swe B Oph. UTILITY AND ECONOMY atts Dil miele mee ere DWELLING HOUSE For Degree oF C. E, ae Lh cea ais - 1 3 vi! 7) wD 5 . : 4 The Utility and Economy of the Reinforced Concrete Dwelling House. Thesis For The Degree of Civil Engineer at The Michigan Agricultural College 1913 by fw eS Maurice ¥-Jongeon. THESIS The Utility and Economy of the Reinforced Concrete Dwelling House. The object of this thesis, is, as the title implies, to show the adaptability of reinforced concrete to modern dwelling house construction, to show some of the methods of designing and constructing, and to give a comparison of the cost of this with other house building materials. Many of the so-called concrete houses have concrete side walls with roof, partitions and floors entirely of wood. Such buildings have few advantages over the frame structure and should not be classified as a reinforced concrete dwelling. Experience and tests show that reinforced concrete is particularly well adapted to all kinds of construction. It is used for foundations, walls, columns, beams, floors, and for nearly every detail of construction. It is not only strong and durable but its plasticity lends it to ornamental purposes as well. It becomes harder with age, never decays, does not need repairs and be made water proof, and is practically fire proof. At present it seems to be the practical building material for nearly every requirement of building construction. It has a larger range of possibilities than any other building material. Materials for its construction are available in nearly every locality, and the fact that it can be cast into nearly every con- ceivable shape right on the job makes it a building material of many advantages. For many years men have becn making a study of the best and most economical house building material to secure permansn- cy, durability, and comtor hoagie materials have been tried With more or less satisfactory results but most of our house construction up to the present time has been more or less of the mushroom order and easily destroyed by fire and elements. Concrete, however, comes nearer the solution of the problem than any other material. When properly mixed and handled it should stand for hundreds of years and with each succeeding year it forms a more perfect bond the better to withstand fire, floods, earthquakes, and all conditions of the weather. Con- crete is a nonconductor of heet, therefore houses built of this material will be warmer in the winter and cooler in the Summer. They are also vermin proof and if properly built they come the nearest to being germ and dust proof, which should be no small item in deciding on a material for house construction. The initial cost of these houses leads one to believe that they are not the most economical. In some cases they are not, perhaps. In building houses to sell, a larger percent of profit would probably be rezlized from a wooden frame structure than from concrete. Where permanency is desired, however, there are several things to consider in determining the most economical material. Fire insurance, repairs, and painting should be notning at ell in a concrete dwelling, which in a few years would more than offset the actual difference in first cost. Besides this the safety of such a structure sgseinst all sorts of emergencies to ones family, furniture and valuables is a big item in its favor. There are very few, if any, disadvantages to be overcome in the use of concrete for house construction, unless perhaps it is the difficulty of securing competent and experienced workmen, which is an item that should not be over- looked. When considered from all viewpoints, however, concrete seems to be the nearest to the ideal house building material. Time alone can decide the style of architecture that will prevail. Concrete adapts itself to any form of plastic design and lends itself to almost every conceivable style. The more modest houses will undoubtedly follow the straight line patterns with few exterior decorations, except for vines, shrubs, etc., which lend a great deal to the beauty of concrete houses that might otherwise be plain and unattractive. There is a wide range of possibilities in tne finishimg of outside walls. Surfacing may be carried on by the use of a false partition of sheet steel held in place an inch away from the rough wall,and the space between filled with the finishing mixture. This operation is carried on at the same time that the wall is being constructed. By removing the partition before the wall sets the facing mixture adheres to the wall. The same results may be obtained by spading the concrete back from the front of the forms and introducing the finishing material which at once unttes with the wall. These finishing mixtures, usually a l to 2 mixture, may be a plain or colored cement mortar or composed of cement and aggregates of broken stones, brick, or gravel, depending on the color and texture desired. After the forms are removed the joint marks and impressions of the grain of the wood will be retained on the wall. These disfigurenents must be removed before an acceptable finish is obtained. This may be accomplished in different ways. The outer film of cement ~3e is scrubbed or brusned from the surface exposing some of the agsregate and leaving a very pleasing surface. This scrubbing or brusning must be undertaken within twenty-four hours of the time the concrete is poured into the forms, and while the con- crete is still green. For this reason the walls cannot be carried to any considerable height at one operation and the forms must be so arranged that they can be readily removed. If for any reason the forms cannot be removed before the concrete is set and too hard to surface by scrubbing or brushing with a wire brush, some method of tooling the surface may be employed. Hammering, picking, and sand blasting are used to good effect. These methods require care and experience in using them. The ageresate inay be disturbed by hammering or picking, while the sand blast will cut too deep in soft spots and not deep enough where the surface is harder, thus weakening the walls. If the walls are to be surfaced by scrubbing it is customery to pour about two feet of concrete at a time, removing the forms as soon as the concrete is stiff enough to stand alone. Tne surfacing mixtures may vary in color from white, obtained by the use of white cement, to several shades of gray and slate, obtained by the use of coloring mixed as follows:- The ingredients should be mixed with the cement while dry. (Any concrete excepting that colored by crushed rock will fade with age.) In the following table the mortar is ge 1 to 2 mixture:- Material +# per 10O# Cement 44 per 100# Cement Lamp Black Light slate Dark Blue Slate Prussian Blue Light green slate Bright blue slate Ultra Marine Blue Bright blue slate Yellow Ocher Lignt green Light buff Burnt Umber Light pinkish slate Chocolate Venetian Red Slate, pink tinge Dull pink Red Iron Ore Pinkish slate Light brick red. A concrete made of granite screenings and mixed comparatively dry gives a good mortar to be used in the above mentioned metnod of surfacing. Stucco may be applied directly to the concrete in sur- facing the outer walls. In order to secure an even color, if coloring is used, a large amount should be mixed dry and water added to such quantities as will be immediately needed. This prevents unevenness of color caused by mixing small batches. Surfaces that are floated or troweled may show slight variations in color due to differences in troweling. Freezing will change the color of stucco, as will sunlight and cloudy wet weatner. Stucco should not be applied in freezing weather. If the water freezes before the cement has set the stucco will not harden. Stucco is not the most economicel surfacing for concrete walls, as much the same effects may be obtained from other methods wnich require less time and material and are more durable. The roof of a concrete house should be flat. The pitching of residence roofs at a steep angle was originally to ~Aa make a shingle roof rain proof. Considering the preponderence of the shingle roofs over those of any other material it is not surprising that the pitched roof should become our standard. The concrete slab roof does not require such construction. It should be pitched enough to carry off the rain and if necessary add a parapet or other architectural features. This will make it possible to use the roof much as our porches are now used. Such a roof would not be feasible with timber, but with concrete it is simple and most economical. The concrete house, whether it has block or monolithic walls should have, not only the reinforced roof, but reinforced walls and stairs as well, and these without the wooden surface. Such construction adds to the fire proof qualities of the house and is cleaner and more sanitary. By removing the rugs the house may be flushed out with the hose, removing the dirt more easily tnan in any otner way. Concrete conveys the sound quite readily, so if the floors are to be used without rugs over them it is better to construct the floor by combining the concrete with hollow tile. The hollow tile are laid in rows about four inches apart and in the space between are built reinforced concrete beams. A layer of concrete is then placed over the entire surface. If a wood floor is desired wooden sleepers are embedded in the top layer of concrete to which the flooring is nailed. For interior non-supporting walls, plastering over metal lath is probably one of the most economical methods of construction ; Companies manufacturing the metal lath also make a metal studding to be used with it so no wood need enter into the construction. Two rough and heavy coats of plaster, followed by a coat of hard plaster, makes a very good partition. The expanded metal is also used in floor and roof con- struction but it is not as well adapted to stress analysis as some other methods. The metal lath may also be used for outer wall construc. tion, but it is generally so used in connection with wooden floors and a semi fire proof construction. To overcome the cost of constructing forms for concrete beams and floor slabs, a metnod of casting these structural men- bers in standard sizes has been devised. Concrete floor joists. and slabs are made and delivered by the manufacturer and set and finisned by the builder. When beam and slab are built at tne same time so there is no crack between them, a portion of the slab may be considered as acting with the upper portion of the beam in compression. In this way the quantity of concrete necessary for safety may be very much reduced. The theory of design is similar to that of the rectan- gular bean, tnet is, the unner portion takes the compression and tne lower portion takes tne tension. In the design of a T beam the tnicxness of the flange is determined by the thickness of slab required to a2Ne- to support its load and the width of flange to use is selected in accordance with empirical rules. The width is limited on either side to four times the depth of the slab, for heavy work, for house construction, however, this ratio might be slightly increased and still be within safe limits. In the following let ds depth of T beam from compressed surface to center of steel in inches t #« thickness of flange in inches b » breadth of stem in inches t d- 2 + moment arm, the depth from center of slab to steel. VY ss total vertical shear iM. bending moment in inch pounds Fs 2 allowable unit tension in steel in pounds per sq. inch. r = ratio of unit cost of steel in place to unit cost of concrete in place. AS 2 cross section of steel in square inches. Using the given notation the following formula determines the cross section of the web for shear. b! (ae ET 0 (120 - Max. allowable unit shear) Formula for determining the economical depth of a T beam (4B) se In using this formula different widths are assumed and d d calculated. (The ratio of b should never be less than 2. ~2l- Formula for determining sectional area of steel ina TT beam M As » Fs (ad - * ) 2 In solid concrete beams horizontal shear need not be considered. Design of T Beam for ceiling of living room to support wall above. Span 16' - 3" Distance between beams 8! - 4" C to C. Live locd 150; per sq. ft. Assuned dead lo.d 50}/ per sq. ft. " " " of beam 2CC# per ft. Total logd ver running foot of beam, 2200; Using same notation as in preceding work. wi 2200 X 16.25 XK 16.25 xX 12 . 560,000 If = Le = Le Reaction at supports = V = 17,500. To find breadth of flanse take 8 times the thickness of slab nlus breadth of stem of beam (assumed 10 inches). b =(8 X 4) 10 = 42 in. febt 2650 X 42 X 4 -# 109 200 Assumed ratio — . 3 Using these valves with table on nase 225 of Taylor and Thomson's Reinforced concrete the minimum depth is 10 inches. oo) enw Using formula for most economical depth. ~ rv (d= 2 =f fsb! Using re 70 Ki = 560,000 fs = 16,000 bt = 10" t2 32" t 70 X 560,000 (d - 2 *~ “i6,000 xX 10 d = 16; " Cross section deternined by shear. t 17, 500 bi(a-D = YSo. =~ Teo * 148 d - 163" make e 1" (covering for steel) h 2 1730 M Sectioned area of steel AS = fa(i~t-) 560 , OOO - 16,000 X 154 - 23 Use 4 rods 7/8" in diameter two bent up to lup over top of support. In a continuous beam the negative moment over posts is the same as the vnositive moment