146 237 LIBRARY 1 Michigan State Quivelgmgg PLACE IN RETURN BOX to remove this checkout from your record. TO AVOID FINES return on or before date due. MAY BE RECALLED with earlier due date if requested. DATE DUE DATE DUE DATE DUE 6/01 cJClRC/DateDuepGS—pJS “l ' Box to remove this checkout from your record. ‘ FINES ' ' “ on or before date due. 1. ") ‘ ' a if requested. 1‘1me A HISTORICAL SURVEY OF EIGHTEENTH-CENTURY COLONIAL INTERIOR DESIGN AS EXEMPLIFIED BY INTERIOR WALLS OF HOUSES IN'WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA BY Sandra Feldpausoh Goran A PROBLEM Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of HASTER.OF ARTS Department of Textiles, Clothing and Related Arts 1966 ABSTRACT A HISTORICAL SURVEY OF EIGHTEENTH CENTURY COLONIAL INTERIOR DESIGN AS EXEMPLIFIED BY INTERIOR WALLS OF HOUSES IN WILLIAMSBURG. VIMINIA by Sandra Feldpausch Goran Photographs of the fireplace walls of fifteen rooms of Hilliamsburg. Virginia. houses were used to study and deter- mine the characteristics of Colonial design. The findings of this study correspond with descriptions presented as back- ground information of the decorative interior details from the literary sources. in examination of representative rooms of Williamsburg houses confirms the particular styling of the interior design details known as Colonial. The rooms of the Williamsburg houses can be divided into three groups, progressing from the simple to the more elaborate: - (1) rooms with combinations of a comics, chair rail and baseboard, (2) rooms with a dado. and (3) rooms with fully-paneled wainscotting. The treatment of the over-mantel on the fireplace wall was determined by the amount of paneling and moldings used. There were no examples of walls finished with wallpaper or fabric. Fireplace moldings were composed of three materials: marble, stone and wood. Marble fireplace moldings were used in the less elaborate room interiors and in houses having fully-paneled walls. Wood was painted and plaster was treated with whitewash. ’ 0 o . o n-V .lt . . . 0 1‘ K I . . Uh . .h r. s c . , a ._ . v Dr “.1.— s . r. . . .. . . . ,‘ r . . v u . r o. , . . J .. t n a. . . r . . r a O u x f . . 4 . m ii . .a \ h A v a , \ . a in I . _ I. u I . , . . .a r I. I v |.. .. . . a... on . .. I.- -. . 5 r . A t . y . . t .. ’2 ' r. Y. n u I o a . \ i l t a. : 1. . .r .p. . a, ,. a 4 ... w n - o .. . I. .- .. . I .L _ .. ACKNOWLEDGHENTS I would like to acknowledge the invaluable help given me by Hr. Paul Buchanan, Supervisor of Architectural Research and Records and Colonial Projects Designer, Wil- liamsburg, Virginia. He suggested the list of houses used in the study as being representative examples and permitted the use of the Progress and Research Photograph Albums in his office. I wish to express gratitude to the members of my committee, Dr. Mary Gephart, Hrs. Stephanie Winkler, and Mrs. Mabel Cooper Skjelver,for their guidance through this research problem. The personal interest in my study by my advisor, Dr. Elinor Nugent, gave me the desire to continue when time seemed to be unavailable. Her patience and kind manner is envied by the author of this study. I wish to extend sincere appreciation to her. The encouragement of my parents and understanding of my husband was needed and always welcomed. They helped me find the answer to my concern for care of Lynette and Jamie so I could continue and complete this study. Too, I thank my children for their good behavior and ready love. ii TABLE OF ACKNOWLEDGMENTS. . . . LIST OF TABLES . . . . LIST OF PLATES . . . . Chapter I. II. III. IV. INTRODUCTION. . CONTENTS Statement of the Problem. Methodology . Definition of Terms . Review of Literature. Focus of the Study. . THE CONTRIBUTION OF WILLIAMSBURG TO EIGHTEENTH-CENTURI COLONIAL Historical Background . Restoration . Summary . . . . . DESIGN. . . . DESCRIPTION OF REPRESENTATIVE CENTURY COLONIAL DETAILS USED WILLIAMSBURG HOUSES . . Fireplace and Kantel. Wall Treatments . Holdings and Paneling DoorS........ smaryeeee DESIGN DETAILS FOUND IN Summary 0 e 0 iii THE EIGHTEENTH- IN INTERIORS OF SELECTED HOUSES IN WILLIAMSBURG . . . . . "d m 09 ii 4 t: H UNU‘IUIN H 14 17 18 (D Chapter Page V. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS. . . . 44 0 O O O O I O O O O O O O 44 O 0 O O 0 O 0 O O 0 O O O 45 O O O O O O O O O O O O O 4 6 O O O O O O O O 48 swam O O O O 0 Conclusions . . . Recommendations . BIBLIOGRAPHY O O O O O O O O O O O O 0 iv LIST OF TABLES Table ' Page 1. Interior design details of the fireplace wall in living rooms of fifteen rooms of 00101113]. Williamsburg, Virginia. 0 e e e c e e e c 39 LIST OF PLATES Plate Page I. Various Fireplace and Room Arrangements. . . . . . 21 II. Five Baseboards. , , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 III. Five Chair Rails , , , , , . , . . . . . . . . . . 27 IV. Four Interior Cornices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 V. Fireplace Wall of the Powell-Waller'House, Williamsburg, Virginia 0 g o e o o e e e e e e e 35 VI. Fireplace Wall of the Peyton-Randolph House, - Williameurg, Virginia 0 e e e e e e e e c e e e 36 VII. Fireplace Wall of the Peyton-Randolph House, Williameurg, Virginia 0 e e o e e e e e e e e e 37 vi CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION In this mid-twentieth century there is an increased interest and use of architectural details and interior furnishings to capture the essence of our Early American heritage. The houses of the eighteenth century offer to contemporary designers and builders a source of inspiration and detail which is expressive of the ideals and standards of a new and vigorously developing country. It is perhaps the desire to acquire the strength and stability as.wsll as the beauty of the past that contemporary architects and in- terior designers turn to the Colonial period. The restoration of Williamsburg, Virginia, in the late 1920'slbrought the merits of Colonial design to the attention of twentieth-century designers and builders. The restored houses and public buildings created not only a source of inspiration, but also a basis for the study of the design of a past era.. Through a utilization of this source, it is possible to determine and summarize the char- acteristics of the design which is known as "Colonial.". 1A. Lawrence Kocher and Howard Dearstyne, W lliams- bur : Its Buildi s and Ca ens (New York: Holt, ne art an n8 on, no” 9 P. ' 3:; Statement of the Problem The purpose of this study is to determine the char- acteristics of Colonial design as expressed in the details used in the interiors of houses built in America during the eighteenth century. By examining and summarizing the treat- ment used for fireplace walls in the living rooms of a selected group of original and restored houses in Williams- burg, Virginia, it is possible to identify the characteristic interior design style of the Colonial period. The assumption guiding this study is that the interior design details found in the houses of Williamsburg, Virginia, are examples of the eighteenth-century Colonial period in America. Details of interior design are compiled and sum- marized as an aid for those interested in creating furnish- ings and interiors for contemporary homes using adaptations of eighteenth-century Colonial design. The use of such details can assist in capturing the spirit and feeling evidenced in the houses of Williamsburg where the furnish- ings were in harmony with the basic structural and archi- 2 It is hoped this study will contribute tectural qualities. information for the use of designers of interiors, whether professional designers or interested homemakers. 2"The Williamsburg Tradition," Williamsburg Repro- ductions, May, 1965, p. 7. Methodology This is an historical and descriptive study of eighteenth-century colonial interior design. In addition to literary sources, it is possible to utilize the actual structures of this period which have either been maintained or reproduced in the restoration of one of the most impor- tant towns of the eighteenth-century Colonial period in America. Williamsburg was the capital of the Commonwealth of Virginia from 1699 to 1780. The town became a political and social metropolis and reflects this role in its archi- tectural development.3 Ideas and ideals of the nation were focused in Williamsburg as the great statesmen verbally and physically fought for and won their independence from England. Williamsburg offers an authentic and unique source for study because of the efforts since 1926 to reproduce exactly the structures of the Colonial era.5 After examining the available literature pertaining to interior wall treatments of houses in Williamsburg, Virginia, photographs of fifteen rooms of fourteen houses were selected and used during a visit to the restored city. These photographs formed a basis for a description of eight- eenth-century Colonial wall treatments and interior design details found in the fireplace walls of the living rooms. 3Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 3. 4Kenneth Chorley, Williamsbur in Vir inia (Williams- burg, Virginia: Colonial ams urg, Incorporated, 1963), PP. 1']. e 5Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 45. 4 . A representative list of living rooms was taken from Part II of Whiffen's book, The Eighteenth-Century Houses of Williamsbugg.6 Marcus Whiffen was a member of the staff of Colonial Williamsburg as an architectural historian from 1954 to 1959. Part II of his book is a pictorial survey of thirty-two of the eighty-three original houses in Williams- burg’s restored area. These photographs were from the Progress and Research Photograph Albums7 of Colonial Williams- burg. Photographs of representative living rooms for this study were selected and permission for this use was granted by Paul Buchanan, Supervisor of Architectural Research and Records and Colonial Projects Designer, Williamsburg, Vir- ginia. Buchanan has been associated with the restoration program since 1950, a period of sixteen years. These rooms were chosen according to information relative to this study which was found in the Progress and Research Photograph Albums. These albums collected at Williamsburg contained pictures taken during various phases of the restoration or preservation of each building from its start to its completion. Incorporating the suggestions of Buchanan, fifteen rooms of fourteen houses were selected fbr'this study. These rooms included a fireplace wall which was considered " 6Marcus Whiffen, The Bi hteenth-Centu Houses of Williamsb (New York: ROII, RIEeEEET, and NInsIon, Inc., I535}, pp. 59-185. 7Progress and Research Photograph Albums. Williams- burg, Virginia: Colonial Williamsburg, Inc. ..u. . .~ c u v . . . ,. .- a 'a- - V S v a ..-v r - o - a. I c ‘ _. ~ C It . . ‘- '1' ' o I o. A” a" l ' n r I O a ‘ c e - ~ . . -~ “\ . p .- J . ' O .1. . ' as .n A J .“ 1 . I. A... . . o - n 4 ‘-. (1. ' . (I .~ 7 .4 c .L. .‘, ‘ a ‘. -a a ‘ . . . I t . . 4 t 5 ’ . l - l a . .. n . -. a O’ a ‘ .' . u .. z . o > n In. I- 4 I ‘ r ‘ . U - -. _ 't .‘ ' . a. .‘ l. ‘7 " v r a b J . . ,_ . _. . a ' ..- ,- F . . ' ‘ I. , no. 'I'. . I . .‘ J. t .4... . ,- §' I I ‘ . O . ‘ l . a. , ' .~ ‘ A‘r v . l ' V , emu. . .. ' I r '- . , . . . . ‘- .- .. ._,. -vw» .u— , - I l s c ;.- F _ . . . , ~ 7. - ‘ ~ - . i \ - . ' , . I t s r I" f' . ' r ' i . c. , . c 'v I r ' .0 .b a ' -- r “ I . . u a. ‘. \~ ‘ \u'.. .l I t A 4 ‘ .L ' ¢ \ ' t . p- , l I ‘- ( ~~ ‘ . -.~ .- '3 - L"? . 4 g . ' u — t -' n ’ I ' . n» i . V». - .- . Ir 1 u a<- a. e -- L 5 --I l.’..a . - a v '\' F - .c m ~- . l" , ‘ : ' ‘r — . .. . ,, » k c . . - - ' - .- r‘ - I ‘ ‘ I 1 ' t 4 . . r, v . , v. v '. I ,“ t r ,5 ->-. . -\- x . . . .. . .- .- y' 1 ' I d a . - e . g u f ‘ I ' . -t' , a - ‘ ,1 .V '-' .- r‘ ,V 0"! i ' \ , I“ . . e.- . 4 a e ' * \— . ’ ‘ ,_ \ r x ‘ fi. 5. -' ,. -1 ‘l u l . ; ,« v.“ r‘ u_ .5. . .. '_ . A . - - . ." - , ‘ '. p I e - L A... A ’ ‘ V . 'I ‘ 4 .J . . _ ‘, e- l ' \ II v -- t ' ' , ' . l . . m 1 . - “an f r . I a , -.J . n I ‘ a \ 4 u , r‘ 4' t a - fl 1’ '- | r ‘ r , e v ,. ~ . ~ - I A. I . . I > -- . - ”A .. a O .- c . . a‘ r .- i r ‘ I . ‘3 . t ’ t H. .‘ a oo-e..a.--- . ’ 4 . . .. , AI ' I» I 'I , . . . -I . . . I i l x - v ,.-1 . . l O ‘Q , . -r J. \ .-.. . O In“ IW‘. . rs ' '. representative of eighteenth-century colonial interior design. From literary sources an outline compiling the details of the interior design was developed for use in studying these photographs. The details studied include: (1) the divisions of the wa11--paneling (wainscot or dado), moldings (cornice, chair rail, baseboard), fireplace (mantel or over-mantel, molding), and (2) the decoration of the wall-- actual materials (paint, whitewash, wallpaper, fabric). The details gathered from literary sources were described and some illustrations were included to identify the Colonial details. The outline of the compiled interior design details of the fifteen rooms presents further identi- fication of the characteristic interior design style of the Colonial period, and the characteristic features which express the qualities of eighteenth-century colonial design are sum- marized. Definition of Terms Various terms are used in the description of eight- eenth-century architectural details. These need to be de- fined to promote an understanding today of the meaning of these terms as used in the eighteenth century. The term Colonial Williamsburg designates the time when Williamsburg was the capital of Virginia from 1701 to 1779.8 8"The Historical Background," The Architectural Record (December, 1935), pp. 160-61. The restoration program restored the architectural details by using new materials to duplicate the original or preserved the object by retaining the original through the use of ordinary repair.9 The livipg room is that part of the house used to entertain acquaintances.10 The terms wainscottipg and gggp are used to refer to types of paneling that are wood coverings applied to the wall area in varying amounts.11 Paneling that extends from the baseboard molding to the ceiling is referred to as wainscottipg. Paneling extending from the baseboard molding up three to five feet ending with the finishing molding, dado cap, is referred to aswainscottigg or $293.12 The terms comics, dado cap, W or W, and baseboard refer to types of moldings of wood applied horizontally to various areas of the wall.13 The cornice is applied to the area at the angle of the wall and ceiling.14 The dado cap is applied to the wall as the finishing molding at the top of wainscotting or dado.15 The chair rail or sur- 9William Graves Perry, "Notes on the Architecture," The Architectural Record (December, 1935), p. 370. - 10Whiffen, op. cit., pp. 46-51. 11Norman Morrison Isham, A Glossa of Coloniaerrchi- tectural Terms (The Walpole SociEt5T'ICESTT‘BETTE5:577""" 12Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 25. 13Isham, loc. cit. 14Ibid. 15Whiffen, 0p. cit., p. 81. l r A V up ‘- ‘. - 7‘ “ - : .r-- 0 l . n I . , " ‘ . n w - e a ‘ I 4 .3 o - - ‘ ‘ .. nus. -.-.t ....-.. . 4 - A . D . ,. . . . . —‘ . .- ' ‘. . _ . a ' - l A A Q ' ' ' ’1 ‘ . ‘r r . L" — o I . — ‘ l 4-4 a . ' e A . s , , " ' " x A A r . 2 ‘I’ ~ A ’ . . he :. I f ‘.._ I r I l , . ‘ r I r ' J ‘ A) ‘ -.-*J A a . . A .. . . - . . -. .n - . -. 4- . , ' , , 'nr . . ‘ . - I A ' K e 1 e e . l . . . J r r I ‘- ’ .. ~ . I A 1 ~. . v t - L . ‘ A .1 ‘ . A - ’ . - . . . .r. a I“ o --'a 'V'O’.‘ -I~- .. e I . '. ,3 , ,, ‘ . ’ 1...). (V O u ' a . J ‘ a ’ . v - - . H. ‘ ' p' "‘ ~ I ~ . a - p- r - < , a ., f. . i. a - - w u ' . t - A | u l f ‘ A .l . " o . . r. ' '. 1. A ~ - ~ A s . tea-or . «v . - n - -- am. ~—. “ a . ' - a ‘ D ‘t H ‘ -- DJ . l ‘ r . c (x‘ ‘. I, '. v -. A ;. . ‘ rfi o,- - ,. — J Q~ . .‘ -'~ . a \. _. . A A 'v x‘ . - I _ , _ p K, x A . . -1 1. . . - n- r. . u._ , . . . 1 . ~ . - _., , ,.,., _ .., , - - . . ‘ | . A t ‘ A - l‘ ' " A ' . " - ' 8 ‘ n v a . ‘ . ' a I. v’ - e t. v " «I. - .L - Q _~ , - I - e I , . . . , A, . , A, , . ,‘ ‘ t .. , ,.. _ a. ', + V. y 1'“, a _ . ,_ r ., .— A: A . A , ‘ ' I . ~ 1 \a; . - . . _ J. _, , , '_ , L .u‘ _ . '. .‘ ~ . ;. IV 0. - 1. -. 1 ‘- ‘- ‘ - r- . . , _ . . I... v .,, . . \‘l .. . . . .. .., A. .. .3. . . - . 3 ..A .A ~ - . . g - i . . _ ‘ . . . u .1 . J v‘ ‘ .1 . ‘ .g n w ~ l.‘ . . - - 4 a ' . X .I- ’. ' - ' O ..‘. .- a. - .r- - We 0 u a - . t P» - 'Y r‘ . , . P' . I . . t , .t .' — , ~ . ' “ . A.' . s- . - - ,. e, H . ' ‘ ‘ \ . , ' l . v .. s . . . x L l . ' . Lt . g L- ' ‘ "‘ I ' ‘ " F ‘ ~ -‘ ‘L w 0— u -‘ << ‘- 4 I a. A. a a‘ .L \ 1 . -e a K a -~ .. *1 4 - f I u 4 re I ' _ 9 P. ‘n. .~ I a O . ‘ . ._ I. . ' . a . t. ,‘ l , __. .1 1 \r‘. . A , Q ‘r . r .t A . - ~ ‘ . , .- . A , , I . -. J- , , A. . ,4 .J I .I r . ,, .1 , J. . . _ 4-. , _ _ oh . . ‘O N o-gw—r... .- “- w.,.,.- ‘ , ' . . ‘- . 5 . ' V | an. I ' ' ‘ f, ’ ‘ I " . . ' ’ r‘ ‘1 . ~ (V I C" I'. f - . .' :- ‘DI ‘ _I I. h-¢.V l- 'x“ D r , ' ‘W "" W“ D‘“' ‘ duvvvm‘c-v-ov.” -m -' '00- up on... A. us..-.-..-v .Q-A‘. ' I" u r I - . r ' I i ’ 3 H' - r‘. ' 4 -. v“; ~o~. - . '\ r'. |-. ' , a . . a ' 4 '. :- w ’- ' . ‘ t" _‘ b ,a . . . . . . . ‘1 . A ' s v. J \I “v ' .3 ‘u (a , . J 4 . . \ r.“ - ‘ " .,' .‘ , .i ,: a , ‘ t O - I - v . . ”a... galley I..." . . , u . . . 'r' L .T_ ‘ 0 ,_ e ' ,, a . , a a . ‘ u . ~ , u . _' (I. . i _ ; 11:." _ r. 1‘) t , a", '2: p . p. 2 _ v .fi . .‘I . '7 r) :- . , , . ‘,, ' . ' 9 . o t .' ~ ‘ , 2 ’ . : ,~. '3 f . J. p “ I u . .' c. I‘ . . I. . .. e‘ ‘- r' 4. .l . - . r ,- J¢-.—-' . ‘V ’ -.-5 ul .’ .l.‘-' I. , 4. y. ' u ’1 -‘9- a -- .'I.\‘ ‘ -. . ~ .- g_ 9 l" o . . a ' - I . '- ‘ | {i ‘ f‘ V, , ) .' ,' - ‘ ( '9 -~ ' tn": r. I I“ ." .‘ "‘ , I» 1, ’ . . a J. . .0 at . \ J » ' ”I. J- “J ' \ ' ll e.’ .L J. ‘-‘ ' ‘ ' ‘ - J, ‘u’ ’3 ' n '- ' ~ - . . ' v1 ' ' I C I l I v . r . ~ ' I -- i l: "' ‘1’ .".'-f "‘2 v;."; L a- r- |‘ ’\'.' A .\ a ' '1 +r‘\ 1'" .' r ' \ ~ '.r‘,-' C ~'.' ' .- -¢ ‘- ‘ 1 I ' - - - - — ‘ \’ a .1 IV- as ' i ~ v "- I c- . ‘ I . LA- I .. k. 1“ L. ’ ' ' ‘ I~¢D~--"-' '---v—.-'p~ «"6 -~a.vm- 'O-U -'—..k- ‘ . 1 » o f q- - z. . O'. ' r . , I - ‘ ‘ p l 1‘ a. ' r .' r O A . ' . ' A. 1' ' f: -‘ ' r . \ -.1Jk ale A. Md L. -.. - .. . , a ’ «45 ~. ”-3- - ' - ' ' ' '("‘ I. ' -. . ' I . ' 'e A . I ’ . ‘ ‘ hi. ._ 1 l‘fi.’ 3‘ -‘. I. ' ’ -‘ r. t . . 1- .«y'. ‘ ‘ I I ‘& . .- S K i “ ‘ ‘L _. . ‘ ‘ ’ - . I - ' " I ‘ - A J .. ‘ .flfln .--, aw.‘ . ~~ -. ¢.-.-. n. .. .l.. I .- ~ . r .. . - .~‘ 4'- ‘ ‘T‘. f. , -' ‘ I. 0‘ -. A ._a_ " "o o ' ' e. -- t . _ I A ' . ~ ' I O " ‘ -' . . I_ . O a I z 0 , A I ‘ - L ‘ gs. - . - ’ ow- -O~~- Incl-s ‘ ‘ I. . '- o - - . .- - ' ‘ ‘ - I" . f‘ \ Q P, -‘ f h c l. ._. '- C A‘ g-. u I") ‘ e ’ pY ~ . ‘ - a _ ', - .- '.’ . a t ' . l- O :‘- a ' .I“ J, . I_ .g. ,L '; ‘ L'.:’ D ‘- -e-‘ ‘a n v .r .. .. -. sac-'w‘. . -‘ r v -m- Ace-us- ‘ .- , . ,1" r .. _ ,» _ ‘ H ‘ ' ‘ .‘ ,. ( .‘ ,. .. g f . . .— “‘ .- e .t_ J. a .. - c‘ .. .' A . '1 A .1 -' .3 4. L ' .5 .. ' ' ' ‘ ‘ a- o. v --9:- .- -. . . .1 r r‘ ' .. v v . _ \ ‘f ‘ I r . "; L ‘ ‘e .'_h -. ."\ .“ n‘ . . . c . J ‘ ul . ~ g “ I ' . n ‘ . .o v - ..- .v-o ' ' . n...- - r . . . ‘ \ \ . r - ‘ . ' c. . " ’ . x a leg - ‘ . .c .. ‘ "- V.“ 1' ‘.~ .0- I .I' .\ r f : ' "' " .' C . our . v . , A r 7 base is applied half-way up the wallor at "chair height" as a protective molding where there is no paneling.16 The base- board is applied to the are: at the bottOm of the wall.17 The fireplace molding and mantel or overbmantel are the components of the area around the fireplace and the area above, respectively.18 Review of Literature Interest in the restoration of Williamsburg, Vir- ginia was reflected in the many writings which presented the various facets of the Colonial city. Many articles focused upon the architecture, the gardens, colonial cookery, life in the eighteenth century, and the progress of the restoration program. Numerous magazines presented the newly restored and rebuilt.houses through pictures and descriptions. Two - issues of House and Garden819 presented articles on the out- standing features of the houses of the restored city; both named and described the fireplace wall and the window detail- ' ing. The thirty-one page coverage in the 1937 issue20 also 16Kocher and Dearstyne, loo. cit. 17Isham, loc. cit. 18M' 1 191?.thel A. Reeve, "Inside A.Virginian Colonial House :3.O%g-g;lliamsburg,f House and Gardens (November, 1933), 2°”Williamsburg, What It Means to Architecture, to Garden ,-to Decoration," House and Gardens (November, 1937).' PP . 37- . ' I 1 l _ . . . , . - . 0 a ~ a ‘ a w a "‘ U ' c s o t 0 A .- a . n ' . . - I .g . . , .. —- u . v a . . ; ‘ _ J I . w. I 1 i - . - ' . ' u —- .a. w , . t . _ . , ' ~ . V w . .. _ - . ‘fall"¢ , 7‘ c.- o¢O.--- -- , - -v-‘ LA- - .alo. - -u . . w v - . I l -’ ’ " 0 ' I I_ , . . . — ' AI. ) _ A ’.t h In 5- d 0‘ r .a ’ '. . . .t‘ A A». . ,7 - < ° . V ,' V v . . . - . -. > . . ~ 7 _. ‘ - , . ‘ . ’ I - ‘ a - - — ., . - . 9 o f v A - ‘ - ¢ 4. ~ - - , . ‘ I . A ‘ , ' ~ . . - . u .1 , a 1 ' .- . , v . . ~ « . - . v p - a y v ‘ 1 ‘ . ' t ‘ ‘ ~ ' - \ ‘ ' < . . - . - . , _ - ‘ .4 4 r . , - . .. < . , vs . n , . A e , . ,3 . : . . . _ . A , x. . o . < . ‘ e . \ o ‘ - . v . |i ‘- K , ~ e ' ' A ‘ ‘ . ' ‘ ‘ r ’ ' ‘ I l' ‘\ ' 1 h ' I u v ' ‘ t u . .- .. . . _ -. - .. J .- o < ’ - - I .. > . P. ‘ v‘ ' g . ‘ 4 ‘ A . ~v- - A- - r . . . . . . I , 7 v: v . v 1 e ~ . e I t l I . a I i ‘ - ' v . . ' ‘ _ a . . . 1 . . _ 3 . \ . - . . -. ‘ 1. g - . - ‘ - K r ' ' o- , ' '- » . c . I - o \ . - . . v - . . , 0 . ~ - . ‘ c a o .c O , .~ 1 v . I P . . . , . m, e- p ‘ v a | ‘ a . U V C e . v . a-r a . 'I . . y . g - - - . -.s.. | n . . . O I . z . ~ ‘ mu. 5 . a a . - C o . . . '. u . , - . . . , .. . . g . , . - I «I. -. u H... 553-— named proportions of the rooms and furnishings, and the un- usual color schemes. It was also pointed out that the Williams- burg houses and public buildings contribute generously to a catalogue of fireplace designs. Two issues of the Ladies Home 21 Journal presented relative pictorial descriptions of the exterior and interior of two houses in Williamsburg. In both articles the photographs depicted the details of the fireplace wall.22 Interest in the indispensable traditions of Colonial architecture persisted as the restoration progressed. Many books mention the value of the restoration pro- gram and the merits of the architecture of Williamsburg. Gowans, an analyst of the colonial Spirit in America, points out the value of Williamsburg as a source of study in his book Images of American Living.23 Gowan states: The Williamsburg buildings mean many things to many people. To some, they mean wealth, the wealth of early Virginia that built them, the wealth of twentieth-century America that restored them. To others they mean a style to copy. But their greatest significance remains historical. They are deliberate dramatizations in America of men s power to organize their environment mean- ingfully; they are the first works of and for men consciously delighting to feel Ehemselves in command of the world they inhabit.2 21"Brush-Everard House," Ladies Home Journal (October, 1952). pp-e46-47. 22"Nicolson House," Ladies Home Journal (February, 1955). pp- 50-51- 23Alan Gowans, Imaoes of American Livin (Phila- delphia, New York: J.B. Lippincott Company, I§é4). 24Ibid., p. 135. Hamlin, Professor of Architecture, Columbia University, also regarded the buildings as valuable sources. He states: Williamsburg, of course, had the most sophisti- cated, the most elegant capital of them all. Now rebuilt in as close a reproduction of the original as the existing foundations, contempo- rary engravings and descriptions could make pos- sible,...the reconstructed buildings show a quality in the pr0portion of window and wall, an originality and daring in the use of carved forms, a dexterity in the handling of arched and square- headed openings which is all unique in America.25 Watterson in Speaking of the Governors' Palace in his book, Architecture26 stated: "The interiors, the furnishings, and the very beautiful gardens of this building have made it a shrine in early Americana." Hatterson further voices the praises of the colonial architecture of Williamsburg as he writes: The restoration of Colonial Williamsburg, Virginia, affords a unique opportunity to see early eight- eenth-century Virginia architecture at its best. Not only a few buildings, but an entire portion of the city, about a mile long by one-third of a mile wide, has been restored to its condition before 1810....Along this street are many old houses and taverns, as well as Bruton Church, carefully rebuilt or restored, completely cap- turing the atmosphere, as the aspect, of the old city. 7 Kimball, the Director of the Pennsylvania Museum and His- torian of the American Institute of Architects, stated: "Williamsburg, at the Revolution, was a town of beauty and 25Talbot Hamlin, Architecture Throu h the Ages (New York: G.P. Putham's Sons, 19535. pp. 530-51. 26Joseph Watterson, Architecture (New York: W.W. Norton and Company, Inc., 19 0 . 27Ibid., p. 301. \r. 10 of architectural significance; its major buildings were milestones in history of American style, its Palace Garden perhaps the most beautiful in America."28 The work of Kocher and Dearstyne, Williamsbugg: Its Buildings and Gardens29 described the restoration. Exterior and interior architectural details found in the houses and public buildings were presented. This book was done under the guidance of the Colonial Williamsburg organization. Also under their guidance the comprehensive presentation of Williamsburg's public buildings entitled, The Public Buildings of Williamsburg30 was done by Marcus Whiffen, architectural historian. His later book, Th2 Eighteenth-Century Houses of Williamsburg31 included detailed descriptions of the original houses in the town. 'Gowans states that Marcus Whiffen's writings have been classical sources on Williamsburg since their appearance. The book written by Kocher and Dearstyne and the work of Whiffen were recommended by Mr. Paul Buchanan, Supervisor of Archi- tectural Research and Records and Colonial Projects De- signer, Williamsburg, Virginia. Considered as good repre- sentative sources for this study, these writings were the major sources for Chapter II and III of this study. 28Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 11. 291bid. 3OMarcus Whiffen, The Public Buildin s of Williams- burg (New York: Holt, Rinefiaft, and Winston, Tnc., I§535. 31Whirfen, The Eighteenth-Century Houses of Williams- burg. 11 The Williamsburg Restoration, Incorporated has periodically published catalogues, Williamsburg Reproduc- tgpng?2of the available authentic reproductions of the interior decor of the important historic city. The organiz- ers of this crafts catalogue attribute the lasting interest and harmonious results in Colonial interiors to the effective use of proportion, detail, and symmetry. The structures, gardens and interiors are based on geometric designs. They state: Grace of proportion and rhythm of pattern, hon- est use of materials, subtle harmony of varied designs; these ancient concepts are as applic- figigStgwgogzg;:rigziggoagsthey were to towns and Interior design studies have been very few and none has been completed utilizing the houses of Williamsburg, Virginia. Sisson completed a thesis entitled, "A Study of Architecture, Interior Design and Furnishings of Selected Houses in the United States in the Period of 1890-1920."34 This study, concentrating upon a period of rapid industrial growth and arChitecture in the United States, was undertaken to analyze the architecture, interior design and furnishings of selected houses in New York, Philadelphia and Chicago. 32Williamsburg Reproductions (Williamsburg, Virginia: Williamsburg Restoration Inc., 1965). 33Ibid. 34Marian B. Sisson, "A Study of Architecture, Interior Design and Furnishings of Selected Houses in the United States in the Period of 1890-1920" (unpublished Master’s thesis, Drexel Institute of Technology, 1964). 12 It was also the purpose to determine to what extent, if any, there existed a correlation between the architecture, interior design and furnishings of these houses. A similar study util- ized as source materials a group of houses in southwest 35 The purpose of Cannon's study was to locate and Georgia. preserve a record of selected Greek Revival influenced houses in southwest Georgia, together with certain pieces of furb niture used by their original owners. It was believed that a partial reconstruction of life in the nineteenth century for a selected number of people might be realized if written descriptions and visual records of the architectural features of theil'houses and of their furniture were compared with those in standard sources and presented against a background of contemporaneous state, county, and family history. Although these studies are not concerned with the Colonial period, they do show an interest in interior design. The value of an examination of historic houses was brought out by Kenneth Chorley, the President of Colonial Williams- burg, Incorporated, when he stated: "That the Future may learn from the Past."36 I General works on the architecture of Williamsburg appear but architectural studies researching for Specifics are limited. Therefore, determining the characteristics of Colonial design as expressed in the details used in the 35Margaret Cannon, "Southwest Georgia Houses of Greek Revival Influence and Their Furniture, 1820-1890" (unpublished Master's thesis, Florida State University, 1963). 36House and Gardens, LXXII, loc. cit. 13 interiors of houses built in America during the eighteenth century is the purpose of this study. Focus of the Study This study of Colonial design is directed toward a compilation and presentation of the decorative details which are eXpressive of interior.house design during the eighteenth century. Through an examination of the living rooms of houses which were either built in the eighteenth century or restored to their original state, it is hoped that a better definition and understanding of Colonial design may be achieved. There also seems to be confusion in the use of the term "Colonial" with the term "Early American." "Colonial" has been used repeatedly to explain and discuss interiors . that are "Early American." This unintentional misuse of terms causes confusion on the part of salesmen as to what their customers actually want; relatives, neighbors and acquaintances find themselves discussing two completely different aspects of interior design. This study is an attempt to lessen this confusion by trying to establish the characteristics of the Colonial period. The restoration of Williamsburg, Virginia, has brought the merits of eighteenth-century design to the attention of contemporary designers and home furnishers, and created a basis for study. Through an examination of historic Williams- burg and interior design details, this study will strive to present the characteristics of eighteenthpcentury colonial interior design. ( v4, 1 ‘. i . I! . ‘- .‘ . l 0 e 1 V I .- - ' - J - ‘ ('| u ,. ”‘2 l - . '. .b V. ; ' A F! - . - -I. . .4 v I... f l d.- . . I-- -- . o t or D. a o- n f a II . '- c | o' . f. .. . O . i . i .‘ l‘ ‘ .1 . ,. . Cal. ‘1 .- ‘ aw. .-. . - u. ... . . .. a» ' ,. . .. _ ..- u I l p ~ ’ I I u -4 -s .. \ -- . “a ‘ v‘I- '- - .c . , ' . I l v Q . I a . . -1 -t .c n . .t. '. ‘ . . I ' . I - A . a c a _ - ~ . . » . . .. . . - . ‘ . o . . I ' . t . - . . . . . t. ‘ ‘ , < c x 1 > | . . . .r . .. . —\ . o u .. - ‘9 I V. ‘ ." 2. ' ’ '. r P.‘ . --- . a- i .9 - '4 ‘ -._ ' ‘ 2 r‘. , : v . -. . ‘~ . . u' I» ‘ g .. J. -. " l ' I- .. t. " _ L' , \‘ ’ . 4 Q . . . . . . _ ' t , ' T ,' ,~ 1 .4. ~/ I I . ‘ .I . , — , -. . .'- ..- ._ ' l '\ ' .i u ' I? v r -. f- ‘7‘ o . . § . . - e. _. ‘ .. a 0 I -' I- ' u f' ‘ J. a ' " A n . g r .. ' ' i.- v-r.,- ‘ § . - ' 1. § ...§. ‘. Aluk 1" 1 C O c .‘1‘ ‘ . p ‘ . I . l ‘ .. O ‘ v I ‘~ ,- s‘. ‘- r . I v ,. f‘l " _u. . . »_ . . .3 .2- 5.. 'J '4 - . . . V .\ . . .. . ‘u . . .- ' . I, l I, t ‘ . . . .a a . . .- \ v ,- . I a . I o - . ‘ w -- a ‘ 3.2 ~ . . , ..- . u: I r T Y . _ 1‘: ‘ ‘ .3 6,.- v , . -. . - . 4 .. . . J . . . . . . . o . u l D \ I - . , --. , ... . ? . _ A . . . , -. . .. .1. s' . . r i 2. .'. -. - . . . e ' V! (I ~ ‘ --s. ' aw i o ,. N '- . .I - V. I 'J, ' .. 5 a , i u s ‘r ".‘ I . . ~' 1 I I“ ‘- I - tu‘ - O r . t 1 i ,1 u t , a... o. \t- . a . fin ' . - 0 cl. is , n ' . ' a - . .n , . r , . _‘ - a x 5' ' . - “t ‘ . o ' .. J . . A I I“ a. .— a ‘0‘- ." I~ ' o . .. ‘ 0 \u . 4 ~ ~ 0 . a . ' - . ‘ \. I . . . . . . .. A .f ‘— s A -50 r-«n 1‘“ r» -r I .. . v o 0 ' ' . ., e. I V . f". . .1. . - 1 \f' \ ~<.' . l '1'? . l .1 . u. u‘ - . . . ' . \ - - . _ _ v I .' ' I . a 1' -~ . , . fl . . 0 . ,. -‘~.- . _.a. v - J. -. - V . . ..v, - J ‘, . - '| ., .o o f' .‘ .t I. ‘ n. . | 'l - 1 ..-. .1- - F Y a . . .‘ 1‘ ‘5‘ , _\. -\ , » r\ . I _ .‘ . ,._. I I g... . CHAPTER II THE CONTRIBUTION OF WILLIAMSBURG TO EIGHTEENTH-CENTURY COLONIAL DESIGN Historical Background Williamsburg was distinctive as the seat of govern- ment and as the cultural center for one of Britain's largest and most powerful colonies; its size belies its importance in shaping the history of America. Williamsburg's political significance is intimated in the Capitol; its prestige for the Crown in the Governor's Palace; its cultural role in Bruton Church and the Wren Building of the College of William and Itiary.l Williamsburg served as the capital of Virginia from 1699 to 1780. It was during these years that the cap- ital experienced historical and architectural significance. The town was originally settled as Middle Plantation. In 1699, when the capital was removed from Jamestown to Williams- burg, it was renamed in honor of King William III. In 1780 the capital was moved to Richmond and then Williamsburg fell into decline. lKocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 3. 2Ibid. 14 15 During the period Williamsburg was the center of colonial activity, it was a small college town and market place for the major part of each year. Twice a year the town was crowded with people intent upon serious business as well as activities for the fun-loving. Usually this was the time when the legislature met and the courts were in session. The town actually doubled in population and every available Space was used for lodging in the taverns, inns, and private houses. Very important peOple made their appearance at the capital during these "publick times." Banquets, balls, lawn fetes, displays of fireworks, horse races and fairs were held for the amusement of the people as well as to encourage trade. Although Williamsburg was not a large trading center, the skilled craftsmen and the shopkeepers made certain the finest goods of the colony and the latest creations from England were available.3 Many manufactured goods were imported frmm England as late as 1752. When the Stamp Act and other restrictive measures were passed, the tense relations with England led to a decrease in the number of imports and an increasing demand for the home crafts and manufactured goods. Williams- / burg produced furniture, candies, coaches, saddles and harnesses, jewelry, shoes, hosiery, and wigs.4 I The cultural position Williamsburg held in the colony was due in part to the presence of the College of 31bid., pp. 3-4. #Ibido , Po 40 U 16 William and Mary. This college was founded in 1693 as the second oldest college in the colonies. The college and the government of the town worked together. Members of the college were even represented in the House of Burgesses. Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Harrison, James Monroe, John Tyler, John Marshall, Edmund Randolph and other'men impor- tant in America's past were students of this college. George Hythe was one of the prominent members of the faculty. He was the tutor of Thomas Jefferson and founder of the first course in law at an American college.5 The site and position of the College was an asset to its students, the townSpeople, and the colonists. It was in the center of the social, cultural, and political life of the colony. The students saw and experienced at first-hand the operations of colonial society and government. Bruton Church also had its part in the cultural role Williamsburg held in the colonies. Between 1711 and 1715 the church was erected so it would be adequate to serve as court church of the colony. This building became the center of religious life in the capital. Students, governors, members of the Council and the House of Burgesses, and aristocracy of the town and nearby plantations came to listen to the sermons. Church events brcught people together dressed for the occasion and many came for'the purpose of displaying their best attire.7 6 1? Restoration The historical value of Williamsburg was recognized by Dr. W. A. R. Goodwin, late rector of Bruton Church, who became interested in the preservation of an important land- mark in the nation's history. He persuaded the late John D. Rockefeller, Jr. to invest in a program of restoration. Originally the project, begun in 1926, was to recover'the significant portions of an historic and important city of America's period. This has been broadened to include an interpretation based upon the recognition of Williamsburg's importance in the formulation of American political thought, education, commerce, fashions of the New World, and religion.8 This program required a vast staff of experts. Architects, archaeologists, landscape gardeners, builders, town planners, historians, lawyers, engineers, decorators and many others were employed. The entire area of land that originally comprised the city was purchased or contrclled. This area was then studied from the very depths of the earth through the construction of entire buildings. Whenever it was possible, the first desire has been to preserve the surb viving work by ordinary repair and then secondly, to restore the old forms by new work.9 As the project continued, new information was constantly being discovered and the buildings were authentically reconstructed as well as more correctly reatoredc 8Ibid., p. 45. 9Perry, op. cit., p. 370. 4’ 18 Summary Williamsburg served as the capital of Virginia .from 1699 to 1780. It was during these years that the capital experienced historical and architectural signifi- cance. During "publick times" the legislature met and the courts were in session; the town doubled in size. Banquets, balls, lawn fetes, displays of fireworks, horse races and fairs were held for the amusement of the people as well as to encourage trade. The latest goods from England were on hand as well as furniture, candies, coaches, saddles and harnesses, jewelry, shoes, hosiery and wigs produced by the craftsmen of the town. The cultural role Williamsburg held in the colony was in part due to the presence of the College of William and Mary. Important men of America's historic past were students of this college. Bruton Church served as court church of Virginia, furthering the town's cultural role. ‘ The historical value of the town was recognized by Dr. W. A. R. Goodwin, late rector of Bruton Church, who interested the late John D. Rockefeller, Jr. in restoring Williamsburg. Employing a vast staff of experts, restoration began in 1926 and has continued up to the present time. CHAPTER III DESCRIPTION OF REPRESENTATIVE EIGHTEENTH-CENTURY COLONIAL DETAILS USED IN WILLIAMSBURG HOUSES The architecture of Williamsburg, Virginia, was based on the mode of building already established in eighteenth- century England. This architecture had been "adapted to the Nature of the Country" by the local builders and crafts- men. It became definitely Virginian.1 A brick house built in Williamsburg in the eighteenth century would not have looked out of place if the same building had been placed on English soil. This was not true of the frame house. In England the utilitarian structures, such as mills, barns, and cottages were frame; but the Virginians, contrary to the thinking of the Englanders, favored frame houses and believed highly sophisticated designs could be executed in timber.2 The working details used by builders of the early eighteenth century for composing their building designs were obtained frcm builders' handbooks published in London before 1700 and there were not any complete designs for buildings.3 1Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 10. 2Whiffen, The Eighteenth-Centupy Houses of Williams- burg , p. 85. 3Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 23. 19 20 Very few directions were included of the "orders of archi- tecture." These eighteenth-century colonists created an en- vironment comparable with that found in England. The exteriors and interiors of their houses proved the colonists' knowledge of the latest decorative practices of England. Furniture, fabrics, finishing materials, and many accessories were imported from the mother country. Also, many of the colonial artisans had been trained in England. Fireplace and mantel The plan of the eighteenth-century house was deter- mined by the placement of the fireplace. Varying from the early placement of the fireplace in a central location, fireplaces were located either outside the room wall or within the room,as shown in Figures 1 and 2, Plate I. The corner fireplace and fireplaces centered in walls on either side of a central hall are illustrated in Figures 3 and 4. Figure 5 shows an early central fireplace plan which was not used during the later period.5 Fireplaces were the only means of heat for the house. Corner fireplaces were the most popular in the colonies and Williamsburg. This resulted in the need for only one chimney, 41bid., p. 25. 5Interview with Paul Buchanan, Supervisor of Archi- tectural Research and Records and Colonial Projects Designer, Williamsburg, Virginia, September 3, 1964. VARIOUS FIREPLACE 7-. 7/////, Fig. Fig. Fig. Fig. 21 PLATE I ND ROOM ARRANGEMENTS Fireplace built outside the room wall Fireplace built Within the wall Corner fireplaces Fireplaces centered on walls on either side of a central hall Fig. 5. A central fireplace EZZZZE......hall or end passage - . . . . . .fireplace opening 22 since the fireplaces could be placed back-to-back in rooms beside one another.6 : At the beginning of the century the openings in the fireplace were large, but these openings decreased in size by the end of the century. By that time, wood had become scarce and better construction improved the efficiency of the fireplace.7 A variety of materials were used to frame the fire- place Openings. In early versions, a beam of heavy oak or a brick arch was over the opening of the fireplace. At the time of the Revolution the iron lintel was becoming more common. Much of the stone used for the mantels was imported from England for suitable materials were not found in this area of the colonies. A native "white stone," found nearby at Fredericksburg, Virginia, was often used as a substitute. Marbles and other stones were commonly used in the private houses. Wood was used for the mantel facings and the same treatment was further carried above the fireplace to provide an overbmantel of paneling. The woodwork was separated from the opening of the fireplace by a plastered brick frame which was of various widths. Brick or the "white stone" was used for a hearth. The hearth was usually flush with the flooring.8 6Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 27. 71bid. 81hid., p. 28. 23 Usually the space over the fireplace was decorated with paintings of a landscape or a portrait. Maps or map prints were also framed and placed over the fireplace.9 Wall Treatments The walls of the rooms in eighteenth-century houses ‘were usually plastered with a combination of oysterbshell lime, river sand, and animal hair.10 Today a builder secures the moldings after the plasterer has completed his work. In the Williamsburg houses the woodworking was finished by the carpenter and then the plasterer applied wall covering. The plaster was applied against the trim and reduced the relief or salience of the trim. Hence, there is a subtle transition between the two materials which is a definite characteristic of eighteenth-century interiors.11 Plaster was whitewashed and not painted.12 White- wash is a water paint that was and still is made by slaking quicklime in water. This lime-wash was often colored by the addition of various pigments: copperas to make the wash green, ocher for a yellow hue, and archil to obtain a deep blue shade. Milk and buttermilk were also occasionally added as vehicles in these washes of color.13 It was the 9Interview with Paul Buchanan, Sept. 3, 1964. 1°Kocher and Dearstyne, 0p. cit., p. 25. 11Whiffen,The Eighteenth-Gentupz Houses of Colonial Wil- - liamsburg,=p. 84. laInterview with..Paul Buchanan, Sept. 3, 1964. 13Kocher and Dearstyne, pp. cit., p. 31. 24 custom to whitewash once a year and some families did so more often for sanitary reasons.14 Wallpaper became a substitute for whitewashed walls during the second half of the eighteenth century. Wallpaper was introduced into the houses of Williamsburg in the mid- sixties. It was first imported into Virginia by George Washington for rooms in Mount Vernon in 1757. Sources indi- cate a wide variety of papers was available. This item was found in the Virginia Gazette in 1771: A NEAT and ELEGANT ASSORTMENT OF PAPER.HANGINGS, of various Kinds, and of the newest Fashions, for Staircases, Rooms, and Ceilings; namely, embossed, Stucco, Chintz, striped Mosaick, Damask and common.... In addition to these varied papers, Chinese designs were favored during one period.16 Wallpaper was used Sparingly. One reason for the Sparse use was the presence of arsenic in the paste used to secure the paper to the walls.17 People were hesitant to use this dangerous material. Another reason for the infrequent use of wallpaper was the condensation which was present because of the structure of the walls. In the frame houses, the plastering was put over the hand-split lathes nailed to the studs. In the brick houses the plaster 14Ibid., p. 25. lSWhiffen, The Eighteenth-Centupy Houses of Colonia Williamsbur , p. 84. 16Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 26. 17Buchanan, Sept. 3., 1964. 25 'was put directly on the brick walls. Hence, the Virginians 'were troubled with condensation. Only three rooms in the houses of Williamsburg yielded fragments of wallpaper.18 old 8 d Panel ‘The use of moldings and paneling in the interior room designs can be divided into six stages. These six stages, progressing from the simple to the elaborate and more costly are: plaster walls using a chair board and base- board; plaster walls using a cornice, chair rail and base- board; paneling above the fireplace; wainscotting around the room; the whole room paneled; and marble fireplace surround or mante1.19 Pictorial examples as presented in Plate II, III and IV, show the baseboards, chair rails and cornices in the styles used by the Williamsburg carpenters.20 1 Full-length wainscotting or paneling was used in a few of the houses but was customarily found in the public buildings. It was used as a protection from the condensa- tion on the walls.. The "dwarf" wainscot or dado was con- structed to the height of three to five feet from the floor. This type of treatment was more commonly used in both the private houses and public buildings. When this dado was used, paneling was sometimes applied to the area over the fireplace-- 18Whiffen The Eigpteepth~Centupy Houses of Colonial Williamsburg, p. 54. 39311011311311. Sept. 3., 19640 eoWhiffen, The Eighteenth-Centupy Houses of Colopia; Willim mburg, pp. 7 - 26 PLATE II FIVE BASEBOARDS FOUR INTERIOR C ORNICES 29 the mantel or over-mantel, to the ceiling. This area was then decorated with landscape or portrait paintings or map prints which had been framed. The most common wall treat- ment was the baseboard, cornice, and a heavy, waist-high protective chair rail.2l Whiffen points out an observation of the character of the eighteenth-century trim. The cornice prefiles show that the use of the re-entrant right angle and the vertical face was avoided. There was also a tendency to avoid a segment of the circle in both convex and concave moldings. The half-rounds were slightly flattened. Whiffen states: "This is certainly not due to any technical deficiency on the part of the eighteenth-century craftsman, but to his dislike of mechanical effects--and to an eye for detail which our century, in its haste, so rarely develops." 22 Doors Doors in the Williamsburg houses were usually no more than one and one-eighth inch thick. The design of these depended on the placement of the panels. The most common types of door paneling had six panels or four panels. The most used six-panel door was arranged, reading from top to bottom, in the following order: two small, two large and two large panels.23 The eight-panel door was arranged 21Kocher and Dearstyne, op. cit., p. 25. 22Whiffen,The Ei hteenth-CenturyiHouses of Cglonial Williamsburg, p. 8 . 231bid. .15 30 With two small panels at the top, two large, two small and finally two large panels at the bottom. Less frequently used panel arrangements were the eight-panel door arranged with two small panels at the t0p, two large, two large, and two small panels at the bottom. Two panel doors and four panel doors were popular but the two panel doors were used on cupboards.24 Summapy The plan of the eighteenth-century house was largely determined by the placement of the fireplace. The area around the fireplace was treated in a decorative way to make the fireplace wall one of the dominating features of the interior design. A variety of materials framed the fireplace openings-- marbles, a native "white stone," and wood. Sometimes wood was further carried above the fireplace to provide paneled over-mantels. The Space above the fireplace was usually decorated with paintings or a landscape or a portrait. Framed maps or map prints were also used. Six stages of wall treatments, progressing from the simple to the most costly were: plaster walls with a chair board and baseboard; plaster walls finished with a cornice, chair rail and baseboard; paneling above the fireplace; wainscotting around the room; paneling throughout the whole room; and marble fireplace surround or mantel. The plastered 2'4 Ibid. Q 31 area of the walls was usually whitewashed, but wallpaper was present in a few of the houses. The doors were of a paneled design. Four, six, and eight panels were found in a variety of arrangements. CHAPTER IV DESIGN DETAILS FOUND IN THE INTERIORS OF SELECTED HOUSES IN WILLIAMSBURG Fifteen living rooms of the houses of Williamsburg were selected for this study. The Specific houses were sug- gested as being representative by Paul Buchanan, Supervisor of Architectural Research and Records and Colonial Projects Designer. The selected group of houses was taken from those pictured and discussed in Whiffen's book, The Eighteenth- Century Houses of Williamsburg. Whiffen was architectural historian of Williamsburg from 1954 to 1959. With Buchanan's permission, photographs were used from the Progress and Re- search Photograph Albums in his office at Williamsburg to acquire the necessary data. These albums contained pictures taken during various phases of the restoration or preserva- tion of each building from its start to its completion. The selected rooms were chosen according to the existence of information relative to this study in the Progress and Research Photograph Albums and the inclusion of a fireplace wall. The rooms used as a basis for study were selected from the following houses located in Williamsburg: Nelson- Galt, John Blair, Orrell, wythe, Benjamin Waller, Palmer, Brush-Everard, Powell-Waller, Carter-Saunders, Taliaferro- 32 33 Cole, Peyton Randolph, Ludwell-Paradise, Tayloe, and Captain Orr's Dwelling. From literary sources an outline was developed for studying details of the interior design in the photographs. These details were categorized as; (1) the divisions of the walls and (2) the decorative treatment of the walls. Within the wall divisions there were different stylings of paneling, moldings and fireplace areas. Panelings were three and one- half feet high (dado or wainscot) or extended from floor to ceiling (wainscot). Moldings were used as cornices, chair rail, and baseboards. The fireplace areas, consisting of the moldings and the over-mantel, were treated in a variety of ways. Plaster, pictures, paneling, wallpaper and fabrics ‘were used for the over-mantels. Moldings were of wood, marble and stone. The decorative treatment of the walls and moldings included whitewash, paint, marbleized and natural finishes. This outline was to assist in a deter- mination of the characteristics of Colonial design as found in the interiors of houses built in Williamsburg during the eighteenth century. Looking at the interior design details of the selected group of rooms, five were finished with a wood cornice, chair rail and baseboard. One room had simply a WOOd base- board. The fireplace moldings of three of these rooms were of wood which was treated with paint. In one of these examples the wood was carried to six feet from the floor. Two of these fireplace moldings were of marble. One molding 34 surrounding the fireplace was of stone. The overbmantels of these six fireplace walls were plaster which was treated with whitewash. Five rooms had a three and one-half foot "dwarf" wainscot or dado of wood on the fireplace walls. 'The wood material was treated with paint. In each example the room was finished with a painted wood cornice and baseboard. In one room the baseboard was painted to imitate marble. The fireplace moldings of the five rooms were of wood. The material was preserved with paint. Three of these rooms had paneled over-mantels which were painted. Plate V shows 1 One over-mantel an example of a fireplace of this style. was plaster treated with whitewash. The fifth over-mantel contained a picture that covered the entire mantel area. Four living rooms had fully-paneled wood wainscotting on the fireplace walls. The wood material was treated with paint. In each example the room was finished with a painted wood cornice and baseboard. The fireplace moldings of two rooms were painted wood. Two fireplace moldings were of marble. Plates VI and VII Show examples of represenéative styles of the marble fireplaces.2 In the fifteen selected rooms there were no examples of wallpaper or fabric used on the overumantel. There were no examples of the wood materials treated in a natural color. ilProgress and Research Photograph Albums. Williams- burg, Virginia: Colonial Williamsburg, Inc. has PLATE V FIREPLACE WALL OF THE POWELL-WALLER.HOUSE, WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA 36 PLATE VI - 4!" i . l : V D. . I . v ,1 . * ‘~ w ' ‘ - . g c -‘ ‘ H' .I" . _‘ ;' ”0.7.0': ‘ ~40? ..ll . . .1 ‘A v .'I ‘. , .- . ‘ l .‘u’. .‘ ‘ r ‘ . u 0:, .‘. a , .1 ‘ . p. f , o l A 1" o . ‘ V .‘J. r.‘ .."-.' , j . 3 . . n . ‘z‘o' IL - ‘ i . -y I ~ ' v .' 8 a. g b ll.) 6.! he, u-u FIREPLACE WALL OF THE PEYTON-RANDOLPH HOUSE, WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA 37 PLATE VII ’ "' ‘WM"‘~-—‘ -~‘vvo?-_.--..v .... ~_.-. ... . .. .1..- M‘ ~-- . . I v-m.*“~“p‘_ : . We‘v-u. .. ; .’ - ~o~g--., ,___ . __~.. ..,, ”33".3‘4 ....-.-.' . .'o“t§'6'-‘3-¢#|§34 .' ~'- . ~ " 104.1...13‘333: . ... ”3.,. . FIREPLACE WALL OF THE PEYTON-RANDOLPH HOUSE, WILLIAMSBURG, VIRGINIA 38 The findings of the outlined details for studying the photographs were summarized in Table 1. Fifteen rooms ‘were finished with a baseboard and fourteen rooms with a cornice. Five rooms had chair rails, five rooms used a three and one-half foot dado and four rooms completely paneled the fireplace wall. Ten fireplaces had wood molding surrounding the opening, four rooms had marble fireplace moldings while one room used a stone molding. Seven rooms had paneled over-mantels and seven had plaster over-mantels. In every example the plaster was treated with whitewash. One overbmantel was decorated with a picture covering the entire area. There were no examples of fabric or wallpaper on the walls. In every example the wood materials were. preserved with paint. One baseboard was painted to imitate marble. There were no examples of wood treated in a natural color. The findings of this study are supported by literary sources. Whiffen3 and Kocher and Dearstyne4 confirm that paneling and moldings are used in varying amounts on the fireplace wall in the living rooms of Williamsburg. Rooms 'were finished with simply a baseboard or rooms were finished with a baseboard, chair rail and cornice. Other rooms had wall paneling with a dado and wainscotting extending from the baseboard molding to a point three to five feet up the 3Whiffen, The Eighteenth-Centupy_Houses of Williams- burg, p. 81. 4Kocher and Dearstyne, cp. cit., p. 25. 39 3 Table 1. Interior design details of the fireplace walls in living rooms of fifteen rooms of Colonial Williams- burg, Virginia Decorative Treatment of Walls and Moldings Interior Design Number of Details Rooms White- Paint Marble- Natural wash 126 N N N N Divisions of Walls Paneling Floor to ceiling 4 - 4 - - 3% feet high 5 - 5 - - Moldings Cornice 14 - 14 - ~ Chair rail 5 - 5 - - Baseboard 15 - l4 1 - Fireplace Area Over-mantel Plaster 7 7 - - - Paneled 7 - 7 - - Picture 1 - - - - Wallpaper - - - - - Fabric - - - - - Molding Wood 10 - 10 - - Marble 4 - - - - Stone 1 - - - - 40 wall and ending with the dado cap. Walls of some rooms were paneled with a wainscotting extending from the base- board molding to the cornice molding. The fifteen rooms used in this study can be divided into three groups; (1) rooms with combinations of a cornice, chair rail and baseboard, (2) rooms with dado, and (3) rooms with fully-paneled wainscotting. Furthermore, these groups progress from the simple to the more elaborate or decorative in wall treatment. The simple yet unique use of decorative moldings in the first group can definitely hold its place with the decorative rooms using a dado and the still more elaborate fully-paneled rooms. These harmonious results are attributed to the effective use of proportion, details, and symmetry. The interiors are based on geometric designs. The writers of Epliéamsburg Reproductions5 attribute lasting interest to the "Grace of proportion and rhythm of pattern, honest use of materials, subtle harmony of varied designs...."6 Kocher and Dearstyne7 validate the findings that varying treatments were found on the fireplace mantel or over-mantel. A plaster overbmantel was used. Paneling reaching from the fireplace molding to the cornice molding 'was also evidenced. Kocher and Dearstyne further confirm this finding when they state that in some cases when a dado is present, the area above the fireplace is emphasized by 5WilliamsburgReproductions. 6Ibid., p. 7. 7Kocher and Dearstyne, loc. cit. 41 paneling extending to the cornice molding.8 In one room a picture decorated the overbmantel and confirmed the informa- tion learned from Buchanan's interview. He stated that paintings were found above the fireplaces.9 When combinations of the baseboard, chair rail and cornice were used, the overbmantel consisted of plaster applied to the wall area. When the dado or "dwarf" wainscot was present, the overbmantels in three of the five examples ‘were found to be paneled. Rooms with fully-paneled walls had mantels that were paneled. It is apparent than that the treatment of the overhmantel was determined by the amount of paneling and moldings present in the room. Of the fifteen rooms of the houses of Williamsburg there were no examples of walls using wallpaper or fabric. This finding is confirmed by Buchanan, who stated: Wallpaper was used Sparingly. One reason for the sparce use of it was that people were hesi- tant to use wallpaper in their'homes for arsenic was present if the paste used to secure the paper to the walls. 0 Whiffen also states: In frame houses the plastering was done over'hand- split laths nailed to studs. In brick houses the plaster was laid directly on the brick walls. This helps to account for the condensation by which, Jefferson tells us, Virginians were so much troubled; it also accounts, in no small 8Ibid., p. 28. 9Buohanan, Sept. 3, 1964. 101bid. T. I . a. u I. A r a... 7 a . . a . L t 7 . a t. A... .0 I . . u . .. V .. Q t l I . . a a u I ~ . A... . . t . x I t . O I O . A. . , .o . J , o. n z . .l n . . I o I? .7 a u v o . 7 . . . I Q . w . fl . C .. . a I c. a CI p . . b _ . .o . 7.. . . . . . a . mu 7. a :5. . 7 . .... _ l .. . . . 7 '. J l l . ~ 9 . l. t n n O. s a . . 7 . . I . . no a I , IwO‘ - I ~ . . . . O _ v .L. v . . . . n J J A . . w . 7 . a — ~ . LI O s . I . .. . .a s . II . , a u . . n, .4 7 v‘ u 7» a v. (I r. l o u . .. . .. ‘1» A ~ . . . w . | It . l . . . r. 7 . J V. l I u. l . . C .. c 3 .. . . r . . . x. I. . .\A .7. . 3‘ Yul. p lrlw Li 0 y i .. I. ( ‘4 (q 7 . _ , o 'c. .. . . . . . . 1 . . a . i I A . . . a . . 1 . [4 ‘n. . .A .. . a o 0" .- ..,..~ n . I“ . . .. . . .. . - u 7. 7. e (a I. . A I r .7 . a . . a . . . . I . y A O ‘ A 7' . . . 7 . .v. Q . . l w} .. .u 1 {\- n . v . . s ‘ ' x . .. 7 .7 v. > J. a s I. IS. . .l. . 4 .a . . . 1 2‘ o ‘b . K 7 'I I u. .1. O7 . A u o 42 Eziiure, for the complete disappiprance of y wallpaper in brick houses. Whiffen accounts that only three fragments of wallpaper have been found in Williamsburg houses, although a wide variety was available. Kocher and Dearstyne have reported only one house evidencing the presence of fabric hangings. Literary sources confirm the findings that fire- place moldings were composed of three materials: marble, stone and wood. {ocher and Dearstyne support the additional finding that marble moldings were found in the houseslz and not used only in the most pretentious buildings like the Governors' Palace. Rooms designed with simply a baseboard, chair rail and cornice used marble moldings as well as fully- paneled rooms. In each of the selected fifteen rooms where wood was used it was preserved with paint. Kocher and Dearstyne confirm this finding with the words: "Interior woodwork was occasionally left in a natural state, but more often it was painted."13 In every instance the plaster was whitewashed. This use of whitewash is validated from the literary sources and Buchanan's interview. llWhiffen, The E t ggh eenth-Centugy Houses of Colonial Williamsbur , p. 81. 12Kocher and Dearstyne, loo. cit. 13Ibid. 43 Summapy Photographs of fifteen rooms of houses of Williams- burg were used to study and determine the characteristics of Colonial design. The findings of this study cormeSpond with descriptions of decorative interior details as presented by literary sources. An examination of representative rooms of Williamsburg houses confirms the particular styling of the interior design details known as Colonial. Paneling and moldings were used in varying amounts on the fireplace wall. The rooms of the Williamsburg houses can be divided into three groups, progressing from the simple to the more elabo- rate; (1) rooms with combinations of a cornice, chair rail and baseboard, (2) rooms with a dado, and (3) rooms with fully-paneled wainscotting. The treatment of the over~ mantel on the fireplace wall was determined by the amount of paneling and moldings used. There were no examples of walls finished with wallpaper or fabric. Fireplace moldings were composed of three materials; marble, stone and wood. Marble fireplace moldings were used in the less elaborate room interiors and in houses having fully-paneled walls. Wood was painted and plaster was treated with whitewash. ‘t CHAPTER.V SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Summapy Photographs of fifteen living rooms of houses of Williamsburg were selected for study and determination of characteristics of Colonial design. Permission to useethese photographs from the Progress and Research Photograph Albums of Colonial Williamsburg was given by Mr. Paul Buchanan, Supervisor of Architectural Research and Records and Colonial Projects Designer, Williamsburg, Virginia. An outline com- piling the details of eighteenth-century interior design was developed for studying the photographs. The interior design details which were utilized in the decoration and finishing of living rooms in houses of Colonial Williamsburg were presented and summarized. All of the selected rooms had baseboards and the walls of fourb tsen of the fifteen rooms were terminated with cornices. Five rooms were finished with a chair rail, five rooms had -a three and one-half foot dado and four fireplace walls were completely paneled. Ten fireplaces had wood molding surround- ing the opening, four rooms had marble fireplace moldings while one room used a stone molding. Seven rooms had paneled overbmantels and seven had plaster overbmantels. In every 44 45 example the plaster was treated with whitewash. One over- mantel was decorated with a picture covering the entire area. There were no examples of fabric or wallpaper on the walls. In every example the wood materials were preserved with paint. One baseboard was painted to imitate marble, and there were no examples of wood treated in a natural color. Conclusions An examination of selected rooms in the houses of Williamsburg, Virginia, built during the eighteenth century has led to these conclusions concerning the characteristics of Colonial design: 1. Paneling and moldings were used in varying amounts on the fireplace walls of Colonial houses. 2. The fireplace walls of living rooms of Colonial houses can be divided into three groups from the simple to the more elaborate and decorative in wall treatments-rooms with combinations of a cornice, chair rail, and baseboard; rooms with a dado; and rooms with fully-paneled wainscotting. 3. Treatment of the overbmantel was determined by the amount of paneling and moldings on the fire- place wall. The overbmantel was finished with: a) plaster when combinations of the base- board, chair rail and cornice were applied to the wall area; 5. 7. 8. 9. 10. 46 b) plaster or paneling when the wall was finished with a dado; c) paneling.when the wall was fully-paneled. Framed pictures were used to decorate the mantel. Eighteenth-century wall finishes in Williamsburg houses were plaster or paneling, contrary to popular belief that wallpaper and fabric fre- quently decorated the wall. Fireplace moldings were composed of three materi- als: marble, stone and wood. Marble fireplace moldings were used in private houses as well as the public buildings. Marble fireplace moldings were used on walls designed less elaborately as well as the more decorative fireplace walls. Wood used in Colonial houses was preserved with paint and sometimes painted to imitate marble. Plaster walls were treated with whitewash. Recommendations Investigation for this study revealed little informa- tion depicting the details of interior architectural design of eighteenth-century houses has been compiled. Photographs and reliable descriptions were not readily available. It is recommended that composites of pictorial examples and descriptions would be of value and use. Composites could include details of the Colonial period: the design and 47 styling of fireplaces, the arrangement of bed-chambers, window treatments, eighteenth-century furniture and furb nishings, characteristic colors of paint, wallpaper and fabric, costumes, and life in the eighteenth-century. Private houses, plantations and pubTuzbuildings could be researched for information important to a knowledge and understanding of the traditions of the past. The seminar devoted to the Colonial period and the restoration of Wil- liamsburg which is presented by the College of William: and Mary each summer would offer a basis for further study. Researching details of interior design of other architectural and historic periods is further suggested. The interior and exterior architectural designs of America would also be of value. Such studies would be a means not only of providing information concerning the design characteristics of the past, but also a means of preserving the nation’s architectural heritage. BIBLIOGRAPHY BIBLIOGRAPHY Books Charley, Kenneth. Williamsbu in Virginia. Williamsburg, Virginia: CoIonIaI WIIIIamsEurg, Inc., 1953. Gowans, Alan. Ima es of American Livin . Philadelphia, New York: J. B. LIppIncoII Company, 1964. Hamlin, Talbot. Architecture Through the Ages. New York: G. P. Puthan 8 one, 9 . Isham, Norman Morrison. A G case of Colonial Architectural Terms. The Walpo e cc 6 y, . illiamsburv: Its Kocher, A. Lawrence, and Dearstyne, Howard. W Buildin s and Gardens. New York: HoII, RIneEaEE and - WInston, Inc., I§6I. Watterson, Joseph. Architecture. New York: W. W. Norton and Company, Inc., I950. Whiffen, Marcus. The Eishteenth-Centu Houses of Williams- burg. New York: HoII, RIneEaEI, ana WInston, Inc., Whiffen, Marcus. The Public Buildin s of Williamsbur . New York: HolI, RIneEaPE, and WInsEon, Inc., I558. Articles and Periodicals "Brush-Everard House," Ladies Home Journal, LXIX (October, 1952)) 46'70 "The Historical Background," The Architectural Record, LXXVIII . (December, 1935), 360-5. "Nicolson House," Ladies Home qurnal, LXXII (February, 1955), - 50-10 7 Perry William Graves. "Notes on Architecture," The Archi- ’ tectural Record, .LXXVIII (December, 1935). 5333817 49 206 040425 S’ 5O Reeve, Ethel A. "Inside A Virginian Colonial House in Old Williamsburg," House and Gardens, LXIV (November, 1933)! 29-90 "Williamsburg, What It Means to Architecture, to'Gardening, to Decoration," House and Gardens, LXXII (November, Unpublished Material Cannon, Margaret. "Southwest Georgia Houses of Greek Revival Influence and Their Furniture 1820-1890." Unpublished Master's thesis, Florida State Univers ty, 1963. Sisson, Marian B. ~' and ,7m, sh 7 State; -”” haster's thes . ior Design . United Jolished :chnology, 1964. ./‘.\ , Drexel Institute 0 Williamsburg Re roductions. Williamsburg, Virginia: Williams- burg RestoratIon Incorporated, 1965. Other Sources . Personal interview with Paul Buchanan, Supervisor of Architectural Research and Records and Colonial Prggects Designer, Williamsburg, Virginia. September 3, l9 . Progress and Research Photograph Albums. Williamsburg, Vir- ginia: Colonial Williamsburg, Inc. MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF HOME ECONOMICS EAST LANSING, MICHIGAN 3 1293 02242 0180