pw , MUP VUOR ee sa) ai BUNT Oe ges 0 1 DG mata ROBERT W. GOSS 1915 ‘ \ m_ 4 Cs — \ oS LIBRARY Michigan State “ersity PLACE IN RETURN BOX to remove this checkout from your record. TO AVOID FINES return on or before date due. MAY BE RECALLED with earlier due date if requested. DATE DUE DATE DUE DATE DUE 5/08 K:/Proj/Acc&Pres/CIRC/DateDue.indd POTATO WITT CAUSED BY FUSARIUK OXYSFORUM. Thesis for tne Degree of Master of Science, Michigan Agricultural College. he? Robert W. Goss June 1915. ~~ THESI- * TABLE OF CONTE: TS. History ----<------------- eer cree -- ercrero-e ---fp 1 Geograpnic distrivution,------- mec cr ere e rene -- 13 Economic: Imvportance--------- eoewere eee aorene 16 Field obeervations ~~ ----<----- wens ecee creer 19 Descrivtion of alc eage.-- - erence eennn- ccce--- 35 Btiology crvrcrccccr-e--- wer mmm reer eter err e-ee - 45 Patnogenicity ----------------- eer ccesceceee-- | (45 MOTOg LOBYyY wen - one eee ---- wee ener ee -------- 46 Cuttural s tudleas----------- were cece r nee eee-- o-- 54 Spore germination studies ------- eeceeeeeee--= ) (77 Maximum and iilninum Zrowtn, -e-escse-- eee wn -ne- C1 Toeral deata point, ----e-+-------------------- G4 Polsonous binroducsvs ot tue Tungus e--2------- ~ &5 Infection exneriments, ---------<------------- - && Control - «----2-------------------- ewww eenwee 103 Experiment witn intected tuvers. ---------e-enn-- 105 2eSts WIth Neil aAlsa eeneerseowowenne ween ee ene--110 Eftect of tungicid:.] econo eee een n-ne --e- eee - lil WeEdL@ LOrm@lAae@ snc ennn- meen - - mew ee we wen eene 116 Literature, wee e ee eee---- wee ween e-e-ee e--- 119. 96428 POTATO WILT CAUSED BY FUSARIUM OXYSPORUM HREKKKHKKKE HISTORY. The Fusarium wilt of potatoes was probably present in this country for many years beiore the cause of tne wilt was determined, The tirst note of the patnol ogical condition caused by thia disease in this country dates only as far back ae 1695 when G.P. Ciinton reported the disease in Illinois. Since that time it nas been widely observed but until recent years it has probably been more or less contused with the other wilts of the potato, In most cases simply tne presence of the condition caused by the organism: wae noted and very little attempt was made to determine the cause of thie pathological condition. It was not until about 1904 that the disease came into prominence, when it tirst assumed economic importance in this country. At tnis time there appeared a bulletin py Smith and Swingle (1904) describing Fusarium oxysporum as the cause of the wiit of potatoes noted in Miecnigan ard the District ot Columbia. nO important epidemic periods or epocha in tne nistory of the dieeagse are found; this is probably owing to tne slow and insidious nature of the irfection of tne potato crop, not caueing a rapid rot of the plants but slowly undermining tue seed stock and gradually decreasing the yield. Very little work was done on the disease in this country after 1904, until a widespread occurrence of the disease wae reported in California in 1908, which was studied vy Orton (1909), wno also satudied tne diseases of potatoes in various parts of the country in 1909 and 1910 and abroad in 1911. He found Fusarium wilt to be very wide- epread in America but not recognized in Burope. Since that time very valuble work nas been done by Dr. Wollenvweper, especially on the morphology and classification of this especies of Fusarium, and inoculation exrerimentsa nave been conducted by Manns in Onio, The diseare was first noted in Micuigan in 1899, (Smith and Swingle 1904) and since that time very little has been done with the disease in this state. It was reported by G.H. Coons (1914) and was studied py the writer in various parts of the state during the past season and found to be of widespread occurrence, and while strictly speaking it has not caused an epidemic as yet in thie atate it is certainly assuming great economic importance. PREVICUS WORK. The literature on the taxonomy of the genus Fusarium has been in a very cnaotic etate until recent years, 3. ‘and necessarily that part of the literature in reference to the pathological conditions caused by these organisms has been in no better condition. In regard to Fusarium oxysporum in particular, tne literature nas been very corfusing, principally because no reliable cultural and morphological studies and inoculation experiments have been conducted with reference to the path- Ological conditions noted in the field. Fusarium oxysporum had long been regarded as tne cause of the dry rot of potatoes, even up to 1904 wnen Smith and Swingle 1.c. wrote on the suodject. In tueir bulietin tne authors describe a species of Fusarium. which they identity witn te Fusarium oxysporum of Schlechtendal (1824) and wnich they report as causing a dry rot as weil as the wilt of the potato vlant. No inoculation experiments were made and it ie very probable that they were working with more than one species, in the Lignt of tue recent ctudies of Wotlenwevber wno hae shown that F. oxysporum is a vascular varasite causing wilt and wintering over in the atem enda of tne tubers but not producing a decay of tne tuber. Wilcox in 1912,(Wilcox, Tink and Pool 1912, ) working with a Fusarium causing the dry rot of the tuber compared his epecies with that which Smith sent him as F. oxysporum and found that the two were not identical. The F. oxyeporum caused a wilt but not a decay, while his species which he calles F. tuberivorum (sp. n. Wilcox and Link) was a saprophyte incapable of infecting any part of the potato plant except the tuber. In fact previous to 1910 no reliable work had been done on the genus. In that year a publication by Wollenweber and Appel (1910) appeared which was the first authoritativepunplication giving a aystematic treatment of the morphological characters and laying the foundation for the seperation of the spesies. Wollerwevoer in 1913* aescribed F. oxysporum as a"*vascular parasite causing the wilt disease but not the tuber rot of Solanum tuberosum in the United Statee of America, possibly also in Soutnern Europe and the potato districts of South Africa, Australia, etc. Aliso found on various hosts, such as Solarum lycopersicum, Vigna, Pisum and Ipomoeo. The disease associated with the fungue has been confused with " leaf roil" a disease called "Blattroll- krankneit® in Germany."(A fuller discussion of tnese two wor:s is given under morphology.) Tne final result of Dr. Wo:lermeber's etudy of this gems will undoubtedly «straig/ften out and simplify the cnaotic condition of the present classification of tnis geme. Tois description and classification is considered authoritative and is used as the basis for the following work. * Woilenweber, H.W. Phytopath. 1913, p. 24. 5. It is not the purpose of thie article to discuss the literature in regard to classification, nomenclature and morpnological chacterietics which are fully covered in Wollermeber's work as well as in Smith and Swingle's, where comvlete bibliographies can be found. The account which follows concernes itself with the publications upon the pathological aspect of tne wilt in the field and . the presence of the disease as noted in different sections of tne country. Probably the first note upon the pathological condition caused by this disease in this country was tnat by Clinton in 1895.* He deacibes a condition found in the tubera whicn ne caéils * burdle blackening". * Tnis ia a fungus trouble of stored potatoes which srows as smalit aots or lines @ snort distarce from the surfacer-e--re---- Tuese bundles originate at tne stem end and send off a few bundles to each of the eyes. The fungus gains entrance, probably after tne potatoes are gathered, through the aead atem, and proceeds from this through the bundies cauring them to turn biack as the result of its attack." He goes on to say that, * tne fungus is quite similar to the one causing the following trouble.* He then describes a condition of the tuber whicn he calle * dry end rot", * It affects all the tissue ase it slowly advances forward, until, pernaps, the wnoie tuver is destroyed. As in the preceeding case the trouvnle begins at the stem end, the fungus gaining entrance after the rupture * Clinton, C. P. p. 139, 1895. 6. of the tuber from the plant.” He believed that the latter disease was due to F. solani. In none of his observations has ne connected the patnological conditions in tne fieid witn the conditions he notes in storage, and he has probably eonfueed the bundle blackening of the wilt with the stem end rot caused by another Fusarium, Stewart in 1696 writing on*Another Stem Blight of the FPotato® describes a wilt of the potato and in his paper says he was doubtful if any organism was responsible for the trouble, This has been considered in previous literature to nave been one of the first reports of the F. wilt in this country and was tnought by Smith and Swingle to be probably the same disease tney were working on, but according to Orton # “The disease deacrived py Stewart (1896) and thought by Smith and Swingle to be probably the same, was stated by Prof, Stewart at a recent meeting of the American Pnytopatnological Society to be not due to Fusarium." Clinton in 1904*reports from Connecticut that "many vines wilted pefore the middle of July" probably caused by F. oxysvorum described by Smitn and Swingle l.c. He connects the wilt with the umaual amount of bumie blackening and rotting found in market potatoes. He apparently reporte a condition simiiar to that described by Smith and # Orton, W.A. 1913, p.3. * Clinton, G.P. 1904, p. 349. 7. Swingle in which he has contused tne wilt with other Oorganismea causing dry rot of the tuber. Smitn and Swingle l.c. in 1404 give the first accurate description of the syptoms of the disase, and it is to tnem tnat we owe much of tne present knowledge of the Fusarium wilt in tnia country. In spite of the fact that Wollerweber has since proved that tney were probably working with more than one organism, their conditions of the path- ological conditions found in tne field is atiil standara as well as much of tneir cuitural work. It is well to note tnat the first tubers Smith observed and on which he worked were from Hubbardston, vichigan. Tne next report of the disease comes from Maryland, Norton in 1906 * reters to a dry rot as causea by F., oxyenorum. * The disease is indicated by tne iignter colored and more or less rolled up condition of the leaves. When dug the potatoes may appear sourd, but internally snow black or brown streaks, and later are destroyed at least at One end by the dry rot." Here again we find the confusion of the wiited condition of the plantea with the dry rot of the tubers. gne next report is by Orton in 1909 # from California and is probably the tirst report of the disease * Norton, J.B.8. 1906, p. 67. # Orton, W.A. 1909, p. 4. 6. on the Pacific coast. He says, ® Tne principal cause of the marked decrease in the yield of old potato land is the presence .0f a fungus disease, tne wilt or dry rot- Fusarium oxysporum Sehlec. He gives a descripticucn of the wilt and dry rot similar to that by Smth and Swingle. Again Orton in 1911 * aescribes tne disease in regara to its geographical distributién, ne says " the disease described by Smith and Swing] e--------- e-----is now coming into prominence as one of the most wide apread and deatructive maladier of thie crop. It appears to occur throughout the United States, but is more injurious in the irrigated sections of the west and in the soutnern half of the potato belt." His description is the same aa nis previous one, ° worse in 1909 # revorts tne disease from Maine, saying," Fusarium ary rot caused oy the fungus F. oxysporum Scnliect. has bveen found for the first time in Maine during the past summer.* He reports it as not being very widely distributed through Kaine, Loundsbury in 1909 ** desrcibes a dry rot of the potato tuber found in Cape Colony as caused py Nectria solani. He says, “* the infection is introduced into tne soil * Orton, W.A. 1911, p. 751. # Morse, W.J. 1909, p. 2. ** Loundsbury, C.P. 1904, p. 42. 9. with diseased tubers and it remains there from season to season, 80 that a crop from perfectly healthy seed may get infected if grown on tand that previously pore an aftected crop. The disease generally enterm at the stem end. The fungus developes most rapidly in the vascular ring." From his reference to the wilt symptoms shown by affected vines it appears tnat ne nas confused the Fusarium wilt witn another species causing a rot of the tuber. Tidewell in 1910 describer a dry rot ana wilt of the potato in New South Wales, which he says is caused by ¥. sclani, an organism which he claims shald be more properly called F. oxysporum. He also makes refererce to the wilting ot the tops, blackening ot the vaeculur regions and root infection, showing that ne probably confused one or more otner diseases with the wilt of the plant. Manns in 1911 publianed a twilletin on tnis disease in Onio. He desacrives a ex: ndition in the fieid and storage similar to the one that Smith and Swingle reported. He goes a step further, however, by saying that tne Fusarium found in the vlackened vascular ring is identical with the Fusarium of dry rot. Tnis he proved oy isolating the organism from the two sources, and carrying them through artificial cultures and inoculation experimenter. They were identical and both brought about wiiting in the field. These inoculation experiments are probably the first reported in this country 10. and according to Orton (1914) cultures of the Ohio strain have been studied by Dr. H.W. Wolienwever in comparison witn & targe number of others and proved to be what we stiil call F. oxysporum. However according to Wollenweber's work iarna must nave been dealing with a dry rot organism in connection with the F. oxys-orum whieh he nad. The only point in his infection experiments which might be open to criticism is the fact that most of nis inoculation experiments were conducted by growing healthy plants on baaly infected soil, and ne draws the conclusions that * Tne disease comes on much more definetly under the sick soil conditions than it did where artificial cultures had veen used.” There is a possibility that a great deal of the poor stand he speaks of in the sick soil may have veen due to other organisms, because in carrying out an inoculation experiment, in order to draw definite anda reliable conclusions, it would be necessary to use realtny seed grown in sterilized soil that had been imected with tne diseace artificially. The next report of the wilt comes from Minnesota, Stakman in 1912 reports tne wilt as one of the worst potato diseases in that state. He associates the wilting of the plants and the browning of the tubers with the storage rot , but says, * It is doubtful wetner this rotting is caused by the same fungus which causes the wilting o1 the ll. vines. If it is not identical with the wilt fungus it is very closely related to it." Jones in 1912* makes note of the disease in Wisconsin and describes it as a wilt and ary rot, wnich ne reports as not ocaring seriously anywhere in Wisconsin, * It seems most frequent in the southwest part of the state where the soil is warm and early potatoes are grown,“ He also mentions in the same paper a slight browing of the stem end of the tuber which ig not caused by the wilt. “Apparently due tO late autumnal growth or other cause, wnich interferes with the full normal matureing of the tubers.* Wollenmweoer in 1913 ** published another article on the gems Fusarium, wiich he divides into rections on the basis of torm of conidia and other morpho: ogical chacteristics. F. oxysporum he places in the section fleganr which contains all tne vascular parasites causing wilt, and differenciates this section from the other Fusaria, Wollerwever in 1913 1.¢c. also publisned in Phy topatnology, the results of furtner work on Fusaria. in thie he refers to the unreliability of the stroma as a taxonomic character owing to the variation of forms on the defferent substrata. He describes in detail the morpnoi ogical characteristics of this species, whicn will be taken up later, * Jones,L.R. 1912, p. 4. *%* Wollenweber, H.W. Ber. d. deut. Bot. Gea. 1913. -~_—- le. and also states that the potato is the host of 30 different forms of Fusaria. This article refers to many inoculation experiments and also contains a complete pibiiograpny. The latest article in print on this subject is probably the one by Orton (1914) in which he takes up a. general discussion of the symptoms, cause of the disease and control measures aa well as the geograupnical diatribution of the trouble, which ne claims is found in all the potato growing districts of the Umted States and he also beleives that there is no evidenee that tne Ame:ican wilt disease occurs in Burope. 13. GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION. In tne first extensive work aone on this disease by Smith and Swingle l.c.*tney report after examinati on of tubers from District of Columbia, Michigan, Virginia, Kansae, Nebraska, New York, Florida and Wiscorsin that , °® It seems safe to sry that Lnis disease extends north to Canada, east to the Atiantic, south to the Gulf of rexico and west to Colorado. How much wider its distribution is in this country cannot be stated at the present time, but it is almost undouvtedly beyond the limits from whicn it nas been so far reported." This latter statement was soon proved by the widespread reports of the disease in sucsequent years, especially from Califernia where the disease had not been reported at that time. Orton(I914)* after a study of the occurrerme of the disease in the United States, concludes that " It is certain that tne Fusarium wilt is a nation wide problem and one that will have a marked infiuence upon American agriculture," He aleo states that aftera study trip througn Germany, Austria and England in1911 he veleived tnat there was no evidence tnat the American wilt occurs in Europe. Reports of such occurrence have been confused with the leat roll disease. * Smith, E.F. and Swingle, u.B. 1904, p. 42 ** Orton, W.A. 1914, p. 16. 14. Dr. Wollenweber in his morvnnoiogical studies of Fusaria has been able to differeaciate the F. oxysporum cauei ng American potato wilt from the European form. CLIMATIC RELATIONS. Most of the Fusaria causing a wilt dis+ase of other crops are apparently diseases of tne waruwer clinates. The Fusarium wilt of potatoes is undoubtedly more serious and causes more Joss in the soutnern atatea than in tne north. In fact Orton (1914) states that +usarium wilt le avparently a@ disease of warmer climates. The soutuern states with high summer temperatures seem to suffer more than the northern States. new England and tew York are reported comparitively free from tne disease, wiile Manns in Onio reports a very wide distribution. Going weet the tungus is found furtuer north, many cases having veen observed by the writer in the irrigated sectiorns of Idano and in eastern Oregon. she results of a months atudy of tie aisease in ..ichigar snowed the rresence of the wilt even as far nortn as Houghton, and several sections of the Upper Peninsula. were found to ve neavily infected; the same amount of infection was found in the southern part of the Lower Tenineulayz, 80 that in the opinion of the writer the temperature conditions do not affect tune distrivoution of the disease to any anvraciable amount in tne state of sicnigan, and probably a closer inepection of potato crops in many of the other northern 15. potato growing st ates would reveal the preserce of the wilt in many cases. Neither do the s:i0lature conditions present any detinite distinction on the severity of infection, aa mary of the fielde examined in the Upper Peninsula had been exposed to excessive rains in the tater part of the summer, while fields simiiarly infected nad been through a comvaritively dry field in the Lower Peninsula. There is nowever,an affect , that the various moisture conditiors would nave on the severity of infection by means of weakening tne nrlants and predisposing them to infection or by causing a pvreaking down or the tissues in the plant and making them more suceptible to invasion by the fungus. 16. ECONOL:IC IMPORTANCE. The economic importance of the disease in the United States varies greatly with the comitions found in tne various localities, but it is undouvotediy much greater than was previously supposed, and the disease will contime to spread until more tringent metnods are used for its control. According to Orton (1914) the disease in the soutnern states wnile of possibly greater severity, is of minor importarce owing to the fact that in most districts tue Irisn potato is a minor crop, while in the trucking sections of the soutn the main crop is the early one grown tor nortnern markets and the infection of this cron is relatively slignt compared with that of the fall crop. in tne irrigated sections of the west the disease plays an important role because of the necessity for a longer rotation of crops less remunerative than the potato. In Caliiornia the wilt is tne prinepal factor in causing a reduction of tne yield in the San Jouquin Vatley, (Orton 1909). It is also serious in Oregon and a few otner western states. In the middie west Ohio and Michigan are badly infected and recent reports would show that tnere is also a great deal of infectiun in Wisconsin. Estimates of the money losses caused by this disease are necessarily very aard to ovutain, owing to the peculiar nature of the disease, and the small amount of im ormation avallabie. Tne loss is occasioned principally by 17. a reduction in the yieid, and there are so many otner factors wnicn may cause a reduction of the yield that it is almost impossible to determine tne exact amount of ioaes caused by the wilt. Manns of the Ohio station reports in191l tnat the sick sc:il conditions may reduce the crop in mary cases 50 # or more of. the average yield. Their experiments on infected fields show a yield of 69 bu. per acre, while the average for the county was 186 bu.. Tne nreceeding four years average for the station was 1:0 wu. and the county 101 bu. This shows the large amount of injury to the yielid-caured by tne wilt, and fuguring that only 5 @ of tne Onio fields were infected, he would estimate that the loss would amount to over 870,000 bu. for the state. In this state the lora could not be accurately acertained from the field data. The fieldea exa;ined showed an average of 30 % siight infection and 1.5 % serivus; clearly inaicating the large amount of toss due to the disease in tnis state. In many cases where the infection was bad the yield was reauced to under 100 bu. per acre, while there were very few Other fungus troubles found in the same fields. Tne averare given nere is probably low for the entire state as this was taken from the best fields growing votatoes for seed purposes, The disease is more important economically in this state in the seed growing section, The serious infection | 18, found in bhe state during the last year was not large enough to be of great economic importance, but the fact that the high percentage of slight infection is present, is of vital : interest to the seed grower as even the slight imnfection of the tubers without materially decreasing the yield for the present year would disqualify tne potatoes for seed, ‘The widespread occurrene of the wilt in this state makes it undoubtedly one of the worst enemies of the potato grower, especially as it is hard for many growers to realize, that while the present years crop may not be badly damaged, by planting the irnfecteec tubers the following year tne stand will probavly be very poor anda the yield materially reduced. Thus it is seen that tne disease is of tne greatest economic importance in this state especially in those sections where the growing of potatoes tor seed is being conducted, and it should be considered as such, vecause of the great ditficulty in eradicating the trouble from the fields after it has once gained a foot hold. 19. FIEYV.D OBSERVATIONS. Early last fall it was decided to conduct a system of potato seed inspection and certification in this state by the cooveration of the Michigan State Potato Association and the Michigan Agricultural College. The writer attempted to conduct this work and during the month of September and October many of the ost important seed potato producing centers were visited personally, in both the Upper and Lower Peninsulas. A general survey of the potato diseases in the state were obtained in this way and the widespread nresenceof the Fusarium wilt was noted and the particular condition of the infected fields was observed by tne writer and accordingly was made tne subject of special atudy in the field and the coOntinuence of the work on the »roblem during tne winter. Tne following data were ovtii ned py tne writer during September and October, one examination being made just vetore digging time, Only tnose lields were examined that were being grown for seed, so that the nercentage of diseace taken trom these fields would probably not be ase hign as an average of the entire potato crop of the state. It waa impossihle to make examinations of all tue potato growing sections in the state bu. tnose counties which were examined are probably afair avcrage for the entire state. Two counties were examined on the Upper Peninsula; the principal potato 20. “rowing sections in the northern part of the Lower Peninsula as well as St. Clair county in the southeast and several isolated fields of the larger growers in the central and western sections, METHOD OF TABUT.ATION., . Tne percentage of infection in a one- half acre field was obtained by a close examination of about 300 tops, a short examination of the entire field, and by digging up three or four groups of 10 consecutive hiils in various parts of the fild to obtain a good average. In all the hills dug up a cross section was made of the stem end of tne tuber and alego of the main stem of the plant a short distance above the tuber, and sections further up the stem were made to determine how far up the stem che fungus advarced. On larger fields a greater mmber of plants were examined, in propor.ion to the size of tne field. Tne percentage of slight iwfection does not relate to the depth of infection in the tuber but indicates tuat the plant was fully matured, all tubens tormed, no wilting of the tops occuring and no material damage to the crop could be seen, although the browing of the vascular system in the stem and tuber was present, Tne percentage of serious infection indicates that the Plant had witted and died before the tubers had matured thus greatly decreasing the yleid. the field indicated and would was taken 21. Total infection indicates that all hills in showed infection, either slightly or serious as in the tables. Tnis is simvoly an approximation vary trom 85 % - 100 %. In all the examinations the entire tield as the unit and not the acreage, Cle ALPENA COUNTY. yi ¥ slight serious other frost date — Now Acres-Variety-infect.-infect.-disease-killed-inspection. Late 1% I.- +-Petoaky-- trace-e- —mae ee -slighte noee Sept. el. Rural , 2.-I4- N.Y. ow ® r " " ne 3-H ” 2% * e ° " . Late 4.-8 -Petosky-- 5% " " " Oct. 25. 5,