Sex and individual differences in agonistic behavior of spotted hyenas (crocuta crocuta) : effects on fitness and dominance
Agonistic behavior can be observed across all taxa arising from a common need to compete over limiting resources. Within species, individual variation of agonistic behavior can allow individuals to acquire and maintain limiting resources leading to higher reproductive success or fitness. However, what is often overlooked in studies of agonistic behavior is submissiveness, and how this aspect of agonistic behavior relates to aggressiveness. Further, historical studies of agonistic behavior among social mammals are biased towards studies of male agonistic behavior, often ignoring aspects and effects of female agonistic behavior. Here, I address these knowledge gaps through a long-term study of a free living highly gregarious mammal, the spotted hyena (Crocuta crocuta). Spotted hyenas offer an excellent model system for studying variation in aggressive and submissive behavior within individuals and between sexes, as they live in complex societies formed around a female dominated, or matrilineal, hierarchy that is enforced through constant agonistic interactions. For this dissertation, I utilized 30 years' worth of consistently recorded behavioral data collected by Dr. Kay E. Holekamp and her team from free living hyenas residing within the Masai Mara National Reserve, Keyna. Because this dissertation involved many collaborations with other scientists, I use "we" throughout this abstract to describe participation in each chapter. In Chapter 1, we describe sexually dimorphic traits within spotted hyenas that fit common mammalian patterns, as well as numerous traits that violate mammalian norms, including sex differences in agonistic behavior. In particular, adult female spotted hyenas are significantly more likely to emit unsolicited acts of aggression down the hierarchy than adult breeding males, and females do so significantly more ferociously, or intensely. For Chapter 2, we analyzed rates and intensities of unprovoked aggressive and submissive acts emitted by adult females to determine if these two behaviors were individually consistent, as well as testing the hypothesis that these two behaviors may represent separate traits within individuals. Here we found that the intensity at which females emit aggressive and submissive behaviors are consistent, and that these traits were not correlated within individuals. Further, both consistent aggressive intensity and submissive intensity were correlated to adult female fitness, such that individuals expressing high or low extremes of these behaviors had lower annual offspring survival. Then in Chapter 3, we assessed drivers of female dominance within spotted hyenas. Within this chapter we tested two hypotheses 1) that intrinsic sex differences in agonistic behavior drives female dominance and/or 2) social support facilitates female dominance in this species. Further, we assessed these hypotheses among juvenile age classes to determine if drivers of female dominance occurred prior to sexual maturity and subsequent male dispersal. We found that females are intrinsically more aggressive both as cubs and adults, and adult males more submissive whether provoked or not. Further, social support during agonistic encounters is more likely to occur when acting against a female than a male, and adult females can dominate males with or without support. In completion, my dissertation provides interesting insights to sexual and individual variation on agonistic behavior among a social mammal.
Read
- In Collections
-
Electronic Theses & Dissertations
- Copyright Status
- Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International
- Material Type
-
Theses
- Authors
-
McCormick, S. Kevin
- Thesis Advisors
-
Holekamp, Kay E.
- Committee Members
-
Getty, Tom
Lonstein, Joe
Braasch, Ingo
- Date Published
-
2022
- Subjects
-
Spotted hyena--Behavior
Aggressive behavior in animals
Sex differences
Dimorphism (Animals)
- Program of Study
-
Zoology - Doctor of Philosophy
- Degree Level
-
Doctoral
- Language
-
English
- Pages
- xiv, 147 pages
- ISBN
-
9798841725558
- Permalink
- https://doi.org/doi:10.25335/jq4h-6z77