OVERDUE FINES ARE 25¢ PER DAY PER ITEM Return to book drop to remove this checkout from your record. HATER DISTRIBUTION, AVAILABILITY AND PROBLEMS IN JEDDAH CITY, SAUDI ARABIA: A HOUSEHOLD SURVEY By Abdulaziz Sagr Al-Ghamdi A THESIS Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfiliment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS Department of Geography 1979 ABSTRACT WATER DISTRIBUTION, AVAILABILITY AND PROBLEMS IN JEDDAH CITY, SAUDI ARABIA: A HOUSEHOLD SURVEY By Abdulaziz Sagr Al-Ghamdi Jeddah is a rapidly growing major city in the Southwest and Western Region of Saudi Arabia. The raoid growth is not accompanied by comparable growth in essential public services such as an available water supply. The purpose of this study is to examine the perceptions of the residents regarding the water problems in the city. A survey was conducted of 500 residents throughout the city. The interviews were focused on five important factors: l) water accessibility by districts, 2) water accessibility by type of house, 3) income and type of house by sources of water, 4) water uses by type of house, and 5) the reception of water from the network as influenced by construc- tion work going on in the city. The data were analyzed using chi-square, a series of analyses to identify if there were significant differences in the sources, types of uses, and types of housing. The results demonstrated that there are water problems in the city; that old districts have greater access 1 Abdulaziz Sagr Al-Ghamdi to water from the network than the new districts, that most high income people living in villas and apartments received water from the network while most people living in traditional houses and shacks do not receive from network, that people living in villas have gar- dens and use water from the network to irrigate the gardens whereas those in traditional houses and shacks use water only for domestic use, and that public constructions frequently impedes water recep- tion from the network. Water problems in the city can be attributed to three factors: (l) insufficient water from the existing natural resources to meet increasing demands, (2) lack of proper planning for the distribu- tion of water, and (3) misuse of water for non-domestic purposes at home and in the city. On the basis of these results a series of recommendations are offered to resolve the problems identified. DEDICATED To my mother Who is looking forward to seeing me in the near future to live with her in the holy places. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author would like to express his deepest gratitude to the chairman of the Author's Committee and major advisor, Professor Stanley D. Brunn, for his guidance, comments, and encouragement. The author is indebted to Professor Ian M. Matley and Professor Jay R. Harman for their comments and suggestions. The author would like to thank King Abdulaziz University for their financial support. Also those in governmental office who were contacted by the author. Finally, to those friends who were behind the author in doing his research, his best wishes for them. TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF TABLES ......................... vii LIST OF FIGURES ......................... viii Chapter I. INTRODUCTION ...................... l FOCUS OF THE STUDY ................. l STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM .............. 5 OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY ............... 6 ENVIRONMENTAL PERCEPTION .............. 6 ORGANIZATION OF THE STUDY .............. 9 II. THE ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL GEOGRAPHY OF JEDDAH CITY . . . . l0 SITE AND SITUATION ................. lO ECONOMIC FUNCTIONS ................. l4 INTERNAL LAND USES ................. l7 RECENT POPULATION GROWTH .............. 21 URBAN PROBLEMS ................... 26 iv TABLE OF CONTENTS (Cont'd) Chapter Page III. HATER SYSTEM IN JEDDAH CITY ............... 28 HISTORIC BACKGROUND ................. 28 CURRENT WATER RESOURCES ............... 30 Wadi Fatima ................... 32 Wadi Khlais ................... 34 The Deslainization Plant ............. 37 THE EXISTING AND PROPOSED WATER NETWORK ....... 39 THE MANAGEMENT OF WATER SYSTEM ............ 42 WATER USES AND PRICE ................. 45 IV. HYPOTHESES AND METHODS OF ANALYSIS ............ 53 HYPOTHESES ...................... 53 METHODS OF ANALYSIS ................. 56 V. ANALYSIS OF PERCEPTION REGARDING WATER SUPPLY PROBLEMS. . 61 WATER ACCESSIBILITY AND AGE OF DISTRICTS ....... 52 WATER SHORTAGE AND TYPE OF HOUSING .......... 68 INCOME, HOUSING, AND SOURCES OF WATER ........ 73 TYPE OF HOUSE AND WATER USE .......... ‘ . . . 77 WATER AVAILABILITY AND THE IMPACT OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS ..................... 80 TABLE OF CONTENTS (Cont'd) Chapter Page VI. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS .............. 85 CONCLUSIONS ..................... 85 RECOMMENDATIONS ................... 87 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................ 9l APPENDIX ............................. 96 vi Table 10. ll. LIST OF TABLES ASSOCIATION OF ATTITUDES TOWARD WATER SHORTAGE AND TYPE OF DISTRICT ................ DISTRICTS WITH WATER SOURCES .............. ASSOCIATION OF ATTITUDES TOWARD WATER SHORTAGE BY TYPE OF HOUSE .............. ASSOCIATION BETWEEN SOURCES OF WATER AND TYPE OF HOUSE. . . . . . . . . . . ......... THE INCOME AND TYPE OF HOUSE .............. ASSOCIATION BETWEEN TYPES OF HOUSES AND PRESENCE OF GARDENS ................. WATER USES AND TYPE OF HOUSE .............. NETWORKS PROBLEMS AND PEOPLE WHO RECEIVE WATER FROM THE NETWORK ............... PUBLIC CONSTRUCTION WORKS AND PEOPLE WHO RECEIVE WATER FROM THE NETWORK ............... vii 63 66 69 71 74 78 80 82 83 LIST OF FIGURES .EJ’SEEE I. General geological map of Saudi Arabia ......... 2. Saudi Arabia location map ................ 3. Jeddah climatic condition 1966-l976 ........... 4. Jeddah influence in the western and southwestern regions of Saudi Arabia ............... 5. The growth of Jeddah .................. 6. Population growth forecasts 197l-1991 .......... 7. POpUlation growth of Jeddah: l933-l978 ......... 8. Jeddah water district .................. 9. Indicative water balance for Wadi Fatima ........ lO. Indicative water balance for Wadi Khlais ........ ll. Summary of current operations aNd projects up to l983 for Jeddah city Desalinization Plant ..... l2. Jeddah water supply distribution net: Main distribution net plan .............. l3. Jeddah water supply distribution net: Fourth stage layout plan ............... 14. Percentage of water consumption in 197l ......... l5. The population growth and urban water demand 197l-l99l ................... viii Page 4 ll 13 IS 18 22 23 31 33 36 38 41 43 47 48 LIST OF FIGURES (Cont'd) E13123 T6. The daily water consumption l97l—l99l ......... 17. Type of water sources ................. 18. District boundaries .................. 19. Type of houses ..................... 20. Perception of water problems in new and Old districts .................. 21. Sources of water by district .............. 22. Perception of water shortages by type of housing ................... 23. Sources of water by type of housing .......... 24. Income by type of housing ............... 25. Household income and sources of water ......... 26. Types of housing with gardens ............. 27. Uses of water for drinking and irrigation by type of housing ................... ix Page 49 50 57 59 64 67 7O 72 75 76 79 81 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION FOCUS OF THE STUDY The importance Of water resources to society and to government is not diminished today. Our complex, metrOpOlitan civilization and advanced technologies have generated new demands for water.'I Water is a fundamental need for human survival. The growth of urbanization world wide presupposes there is sufficient amount of water to meet the needs for development. Unfortunately there is often not enough water at the right places at the right time. The lack of an adequate water supply for any area can cause severe problems for the many and varied agricultural, industrial, and domestic uses, and for the public services sector as well. As the urban population of a country increases in numbers and area, and the industrial sectors as well, the need for a number of natural resources correspondingly increases with the greatest increase being water.2 The existence of 1Henry M. Jackson, "Foreward," in H. G. Deming, Water, the Foundation of Opportunity (New York: Oxford University Press, 1975), p. v. 2Lawrence M. Sommers, "Man-Water Relationship Research and the Application of the Geographic Approach, "Harold A. Winters and Marjorie Winters, eds., Applications of Geographic Research (East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University, 1977), p. 89. l water is one of the main factors in the city's existence. The quality and quantity Of water available are both important in the social politi- cal and economic life of urban areas.3 In 1963 a survey on the water conditions in seventy-five devel- Oping countries, with a tota1 population of about 1.3 billion, was conducted by the World Health Organization. It established that only one-third of the city dwellers and less than one- tenth Of the rural population had water faucets and pipes. Two-fifths of the urbanites and almost three- fourths Of the entire pOpulation were without regular water supply.4 Another survey also conducted by World Health Organization in 1975 looked at community drinking water supplies in developing countries. It included about 90 percent of the total pOpulation of developing world; China was not included. The survey indicated that about 144 million people or about 23 percent Of the urban population in these developing countries and about 1.1 billion people or 78 percent of the rural population did not have the reasonable access to water supplies as of 1975.5 3Melvin G. Marcus and Thomas R. Detwyler, eds., Urbanization and Environment: The Physical Geography of the City (Belmont, CA: Duxbury Press, 19727, p. 17. 4Georg Borgstrom, Too Mapy, An Ecological Overview of Earth's Limitations (New York: Collier Books, 19711} p. 181. For further discussion see World Hea1th Organization, Urban Water Supply Condi- tions and Needs in Seventy-Five Developipg_Countries, Geneva, 1963. 5United Nations Water Conference, "Meeting Domestic Water Requirements of Developing Countries,“ Mar del Plata, Argentina, 1977, p. 3. Saudi Arabia is one of the developing countries facing these water problems. It occupies an area covering about 2.2 million square kilometers.6 While it is one of the largest arid nations in the Middle East.7 It is also one of the largest countries in the world without a river. The mean precipitation for the entire country is only about 50 mm per year.8 Because the rainfall is insufficient to meet the demand for water for residential, agricultural, commercial, and indus- trial uses, the ground water resources of Saudi Arabia are of great importance for agriculture. Two-thirds of the country is underlain by sedimentary formations mostly of sand- stones, 1imestones, shales, marls, and alluvium; and these are the main resources of ground water.9 The geologic structure of the country is depicted on Figure 1. Rapid population growth due to both extensive rural-urban migration and a high rate Of natural increase has made the water crisis a critical problem in urban areas of the country. At the same time, water demands in urban areas are increasing due to constant improvements in the liv- ing standards, economic status, level of education, and social life of 6Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Agriculture and Water, Seven Green Spikes, prepared by Abdul Basset El-Khateb, (Beirut: Dar al-Qalam Press Co., 1974), p. 3. 7Peter Beatumont, "Water and Development in Saudi Arabia," Geographical Journal, Vol. 143, March 1977, p. 1. 811311., p. 2. 9Seven Green Spikes, op. cit., p. 6. gnawed” ”mum O hugtok ummmmnm . 08098.3 0 Est-non 283.3. 2.3:... 2.35.. 389220 2393...“. 23.6 .o 2.332 ozq 2038 do :6 8m»/. .\.(.. Immvflwoflex< row. . .- 1‘ 12 humidity was about 94 percent with the mean average relative humidity about 70 percent monthly.2 The mean daily maximum temperature is about 36°C in the summer and mean daily minimum temperature about 19°C. The annual average temperature is about 27.5°C. The highest tempera- tures and the relative humidities bother the inhabitants in the summer; sometimes the summer winds carry dust which causes a great deal of inconvenience. The temperature goes down in the night and there is less relative humidity. Rainfall is highly unpredictable. Most of the time there is no rain for months; sometimes there is none for years. When rain comes, it comes heavily and quickly bringing havoc and discomfort to the people and to businesses.3 Most of the rain falls in November, December, and January. There is practically no rain most of the sum- mer months. The average rainfall is about 50 mm. The graphs in Figure 3 for humidity, temperature, and rainfall provide a clear picture of the climate in Jeddah. 2Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Defense, Meteorology Department. Mean Monthlnglimate Data for Jeddah City 1966-1976, Jeddah Station, p. 1. 3Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Interior, Municipal Affairs, Regional and Town Planning Department, Western Region Plan, Alter- native Urban Strategies, Jeddah, 1972, p. 23. 13 JEDDAH CLIMATIC CONDITION (FIGURE 3) l966 - l976 30 E 25 ..E. ... 2o ‘. e . I“ c ‘ t ‘\ - 15 i E . . . ‘5! ' ‘\ s 5 x. - 2 I“ ,‘-"-.~‘ I! 5 o 1' ‘ *n-O-IIDO—MFJ g Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May June July Aug Sept. Oct. (Nov. Dec. 60 50 4O 30 20 10 0 Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. Mean Monthly Temperature (c) 120 100 80 60 4O 20 Mean Monthly Relative Humidity 0 Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. Seine: Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Mean Monthly Climatic Data For Judah City lOOO-IOTG Ministry 0' Dafanu, Mat. Dept. June July Aug. Nov. Dec. Oct. Nov. Dec. Mean Moon Moon Moon Mean Maximum Minimum Maximum Minimum 14 ECONOMIC‘FUNCTIONS In 1945 a study by Harris and Ullman Offered various explana- tions for the nature of cities.4 The authors stated that cities per- fOrm various functions for society. Three of the important functions cities perform include providing comprehensive services, transporta- tion, and Specialized services. Harris and Ullman categorized the first group of cities as central places because they perform comprehensive services to the surrounding areas. The second group of cities are based on transportation. These transport cities perform break-of—bulk and allied services along transport routes. The third group Of cities perform specialized functions such as mining and manufacturing, or services such as recreation for large areas including general tributary areas of nearby cities. Most cities, according to Harris and Ullman, represent a com- bination of these three types of functions with the relative importance of each factor varying from city to city. Such is the case of Jeddah city as it provides comprehensive services as an important trade center for Saudi Arabia. It also has the main international airport in the Southwest and Western regions of the country and is the main industrial and manufacturing center for these same regions (Figure 4). ‘4Chauncy Harris and Edward Ullman, "The Nature of Cities," Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol. 242 (November 1945), pp. 7-17. . . . d 000 . . u...’ q - OOH 8N H 4 00¢ 00. 0 820622 d 1 4 W q 8' 80 SN 00. 0 «so. ...-3.. I. 83228 .. ... 8.5 2:88.: .322 .835: \l\ a... 8.8.... 3 ...-...! .332 Clo . . . e mam... :2 .212 .38 x 8.2 ... ...-8.... .33. .. x 205mm 5.383528 D n uuuuuu I 20.6mm 2mmhmu3 ozwomn. \ . ...u I I .. .... s I ... .... . . . . ....n .r .u.... . .. ......" .. . .. . Q . .m”. awn... . ...-I...” . $9 .... . ...... o... . .....u... .....n. ..... . §¢QY... .. .. . ...u.\ . .... .. . *V .m...... .. can. icon] no 20.0mm 2mmhmw31h30m 024 zmwhmmg MI... 2. wozwDsz. Tacoma _ _ 00». as b I I) l I l I (5414 andm 0°“ 1 310.com tloifl h 62...... i so flu: J / 16 The strategic site of the city of Jeddah on the shore of the Red Sea gives it prominence as an important situation in the country's Southwest and Western regions, a situation that has been essential in accounting for its growth.5 Jeddah city dominates the Southwest and Western regions in the following four ways.6 First, it contains the most varied concentration of economic services. With the main port and airport it dominates the export and import trade; the city accounts for about half of the country's total trade. Second, the comprehensive services such as the commercial, financial, and wholesale are concen- trated in Jeddah more than in any other city in these two regions. Third, Jeddah has the largest concentration of the manufacturing establishments and the largest Red Sea Port. Most of the capital invest- ment and work force in manufacturing are located here. Fourth, Jeddah is the gateway to the holy place of Mecca. Every year thousands of devout muslim pilgrims from all over the world make their pilgrimage to Mecca by land, sea, and air. During this period the streets and shaps in Jeddah are crowded because it is the main transit point for most of the pilgrims. Thus a combination of commercial, industrial, and other service functions make Jeddah the most important city in the 5For further discussion of site and situation see Dean S. Rugg, Spatial Foundations of Urbanism (Dubuque, IA: Wm. C. Brown Company, 1972), pp. 79-98. 6Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Interior, Municipal Affairs, Regional and Town Planning Department, Western Region Plan, Master Plan Report for Jeddah, 1972, p. 13. 17 country's Southwest and Western Regions, and one of the most impor; tant cities contributing to the country's total economic development. INTERNAL LAND USES Three theories have been developed concerning the internal structure of cities.7 The concentric zone theory states that the pattern of growth of the city takes place from its central area and Spreads outwards in a concentric pattern. Five concentric zones have been identified in this theory developed by Burgess. The second theory, the sector theory, developed by Hoyt, states that the growth takes place out from the core of the city along major routes of transportation. The third theory used to explain urban growth is the multiple nuclei theory developed by Harris and Ullman. It postulates that the land use pattern in many cities is built not around a single center but around many discrete nuclei. Of these three theories, the sector theory appears to be the most applicable in explaining the existing land uses and historic growth of Jeddah city. The city stretches outward in two main direc- tions, the north and east, where they are along the main transport routes linking the city to Medina and Mecca (Figure 5). Before 1948 Jeddah was a small town surrounded by walls; it served as the port of 7Harris and Ullman, Op. cit. J 18 THE GROWTH OF JEDDAH (FIGURE 5) L-E_GE.NQ 350 BC- 1950 1850 - 1946 P 1946 - 1952 1952 -1956 1956 - 1964 1964 - 1971 19 entry for the pilgrims who arrived by sea. Beginning in the 19605, the town began to grow gradually with new dwellers residing in eastern and southern sections outside the walls. More recently the built-up area extended with the addition of the airport and larger harbor facilities and with more streets being laid out.8 The city area has been expand- ing very rapidly since 1970. In terms of land uses, most of the city's commercial activities are located in the central business district. The areas surrounding the CBD provide most of the retail services such as food, construction materials, domestic goods, banks, travel agencies and hotels. Pepple in the medium income bracket live here. The southern part of the city is where most of the low income residents live. This quarter is growing relatively slowly economi- cally because it is mainly a slum area that experiences high levels of industrial pollution because of the petroleum refinery. It is also spatially disorganized in terms of the planning of streets, the designs of houses, the spacing between houses, and in providing public utili- ties. Land values in this quarter are low compared to other districts. Land uses in the eastern part of the city are oriented along Mecca Road. The land values are high. Government and company offices, car dealers, car services, supermarkets, departmental stores, some 8Master Plan Report for Jeddah, op. cit., p. 13. 20 industrial plants and mixed residential areas are fOund in this part of the city. Economic and population growth in this quarter is rapid. Urban expansion to the North is more rapid than elsewhere. The existence of Medina Road is very critical to the rapid growth. This sector is a mixture Of residential, conmercial, and industrial activi- ties. Most Of the recent developments including high income residen- tial villa, foreign embassies, company offices, and several industrial plants have taken place in this sector since 1970. About twenty-five miles along the Medina Road to the north of the central area, a new airport is under construction. The new airport will be one Of the lar- gest in the country and will relieve the heavy pressure on the old airport during the months when thousands of pilgrims arrive from all over the world. This northern sector has experienced better planning for human services than the other sectors described. Housing construction is expanding rapidly north and east of the city, however, this has not been accompanied by good comprehensive plan- ning that is designed to meet other needs facing the city. Successful integrated city planning should attempt to provide the inhabitants with essential utilities such as a water supply, electricity, a sewage system, transportation, good public health, and recreation facilities. Currently only some of these essential utilities are available within the city. Where many of these services are available, there is often a lack in proper organization and delivery to all districts and to the total 21 population. Ineffective administration could be tied to poor planning in the past and to the lack of experience necessary to provide good planning. RECENT POPULATION GROWTH Jeddah has experienced a high growth rate in population over the last two decades. This trend is likely to continue from a base population Of 381,000 in 1971 to an estimated population of between 800,000 and 1.65 million by 1991 (Figure 6). These projections are included in a report on the master plan for the city prepared by the Regional and Town Planning Department.9 There are not accurate available data about the city's pOpula- tion. The lack of a census from a long time has meant that estimates have to be used. In a history of Jeddah city, one author included some data about the population in Jeddah that were collected from a variety of sources.10 However, all data are just estimates (Figure 7). The last two population estimates cited in government reports are 381,000 in 1971,11 and about 561,000 in 1974.12 Most of the government planning 91bid., p. 41. 10Abdul Gaddous Al-Ansari, History of Jeddah (Jeddah: Dar Al-Asafehani, 1963), pp. 87-94. 1]Master Plan Report for Jeddah, Op. cit., p. 41. 12Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Education, Data Center, Some Indica- tions of Saudi Arabia First Population Census 1974, Riyadh, 1976, p. 9. 20 22 mafia 969111 Ion em atianl Population by 100,000'5 O I97I7273747576777879808|82838485868788899091 POPULATION GROWTH FORECASTS l97l-l991 (FIGURE 6) Sacco: Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Mootor Plan Report - Juan Iiaiatry at interior, Municipal Mtaira, l9?! High Estimate Loo Estimate T-- Population 1971 f 23 aoo fla— . 1' 750 7 I, 700 I I 650 # I 600 ! 550 450 ‘I 500 I l l IN THOUSANDS 400 d 350 300 / 250 / 200 150 ’4 J POPULATION 100 C .F’fi A 50 .—-——r /‘/r‘ / ' O 1930 1935 1940 1945 1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 POPULATION GROWTH OF JEDDAHI 1933 - 1978 (FIGURE 7) Sana: I. Al-Anoarl, A. Notary of Jo“, 1003 2. Soot Arum, Ministry at lntorior, Wat Alton, Mootor Plan Roan tor m, 1072 3. Saudi halo, Wyatt-notion, Data Cantor. Sauna It Saudi Arabian trot oaoolatlon onto-1o oroooroa in ma, Rina. 1m 4. From 1.73-1.70 in on ootinattan 24 agencies estimate the 1978 population for Jeddah to be 800,000. Recent population growth can be explained by five major reasons. First, there is increased immigration from the rural areas to the city of Jeddah because of the greater Opportunities for employment and better benefits than on the farm. In the city there are Oppor- tunities for work and study, more money is also available than in the rural areas. Most of the young people who migrated from the rural areas return to their villages for summer. Second, most of the largest national and international com- panies and firms locate in Jeddah because it has the main airport, harbor, and is the focus of commercial activity in the Southwest and Western Regions. It is also the main city for commercial contacts with North and East Africa and other Middle East countries. Third, Jeddah is occupied by an increasing number of non-Saudis. In 1961 about 35 percent of Jeddah population was non-Saudi.13 Accord- ing to a survey undertaken by the Regional and Town Planning Department in 1971-72, about 88 percent of families sampled were born outside Jeddah and of these 29 percent came to Jeddah within the last five years before the survey.M Of this 88 percent, about 60 percent were born outside Saudi Arabia. About 58 percent of the 29 percent who arrived in Jeddah within the last five years prior to the survey were living in 13Abdu1 Gaddous Al-Ansari, op. cit., p. 93. 14Alternative Urban Strategies, Op. cit., pp. 71 and 74. 25 foreign countries. About 42 percent of total sample did not report Saudi citizenship. Finally, about 53 percent of Jeddah's population cOnsists of non-Saudians. The estimate of non-Saudians at present is between 55-60 percent. Most come from the Arab countries of North Yemen, South Yemen, Egypt, Sudan, Lebanon, Palestine and from non-Arab countries including Nigeria, India, Pakistan, South Korea, West Germany, Great Britian, and United States. The concentration of these people is found in Jeddah because of the availability Of employment, proximity to for- eign agencies, and easy accessibility of other cities and villages in the country to Jeddah. Most of the population from WeStern countries live in villas and apartments along Medina Road. The Yemenis, Egyp- tians, and Pakistanis live in traditional houses in the central area and Nuzla districts. Other nationalities live throughout the city. Most Of the black population from Africa live in shacks in south Nuzla district. The fourth reason for recent urban growth is attributed to the current five year plan (1975-1980) which is associated with a high rate of inflation. Land values have become more expensive. Obtaining a government loan for hoUsing or an industrial project is possible for those who can raise about 30 percent of the capital. Hundreds of villas and apartments have been built; also many industrial plants have been established according to this plan. This has increased the demand on the labor force from outside Jeddah, within Saudi Arabia, and other 26 countries. Most people work in the construction industry, in various offices and companies, and for the government. A fifth and final reason that accounts for rapid growth in the city is the flexible visa regulations which encourage non-Saudis to enter the country. Many from neighboring Islamic countries have come to Jeddah on the pretense of visiting the holy places only to remain indefinitely. Some decide not to return to their native countries. It is difficult to keep track of these people for lack of an effective immigration checking system that provides accurate addressess. These are among the main reasons for the tremendous pOpulation increase in Jeddah; all contribute to a number of problems. URBAN PROBLEMS The current rapid population increase and anticipated growth are the basis for a number of problems facing Jeddah. Many problems are the result of insufficient planning and the absence Of comprehen- sive coordinated planning schemes. Among the problems are increasing air pollution, a noisy airport, too many traffic accidents, poor health care services, lack of recreation facilities, insufficient parking lots and public facilities, and a sound water system. One of the major environmental problems facing the city is lack of a sufficient water supply. This has increased particularly within the.1ast five years. chapters. 27 It is examined in some detail in the following CHAPTER III WATER SYSTEM IN JEDDAH CITY In this chapter six tOpics related to the city's water system are discussed: (1) an historic background to the city's water prob- lems, (2) the three currently available water resources, (3) the existing and prOposed water network, (4) the management of water supply, and (5) water uses and prices. HISTORIC BACKGROUND Most of the early travelers described Jeddah as the "thirsty city." They described the water crisis and how residents used cisterns and pits to collect rain water.1 All of the regimes which have gov- erned the city through its history have tried to solve the problem of insufficient water by transporting water from any district where there was a surplus. In 1517 the Ottoman state governed the Hijaz, the district where Jeddah is located.2 The Ottoman Sultan supplied the city with 1Saudi Arabia, Saline Water Conversion Corporation Projects, Water Unlimited (Napoli, Italy: Falcon Press, n. d.), p. l. 2Abdul Gaddous Al-Ansari, History of Aziziah Water Supply in Jeddah (Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, n. p.), 1972, p. 43. 28 29 water from the springs of Waziriyah, a site about 6.8 miles east of Jeddah in the direction of Mecca.3 These springs depended on rainfall which when it came provided sufficient water. However, when there was no rainfall, there was a water shortage. As described earlier, rains in and around Jeddah are irregular and these springs failed to meet the growing demands of water that the city needed. TO meet the deficit in water resources, in 1907 the Ottoman government decided to import dis- tillation machines from EurOpe.4 Though the distillation machine was performing commensurate with the city's water demands, the machine itself performed irregularly. During the 1924-25 Saudi Hashemite War, the coal supply, used to operate the distillation machines, was cut off.5 This resulted in wood being used as a substitute to distill the water. But wood damaged the distillation machines. After this war the Saudi government tried in vain to repair the machines so that they could resume the increasing water supply demand by the city, especially for the large number of pilgrims arriving during the pilgrimage season. However, the damage proved irreparable. Finally in 1927 the government imported two new machines from Europe to distill water and meet the needs of the city.6 Ibid., p. 44. 30 In 1942 the Saudi government invited a technical mission from the United States to study the water situation with the aim of improv- ing the water supply.7 The mission reported there was a possibility to supply Jeddah with water from Wadi Fatima located about 34 miles east of the city. The government started the Operation and by 1947 the project was successfully completed. Later, in 1967, another new resource called Wadi Khlais, about 70 miles to the north Of Jeddah, was also tapped to supply water to the city.8 In the early 19705 the desalinization plants, which are discussed more fully below, provided a good part of the city's water supply. CURRENT WATER RESOURCES Presently Jeddah receives its water supply from three different sources (Figure 8). They are from Wadi Fatima located about 30 miles east of Jeddah, (2) from Wadi Khlais located about 70 miles north, and (3) a desalinization plant Site in the northwest part of the city of Jeddah at Kubbat Asherah. Each of these sources needs to be discussed further. 71bid., p. 53. 81bid., pp. 213-16. 31 JEDDAH WATER DISTRICT [FIGURE 81 Source: Saudi Arabia Miniotry at interior, Municipal Aitoiro, 1972 0 5 101520 ocala kliomator sun/- Wadl E] Cultivation Highland 32 Wadi Fatima This wadi covers an area of about 4,500 square kilometers.9 Most of the storage areas are alluvial. There are actually two wadis here, an upper and a lower one, with the upper wadi supplying water to Mecca and the lower one to Jeddah. According to data released in 1971-72 (Figure 9), the exact amount of water storage in the upper wadi is unknown, but it is insufficient to meet the needs Of Mecca (5.6 Mm3) and for irrigation and rural population (2.3 Mm3).* However, the pic- ture is not that encouraging in the lower wadi as the storage level is 3 in 1967-68 to 263 Mm3 in 1972). gradually declining (315 Mm Observations of the water table in the lower wadi reveal that the average decline in the ground water is about 70 mm per month. About 10 Mm3 of water available in the lower wadi goes to Jeddah and another 17 Mm3 goes for irrigation and rural needs every year. The declining water table poses a special problem for Jeddah. Currently there are fifty wells and three springs that supply 16-20 million gal- 10 lons daily, the actual amount that arrives in Jeddah city is about 10 9Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Interior, Municipal Affairs, Western Region Plan, Immediate Action Studies Report, Vol. 3, Water, Jeddah, February 1972, pp. 23-24. 1OInterview with Mr. Mohammed M. Al-Harbi, the Supervisor of the Geologists in Jeddah, The Branch Office of Ministry of Agriculture and Water in Jeddah, March 1978. * Mm3 = Million cubic meters per year. ...... 8.82.6 .28. «so. 5.32 .8323: :25... .6 53...... .324 a...» .838 Am Nanci. 42:4“... 54.5 3.. uoz<4_._._._.- II :1 I 4 35 ,5 350 o I I ‘5 " _I {I I" _I , l- “ é o 25 ‘ 250 I' 3 [L o I' In 20 } 2002 (D I Z ,I 9 III .J - =I IS / I50 2 ,1 I I0 ’J’ IOO ’ava""I b"”" 5%" so 0 o I9707I 72 73 74 75 76 77 7e 79 so 8| 82 83 e4 85 86 87 ’L r At f 11 1 1‘ PHASE I PHASE 2 PHASE 3 PHASE 4 SUMMARY OF CURRENT OPERATIONS AND PROJECTS UP TO l983 FOR JEDDAH CITY DESALINATION PLANT (FIGURE ll) Source: Saudi Arabia Saline Voter Conversion Com, Vow Unlimited 39 Work on Phase 1 began in 1970 with production of 5 million gal- lons daily and production of 50,000 megawatts of electricity. Phase 2 started in 1970 with production anticipated in 1977. However, the expected actual production has been pushed back and was scheduled to begin in summer l978. It is expected to yield about l0 million gal- lons daily and 84,000 megawatts of electricity. Phase 3 started in 1976 and once completed in 1980 will yield 20 million gallons daily and 200,000 megawatts of electricity. Phase 4 is scheduled to begin in 1980. It will provide about 50 million gallons daily and 500,000 megawatts of electricity by l983. Through the desalinization of sea water, Saudi Arabia hopes to meet satisfactorily the demands of Jeddah city for fresh water and electricity by eventually providing 85 million gallons of water daily and 850,000 megawatts of electricity. It should be mentioned that at present the desalinization plant does not provide the city with water it is capable of yielding. THE EXISTING AND PROPOSED WATER NETWORK The old network of the city's water supply covered most of the old districts like Central Area, Ruwais, and Nuzla. In l967 and again in May.1969 VATTEN BYGGNADA BYRAN Company (VBB), a Swedish company, submitted reports and proposals to the Ministry of Agriculture and 40 Water regarding the water system and the distribution network in the city.18 There are five stages in the operation of the existing Network that merit discussion. The first and second stages include extended pumping stations and reservoirs at Medina Road Kilo 8. At the same time they distribute via the main network pipes water from the desalinization plants on the Red Sea shore; also water is pumped to the Medina Road Kilo 8 reser- voir. At this main reservoir these two waters are mixed and treated and then pumped to the central areas of Jeddah city through the main network. To raise the water pressure in the southeastern side of the city there are booster stations at Mecca Road Kilo 5. These two stages were completed in 1973.19 The third stage comprises the house connections for the devel- Oped parts of the city like the Central area, the harbor, Ruwais and some parts of Nuzla district. A water tower with an effective volume of 13,500 cubic meters is to be erected at the Palace Gardens near Sea- port Road. Work on the erection of this tower started in 1974 and is almost completed. (Figure 12).20 18Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Agriculture and Water, Jeddah Water Supply, Further Extension, VBB, Jeddah, January 1973, p. 2. 191bid., p. 2. 20Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Agriculture and Water, Jeddah Water Tower, Jeddah, n. d., p. l. . E cocoon. u-_I_Qn5m mug-<3 Tacoma cg unhi’ Du: ugng 44 It took care of the water supply to the city and its own management until about 1970. In 1965 the Ministry of Agriculture and Water started the desalinization project in the city of Jeddah.25 This ministry signed a contract with the Swedish company referred to above, VATTEN BYGGNADA BYRAN (VBB), some time after 1965.26 V88 is responsible for the water distribution network system, pumping stations, reservoirs and have connections.27 Another company, Saudi Arabian BLOKAT, also takes care of the operation and maintenance of Jeddah water works.28 Both VBB and BLOKAT are under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Agriculture and Water, which has its branch office in Jeddah. The branch office has supervising authority over these two companies and represents the Ministry in the Western Region. In 1971 the total amount of water delivered by the two wadis and the desalinization plant to the city of Jeddah was estimated to be 20 Mm3 gallons a year (Table l).29 In the same year the consumption of the 20 Mm3 gallons can be divided into four categories: 1) essential 25Water Unlimited, op. cit., p. 7. 26Seven Green Spikes, op, cit., pp. l97-207. 27Ibid. ZBSaudi Arabia, Ministry of Agriculture and Water, Saudi Arabian BLOKAT, Operation and Maintenance of Jeddah Water Works, Jeddah, January, 1978, p. 1. 29Master Plan Report for Jeddah, op. cit., p. 160. 45 or domestic urban, 2) municipal, industrial, harbor, etc., 3) garden- ing, and 4) network losses (Table 2).30 The amount of water consumed in Jeddah city in 1971 for the population of 38l,000 for various uses is shown in Figure 14. Based on current water usage the Ministry of Interior, Municipal Affairs Division, projected both the low and high population growths and low and high water supply needs to l99l (Figure 15). Figure l6 shows the consumption per day in l97l and estimates the demands to 1991. Residents in the city of Jeddah obtain water from five different sources: (1) their home is connected directly via pipelines to the water work, (2) they purchase water from long water trucks (tanks), (3) small donkey pulled water carts, and (4) water peddlers who carry water in large buckets and tins, or (5) they carry their own water from the public standpipes. The scenes depicted in Figure 17 are common in Jeddah. WATER USES AND PRICE Water uses can be divided into three categories: domestic, commercial, and irrigation uses. Domestic uses cover cooking, washing clothes, and cleaning the houses. People who live in villas wash the floors of the houses and stairs about once a week. In the summer season ' 46 TABLE I WATER RESOURCES IN 197I Water Resource Quantity (in gallons) 1. Wadi Fatima 7 MmB/yr 2. Wadi Khlais 7 Mm3/yr 3. Desalinization Plant 6 Mm3/yr TOTAL 20 Mm /yr TABLE 2 CATEGORIES OF WATER CONSUMPTION IN l97l % of Daily per Category of Consumption MmB/yr Total Capita Rate 1. Essential urban ll 55 80 2. Municipal, Industrial, etc. 2 10 14 3. Gardening 5 25 36 4. Network Losses 2 l0 l4 TOTAE --------------- 80- - - - - - T00 ..... 1A4- - - Note: Mid-l97l Papulation about 381,000. Source: Ministry of Interior, Municipal Affairs, Master Plan Report For Jeddah, 1972, pp. 160-l61. 47 «8. .332 .2228: .18.... t :83: 2930.. I .800: not .288 03.3 C...» 3 is... Solon ...:es. 0.. 0030-. 2.0502 Fake... 0 05:00.00 , 25...... ~_ .20 0000.0: .0330... 400.3002 rakes. :— 0005 .22300 2v. mmamfiv Km. 2_ ZO_._.Q§DmZOU mug-SS “.0 MOE-zwumma 48 :WW HBLVM o 9 ON Om oc on ow on Go 00.0. 5.3: 2.0.2.5: :25... t 52...: ‘03.... I .30.: so... 3...! .203 .33 .0 £82.... n22.2.0 Km. 2. 20.0.4425... IIIIII 025200 002; 30.. ........ AD. MKDOEV ......wzflfip fin ............. am. - .5 023.00 0022. 2.2000 0...» 02¢. I._.>>Omo ZOE-4430.00. MI... 29.2 Anton :9: 02000.. .0 00 00 00 ..0 00 00 00 no 00 .0 00 2. 0.. R 0.. 0.. 2. m» 0.. .3. 0 oo. OON 00m 00v com 000 00h coo 00m 0.. ... NOIlV 10d0d :IO ONVSflOHJ. N. n._ Q.- n._ 9. s... won-um 49 340 320 300 280 # "O‘P’ 9‘“ I 1" 260 3» w" 4 240 ’%' l’ ' Y to to o ’V I 3 ,0' I 3200 f n. I/ a J" g I80 ’7’ 3 ’4’ I l60 ’ O; I40 |20 I00 I97I 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 8| 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 9| THE DAILY WATER CONSUMPTION l97l-l99l (FIGURE l6) Source: Kingdom 0' some Arabic loom Pm Rayon - mun Ibis", 00 Interior, flunIproI amm, I972 50 Figure 17: WATER SOURCES 51 most people in Jeddah city consume almost twice the amount of water they do the rest of the year mainly because of the very high temperature and humidity. Commercial use applies to municipal, industrial, harbors and businesses. Since there are pipelines in these places, peOple use fresh water for various purposes when they could actually use some other sources of water. Irrigating gardens is done in most of the villas. Fresh water is used to water these gardens. About 25 per- cent of the total water supply (l97l) was used for such purposes. The price of water from the network is very cheap compared to that of truck prices. The water supply administration in Jeddah has set the legal price of the water carried in a 4,000 gallon truck at about $45.3] PeOple can also purchase water from truckers for much less, but these truckers do not bring the water from the sources which are legal. Obtaining water from illegal sources and private truckers poses many health hazards. A World Bank Report on village water sup- plies states:32 Lack of safe water for drinking and washing is also an important factor in the spread of other diarrheal diseases, which form possibly the most important single disease group throughout the developing world. . . . Numerous other diseases are also linked to poor water supply or sanitary conditions. 31Saudi Arabia, OKAZ Daily Newspaper, Thursday, June 22, l978. p. 5. One Dollar = 3.50 Saudi Riyal. 32 p. 54. World Bank, Village Water Supply, (Washington, D.C., l976), 52 Residents often do not know whether the water purchased is from legal or illegal sources; truckers as well do not realize the diseases carried in water taken from illegal wells. Sometimes the price of illegal water increases to $80 or more per tank in the summer. How residents perceive the existence and seriousness of the water problems facing Jeddah city is the focus of the two chapters. CHAPTER IV HYPOTHESES AND METHODS OF ANALYSIS Chapter 111 provided a brief description of the water system and the accompanying problems in Jeddah city. In this chapter five hypoth- eses regarding the residents' perceptions of water problems and their water uses are postulated. Also, the field methods used to collect the household survey data are discussed as are additional data sources that aid in examining the city's water use. HYPOTHESES The research hypotheses are based on an understanding of both socioeconomic differences within the city and knowledge of the city's water system. They are: Hypothesis 1: That residents in the old districts such as Nuzla, Harbour, Central Area and Ruwais receive water more from the city's network than new districts like those along Mecca Road and Medina Road. 53 54 '3533199glg; The growth in the new district is very rapid. Not adequate attention is given to this rapidly developing new district to construct water network system. Hypothesis 11: That villa residents have greater access to water from the network than people who live in traditional houses or shacks.1 Rationale: It is assumed that villa dwellers have high income, and they can afford to manipulate or influence the agency responsible for water supply to construct the pipeline to their residences, whereas those who dwell in traditional homes and shacks receive low income and do not have such influence to enjoy the privileges of a pipeline from the network. Hypothesis 111: That people who have higher monthly and annual incomes live in better houses and receive more water from the network than those living in shacks. 1A villa is considered to be of excellent design constructed in concrete. A small garden usually surrounds the villa and a wall sur- rounds the whole villa. A traditional hog§g_is considered to be con- structed with inadequate engineering design. The ceiling usually is made from wood and no yard surrounds this type of house. A shack is considered to be constructed from wood and old tin, usually consisting of two or three very small rooms without facilities, and very close to each other. 55 “Rationale: A person's income is an important factor in determin- ing one's social status. The rich people can afford the luxuries of a comfortable life, whereas the poor peOple have their limitations in this regard. Hypothesis IV: That water from the network is used to irrigate gar- dens of villa residents. Rationale: Gardens that are watered regularly are mainly found among those living in villas. Using fresh water from the net- work for the beautification of a garden is considered wasteful when those in other types of housing do not have a chance to obtain sufficient water from the network. Also there are other sources of water available to water the gardens. Hypothesis V: That residents perceive ongoing public construction work as impeding water reception from the network. Rationale: Lack of cooperative planning among various public con- struction agencies adversely affects the quality and quantity of water received. 56 muons'or ANALYSIS Researchers conducting household interviews or surveys in Saudi Arabia are confronted with a variety of problems. These problems are related to the selection of a representative sample, the actual collec- tion of field data, the lack of readily available published census materials and maps, and the difficulty in obtaining unpublished reports and documents from government offices. The collection of field data in a city like Jeddah is very difficult mainly because the city is organized in districts that often cannot be easily delimited and houses and streets that are difficult to locate for sampling purposes. Generally speaking, only the main streets have names. The small streets have neither names nor numbers. Moreover, there is no numbering on the houses at all, all which makes it difficult to identify residential locations for a sample. A cross-section of residential areas and housing types was considered necessary in order to assess spatial variations in per- ceptions the residents had of the city's water problems and of the variations in water use. In order to obtain that cross-section of households in different parts of the city, a variation of the method adapted by the Ministry of Interior in 197l for surveying and planning was used to divide the city into six districts: Nuzla, Harbour, Central Area, Ruwais, Mecca Road, and Medina Road (Figure l8). 57 E 2... .382 3.33.. .83.... t :33: 050n9nm.o .38-.8.o¢8...!83.. w 3333:. 39:55 am... . . . . . .. $05.55 So v.63 . . .. n .. . ‘ ozmou... . .. .. . 1m m. . .......... . ...... ..........m.....n............. o I a no u c II I I I. II I . I I u.- I. I I . II. III I a III - III. . I I I . u out o . o... IcoI I . a I . n n n I I c . II b . . o q. a n u -.I III u I - c u o I u u o o I I I I _ . I oo- cooo nu II I , . . I a u I u n I . I I no. I I - o I. III 0 I I I . I n n a I I. --------- I I u .u I. o. .. . . n .............. o. u on II I , . .. II o ooooooooo u I I n I .I . . oooooooo - II I I , . I . a c n I I . ... n I o I I II I n n I n I I I o I p a II ...... ooooooooooooooooooo on . o. . I o I .. .. . ... a . n. . .. .o .... u. no . I g I I... I o . p. . .- - -.oo.. o- a one I u. I I n a u I I I I a-I on... I! I. In In... oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo .0 III. 0 u u n u I oo . a a... ........................... I... ...-.Iaouno ...... q I o I o ....... I a I c. I u o c o . o c ..... I I. u o no on I u I n a... o. .. I no...- u oooooooooo can u. nnnnnnnn I...» o I I In nnnnn III I o- o I. In I. I o I u .......... ...-a .... no - I .. . o u ...... o. . .~ . ... n I I II. III I.- .. one. In nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn o .- . o I u ..... . ...... . I a . u . u ------- . no I . . ... . . . .u a .. .. .o . o - III. to. o I. no .. . 0.. n ..................... a . no I o n I. n I I II . .. a. ............ I u g - I c. o . . _ .. ... u ....... a I . OI yo I . .. . I I... IIIIIIIIII II c o u u 3 ... - .. .- . .... ......... o. a. o I I I . . . . . o o. .......... III - . . .1 ... ............ ......... .......... .......... II I ..... ........ . 0.. I I... toe; .. .. ... rye... “fr... . ... ... . .. ., .. u u .. . .f . s . a . 8. manor: mmEb oz< mwS;: "Tina." \ . O I f NETWORK TANK CART PEDDLER L 1 1 4b 5 WATER SOURCES LEGEND . —— I. NUZLA DISTRICT ---------- 2. O HARBOUR DISTRICT OLD DSTRICTS O ------- 3. CENTRAL AREA DISTRICT 3 -——-—-— 4. RuvIAIS DISTRICT E] —+—+— 5. MECCA ROAD DISTRICT [:1 -—x—x— 6. MEDINA ROAD DISTRICT :I‘MEW D'STR'CTS SOURCES OF WATER BY DISTRICT (FIGURE 2|) 68 figures reveal a need for planning water networks for these districts in the fUture. While it will take time to plan and to expand the net- work into these new districts, they are expected to continue growing which will likely pose more serious problems in the future. WATER SHORTAGE AND TYPE OF HOUSING It is hypothesized that people who live in villas experience fewer problems and have greater access to water from the network than people who live in traditional houses or shacks. The survey results, summarized in Table 5, show that those living in villas and apartments experience the fewest shortages. While only about ll percent of villa dwellers and IQ percent Of apartment dwellers face extreme problems with water shortage, about 35 percent of those in traditional houses and 63 percent Of those in shacks face extreme problems in Obtaining water. The Chi-Square results show the relationship between type of housing and perception of the water shortage to be significant at the 0.005 level. This result supports the second hypothesis. The acceptance of this hypothesis also verified the fact that the high income population living in villas has less difficulty in obtaining water than the low income people living in traditional houses and shacks (Figure 22) The degree of difficulty may be translated into the degree of accessibility to water. 69 TABLE 5 ASSOCIATION OF ATTITUDES TOWARD WATER SHORTAGE BY TYPE OF HOUSE Extreme Some Little No Problem Problem Problem Problem Totals Villa (1.6)al (5.2) (4.4) (3.4) 8 26 22 17 73 Apartment (3.2) (14.4) (7.8) (6.4) 16 72 39 32 159 Traditional House (15.0) (14.8) (6.8) (6.6) 75 74 34 33 216 Shack (6.4) (3.0) (0.6) (0.2) 32 15 3 1 51 Totals 131 187 98 83 499 2 X = 80.8 p 0.005 a Numbers in parentheses are expected frequencies. There also is a significant relationship between the type of house and the water sources (Table 6). Both Table 6 and Figure 23 7O 100 90 80 7O 4‘ so i. l- ‘, E “ \ g 50 i LU \ 9‘ a \\ I \ x .’ \ 4° \ T '\ \ \\ I 3""“"7'¥)‘ “~-:\ I \ ‘5‘ 30 I I \ \ \ ‘ ,’ Ir ‘\ \ ‘x 1”, \\ \x \ ““~ ”/ \\ \\ *~~~~~~~ 20 III, 'P \\ M" II \ \\ \ I \ --------- , \ l" 4) IO "I x 2 ‘\ ‘r 0 f EXTREME SOME LITTLE NO PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM PROBLEM L ’1‘ 1 4‘ 4‘ WATER SHORTAGE LEGEND LINE I DENOTES VILLAS LINE 2 DENOTES APARTMENTS LINE 3 DENOTES TRADITIONAL HOUSES LINE 4 DENOTES SHACKS PERCEPTION OF WATER SHORTAGES BY TYPE OF HOUSING (FIGURE 22) 7I show that more;than 90 percent of those Iiving in viIIas and apart- ments receive water from the network. This figure is contrasted whiIe onIy 58 percent of those who Iive in traditionaI houses and onTy 16 percent of those Iiving in shacks receive water from the network; most TABLE 6 ASSOCIATION BETWEEN SOURCES OF WATER AND TYPE OF HOUSE Network Tank Cart PeddIer TotaIs viiia (13.9)a (0.8) (0.0) (0.0) 69 4 O O 73 Aoartment (29.8) (2.2) (0.2) (0.0) I46 II I 0 I58 TraditionaI House (25.I) (13.5) (3.0) (I.8) I25 67 I5 9 2I6 Shack (i 6) (0 0) (3.6) (4 8) 8 0 I8 24 50 TotaIs 348 82 34 33 497 2 x = 316.8 p 0.005 a . " . Numbers in parentheses are expected frequenc1es. 72 I00 90 l 2 80 70 ‘ 60 F- 3 :2 DJ 0 so tr \ “J 0. 4O \ / 30 \ / 20 4 \ A IO NETWORK TANK CART PEDDL ER L 4‘ ’1‘ 4‘ meER SOURCES LEGEND LINE l DENOTES VILLAS LINE 2 DENOTES APARTMENTS LINE 3 DENOTES TRADITIONAL HOUSES LINE 4 DENOTES SHACKS SOURCES OF WATER BY TYPE OF HOUSING (FIGURE 23) 73 of the residents in shacks have very low incomes. The two most common ways fbr the Tow income residents to obtain water are to buy it from the carts or peddlers or peddle their own water. Almost half procure water through peddling. The survey results summarized in Table 6 reflect the unfair treatment the low income population suffer in regard to obtaining water through the local administration. Obtaining water from carts and peddlers, as stated above, is not sanitary as often the water is exposed to contamination by dust and germs. INCOME, HOUSING, AND SOURCES OF WATER Following the results obtained by verifying the second hypoth- esis, it is hypothesized that those residents with higher incomes live in better quality houses and receive water from the city's network. Table 7 shows a classification of monthly income according to types of housing. The survey results, summarized in Table 7, reveal that those people with the highest monthly income live in villas and apartments while those with the low incomes generally live in traditional houses and shacks. The relationship between the monthly income and the type of house is also shown in Figure 24. Half of those interviewed who live in villas have incomes of $l,000 or more per month per head of household. 0n the other hand only about 7 percent of those living in 74 TABLE 7 THE INCOME AND TYPE OF HOUSE Income Type of House Traditional Villa Apartment Shack per House Household Respon- % of Respon- % of Respon- % of Respon- % of dents Res. dents Res. dents Res. dents Res. Less than $200 0 0 0 0 4 l 9 3 6 l $200-399 l 1.6 4 26 9 4.3 6 l2.2 $400-599 0 0 7 4.6 32 15.4 19 38.8 $600-799 4 6.3 5l 33.6 74 35.6 15 30.6 $800-999 27 42.2 59 38.8 75 36.l 6 12.2 $1000 + more 32 50.0 31 20.4 l4 6.7 0 0 traditional houses have incomes in this category; no heads of households living in shacks had incomes in this category. The survey further revealed that most households living in apartments and traditional houses earned between 5600-999 per month while those in shacks earned less than $600 per month. There is also a strong positive relationship between monthly income and a household's connection to the city's water network (Figure 25). Eighty percent of those households in the highest income category receive water from the network; none obtain it from peddlers. IOO 90 70 60 g. 2 In 0 so a: m a. 4O 3O 20 (O o VILLA APARTMENT TRADITIONAL SfiACK HOUSE LEGEND LESS THAN $2oo 4._.. IIIIIIIIIIIII $200 - $399 E2) 40o - s99 :aoo - :799 L«THE HOUSEHOLD INCOME PER MONTH E $80O - $999 - slooo AND OVER <—— INCOME MEASURED IN u.s. DOLLAR - $l=3.5 SAUDI'S RIYAL INCOME BY TYPE OF HOUSING (FIGURE 24) «38“.: g AWN mmDmv—n: “u...” M $23 Lo 8858 024 2282. 301mg? xmoiemz I onzImomJ 33$. «.623 n.» u.» - "3.38 .m: 2. 8:83: mzooz: IP20: mun. NJOUZ. OJOImeOI « « $50 92 08.» 83 .. coo» m2.» . com» 83 u 8e» 83 . com“ com o 5:: $3 o o. om on m m m ow 3 a N a I. 3 o on m ... s M oo M ..v. H 3 3 a 2. G om om 00. 77 Those with the lowest incomes Obtain over 40 percent of their water through peddling; a small percentage receive water from the network. Tanks and carts are additional sources for those with low incomes. These results thus support the hypothesis that there is a relationship between income, type of house and sources of water. The high income peOple, it might be concluded, especially in regards to water, have access to the comfortable life and the poor to the uncomfortable life. TYPE OF HOUSE AND WATER USE Since it has been demonstrated that high income people live in villas and obtain water via the municipal network, it is hypothesized that they use water from that network to irrigate their gardens. Before examining this hypothesis, a word about gardens and watering them is in order. Gardens are considered fashionable in Jeddah, especially for those living in villas; most residents have gardens within their compound. The Chi-Square results, significant at the 0.005 level, show a strong relationship between the presence of the gardens and type of house. The survey results revealed that 73 percent of those in villas while 3 and 4 percent of those living in apartments and traditional houses respectively have gardens (Table 8). Households with the lowest incomes do not have gardens (Figure 26). The relationship between the type of house and uses of water was examined next. The results reveal there is a strong relationship 78 TABLE 8 ASSOCIATION BETWEEN TYPES OF HOUSES AND PRESENCE OF GARDENS Traditional Villa Apartment House Shack Totals Garden (10.7)a (1.0) (1.7) (0.0) 53 5 8 0 66 No Garden (4.I) (3I.O) (40.7) (I0.3) 20 150 197 50 4l7 Totals 73 155 205 50 483 2 X = 25l.7 P 0.005 a . . Numbers 1n parentheses are expected frequenc1es. between the type of house and water uses (Table 9). Almost 66 percent of those who live in villas use water for both household purposes and irrigating gardens; only 3.2 percent of apartment dwellers and tradi- tional house dwellers use water for the same purposes. Those living in shacks use water only for domestic purposes. As indicated in Table 6, about 95 percent of those living in villas receive water from the network only; almost 66 percent of villa dwellers use water both for drinking and irrigating gardens (Table 9). These dwellers have much 79 TYPES OF HOUSING WITH GARDENS (FIGURE 26) 2. APARTMENT I. VILLA 4. SHACK 3. TRADITIONAL HOUSE LEGEND - PEOPLE WHO HAVE GARDENS E PEOPLE WHO DO NOT HAVE GARDENS 8O differént uses of water than those in other types of housing (Fig- ure 27). TABLE 9 WATER USES AND TYPE OF HOUSE Type of House Villa Apartment Traditional Shack Water Uses House Respon- % of Respon- % of Respon- % of Respon- % of dents Res. dents Res. dents Res. dents Res. Drinking 25 34.2 153 96.8 209 96.8 48 l00 Drinking and 48 65.8 5 3.2 7 3.2 0 0 Irrigating WATER AVAILABILITY AND THE IMPACT OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS Another problem that exists within Jeddah city involves the effect extensive and ongoing public construction in various parts of the city has on the availability of water. Ongoing construction work includes building structures, paving streets, laying telephone and electricity extensions, and drilling for and laying of sewer pipes. It is hypothesized that residents perceive construction and repair of USES OF WATER FOR DRINKING AND IRRIGATION BY TYPE OF HOUSING (FIGURE 27) 2. APARTMENT 4. SHACK 3. TRADITIONAL HOUSE LEGEND - DRINKING AND IRRIGATION D DRINKING 82 various projects as obstacles to their receiving water. The 348 respondents who received water from the network were asked whether they face any major problems receiving water regularly from the network. While 161 respondents (46 percent) stated that they do not face major problems receiving water regularly, 183 respondents (53 percent) stated otherwise. Four heads of households (1 percent) did not respond to this question (Table 10). The fact that over half of the households receiving water from the network experienced problems on obtaining water suggests the issue was worth examining in some detail. TABLE I0 NETWORKS PROBLEMS AND PEOPLE WHO RECEIVE WATER FROM THE NETWORK Network Problems People who Receive Water from the Network Respondents % of Respondents Satisfactory 161 46.26 Unsatisfactory 183 52.59 Missing Cases 4 1.15 TOTAL 348 100 Even though 151 respondents (43 percent) claimed that they have no prob- lem getting water from the network regularly in spite of construction 83 work, 194 respondents (56 percent) claimed that their water supply is often temporarily cut off because of various construction projects (Table 11). An analysis of the survey results summarized in Tables TABLE II PUBLIC CONSTRUCTION WORKS AND PEOPLE WHO RECEIVE WATER FROM THE NETWORK C 4— Public People who Receive Water from the Network Construction Works Respondents % of Respondents Yes, they have problems 194 55.74 No, they do not have problems 151 43.40 Missing Cases 3 .86 TOTAL 348 100 10 and 11 reveals there is a slight discrepancy in the pattern of response to these two questions. About ten respondents to the first general question indicated they do not face any problems receiving water from the network, however, they did indicate in response to the next question at times their reception is impeded. This minor dis- crepancy could be attributed either to the lack of proper understanding of the first question or to the specificity of the second question. 84 Of those 194 respondents who face irregularity in the water they obtain from the network, about 60 percent of them attributed it to the drilling for and laying of sewage pipes, 30 percent to the laying of electricity extensions, and the remaining 10 percent to the building and paving of streets. An illustration of these problems was reported in the city's major newspaper, Al-Medina, on July 30, 1978. It related an account that people in some parts of the Central Area complained that their drinking water smelled and tasted of sewage. In the same report it also stated that people in some parts of Ruwais district com- plained of the same problem from a month ago, but the authorities had not done anything about it as of the time. This problem of bad taste and smell of drinking water could be attributed to the faulty connec- tions between water pipes and sewage pipes, and directly hence to poor planning of the city's water and sewage systems. These results lead to the acceptance of the fifty hypothesis which states that public construction work impedes water reception of those residents obtaining it from the network. CHAPTER VI CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS Jeddah city faces shortage of various public utilities, one of which is water. In spite of the four ways people obtain water, that is, via the network, tank, carting, and peddling, the water supply and water network do not keep pace with the growth of the city. In order to adequately ascertain residents perceptions regarding the shortage of water supply in the city of Jeddah, a survey was conducted with five hundred heads of households randomly selected from four different type of living units, villas, apartments, traditional houses, and shacks. CONCLUSIONS The raw data identified water problems and attributed them to three major factors: 1) a shortage of water supply from the main resources, 2) a lack of prOper planning for the distribution of water, and 3) the use of water for non-domestic purposes such as irrigating gardens. In regards to the first point, there are three main resources of water supply. These are Wadi Fatima, Wadi Khlais, and the 85 86 desalinization plant. The inadequate supply of water for the city from these three resources is caused by insufficient amount to balance the increasing extraction. At Wadi Fatima there is a gradual decline in the ground water table of 70 mm per month. Rainfall is irregular and only 50-100 mm per year. The water obtained from the desalinization plant does not meet present needs. Moreover, the plant functions on an irregular basis throughout the year. There is an apparent lack of planning in the distribution of water to residents throughout the city. Two points can be made regard- ing this point. Firstly, the old districts are better served by the water network than the new districts. Yet it is the new districts that are growing and developing rapidly. There is currently a lack of plan- ning to supply water to the new districts. Secondly, most of the rich people dwelling in villas and apartments in the old and new districts receive water through the network. Most of the people living in tra- ditional houses and shacks throughout the city do not enjoy this privilege. Access to water from the network and its use are directly related to the wealth of the household and the type of housing. High income people live in villas and apartments while low income peOple live in traditional homes and shacks. Those with very highest incomes, as the survey reveals, misuse water while those with the very lowest incomes do not have water available even for important domestic pur- 87 poses.' Those living in villas frequently have a garden which is irri- gated by water from the network. Low income residents do not enjoy such a luxury; they usually lack an extension of the network into their homes even to use water for cooking and drinking purposes. Water from the network is used in construction projects, to wash cars, and for various public uses, all of which take water which could be used for ‘ domestic uses. RECOMMENDATIONS On the basis of knowledge of the city's water system and resi- dents perceptions of water problems and their uses of water, the fol- lowing recommendations are offered as possible solutions to the water problems the city faces. 1. It is not possible to cut down the extraction of water from Wadi Fatima and Khlais, but the desalinization plant can be operated at a higher capacity and on a more regular basis and thereby increase the water output. Sea water is likely to be the only resource to supply the city with more water in the future. 2. The traditional houses and shacks have been in the city for decades. These dwellings as homes of permanent residents 88 should not be treated as temporary housing, but given fair treatment and provided with water from the municipal network. Municipal government agencies should endeavor to supply water to all residents in all districts whether the residents live in their own or rent their houses, whether they are rich or poor, or whether they live close or far from the city center. Planning the future construction of any type of house in any district in the city should include water pipelines con- nected to the entire network. Water should be made avail- able to the residents upon moving into their new home. While many peOple living in the traditional houses and shacks lack sufficient water for domestic purposes, the villa dwellers are using the water from the network to irrigate gardens. This is a critical problem. The government should stOp such misuse of water. This can be done through periodic and careful inspection of the house connections and water meters. Regularly, various public construction works impede the water supply from the network to the residents. Such practices indicate a lack of communication and coordinated planning among the different government agencies. This situation results in problems the people face and areas undergoing con- 89 struction. Steps should be taken to encourage more communi- ' cation and comprehensive planning between these agencies, so that such construction works do not impede continued water supply from the networks to the homes. Additional recommendations that are not directly related to the study but will certainly help alleviate the water shortage problem in Jeddah city are presented next. These are: l. The traditional practice of transporting water by tanks, carts, or peddlers should be discouraged because such practices expose water to dust and contaminate it. This in turn causes various diseases. 2. Many private water truck owners transport water from illegal sources to sell to the residents. The government should investigate these operations and put a stop to such practices. 3. The government should stop excess immigration from the rural areas to the city of Jeddah. Likewise it should also impose strong visa regulations for non-Saudians entering the country. 4. Much water from the network is used for irrigating gardens, for public work, washing cars and other non-domestic purposes. To avoid such wastage, the government should make immediate 90 plans to install plants to treat sewage water for such non- domestic uses. Water from these treatment plants could be transported by trucks to the various districts for the non- domestic uses. 5. The government should make good use of mass media such as radio, television, newspapers, magazines, schools, billboards, and public posters to educate the people about the regulations of using water and the need for water conservation. 6. The government should stOp drilling more wells in Wadi Fatima and Wadi Khlais to save the agricultural sector and to stop the immigration from these rural areas to the cities. The agricultural sector is very important for Saudi life. This study has considered the water uses, water quality, and the distribution of the network and perception of water problems within Jeddah city. However, for a more detailed study, a geographer needs to conduct further surveys regarding environmental perceptions of the city's residents. Through such studies it is hOped the city's water problems can be better understood and resolved. BIBLIOGRAPHY BIBLIOGRAPHY Books Al-Ansari, Abdul Gaddous. History of Jeddah. Jeddah: Dar Al-Asafehani, 1963. History of Aziziah Water Supply in Jeddah. Jeddah: Printed at the expense of the Administration of Aziziah Water Supply in Jeddah-Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, 1972. Arabian American Oil Company. Aramco Handbook: Oil and the Middle East. Dhahran, Saudi Arabia: Printed in Netherlands by Joh Enschede en Zonen Haarlem, 1968. Baumann, Duane D. and Robert W. Kates. "Risk from Nature in the City", in Urbanization and Environment: The Physical Geography of the City, eds. Thomas R. Detwyler and Melvin G. Marcus and others. Belmont, CA: Duxbury Press, 1972, pp. 169-194. Berry, Brian J. L. and Frank E. Horton. Geographic Perspectives on Urban System. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1970. Bindagji, Hussein. Atlas of Saudi Arabia. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1978. Blalock, Herbert M., Jr. Social Statistics. New York: McGraw Hill Book Company, 1972. Borgstrom, Georg. Too Many: 'An Ecological Overview of the Earth's Limitation. New York: Collier Books, 1971. Carter, Harold. The Study of Urban Geography. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1975. Chapin, F. Stuart, Jr. Urban Land Use Planning. Urbana, ILL: Univer- sity of Illinois Press, 1965. 91 92 Deming, H. G. Water: The Fountain of Opportunity. New York: Oxford University Press, 1975. Dietterich, B. and J. Henderson. Urban Water Supply Conditions and Needs in Seventy-Five Develpping_Countries. Geneva: World Health Organization, Public Health Papers No. 23, 1963. Herbert, David. Urban Geography: A Social Perspective. New York: Praeger Publishers, 1973. Jakle, John and others. Human Spatial Behavior: A Social Geography. North Sciluate, Massachusetts: Duxbury Press, 1976. Johnson, James H. Urban Geography: An Introductory Analypis. Oxford Pergamon Press, 1972. Makky, Ghazy A. Mecca: The Pilgrimmage City. London: Biddles Ltd., Guildford-Surrey, 1978. Manners, Ian and Marvin Mikesell, eds. Perspectives on Environment. Washington, D.C.: Association of American Geographers, 1974. Marcus, Melvin G. and Thomas R. Detwyler, eds., Urbanization and Environment: The Physical Geography of the Cipy. Belmont, CA: Duxbury Press, 1972. Nyrop, Richard F. and others. Area Handbook for Saudi Arabia. Washington, D.C.: American University, Foreign Area Studies, 3rd ed., 1977. Pesce, Anglo. Jeddah: A Portrait of an Arabian City. London, Falcon Press, 1974. Rugg, Dean S. Spatial Foundations of Urbanism. Dubuque, Iowa: Wm. C. Brown Co. Publishers, 1972. Saarinen, Thomas F. Perception of the Environment. Washington, D.C.: Commission on College Geography, Association of American Geog- raphers, Publication No. 13, 1974. . Environmental Planning: Percgption and Behavior. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1976. 93 Schmid, James. "The Environmental Impact on Urbanization", in Marvin W. Mikesell and Ian Manners, eds., PErSpectives on EnVironment. Washington, D.C.: Commission on College Geography, Association of American Geographers, Publication No. 13, 1974, pp. 213-251. Sommers, Lawrence. "Man-Water Relationship Research and Application of the Geographic Approach", in Harold A. Winters and Marjorie Winters, eds.,_App1ication of Geographic Research, East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University, Department of Geography, 1977, pp. 89-96. Taaffe, Edward J., ed., Geography. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1970. World Bank. Village Water Supply. Washington, D.C., March 1976. Articles Al-Faisal, Mohammed. Desalinization Program for Saudi Arabia in Water for Peace, Vol. 2, Water SUpply Technology, Washington, D.C., U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967, pp. 37-42. Beaumont, Peter. "1976 Desalinization Projects in Saudi Arabia", London, Financial Times Survey, January 12, 1976. ; "Water and Development in Saudi Arabia". Geographical Journal. Vol. 143, March 1977, pp. 42-60. Harris, Chauncy and Edward Ullman. "The Nature of Cities". Annals of American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol. 242, November 1945, pp. 7-17. Mishari, Hassan H. "Toward Full Water Utilization in Saudi Arabia". In Water for Peace, Vol. 2, Water Supply Technolpgy, Washington, D.C., U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967, pp. 832-841. 94 Government Reports and Documents Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Agriculture and Water. 'SeVen Green Spikes, prepared by Abdul Basset El-Khateb. Beirut: Dar al-Qalam Press Co., 1974. . Water Supply Survey for Jeddah, Mecca, Taif Area, Final Report, Riyadh, 1969. Jeddah Water Tower. Jeddah, n.d. Jeddah Water Supply, Future Extention, Jeddah, January 1973. Jeddah Water Supply Distribution Net - Fourth Stage. Jeddah, August 1975. . Saudi Arabian BLOKAT, Operation and Maintenance of Jeddah Water Works. Jeddah, January 1978. Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Defense, Meteorology Department, Mean Monthly Climate Data for Jeddah city 1966-1976, Jeddah Station. Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Education, Data Center, Some Indications of Saudi Arabian's First Population Census 1974, Riyadh, 1976. Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Interior, Municipal Affairs. Regional and Town Planning Department, Western Region Plan. Immediate Action Studies Report, Vol. 3, Water, Jeddah, February 1972. Alternative Urban Strategies, Jeddah 1972. Master Plan Report for Jeddah, Jeddah 1972. Regional Frame- work, Stage Two, Phase Two. June 1972. Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Planning, Second Development Plan, 1975-1980, n.d. 95 Saudi Arabia, Saline Water Conversion Corporation, Water Unlimited. Napoli, Italy: Falcon Press, n.d. United Nations Water Conference, "Meeting Domestic Water Requirements of Developing Countries", Mar del Plata, Argentina, 1977. Newspeper Articles Al-Medina Daily Newspaper. Jeddah, Thursday, March 23, 1978, p. 1. Sunday, July 30, 1978, p. 16. OKAZ Daily Newspaper. Jeddah, Thursday, June 22, 1978, p. 5. Thursday, August 22, 1978, p. 3. Saturday, September 23, 1978, p. 3. Thursday, September 28, 1978, p. 3. Saturday, September 30, 1978, p. 3. Saturday, October 7, 1978, p. 7. APPENDIX APPENDIX The Questionnaires Age Name of district Marrital status 1 - Yes 2 - No How many people live in this house regularly? What is your occupation? Work in government Businessman Laborer Student Nothing U'I-bWN-J I Do you own your house or are you renting it? 1 - Own 2 - Rent What is the type of house you live in? Villa Apartment Traditional house Shack th—l l I DO you have a garden in your house? 1 - Yes 2 - No 96 10. II. 12. 13. 14. 15. 97 What is the source of water in your house? 1 - Network 2 - Tank 3 - Cart 4 - Peddler Do you have general problems receiving water from the network? Extreme problem Some problem Little problem No problem th—l I I If you receive your water from the network, do you have problems in having the amount of water you need? 1 - Yes 2 - No If you have problems when do you have them? During the whole year During the summer During the winter During the Hajj period th—I I I If you have it how many days during the week do you not receive water? How much do you pay monthly for receiving water from the network? 1 - 3 0-19 2 - $20-29 3 - $30-39 4 - $40-49 5 - $50 or more If you consume water by tanks, how many tanks do you consume each month? 16. I7. 18. 19. 20. 21. 98 If you get water by the tank, how much do you pay monthly? I - $ 0 - 99 2 - $100 -149 3 - $150-199 4 - $200 or more Of the total water you consume during the year, what is the per- centage you receive through the tank system? - 25% - 50% - 75% - 100% boom—a Suppose you do not receive your water from the network, how long does it take you to get water from another source? 100-199 meter 200-299 meter 300-399 meter 400-499 meter 500 meter or more mth—a I If you rent the apartment, did you rent it including water? 1 - Yes 2 - No If yes, how much do you pay monthly to the owner for water? 1 - $ 0-19 2 - $20-29 3 - $30-39 4 - $40-49 5 - $ 50 or more If no, how much do you pay monthly for that? I - $ 0-19 2 - $20-29 3 - $30-39 4 - $40-49 5 - $50 or more 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 99 Do you have problems with the owner about water? 1 - Yes 2 - No Do you use water for Drinking only Drinking and garden irrigation Business Other wa—l II I What types of water do you receive through the network? 1 - Fresh water 2 - Salty 3 - Fixed (fresh water and salty) What types of water do you get through the tanks? 1 - Fresh water 2 - Salty 3 — Fixed (fresh water and salty) From your experience, which districts of the city do you think receive water more than others? (JON-d Why do you think they receive much water? Because the system and the distribution of the network are very well planned. 1 2 - Because the water agencies paid more attention to it than others. 3 - Because it is close to the reservoirs. 4 - Other reasons. If there is any construction in the streets, does that affect receiving water from the network? 1 - Yes 2 - No 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 100 If yes, which one have more problems than others? The electric extensions The phone extensions The building and paving of streets The drilling and laying of sewage pipes hMN—4 I I Do you have problems from the rainfall? l - Yes 2 - No During the last five years, do you feel the water supply was: - Better than today - Same as today - Worse than today (JON—l How do you evaluate the water supply in your district? - Very difficult - Average - Somewhat no difficulty - Not difficult at all hum—- Suppose the water supply increased in your house, do you think your consumption will: 1 - Increase 2 - Stay the same 3 - Decrease What kind of suggestions do you give to improve the water supply in your area? (check one only) 1 - Change the network 2 - Build many reservoirs 3 - Change the management What is your estimated monthly income (head of household)? 1 - Less than $200 4 - $600-799 2 - $200-399 5 - $800-999 3 - $400-599 6 - $1000 or more "’IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII