INFORMATION TO USERS This material was produced from a microfilm copy of the original document. While the most advanced technological means to photograph and reproduce this document have been used, the quality is heavily dependent upon the quality off the original submitted. The following explanation of techniques is provided to help you understand markings or pa tterns which may appear on this reproduction. 1. The sign or “target" for pages apparently lacking from the document photographed is “ Missing Page(s)“. If it was possible to obtain the missing page(s) or section, they are spliced into the film along with' adjacent pages. This may have necessitated cutting thru an image and duplicating adjacent pages to insure you complete continuity. 2. When an image on the film is obliterated with a large round black mark, it is an indication th at the photographer suspected that the copy may have moved during exposure and thus cause a blurred image. You will find a good image of the page in the adjacent frame. 3. When a map, drawing or chart, etc., was pert off the material being photographed the photographer followed a definite method in “sectioning" the material. It is customary to begin photoing a t the upper left hand com er of a large sheet and to continue photoing from left to right in equal sections with a small overlap. If necessary, sectioning is continued again — beginning below the first row and continuing on until complete. 4. The majority of users indicate th at the textual content is of greatest value, however, a somewhat higher quality reproduction could be made from “photographs" if essential to the understanding of the dissertation. Silver prints of “ photographs" may be ordered at additional charge by writing the Order Department, giving the catalog number, title, author and specific-pages you wish reproduced. 6. PLEASE NOTE: Some pages may have indistinct print. Filmed as . received. Xerox University Microfilms 900 North Zaob Road - Ann Arbor. Michigan 48KM I 74-19,887 VAIL, Harry David, III, 1943SPIDERS ASSOCIATED WITH DWELLINGS IN MICHIGAN WTIH SPECIAL BflHASIS ON THE PREDATORY BEHAVIOR OF CHIRICANIHIUM INCLUSUM HENTZ CARANEAE:CLUBIUNU3AKJ.----------Michigan State University, Ph.D., 1974 Zoology University Microfilms, A XEROXCom pany, A nn Arbor, Michigan SPIDERS ASSOCIATED WITH DWELLINGS IN MICHIGAN WITH SPECIAL EMPHASIS ON THE PREDATORY BEHAVIOR OF CHIRICANTHIUM INCLUSUM HENTZ (ARANEAE:CLUBIONIDAE) By Harry David Vail III A DISSERTATION Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Zoology 1974 ABSTRACT SPIDERS ASSOCIATED WITH DWELLINGS IN MICHIGAN WITH SPECIAL EMPHASIS ON THE PREDATORY BEHAVIOR OF CHIRICANTHIUM INCLUSUM HENTZ (ARANEAE:C L U B I ONIDAE) By Harry David Vail III Of the more than 371 species of spiders reported from M i c h i g a n , 106 <28.5%) were captured from dwellings. Twelve species were found to represent 51.5% of the 1147 specimens captured. These species were from six families, three w e b spinners and three non-web spinners. Analysis indicated that the spider numbers fluctuated during a cal­ endar year to produce two distinct peaks. One peak was generally larger and termed the major peak, with the smaller peak termed the minor peak. The two peaks were observed during the spring and fall with a period of decreasing numbers of animals d u r ­ ing the summer and winter. The majority of the 12 spe­ cies exhibited spring major peaks and fall minor peaks with reduced numbers during the summer months. Examina­ tion of the individual species indicated that the mature females and immature forms were dominant during the major­ ity of the year. Mature males were in low numbers during Harry David Vail III the spring and summer and disappeared completely during the fall, winter and early spring months. Spider bites confirmed during the study occurred during those periods when both the spiders and humans were about in greatest numbers. Though considered as serious by the individual, the bites were diagnosed as not seri­ ous by medical doctors, producing slight local swelling and an itching sensation which persisted for only a few days. The survey of buildings at the local level revealed that the most common species were the same as those found during the state wide survey. Seven species accounted for more than 60% of the 3346 specimens captured. These seven species were from four families representing two w e b *• *■ spinners and two non-web s p i n n e r s . The same peak phenomena were observed in all three building types and the same re­ lationships between males, females and immatures. There appeared to be no affect exerted by the build­ ing type on the species composition, but an effect was noticed on the relative densities of the individual species. The three weather parameters measured indicated that the outside temperature exerted a force on the spiders causing an increase in numbers found indoors. The inside temperature and the relative humidity allowed the animals to survive once the move was made. Harry David Vail III The predation studies on Chiricanthium inclusum Hentz indicated that short contact distances coupled with random search patterns necessitated traveling in excess of one half mile by mature male specimens. Mature females and immature forms traveled proportionally less. These nocturnal animals were found to use and re-use resting cells depending on the prey density and the distances traveled from the previously constructed cell when the light levels suppassed 10 to 12 foot candles. The prey preferred by these animals were soft bodied with a high moisture content and low mobility. Prey sizes selected by the animals could be altered by the hunger state of the animals and the sizes of the prospective prey. flexible. The numbers of prey eaten was not as When the animals were satiated, the number of prey present had no effect on the number killed. Animals that were hunger stressed would eat until apparently satiated and then would not attack and kill further. In­ creases in prey densities served to reduce the time to initial capture as did the increase in the numbers of predators. These spiders did not exhibit cannabalism in the test chambers or in the rearing chambers as long as the food levels were maintained at levels above starvai tion. There was a distinct avoidance reaction by the animals towards one another even when the densities were quite high. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS My thanks go to Dr. T. Wayne Porter, who, while serving as my major professor, helped instill in me his interest in Invertebrate Zoology, and to Dr. J. Alan Holman for the financial support provided while working as a research assistant under his direction at the Michi­ gan State University Museum. My deep appreciation goes to Dr. Richard J. Sauer for his time and efforts expended in my behalf. His un­ selfish expenditure of both scientific resources and moral support helped make this project enjoyable and re­ warding. Our discussions, both scientific and non- scientific', were of great value during my time spent as a student of "spiders." Especial thanks go to Dr. Dean L. Haynes. His in­ sight into biological problems and his philosophy regard­ ing scientific excellence will always be remembered. His sharing of both valuable time and resources helped make this study complete. Finally, I w o u l d like to thank m y wife Dana. With out her patience and understanding during this period, the thesis project and educational background needed for professional excellence would not have been reached. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF T A B L E S ..................................... V LIST OF F I G U R E S ..................................... vi LIST OF P L A T E S ........................................ viii INTRODUCTION ......................................... 1 MATERIALS AND METHODS ............................... 4 State-wide Study ........................... Local Quantitative Study ..................... Predatory Behavior of Chiricanthium inclusum Hentz ........................... Predator .................................. Rearing ...................................... P r e y ......................................... Rearing the P r e y ........................... A p p a r a t u s .................................. Experimental Design ........................ 4 6 7 7 8 10 13 14 17 R E S U L T S ............................................. 25 State-wide Survey ........................... 25 Local Quantitative Study ..................... 43 Wooden Building ............................... 55 Brick B u i l d i n g s ............................... 66 Predatory Behavior ........................... 77 Prey Contact Distance ..................... 77 Effects of Light on Hunting Behavior . . 77 ..................... 81 Prey Moisture Content Search Patterns ........................... 85 Resting Cell S t u d y ........................ 89 Effects of Prey Size . . . . . . . . 97 Distances Traveled Study ..................... 101 Prey Density S t u d y ............................... 105 D I S C U S S I O N ............................................. Ill Page A P P E N D I C E S ............................................. 129 LIST OP R E F E R E N C E S .......................................138 iv LIST OF TABLES Table 1. 2. 3. Page Taxonomic Listing of Spiders Received from the State-wide Survey ........................ 26 Twelve Most Frequently Received Species from State-wide Survey ..................... 36 Number of Individuals Per Sex in the Top Twelve Species ............................... 40 4. Taxonomic Listing Local Spider Survey 5. Sex Breakdown for Five Species Most Fre­ quently Captured in Metal Buildings . . . 52 Numbers of Spiders per 100 Square Feet in Two Metal B u i l d i n g s ........................ 56 Sex Breakdown for Seven Species Most Fre­ quently Captured in Wooden Building . . . 63 Numbers of Spiders per 100 Square Feet in Wooden Building ............................... 65 Sex Breakdown for Five Most Frequently C a p ­ tured Species in Brick Buildings . . . . 74 Numbers of Spiders per 100 Square Feet in 10 Brick B u i l d i n g s ............................ 75 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. . . 45 Time to Initial Capture for Predators in Different Densities and Prey in Different D e n s i t i e s .......................................... 107 v LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. Page Map of Michigan showing counties in which agents participated in state-wide survey and number of specimens received from each c o u n t y ................................... 30 Mean monthly temperatures compared with percentages of spiders sent in by county a g e n t s ...................................... 32 Numbers of spiders broken down by sex and maturity level by the month for state­ wide s u r v e y ................................... 37 Temperatures both inside and outside metal buildings with relative humidity inside buildings compared with monthly changes in spider numbers captures ..................... 47 Proportional breakdown by sex and maturity level of most frequently each of the top twelve species................................ 50 Temperatures both inside and outside wooden building and relative humidity inside building compared with monthly changes in spider numbers captures ..................... 58 Proportional breakdown by sex and maturity level of seven most frequently captured species in wooden building ................. 60 Temperatures inside and outside brick buildings and relative humidity inside buildings compared with monthly changes in spider numbers captured ................. 67 Percentages of total numbers of spiders collected from five most numerous species from brick b u i l d i n g s ........................ 70 Numbers of spiders remaining active before and after starvation observed at different foot candle l e v e l s ........................ 79 vi Figure 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. Page Three graphs showing numbers of individual dying for each of three hunger stress p e r i o d s ...................................... 82 Graph showing deviation from mean value of 20 turns during random search pattern in­ vestigation ................................... 87 Part 1 : Original number of resting cells found with increase over two week period Part 2: Changes in resting cell occupancy and new cell construction rate . . . . 90 Three graphs showing number of spiders returning to resting cells in different sized search areas . . . . . . . . 93 Percent attack rates for three classes of spiders under three hunger stress regimes . 98 Distances traveled by three classes of spiders under six hunger stree regimes . 102 . The three predator densities over avail­ able searching area at different prey d e n s i t i e s ...................................... 108 vii LIST OF PLATES Page Plate 1 . Circular track used to determine distances traveled by experimental spiders . . . . viii 15 INTRODUCTION Spiders, since time immemorial, have held a spe­ cial place in man's mind as an animal to be feared and/or destroyed. Evidence for these beliefs are legend. For example, a Mediterranean dance called the Tarantela was thought to offset the effects of the bite of an aggressive lycosid spider native to the region, but for which the tarantula has been named and blamed. Another example is the small black spider the Indians of California called "The one with long black fingers that causes sickness," more commonly known as the Black Widow. childrens nursery rhyme, Or perhaps the "Little Miss Muffet," which can be traced to a 19th century incident recorded by an English physician and father regarding an incident involving his daughter. Most of the existing information about the occurance of spiders within dwellings is generally found scat­ tered in the locality portions of species descriptions. Bits of such information can be found in Kaston (1948), Levi (1955,1957,1959,1962,1963,1966,1968,1972), Chamber- lain (1933), Dondale others. (1961), Gertsch (1949) and countless There has been little or no work done to ascribe 1 2 particular species of spiders to particular types of dwe l ­ lings at particular times of the year. Spiders discovered within structures are generally destroyed and/or removed with little regard to the place they hold in the ecologi­ cal community. Predatory behavior, as described by Hoiling (1959), has been applied to a variety of invertebrate predators, including spiders in particular, by Turnbull Haynes (1966), Loughton, Derry and W e s t ska-Prot (1966,1968,1970). (1960,1964), (1963) and Dabrow- Studies involving spider p r e d a ­ tion as a portion of a larger study were conducted by Eberhard (1967), Gardner (1965), Levi (1968), Lovell Moulder et a l . (1970) and Peck and Whitcomb (1970). (1915), The majority of these studies w e r e observations of spiders that constructed a capture w e b and w a i t e d for prey to come to them or spiders that are visually stimulated and hunt with both eyesight and agility. The aspect of foraging that considered either traveling of the spider or moving of the w e b has been in ­ vestigated in the Lycosidae by Turnbull lander (1967). Turnbull (1966) and H o l ­ (1964) described the movements of the web location of Achaeranea tepidariorum (Koch) in response to varying prey densities. A project was proposed to assess associations of spider within human dwellings, w i t h the aim of developing 3 an understanding of the niches spiders have in the animal world as part of the biological community and as sources of biological control of insect pests of man. The study was divided in three main parts: to determine, on a state-wide level, first, the species of spiders that are found within dwellings during the year? second, to determine on a local level the quantitative aspects of both resident and migratory spider populations through the year as related to building type and season of the year; and third, to characterize the predatory behavior of one particular species (Chiricanthium inclusum Hentz) and determine its effects on the resident prey population. MATERIALS AND METHODS State-wide Study The extensive portion of the study was to sample Michigan as efficiently as possible without expending unnecessary time and effort traveling. A method of collect­ ing was proposed in which the County Extension Agents throughout the state were asked to participate. In Febru­ ary, 1972, a letter outlining the proposed project was drafted and sent to the 83 County Agents. Included in the letter was a sample of the data sheet to be completed for each specimen collected and a two dram, neoprene stoppered glass vial which contained 70% ethyl alcohol and a number to designate the county and the s p e c i m e n . Return of an enclosed addressed card with the introductory letter ack­ nowledged willingness of the agent to participate. 83 county agents contacted, 53 sent in specimens. Of the 67 agreed to participate and Immediately upon receipt of the card, a set of 12 vials and data sheets, correspondingly numbered, were forwarded to the agent. As each set of vials was returned, set of 12 ascending numbers and data sheets. another was forwarded with the next Data requested included date of collection, type and location of the dwelling from which the spider was 5 taken/ actual location within the dwelling, if the spider was found in or near a web and if a bite could be associa­ ted with the specimen. A sample of the letter and the data sheet is provided in Appendix A. As soon as spiders began arriving, they were iden­ tified to species and data were assembled on the numbers and species of spiders collected from each county. Then a phylogenetic listing was made with numbers of individuals in each species and sex, including the number of immatures. The data was divided into monthly totals to determine the effects of seasonal changes on the populations present as well as the influence of the building type on the species collected. At the completion of the sampling period, the data for the 12 species received most often were analyzed for the months in which they were collected, sex ratios pres­ ent and building types in which they were most frequently found. The results of this listing will be provided for the County Agents in the form of an Extension Bulletin that will be useful in determining the spider fauna in dwellings. One of the objectives of the study was to monitor the incidence of spider bites that could be traced defin­ itely to a given species. The procedure was for the indi­ vidual to submit the spider to a Michigan State University 6 Extension office and have a medical doctor examine the bite. The doctor would provide a written description of the symptoms, reactions and prescribed treatments admin­ istered to the patient. Of the vast potential for arthropod bites throughout the summer months, very few were actually attributed to spiders. Local Quantitative Study During January, 1972, several attempts were made to contact both city and county agencies in order to estab­ lish a regular sampling program in buildings owned and managed by them. When this failed, the housing authority for the University was contacted and permission obtained to use buildings owned by the University, provided collect­ ing activities did not interfere with their operation. Thirteen buildings were selected from around the campus for a one year study. Beginning in February, 1972, a sampling project was initiated to determine what effects collecting and re­ moval of spiders on a bi-weekly basis would have on the resident populations for a period of one month. Three samples were taken during the month long period and the results were examined using a Chi-Square test. The test showed that sampling with removal did not significantly alter the resident populations when done at intervals of two weeks or longer. Thus a regular biweekly sampling pro­ gram was started in March, 1972, and ended in March, 1973. 7 The data sheets used were modified from the origi­ nal, with the following additional data being recorded: temperatures inside and outside the buildings and rela­ tive humidity inside, all taken with an Atkins Thermistor Psychrometer, Model 3Z02B. Specimens were collected, num­ bered in accordance with data s h e e t s , then brought to the laboratory for identification. The specimens of C. inclusum collected were kept alive in rearing vials Rearing Section) (See Predator for future experimentation. specimens were killed, The other placed in numbered vials and stored for identification at a future date. From the data collected, monthly changes in spider populations were noted as well as changes in the measured weather parameters, in an attempt to relate weather changes with noticeable changes in the spider p o p u l a t i o n s . Through­ out the study, particular attention was placed on C. i nclusum. Predatory Behavior of Chiricanthium inclusum Hentz Predator Chiricanthium inclusum was first described by Hentz in 1875. and Whitcomb The general biology was discussed by Peck (1970). Included in their study were d e s ­ criptions of the life cycle, mating behavior, mean stadium for each instar, general food preferences and the effects 8 of several environmental parameters on development and gen­ eral biology. Rearing Beginning in the fall of 1971, specimens of C. inclusum were collected from buildings on campus and re­ turned alive to the laboratory. Each animal was placed in a 20 dram shell vial stoppered with non-absorbent cotton. Various types of food were offered and after several fa­ miliarization periods by the spiders, one was selected, based on acceptance by the spiders and the ease in which the prey could be maintained in the laboratory. Since the spiders were collected in buildings having relatively stable temperatures, they were maintained in the labora­ tory at room temperature during the winter and spring. As the outdoor temperature increased during the spring and summer, accompanied with a marked rise in the relative humidity, the animals were moved to a controlled tempera­ ture room where the temperature was maintained within a range of 70-75 degrees F. Additional specimens were col­ lected and kept both as experimental animals and as sources of egg supply to raise future experimental animals. Initially, several methods were tried to keep the moisture levels sufficient to maintain the animals. Though Peck and Whitcomb (1970) stated that the normal ranges of relative humidity have no effect on the animals' 9 health, observations tended to indicate that the animals began to lose their ability as hunters when the tempera­ ture and relative humidity increased more than 20 units above that to w h i c h they were accustomed. In a pilot study to determine the amount of humidity change needed to alter the hunting behavior of the spider, it was noted that w h e n the humidity was raised over 20 percent above that to which the animals were accustomed, the distances traveled decreased by as much as 20 percent and the number of prey animals eaten decreased by up to 33 percent. M o ist pieces of paper were placed in the rearing vials, but they dried out rapidly and needed continuous attention. Absorbent cotton was tried, but the residues from the spider meals as well as the fecal materials re­ mained m o i st in the small chambers and resulted in mold and contamination. A method reported by Peck (1970) was tried using a tube with both ends removed and stoppered with cotton for easier cleaning. These tubes were stored in a horizontal manner and required a considerable amount of laboratory space. This method was rejected owing to the lack of storage space. burrow between and escape. Also, C. inclusum was able to the cotton and the glass container side Therefore, only one open end was considered an advantage in reducing the numbers of spiders escaping. Feeding regimens for maintaining the animals were established at three to five m e d i u m sized Tribolium confusum 10 larvae per day. This number was determined by feeding the adult spiders an arbitrary amount, waiting for 24 hours, counting the number of uneaten larvae, halving this number and subtracting it from the original number and giving this amount to the spiders the next meal. When the spiders ate those placed in the chambers without leaving one or two animals uneaten or unattacked, as the daily ration. this number was given The tendency of C. inclusum was not to attack every prey animal placed in the container, and therefore several might be found in the bottom of the con­ tainer depending on the hunger levels of the particular spider. Prey Several types of prey organisms were tried as a source of food and, after some experimentation, was determined as the best one to be used. Peck and Whitcomb T. confusurn According to (1970), the more varied the diet, the better the animals grew and matured. According to their results, a wide variety of animals were introduced to the spiders and after 24 hours the results of their eating or rejecting the prey was compared with the acceptance of Drosophila melanogaster as a test food. dale (personel communication) According to Don- spiders need a period of several days to become accustomed to a newly introduced prey species. Therefore, the testing of prey species was 11 conducted for two weeks in order that one be chosen that was easy to rear in the laboratory, was preferred by the spiders and was of such a form that similar types could be expected to be found within dwellings. The types of prey tested were adult fruit flies, D. m e l a n o g a s t e r y Ants, F o r m i c i d a e ; Milkweed bugs, Oncopeltus fasciatus; Cockroaches, Blatta sp. and Periplaneta sp.; the yellow mealworm, flour beetle, Tenebrio m o l i t o r ; and the confused Tribolium c o n f u s u m . The fruit fly varieties tried were both winged and wingless. Their mobility did not permit the spiders to capture them and so as a potential experimental prey were rejected. Ants were noticed in all the buildings investigated as well as the Natural Science Building. When the ants were placed in a rearing chamber as food for C. i n c l u s u m , the spider became very agitated, and if the number of ants exceeded three or four, they often killed the spider. There was never a time when the spiders were observed eating ants. Several times during the rearing of egg m a s s e s , the ants got into the rearing chambers and carried off eggs or young s p iderlings. Milkweed bugs were tried because of their ease in rearing, but the spiders would not eat either the adults or the smaller nymphs. The rejection of Milkweed bugs 12 could be based on several factors: a hard exoskeleton, a possible taste or odor objection, or perhaps the size of the more mature specimens. One of the few animals observed in the dark were cockroaches. Several species, including the adults and nymphs were tried with the same results as with the M i l k ­ weed bugs. The hard carapace and the speed and agility seemed to deter the spiders in their attack. Mealworms, ranging in size from five to twenty millimeters, were used with varying degrees of success. The adult male spiders were able to kill and eat most of the medium and all of the smaller specimens, but the thick integument and active thrashing of the prey would often deter even the most persistent spider. Smaller adults and immature spiders often were dislodged and w o u l d give up the attack. Flour beetles were tried with the highest degree of success. The adult beetles were not readily accepted due to the hard carapace. The preferred forms were the larvae which were attacked and eaten by all sexes and stages of spiders. Because of the soft bodies of the larvae, there were few parts left when the spider had finished eating. weight. The larvae averaged 63-75% moisture by When these animals were the only food sources, they were divided into three size classes by inspection: 13 small, less than four mm.; medium, large, greater than eight mm. four to eight mm.; The soft bodies, apparent high moisture content and lack of mobility proved them to be good food sources. Rearing the Prey Several one quart jars filled with enriched white flour were inoculated with 25-30 adult beetles and left to reproduce at room temperature. As one culture was maturing, another was begun with adults from the previous culture. To obtain food for the spiders, a portion of the flour was poured onto a wire screen of 60 meshes per inch and the flour sifted. The larvae were sorted, the appropriate size removed for food and the rest returned to the stock culture. effects of crowding, When the cultures began to indicate cannabalism, reduced number of larvae, and many beetles along the side of the jar, the culture was discarded and another begun. Peck and Whitcomb (1970) in their experiments with food preferences, gave the spiders a wide variety of prey organisms from several Phyla and Classes of animals. The preferred organisms were the soft bodied forms, particu­ larly larval forms. of this study. Their data agrees with the results 14 Apparatus Rearing Chambers.--The rearing chambers were 20 dram glass shell vials, stoppered with non-absorbent cotton and stored vertically in racks. Experimental Chamb e r s .— Two types of experimental chambers were used, one for measuring foraging, distances traveled and the other for observing hunting behavior. cage °^~ Glass A. The chamber used to measure foraging distances was a clear plexiglass circular track 48 in­ ches in diameter (Plate 1). B. The chambers for observing hunting behavior were three glass aquaria aind a screened cage. Length 8.5 in. Width 5.5 in. Glass 14 in. Glass 20 in. 10.0 in Screen cage 6.6 ft. 8.0 in. 6.6 ft. Height 6.5 in. 10.0 in. 12.0 in. 6.0 ft. Surface area Ratio 292 square in. 2.02 square ft. 1 664 square in. 4.61 square ft. 2 1120 square in. 7.8 square f t . 4 31,104 square in. 216 square ft. 32 15 Plate 1.— Circular track used to determine distances traveled by experimental spiders. 16 17 L i g h t i n g .— The rearing chambers were placed in a constant temperature room at 70-74 degrees F and maintained on a 14:10 light cycle dark) (14 hours of light and 10 hours of to approximate the normal daylight cycle occuring during the spring, summer and early fall of the year. fore any experiments were begun, Be­ all newly captured ani­ mals were placed in the light room for a minimum of 72 hours to acclimate them to the experimental light cycle. Experimental Design The predatory behavior of C. inclusum Hentz ex­ hibited several basic behavioral attributes which will be examined before the actual predator-prey activities are evaluated. Peck and Whitcomb (1970) stated that C. inclusum Hentz is a nocturnal predator that does not see well dur­ ing its normal hunting period. servations, On the basis of their o b ­ C. inclusum Hentz located its prey by touching it with the extended front legs while moving in a forward direction. To determine what the critical distance is b e ­ tween the predator and prey before the attack, five males, five females and five medium sized immatures were selected and placed one at a time in the five gallon tanks. Small larval forms of T. molitor were placed in the tank at var i ­ ous distances from the rearing chambers containing the spi­ ders. The test was repeated twice for each specimen and i 18 the results compared for the significant distances needed to detect prey. Prey detection, or the detection of any object in the path of the spider, was considered as an act­ ion not related to searching; i.e., pausing with the front legs extended, tapping the encountered object, an avoid­ ance reaction, or a direct attack. To determine the necessary level of light to in­ itiate hunting response, five individuals of each sex and five m e d i u m sized immatures, with two replications each, were placed in a two gallon tank and measurements made of the available light by use of a Wilson Illumination meter model 756 with a quartz filter. their hunting activities, in foot candles. When the animals began the light intensity was recorded To determine the effects of hunger, the same experiment was run again following 72 hours of star­ vation . Following the results of Peck and Whitcomb regarding relative humidity, (1970) an evaluation of the moisture content of their food was made to determine if prey m o i s ­ ture content affected the spiders well being. Fifteen spiders of each sex and 15 medium sized immatures were placed in the constant temperature room at approximately 72 degrees F. The purpose of the test was to determine the moisture requirements necessary to maintain healthy spiders in an environment approximating that found in 19 buildings. Having determined the approximate moisture con­ tent of the prey, a feeding regimen was established so that five of each type of animal were fed what had been determined (See Predator Rearing Section) every three, seven and 10 days. as a normal meal During that time, no water was provided to the spiders. The relative humidity was maintained at approximately 45% with the test being run for six weeks. The numbers of animals dying were an­ alyzed by sex, maturity, and feeding regimens. A study was conducted to determine if the search patterns of the spider were random. Three spiders of each sex and three medium sized immatures were placed in the six by six foot screen cage one at a time and left to acclimate for 24 hours. When the individual spiders emerged after dark to begin their search activities, a 25 watt red light was used to observe and tabulate their movements. The spiders were allowed to wander at will and whenever they turned one way or the other from the direc­ tion they were going, a "1" was tabulated for a left turn and a ”2" was tabulated for a right turn. The spiders were permitted to make 40 turns for each run. cations were made for each animal. Three repli­ In order to determine the effects of locating prey on the search pattern, prey were positioned in such a manner that the spider came upon 20 the prey in as natural a manner as possible. After allow­ ing the spider to feed, the experiment was repeated for 40 more turns, with three replications. The effects of starvation on the search patterns were determined by starv­ ing the spiders for 48 hours and repeating the above ex­ periments . The results were tested using the Wald-Walfowitz Runs Test, outlined in Conover (1971) and Bradley The observations consisted of two types, "a" and "b." random, and The assumptions are (1968) . "1" and "2" or (1) the samples are (2) they are mutually independent of each other, (3) they are continuous. The null hypothesis pre­ dicts that the process that generates the sequence is ran­ dom. The alternative hypothesis is that the variables in the sequence are dependent on other random variables, or they are distributed differently from each other. The test statistic equals the number of runs of like elements, called "T." The "T" value is compared with values in a table prepared by Swed and Eisenhart (1943). For values of ”a" or "b" greater than 20, the formula is y 2ab + 1 + x /2ab(2ab-a-b) a " a+b a yj (a+b) ^ (a+b-1) where x = the quantile values in a standard normal random variable. "TH greater than W signifies acceptance of the null hypothesis. 21 At the outset of the study, an attempt was made to census the C. inclusum population within a building by tabulating the number of resting cells found. This proved unreliable because the spiders may use the same resting cell more than once, or may build two in one 2 4 hour pe­ riod. Therefore, an experiment was devised to test if spiders returned to one cell or, if not, what caused the abandoment of the old cell. Beginning in February, 1972, the resting cells in the basement and first floor of the Natural Science Building were tabulated, the spiders col­ lected and the resting cells removed. The spiders that were used in the test were either adults or penultimate instar animals. They were marked with watercolor paint and released in the same areas in which they were collected. After 24 hours, a new census was made of the marked spi­ ders, and the location of the resting cells recorded. For the next two weeks, a daily count was made of the marked spiders and the location of the resting cells. At the same time as the above experiment was in progress a series of tests were run in the laboratory to determine what effect hunting area size had on the return to the established resting cells. Five spiders of each sex and five medium sized immatures were placed individu­ ally in two gallon chambers and observed for five days under established feeding regimes. The number that 22 returned to the original cells and those that did not we r e recorded. The same procedure was repeated in five gallon and 10 gallon chambers and the 6' x 6* x 6' screened cages. A series of similar experiments were conducted on two lev­ els of predator starvation levels, 48 and 72 hours without food. Prey size and its effects on hunting success whe n associated with predator hunger levels was investigated. Three size classes, designated small, m e d i u m and large, were selected from the prey animals. The small and me d i u m size classes were selected from T. confusum stocks and the large size class was selected from T. molitor stocks. The results of this study were analyzed from three aspects: sex of the spider, hunger levels of the spiders, and prey size, using a two way analysis of variance at three hunger levels as outlined in Sokal and Rohlf (1969). Throughout the study the degree of cannabalism in this species of spider was noted. Whenever spiders were mentioned in the literature, a section was always allowed to cover aspects of one spider feeding on the same or d i f ­ ferent species. Peck and Whit c o m b (1970) stated that the incidence of cannabalism among C. inclusum was the highest among the early instars and decreased markedly in the adult stages. Their experiments were conducted in small glass rearing chambers which affected the normal activities 23 of the spiders. Even the notorious Black Widow is not as cannabalistic if she is offered a choice of food (Gertsch 1949). The next two portions of the study have to do with the effectiveness of the predator at various prey densities and the distances traveled under various hunger regimes. The hunger regimes were satiated, one, two, three, and five days without food. four The individual spiders were placed in the circular test chamber and observed under the red 25 watt light for a full hunting period of 10 hours. The number of complete circuits around the track were tabu­ lated for each animal and the distances calculated. To be sure that the wandering was not a desire to escape, food was introduced at various times on several sample tests. The final portion of the study considered the dens­ ity of prey in relation to the success of the spider in locating food. This was accomplished by increasing hunt­ ing area size and varying prey densities to approach the potential prey densities in the natural environment as op­ posed to the laboratory situation. The prey densities varied from a high of one prey per 14.6 square inches to a low of one prey per 180 square feet. Within each of the experimental chambers, prey were placed in a random manner at densities of one, two, four, eight and 20 animals per 24 search area. The random placement of prey was determined by m a rking off the surface area of the chamber into one inch s q u a r e s , numbering them in a consecutive manner and locating the squares to hold prey by drawing random num­ bers from a random numbers table. The animals were fastened to the side of the chambers with small pieces of masking tape. At the same time that the prey density portion of the study was being conducted, the effects of intraspecific non-prey organisms on hunting success was determined by increasing the number of the number of predators from one to two and then to four within the same area. of experiments was run for males. of three replications each. Each set There were five sets The results were analyzed using a three by three factorial design in examining the effects of search area size, prey density, predator density and the inherent interactions. RESULTS State-wide Survey The 114 7 spider specimens taken from inside buldings throughout the state represent 16 families, 196 species (Table 1). 65 genera and Appendix B contains the numerical code developed for the spiders collected during this study. Figure 1 illustrates the 53 counties in which the county agents participated. The numbers in each county indicate the total number of specimens collected in that particular county. Appendix B lists the specimens received from each county in alphabetical order with the county code as used by the Michigan State Extension Service. Of the 16 families, nine were web spinners and seven were non-web spinners. Web spinning families were represented by the Theridiidae, Pholcidae, Araneidae, Linyphiidae, Scytodidae, Age l e n i d a e , T e t r a g n a t h i d a e , Dictynidae and the A m a u r o b i i d a e . The non-web spinning families were represented by the Erigonidae, Gnaphosidae, Lycosidae. Pisauridae, Clubionidae, Drew and Sauer Salticidae, Thomisidae and the (unpublished data) credit M i c h i ­ gan with 23 families of spiders which contain 153 genera and 371 species. The state-wide survey represnted 69.5% of the potential families, 42.4% of the potential genera 25 TABLE 1.— Taxonomic Listing of Spiders Received from the State-wide S u r v e y . Theridiidae Steatoda n---II IV Theridion Crustulian Unknown Achaeranea Latrodectus If Erigonidae Hypselistes Erigone Unknown Dictynidae Salticidae Phidippus II Salticus Sitticus fl fl Pholcidae Gnaphosidae Eris Metaphidippus Maevia Habrocestum Metacyrba Icius Unknown Pholcus Spermophora Zelotes II Herpyllus Gnaphosa fl Pisauridae Drassylus II Geodrasus Drassodes Dolomedes II Pisaurina IV borealis triangulosa altera grosa sp. murarium stricta sp. tepidariorum mactans variolus florens sp. sp. sublata sp. audax regius scenicus palustris floridanus pubescens marginatus sp. inclemens pulex undata sp. sp. phalangoides meridionalis subterraneus hentzi ecclesiasticus muscorum sp. nigar depresus sp. sp. tenebrosus sexpunctatus mira sp. 27 TABLE 1.— (continued). Araneidae Araneus II VI II II It II II II Argiope Clubionidae Neoacona Coneipeira Aramella Gea Chiricanthium Castaneira Clubiona 71------ Trachelas n------ Thomisidae Acfroeca Misumena Philodromis n-------II II II II II Xysticus It It Coriarachne Misumenops cornutus sericatus diadematus marmoreus cavatica undata dlademia dumetorum P. e. gnxa sp. argentata aurantia minima juniperi displicata heptagon inclusum mildei sp. descripta tnlineata abbottr obesa sp. ruber tranquillas sp. ornata yatia sp. pernix rufus placidus vulgaris w ashita aureolus praelustris sp. elegans ferox funestus lucosta acquiescens sp. sp. oblongus speratus sp. 28 TABLE 1 (continued). Linyphiidae Scytodidae Agelenidae Tibellus n---Thanatus Unknown Pityohyphantes n Lepthy lphan te s Linyphia II Bathyphantes Drapetisca Unknown Scytodes Tegenana Agelenopsis Coras Circurina It Lycosidae Cybaeus Wadotes Lycosa II II II II II II It Pardosa II II Trochosa Tetragnathidae Amaurobiidae Pirata II Geolycosa Tetragnatha Amaurobius Callioplus oblongus maritimus formicinus sp. phrygianus costatus nebulosus marginata sp. pallida sp. sp. thoracica domestica pennsylvanica potteri sp. medicinalis juvenalis sp. pallida sp. sp. calcaratus aspersa av.ida praetensis helluo punctulata gulosa carolinensis frondicola moesta sp. milvina moesta distincta modica sp. terricola sp. insularis sp. missouriensis laboriosa bennetti tibialis sp. 29 TABLE 1.— (continued). Non-spiders Opiliones Chelodnethida Phalangiidae and 28.5% of the potential species recorded in the State of Michigan. Many of the parameters outlined in the materials and methods section regarding habitat type and house type were very difficult to quantify in this portion of the study. Over 94% of the animals returned were from wooden, single family dwellings located in a suburban or rural setting. Thus the other catagories were very poorly rep­ resented and could not be analyzed as effectively. The weather parameter available for all the coun­ ties with a degree of reliability was temperature. Figure 2 presents the variation in air temperature during the study period, with the numbers of specimens received as a percentage of the total for the state. For a period of four months, May through August, spider numbers were in­ versely related to temperature. For the remaining eight months, both curves approximate each other closely. ing this period as the temperature increased, numbers of spiders received, creased, Dur­ so did the and as the temperature d e ­ so did the spider numbers. 30 Figure 1 M a p of Michigan showing counties in which agents participated in state-wide survey and numbers of specimens received from each county. 32 Figure 2.— Mean monthly temperatures compared with percent­ ages of spiders sent in by county agents. ------- Air temperature ------ Animals as a percentage of total number (N). 33 70 60 hie 50 10 e 30 Months 34 The months in which spider numbers were directly related.to temperature were also the months in which the most specimens were received. In May, 175 specimens or 15.25% of the total were collected and in September, specimens or 18.6% of the total were collected. 212 When the mean temperature for the state was at a high of 6 8 degrees F., the number of spiders was at a low value of the total) (75 or 6.4% for this four month period. In order that the large numbers of spiders col­ lected could be analyzed in a meaningful manner, the spe­ cies representing more than 50% of the total were analyzed in detail. This decision was made on the basis that many county agents did not collect sufficient numbers of animals to make a valid analysis either by county total or by species in each county. The 12 species selected on the basis of numbers can be found on Table 2. Included are the totals for each species as well as the percentage of the total numbers and the percentage of the total for the 12 species. The 12 species listed represent 591 specimens and 51.5% of the total for this portion of the study. When the 12 species are considered on an individual basis, two main patterns appear. Figure 3 displays the species through the sampling period as actual numbers of specimens received and the makeup by sex and maturity level. 35 The two patterns are the peaks which appear in both AprilMay and September-October. larger than the other, There is generally one peak labeled the major peak. The second pattern is that the major peak may occur either during the spring or during the fall. On the basis of the above observed patterns, the 12 species were separated into spring major and fall major species. The spring major peak species are Tegenaria domes- tica, Steatoda bore a l i s , Chiricanthium inclusum, Phidippus a u d a x , and Salticus scenicus. Thus species having fall major peaks are Achaeranea tepidariorum, Aranea sericatus , Agelenopsis potteri^Trachelas tranquillas, Herpyllus acclesiasticus and Agelenopsis pennsylvanica. Of the spring major peak species, there was only one true web spinner, Steatoda b o r e a l i s . major peak species were examined, When the fall there were two, Achaeranea tepidariorum and Aranea sericatus. When the percentages of males to females were ex­ amined, there were more females than males and immatures combined. The ratios for the individual species (Table 3) ranged from a low of 12 males to 10 females for S. scenicus to a high of two males to 73 females in A. sericatus. When the sex ratios are compared with the major peak data, there is no significant differences between sex ratios from spring peak through fall peak. Any peak can 36 TABLE 2.— Twelve Most Frequently Received Species From State-Wide Survey Species No. Tegenaria domestica 108 9.5 18.2 Achaeranea tepidariorum 90 7.9 15.2 Aranea sericatus 73 6.4 12.3 Agelenopsis potteri 53 4.6 8.9 Steatoda borealis 47 4.1 7.9 Chiricanthium inclusum 47 4.1 7.9 Phidippus audax 43 3.7 7.3 Steatoda triangulosa 38 3.5 6.8 Salticus scenicus 29 2.5 4.9 Trachelas tranquillas 25 2.2 4.2 Herpyllus ecclesiasticus 24 2.0 4.0 Agelenopsis pennsylvanica 22 1.9 3.7 TOTAL 591 % of Total 51.5% % of Top 12 100.0 The number of specimens reported for each of the 12 most numerous species 37 Figure 3.— Numbers of spiders broken down by sex and maturity level by the month for state-wide survey. ;Vf = Female = Male = Immatures 38 20 Tegenaria domestica M N - 108 15 10 If 5 1 »•v«. «, & 0 02 Cfi TT 15 Achaeranea tepidariorum N-90 10 5 J=L *eTi £u Number of Animals (N) 0 15 Aranea aericatus 10 Nm77 n 5 0 ni in m 151 Agelenopsis potter i 10 N «5 3 5 0 H JE B a n J a 1 15 10 H 5 Steatoda borealis N » 47 M QQ 0 ____ - s i . n . 15 10 5 0 Chiricanthium inclusum N-47 I a J F 1973 (5$ • I•t ;• •• •• a. M A M J JZ L JZ L J A S 1972 O N D 39 15 PhIdlppus oudox 10 N * 43 5 JagL O 15 Steatoda borea11s 10 N ■ 3« 5 Hn f l n O Number of Animals (N) 10 Saltlcus scontens 5 N = 29 0 15 Trachelas tranqutI las 10 N » 25 5 S3 a l&S 10 n JZL Herpy11 us occleslasttcus 5 N = 24 O aun it Agelenopsis ponnsyIvan lea s r~i J bbL J F 1973 A mM nJ 1972 r N= J 22 A S nn O N D 40 TABLE 3.— Number of Individuals Per Sex in the Top Twelve Species • Species Cf Tegenaria domestica 46 42.5 42 38.9 17 18.9 Imm. Total 20 18.5 108 18.3% 69 76.5 4 4.5 90 15.2% 2 2.6 74 96.0 1 1.4 77 13.0% 9 17.0 40 75.5 4 7.5 53 8.9% 6 17.0 33 70.0 13.0 47 7.9% Chiricanthium inclusum 15 32.0 18 38.3 14 29.7 47 7.9% Phidippus audax 17 39.5 26 60.5 Steatoda triangulosa 7 18.4 22 12 10 41.5 34.5 Achaeranca tepidariorum Aranea sericatus Agelenopsis potteri Steatoda borealis 8 Salticus scenicus Trachelas tranguillas 6 24.0 Herpyllus ecclesiasticus Agelenopsis pennsylvanica Totals % 9 58.0 0 0 43 7.3% 9 23.6 38 6.4% 7 24.0 29 4.9% 19 76.0 0 0 25 4.2% 10 12 2 41.7 50.0 8.3 24 4.1% 7 31.8 7 31.8 8 22 36.4 372 156 62.9 26.4 3.7% 75 12.1 591 The b o t t o m row of figures associated w i t h each spe­ cies represents percentages of males, females and immatures of each species total. 41 be examined and the major peak, whether spring or fall, will consist primarily of females. Only S. triangulosa and A. pennsylvanica are represented by having immatures as the dominant group. In examining the most frequently occurring species the top nine are found within dwellings through more than 10 months of the year. These species over winter either as penultimate instars or as mature females. Spider bite data was collected in conjunction with the State-wide study and produced a total of 18 suspected bites. The frequency of bites was plotted over the year long survey and the bites occurred at two peak periods dur­ ing the year. The first peak occurred during May which is the month when the spider population is the highest, accounted for eight bites. and August, the second peak of the year for the spider populations, was also the second peak in number of six bites reported. These two periods coincide with several factors im­ portant to man. First, spiders are at their peak densities during these two months and secondly, people are out and active during these months, placing themselves in close contact with potential pests. Of the 18 suspected bites, only four were confirmed by capturing the animals during the biting and having a m e d i ­ cal doctor confirm the bite and describe the symptoms and 42 treatments. Of the four, two were C. inclusum, another was a pisaurid and the third was an unknown species not collected or seen by me but which accounted for possible complications leading to the death of a senior citizen. Of the two C. inclusum bites, one was on the naval of a woman and caused an itching sensation and a small red weal which persisted for several days. The treatment pre­ scribed was penicillin and a bee sting antivenom. The sec­ ond bite was on the finger of a woman sleeping in bed, who awoke following a sharp stinging sensation. The same sym- toms were reported and similar treatment prescribed. The symptoms described for bites coincide with the data reported by Furnam and Reeves (1957) . Their data comes from one sus­ pected bite reported in the California Medical Journal from a study done on spider bite venom. The third confirmed bite was made by a mature female Dolomedes tenebrosus, of the family Pisauridae. The bite was on the buttock of a woman and caused a red weal and severe itching which persisted for several days. treatment with penicillin, Following the itching and the weal sub- suded, with no side effects. The final confirmed bite was reported by a young­ ster who saw the spider bite his grandfather. The spider bit the man while he was working on a woodpile near a stream. The spider was killed and the man taken to a local 43 hospital. The man had a history of heart trouble and was in his mid-seventies, so the death cannot be attributed directly to the spider bite, but the v e n o m may have caused complications. From the description given by the grandson and the nearness to water, there is reason to suspect that the spider was a member of the family Pisauridae, though it could have been from the family Lycosidae as both families contain large dark spider species. Local Quantitative Study The sampling at the local level produced 3346 spider specimens representing 12 Families, 32 Genera and 57 Species. Appendix B provides the numerical code used for both the state-wide and local studies. Each building type will be presented separately with the appropriate weather parameters. Table 4 contains the species found in the local sur­ vey, representing 625 specimens from 12 families, 32 genera and 56 species or 18% of the total for the study. The ani­ mals were taken from two metal quanset-hut structures con­ taining 1950 square feet of surface area each or 3900 square feet total. This gives 0.127 animals per square foot per year or 0.0635 animals per square foot per year per building. There were six web spinning families and six non-web spin­ ning families. The web spinning families were the Theridii- dae, Pholcidae, Araneidae, Dictynidae, Linyphiidae and Agelenidae. Non-web spinning families were represented by 44 the Erigonidae, Salticidae, Gnaphosidae, Thomosidae, Clubi- onidae and the Lycosidae. Weather parameters, Figure 4, are shown with the percentage of spiders collected each month. The outside temperature does not follow the inside temperature closely, but there are similar trends observable between the two. The outside temperatures ranged from a low of 26 degrees F in December to a high of 82 degrees F in August, while the temperature inside the building ranged from a low of 67 degrees F in March to a high of 80 degrees F in August. Relative humidity ranged from a low of 46% in February to a high of 85% in August. The total spider population varied with two peaks, similar to those observed in the state-wide survey. The spring major peak occurred in April and the minor peak occurred in August. The major peak accounted for approxi­ mately 19% of the total and the minor peak accounted for 11 %. To facilitate the handling of the data, the same method used in the state-wide survey was used h e r e . The five species representing the most frequently encountered animals were Steatoda triangulosa, Achaeranea tepidarioru m , Chiricanthium inclu s u m , Steatoda borealis and Tegenaria domestica, representing 450 specimens or 72.0% of the 625 total. These five species represent four web spinners and one non-web spinner, Chiricanthium inclusum. 45 TABLE 4.— Taxonomic Listing Local Spider Survey. Family Genus Species Theridiidae Steatoda n---- borealis triangulosa grossa Crustulina stricta Achaeranea tepidariorum Unknown sp. Dictynidae Dictyna sublata sp. Salticidae Phidippus Sitticus II II Salticus Metaphidippus Maevia Metacyrba audax palustris floridanus pubescens scenicus sp. inclemens undata Pholcidae Pholcus Spermophora phalangeides meridionalis Gnaphosidae Herpyllus Zelotes Gnaphesa ecclesiasticus subterraneus muscorum sp. mger depressus sp. cornutus sericatus diadematus cavatica undata diadema dumetorum sp. Araneidae Drassylus II Drassodes Aranea II II 11 II II II II Argiope argentata 46 TABLE 4.— Continued. Family Genus Species Clubionidae Chiricanthium inclusum mildei sp. descripta trilineata abbotti obesa sp. ruber tranquillas sp. fl fl Castaneira ii Clubiona If VI Trachelas IV Thomisidae Misumena Philodromis IV VI II Xysticus •V II Misumenops Unknown Linyphiidae Linyphia vatia pernix rufus placidus vulgaris sp. elegans ferox funestus oblongus sp. sp. Unknown marginata sp. sp. Scytodidae Scytodes thoracica Agelenidae Tegenaria Agelenopsis •1 domestica pennsylvanica potteri sp. medicinalis j uvinalis calcaratus If Coras Wadotes Lycosidae Lycosa avida helluo punctulata moesta sp. 47 Figure 4.— Temperatures both inside and outside metal build­ ings with relative humidity inside buildings com­ pared with monthly changes in spider numbers captured. ....... — - — -------------- inside temperature Outside temperature Relative humidity Percent of spiders occurring each month Degrees F, Percent Relative Humidity Ul 1972 •b. 00 | 1973 Tl Percent of Total 49 Figure 5 represents the monthly breakdown for each species by number of animals and sex proportions. The two peak phenomenon was again present but not to the extent as found in the state-wide survey. The most numerous species, Achaeranea t e p i d a r i o r u m , had one major peak in May and then gradually decreased in frequency from a high of 1 2 speci­ mens to a low of zero in December. Females again proved to be the most numerous, with immatures a very close second (Table 5). Steatoda t r i a n q u l o s a , a tangled web spinner, of which 133 specimens were captured during the survey, displayed a spring peak composed mainly of females. and June, During April, May females and immature forms were captured but no mature males were captured. The preponderance of speci­ mens captured during the early spring were mature females, tapering off in numbers through the fall. of the summer through late summer, F r o m the middle the numbers of immature specimens increased as the numbers of mature specimens d e ­ creased. Chiricanthium i n c l u s u m , a- wandering or vagabond spider, was captured throughout the year, with the majority of the specimens being females. Immature forms were cap­ tured throughout the year, with a peak coming in spring and decreasing through the early summer. both male and female, The mature specimens, followed the same general pattern but 50 Figure 5.— Proportional breakdown by sex and maturity level of most frequently each of the top twelve species. |i * i | = Females □ = Males = Immatures Nunbor o f A n l w l s (N) o . 8 8 E \ 8 8 r £IA'.> -mm*&wam//// > r w,i?A>As&mmm m// wKg£8i8$i& «£■'////' V/ wisssB! <0 N e o ] z ■ u ?&////// ■ ui H ©asi/M^ 33ftH « I T Is- r ■■//// AW/////// V* '■■///// 0 a B 1 o ■> c 3 52 TABLE 5.— Sex Breakdown for Five Species Most Frequently Captured in Metal Buildings Species Females Males Immatures 55 35% 33 21% 33 44% 157 34.9% S. triangulosa 63 47% 37 28% 34 25% 133 29.6% C. inclusum 39 42% 16 17% 37 41% 92 20.4% T. domestica 13 35% 6 18 49% 37 16% 9 30% 5 17% 16 53% 30 6.7% 180 40% 21% A. tepidariorum S. borealis 97 179 39% Sum 8 450 Totals and percentages for the top five species captured in the two metal buildings. .2 % 53 with many fewer specimens. The males were captured in much lower numbers than either the females or the immatures. Steatoda b o r e a l i s , another tangled web spinner, was taken only during seven months of the year. The majority of the specimens were immatures, with mature males taken only during April, July and August in low numbers. The same pattern of numerical increase and decrease was noticed though in a smaller scale regarding males, matures. females and im­ The immatures were the first captured in the early spring, followed by a few matures then and an increase in the numbers of immatures through the fall. Tegenaria domestica, a funnel web spinner, was col­ lected during all but three months of the year. The major peak occurred during April and May, with the minor peak oc­ curring during August. Females were dominant in numbers through the study, with the immature forms captured less frequently and the males captured in the lowest numbers. When the local study was analyzed from the viewpoint of animals per square foot {Table 6 ) several factors became apparent regarding the effects of building type on resident spider populations. type. The results are presented by building In each of the appropriate sections, evaluations were made of the similarities and differences between buildings regarding the numbers of animals per 1 0 0 square feet both by building type and species of spider. To facilitate the 54 evaluation, three periods were selected during the study for detailed analysis. major peak, The three periods were the months of the the minor peak and the month during the summer when the spider densities were lowest. The major peak came during April, accounting for 114 specimens from the five most numerous species collected. The densities ranged from a high of 0.46 animals per 100 square feet for Achaeranea tepidariorum to a low of 0.04 animals per 100 square feet for both Steatoda borealis and Tegenaria d o m e s t i c a . Chiricanthium i n c l u s u m , the third most frequently encountered species, of 0 . 2 2 animals per 1 0 0 occurred in densities square feet. August was the minor peak month with a total of 53 specimens ranging in densities from a high of 0.41 for Achaeranea tepidariorum to a low of 0.0 3 animals per 100 square feet for Tegenaria d o m e s t i c a . Chiricanthium inclusum had a density of 0.09 per 100 square feet. The month of the summer high temperature was July when the temperature reached 81 degrees F. and during which 57 specimens were captured. Achaeranea t e p i d a r i o r u m , again was the most dense with 0.36 animals per 100 square feet. Tegenaria domestica was low with a value of 0.0005 animals per 100 square feet. Chiricanthium inclusum had a density of 0.08 animals per 1 0 0 square feet. 55 The values of the majority of the species changed as expected from one sample period to another. As the tem­ perature changed, so did the animal densities. The two spe­ cies, Steatoda borealis and Tegenaria domestica did not alter their densities in moving from the spring major peak to the summer low density, but did change when moving to the fall minor peak. When the weather parameters are considered with the spider populations found within the metal buildings, several points became clear. First, the temperature inside the buildings seemed to have little effect on either causing invasion by spiders or maintaining the populations once in­ side. The main effect of the inside temperature was that of allowing the spiders to survive once they made the move in. The spider population follows the changes in outside temperature and percent relative humidity. Wooden Building There were 462 specimens taken representing 12 fam­ ilies, 32 genera and 56 species, or 13.8% of the total study. The building sampled was a single story office building located on the Michigan State University campus, containing 1125 square feet. This represented 0.4 09 animals per square foot per year. Figure 6 displays the weather parameters plotted against the monthly spider catch. TABLE 6 .— Numbers of Spiders per 100 Square Feet in Two Metal Buildings. Metal Buildings 1950 Sq. ft. each, 3800 Sq. ft. total. Species Major Peak April 1 2 #/Mo. #/100 sq. ft. Minor Peak August 1 2 #/Mo. #/100 sq. ft. Summer Low Peak 1 2 #/Mo. #/100 sq. ft. A. tepidariorum 35 0.44 17.85 0.23 17 0 .22 S. triangulosa 36 0.46 24 0.31 28 0.36 C. inclusum 17 0.22 7.0 0.09 6.0 0.08 S. borealis 3 0.04 3.0 0.04 0.3 0.004 T. domestica 3 0.04 2.0 0.03 0.4 0.0005 1-The total number of animals taken per month. 2-The number of individuals per 100 square feet of available surface search area during the sample period. 57 The same families were captured in the wooden build­ ing as those found in the metal ones. Therefore the ratio of w e b spinners to non-web spinners was the same, 6 web spinning families to 6 non-web spinners. The inside temperature, ranged from a high of 73 to a low of 6 8 , and did not seem to have any correlation with the numbers of spiders captured. The two parameters which seemed to follow the spider number changes were the relative humidity and the outside temperature. The relative humidity values moved in opposite directions from March to September, then began to move in a similar direction, rang­ ing from a high of 79% to a low of 45%. peratures moved in the same manner. The outside tem­ The time that the spider numbers and the outside temperatures came into close associa­ tion was during the fall of the year. The spiders captured showed two definite peaks in frequency, one during April with 15.5% of the total and another lesser fall peak in September, with 10% of the total. When the most frequently captured species were e x ­ amined on an individual basis came evident. (Figure 7), several facts b e ­ There were seven species making up 282 specimens or 61% of the total. The species found most fre­ quently in the wooden buildings were the same as in the metal buildings with the addition of Agelenopsis potteri and Phidippus a u d a x . The ratio of web spinning species to 58 Figure 6 — Temperatures both inside and outside wooden building and relative humidity inside bu i l d ­ ing compared with monthly changes in spider numbers captured. Inside temperature Outside temperature Relative humidity Percent of spiders occurring each month 35 Percent of Totol Degrees F, Percent Relotive Humidity 59 85 75 •e 65 \ 55 45 25 1972 M o n th s 1973 60 Figure 7.— Proportional breakdown by sex and maturity level of most frequently captured species in wooden building. = Female = Male = Immatures Number of Animals (N) o vi o vi fea VI 5 tn o vi tn \\m m / / m 7??TT sa&iL a t * 7 m \ i m w m 5 s i o\ H 62 non-web spinning species is five web spinners to two non­ web spinners, a higher percentage than found in the metal buildings. The three most frequently encountered species of the above seven were collected throughout the year with the exception of December. Chiricanthium inclusum, had a major peak in late September-early October and a series of lesser spring peaks in January, April and June. Steatoda triangul- ulosa had a major peak in April and Tegenaria domestica peaked in May. The minor peaks were in September for Steatoda triangulosa and October for Tegenaria d o m e stica. The next three most frequently captured species, Phidippus audax, Achaeranea tepidariorum and Steatoda borealis occurred for six to seven months of the year. P. audax and A. tepidariorum occurred most frequently during April, May and June, while S. borealis was found mainly during May. Agelenopsis p o t t e r i , while occurring only during three months of the year, produced two definite peaks, one in April and one in September. As with the previous spider populations from buildings, the most numerous stage by mature females (Table 7). metal was the immature, followed Mature males, though few in number, appeared in both spring and fall peaks. TABLE 7.— Sex Breakdown for Seven Species Most Frequently Captured in Wooden Building. Species C. inclusum S. triangulosa Females Males Immatures 23 27% 15 17% 49 56% 87 36.8% 7 45 67% 67 23. 8 % 59 20.9% 15 Sum 22% 11% 13 13 22% 22% 33 56% 8 42% 2 11% 9 47% 19 6.7% A. tepidariorum 7 37% 3 16% 9 47% 19 6.7% S. borealis 5 33% 1 7% 9 60% 15 5.3% 5 39% 5 39% 3 22% 13 4.6% 76 27% 45 16% 159 56% T. domestica P . audax A. potteri TOTAL 282 Totals for each species and maturity level for the top seven species. 64 Spiders present in the wooden building had distinct differences in both order and frequencies of species when compared with the populations found in the metal buildings. Steatoda triangulaosa became the most frequently encountered species with a density of 0.40 animals per 100 square feet, as opposed to 0.44 animals per 100 square feet in the metal buildings, where it was the second most dense species. Chiricanthium inclusum became the second most frequently encountered species with a density of 0.31 animals per 100 square feet, as opposed to 0 . 2 2 in the metal buildings. The lowest density was exhibited by Agelenopsis potteri at 0.01 animals per 100 square feet, as opposed to 0.04 animals for Tegenaria domestica (Table 8 ). The minor peak, which occurred in September, proved Chiricanthium inclusum to be the most dense with 0.4 7 ani­ mals per 100 square feet, with S. triangulosa second with 0.13 animals per 100 square feet. Steatoda b o r e a l i s , though found throughout the rest of the year, was not captured dur­ ing this sample period. When the densities were considered at both the major and the minor peak periods, the densities of all species considered decreased except C. inclusum which advanced to a high of 0.47 animals per 100 square feet. The same pat­ terns were seen when the densities during the summer low density period was considered. All species decreased in densities except T. d o m e s t i c a , which increased by 0.03 ani­ mals per 1 0 0 square feet. TABLE 8.— Numbers of Spiders per 100 Square Feet in Wooden Building. Wooden Building 1125 Square Feet. Species Major Peak April 1 2 #/Mo. #/100 sq. ft. 1 #/Mo. Minor Peak 2 #/100 sq. ft. 1 #/Mo. Summer Low 2 #/100 sq. ft. C. inclusum 7.0 0.31 10.6 0.47 4.4 0.19 S. triangulosa 9.0 0.40 3.0 0.13 2.7 0.12 T. domestica 5.0 0.22 1.2 0.05 1.8 0.08 P. audax 0.95 0.04 0.2 0.01 0.2 0.01 A. tepidariorum 0.20 0.01 0.6 0.03 0.2 0.01 S. borealis 0.60 0.03 0.0 0.0 0.3 0.013 A. potteri 0.20 0.01 0.6 0.03 0.7 0.31 1-The total number of animals taken per month 2-The number of individuals per 100 square feet of available surface search area. 66 Brick Buildings There were 10 brick buildings, with 10,200 square feet of surface area on two floors plus a partial basement in each in which 2154 specimens were collected. This total gave 0 . 0 2 1 1 animals per 1 0 0 square feet of surface area per building per year. The total number of animals produced an average number of 215 per building for the twelve month sampling period. found on Table 4. The species list for the buildings can be The ratio of web spinning families to non-web spinning families was 6 :6 , the same as for the metal and wooden buildings. Weather data, Figure 8 , displayed a pattern seen in the two previous building types. The spider numbers were at their peak in the spring, decreased to a summer low and then had a small fall peak, into the winter. followed by a steady decrease All three peaks occurred during the same months in all three building types. The outside tempera­ tures remained the same from one building type to another, while the inside temperature and relative humidity changed in a similar manner to that of the previous building types. The temperature inside varied from a low of 6 8 degrees F during May and October and attained a high of 75 degrees F during July and August. The relative humidity ranged from a low of 46 percent in February to a high of 82 per­ cent in August. The trend observed in the two previous 67 Figure 8 .— Temperatures inside and outside brick buildings and relative humidity inside buildings compared with monthly changes in spider numbers captured. -------- Inside Temperature ------- Outside Temperature _ __ Relative Humidity ” Percentages of Spiders Captured T b to w u r e h i D e s e s N $ « Fna t a r a r ifl H um idity ® ^ ® cr> oo CO V ■n ° w e & P¢ of Towi 69 building -types regarding the changes in the population as effected by changes in the weather parameters was again o b ­ served h e r e . From April until the end of September the weather parameters and the spider populations moved in opposite d i ­ rections. decreased. As the temperature increased, the spider densities In October, the outside temperature began to d e ­ crease as did the number of spiders captured. ber on through the spring, generally April, From Septem­ the spider populations responded directly to changes in the outside temperatures and relative humidities. The temperatures in­ side the buildings, though not directly affecting the immi­ gration rate, seemed to allow the animals to survive once the move inside had been made. The five most frequently captured species produced a total of 1657 specimens or 76.9 percent of the total taken from the brick buildings. C. inclusum The most numerous species was (Figure 9) with 572 specimens or 26.8% of the total collected or 34.6% of the five most numerous species. A major peak was observed during April followed by a minor peak during October. year, Throughout the major portion of the immatures were the dominant group collected, with the majority of these being collected during February and the months of April through August. Females were dominant dur­ ing March and October indicating that there may be more than one generation per year. 70 Figure 9 •Percentages of total numbers of spiders collected from five most numerous species from brick b u i l d ­ ings . «•» I ■ • • # ilil = Female = Male = Immatures f o c a r v Vmue a Tw of Cdumi S S 8 a S mwBBssg /////////// // -'/■' -.// tfWWWJ'Ktmmi M m M M «J5f»SBS»¥ \ \ iwyftSs H 9 ssffiti H ////////////my sssasfn v/////ymm\v\ \ i %m: u Sb b u i k i a R-2B m m v . m - Lia S l M B t TKM— l H t t N* 507 ftwieiiniinn nmniM 9-92 72 {3. t r i a n g u l o s a , of which 507 specimens were cap­ tured, was a species that appeared in all of the previous buildings. The 507 animals represent 2 3.6% of the total for the study and 30.6% of the top five species. Through­ out the study this species had the immatures stages as the most numerous of all, males (Table 9). peak in September. followed by the famales and then the The major peak was in March with a minor The spring peak was primarily females, followed by immatures and then males, for the entire study. the trend observed The fall minor peak was evenly d i ­ vided between females and immatures, w i t h 205 of the total being males. From April through the fall, the majority of the animals captured were immatures, making up as much as 62% of the monthly total. This number decreased steadily until September when the immatures and females were evenly divided. This even relationship can be attributed to the mortality 'amongst the immature forms. S. b o r e a l i s , another tangled web spinner, occurred in lower numbers but was found within dwellings throughout the year as opposed to the other two more numerous species. Major peaks occurred during two months, March with 40 speci mens and May with 44 specimens. The minor peak occurred during October with 2 3 specimens. The two major peaks were not similar in their sex ratios. The first peak occurred during March and consisted of all three stages, evenly distributed. The second peak which occurred during May was 6 8 % immatures, 20% females and 12% males. The fall minor peak occurred during Septem­ ber and consisted of 77% immatures, males. 20% females and 3% Figure 9 gives the proportions for this portion of the study. Even during the middle of the winter, from November through February there were large numbers of im­ matures and females captured. There were only eleven mature males captured during this period, including Novem­ ber during which there were none collected. A. t e p i d a r i o r u m , a web spinning member of the family Theridiidae, was captured during 10 months of the year, e x ­ cluding December and January, during which no specimens were captured. October, The major peak occurred during the month of accounting for 33 of the 188 specimens captured for the species. were females, Fifty-four percent of the October total 14 percent males and 32 percent immatures. The minor peak occurred during May and June, accounting for 48 of the 188 total specimens. Immatures here accounted for 1 2 percent of the total, or 2 0 animals. 5** d o m e s t i c a , a funnel web spinner belonging to the family Agelenidae, was only captured during eight months of the year, with 97 animals captured. The major peak o c ­ curred in April when 25 specimens were captured, where 44 percent were immatures, cent males. 28 percent were females and 28 per The minor peak occurred in October when only 74 TABLE 9.— Sex Breakdown for Five Most Frequently Captured Species in Brick Buildings. Species Females Males Immatures Slims C. inclusum 159 29% 75 14% 338 57% 572 35% S. triangulosa 173 34% 71 14% 263 52% 507 31% S. borealis 81 28% 48 16% 163 56% 293 18% A. tepidariorum 77 41% 23 88 12% 47% 11% 32 33% 21 22% 44 45% 97 5% 522 32% 238 14% 876 54% T. domestica TOTALS 188 1657 The totals and breakdowns by sex and maturity levels as percentages of the total for the species. Also the per­ centage of the total for the brick buildings. five specimens were captured# two females and three immatures. The sex ratios for the brick buildings# Table 9, indicate that immature forms account for almost half of the speci­ mens captured# 22 45 percent immatures, 33 percent females and percent males. Brick buildings were the most numerous structures sampled but consistently had the lowest numbers of animals (Table 10). The differences in densities of animals often differed by a factor of 1 0 to 1 0 0 times lower than densities of the same species in the other two building types. the major peak, C. inclusum was the most frequently During TABLE 10.— Numbers of Spiders per 100 Square Feet in 10 Brick Buildings. Brick Buildings 10,200 square feet each, 102,000 square feet total. Major Peak Species C. inclusum 1 2 Minor Peak 1 #/Mo. #/100 ft. #/Mo. 102.96 0.05 63 2 #/100 Summer Low 1 ft. 2 #/Mo. #/100 ft. 0.03 51.48 0.025 S. triangulosa 70.98 0.036 41 0.02 45.63 0.22 S. borealis 32.23 0.015 23 0 .01 14.65 0.007 A. tepidariorum 15.04 0.007 28 0.01 13.85 0.007 T. domestica 24.25 0.012 5 4.85 0.003 0 .002 1-The total number of animals taken per month. 2-The number of individuals per 100 square feet of available search area. 76 encountered species with a density of 0.05 animals per 100 square feet of surface area. T. d o m e s t i c a , though never frequently encountered w h e n compared to the other species and building types, had a density of 0 . 0 1 2 animals per 1 0 0 square f e e t . The minor peak dropped C. inclusum to a value of 0.03 animals per 100 square feet. T. d o m e s t i c a , w i t h a low value from the major peak, dropped to 0 . 0 0 2 animals per 1 0 0 square feet. The summer period during which the spider popula­ tion w a s lowest, which occurred during August, was when C. inclusum dropped in density to 0.025 animals per 100 square feet of surface area. This value was 0.005 below that for the density during the minor peak period. T. d o m e s t i c a , the animal with the lowest density in both the metal and wooden buildings was also the least dense in the brick buildings. The density was 0.012 animals per 100 square feet during the major peak and 0 . 0 0 2 animals per 1 0 0 square feet during the minor peak. The period during the summer when the spider population was lowest was during August when the density of A. domestica was 0.003 animals per 1 0 0 square feet, peak density. 0.001 animals higher than the minor 77 Predatory Behavior Prey Contact Distance Peck and Whitcomb (1970) state that C. inclusum lo­ cated prey through physical contact with the extended fore­ legs while traveling in a forward direction. The results of this portion of the study agree with their investiga­ tion. When the spiders were exposed to prey at various distances and their attack responses were noted, cal distance was between 0.5 cm. and 1.0 cm. the criti­ When the spiders were exposed to prey at distances greater than 1 . 0 c m . , the response by matures and immatures alike was iden­ tical to the nonexistance of prey situation. Effects of Light on Hunting Behavior The results of this study indicate that light has a very negative effect on the tendencies of the spiders to wander about. Satiated spiders, particularly mature males and females, do not usually hunt when the light levels ad­ vance above eight foot candles. Figure 10 shows that the acitivity curves for males and females do not differ sig­ nificantly. The curve for the immatures indicates that they are active in low light levels as well as levels higher than those tolerated by the adult spiders. The effects of starvation increased the apparent tolerance levels of all classes of spiders towards light. 78 The numbers of animals hunting in the lower light levels does not increase noticeably from the fed animals, but at higher levels a noticeable increase in activity takes place. Mature male spiders, even though starved, followed the same patterns as the satiated spiders except that they were a c t ­ ive at higher light levels. Mature females increase their hunting activities from a high of eight foot candles in satiated animals to 1 2 foot candles in starved animals. Immatures were noticed to be more active in higher light levels even when satiated and display the same tendencies when starved. These animals were found outside their rest­ ing cells and actively hunting even when the light levels exceeded 1 2 foot candles. Under normal feeding conditions, hunting behavior could not be elicited unless the light levels were lower than four to six foot candles. The degree of drop in the response curve was steepest from four to the eight foot candle level in the satiated animals. animals were examined, When the starved the curves were quite different. The steep parts of the curve were extended to the eight to 12 foot candle level. The effects of starvation can force the animals out of their resting cells and assume a hunting behavior. During broad daylight, the spiders: three things could activate first, a severe hunger level; second, the 79 Figure 10.— Numbers of spiders remaining active before and after starvation observed at different foot candle levels. ------- = Female = Male --------= Immatures 80 10 Satiated spiders 8 0 0 2 Number 4 6 8 ID 12 Foot Candles of Specimens Ac tiv e 6 10 i)8 Hour Starvation 8 0 0 2 4 6 Foot Cahjles 8 10 14 81 active searching for a mate by either the males or females; and third, the disturbance of a resting cell such that the animal is forced to vacate it. The response to the rest­ ing cell disturbance was to flee the source of disturbance, move about for a short time searching for another hiding place and becoming quiescent when the disturbance ceased or a hiding place was found. C. inclusum reacts in a negative phototropic man­ ner. The spiders seem to be able to detect the movement of shadows when they are active in subdued light. When an object moved between the light source and the animal caused a shadow to move across the animal, an evasive re­ sponse was elicited. Prey Moisture Content Prey moisture, an often overlooked portion of the ecology of spiders and other animals, has been shown to have certain effects on maintaining the normal condition of spiders. Assuming that spiders which overwinter and remain active in dwellings have little access to water supplies and assuming the relative humidity within heated buildings was fairly low, spiders which are able to sur­ vive must have an alternate source of moisture. Throughout this study, no water was given to the animals in any form except that which they were able to o b ­ tain from their food sources. Figure 11 shows the number 82 Figure 11.— Three graphs showing the number of individuals dying for each of three hunger stress periods. ------- = Female = Male = Immatures 83 Y- 0.46k + 0.28 Y- 0,34k + 0.13 Y - 0.63k + 0.5*1 3 Day 4 2 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 VfeEKS Y- 0.54x + 0.27 Y - O.GCk + 0.74 Y- 0.72k + 1.0 6 7 Day 4 2 0 1 2 3 5 6 Meeks 8 Y- 0.26k + 1.4 Y- 0.89k + 0.40 Y- 0.74k + 0.70 6 10 2 0 1 2 3 4 Meeks 5 Day 84 of animals lost for the three degrees of stress for each sex and the immature s p e c i m e n s . Beginning with the three day stress period the slopes for m a l e s , females and immatures are presented. Re­ gression analysis showed that the equations were not sig­ nificantly different at the 0.05 level even though the equations were different in both slope and intercept. the individual slopes were examined, the lowest slope, the mature When females had followed by the mature males and t]ien the immatures. the When the seven day feeding schedule was examined, immature animals again were found to be the most sus- ceptable to the effects of moisture loss. lowed by the females and then the males. They were fol­ The slopes pro­ vided by the three equations again proved to be non­ significant at the 0.05 level, but were significantly different at the 0.1 level. The three slopes placed the females between the immatures and males this time, indicat­ ing an increased response to lower moisture levels. When the 10 day stress period was examined, the mature males had the steepest slope, 1.26, while the fe­ males had a line equation with a slope of 0.89. The im­ mature forms did not alter their responses much in moving from a slope of 0.72 to 0.74. Following the last two feeding regimens, males died in greater numbers with the reduced moisture levels. When 85 the slope differences are compared between the three day and the seven day regime, there was a difference in slopes of 0.08. But when the 10 day regimen was compared with the seven day regimen, the difference was 0.72. Females showed less severe responses to reduced moisture but there was an increased loss due to mortality for each increase in time between feedings. The females in going from the three day feeding regime to the seven day regime changed in slope from 0.34 to a slope of 0.60, a net change of 0.26. In moving to the 10 day schedule, the net change was 0.29 in going from a slope of 0.60 to a slope of 0.89. The immature animals exhibited the least amount of change in slope when they were examined under the three periods of stress. The net changes in slope in moving from the three to seven and seven to 1 0 day stress periods were 0.09 to 0.02, respectively. Data from Peck and Whitcomb (1970) and this study indicate that the spiders can live for at least a period of three weeks without food. When water is withheld the animals seldom live longer than three to five days. Search Patterns The analysis of data indicated that the search patterns of C. inclusum males, random. females and immatures were When the animals were tested before and after 86 food c a p t u r e , the results indicated that the feeding altered the search patterns slightly, but they remained random. This difference was best illustrated with the mean values plotted for each condition and number of turns. Assuming the mean value for each of the three runs to be 20, the values for each run above or below 2 0 were tabu­ lated. The values for both left and right turns were added together and averaged. The resulting value was plotted for each sex both before and after food capture and before and after 48 hours of hunger stress (Figure 12). In each case, the values following starvation were much more varied, in­ dicating a change in behavior following hunger stress. The degree of change in the deviation from the mean number of turns was greatest in the mature females, less in the mature males and there was no change in the immatures specimens. Following the 4 8 hour starvation period, all three classes of spiders increased their devia­ tions from the mean value of 20 turns. The greatest amount of change was noticed in the immatures which had a change of nine, followed by the mature males with a change of seven and then the females with a change of five. Follow­ ing food capture and feeding, the deviation decreased in all three classes tested. The most severe change occurred in the females where the deviation dropped by eight, fol­ lowed by the immatures with a change of seven and the males with a change of three. 87 Figure 12.— Graph showing deviation from mean value of 2 0 turns during random search pattern in­ vestigation . 88 Satiated 10 5 0 »— Before After Before After Stressed Satiated J Before 10 After Before Satiated After Stressed 5 0 — B efore After Before After [ 89 The results of this portion of the study indicate though the search patterns were random in nature, there were slight changes in the degree of randomness associated with changes in the hunger stress applied to the animals. Under hunger stress the s p i d e r s ' search patterns became slightly less random. were allowed to feed, After the animals captured food and the amount of deviation from the mean value was observed to d e c r e a s e . Resting Cell Study Part one of the study showed that there was an in­ crease of five resting cells from the initiation of the study through the 14 day period. When the analysis of part one of this portion of the study was completed, the data indicated that the method of counting resting cells to determine the number of spi­ ders present would not give reliable results. On day one of the study 14 resting cells were observed to contain spi­ ders. On day fourteen there were 19 resting cells, a net gain of five cells, or a 36 percent increase. a net loss in the number of spiders of four, There was leaving 1 0 animals and 19 cells. The second portion of the study was designed to determine the length of residency in the original cells and the increase in cells built. were tabulated and marked. On day one 14 cells On day two, three old cells Figure 13.— Part 1: Original number of resting cells found with increase over two week period. Part 2: Changes in resting cell occupancy and new cell construction rate. ----------- _ Number of original cells used and reused. Number of new cells constructed over time. NUMER OF RESTIM6 f o 1* 91 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 OF fcSTINB CELLS IkY S 2 3 4 Days 5 6 15 14 92 were abandoned and three new cells were constructed. By the fifth day of the study there were as many old cells as there were new cells. On the eighth day all of the original 14 cells had been abandoned and there were 15 new cells constructed since the original tabulation. The net change in the number of marked spiders during this portion of the study changed from 14 on day one to nine on day eight. This was a loss of five or 36 percent. Part three of the study involved the effects of search area size on the number of spiders returning to the original resting cells. The return rate was also tested against several periods of hunger stress ginning with satiated animals, (Figure 14). Be­ all three classes tested returned to the original cells an average of 95% of the time. This occurred in both the two and five gallon test chambers. When the tests were carried out in the 10 gallon aquarium, the females returned 100% of the time. Males returned 80% of the time and the immatures returned 60% of the time. cage was used, When the six by six by six foot screened the percentages were lower. dropped to 40%, The females the males and the immatures dropped to a 60% return rate. The size of the aquarium seemed to affect the pe r ­ centage of animals returning to the original cells. next factor tested was the effect of hunger. hours of starvation, The Following 48 the same tests were run again. This 93 Figure 14.— Three graphs showing number of spiders returning to resting cells in different sized search areas. X axis denotes search area size. Y axis denotes percent returning to the resting cell. ------------------- Males Females Immatures FT" • 94 100 25 Satiated Spiders 5 Ga l . 10 Gal . 6*5 Screened Cage 75 48 Hour Stress P ercent of Total Retu r n in g 2 Gal . 2 Gal . 5 Gal . 10 Gal . 6x6 Screened Cage 72 Hour Stress 25- 2 Gal . 5 Gal . 10 Gal . 6*6 Screened Cage 95 time the females returned only 80% of the time in the two gallon aquarium. The males returned 100% of the time in the five gallon aquarium, while the females and the im­ matures returned 80% of the time. When the 10 gallon aquarium was used all three classes of spiders returned 80% of the time. The six by six by six foot screened cage had all three spider classes returning at the rate of 60%. Before the effects of hunger were tested on the return rate, the responses of individual spiders were apt to vary considerably. Following the application of hunger, the animals all acted in a similar manner. When severe hunger stress was applied to the test animals, the aquarium size had a direct effect on the per­ centage of animals returning to the resting cells. the animals were starved for 72 hours, When there was a notic- able effect on the numbers of animals of each sex and maturity level returning to the resting cells. Immatures were the only animals returning to the resting cells 100% of the time in the two gallon aquarium. females returned at the rate of 80%. size was increased to five gallons, Both males and When the aquarium all three classes of spiders returned at the rate of 80%. In the 10 gallon aquarium the females remained at the 80% return rate while the males and immatures decreased to a 60% return rate. At 72 hours of hunger stress in the six by six by six foot screened cage, the females return rate dropped to 96 40%, identical to that for the satiated females. Males and immatures dropped to a 20% rate. The overall effect appears to be that aquarium size, when considered alone, exerts a moderate effect on the aban­ donment of resting cells. When a starvation alone is con­ sidered, beginning with the two gallon universe over three starvation regimens, no change takes place in the numbers of animals abandoning their resting cells. gallon squarium is considered, When the five little change is noticed u n ­ til the 72 hour hunger stress is reached, at which point all three classes of animals are at a return rate of 75%. In the 10 gallon aquarium the ef-fects of starvation begin to be apparent. Satiated animals are somewhat more erratic in their activities than those in the smaller aquarium but by 48 hours of hunger stress, all the original resting cells have been abandoned at the rate of 20%. At 72 hours of stress the abandonment rate had dropped to 40% except for the males. When the screened cage was used, satiated and 48 hour stresses animals were not significantly different, but by 72 hours the abandonment rate was 75%. The overall effect was that the greater the hunger stress and the further the animals had to travel in locat­ ing and capturing food, the less likely the animals were to return to the resting cell most recently constructed. > 97 Effects of Prey Size The prey sizes were selected at a percentage of prey body weight to that of the spider. The small size was 1/2 or less than the body weight of the s p i d e r , the m edium size was greater than 1/2 but less than the body weight of the spider, and the large size was greater than the body weight of the spider. be found in Appendix C. The statistical data can Figure 15 displays the results in the three starvation experiments. Spiders starved for 24 hours had a marked prefer­ ence for specific size classes. The effects of spider sex and maturity level were also significant but at a lower significance level. Mature males tended to attack all size classes with more frequency than the females and im­ matures. Females followed the same selection pattern but at 10% lower rate of ingestion. Immatures began at the same level as the females, but decreased at a greater rate. At this level of starvation, significant at the the effects of prey size was .005 level, while sex of the predator was significant at the .05 level. When the spiders were subjected to 4 8 hour starva­ tion stress, the noticable change in prey size attacked was significant. The males did not change their attack rates for the small and me d i u m size classes but when the large size class of prey was introduced, the attack rate 98 Figure 15.— Percent attack rates for three classes of spiders under three hunger stress regimes. — — = Female ■------ = Male —— ---- Immatures 99 100 Large 100 20 48 Hour Stress Medium Large 60 20 Sh a ll Large 100 Increased from 60% to 80%. An increase was also noted in the females, where the increase was from 50% to 60%. The immature spiders increased their attack rates from 40% to 50%. These results indicate that the spiders will increase their attack rates with an increase in hunger stress regard­ less of sex or maturity level. The effects of hunger on the size of prey attacked increased when the stress reached 72 hours. The most no tice­ able increase occurred among the mature females. There was no difference when the small prey size was offered, but when the me d i u m sized prey was offered, increased from 70% to 90%. offered, the attack rate When the large sized prey was the attack rate increased from 60% to 80%. the immature spiders were examined, When their attack rate d e ­ creased to that of the 24 hour stress period. When t h e results of the entire investigation were considered, there was an increase in the size of prey at­ tacked and eaten associated with an increase in hunger stress. This increase affected the mature specimens to a greater degree than the immature specimens. The statisti­ cal analysis indicated that the effects of the sex of the spider attacking the prey was barely significant at the 0.1 level. The size class of the prey proved to be non-signifi­ cant at the 0.1 level. This indicates that the predators would attack almost any size class w i t h minimal selection. 101 The interactions between the sex of the spider and the prey size proved to be barely significant at the 0.1 level. Distances Traveled Study The distances that C. inclusum travels during a foraging period has been shown to be related to sex of the spider, maturity of the spider and to what extent it has been stressed by hunger. Mature male C. inclusum speci­ mens have been shown to wander in excess of 2400 feet d u r ­ ing a 10 hour foraging period. The mean value for the animals tested was 1940 feet during the same length of time (Figure 16). As the stress of hunger was applied to the animals, a steady decrease in the distances traveled was noted. As the stress increased from satiated spiders to those without food for five days, in a regular manner. the distances decreased When the mean values for each stress period were plotted and a regression line fitted, the eq u a ­ tion for the line was Y = -2.91X + 16.39. In looking at the mean values of the distances traveled at the individual stress periods, it can be seen from Figure 17 that from the fourth day of stress onward, the mini m u m distances had apparently reached a minimum. proximately zero. The slope of the line is a p ­ The correlation coefficient between starvation and distance traveled is quite high at 0.943. The coefficient of determination was 0.88 9, again quite high. 102 Figure 16.— Distances traveled by three classes of spiders under six hunger stress regimes. Y axis de­ notes distances traveled in feet, multiplied by 100. X axis denotes six regimes. r r Y = The Correlation Coefficient. 2 = The Coefficient of Determination. = The equation for the line represented by the six mean values of the feeding regimes. 103 20 R ■ 0.9*1 15 . Y ■ -.29b< +16*4 10 5 Distances Travels in Feet (Times 100) 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 fknjRE Females 20 R ■ 0.96 15 Y * - 15.9b( + ID 10 N v 5 • • *--- Y - -8.4*+ 11.8 R ■ 0.70 20 10 5 0 0 1 2 3 Days op Starvation 4 5 104 The mature females had a maximum distance traveled equal to 1925 feet, somewhat less than the mature males. The mean value for satiated females was 1125 feet, which decreased through the individual stress periods to a low of 270 feet after five days without food. As can be seen from Figure 17, the range of distances for the females is wider at the more satiated levels and then decreases when the hunger stress is increased. The equation for the line representing the plot of the mean distances traveled is Y= -1.59X + 10.05. The coefficient of correlation between the distances traveled and the hunger stress effects was 0.96 3, higher than that for the mature males. ficient of determination was 0.928. The coef­ Both these values are very high and indicate a close relationship between dis­ tances traveled and the effects of hunger stress. The immature specimens displayed a less direct response to the effects of hunger stress. The distances traveled through the stress periods were not consistant. The correlation coefficient was lower than either the males or the females at 0.7 04. The coefficient of determination was also lower at 0.496. The mean distances at each of the stress periods did not produce the decreasing slope of the males and females. + 11.83. The equation for the line was Y = -.84X The responses of the immatures to stress proved to be less predictable. 105 When the investigation is considered in its en­ tirety, the mature males have the more direct response to hunger stress, followed by the mature females and then the immature specimens. When the correlations between stress and distances traveled are examined, the females have the most direct response followed by the males and then by the immatures. Prey Density Study These experiments were designed to determine the effects of both prey and predator densities on the ability of the predators to capture prey. The design of the ex­ periment was to manipulate prey densities within four search areas of increasing size. methods section, As explained in the each area was tested using one predator at each of five prey densities. As a result there were several redundancies in prey densities as the area sizes were increased. Therefore, specific densities were se­ lected from different area sizes to give a series of prey densities which would increase in an approximate geometric manner. Table 11 gives the values for the situations in­ cluding one, two and four predators per search area. From inspection of the table, the prey densities roughly double from one animal per 14.8 square inches to a low of one prey per 2960 square inches in eight density changes. 106 Operating under the assumption that these spiders hunt in a random manner, with a known increase in prey dens­ ity there should be a corresponding decrease in predation time for a corresponding decrease in available search area. As the time to capture prey changed from the high to the low density, a straight line relationship developed. Fig­ ure 18 gives the curve and the equation for the data. The equation for the line is Y = 0.8 3X + 62, with a correlation coefficient of 0.848. The high correlation coefficient supports the contention that a straight line relationship exists between search time and prey density. The question arises that if there is a 1:1 relation­ ship between the search time and the prey density, should not the slope of the line be 1.0 instead of 0.83? One e x ­ planation for this difference is that the majority of the tests were run in the small tanks where the possibility of encountering prey would be increased with a reduction in search time. When the stress of increased predator numbers was considered, several patterns emerged regarding changes in slope and intercept of the e q u a t i o n s . When the predators were increased from one to two per search area, the assump­ tion was that the slope of the line would decrease by one half. balism. This assumption was made on the basis of zero cannaF r o m the results of previous observations, canna- b a l i s m among adults was practically n o n - e x i s t a n t . With 107 TABLE 11.--Time to Initial Capture for Predators in Differ­ ent Densities and Prey in Different Densities. Tank Size Surface Area ? ™ X « Ure xn ™ mxnutes 1 Predator/Universe 10 10 5 5 2 2 5 2 gal; 1:1 gal; 2:1 gal; 1:1 gal; 2:1 gal; 2:1 gal; 4:1 gal; 20:1 gal; 20:1 2960 1480 740 370 148 74 37 14.8 285 215 145 145 105 62 48 15 2960 1480 740 370 148 74 37 14. 8 93 85 60 55 65 35 12 10 2960 1480 740 370 148 74 37 14. 8 78 108 35 35 18 12 12 5 2 Predators/Universe 10 10 5 5 2 2 5 2 gal; 1:1 gal; 2:1 gal; 1:1 g a l ; 2:1 g a l ; 2:1 gal; 4:1 gal; 20:1 gal; 20:1 4 Predators/Universe 10 10 5 5 2 2 5 2 gal gal gal gal gal gal gal Gal 1:1 2:1 1:1 2:1 2:1 4:1 20:1 20 :1 108 Figure 17.— The three predator densities over available searching area at different prey densities. r = The Correlation Coefficient. Y = The equation for the line representing the plotted points. 109 320 1 Predator /S earch Ar e a 280 • /' Y - O.ffifc + 62 240 r 200 - 0.949 160 120 / H / 80 V - 40 90 2 * * ? £ S I I nitial Capture Search Area in S quare I nches 80 70H 60 2 R o a t o r s /S earch Ar ea Y -0.24*+ 34 R - 0.793 30 o t 40 Minutes 30 in 120 T ime 20 103 00 73 60 10 4 P redators /S earch area • Y ■ 0.29k ♦ 17 R - 0.806 43 30 15 i *s * 2 * * SfewcH Am * g 2 I S e a rc h A rea in S q u are l i n e s ! n in So m e i hoc* | 110 zero cannabalism and two predators per search area, the data produced a line with the equation of Y = 0.237X + 34.57. This does not meet the assumption of a 50% reduction in the slope of the line. The interesting point, however, is that when the number of predators was increased from two to four, equation of the line was Y = 0.28 7X + 16.99. the The slope of this line was very near the slope of the line for the two predator case. The difference between the two equa­ tions was in the Y intercept, in which the four predator case had an intercept very nearly that for the two preda­ tor case. When the two equations were plotted together, the apparent difference was that the two predator case operates at a slower rate. When the correlation coefficients were examined, they were found to differ by only 0.015, which is a small difference in light of the sample sizes and the number of re p l i c a t i o ns. When the entire density study is considered, C. inclusum apparently behaves in a predictable manner when predator densities exceed two per search area. When the densities fluctuated between one and two predators per search area, apparent behavioral acitvities tended to render the spiders unpredictable. DISCUSSION Examination of the spider species found within dwellings in Michigan during the local survey indicated that there were many species of spiders able to invade dwellings and to occur there for varying periods through­ out a calendar year. However, when the quantitative as­ pects of the spider species were examined, there was a reduction in the numbers of species containing large num­ bers of individuals through the year. The species were ranked in order of the number of individuals captured by building type in descending order. The species making up 50% or more of the total numbers of animals were ex­ amined in detail to determine changes in the density and population structures throughout a calendar year. In conjunction with the animal survey, three environmental parameters were measured at the same time as the spider survey. The parameters measured were the temperature in­ side the buildings, the percent relative humidity inside the buildings and the temperature outside the building. The parameters were related to the spider populations in several ways. The initial effect of the temperatures was 111 112 whether they were the cause of the increase in spider nu m ­ bers or whether they were responsible for the continued existance of the animals within the particular dwelling. The outside temperature, though not a direct in­ fluence on the spiders once the move was made inside, was used as a measure of the degree of movement evidenced by the spiders. As the temperature increased in the spring, so did the numbers of spiders. The change was from a low of 32 degrees during December when there were 27 spiders captured. As the temperature increased in the spring months from the minimum, so did the number of spiders. There seemed to be no absolute temperature when the spiders began their movement indoors or o u t d o o r s . The changes were gradual in both temperature and the numbers of spiders cap­ tured. The upward changes in both temperature and spider density continued until April when the spider densities began to decrease. This change in direction continued un­ til August when another change in density took place. Du r ­ ing October the directions of the curves again coincided and continued so until the end of the study. The two parameters that helped maintain the spider populations during the periods of adverse conditions were the temperature inside the dwellings and the relative humid­ ity. The latter seemed to move in the same directions as the outside temperature but without the same degree of 113 change. When the relative humidity and the temperatures inside the buildings were considered at the same time, there appeared to be an environment more suitable for the continued habitation by the spiders. The results of this portion of the study indicate that the temperature outside affects the spiders to the extent that they either must escape to a more protected area or die. The two parameters inside the buildings allow those spiders that have made the move the opportu­ nity to survive in an active state unless some factor present indoors kills or removes them or their food supply. The fact that spiders were found in the character­ istic two peak pattern can be explained in several ways. The life cycles of many spiders follow the pattern of m a t ­ ing and the laying of eggs in the spring and early summer, overwintering as penultimate instars with maturation and m ating in the spring again Dondale 1961). (Gertsch 1949, Comstock 1948, This cycle, when considered in a numerical sense, can account for population fluctuations in the fol­ lowing ways. In the spring there is an increase in both numbers of animals as they emerge from the winter estiva­ tion coupled with the high degree of mobility associated with the active searching for mates by the mature spiders. These facts are all associated with the favorable conditions found during the spring and early summer. 114 As the numbers of immatures increased during the summer and early fall there was a drop in the numbers of both mature males and mature females captured. Moulder et a l . (1970) have found that there is an increase in the numbers of immature animals in the months of May and De­ cember. The increase during May can be explained as due to the numbers of animals newly hatched and their increased mobility. The increase during the month of December is harder to explain as the winter months were usually the poorest in numbers of animals captured. My data indicated that the two peaks were composed mainly of immature speci­ mens and mature females. The spring peak being mostly mature females and the fall peak was mainly immature speci­ mens. The absolute numbers of immatures were found to re­ main relatively constant during the latter months of the year. When the numbers were considered as percentage values of the totals for each month, the immatures seemed to increase in number. This was due to the gradual de­ crease in number of both males and females. These results confirmed the hypothesis based on the understanding of spider life cycles. When the three building types were considered with the most frequently captured species, the same patterns emerged. The major peak occurred in April consisting 115 mostly of females and i m m a t u r e s . duced during the summer months, The population was re­ increased to a lesser peak during the fall and decreased to the low period of the year during the winter months. The five species most dominant in the metal buildings, the seven in the wooden building and the five in the brick buildings all followed the same pattern, that of spring major peaks followed by summer low densities and a smaller peak in the fall fol­ lowed b y a reduction in numbers to almost zero. The densities of spiders on a square foot basis were examined to assess the actual numbers of animals at specific times during the year. The three time periods selected were the spring major peak, the summer low density period and the fall minor peak period. The densities per 100 square feet indicate that there were only two species out of the many frequently captured that provide the most animals. The top two species, though not the same in all three building types, were within the four most frequently captured species. The top three species in all three building types were composed of two web spinners to one wandering or non-web spinning s p e c i e s . C. inclusum, the species of concern throughout the study, was captured in densities varying 0.05 animals per 100 square feet in the brick buildings to a high of 0.3 animals per 100 square feet in the wooden building. The 116 two metal buildings had a density of 0.22 animals per 100 square feet. When these values are compared with the spe­ cies most frequently captured during the study, £3. triangul o s a , w h ich had a density of 0.40 in the wooden building and 0.44 in the two metal buildings, it was found that these two species were always present during almost the entire year and the proportions of males to immatures to females held relatively constant. W h e n considering the third most frequently captured species on down to the least frequent of the detailed ones, the densities were smaller by a factor of from 2 to 45 times. The least frequently captured species in both the metal and brick buildings was T. d o m e s t i c a , with S. borealis in both the metal and wooden buildings. When the remaining two periods were examined, same order within the species was retained. the In other words the placement of the species in order of densities was the same from one sampling period to another within a particu­ lar building type. Size of the spiders was at first suspected as a potential means of explaining the make up of the popula ­ tions with particular dwellings. The hypothesis being that the smaller more inconspicuous species would attract less attention and thus be less susceptable to predation or removal by humans. Of the three most frequently cap­ tured species within the three building types none can be 117 considered as small spiders. C. inclusum ranges up to three-quarters of an inch as a mature animal, while T. domestica approaches the same dimension, with S. tr i a n g u l o s a , a slightly smaller spider at one-half inch. An interesting point regarding the movement of • spiders into dwellings is that even though the sampling method used called for removal of all possible specimens, there were always more spiders being captured even during the w i n ter months. This indicates that even though there was a good possibility that all specimens were not captured, enough were removed each time so that similar populations could not become established between sampling periods, cluding invasion. ex­ This indicates that there must be a continual movement of spiders into dwellings throughout the year, including the winter months. This constancy of numbers would also indicate that the prey densities will support only that number of animals so that there would not be a large number of animals similar to the spring and fall densities. There apparently is no concerted effort by the spiders to move indoors, but the move indoors does allow those that make it to extend their survival beyond that of those remaining o u t d o o r s . The conclusions of this portion of the study are that only a very few species, in most cases from five to seven, are able to maintain themselves within dwellings ■e ■ ■ 118 over time. Of this number, three make up the majority of specimens captured in the ratio of two web spinners to one non-web spinner. considered, When the effects of building type was there was no apparent effect, as the species were the same from one building type to another. The only differences were in the order of frequencies of the most common species. The environmental parameters appeared to have only a slight effect on the spider numbers once the move had been made indoors. The outside temperature e f ­ fect was that of a driving force causing the spiders to move and also aid in the maturation process. The results of the state-wide survey reinforce the conclusions drawn from the local quantitative survey. There were 12 species captured that made up more than 50% of the total number of specimens. Seven of this number were common to the three building type species list from the local survey. The remaining five species were A. sericatus, S. s c e n i c u s , T. t r a n q u i l l a s , H. ecclesiasticus and A. p e n n s y l v a n i c a . Of this number, there was only one new family added. This was the Gnaphosidae which contains the species H. ecclesi­ asticus . T. tranquillas belongs to the family Clubionidae as does C. i n c l u s u m . A. sericatus has been eliminated from the discussion because there was only one time when the specimens were captured and turned in. This represented 70 of the 7 3 specimens which were captured in one day from p 119 a warehouse in Detroit. This sample tended to bias the sample and the results of that portion of the study. The differences between the two studies were sig­ nificant only when the relative frequencies of the species were considered. In the local survey, the most frequently captured species in one building type were not the most frequent in the next. The same principle held true for a comparison between the state wide and local surveys. The most frequently captured species in the state-wide survey was from first through third in the local survey. the entire study was considered, When the fact that the top seven species in the local survey were the top seven spe­ cies in the state-wide survey, the conclusion that only a few species were able to invade buildings successfully was reinforced. The results of the predation study, when combined with the results of the Peck and Whitcomb study, give a more detailed view of the basic biology and behavior traits of the spider as found in the state of Michigan. C. inclusurn, a clubionid wandering spider, has been shown in the past to have a single generation per year when found in the natural habitat. However, the results of this study and the results of the two surveys indicate that there is a possibility that two generations are possible when the spiders remain indoors through the winter. This 120 is evidenced by the fact that matures were found late in the season as well as immature forms. If only one genera­ tion was to found, there would be distinct times when the mature forms would dominate and other times when the im­ matures would be dominant. There is enough overlap in the occurance of both matures and immatures that the two generation per year or at least an overlap of two genera­ tions idea can be considered. The behavior associated with food location and cap­ ture is presented and discussed as follows: Adult and immature specimens of C. inclusum have been tested and found to require a contact distance of less than 0.5 cm. before prey can be located under normal hunting conditions. When this small contact distance is coupled with habit of the animals to hunt during the night hours an interesting behavior pattern becomes apparent. The more light that was applied to the animals, the less the hunting activity was observed. The mature forms were less likely to be hunting when the light levels exceeded eight foot candles than when the light levels were below eight foot c a n d l e s . Immature specimens were observed hunting in slightly higher levels. This tendency on the part of the immature forms to be a little less predictable also held true when the stress of starvation was applied to the spiders and the experiment repeated. After 48 hours of hunger stress, the mature specimens were found hunting 121 in light levels up to 12 foot candles. Again the immatures were found hunting in slightly higher levels. There is no apparent reason except that they have not yet learned that higher light levels may lead to higher predation levels. The differences between the sexes of the mature specimens is also difficult to explain. Mature males were consist­ ently the animals found in the lowest light levels. Fe­ males were always found in slightly higher levels# with the immature forms found hunting in the highest light levels. This relationship was first observed during this set of investigations and was noticed to be true for many of the subsequent investigations involving adult and im­ mature animals. When the animals were considered within buildings the ability to obtain moisture became a question that needed answering. The question asked was whether or not the ani­ mals would be able to maintain themselves on a diet of prey organisms with no water. And if so# how long b e ­ tween feedings would the animals be able to stay active and healthy. The results of this study, significant statistically as was hoped, though not as have shown that there is a relationship between survival of the animals and the frequency of feeding. Because there was no wa t e r introduced at any time, the only source of moisture was that obtained from the food. Two pilot studies were run 122 Initially to determine the length of time needed for the spiders to die strictly from the effects of starvation, and whether or not the animals would be able to survive on a diet of dried prey. The first study indicated that the animals were unable to survive longer than 10 days when all sources of food were withheld. This held for all three groups of animals, mature males, immatures alike. As the animals will only attack living prey, as stated in Kaston berlain females and (1933), Dondale (1948), Gertsch (1949) , Cham­ (1961), they were shown not to be able to survive for any length of time on dry or freshly killed prey with low moisture content. By deduction then, if the only moisture present was found in the prey animals, then the prey animals must contain adequate amounts of moisture to support the ani­ mals. Peck and Whitcomb (1970) state that C. inclusum was shown to prefer prey forms that were generally large, slow moving and had high moisture content ratios to body weight. This date confirms my findings, and so the animals can be shown to acquire much of their moisture requirements for the prey they eat and not necessarily from outside sources. Having poor eyesight and thus a small prey contact distance, coupled with a moisture requirement of three to five days, the hunting strategy would have to be a success­ ful one for the animals to survive. The search patterns F 123 were tested and found to be random in manner for both the matures and the immatures. The degree of randomness changed from one sex to another and from one stress level to another. This difference in significance level, though slight, was enough to indicate that the animals were effected in their search patterns by hunger and the sex and degree of ma t u r ­ ity exhibited. When the animals were considered as wandering for­ agers, the degree of residency in any given area would be dependent on the nearness of potential prey to the resting cell and whether the resting cells were of real importance in the hunting strategy of the spider. The results of the first two studies regarding return to previously con­ structed resting cells indicated that the resting cells were reoccupied as many as two to three nights in succes­ sion. The cells were not occupied for periods longer than eight days. When the search areas were not greater than 4.6 square feet in area, the return rates were above 80%. When the search area increased to near 8 square feet, the return rates declined to an average of 75%, falling off to near 60% when the search area exceeded 216 square feet. Above 216 square feet the return rates would be expected to continue to drop when related to prey densitiy. When the effects of hunger stress were applied to the animals, the return rates did not change significantly 124 until 72 hours of stress. The greatest numbers of spiders not returning to the previously constructed resting cell was w h en the animals were stressed for 72 hours and the search area was 216 square feet. These results conclude that the resting cell was used repeatedly when the search area was small and prey capture was successful. search area increased in size, As the the time to capture success decreased and so did the return rate. The resting cells are therefore used repeatedly in high prey densities and abandoned in areas of low prey densities. Prey size selection was proven to be a character­ istic that could be altered through the effects of hunger. When the spiders were in a satiated condition, they exhib­ ited definite preferences for specific sizes of prey. These preferences also were shown to vary from one sex to another and from mature to immature animals. The effects of hunger stress were also exhibited from one group to another. From the hunger studies, it can be stated that the mature males attack a more diverse prey size range than the females and the immatures. The females are the most severely affected by hunger stress in that they can be influenced to take more diverse prey sizes based on the degree of hunger applied. The immature forms on the other hand are relatively static in their response to hunger stress. Hunger stress was shown to lower the barriers of both mature and immature specimens. 125 Prey size can be related to hunger and the sex and maturity of the animals considered. From this point of view, prey size selection is a variable that is constantly changing with the hunger state of the spider and the m a t u r ­ ity level of the spiders. C. inclusum was shown to be worthy of the name wandering or vagabond spider. The distances traveled were large for both mature and immature forms and con­ sistent from one search period to another. The distances traveled varied from one animal to another but were consist­ ent enough within the sex or maturity level that ranges could be predicted when the sex and hunger levels were known. The relationship between sex, hunger level and d i s ­ tances traveled was direct, linear and negative. The more the spiders were stressed by hunger the shorter the d i s ­ tances traveled. Males were shown to travel further than females and immature forms traveled the shortest distance of all. The opposite was found to be true of satiated animals. Under satiated conditions, endurance levels remained high. the energy levels and The distances were near the m a ximum for the sex and maturity level of the particu­ lar animal. This assumption was less reliable when the immature forms were considered. The immatures were shown to be less predictable in their responses to stress. 126 The predator-prey studies established the fact that the successful capture of prey by C. inclusum was related in a direct manner to prey density. Because of the h u n t ­ ing patterns of the spider, the density and placement of the prey should have little effect on capture success. This is so due to the short contact distance of the spider. When the short contact distance is coupled with the random search pattern, each prey has an equal chance of being en­ countered, assuming random spacing and placement. The change in time to capture one prey in varying prey densities was shown to be a straight line relationship when there was one predator per search area. The straight line relationship held for medium to high densities but when very low densities were encountered, the time to capture varied from five hours to more than one 10 hour hunting period. Holling tors. (1959) These results differ from these given by in his disc equation for invertebrate preda­ His equation gives a type 2 response curve, which is a negatively increasing slope to a plateau. One ex ­ planation for this difference is that the biology of the spider affects the predatory behavior. The spider, though an active predator, does not behave in the same manner as those reported by Haynes and Sisojevic (1966) , Turnbull (1966), Dondale (1970) . C. inclusum does not continue to attack and kill prey after the initial prey has been captured. After the capture, 127 the prey is eaten and then the search is continued until the next contact is made, or the searching period is in­ terrupted by daylight or satiation. The same relationship between capture time and prey density held constant even w h e n the number of predators was increased. The correlation coefficient, however, d e ­ creased in value, indicating that the relationship was not as definite. The increase from one predator to two altered the equation for the relationship between the cap­ ture time and prey density such that the search time was reduced. In changing the predator density to four preda­ tors, the changes in the relationship evidenced by the change in the equation, indicated an even stronger effect of one predator on another by a more reduced search time. Because no cannabalism was seen or the evidence of it d e ­ tected, the changes in the response equations can be con­ sidered to be the effect of the positive interaction between the spiders. In summary, the results of this study indicate that C. inclusum has a range including both the upper and lower p eninsula of Michigan. There is evidence that there may be as many as two generations per year when considered w i thin dwellings in Michigan. The mature females usually outnumber the mature males, and the immatures. There were two periods during the year when the populations within 128 dwellings exhibit peak densities. April and October. These two periods were The effect of the spiders on resident prey populations has been shown to be related directly to the density of the spiders. This is because the spiders do not kill and eat large numbers of prey but kill and eat only that amount which satiates them in areas of high prey density or those prey animals that can be captured in one hunting p e r i o d , if satiation is not reached. W h en the prey density is low, the number of new resting cells constructed will increase to one per hunt­ ing period. After spending the daylight hours in the cell, the spider begins its search and constructs another cell the following morning. In areas of high prey density, the resting cell may be used again the following day, depend­ ing on h o w far the animals have to wander from the cell in search of prey. The effects on the human population were shown to be slight except for two short periods during the year when the potential for harmful interaction is reased. Bites, when they occurred were few in number and were the cause of only short term ill effects. C. inclusum can be considered as a potential source of biological control only on a limited bases because of the basic biology of the a n i m a l . The spider can there­ fore be considered as a resident species which has limited effect on either prey organisms or the human inhabitants. APPENDICES A PPENDIX A Introductory Letter and Data Sheet 130 131 COOPERATIVE M ICHIGAN STATE EXTENSION UNIVERSITY SERVICE • CAST LANSING • M ICH IGAN Entomology AND U .S . DEPARTMENT February 23, Of AGRICULTURE COOPERATING Natural Science Building 1972 Dear County Extension Director: You are already aware of my responsibilities as Survey Entomologist, because it Includes the preparation of the "Insect Alerts" newsletter which enters your mailbox each week from April to September. You may not know, however, of my Interest in spiders and my extension responsibilities for Spiders occurring in dwellings. Many county extension staff members have asked for literature that would allow them to readily identify a majority of the spider specimens submitted to their offices. Public health officials, pest control operators, medical doctors and others also have need for such literature. I plan to produce an extension bulletin that will serve this need among extension staff and the other professional groups above. First, however, I need more reliable information on the kinds of spiders that occur in Michigan dwellings, their relative abundance, and association of suspected spider bite cases with the creature that actually caused the bite. To gather some of this information I would like to conduct an extensive one-year survey of spiders In dwellings throughout the state, and I invite your cooperation In this survey. You arc, of course, under no obligation to participate. However, if you feel that there Is a need for an extension bulletin on spiders, your contri­ bution would help make it a more accurate and complete bulletin. If you or another staff member In your county office is willing to cooperate, I would like you to save all of the spider specimens that you receive during a one-year period (April I, 1972-March 31, 1973). t w t 11 provide you with a set of pre-numbercd, alcohol-filled vials and pre­ numbered forms on which to record the necessary information. A copy of the form is enclosed, and you can see that it is very brief and simple to complete. I will also provide you with a mailing container in which to periodically ship me a group of vials. In addition, I would like to be notified each rime a suspected spider bi te is reported. I wi11 attempt to personally follow up each one of these'reports. If you are willing to participate in this s u r v e y , please reply by March 15 with the enclosed card. I will then ship you a set of vials and forms before April 1. Thank you for any attention which you may give to my request. Sincerely Richard J. Sauer Extension Entomology Specialist and Survey Entomologist 132 SPIOER INFORMATION SHEET R. J. Sauer Dept, of Entomology HSU Spider N o .: (Hatch this no. with no. In vial) County:____________________________ D Collected by: Spider was found: a t e Inside of a bu 11d Ing : __________________ _ Outside of a building_____________ _________ (if you check outside plo'su make som.- notes on h-»bif>t «.;ch .is host plnnt or substrvt. undt r "additional notes b: low) . Check one blank In each of the following nine categories on which you may have Information: 1. AREA: Urban Suburban flu ra 1 2. STATUS OF 9UUDII.G. _________ In Use ________ Abandoned 3. CONO IT ION: ________ Heated ________ Unheated k. CONSTRUCTION: SIngle story with basement ________ Single story without basement Hu 111 story with base'-e^t Hu 11 istory without bnscmcnt 5. EXTERIOR: ________ Brick ________ Wood _ _ _ _ _ _ Aluminum nr Vinyl Siding O ther (Specify) 6. USE: Fes Iliert ial Commercial _Single-fami Iy dwelling HijI 11-fami ly dwelling Form Factory (Manufact.) Retail ;non-food) or Business [Retail food (grocery store) Food serving (restaurant) Food processing (dairy, cor^crrtal bakery, etc.) Bn r n _________S* lo __ 1ned ________ Other (specify) 7. SPIOEfl LOCATION IN BUILDING: 8. PRESENCE OF WEB: Found in web W ebbing evident nearby No web 9- SPIDER BITE7 Bite reported No bite reported Additional notes (optional): _________Basement Bathroom ________ Attic ________ C loset ______Ki t c h m ________ Other isrec.ify) APPENDIX B Number of Spiders Sent by County Agents 133 TABLE APPENDIX B.l.— Spiders Turned in by County Agents. County Spiders 01 03 07 08 09 10 11 15 17 20 24 25 27 28 30 31 34 13 14 21 26 10 15 3 41 7 15 1 3 6 16 18 13 1 County Iosco Kalamazoo Kalkaska Lake Lapeer Leelanau Lenawee Livingston Luce Macomb Manistee Mason Mecosta Menominee Missaukee Monroe Montcalm Code No. 35 39 40 43 44 45 46 47 48 50 51 53 54 55 57 58 59 Spiders 10 33 14 6 3 18 8 7 19 312 8 7 3 77 5 63 6 County Code No. Spiders Montmorency Muskegon Oakland Osceola Oscoda Ottawa Presque Isle Roscommon Saginaw St. Joseph Sanilac Tuscola Van Buren Washtenaw Wayne Wexford 60 61 63 67 68 70 71 72 73 75 76 79 80 81 82 83 12 9 22 3 9 5 13 22 12 14 10 6 21 4 111 13 TOTAL 53 1147 134 Alcona Allegan Baraga Barry Bay Benzie Berrien Charlevoix Chippewa Crawford Emmet Genesee Gogebic Gr. Traverse Hillsdale Houghton Ionia Code No. APPENDIX C Statistics for Size Class Study, Distance Study and Predator Prey Study 135 136 TABLE APPENDIX C.l. — Size Class study • cf Sm. Md. 9 Iran. X 8 7 5 6.6 8 6 4 6.0 8.3 7.0 5.0 X 9 8 6 7.7 Sm. Md. L?. X 9 8 8 8.3 8 7 6 7.0 8 7 5 6.6 8.3 7.3 6.3 Sm. Md. Lg. X 9 8 8 8.3 8 9 8 8.3 7 6 4 5.7 8.0 7.7 6.9 Significance Levels Aov. .24 Hour Starvation 48 Hour Starvation 72 Hour Starvation df M.S. F 9.48* 37.95*** Col. Row Error 2 2 4 4.222 16.889 0.445 Total 8 21.556 Col. Row Error 2 2 4 4.666 5.999 1.335 Total 8 12.000 Col. Row Error 2 2 4 14.222 2.889 3.112 Total 8 20.223 3.39 4.49 4.56 <1.0 N.S. / P>0.1 N.S. 0.10 ✓ 0“lt>5 * 0.01 ** 0.005 *** TABLE APPENDIX C.2.— Distance Study, AOV Table. Factor df M.S. A B C AB AC BC ABC J 2 5 1 10 2,415,367 4,502,551 57,553 456,381 191,219 177,826 2,981,545 201.866 2 5 10 144 Significance Levels F 11.97 22.3 <1 2.26 <1. <1. 14.7 Factors Cf **** **** A = Sexes; N.S. B = Starvation Levels N.S. N.S. C = Before + After Capture of Food * **** .05 * .01 * * .005 *** .001 * * * * N.S. Non Significant , QT , Inun 137 TABLE APPENDIX C.3.— Analysis of Variance for Universe Size, Prey Density and Predator Density Study. Factor df SS MS F Significance A 2 77.389 38.695 19 *** B 4 107.386 26.847 13.4 *** C 2 228.881 114.441 57 •*■*** AB 8 24.140 3.018 1.41 AC 4 210.334 52.584 24.51 **** BC 8 104.816 13.102 61.08 **** ABC 16 407.166 25.448 11.86 **** 180 386.850 2.145 J Factor A = Universe Size Factor B = Prey Density Factor C = Predator Density Significance Levels .05 = * .01 = * * .005 = *** .001 = * * * * P<.25 LITERATURE CITED Bradley, J. V. 1968. Distribution-free Statistical Tests, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N. J. Chamberlain, R. V., Ivie, W. 1933. A New Genus in the Family Agelenidae. Bull. University, Utah, 24:1-7. Conover, W. J. 1971. Practical Non-parametric Statis­ tics. New York. John Wiley & Sons Inc. 462 pp. Dabrowska-Prot, E. 1966. Experimental Studies on the Reduction of the Abundance of Mosquitoes by Spiders, II Activity of Spiders in Cages. Bull. Acad. Sci. Cl. II. 14:771-75. _______ . 1970. Interaction Between Two Spider Species Tn Prey Reduction. Bull. Acad. Pol. Sci. Cl. II. 18:3B3-88. ________ , Luzak, J. 1968. Spiders and Mosguitoes of the Ecotone of Alder Forest (Carici elongatae-AlnetumT and Oakpine Forest (Pino-Quercetunil) . Ekol. Polska A 16:461-63. Dondale, C. D. 1961. Life Histories of Some Common Spi­ ders From Trees and Shrubs in Nova Scotia. Can J. Zool. 39:777-87. Eberhard, W. 1967. Attack Behavior of Piqueted Spiders and the Origin of Prey Wrapping in Spiders. Psyche 74:173-81. Furnam, D. P. and W. C. Reeves. 1957. Toxic bite of a spider. Chiricanthium inclusum Hentz. Calif. Med. J. 87:114. Gardner, B. T. 1965. Observations on Three Species of Phidippus, Jumping SpidersT (Araneae:Salticidae). Psyche 72:133-47. Gertsch, W. J. 1949. American Spiders. Nostrand. 285 pp. 138 New York:Van 139 Hollander, H. 1967. Range and Movements of the Wolf Spi­ der Pardoaa chelata (O. F. Muller) and P. pullata (Clerck)^ Oikos 18:360-64. Haynes, D. L . , Sisojevic, P. 1966. Predatory Behavior of Philodromus rufus Walchenaer (Araneae:Thomisidae). Can. Entomol. 98:113-33. Hentz, N . M. The Spiders of the United States. Occ. papers Boston Soc. Nat. Hist. 2:1-171, 1875. Holling, C. S. 1965. The Functional Response of Preda­ tors to Prey Density and its Role In Mimicry and Population Regulation. Mem. Ent. Soc. Canada 45: 1-60. ________ . 1959. Some Characteristics of Simple Types of Predation and Parasitism. Can. Ent. 91:385-98. ________ . 1966. The functional Response of Invertebrate Predators to Prey Density. Mem. Ent. Soc. Canada 48:1-86. Kaston, B. J. 1948. The Spiders of Connecticut. Conn. Geol. and Nat. Hist. Survey Bull. 70. 874 pp. Levi, H. W. 1955. The Spider Genera Coressa and Achaeranea in America North of Mexico. (Araneae, Theridiidae). Amer. Mus. Nov., #1718. _______ . 1957. The Spider Genera Crustulina and Steatoda in North America, Central America and the West Indies (AraneaeiTheridiidee) . Bull. Mus . Comp . Zool. 117;3:367-424. ________. 1959. Problems in the Spider Genus Steatoda TTheridiidee) . Sys'. Zool. Vol. 8, #: 107-16. . 1962. The Genera of the Spider Family Theridii­ d a e . Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool. Vol. 127, 1:3-71. . 1963. American Spiders of the Genus Achaeranea and the New*"Genus Ec.hlnotheridion (Araneae :TherldXTd a e ) . Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool. Vol. 129, 3:189-240. . 1966. American Spider Genera Theridula and P aratheridula. (Araneae:The r i d i i d a e ) . Psyche Vol. 73, 2:123-30. . 1968. The Spider Genera Gea and Argiope in America (Araneae:Araneidae). Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool. Vol. 136, 9:319-52. 140 ________ . 1972. Predatory Behavior and Sexual Behavior of the Spider Slcarlus (Araneae:Sicariidae). Psyche 74:320-30. Loughton, B. G . , Derry, C. , West, A. S. 1963. Spiders and the Spruce Budworm. pp. 249-68. Ed. R. F. Morris. The Dynamics of Epidemic Spruce Budworm Populations. Mem. Ent. Soc. C a n a d a 332 pp. Lovell, J. H. 1915. The insects Captured by the Thomisidae. Can. Entomol. 47:115-16. Moulder, B. C . , Reichle, D. W . , Aurback, S. X. 1970. Sig­ nificance of Spider Predation in the Energy Dynamics of Forest Floor Arthropod Communities. PhD. Thesis. Univ. Tenn. 170 pp. Peck, W. B., Whitcomb, W. H. 1970. Studies on the Biology of a Spider Chiricanthium inclusum (Hentz). Agr. Exp. Sta., Div. Agr., Univ. Arkansas Bull. No. 753. 76 pp. Robinson, M. H. 1969. Predatory Behavior of Argiope aurantia (Fabricius). Am. Zool. 9:161-73. ________ , Mirick, H . , Turner, O. 1969. The Predatory Behavior of Some Araneid Spiders and the Origin of Immobilization Wrapping. Psyche 76:487-501. ________ , Olazarri, J. 1971. Units of Behavior and Com­ plex Sequences in the Predatory Behavior of Argiope Argentata (Fabricius): (Araneae;Araneidae). Smithson. Contrib. Zool. 65:1-36. Sokal, R. R. , Rohlf, F.