THE CRYSTALLIIATiON OF AMORPHOUS SIUCA USING SALT CATALYSTS Thesis for the Degree of M. S. MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY Paui D. Baranyai 1954 filESI‘ LIBRARY Michigan State University ABSTRACT THE CRYSTALLIZATION OF F AmHmWSEEA USING SALT CATALYSTS by Paul D. Baranyai It is known that the three common polymorphs of silica; quartz, tridymite, and cristobalite, crystallize within a large range of temperatures at atmospheric pressure. Each polymorph is stable within a certain range of temperatures. Tridymite and cristobalite are characteristic of high temperature environments. An investigation of the various polymorphs was conducted using amorphous silica gel and various salts as catalysts to determine whether the two high temperature forms could be made to crystallize at tempera- tures below their respective thermal stability range. All work was carried out under one atmosphere of pressure at temperatures ranging - from 600°C. to 900°C. Various concentrations of each salt were used. Each sample was heated for two hours. ‘There has been much work conducted at elevated temperatures and pressures for long durations of time. However, there has been little research conducted at the temperatures used in this study. Nor has there been much work dealing with the action of various salts toward the cry— stallization of amorphous silica gel. The amorphous silica gel was prepared fresh from sodium silicate and hydrochloric acid. The gel was washed thoroughly with de-ionized water and was dehydrated at a low temperature. The powdered gel and Paul D. Baranyai salts were heated in covered platinum crucibles, and then x-ray powder photographs were taken of each sample. Each polymorph pre- sent was identified by the x-ray photographs. A spectrographic analysis was also made to determine whether any of the salts had entered into the atomic structure of the silica. The results showed that at atmospheric pressure and at tempera- tures ranging from 600°C. to 900°C. the various polymorphs of silica can be crystallized by using various salts as catalysts. The poly- morph which was formed predominately in all the samplesets was cris- tobalite — the highest-temperature polymorph. It was also found that sodium had entered into the structure of cristobalite. The open struc- ture of cristobalite had been presumably stabilized by the sodium atoms. THE CRYSTALLIZATION 0F ADDRPHOUS S IL ICA USING SALT CATALYSTS BY Paul D. Baranyai A THESIS Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE Department of Geology 1964 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to express my grateful appreciation to Dr. Harold Stonehouse for his suggestion of the problem and for his constructive suggestions during the course of the research and for his critical review of the manuscript. I would also like to thank.Dr. Hinze and Dr. Zinn for their constructive criticism of the manuscript. A special note of appreciation is for my wife, Jan, who provided a constant source of encouragement throughout the entire research. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Purpose of Study Introduction Phase Relationship Review of Early Literature Experimental Procedure X-ray Diffraction Theory X-ray Data Interpretation of X-ray Powder Photographs Spectrographic Analysis Procedure Conclusion Suggestions for Future Study Bibliography iii Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page ll 18 23 24 44 45 48 50 51 LIST OF TABLES Table 1 'Stability Range for the Polymorphs of SilicaPage Table 11 .Structure of the Polymorphs of Silica Table III High Pressure Crystallization Table IV yCommercial Brands of Silica Gel Table V IPercentage Loss of Weight Table VI T-Ray Data Table VII.Frystallization Products Table VIIIPolymorphic Inversions Table Ix,'Density Increase with Temperature Table x pectrographic Wave Lengths Table XI Spectrographic Analysis iv "T‘F—_—_- Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page Page ll 14, 15 23 36, 37, 38 39, 40 43 45 46 Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure 0 LIST OF FIGURES Phase Relationships Isothermal Rate Curves X-Ray Radiation Wave Lengths ,Generation of a Lattice Net Conditions for Scattering-In-Phase iProduction of a Powder Diagram I 'Cylindrical Film Arrangement Page Page Page Page Page Page Page 5 9 17 18 19 20 21 PURPOSE OF STUDY This study was undertaken to investigate the crystallization of the polymorphs of silica from the amorphous state by the use of various salts. Varying concentrations of the following salts were mixed with the amorphous silica gel and heated at temperatures rang- ing from 600°C. to 900°C.: sodium chloride, calcium chloride, lithium chloride and potassium bromide. All of the heating was performed under one atmosphere of pressure. These four salts were chosen be- cause they are common impurities which are found in the polymorphs of silica. Although this study may not have direct geologiq implications, it is important to note that while the temperatures used in this study were below the stability range for tridymite and cristobalite, these were the resultant crystallization products. Studies of the crystallization of silica gel using various catalysts are few at the temperatures used in this research. INTRODUCTION Silica, SiOz, exists in a number of polymorphs which are stable at different temperatures and pressures. Among these polymorphs are quartz, which is stable at ordinary conditions, tridymite and the high temperature polymorph, cristobalite. Along with the above forms, three less common forms exist, which are metastable at ordinary condi- tions. These are keatite, coesite and stishovite. The following table lists each polymorph and the thermal stability range at one atmosphere of pressure. Table I (Frondel, 1962, Page 1) Name Thermal Stability Range- one atmosphere in 0C a Quartz Stable below 573 / Quartz Stable 573-870 Tridymite Stable 870-1470 If tridymite Below 117 A tridymite 117-163 a( tridymite 163-1570 Cristobalite Stable 1470-1720 04 cristobalite Below 200 / cristobalite 200-1720 Keatite Metastable at ordinary conditions Coesite Metastable at ordinary conditions Stishovite Metastable at ordinary conditions Historically, quartz as a name was used first in the Middle Ages (Frondel, 1962) in Saxony for massive vein quartz. However, it was not until the 1850's that an adequate method of study was available. Tridymite, the first polymorph of silica to be recognized in addition to quartz was described by von Roth in 1868, and he described cristobalite in 1884. Since the first acknowledgment of these poly- morphs of silica, other individual polymorphs closely related in crystal structure have been identified. Merion in 1884 was the first to observe the high and low forms of tridymite. In 1890, Mallard described the high and low forms of cristobalite. Fenner, who in the early 1900's investigated the stability relations of these polymorphs, was the first to define the existence of middle tridymite. It was not until much later that additional polymorphs of silica were synthesized in the laboratory. The first of these was Coesite, synthesized in 1953 by L. Coes. Coesite was obtained originally in the temperature range between SOD-800°C and at 35,000 atmospheres for periods of about fif- teen hours. P. P. Keat synthesized Keatite in 1954. Keatite was obtained over a range of temperatures from 380-585°C and 5,000:18,000 p.s.i. Then in 1961 Stishov and Popova synthesized Stishovite. Stishovite was first synthesized at temperatures between 1200-1400°C and a pressure reported to be about 160 kilobars. Since the initial syntheses of these polymorphs, two have been identified in nature. Coesite was found in nature at Meteor Crater, Arizona. It occurs abundantly in sheared and compressed areas of sandstone as a fine grained nearly istropic matrix in which the fractured quartz are em- bedded. Stishovite has also been found in association with coesite and silica glass at Meteor Crater, Arizona, and in other areas. PHASE RELATIONSHIP The phase relationship between the three common polymorphs is given in Figure 1. Figure l I ,l’ l I | I Liquid /// 1800 ._ x’ _ / ”T *+———-Cristobalite 1500 _._._.,' .. I, flquartz I 44___——Tridymite 1200 ' .— c, F'T o a / m / *5 / g 900 / __ H 8. J Coesite E E! 600 I-— .1 I O