PART ONE THE PREPARATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF A SERIES OF CHLOROALKOXOBISCYCLO- PENTADIENYLZIRCONIUMHV) AND DIALKOXDBISCYCLO ' PENTADIENYLZIRCONIUMUV) COMPOUNDS PART TWO NITROGEN FIXATION UNDER MILD CONDITIONS BY USING SOME ' ORGANOMETALLIC COMPOUNDS OF THE SECOND-ROW TRANSITION ELEMENTS AS THE ACTIVATING AGENTS Thesis for the Degree of Ph.D. MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY DONALD R. GRAY 197D 6,; This is to certify that the thesis entitled PART ONE: THE PREPARATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF A SERIES OF CHLOROALKOXOB ISCYCLOPENTAD | ENYLZ IRCON I UM (IV) AND D IALKOXOB ISCYCLOPENTAD I ENYLZ I RCON IUM (IV) COMPOUNDS PART TWO: NITROGEN FIXATION UNDER MILD CONDITIONS BY USING SOME ORGANOMETALLIC COMPOUNDS OF THE SECOND-ROW TRANSITION ELEMENTS AS THE presented by ACTIVATING AGENTS DONALD R. GRAY has been accepted towards fulfillment of the requirements for Ph. D. Jegree in Chemistry A'r \‘1 Major professor Date December, 8, 19 70 0-7639 ABSTRACT PART ONE THE PREPARATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF A SERIES OF CHLOROALKOXOBISCYCLOPENTADIENYLZIRCONIUM(IV) AND DIALKOXOBISCYCLOPENTADIENYLZIRCONIUM(IV)-COMPOUNDS PART TWO NITROGEN FIXATION UNDER MILD CONDITIONS BY USING SOME ORGANOMETALLIC COMPOUNDS OF THE SECOND-ROW TRANSITION ELEMENTS AS THE ACTIVATING AGENTS BY is \,53 . Donald REIGray PART ONE A new series of zirconium(IV) compounds of the type (c5H5)22r(0R)nc12_n (n = 1 and 2; R = CH3. C2H5, ifC3H7) were prepared and characterized. .The compounds were pre- pared by allowing the appropriate alcohol to react with (C5H5)2ZrC12 and triethylamine in tetrahydrofuran solvent. All the compounds were purified by sublimation under vacuum. The nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of the compounds were used to show unequivocally the presence of the cyclo- pentadienyl and alkoxide groups. The integrated areas of the resonance peaks were used to determine 'n'. The change in chemical shifts of (C5H5)22r(OR)nC12_n as 'n' increased showed the opposite trend from what has been observed in similar series of titanium(IV) compounds. Donald R. Gray The infrared spectra were studied to prove further the existence of the cyclopentadienyl and alkoxide ligands and to speculate on the electron density change about the zir- conium as 'n' increased. The far-infrared spectra gave clear indication of the presence of the Zr-OR and Zr-ring bonds. The shifts in all infrared and far-infrared fre- quencies were consistent with basicity arguments. The hydrolysis reactions were studied. For n = 1, the hydrolysis product was of the form (CPZCer)2O with a zir- conoxane (Zr- 0 - Zr) linkage. For n = 2, the hydrolysis product was of a more complicated form, probably -[O-Zr(OH)2]n-. The infrared spectra, weight changes, and melting point changes were consistent with these conclusions. Polarograms of the compounds in THF were attempted but were unsuccessful in yielding the desired reduction potential. PART TWO A survey of several early second-row transition metal organometallic compounds was made to determine their ef- ficacy as nitrogen-fixation agents under mild conditions. Most of the compounds used were of the form (C5H5)2MClx_2, where x is the oxidation state of M. Some of the com- pounds prepared in Part One were also used. AThe experiment was similar in all cases. Nitrogen was continually passed through a solution of the complex in tetrahydrofuran. A two-electron reduction of the compound Donald R. Gray 'was attempted by using sodium naphthalenide. If the reduc- tion was effected, the compound conceivably attached a molecule of nitrogen. Hydrolysis at this point produced ammonia. rThe experiment gave measurable quantities of ammonia when (C5H5)2NbC13, (c5H5)22rc12, and (C5H5)2Zr(OC3H7)Cl were used. Several other compounds were effective in pro- ducing very small amounts of ammonia. PART ONE THE PREPARATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF A SERIES OF CHLOROALKOXOBISCYCLOPENTADIENYLZIRCONIUM(IV) AND DIALKOXOBISCYCLOPENTADIENYLZIRCONIUM(IV)-COMPOUNDS PART TWO NITROGEN FIXATION UNDER MILD CONDITIONS BY USING SOME ORGANOMETALLIC COMPOUNDS OF THE SECOND-ROW TRANSITION ELEMENTS AS THE ACTIVATING AGENTS BY 0 (yoga Donald RJ\Gray A THESIS Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Chemistry 1970 DEDICATION This work is dedicated to the following: Joan, my wife, whose constant love and encouragement made these years very good years; Rick and Cindy, my children, whose existence makes everything worthwhile; Mr. and Mrs. W. Russell Gray, my parents, whose under- standing and assistance have made rough times smooth and whose general attitude has created a close and wonderful family; Vera Elliott, my mother-in-law, whose self-sacrifice for her family has been inspirational. ii ACKNOWLEDGMENT The author wishes to express his appreciation for the guidance and leadership of Professor Carl H. Brubaker, Jr. Financial support from the National Institute of Health (Predoctoral Fellowship) was profoundly appreciated. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS PART ONE THE PREPARATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF A SERIES OF CHLOROALKOXOBISCYCLOPENTADIENYLZIRCONIUM(IV) AND DIALKOXOBISCYCLOPENTADIENYLZIRCONIUM(IV)‘COMPOUNDS Page INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 EXPERIMENTAL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Analytical Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Experimental Apparatus and Technique . . . q -a m a: A D. Preparation of Compounds . . . . . . . . . E. Hydrolysis Reactions . . . . . . . . . . . 12 F. Spectroscopic Measurements . . . . . . . . 13 G. Polarography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 A. Preparations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 B. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectra . . . . 17 C. Infrared Spectra . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 D. Hydrolysis Reactions . . . . . . . . . . . 42 E. Miscellaneous Observations . . . . . . . . 46 iv TABLE OF CONTENTS (Cont.) . PART TWO NITROGEN FIXATION UNDER MILD CONDITIONS BY USING SOME ORGANOMETALLIC COMPOUNDS OF THE SECOND-ROW TRANSITION ELEMENTS AS THE ACTIVATING AGENTS INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . EXPERIMENTAL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. B. C. D. E. RESULTS A. B. C. D. E. BI BLIOGMPI-IY O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O C .Materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . Analytical Methods . . . . . . . . . .Experimental Apparatus and Technique The Nitrogen-Fixation Experiment . . Preparation of the Compounds . . . . AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . General Observations . . . . . . . . Compounds of Zirconium . . . . . . . -Compounds of Niobium . . . . . . . . Compounds of Molybdenum and Tungsten Ruthenocene ;. . . . . . . . . . . . Page 49 54 54 56 57 57 6O 62 62 65 66 66 67 68 LIST OF TABLES TABLE Page I. Reactant Ratios and Sublimation Temperatures for the Compounds Cp22r(OR)Cl, Cp22r(OR)2. and zr(OR)4 O O O O O O ‘ O O O O O O ‘ O O O O 16 II. Proton NMR Chemical Shifts for szzr(OR)nc12_n and ZI(OR)4 o o o o o o o o o o o o v o o o o 24 III. .Characteristic Frequencies (cm-1) of Alkoxide Groups in Cp,,Zr(ORJ)nC12__n . . . . . . . . . . 36 IV. Far-Infrared Frequencies (cm—1) of Zr-O and Zr-ring Bonds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 V. A Summary of the Results Obtained by Using Various Transition Metal Compounds in the Nitrogen-Fixation Experiment . . . . . . . . 63 vi Far— infrared spectra of Cp2Zr(OC2H5)n Cl - 2) and Zr(OC2H5) . . . . LIST OF FIGURES of of of of of of of of of FIGURE 1. Proton nmr 2. Proton nmr of 3. eProton nmr of 4. Proton nmr of 5. Proton nmr of 6. Proton nmr of 7. Infrared spectrum 8. Infrared spectrum 9. Infrared spectrum 10. Infrared spectrum 11. Infrared Spectrum 12. Infrared spectrum 13. Infrared spectrum 14. Infrared spectrum 15. Infrared spectrum 16. Far-infrared spectra (h = 17. 4 4 120 R ETC3H7 1 >4 4 120 17 B. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectra Nuclear magnetic resonance provided a convenient method of characterizing the compounds and of checking for the presence of impurities. The spectra were recorded in C6D6, and the resonance peaks were sharp and well-defined. The nmr spectra, along with important analytical results and melting points, are shown in Figures 1—6. A summary of the chemical shift data is shown ianable II. The chemical shift results are especially noteworthy. Nesmeyanov has studied the nmr of the series of compounds CpTi(OCZH5)nCl (n = 0 - 3).2 His results show that the a-n chemical shifts of the ring, methyl, and methylene groups shift to higher frequencies as 'n' increases. This trend is explained by invoking electronegativity arguments. As the ethoxide groups are replaced by the more electronega- tive chloride ligands, the electron density is decreased about the Cp ring and the methylene and methyl groups of the ethoxide ligand. The result is a shift toward lower frequencies in the nmr spectrum. »Nesmeyanov's results are significant because the exact opposite effect is seen with the zirconium compounds (see Table II). As the number of alkoxide groups is decreased, the chemical shifts of the ring and alkoxide resonances in- crease. The electronegativity argument cannot be used to explain this apparently anomalous behavior. The primary differences between the Nesmeyanov work and the present 18 COMPLEX C5H5\ 2 /Cl r /’/’ ‘\\ C5H5 0—CH3 NMR T=4,os 6.35 intensity IO 2.7 thoor IO 3.0 el.onoI. Zr Cl C H colcd 31.69 12.32 45.89 4.52 found 31.51 12.06 45.35 4.l5 m.p. III-I146 Figure 1. Proton nmr of Cp2Zr(OCH3)Cl. Chemical shifts in ppm . Figure 2. Proton nmr of szzr(OCH3)2. 19 COMPLEX C5H5\ Zr/O CH3 c511 / \O—CH3 NMR T=4.02 6.23 intensity 10 5,7 "100! 10 6.0 eI. anal. Zr C H colcd 32.19 50.86 5.65 found 32.20 48.91 5.02 mp. 63-68’ Chemical shifts in ppm. Figure 3. 20 COMPLEX r . a’l’ .\\\ N M R If: 4.01 200 6.14 - _1Ma_ __ intensity-a 10 L9 2.8 theorn- 10 20 10 81. cool. Zr Cl C H calcd 30.24 11.75 47.77 4.97 found 30.09 11.87 47.48 4.78 m.p. 72-77° Proton nmr of Cp22r(OC2H5)Cl. in ppm. Chemical shifts 21 COMPLEX CSHS \ /0—CH2—CH3 Zr NMR T=4-00 8.89 6.07 intensirym 10 3.8 6.4 thoor - -- 10 4.0 6.0 61. cool. Zr C H 1:0ch 29.30 54.00 6.42 found 2 9.01 5 2.03 6.01 m.p, 52-54' Figure 4. Proton nmr of Cp2Zr(OC2H5)2. in ppm. Chemical shifts 22 COMPLEX C5H5\z/Cl C r H 3 9115/ \o—cH/ ‘\ CH3 NMR T=4.05 'ROO intensitym 10 5.9 rhooru' 10 60 61.61161. Zr Cl C H colcd 28.88 11.23 49.44 5.38 found 29.21 11.21 48.90 5.07 m.p. 81-82.5' Figure 5. Proton nmr of Cp2Zr(OC3H7)Cl. Chemical shifts in ppm. 23 COMPLEX C5:5\zr/ 0"- C H— (C “3’2 NMR 1’=4.01 8.92 592 II w - . intansin 10 12 thaor no 12 e1. anal. Zr C H calcd 26.88 56.62 7.07 found 26.92 56.29 7.36 m.p. 1105-115" Figure 6. Proton nmr of CpZZr(OC3H7)2. Chemical shifts in ppm. Table II. Proton NMR and Zr(OR)4 standard = 24 Chemical Shifts for Cp2Zr(OR)nC12_n (solvent = C6D6; T-scale; internal TMS). Chemical Shifts (Rpm) Compound Ring Methyl Methylene szer12 4.09 '- Cp22r(OCH3)Cl 4.05 6.35 Cp2Zr(OCH3)2 4.02 6.23 Cp2Zr(OC2H5)Cl 4.01 9.00 6.14 szzr(OC2H5)2 4.00 8.89 6.07 Zr(0C2H5)4 - 8.64 5.73 Cp22r(OC3H7)Cl 4.05 9.00 Cp22r(OC3H7)2 4.01 8.92 Zr(OC3H7)4 - 8.65 25 zirconium work are (1) the central metal, and (2) the num- ber of cyclopentadienyl rings bonded to the central metal. Wales13 has published the nmr work of the only other relevant series,.Cp2Ti(SR)nC12_n (n = 0,1,2). Because this series contains two Cp rings, the analogy to the zir- conium series may be more valid than the Nesmeyanov series. However, Wales' results show the same trends in chemical shifts as the Nesmeyanov compounds show. The presence of thio—alkoxide groups rather than alkoxide groups makes this comparison questionable. Until additional work is done with the zirconium series, it is futile to attempt an explanation of the anomalous chemical shift observations. The reason could perhaps be the result of using zirconium rather than titanium. The series of compounds szTi(OR)nCl and Cer(OR)nCl 2-n 3-n’ neither of which has been characterized, should clarify this matter. The anomaly could also be a solvent effect. The Nesmeyanov compounds were studied in THF, the Wales compounds in CDCl3, and the zirconium compounds in C6D6. C. Infrared Spectra The infrared spectra of these compounds also provide an important characterization technique. Coordinated cyclo- pentadienyl rings and the alkoxide groups give character- istic infrared absorption bands in the 3500 - 700 cm"1 re- gion. In addition, valuable information about the 26 Zr - ring and Zr - OR bonds can be obtained by a study of the far infrared (700 - 250 cm_1) region. The infrared spectra of the 3500 - 700 cm-1 region for the compounds studied are presented in Figures 7 — 15. The bands characteristic of the vibrations of the cyclopenta— dineyl rings (3100, 1020-1010, 850-840-815) are all present in the series of compounds Cp2Zr(OR)nCl rThere is a 2-n' slight shift towards lower frequencies of the 1020-1010 and 850-840-815 bands as 'n' increases. This may well re- flect the increased electron density on the ring as the alkoxide groups replace the chlorides. The bands characteristic of the OR groups become much more intense (relative to the Cp bands) as "n" increases. The band assignments, based on standard spectra for the pure alcohol, are presented in Table III. The CH3-bending modes which are not shown are overlapped by the Nujol bands in the 1400 - 1500 cm"1 region. A study of Table IIIshows that insignificant shifts occur in the OR bands as 'n' goes from 1 to 2. The unas- signed bands in the 730 - 770 cm"1 region, however, undergo significant shifts to lower frequencies as 'n' goes from .1 to 2. These bands are absent in the spectra of the pure 'alcohols and the Cp2ZrClz. It is reasonable, therefore, to assume that they arise from the Zr - 0 bond. The pres- ence of a chloride ligand should decrease the electron density about the central metal, thus allowing a stronger Zr - 0 bond to be formed. This is consistent with the 27 aauomwsuou oon .NHUHNNQU mo Eduuommm CoumnmcH .h whomflm ATE: xucoaoo; oom coo. oo~_ oov. oonWI ooum OOOn a q _ _ 47 q d 28 95061411115001; oon 00m ooo— _ .HoAnmUoVuNumo mo Eduuoomm CommuwcH ATE: xucoaoo: CON. oov. OOMW oonu _ _ Lfl. AI .m ousmflm coon 29 aouomwsuou .mAmmUOVHNmmU mo Eonuommm UmHmHMCH .m musmflm ATE: Sconce: oom 00m 000. cow. oov. oonw ooum ooon _ _ _ 7 .7 a H 30 83001111115001; oon oom coo— _ .HoflmmmooVHNnmo wo Eduuoomm COHCHMCH .OH ousmflm ATEOV Sconce; oo~_ oov. oonw Conn _ .I 47 a 1 ooon fl. 31 85004111115001; oon oom ooo. _ .mflmmmuovnmmmo mo Eouuoomm UmnmumcH .HH ousmflm A—IEUV xucoaao; CON. oov— oonI— 00km _ _ A_I E ooon 32 33001410150011 oon 00m 000— _ .vAmmmUovHN mo Esnuoomm COHCHMGH :IEUV xucoanuo; OON— OOV— OOMW CONN _ _ .1 a .Na onsmflm oooM 33 asunIIstuou .Huflnmmoovumumo mo Eouuoomm UmumumcH .mH ousmflm ATEOV 88:06: com com ooo— ooNp oov— oonI— OOKN coon — _ _ . :I q 7 34 aauougwsuou com 00m 000— IIfi q 2 .mflnmmoovuwmmo mo Eduuoomm CommumcH .vH ouomflm ATE“; xucoaooi com. 00V. comp CORN _ _ d7 7 ooom 35 aauomwsuou oom oom coo— _ .vflnmmoovum mo Esnuoomm CoumnmcH :IEUV xucoaoui OON— OOV— comm CONN _ _ 41 a .mH onsmflm coon 36 owe cmfifiumoflfl mmmfl ooom «Asmaoovuuado non AAHHIHoHA omms comm Hofismeoovuuado «me «He umfifluoefls osos «Asmaoovuuado was one «mnfiuomfifi whoa Hoflamaoovuusdo can oNHH comm «Aemoovuusoo «on cuss nowm Hoflemoovuuaao AmVAOIHNV nouonum comm nouonum ocmm nuuouum oocmsnnmco Ono 0.0 010 Tue. mno oaaomsoo .cIAHOEAmoVuNamo CA mmsono moflxoxad mo AH 180v moaocosooum oflumfluouomnmno .HHH manna 37 observed shift to higher frequency of the Zr - 0 bond as- signment as chloride replaces alkoxide in each case. Since the Zr - O stretching frequencies are found at much lower frequencies, the frequency in the 730 - 770 cm.1 region is possibly a bending mode. The far-infrared spectra (700 - 250 cm-1) of the com- pounds of interest are shown in Figures 16-18. The import- ant features of these spectra are the assignments and observed shifts in the Zr - O and the Zr - ring stretching frequencies. These frequencies are summarized in Table IV. The assignments were made by comparing the spectra of Cp,Zr(OR)nc12_n with the spectrum of CpZZrClz. From Table IV it is seen that the Zr - O and the Zr - ring frequencies are shifted to lower frequencies as the chlorides are successively replaced by alkoxides. This is once again consistent with the electron density argument expressed above. The Zr - O and Zr - ring bonds are equally affected by the presence or absence of chloride ligands. 38 Figure 16. Far-infared spectra of Cp2Zr(OCH3)nC12_n (n = 0-2). (C5H5)2 Zr (OCHg) 2 (C5H5)2Zr(OCH3)k W I I fwt:_‘v‘~ "-VA‘VA' ‘I (C51'15I'21r C12 I1 L 1 A 1 L 1 L 3— L 700 600 500 400 250 freq uancy (cm‘ ') transmittance 39 Figure 17. Far—infrared Spectra of szzr(OC2H5)nCl2 (n = 0—2) and Zr(0C2H5)4. —n Zr(QC2H5)4 W (C5H5)2 Z r(OC2H5)2 (C5 H5)2 Zr(OC2 H5) C1 (C5H5)2Zr 02 I L_ LL i 1 L A J L A transmittance 700 600 500 400 250 frequency (cm") Figure 18. Far-infrared spectra of Cp2Zr(OC3H7)nC1 40 (n = 0-2) and Zr(OC3H7)4. -n (C5H5)2Zr( C (C5H512zr( l l I 1 I L A L J 700 600 500 400 250 frequency (cm-1) transmittance 41 Table IV. Far-infared Frequencies (cm-1) of Zr-O and Zr-ring Bonds. . Compound Zr-O Stretch Zr-ring Stretch CpZZrClz Cp22r(OCH3)Cl Cp2Zr(OCH3)2 Cp22r(OC2H5)Cl szzr(0C2H5)2 Zr(OC2H5)4 Cp22r(OC3H7)Cl Cp2Zr(OC3H7)2 Zr(OC3H7)4 507 482 532 521 (520,472,421) 572 560 (453,435) (570,516,463) 359 342 329 338 318 344 315 42 D. Hydrolysis Reactions It has been previously noted that the compounds Cp22r(OR)Cl and Cp2Zr(OR)2 are extremely sensitive to moisture. If water vapor is allowed to come in contact with the compounds, the compounds are quickly destroyed. This section will deal with the products of these hydrol- ysis reactions. If the compounds are exposed to air saturated with water vapor, they lose weight rapidly. No physical change can be visibly observed, but the melting points change from the relatively low values reported earlier to values in the range of 300° or greater. The infrared spectra undergo marked changes. -The infrared spectra and melting points indicate that the end hydrolysis product for each of the three compounds szzr(OR)C1 (R = CH3, C2H5, ifC3H7) is the same. Further- more, the weight loss corresponds to the hydrolysis reaction Cp\ /Cp 2Cp2Zr(OR)Cl + HOH > Cl-Zr-O-Zr:Cl + 2ROH ./ This is the same noted by Brainina4 when he performed an elaborate hydrolysis reaction with szzr(OC2H5)Cl. The infrared spectrum of the hydrolysis products of Cp3Zr(OR)Cl is shown in Figure 19. The spectrum (the same regardless of 'R') is consistent with the above reaction. The absorption bands characteristic of the cyclopentadienyl 43 eouougwsuou CON COO .Honmoqummo mo uosoonm mflmwaouohz mo Eduuoomm COHOHCCH ATE: xucoaoo... COO. CON. OOV. COO. CONN .OH musmflm coon _ q E .Eci _. H 44 rings (3100, 1030-1020, 840-810 cm-l) are still present. All bands characteristic of the R-groups are absent. There are additional strong bands at 779 and 752 cm.1 which may be additional cyclopentadienyl bands. The far-infrared region (see Figure 20) shows the Zr-ring stretching band at 349 cm.1 and the lower frequency broader bands character- istic of a Zr-Cl bond. The hydrolysis of the compounds Cp2Zr(OR)2 [B] is much different from and less straightforward than the hydrolysis of Cp2Zr(OR)Cl [A]. The weight loss (relative to weight of original product) attending the hydrolysis of [B] is much greater than the weight loss for [A]. The hydrolysis of [B] seems to proceed in two rather ill-de- fined steps. On the basis of infrared spectral evidence and weight loss calculations, the two steps can be ex- pressed as follows: Cp Cp (1) n Cpgzr(OR)2 + n HOH > Zr O-Zr—O + n ROH ('29 GP n-I [Cl OH OH (2) [C] +nHOH > Zr -Zr-O + nHCp OH OH n-1 ID] The above steps are undoubtedly an oversimplification. If the hydrolysis is allowed to proceed for about 30 minutes, 45 A 0 u C 2 'E Q C 2 B O- L_ 1 I 1 L l 41 J I 700 600 500 400 250 frequency Icm") Figure 20. Far-infared spectra of hydrolysis products of (A) Cp2Zr(OR)Cl : (B) Cp22r(OR)2. 46 the weight loss corresponds roughly to the weight lost by elimination of alkoxide groups in step (1). The infrared spectrum shows that all bands characteristic of the R-groups are absent. The spectrum shows, however, that the cyclo- pentadienyl absorption bands are superimposed on the broad band characteristic of the Zr-OH band (very broad centering at 480 cm-l). See Figure 20. This would indicate that step (2) has already begun. Further hydrolysis results in a slower weight loss until a constant weight is finally observed. This weight loss corresponds roughly to the elimination of HCp as in step (2). The distinctive odor of cyclopentadiene is observed during the latter stage of hydrolysis. The infrared Spectrum of [D] shows no indica- tion of the presence of Cp. Broad bands are observed at 3300, 1480, and 480 cm-1. The former two are indicative of bound OH while the latter is probably due to the Zr-OH bond. E. Miscellaneous Observations Reduction Potentials. It was hOped that reduction po- tentials for each of the compounds could be determined. This information would be particularly useful in relation to Part Two of this work. .The polarograms were attempted in THF solution. The resistance of THF, however, could not be sufficiently overcome by the presence of supporting elec- trolyte (TBAI) to obtain valid polarograms. This work is being continued. 47 Melting Points. .Each of the compounds gave clear melts with no apparent decomposition. Brainina4 reported that his preparation of Cp22r(OC2H5)Cl melted with decomposi- tion. It is possible that his compound was not sufficiently purified. Small quantities of hydrolysis product cause the melt to become brown. This gives the appearance of decompo- sition. PART TWO NITROGEN FIXATION UNDER MILD CONDITIONS BY USING SOME ORGANOMETALLIC COMPOUNDS OF THE SECOND-ROW TRANSITION ELEMENTS AS THE ACTIVATING AGENTS 48 INTRODUCTION The process by which nature converts molecular nitro- gen to ammonia and other more useful compounds has long been a fascinating puzzle to the chemist and the biologist. Nitrogen can be industrially converted to ammonia only under severe conditions of temperature and pressure.14 Micro-organisms, however, have the ability to "fix" molecu- lar nitrogen under the mild conditions of ambient tempera- ture and pressure. These natural systems inevitably con- tain iron and molybdenum components, and for this reason inorganic chemists have long tried to duplicate the nitrogen- fixing process. The first major breakthrough in molecular nitrogen activation under mild conditions by a transition metal was made by Vol'pin in 1966.15 By allowing one of several Ti(IV) compounds to react with an alkyl magnesium halide in the presence of molecular nitrogen, Vol'pin found that subsequent hydrolysis produced detectable quantities of ammonia. Since then this syStem has acted as the model for most attempts to "fix" molecular nitrogen by inorganic or organometallic complexes. 49 50 The mechanistic concept by which Vol'pin's system "fixes" molecular nitrogen remains to be elucidated. Brintzinger has suggested that the monomeric dihydride anion [(v-C5H5)2TiH2]- may be an intermediate.1°v17 The focus of this topic has shifted away from Vol'pin's system, however, and little mechanistic work seems to be in process. .Much work in the last two years has been done by van Tamelen and co-workers.13'34 Van Tamelen has worked with a variety of titanium(IV) systems and has achieved a sig- nificant amount of success. He asserts that a Ti(II) species is the activating intermediate in practically all of his systems. A strong reducing agent, either chemical or electrical, is employed to give the two-electron reduc- tion. In this reduced state, the Ti(II) species perhaps "complexes" a molecule of molecular nitrogen. Van Tamelen suggests that the NeN bond is cleaved by further reduction at this stage, and the result is a nitride-type structure. Subsequent hydrolysis of this species liberates ammonia and possibly regenerates the initial (Ti(IV) species. If van Tamelen's suggested mechanism is correct (see Figure 21), a true catalytic process is possible. Yields of greater than 100% (based on moles of ammonia produced per mole of initial titanium compound) have been realized by van Tamelen's pro- cedure, but a true catalytic process is yet to be shown. An alternative mechanism for the van Tamelen-type pro- cess has been proposed by Henrici-Olivé and Olivé.25 The 51 .coflumxflw COCOHDHQ How Emflcmzomfi Comomoum m.cmHOEmB Cm> -56 + MUr21." .mIromo + -66 + N2 mot._zi._ A -3. \ 1046 620%.. AK mIzm 4 50:. \ ...dz +624 > OZV Oco_of;doc OZN .fim onsmflm "mmouoca .oc __ocO>O a mzmaoé \ 7 (If 5+9: I.QZ +07— N .3 < \ Dr 620% 52 Olivés' mechanism, unlike van Tamelen's, involves a hydrogen- bridged Ti(III) dimer as the activating intermediate. Van Tamelen has recently shown that this is highly unlikely.24 Regardless of which mechanism one chooses to believe, it is nevertheless clear that somehow the molecular nitrogen has been chemically activated. No actual molecular nitrogen complex of the early transition metals has been isolated. vThe nature of the metal-dinitrogen bond is thus not known. It is quite probable, however, that an olefinic-type of U- complex is formed. This type of complexation is a common phenomenon in complex catalysis. .The usual result of such a U-complex formation is the activation of the multiple bond. The activation is a result of the donation of the U-elec- trons of the multiple bond to the empty d-orbitals of the transition metal, which causes a partial rupture of the multiple bond and imparts a slight positive charge to the atoms comprising the multiple bond. These effects produce a weakening of the multiple bond and permit further reaction to occur. It is quite probable that bonding of this type is somehow involved in the nitrogen fixation-reduction cycle. A large number of stable molecular nitrogen complexes have been prepared and characterized, but these complexes invariably involve a transition metal containing six to eight d—electrons. .The most interesting from both a histori- cal and theoretical perspective are [Ru(NH3)5N2]C12,26 IrCl(Ph3P)2N2f,27 HCo(Ph3P)3N338, and [RU(NH3)5]2N2-29 The important feature of all these complexes is that all 53 attempts at further activation of the bound molecular nitro- gen have proven futile. In each case the metal-dinitrogen bond is nearly linear. The bonding is analogous to the metal-carbonyl bond. Back r-bonding from the filled d-elec- trons of the transition metal to the empty antibonding p- orbitals of the molecular nitrogen is thought to be the stabilizing factor. Because the electrons involved in the multiple NEN bond are not significantly affected, it is not difficult to understand why further activation is improb- able. This is quite different from what would be eXpected if the bonding were of the olefinic type as described pre- viously. The stable molecular nitrogen complexes are fur- ther hindered as possible intermediates in the nitrogen- fixing cycle if one accepts van Tamelen's suggestion that a two-electron reduction is a necessary first step. In each case this would mean forcing electrons into the next higher molecular orbital, but the next higher molecular orbital in these molecules is an antibonding orbital of high energy. Because the titanocene dichloride system works well in the van Tamelen experiments, perhaps the biscyclopentadienyl- halide and the mixed cyclopentadienyl-alkoxide compounds of the second-row transition metals also have the ability to fix nitrogen. Part Two of this research project deals with a survey of these organometallic compounds and their efficacy in the fixation-reduction cycle. EXPERIMENTAL A. Materials Bis(U-cyclopentadienyl)dichlorozirconium(ij was ob- tained from Arapahoe Chemical Company and used without further purification. Anal. Calcd for C10H10ZrC12: Zr, 31.22; Cl, 24.26. Found: Zr, 31.09; Cl, 24.13. Niobium pentachloride was obtained from Research In- organic Chemicals and used without further purification. .Molybdenum pentachloride was obtained from Climax Molybdenum Company. The commercial product was further purified by vacuum sublimation. The green oxychloride im- purities were removed by gradually increasing the tempera- ture until no more green substance sublimed. The shiny black crystals of pure MoC15 were then sublimed and stored under dry nitrogen. This process was accomplished by the use of a three-component Pyrex tube and a tube furnace. Ruthenium trichloride was purchased from Alfa Inor- ganics and used without further purification. 54 55 Sodium was used in the form of finely dispersed sodium prepared according to the method of T. P. Whaley.3° The sodium was stored under sodium-dried xylene in a dry nitro- gen atmosphere. Transfers of sodium were effected by use of a pipet. The xylene was removed under vacuum before the sodium was weighed and used. -Cyclopentadiene was freshly prepared by depolymeriza- tion of dicyclopentadiene by heating the dicyclopentadiene until the depolymerization occurred. .The cyclopentadiene was fractionally distilled into a flask and stored until used at -78°. [W(OCH3)2C13]J2f and [W(092TH5)2C12(C2H50H)]2 were obtained from D. Paul Rillema.31 Solvents. All solvents were refluxed with the appropri- ate drying agent under a nitrogen atmosphere unless indi- cated otherwise. Tetrahydrofuran (THF) was refluxed continuously with lithium aluminum hydride and distilled immediately before use. Benzene was refluxed continuously with calcium hydride and distilled immediately before use. Hexane was continuously refluxed in the presence of sodium metal and distilled immediately before use. Chloroform was washed with water and dried over calcium chloride. The chloroform was then refluxed in the presence 56 of phosphorus pentoxide and distilled. The distilled chloroform was stored in the absence of light. gaggg. Prepurified nitrogen from Liquid Carbonics was passed through an activated copper catalyst (BTS catalyst - BASF R-3—11 from Badische Anilin - Soda-Fabrik AG) to re- move oxygen. It was then passed through two drying towers filled with calcium sulfate and barium oxide to remove any water present. Argon was obtained from Liquid Carbonics and used without further purification. B. Analytical Methods Niobium Analysis. The solid sample was decomposed by dissolution in very dilute nitric acid and digesting the solution over a steam bath for about an hour. This solution was made basic by addition of aqueous ammonia, and the di- gestion was continued for an additional two hours. Dilute nitric acid was added until the solution was acidic. The precipitate was removed by filtration and washed three times with dilute nitric acid. This precipitate was ignited for several hours at 700°, and the niobium was weighed as Nb205. The filtrate was saved and used for determination of chlor- ide content. Molybdenum Analysis. The samples were decomposed by dissolution in BE aqueous ammonia. This solution was acidi- fied with BN_nitric acid and heated to the boiling point. 57 The solution was then diluted to 100.00 ml. Twenty-five-ml aliquots were analyzed for molybdenum according to the method of Pribil and Malat.32 Ammonia Analysis. Ammonia was detected qualitatively by the use of Nessler's Reagent. Nessler's Reagent was pre- pared as follows: (1) Fifty grams of potassium iodide were dissolved in 50 ml cold water; (2) A saturated solution of mercuric chloride (about 22 g in 350 ml of water) was added until an excess was indicated by the formation of a precipi- tate; (3) Two-hundred ml of 5N_sodium hydroxide was added, and the solution was diluted to one liter. Ammonia was quantitatively determined by being passed through standard hydrochloric acid. The remaining hydro- chloric acid was then titrated with standard sodium hydroxide solution, and the ammonia was determined from the amount of acid which had been neutralized. Phenolphthalein was used as the indicator. C. Experimental Apparatus and Technique Most of the materials dealt with in this research were sensitive to oxidation and/or hydrolysis. Similar techniques to those explained in Part One were used. D. The Nitrogen:§ixation Experiment The general procedure followed in the nitrogen- fixation experiments was essentially the same for each 58 compound studied. The apparatus used and a simplified pro- cedure are illustrated in Figure 22. .A more detailed ex- perimental description follows: 1. The reducing solution of sodium naphthalenide was prepared by allowing stoichiometric (1:1) quanti- ties of finely dispersed sodium to react with re- agent naphthalene in THF. A deep emerald-green solution resulted. 2. The appropriate transition-metal complex was dis- solved in THF. The quantity of complex was stoi- chiometrically one-sixth that of the sodium naph- thalenide. This solution of complex in THF was added dropwise to the reducing solution. A con- stant stream of nitrogen was bubbled through the reaction mixture and directed through Nessler's Reagent, which was used for qualitative detection of ammonia in the escaping gas. 3. A slight excess of ethanol, diluted with THF, was added dropwise to the mixture of complex and re- ducing agent. If fixation-reduction occurred, the mixture remained dark; ammonia was very quickly observed in the Nessler's Reagent. If no fixa- tion-reduction occurred, the alcohol reacted with the sodium naphthalenide, the solution became clear, and no ammonia was detected in the Nessler's Re- agent. .DCOEHHOQMO :oflumxflm Isomouuflc map How onsooooum one msumummmm Hmucwefluomxm .NN musmflm .9. 6.3.302 K W“; f _/\ .w 7.5.0.5 5.0. to. .U... a. all polo; 36:3 pea .¢.Z a_> ~12 to. .8. n IIIIIII) .6: R r 9 .92 .a 5:296 to. .2... n at... a. on... .xoiEoO 6.0.50.5»? tt< u c...» c.1mzo.U+OZ .0 £3 Octave. atone... . ”mznamUOxm 60 4. If fixation-reduction occurred, the escaping nitro- gen stream was passed through standard hydrochloric acid solution for 24 hours. Ammonia was determined as previously described under Analytical Methods. B. Preparation of Compounds_ Trichlorobis(1-cyclopentadienyl)niobium(V). A combina- tion and modification of the methods of Birmingham33 and Brantley34 were used. A solution of sodium cyclopentadi- enide in THF was prepared by adding 8.1 ml freshly distilled cyclopentadiene to 2.54 g of finely dispersed sodium. This solution was added dropwise to a suspension of 10,9 Nbcl5 in 50 ml dry benzene. Vigorous mechanical stirring and strict exclusion of air were required. The reaction con- tents were vigorously stirred for several hours. The sol- vents were removed under vacuum. A brownish—black dry solid resulted. This solid was ground to a powder. The powder was placed in a continuous extraction apparatus and ex- tracted with benzene. The extracted product was recrystal- lized from benzene. The product crystals were deep purple. Yield = 4.3 g. The infrared spectrum agreed closely with that reported by Birmingham.33 Analysis Calcd for NbC13C103103 Nb, 28.21; C1, 32.29. Found: Nb, 28.05; Cl, 33.16. Dichlorobis(U-cyclopentadienyl)molybdenum IV .35135.37 Freshly sublimed molybdenum pentachloride (0.05 mol) was 61 added very slowly to an ice-cooled solution of sodium cyclo- pentadienide (0.25 mol) and sodium borohydride (0.13 mol) in 125 ml THF. This mixture was stirred and allowed to reflux for several hours. The solvent was removed by evaporation, 1mm) and the residue was sublimed under vacuum (about 10- at 120°. Bright yellow crystals of (C5H5)M0H2 were obtained. These crystals were extremely sensitive to air, and extreme precautions had to be taken. Exposure to air caused the crystals to turn brown immediately. .The (C5H5)2M0H2 pro- duct was added to 50 ml anhydrous chlorofOrm, and a dark green solution resulted. Green crystals of (C5H5)2M0C12 crystallized from this solution. The physical properties of the product agreed with those given by Cotton and Wilk- inson.35 Biscyclopentadienylruthenium II .35 Ruthenium trichlor- ide (0.01 mol) was added gradually to a solution of sodium cyclopentadienide (0.06 mol) in THF at -80°. The contents of the flask were warmed to room temperature. As the tem- perature was raised the contents became purple. This reac- tion mixture was allowed to reflux for two hours. The sol- vent was removed by evaporation and the remaining solid material was dried. This violet-purple solid was ground to a fine powder and sublimed under vacuum (10-1 mm) at 120°. The resulting product crystals of (C5H5)2Ru were light- yellow. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Part Two of this research is concerned with a general survey of the possible nitrogen-fixing ability of some early transition metal organometallic compounds. .It is not an in-depth study, but is rather an overview with the purpose of pointing out some of the possibilities for future study. The emphasis is on the biscyclopentadienyl compounds of the second-row transition metals. This work will be discussed by each group metal. The discussion will thus be divided‘ into the following headings: A. General Observations, B. Compounds of Zirconium, C. Compounds of Niobium, D. Com- pounds of Molybdenum and Tungsten, and E. .Ruthenocene. A. General Observations Except as otherwise noted, the nitrogen-fixation ex- periment was performed according to the directions prescribed in the Experimental section (see Figure 22). The important aspect of this experiment is to see whether a given transi- tion metal compound is capable of activating molecular nitrogen. The proposed mechanism for the activation has already been reviewed in the Introduction (see Figure 21). The results are summarized in Table V. 62 Table V. A Summary of the Results Obtained by Using Various Transition Metal Compounds in the Nitrogen-Fixa- tion Experiment. 'Compound' + Na+C10H8'_ + N2 big? NH3 Compound %NH3 Comments CpZZrClz O NaBH4 usgd rather than Na C10H8' Cp2ZrC12 2.7.4.1 Cp2Zr(OC3H7)Cl 1.3 CPazIIOC3H7)2 0 CpngCl3 2.6 NbCl5 0 NbCl5 reacts with THF at 25° CngoClz ? Solubility problems not overcome CngoH2 pb W(OCH3)2C13 0.3 W(OC2H5)2C12(C2H50H) P szRu 0 aBased on moles NH3: moles of compound. bPositive qualitative test but not measurable quantitatively. 64 It was necessary to test the validity of the experiment. Spurious conclusions could be drawn if ammonia were already present in the gaseous nitrogen or if some substance present in the compound or reducing agent were to react with Nessler's Reagent. The following tests show that the experiment is indeed valid: (1) If nitorgen gas was bubbled through the reducing agent and the escaping gas was directed through Nessler's Reagent, no ammonia was detected. There is no ammonia in the nitrogen. (2) If the experiment was con- ducted as outlined but without the addition of transition metal complex, no ammonia was detected. The transition metal complex is a necessary constituent in the experiment. (3) If a transition metal compound was found to have the ability to fix nitrogen, the experiment was repeated but argon was substituted for nitrogen. No ammonia was detected when the argon was used. .Molecular nitrogen was the source of the nitrogen in the ammonia. (4) If no reducing agent was used, no ammonia was detected. Reduction of the transi- tion metal complex is an important step in the mechanism. (5) No ammonia was detected until the final hydrolysis and thus the source of the NH3 protons is probably the alcohol used for the hydrolysis. B. Compounds of Zirconium Only for zirconium was a systematic study of related compounds possible. -The compounds which were used were those synthesized and characterized according to Part One 65 of this research. The only compounds available in large enough quantities to permit a valid study were Cp2ZrC12, Cp22r(0C3H7)Cl, and Cp22r(OC3H7)2. The results of the nitrogen-fixation experiment for these three compounds are shown below: Compound Eggs CpZZrC12 2.7, 4.1 Cp22r(OC3H7)Cl 1.3 CpZZr(OC3H7)2 0.0 The yields of ammonia produced are disappointingly small, and any conclusions must be drawn with considerable uncertainty. However, it does appear that the nitrogen- fixing ability of the series decreases as the chloride ligands are replaced by isopropoxide groups. One can only speculate about the effect being related to the ease of the two-electron reduction of Zr(IV)-Zr(II). Watt and Drummond38 have shown that sodium naphthalenide is capable of reducing szer12 to CpZZr. Unfortunately the actual reduction potentials are not known. Attempts to obtain these reduc- tion potentials polarographically (see Part One, Results and Discussion, Section E) were unsuccessful. The speculated'ease-of-reduction" series Cp2ZrC12 > Cp22r(OR)C1 > Cp22r(OR)2 may be a result of the relative electron density about the zirconium. As the chlorides are replaced by the more basic alkoxide groups, the electron density about the zirconium should increase and may have 66 the effect of raising the energy of the lowest-lying d-or- bital slightly. Such an effect would make reduction more difficult. This would be consistent with the trend seen in the relative nitrogen-fixing abilities of the compounds. C. Compounds of Niobium No niobium series similar to that discussed with zir- conium was available. The two compounds studied were szNbCl3 and NbCls. When szNbCla was used in the experi- ment, yields of 2.6% NH3 were realized. The NbC15 gave no indication that NH3 had been produced. The yield of NH3 produced by szNbCl3 was too close to the yield given by Cpaerlz to allow a significant comparison.39 During the course of the szNbCl3 experiment, several of the possible variables were investigated for their ef- fect on the nitrogen-fixation process. After the ammonia- producing process had been proceeding for several hours, the nitrogen flow was replaced by an argon flow. Ammonia production ceased immediately. When the nitrogen flow was once again begun, more ammonia was detected. The addition of more sodium after the reaction had proceeded for a day caused slightly more ammonia to be produced. Adding more szNbCl3 had no effect. D. Compounds of Molybdenum andgungsten The compounds of molybdenum used were szMoClz and szMon. The CngoClz was difficult to study because of 67 its insolubility in THF and most other organic solvents. This insolubility necessitated a vigorously-stirred solid- (CpaMoClz)-liquid(NaNp)-gas(N2) reaction, and the reported results are probably not a valid indication of the ability of Cp2MoCl2 to fix nitrogen. The tungsten compounds used were the dimers [W(OCH3)2C13]2 and [w(oc2H5)2c1(c2H50H)]2. Each produced small quantities of NH3. E. Ruthenocene (CpaRu) It was thought that CpgRu would be most significant if it could fix molecular nitrogen. Isolated molecular nitro- gen complexes of ruthenium have been isolated,26 and it would be significant to show that other compounds of the same metal could work in the nitrogen-fixation experiment. It was also hoped that szRu would be an ideal compound to try since the ruthenium is already in a reduced state, but szRu gave only negative results in the nitrogen-fixation experiment. BIBLIOGRAPHY 10. 11. 12. BIBLIOGRAPHY A. N. Nesmeyanov, O. V. Nogina, and A. M. Berlin, Dokl. Akad. Nauk. SSSR, 134, 607 (1960). A. N. Nesmeyanov, E. I. Fedin, P. V. Petrovskii, V. A. Dubovitskii, O. V. Nogina, and N. A. Lazareva, Dokl. Akad. Nauk. SSSR, lg; (3), 659 (1965). "" G. G. Dvoryantseva, Y. N. Sheinker, A. N. Nesmeyanov, O. V. Nogina and V. A. Dubovitskii, Dokl.Akad. Nauk. SSSR, 161 (3), 603 (1965). E. M. Brainina, R. Kh. Freidlina, and A. N. Nesmeyanov, Dokl. Akad. Nauk.fl§SSR, 154, 1113 (1964). P. C. Wales and H. Weigold, J. Organometal. Chem., 24, 413 (1970). C. K. Mann in "Electroanalytical Chemistry," Vol. 3, A. J. Bard, Ed., Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, N. Y., 1969, p. 132. H. Lund and J. Bjerrum, Ber. Deut. Chem. Gesell., 64” 210 (1931). H. F. Walton, "Principles and Methods of Chemical Analysis," Prentice Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1964, p. 236. S. Herzog, J. Dehnert, and K. Luhder in "Techniques of Inorganic Chemistry," Vol. III, H. B. Jonassen and A. Weissberger, Eds., Interscience Publishers, New York, N.Y., 1968. D. C. Bradley and W. Wardlaw, J. Chem. Soc., 1951, 280. D. C. Bradley, C. G. Barraclough, J. Lewis, and I. M. Thomas, J. Chem. Soc., 1961, 2601. C. T. Lynch, K. S. Mazdiyasni, J. S. Smith, and W. J. Crawford, Anal. Chem., §§'(12), 2332 (1964). 68 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 69 R. S. P. Coutts, J. R. Surtees, J. M. Swan, and P. C. Wales, Aust. J. Chem., 18, 1377 (1966). B. Timm, Chem. Ind. (London), 1960, 274. M. E. Vol'pin and V. B. Shur, Nature, 888, 1236 (1966), H. Brintzinger, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 88, 4307 (1966). H. Brintzinger, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 88, 6871 (1967). E. E. van Tamelen and M. A. Schwartz, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 81, 3277 (1965). E. E. van Tamelen, G. Boche, and R. Greeley, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 88, 1677 (1968). E. E. van Tamelen, G. Boche, S. W. Ela, and R. B. Fechter, J. Am. Chem.y§oc., 88, 5707 (1967). E. E. van Tamelen and B. Akermark, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 88, 4492 (1968). E. E. van Tamelen and D. Seeley, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 88, 5194 (1969), E. E. van Tamelen, R. B. Fechter, S. W. Schneller, G. Boche, R. H. Greeley, and B. Akermark, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 8;, 1551 (1969). E. E. van Tamelen, D. Seeley, S. Schneller, H. Rudler, and W. Cretney, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 88, 5251 (1970). G. Henrici-Olivé and S. Olivé, Angew. Chem., 81, 679 (1969). A. D. Allen and C. V. Senoff, Chem. Commun., 621 (1965). J. P. Collman, M. Kubota, F. D. Vastine, J. Y. Sun, and J. w. Kang, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 22.1 5430 (1968). A. Sacco and M. Rossi, gporganica Chimica Acta, 8, 127 (1968). H. Scheidegger, J. N. Armor, and H. Taube, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 88, 3263 (1968). T. P. Whaley in "Inorganic Syntheses," Vol. V, T. Moeller, Ed., McGraw—Hill Book Company, New York, N.Y., 1957, pp 6r10. D. Paul Rillema, Ph.D. Thesis, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, 1969. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 70 R. Pribil and M. Malat in "Gravimetric Analysis," Part II, L. Erdey, Ed., Pergamon Press, New York, N.Y., 1965, p 540. G. Wilkinson and J. M. Birmingham, J. Am. Chem. Soc., Z8, 4281 (1954). J. C. Brantley, U. S. Patent 2,921,948 (1960); Chem. Abstr., g2, 11048i. . ' F. A. Cotton and G. Wilkinson, Z. Naturforsch, 88, 417 (1954). M. L. H. Green, J. A. McCleverty, L. Pratt, and G. Wilkinson, J. Chem. Soc., 280 (1951). M. H. Green, University of Oxford, private communica- tion, 1969. R. S. P. Coutts, J. R. Surtees, J. M. Swan, and P. C. Wales, Aust. J. Chem., 18, 1377 (1966). D. R. Gray and C. H. Brubaker, Jr., Chem. Commun., 1239 (1969). 3’ r. .21.... Jul lu IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII lHllmlfllLIIWWIH 06