 6.45 6.62 6.20 5.50 0.56 0.82 0.71 so 4.5 2.7 1.6 3.0 (f) L5 32 10.19 10 37 7.00 852 0.34 0.76 0.80 so 4.7 74 4.6 55 (3) R1 SE 10 84 11.41 10.02 8.48 0.26 0.77 0.53 so 41 4.4 2. 5.3 00 R2 i 9.92 9.42 7.66 9.25 0.37 0.69 0.44 so 2.5 4.0 2.0 4.6 (1) R3 2 7.92 7.66 6.53 7.28 0.48 0.80 0.67 so 2.6 1.7 2.8 2.3 PW = Pre-work; Ll-L5 = Level l-5 of work. R1-R3 = Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery S = Supplement; D = Diet; I = Interaction 43 TABLE 4-2.--Changes in Lactate (mMoL/L) and Statistical Results. Comiujcns ANOWA Naml) Nafll) Plamflx> Plamflx> + + + + S D I CHO ZFat-Pro CHO Fat-Pro P P P AP-L5 LactateP 1.07 1.04 1.04 1.24 LactateL5 10.19 10.97 7.00 8.52 ALactatePL5 9.12 9.33 5.96 7.28 0.32 0.74 0.83 AP-R1 LactateP 1.07 1.04 1.04 1.24 LactateR1 10.84 11.41 10.02 8.48 ALactatePR1 9.77 10.37 8.98 7.24 0.16 0.93 0.64 AP-R3 LactateP 1.07 1.04 1.04 1.24 LactateR3 7.92 7.66 6.53 7.28 ALactatePR3 6.85 6.62 5.49 6.04 0.66 0.97 0.99 AL5-Rl LactateL5 10.19 10.37 7.00 8.52 LactateRl 10.84 11.41 10.02 8.48 A'LactateL5Rl .65 1.04 3.02 .04 0.80 0.76 0.12 AL5-R3 LactateL5 10.19 10.37 7.00 8.52 Lactate R3 7.92 7.66 6.53 7.28 ALactateLSRB 2.27 2.71 .47 1.24 <0.09* 0.55 0.46 PW = Pre-work; Ll-LS = Level 1-5 of work. R1 - R3 = Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery S = Supplement; = Diet; I = Interaction 44 OM Effect By Smolemenl I50 I I i W) :1 IO t 8 I O 5 H SC 7 a o----o see 6 7 O 6 I I I I IHHI—II I I I I O O 5 IO l5 PW O 3 O 9 I2 l5 5 IO l5 L. L. L3 L. L. RECOVERY m “COVE!" TIME (mm) Tl“ (mm) (o) §QDIUM QICMATE (b) m '50 Supplement Effect By One: I' I I ‘_ 12.5 - I I g IO 0 q‘ .. ‘\ on»: SPEED w 7 5 ‘x. m M) y‘— ‘0 9 IO 5 5 o o 9 3 0—0 SC 7 O 2 5 o----o PC 6 1 5 6 00 I 1 I O O 5 IO l5 RECOVERY WORK RECOVERY TIME (mun) THE lam.) (c) CARQQHYDRATE . (d) FAT-PROTEIN Pooled ROSUIIS I50 I- I I .. 12.5 » I I = I i I0.0 - 5 k--.“ «no: 98650 a 75 b ‘\\V m m, a O IO 25 I. I 0"-'° P . 7 l O O 0'0 b w o sHsHeHi T: 6 Y ' o o I I I0 l5 L. L. L, L. L. WORK RECOVERY T“ (min) TIK Iain.) (C) SUPPLEMENT If) DIET Figure 4-l.--Lactic Acid Results. 45 lactic acid curves for the supplement data (Fig. 4-1 c, d, e), it is evident that the curves appear different. No statistically significance can be expressed from these graphs. From the (ALS—R3), it can be concluded that there is a significantly greater rate of lactate reduction under sodium bicarbonate (Figure 4-1 e). pH Results The pH results are shown in Table 4-3, 4-4, Appendix C and Figure 4-2 a-f. The ANOVA results demonstrated significant supplement effects in the pre- run measure (P = 0.09) Table 4-3, and in the difference between the measure taken at the end of exercise and five minute of recovery (ALS - R3, P = .03) Table 4-4. There were no other statistically significant differences. However, it should be noted that all the pH values were higher under the bicarbonate supplementation than the placebo condition (see Figure 4-3 c, d, and e). In the Sign test results a significant effect of bicarbonate upon pH (P<.l) was demonstrated under both dietary conditions. The mean pH values were higher when bicarbonate was ingested. It is evident from the ANOVA results and Figure 4-3 a, b, and f that diet did not significantly affect the pH values. 46 TABLE 4-3.--Statistical Results, pH. Comihjcns ANOWA NaI-ICC; Ncho; Placebo Placebo + + + + CHO Fat-Pro CHO Fat-Pro s o I varnflfles (SC) “5?) (PC) GT?) P P P (a) PW 2' 7.43 7.44 7.42 7.41 0.09* 0.90 0.19 so 0.02 0.03 0.03 0.02 (b) Ll ‘i 7.41 7.42 7.40 7.38 0.12 0.71 0.57 so 0.04 0.03 0.03 0.06 (C) I_._2_ 2' 7.42 7.41 7.40 7.39 0.15 0.55 0.93 so 0.04 0.04 0.4 0.06 (8) L3 2' 7.39 7.38 7.35 7.36 0.17 0.88 0.73 so 0.04 0.07 0.06 0.06 (e) L4 2' 7.30 7.31 7.28 7.26 0.25 0.73 0.63 so 0.07 0.09 0.08 0.09 (f) L5 8' 7.23 7.24 7.23 7.18 0.28 0.48 0.30 so 0.07 0.07 0.05 0.07 (9) R1 2' 7 19 7.21 7.18 7.20 0.71 0.38 0.84 so 0 06 0.05 0.09 0.09 (h) R2 2' 7.26 7 25 7.26 7.23 0.60 0.33 0.72 so 0 05 0 06 0.07 0.08 (1) R3 2 7.31 7.29 7.29 7.26 0.37 0.39 0.75 so 0.05 0.07 0.07 0.11 PW = Predwork; Ll-LS = Level 1-5 of wotk. Rl - R3 = Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery. * = Statistical Significance S = Supplement; D = Diet; I = Interaction 47 TABLE 4-4.--Changes in pH and Statistical Results. Oaxutnxs NMNA NdiXb lkmCD3 Plamxx> kaebo + + + + s o I CHO Fabfmo CEO Fabikc P P P AP-LS pHP 7.43 7.44 7.42 7.41 pHLS 7.23 7.24 7.23 7.18 ApHPL5 0.20 0.20 0.19 0.23 0.44 0.55 0.39 AP-Rl pHP 7.43 7.44 7.42 7.41 pHRl 7.19 7.22 7.18 7.20 ApHPR1 0.24 0.22 0.24 0.21 0.91 0.30 0.87 AP-R3 pHP 7.43 7.44 7.42 7.41 pHR3 7.31 7.30 7.30 7.26 APHPRB 0.12 0.14 0.12 0.15 0.58 0.29 0.94 AL5-R1 pHL5 7.23 7.24 7.23 7.18 pHRl 7.19 7.22 7.18 7.20 * ApHLSRl 0.04 0.02 0.05 0.02 <0.03 0.31 0.96 AL5-R3 pHS 7.23 7.24 7.23 7.18 thB 7.31 7.30 7.30 7.26 APHLSRB 7.08 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.77 0.81 0.95 PW = Pre-work; Ll-L5 = Level 1-5 of work. R1 - R3 = Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery. * = Statistical Significance S = Supplement; D = Diet; I = Interaction 48 "5 Out Effect By W | no 0—0 9c I H n cum-o are I o-o-o FFP 7.35 I I 7.30 I nuns 'EEO 7.26 l a.) m O IO 7.20 O O 1 O 7.I5 O 7 5 O I T I 1 1 T o o 5 IO I5 5 I0 I! RECOVERY REOOVERY TI“ (mm) In) W "5 _ Supplement Effect 8y Diet 7.00 H SC o---o PC 7.35 7.30 7.25 9 O 7.20 O 9 7 O 7.I5 O 7 I Z 5 5 I I I W H H H IgTIL I I I O O 5 IO l5 PW O 3 O 9 I2 I5 5 IO I5 Ll L8 Ll LO LO RECOVERY IORK RECOVERY TIME (mm) T“ (mm) (c) wow: «n W 7.45 I It I 140 I o———o c I o---o PP 7.35 I I 7.30 l 7.25 I 7.20 [—— . I—-II--II—-II—-IF1 T PW O 3 O 9 l2 l5 5 IO I5 LI L: L: L. L. m I I l I RMVERY TIME (mm) TIME (min) (I) WEWNT (f) DIET Figure 4-2.--pH Results. 48 no P Diet Effect By W 7.0 P H PC o---o ere 7.35 - 7.30 I- .“ ”EEO 7‘3 ,_ N ”HI 0 IO 7.20 - O 9 7 O 7. I 5f- . 7 f 5 O L 1 O O 5 IO I5 m RECOVERY RECOVERY TIIE (mm) ‘0) W ,1 .5 _ aplement Effect By Diet 7.40 - o—-o SC 0—0 9? o---o Pc o---o PEP 7.35 '- 130 .- NADE ’EED 7.25 I' “I m 9 IO 7.20 . I O 9 . 7 O 7J5 - O 7 IL I . . T I—. l I I— ' 5 6 " “fi_f‘_'I H H H I I I fi I fi—I—I H H H I IL 1 I I O 0 PW O 3 6 l2 I5 5 IO I5 PW O 3 O 9 I2 l5 5 IO I5 L. L. L. L. L. L. L; L. L. L. WORK RECOVERY 'ORK RECOVERY TIME (mm) Tl“ (mm) M 9" ME Iflflfliflflflu 7.45 v- I I 7.40 - I e——-o s e——e c o---o P o---o FP 7.35 - TJO '- D GRADE SPEED 7.25 b “) ”HI 9 IO 7.20 - C O O ; I 7 0 us > r— . 6 7 J- I ‘ s 6 Itz—Ffil—‘r‘lfi I ' ' ' . r ° ° L. L, L. L. L. IO I5 5 IO I5 NORK RECOVERY m RECOVERY TIME (mun) TIIE (min) (0) SLPPLEMENT (f) DIET Figure 4-2.--pH Results. 49 Base Excess (BE) Results The base excess results are presented in Figure 4-3 a-f, Tables 4-5, 4-6, and Appendix D. The change in base excess was statistically significant between the prerun and the five-minute postrun (AL5-Rl, P==0.0l, Table 4-6). The base excess was consistently lower during exer- cise under the carbohydrate condition, CFig. a,kn.f). These differences, using the Sign test, are significantly differ- ent (P==.09). On the basis of these data, it can be con- cluded that the base excess values were lower under the carbohydrate dietary condition. The base excess values were significantly higher under the bicarbonate condition (Sign test P==.02) throughout the multi-state treadmill run and during 10 and 15 minutes of recovery (Fig. 4-3 e). PC02 Results The PC02 data are present in Table 4-7, 4-8, Appendix E, and Figure 4-4 a-f. A statistically'significant dietary effect was evident in level 2 (P==0.02) and level 3 (P==.009, Table 4-7). None of the changes in PC02 analyzed were statistically significant (Table 4-8). Utilizing the Sign test, the PC02 is significantly lower under the carbohydrate condition than when the fat protein diet was consumed (Fig. 4-4a, P<.O9; Fig. 4-4b, P<.Ol; Fig. 4-4f, P<.02). With supplementation of bicar- bonate the PC02 is significantly lower under both dietary 50 TABLE 4-5.--Statistical Results, Base Excess (mEq/L). Caxfitnxm .NKNR Naxxg nonoi; Phxmbo Pflaxxn + + + + CHO Fat-Pro c140 Fat—Pro s o I vanhflfles (SC) “flfifl (PC) GT?) P P P (a) PW x +1.60 +2.18 +1.46 +0.72 0.49 0.92 0.56 so 3.8 2.6 3.6 2.0 (b) L1 x -2.24 -o.79 -2.68 -2.31 0.50 0.54 0.72 so 3.6 2.1 5.2 4.8 (0) L2 SE -2.20 —o.34 -3.74 -1.37 0.41 0.18 0.87 so 3.8 3.2 5.7 3.7 (d) L3 32 -5.15 -4.09 —6.44 -3.82 0.78 0.32 0.68 so 4.4 4.1 5.6 6.2 (e) L4 3? -10.9 -9.59 -11.25 -11.14 0.64 0.73 0.77 so 4.3 7.8 5.3 6.8 (f) L5 2 -14.63 —13.70 -14.58 -16.3 0.44 0.77 0.40 so 3.4 3.5 3.0 4.8 (9) R1 x —17.41 —16.30 —17.10 -16.17 0.89 0.50 0.96 so 3.4 2.3 5.0 5.7 (h) 122 x -13.61 -14.52 -13.49 -14.91 0.91 0.32 0.82 so 2.5 2.4 3.0 4.5 (i) R3 x -11.69 -12.16 -12.42 -13.23 0.61 0.72 0.92 so 3.3 5.6 3.1 6.5 PW Pre-work; Ll-L5 = Level 1-5 work; R1 R3 = Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery Supplement; D = Diet; I = Interaction TABLE 4-6.--Change in BE mEq/L and 51 Statistical Results. Comifijons ANOWA NaHCO3 NaHCO3 Placebo Placebo + + + + s D I CHO Fat—Pro CHO Fat-Pro P P P AP - L5 BEP +Ol.6 +02.18 +Ol.46 +00.7O BE5 —14.63 -13.70 -l4.58 -16.30 ABEP5 —13.07 -ll.50 —13.12 —lS.58 0.81 0.81 0.65 AP - Rl BEP +01.6O +02.18 +Ol.46 +00.70 BERl —l7.4l -l6.30 -l7.10 -l6.l7 ABEPR1 ~15.80 -14.10 -lS.60 -15.45 0.40 0.29 0.82 AP - R3 BEP +01.60 +02.18 +01.46 +00.7O BER3 -ll.69 -12.16 -12.42 -13.23 BEPR3 —10.10 -09.96 ~10.93 ~12.51 9.77 0.68 0.87 ALS - Rl BE5 -l4.63 -l3.70 -l4.58 -16.30 BERl -l7.4l -16.30 —l7.lO -16.l7 ABESRl - 2.78 - 2.60 - 2.50 -00.13 <0.01* 0.51 0.74 ALS - R3 3E5 -l4.63 -13.70 -l4.53 -16.30 HERB -11.69 -12.16 -12.42 -l3.23 ABE5R3 - 2.93 - 1.54 - 2.17 - 3.07 0.54 0.77 0.94 PW Pre-work; Ll-LS = Level 1-5 of work R3 * II II I II = Diet; I: Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery Statistical Significance Supplement; Interaction IE. IIIEQIII 94E (mEq/II 30 0.0 -50 O E. Ilia/II -I0.0 ~I5O 3.0 r- 0.0 *- -|DO> - ISO HE‘I 30 00 -5.0 - I0.0 ~I5.0 52 Diet Effect 83; Supplement o—o ac H 'C o---o are o-—o FFP eeeoc 'EED flu) DH) 0 ID ’I' . . 7 O D 7 5 C I I I I I 0 O 6 ID t5 5 ID ID RECOVERY RECOVERY (a) t l AT Supplement Effect By Diet H 3C o——o sl-‘P woo-o Pc o-«o PFP “ADE ’EED Ho) ”PHI 9 ID ”A e e [— 7 l [—— I 6 7 l 5 6 -fi——£;Pfihflkfit . t . t a . ° ° PW O 3 6 9 l2 l5 5 ID l5 5 IO I5 L. Le L: La Le UDRK RECOVERY RECOVERY T“ (mm) (c) 2MYDRAT§ Pooled Results o—o s e-—o c o---o P o----o FP [— l . . 1 . FZP—H—fihfi: I 5 IO I5 P. L. L. O L. O L. I! “I5 5 IO IS ”VERY m “NVERY m ('60.) 7‘ Iain.) mswnrmmt mgfifl Figure 4-3.--Base Excess Result. 53 conditions and these changes became obvious when the data were pooled (Fig. 4-4c, P < .01; Fig. 4-4d, P < .01; Fig. 4-4e, P < .01). From these data it can be concluded that the PC02 values are lower when a high carbohydrate diet is consumed as compared to a high fat-protein diet and when bicarbonate supplement is given pre-run. Performance Results A two-way analysis of variance was applied to determine if performance time were affected by dietary and supplementary treatment. All subjects were not able to complete the work which were performed at six levels. Seven of them were exhausted during level five. Only SF who was accomplished level five and ran at level six for 90 seconds under SC condition; 123 seconds under SFP condition; 97 seconds under PC condition; and 67 seconds under PFP condition, Table 4-9. There were no signifi- cant differences in mean performance time between the supplementary and dietary treatments. The shortest mean performance time was made when subjects consumed the PC (Placebo + Carbohydrate) (Table 4-9 and Figure 4-5). The longest mean performance time was achieved when subject consumed NaHCO3 + CHO (Table 4-9, Fig. 4-5). In the pooled data greatest mean performance time was obtained under supplementary conditions but there were no significant differences in performance time between dietary and supplementary conditions. 54 TABLE 4-7.--Statistical Results, PCO2 (mmHg). Omtfitfixs .NKNR Ncho'3' Ncho; Placebo Placebo + + + + CHO Fat-Pro CHO Fat-Pro S D I Variables (SC) (SFP) (PC) (PFP) P P P (a) PW SE 37 52 39.11 39 49 39.88 0.46 0.61 0.75 so 6 3 5.7 5 0 2.8 (b) Ll SE 34 52 35.94 36 87 37.06 0.32 0.65 0.72 so 2 5 5.1 5 6 5.6 (c) L2 2 31 13 36.33 34 07 37.57 0.26 0.02* 0.65 so 4 9 4.0 6 3 4.8 (d) L3 R 31 26 33.46 32 35 36.61 0.26 0.99* 0.58 so 5 4 4.6 5 o 5.9 (e) L4 34' 29 72 29.95 30 11 32.07 0.37 0.42 0.76 so 4 8 7.0 2 8 4.8 (f) L5 Y 27 91 29.50 29.22 30.17 0.63 0.55 0.88 so 5 5 4.3 4.6 5.7 (9;) R1 i 26 25 26.00 27.00 27.07 0.54 0.95 0.91 so 2 8 1.7 5 4 5.1 (h) R2 i 26 32 26.12 26.82 27.31 0.49 0.91 0.77 so 2 9 2.9 4 5 2.5 (1) R3 2 26.33 27.37 26.86 27.90 0.74 0.52 0.99 so 4.9 5.2 4.4 3.2 PW R1 Pre-work; Ll-LS = Level 1-5 of work. R3 = Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery. Statistical Significance Supplement; D = Diet; I = Interaction 55 TABLE 4—8.--Changes in PCO (mmHg) and Statistical Results. mefithm .NKNA NfiKDB main Phxeho kaeho + + + + s o I CHO Fat-Pro CHO Fat—Pro P P P AP - L5 PCO2P 37.52 39.11 39.49 39.88 PCO2L5 27.91 29.50 29.22 30.17 APOO2PL5 09.69 09.61 10.28 09.71 0.51 0.75 0.65 AP-R1 PCO2P 37.60 39.11 39.50 39.90 PCO2R1 26.25 26.00 27.00 27.07 APCOlPRl 11.35 13.11 12.50 12.33 0.84 0.73 0.68 AP - R3 POO2P 37.60 39.11 39.50 39.90 PCO2R3 26.33 27.37 26.86 27.90 APCOZPR3 11.27 11.74 12.74 12.00 0.85 0.80 0.48 AL5-Rl PCO2L5 27.91 29.50 29.22 30.20 POO2R1 26.25 26.00 27.00 27.07 APOO2L5Rl 01.66 03.50 02.22 03.13 0.77 0.50 0.89 AL5-R3 POO2L5 27.91 29.50 29.22 30.20 POO2R3 26.33 27.37 26.86 27.90 APCOZLSRB 01.58 02.13 02.36 02.30 0.62 0.99 0.69 PW = Pre-work; Ll-LS = Level 1-5 of work R1 - R3 Five, ten and fifteen minutes of recovery S = Supplement; D = Diet; I = Interaction 56 «1w (f) DIET Figure 4-4.--PCO Results. 2 ‘0 0 Diet Effect By Wt Q I \‘ ' o—o PC 2 ' .... m i 35.0 >- I I 8 l ° mo: stucco so 0 P ' on am 9 ID I -- i ,A . ’ I 7 O 25.0 v- r— C 7 J» f—' : ' I O . I—F—I—II—II—IHFII‘I f I I I IHI—II—‘II i I I # O 0 PI 0 3 6 9 I2 I5 5 IO I5 N O 3 C 9 I2 I5 5 IO IO LI L: L: La Le Lu Le Lo Lo Le WORK RECOVERY 'ORK RECOVERY TIK (mm) TI“ (Inn) (0) §QQIUM QICAMATE (b) M supplement Effect By Duet 40 O P .. 0—0 3C e—-e 3» f o-«o PC 0----o PFP E 35 O P .5. 6‘ :8 «no: 95:0 300 I- (7.) W) D ID r— °__- ___° 0,--.ov" O 9 r— l 7 e 25 o l- ,—-— l I e 7 :f- r— l i 5 C _I'—+'_I I—I I'—'I H IL T I I I I 7 H fl I I O 0 PI! 0 3 6 9 I? I5 5 I0 I5 PW D 3 B 0 l2 l5 5 IO I5 Lt L. L. L. L. LI LI LI LO LO VORK RECOVERY m RECOVERY TIK (min) TIIE (mm) (c) CARBOHYDRATE Id) FAT-PRQTEIN Pooled Results 40.0 .— Q ' —— g I H 5 0—0 C f I o----o P o---o PP E 35 0 ~ I ‘1, l 8 l o GRADE SFEED 30.0 .- fl.) M) 9 IO ['— 3 o---o—-- . to"° 9! : ['— I LL 1 6 e —"_£_-_I H H H IF I I I I I I I O O N O 3 6 9 I2 I5 IO I5 5 ID ID L. L. L. L. L. WORK RECOVERY RECOVERY TIME (min) 57 TABLE 4-9.-~Basic Data Performance Time (Sec) and Statistical Results. Comiufioms INKNR NaHCO3 NaHCO3 Placebo Placebo + + + + CHO Fat-Pro CHO Fat-Pro S D I Subjects (SC) (SFP) (13¢) (pr) P p p SF 0990 1023 0997 0967 BM 0616 0640 0639 0627 DS 0856 0858 0825 0767 BR 0814 0816 0792 0810 DA 0840 0799 0810 0805 GD 0780 0800 0787 0769 BK 0830 0788 0780 0831 GS 0764 0656 0660 0750 '2 811.25 797.50 786.25 790.75 so 104.0 119.0 110.0 95.0 0.68 0.90 0.81 .muHsmwm mocmEHOMHmmII.mlv musmflm 58 hzmSmJaQDm ._.w .0 mzo_ 50200 n. m a... o mun. on aim om J1" A. 4...“ H ._. H H ._. ._. ._. ._. w. 5.. u 4. .. .. a .1- .. 4.. 4 .1 .1 g .1 1 mm» 1 09. 1... II J] J! J] Jl 1 mt. Fl rllL11|L .I. 1 000 LI ruL Ikl I?! Ir: || 1 mmm L mhw ('993) EN”. BONVWHOdH 3d 59 Discussion In general, the rate of lactate production is dependent on the intensity, duration, and type of work. In the present study the blood lactic acid values recorded at the finish of each level of a multi—stage treadmill run show a close relationship between the lac- tic acid accumulation and the different levels of the run (Table 4-1, 4-2 and Figure 4-1 a-f). As expected, the highest lactate values were obtained with sodium bicarbonate supplementation (Figure 4-1 a, c, d, e), but the differences even at L5 were not statistically signifi- cant. The experiment of Dill, Edwards and Talbot (41) on endurance runners showed that consumption of sodium bicarbonate resulted in an increase in lactic acid of 40%. The present data do not support this position. Margaria (93) also reported that the concentration of lactic acid was enhanced after alkalization. In the present study an increase of only 16.8% of lactic acid was found after alkalization. Under the supplement conditions, the greatest difference in lactic acid concen- tration was found between level five and fifteen minutes during recovery (ALS - R3) (P = 0.09, Table 4-2). None of the other differences analyzed by ANOVA or Sign Test were significantly different. 60 It has been reported that the level of arterial blood lactate during exercise is apparently dependent on diet.(130). This level was lower under the high fat diet condition (65,107). However, the results of this investigation did not show any significant differences in arterial blood lactate levels between the high CH0 and the high fat-protein dietary conditions. Since a rest period of three minutes was necessary between work levels to obtain blood samples some of the lactic acid produced might have been metabolized by skeletal muscles, kidney, heart, liver, and other tissues (54,67). The consumption of sodium bicarbonate in adequate quantities has been shown to enhance the alkaline reserve of blood (15,21,22) and to increase the capacity of the blood for buffering acid metabolites (42). The blood buffering capacity is considered to be directly associated with the ability to continue muscular work. The pH of the blood is associated with the intensity and duration of exercise, the physical conditioning of the subject and the termperature of the environment (20). In the present study the two-way ANOVA results show significant supple- ment effects in the pre-work measures (P = .09). Signifi- cant differences were also observed between the end of exercise and first level of recovery (A5 - RI, P = .03). 61 In this study the pH of the blood was not signifi- cantly altered by diet but it was significantly increased under both dietary conditions (Figure 4-2, c and d). In the meantime, the pH of the blood was not significantly changed on a carbohydrate or fat-protein diet (59). It must be noted that the pH values probably did not stand below 7.00 for any long period. The buffer system of the body starts to react immediately to the acidotic condition. It is important ot point out that this experiment involved highly trained subjects who were capable of withstanding stressful conditions. During exercise the lower levels of base excess occurred under the carbohydrate dietary condition (Figure 4—3 a, b, and f) and higher levels were observed under the bicarbonate condition (Figure 423, c, d, and e). Only the difference in base excess related to the supple— ment condition was statistically significant between level five and the first level of recovery (ALS - Rl, p < .01, Table 4~6). The rationale is not clear for a reduced base excess under the carbohydrates condition. The PCO2 of the blood is a variable which can change much faster than the other acid-base variables. Statistically significant dietary effects were observed at level 2 (p = .02) and level 3 (P = .009). This study shows that the PC02 fell as a result of exercise (24,49) 62 and PCO2 values on a fat-protein based diet were higher than on the CH0 dietary conditions. The results of this study do not agree with the findings of Hasselbalch (59) I Hasselbahfln et al. (60), Moller (97) and Siggard-Anderson (ll7b these investigators found that under a vegetable- based diet the PC02 balues were 2-3 mmHg higher than the PC02 values observed when on a meat-based diet. The findings of this experiment indicated that pre-exercise alkalization did not significantly effect performance times. This is in conflict with the results reported by Dennig (40), Hewitt and Callaway (69), Jones, et al. (79), Simmons (122), and Sutton, Jones and Toews (124) who found'dum.pre-exercise alkalization increased physical work capacity. However, their exercise durations were different than the durations used in this study and the fitness levels of the subjects were not comparable. The only work conducted with trained athletes (cross- country runners) and which is comparable to the present study was that of Johnson and Black (77). They found that there was no significant improvement in the athlete's performances. In the experiment, however, they failed to follow the ingestion protocol utilized by Dennig (l or 2 days before endurance events). However, Karpovich and Sinning (82) claimed that Dennig's formula had no significant effect on performance of college 63 swimmers. Margaria et al. (92) also reported that pre- exercise alkalization had no significant effect upon performance during supermaximal exercise. Also, Dawson (37) showed that endurance was reduced by pre-exercise alkalosis because anjxmueasing'difficulty in breathing was attributed to the exhaustion of the runner. In the present study statistical analysis of the data revealed that the performance capacity was not affected by either the dietary or the supplement condi— tions. It is appropriate at this time to examine the three research hypotheses: l. Pre-exercise sodium bicarbonate supplementa- tion produces increased metabolic alkalosis and improves exercise performance capacity. The alkalosis was increased by the supplement as indicated by the higher pH and BE values under this supplement condition but the performance was not increased. The initial part of the hypothesis therefore, may be accepted. The latter portion may not be accepted. 2. A high carbohydrate diet, as compared to a high fat-protein diet produces increased metabolic alkalo- sis and improved exercise performance capacity. The alkalosis was somewhat less, not higher, under the carbohydrate condition as increased by the similar pH 64 values and the lower BE values. This hypothesis may not be accepted. 3. The metabolic and performance effects of a high carbohydrate diet and sodium bicarbonate supplemen- tation are synergistic. In this type of athlete using the test protocol of the present study this hypothesis cannot be accepted. CHAPTER V SUMMARY, CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATIONS Summary The primary purpose of this study was to deter- mine the effects of sodium bicarbonate ingestion (0.06 grams/kg body wieght), under either high carbohydrate or high fat-protein dietary conditions, upon acid-base balance and work performance. Eight healthy-male-marathon runners (average age 30 years) from the Central Michigan area volunteered to act as subjects under four dietary conditions (supple- ment carbohydrate, supplement fat-protein, placebo carbohydrate, placebo fat-protein). Sodium bicarbonate and placebo were administered blindly in gelatin capsules, .06 and .05 grams per kilogram of body weight, respec- tively. The subjects were assigned numbers randomly to the treatment condition and then were rotated to the other treatment condition each week. The subjects performed the exercise on the motor driven treadmill at a different speed and different inclination four times under four treatment conditions. An arterialized capillary blood was sampled, before and during each level of exercise 65 66 and 5th, 10th and 15th minutes of recovery. The blood was analyzed for pH, BE, PC02 and lactate using the astrupt method. The results of the present study indicated that the change in lactic acid, pH and BE concentrations observed under the supplement condition (lactic acid ALS - R3, pH and BE ALS - Rl) were statistically signifi- cant. The pH was significantly higher under the supple- ment condition. The PCO2 values were significantly lower under the supplement and carbohydrate conditions. Conclusion Based on the data obtained within the limitations involved in this study, the following conclusions appear to be justified. l. Alkalosis was increased by bicarbonate supplementation. 2. Performance times were not affected by either diet or supplement conditions. 3. The shift in alkalosis observed was unrelated to work performance. Recommendations Based on the findings and the experiences encountered in conducting this study, the following recommendations for further study are made: 67 1. It is recommended that this research be duplicated using a larger sample for increasing the accuracy of the statistical treatment of data. 2. A tighter control must be kept on the food intake (amount and type) of the runners at least 3 days before the test. 3. An additional study should compare long distance runners with short distance runners. APPENDICES 68 APPENDIX A DIETARY RECALL 69 70 TABLE A-l.--High Carbohydrate Diet. DIET: HIGH CARBOHYDRATE Foods that can be consumed in any amounts: Fruit (except cranberries, plums, prunes) Vegetables (except corn and lentils) Bread Cereal Potatoes, Rice, Macaroni Margarine Sugar Skim Milk (no more than 3 servings of whole milk) Cottage Cheese Lettuce Pancakes No more than one serving of any combination of the following can be consumed each day: Meat Egg Fish Nuts (including peanut butter) Corn, Lentils Cranberries, Plums, Prunes Cakes and Cookies, plain Butter AN EFFORT MUST BE MADE TO KEEP YOUR TOTAL CALORIC INTAKE RELATIVELY CONSTANT. A BODY WEIGHT LOSS OR GAIN DURING THE CONTROLLED DIET PERIOD COULD EFFECT THE EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS. 71 TABLE A-2.--High Fat x Protein Diet. DIET: HIGH FAT X PROTEIN Foods that can be consumed in any amounts: Meat Fish Fowl Eggs Nuts Peanut Butter Bacon Butter Corn Lentils Cranberries Lettuce Margarine AT LEAST 3 SERVINGS OF ANY COMBINATION OF MEAT, FISH, AND FOWL MUST BE CONSUMED EACH DAY. No more than three servings of any combination of the following can be consumed each day: Fruit Vegetables Bread Cereal Potatoes, Rice, Macaroni Margarine Sugar Milk Cakes and Cookies, plain Pancakes AN EFFORT MUST BE MADE TO KEEP YOUR TOTAL CALORIC INTAKE RELATIVELY CONSTANT. A BODY WEIGHT LOSS OR GAIN DURING THE CONTROLLED DIET PERIOD COULD EFFECT THE EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS. 72 .cu34aoa use .au_:ooc .au.» can-a .‘:0uwoul ._uuocaaan nova—uc~c a on. acuuuvox Coon 30.: .uasom amuuou .coh soda: .ucumo0u .uuoaouoso .0qvc:o.e:.ao .uuuan .zq_um .laq .zvcau .luouu au— ao; «vow .uuu .uusszuaou .nosaucaa .uvoon woman annoys vascuucu as. .uisuuu :«auu muss: nouaauuno> can ouqsuu nosuo tog-1| .osusu "coca-Dom nounuuouus Jenna» .soouu a.qua onus». manage we. urea-lab u0¢u34lI= .0u0 .guuu .uGOI uqo .uouusa “ac-on .uouuaa .ucuuqnu-I .ocnon vogue sium 0.00:0 Jan! m m L h 3 h : 0.12 o..«uoam .o>< ~Iu0h wuw flu a win .u>< ~aaoh as: you aucu>hom no Cools: Anuuocun adv noon ..: .uz new ou< lellxllru-a homfigm 12:29: z< so mxS—hu ask “—0 Eng.“ hvaum .uuqaam .uomnnsm HMDUH>H©CH am no mxmucH boom mo humEESmII.mu< mqm<9 APPENDIX B BASIC DATA LACTATE (mMOl/L) 73 '744 A u... 98 6 832.. «6.5 6.393-666 6 336.6 66.6 66.6 .6.6 66.6 66.6 .... .6.6 6..6 .6.6 . 66.6 66.. 6..6 66.6 66.. .6.6 6..6 .6.6 .6.6 66 66.. 66.6 66.6 66.6 66.6 6..6 66.. .6.. 66.. M 66.6 66.. 66.6. 66.. 66.6 6..6 66.6 .6.. 66.. 6 -- -. -- -- : -- .- -- .. w 6.1. 6.1.6 66...: I...| fl 6646. 6...... .l6..6 Inn 66 66... .6.6. .6.6. 66.6. .6.. 66.6 66.. 66.. 66.6 M 66.6 66.6 66.6 -- 66.. 6..6 66.6 6... 6..6 66 66.6 6..6. 66.6 6..6. 66.6 66.6 66.6 6... 6... M 66.. 66... 6..6 .6.6 .6.. 66.6 66.6 66.. 66.6 66 6..6 66.6 66.6 .6.6 66.6 66.6 66.6 66.. 66.. m 66.6 .6.6 66.6 66.6 66.6 .6.6 .6.. 6... .6.. 66 66.6. ..... 66.6. .. 6. .6.6 66.6 66.6 66.6 6... 6 .- -- -- -- -- .- -- -- -- 66 -- -- -- -. -- -- -. -- -- m 66.6 66.6 ...6. 6..6 .6.. 66.6 66.6 66.6 6... 66 66.6 66... 66.6. -- 66.6 66.6 .6.6 66.6 66.. . .6.6 66.. 66.6 -- 66.6 66.6 66.6 ...6 66.. :6 66.6 .6.6 66.6 6..6 6..6 6..6 6..6 ...6 66.6 m -- .6.. 66... 6..6. 66.6 6... 6... .6.6 66.6 .6 W . .6.. 66.6 66.6 66.. ..6 66.. 66.6 66.6 .6.6 m 66.6 66.6 66.6 ...6 66.6 66.6 .6.. 66.6 66.6 66 66.. 66.6 .6... .6.6. 66.6 66.6 .... .6.. 66.. 6. 66.. 66.6 66.6. 6..6. 66.6 8.6 66.. 66.6 .6.. m 66.6 66.6 66.. -- 66.. .6.6 66.. 66.6 .6.6 6.61.16 3 661m 3 66.4.6.6 Ham fl M61. 3 66 66.6 66.6 66.6. 6. .6. 66.6 .6.6 .6.. .... 66.6 w : ...6. 6.... 66.6 66.6 66.6 .6.. 66.6 66.6 6.6 6..6 66.6 ..... 8.6 66.6 66.6 6..6 66.. 66.6 .H 66.6. 66.6. 6..6. 6..6. 66.6. 66.6 .6.6 66.6 66.. ...6 : -- -- -- : -- -- -- -- _ 66.6 66.6 .6.6 66.6 66.6 66.6 .6.6 66.6 .6.6 66 6... 66.6. 66.66 6..66 66.. 66.6 66.. 66.6 .6.6 .. 6... .6.6. 66.6. 66.6 8.6 66.. 66.. 6..6 6..6 ..6 66.6 66.6. ...6. 66.6 6..6 .6.6 66.. 66.6 66.6 W -- -- -- -- -- -- -- .- -- 66 66.6 .6.6 66.6 .- 6..6 66.6 66.6 66.. 66.. -- .- -- : -- : .- -- I 6.6 -- 66.6 66.6. 66.. 66.. 6... 6... 6. .. 6..6 . : .6.. .6.6 8.. 66.6 6..6 .6.6 66.6 66.6 .6 .6.6. 6.3.66.6-,..6...-. 68...... ._ «Hanoi; - -.I-tl--ri-) --II-|III.,-I It)! 1 1-22»)- -2 I! .. 6 )I)- nguoz Egmoma Cairo: I”: .6”... 76“.. a In: 2...: 6M...“ ngccu Cgmgz Cot—68¢ 3m: .0": .0”: Em: 3...: an” 3833.. I 6 6 b. «I. u u... .6..... . .. - ..6-.DD-Oa6o>1-vfi rV.-. ‘01.solhhot..l - o’.|.|b.lt RI. . OIIEODCIOIUCI0":.A:FR:..:‘6....I..I..l..II6Ilcpla - ...\.6ze. 666666. 6666 6.666--..-6 6.66 APPENDIX C BASIC DATA, pH 75 76 --I-‘II.I" I . .I I ‘ll '.'-‘l'0l.l.nl. .: [I‘l‘l'lill I'll ...9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 99.9 99.9 99.9 9... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.9 99.9 9... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 m 6...... ...6... 66.... 66..... 6...... ...6... .66.... 6.4.. 9.... . 6.6.... 664.. 6.3. 1...! 99.... ml. 66..... 664.. 6......1 ...6 99.9 9_.9 -- 9... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 . 96.9 9_.9 9_.9 9..9 9... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 29 99.9 99.9 99.9 9... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 _ 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 _ 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 (9 9... 99.. 9... .9.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.. 99.9 _ 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99 -- 99.. 99.9 9... 99.. .9.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 99.9 99.9 99.9 -- 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 _ 99.9 .9.9 99.9 .. 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 :9 99.9 .9.. 99.9 99.. 99.. 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 9.3.6.669... .436... 6 6... ...6 . 3...... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.. .9.9 99.9 .9.9 99.. 99.9 _ .9.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 69.9 99.9 m .6..... 6.6.... ...6... -.u. 66..-.. .66.... 66.... 6...... 6...... w .66.... 6.64... 8.... 9...... 9...... 61...... .13.. 66...... .69.... 66 99.. 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.9 _ 99.9 99.9 9_.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 :9 99.9 99.. 9... 99.9 99.9 99.. 99.9 99.. -- _ 99.. 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 .9.9 99.9 99 99.9 99.9 99.. 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.. 99.9 99.9 9... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 99.9 .9.9 99.9 -- 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 99.9 .9.9 9... .9.9 99.9 .9.9 .9.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 9... 9... 99.9 -- 9... 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.. -- 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 :9 99.. 99.. 99.. 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 69.9 99.9 99.. 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99.9 99 :66 6.66663... . 66...... 996.961.;696 9Lo>woou 9.96Moox 6.66woou .omob .oneb .umob .omob .ohub gum” ato>w669 9.66Mooz >Lo>wooz .omoa .owod .omob 99mm; _o”oa gum” 69909999 9:59... .96OODI‘. Y...D§6IO-O.bhloflsOOVAOOOO-pun-Obloo. pols-I'I-IUICU. 'DPI-OI-rinsRIln . ' 6 . .6 coiIOprnivabs POIIPDIP‘DPEoII'D‘EgREEORORIRRRCOEIIIIIOU-R.9900...... 9. . . ..r .66 .6666 6.666--..-6 6.66. APPENDIX D BASIC DATA, BASE EXCESS (mEq/L BLOOD) 77 78 99.9 99.9 6..9 99.9 99.9 69.9 6..9 99.6 99.9 9..9 99.6 99.6 99.9 .9.9 99.9 9..9 99.9 99.9 99 69.9.- .9.9.- ...9.- 6.9.. 6....- 99.9- .9..- .9.9- 9..9. 99.9.- 99.9.- ....- 99.9.- 99...- 99.0- 9..9- 99.9- 99... u .IUI MANI- .~I.m~.. ...6-- old...- ..|..- 4....” .64.!- d...” N:- 37 0.....- -- 6.9.- 9.:- 9..- n...- .... 8 9.6.- 9.9.- - 9.9.- 6.9.- 9..- ..9- 9..- 9.9. ....- 9.9.- 9..9- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9- 9.9- 9.9- 9.9- 39 9.6.- 6.9.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9- 9.9- 9.9. 9.9. 9.9.. 9.9.- 9.9.- 0.9.- 9.9.- 9.9- 9..- 9..+ ...9 99 ..9- 9.6.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9..- ..9¢ 9.6- 9..- 9.9- 6.9- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.99- 9..9 9.96 9.96 9.96 99 9.99- 9.9.- - 9.6.- 9.9- 9.9. ..9. 9.96 9.96 9.9.- 9.6.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9- 9.9.- 9...- 9.9- 99 - 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.6.- 9.9- 9.9- 9.9.- 9..- 9.6.- 9.6.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9.- 9.9- 9... 9.6+ 99 9.9- 9.9- 9.9.- - 9.9- 9.9- 9.6- 9... 9... 9.9- 9.9.- ..99- - 6.6.- 9.9- 9-9- 6.9- 9.96 :9 6.9- 9.9.- 9.9- 9..- 9.9. ..0. 9.9. 9.9- ..96 9.9.- 9...- 9.9.- 9...- 9.99 ..9+ 9.96 9.96 9.99 99 3...: 5395-99. . 339... al.99393- 99... 66.. 6.... 69.. 8.. ...6 .6.. 8.. .96 .9.9 99.6 66.9 96.. 96.6 96.6 99.6 69.9 6.9 99 9..9.- 99.6.- 96.9.- 9..9.- 99.9- 99.9- 69.9- 9..9- 9..6. 99...- .9.6.- .9.9.- 99.9.- .9.9.- 9..9- .9.9- 99-9- 90..+ u .6..-9..“ .9.9-fl -949...“ in... 9.6.... .9.9.- ...-... .3.- m...... .9.9...- 6...- ...6- 6.8- .949...” 6..- ..o- 9.6- o... 8 9.9.- ....- 9.9.. 9...- 9.6.- 9..- 6.6- 9.9- 9.9. 9.9.- ....- 9.99- 9.9.- 9.6.- 9..- 9.9- ..9- ..9- a9 9.9.- ..9.- ..9.- 9.9.- 9...- 6..- 9.9- 9..- - 9.9.- 9.0.- 9.9.- 9.0.- 9.9.- ..9- 9.9- 9..- 9.9- 99 6.99- ..6.- 9.6.. 9.9. 9.69- ..9. 9... 9.6. 9.9. 9.9- 9.9- 9.99- 9.9.- 9.6.- 9.9- 9.9- 9... ..9. 99 6.8. 0.:- ..2- -- 0.3- a..- o... 9.? 9.9. 9..- 9.6.- 6.9.- 6.6.- 3:- 6..- 9.6. a... 9.9. .3 ..9.- 9.97 9.97 9.9.- 9.9.- ..9- 9.9- 9.9- 9.: 9.97 9.9.- 99.- 9.9.- 9.0- 9.9- 9.9- ..9- 9.96 99 9..6- 9.9.- 9...- - 9..9- 9.9- 9.9- ..9- 9..- 9.6.- 9.9.- 6.9.- - 9.9.. 9.9.- 9.9- 9.9- - :9 - 9.9.- 9.9. ..9- 9.9. 9... 9.6. 6.9- ..9. 9...- 9.9.- ..9.- 9.9- 9.9- 6.96 9.9+ 9.9- 9... .9 .39.. ........8...-..... . 98:... male... . 99.2.... . 6 _ 9 c p 6 . , ...ca 9 6 _ 9 6 9 6 . ...5: 9.999999 ..e>ouoz 9.9»0999 .e>o. .~>6. .999. .o>e. .e>o. on. >go>ovoz 999,9999 aso>cuo¢ .o>o. .9599 .o>o. .999. .0909 9.9 9.906999 I...l.-..-o'..s 9'99-9 ..... no. ...u..ou. ...99... ..p.. 9.. 99.9-.969 . .- .. .-.uv 0.9.05.1... 690‘.D.IO099909.-.9.II-IDI09 99.9.9...I."D.Q-9909IIOIIIO\O 00.996 I 9 . . ..uoo.m ..ous. mmmuxu mmmm .mpma u.mmm--..-o m.m<. APPENDIX E BASIC DATA PCO2 (mmHg) 79 80 I III. I f'l'l II.§I|. ‘1": II _ ~_.m o..~ m_.m o~.m m¢.. =:.m Na.. ~o.m .¢.~ M 9... mm.. ...m om.. .w.~ ~a.m on.e om.m “9.. am co.- .n.- so.- h_.on so.~m .e.en Km.~m oo.~m ae.om m om.o~ Na.e~ c.- -.o~ ...cn .n.~m so..n “n.9n m..on m . ...M .a. to... ..n. MM 4m- ,m. ..a. la. W Q. .3» la: .u. I:: 1%: l2: 4.: 4% a .n KN -- o~ .a o. .. O. ne m m~ ¢~ m~ KN ~n km on ON an an ~p om Kw an an ~n .n Kn wn M ow o~ QN an Na Na mm ~. _. ac .m m~ .~ - - on ~. Kn an m m~ e~ o~ - an ¢n an o. a. ¢a m~ ‘ -- o~ _m an m. N. N. ~. ” ¢. _~ a. .~ ¢~ an mm on .n an __ -- ¢~ on .m am an Kn ~. u _~ on .n ma QN m~ MN an .. no on an o~ -- oN KN NM on on m K~ a. °~ -- m~ - o~ .n on an m~ on mm mm _. n. a. an ~. m ~n .n .n o~ .m Kn an an _. um 9.5 532..-... . 23.: m 333 w m _~.m ¢¢.« .~._ -.. no.9 ~o.. No.” co.m oo.m I on.. .m.~ cm.~ nm.m ~o.. ...m mo.. mm.~ o~.o on Nn.- ~..o~ oe.e~ om.o~ mo.o~ a..mn mm.on .o.mn ...on m nm.o~ Nn.o~ m~.o~ .o.- -.o~ o~._n a..." ~m..n Nm.hn w x3: :3. Iowl ,.. .1 4% am, 1.... _ ...ns ind m In”: .81 Ia. 1%: Am: 4n: 1%: IN”: .Mfl. 8 ”N .N KN - ~m on mm an _. _ - n~ v~ m~ c~ an an an mm an an «N .m m“ cw .m an o. -. m mN aw - - .~ o~ mm mm on 99 mm ”N .N am NM .. c. m. cm . .m c” mN NN .~ .~ .~ on _. «a ~n - m~ .- on m~ an an on KN m~ .~ o~ ca ~n a~ mm _. a. o~ o~ KN mm ow an an .m on m~ an RN an en mn - on ~. ma o~ Np .N -- .N .m an .n em a. mw o~ -- o~ - o~ an n~ :u -- "N c~ - _. NM .n .n an oN ow ca an ”n on an N" a. mm «a .3 .... ...39&..:..,. .. nouns... 3.54.5 . 8%... --g--- ; .e::---:::---.nu|--..-.. :% Aggro: 33mg: {tween 3mm... 3N3 Ems 3mm: 3...: an” Agngoa aggmuex fol—Up: .owoa pun».- .owod .0”; Two.- .mfi 30023.. .........z‘ul...u...............:.n..5.-:.......:........v.......‘...l...v.-n..... .F.....u.llp!.l.uluobbu.iotl!lpvvln - .-unnnll-nllll .Amzssv Noon mama u_mmm--.F-w m4m