--:.l.0)xh1\u 4151 11A!" 1 141114 11. . .llqll ll: ‘1111i31 1 r V Y..-%ov.: .(I...m. - it- .. ‘ . ,- w _ . .. $23. . . 123?, . . . _ .Q Q '.~ . ud. l‘ - .. Aw I‘ ,K . . . u. .. . ' ¢ ‘V O ‘ I ‘ I +u k ”r 9. .04V '..L..M. x . P l ‘( ‘. 1:": EJ'LTT‘FEI’TTETFI. STUDY OF THE: EE‘F'TECTS OF" STEAGE SJEDING 0’! T' ’3 WIiV°¥Ifl5I"“-.L 0(Ym7‘5 3:77;??? 07“ .s" S'T’ERILE IT-IDUSTRIAL 117M GMT? "1 iAJA. 1.21. A THESIS S'E3 TafII‘T 7.3 TO THE FA SULTY 0}“ an n ramp-Mr “QT? :fiq .1I\IA—T\‘ ‘Ji .154 \J£)L FD“\~J.¢4 of AGE-lICULTUfiTS MD $~-.}"‘I..I‘T.3 ""133." by Kenneth W. Cos 13 CAZ'IDI ELITE FUR T1" DYE-Gt E OF .-. 3 7-“? an vannw L“‘1,5LJWJ'\)WO any L5 Akin. JU‘IET‘Z, 1938 THESIS mrnrv'fl. *‘* “WW; "1" pO‘J...‘ \-"'~a.~.|-v:)v;:,5 I‘TL The writer wished to express his appreciation to Mr. E. F. Eldridge and Dr. W. L. Valimsnn whose thoughtful assistance and helfiful guidance made this thesis possible. 1168-15 INTRO DUCT ION The importance of the biochemical oxygen demand (B. O. D.) test cannot be questioned in its application to sewaze treatment plant Operation, water treatment plant operation, stream surveys and the treatment of industrial wastes. The test is used to determine the efficiency of a waste treatment plant or of a unit of such a plant, to determine the extent of pollution of a stream and to compare the strengths of different domestic and industrial wastes. This thesis is chiefly concerned with the application of the test to industrial waste analyses. In the design of sewage treatment plants the engineers are often confronted with the problem of determining the population equivalent of some contributing industrial waste. This is usually done by determining the H. O. D. of the waste and calculating the population equivalent in terms of domestic sewage having the same B. O. D. requirements. Large contributions from industries have an important bearing on the capacities of sewage treatment plants and it is important that the 3. O. D. determination of any industrial waste be accurate. The biochemical oxygen demand determination is a measure of the oxygen required to oxidize the ornanic matter of a certain sample (1). The oxidation is brought about by bacteria in a samnle which is held at some predetermined temperature for the required incubation period; frequently for five days. Eizht ounce glass stoppered bottles are -2- used for incubating the sample which is prepared by making a proper dilution of the waste being used. Several dilutions are usually required so that after the incubation period a few parts per million of oxygen will be left in the bottles. Sterile industrial wastes must be inoculated with the proper organisms. To do this, various amounts of sewage are added as seeding to the bottles and then incubated for the desired period at some constant temperature. Bottles containing the various amounts of seeding and diluting water with no waste are also incubated to eliminate the 3. O. D. of the seeding material that has been added. Similar sets of incubation bottles are set up for each day that the B. O. D. is to he determined. After the incubation has proceeded the proper number of days, one set of bottles is removed from the incubator and the dissolved oxygen contents of the ineuhations are determined by chemical methods. The difference between the oxygen content of the diluting water and the dilution is a measure of the B. O. D. of the waste. however, the test as it is now made, has not proven entirely satisfactory for the determination of the 8. O. D. of industrial wastes. vany discrepencies are apparent due to several factors among which the most important is the seeding given to the dilution prior to incubation. HICTCRICiL The biochemical oxygen demand determination is by no means a new test for it was used as early as 1370 by a British Rivers Pollution Commission. In Germany it was used as early as 1900 and in France as early as 1335. The test in its present modified form has been used in the United States since about 1715.(2) From experiments conducted by Theriault and confirmed by others, it has been found that the deoxygenation of an organic waste proceeds in two distinct stages-~first the carbonaceous staze where the carbonaceous matter is oxidized and then the second or nitrification stage where the nitrOgenous matter is oxidized. The general course of the deoxygenation curve is shown in the accomnanying graph which is taken from Theriault. The curves are plotted from data of the same sample incubated at different temperatures for varying lengths of time. Phelps proposed a formula many years ago which fits with reasonable accuracy the eXperinental results of deoxygenation. The formula is based on the assumption that the rate of deoxygenation at any instant is directly proportional to the amount of organic matter present in the sample and is applicable only to the first stage of deoxygenation. Without going into the derivation of Phelps formula which can be found elsewhere(3) it may be stated as follows: m1.) VAN \<\ \Q Kg QQRWMNQ ON 0% mw\ \\ ,0\ .0\ xi m,\ MQ \\ U\ Q mu \ O .0 Nu m; N. .\ Q 0 a 1 — a. P _ _ , A, / llll l¢lll+lll lll l :1 l 4 _ l 9 ll ll Il ll 0 , M . _ M a M _ P . l _ H 6 9 _ E _ _ _ d l I - - Y. Jog, xxx x, l. .1llll+ll_ fl + 4h . ll L_ll-l -l f L .2 V , _ _ o W , a _ _ i fi 1 _ , l l m: 9 H I , a d . k W _ j _ _ A a lllllllwll Ll! 7 a W _ k n 0 7 H 4 “ W . e m m w n L , g l ll4 4ll.l+ll . . 7 h k w 0 / 7? _ . O . m N -_ : -. , Ill illll 9 _ fl % 0 l y , M g HN§NW§\mu\.-h_\>\.mwmv\AXCL\Q EEK KG NWAUQVQL valeNP‘l‘wmx 0 9A .X/O 3’ 03/4/09/V03 /\/ Xt = L — Lt a L(l - lo-Klt) Where Lt equals the B. O. D. in p.p.m. remaining after time t. Where L equals the B. O. D. in p.p.m. exerted by the organic matter during first stage. L - Lt 3 Xt oxygen in p.p.m. used up in t days, as determined by the B. O. D. test. K1 8 deoxygenation constant. The deoxygenation constant for any temoerature has been found to vary with the 20° temperature constant as the following formula; Klan) ‘ Kuzmll-W‘T " 20’] Where K1(20) . 0.100 The temperature also affects the magnitude of the first stage B. O. D., and the first stage demand at any temperature T bears the following relation to the 20° demand: LI. :- L 20 [1+ 0.02m - 20)] These formulas can be used to change any oxygen value for one temperature and a given period of incubation into terms of the oxygen value under an entirely different set of conditions. They are applicable to recently polluted samples. There are a number of factors which affect the 3. O. D. determination: the pH of the medium, the amount and kind of bacteria present and the mineral content of the sample .and/or diluting water. In general the advantage of the test over a strictly chemical test like the potassium permanganate oxygen consumed test is that it is very similar to the natural stream -6- conditions or conditions in the diluting body of water. The disadvantages of the test are that there are often toxic substances which inhibit bacterial growth especially in some industrial wastes, long periods of incubations at constant temperatures which require a high degree of mechu anical control and rather close attentionl5) and also there may be, particularly in industrial wastes, certain chemical constituents which will interfere with the dissolved oxygen determination hy the Winkler method. Theriault(6)(7) and Theriault and Kchaneelal have success- fully modified the Winkler method to give correct values for dissolved oxygen when interference is encountered due to iron salts, nitrites, organic matter, hypochlorites and sulphite wastes.‘ Eldridge and hallmannlhl have found that a synthetic diluting water with a mineral content very similar to the mineral content of river waters will give higher 3. O. D. values than distilled, bicarbonate, carbon. ate or phosphate waters. They also found that the pH of their dilutions dropped slightly during the oxidation period in dilutions made with tap water and distilled water, but in dilutions with other waters there was practically no change. Their results show that the initial pH has some effect on the B. O. D. results, but that it is not necessar- ily a limiting factor. Eldridge(9) has found that in making dilutions of sterile material and seeding with sewage that the B. O. D. varies almost directly with the amount of seeding up to about seven days incubation. Holderby and Lea(10) have found that the B. 0. D. is substantially affected by the ratio of organic car on to total nitrogen. With ratios of cnr\on to nitrogen as large as 120 to l the rate of oxidation is ver slow, but if the ratio be reduced to 5.7 to l the five day oxygen demand values would he at a maximum. Tuch uncertainity surrounds the test esvecially when seeding material must be added as pointed out by fildridgelll) who shows that the five day 3. O. D. of a paper mill white water increases in hither dilutions and increases with an increasing amount of seeding. These same results have been found to apnly to a sterile milk waste as is shown in the accompanying eXperinental and data portions of this report. This study was made to determine, if possible, the correct amount of sewage seeding to be added to a sterile industrial waste sample to get the proper B. 0. D. of the waste. The experiment was divided into three trials, each of which extended over a twenty-day incubation period using an incubation temperature of 20°1=1° Centigrade. milk waste was selected because it eliminated many factors which affect the B. O. D. determination. This waste is homogeneous, has an optimum ph value, is easily obtainable and easily made sterily. A factory waste of milk -8- diluted with distilled water and containing 0.5 per cent whole milk was made up and sutoclsved for'sach trial. In trial No. l, 1.0 per cent and 0.5 per cent dilutions were made of this factory waste and in trials No. 2 and No. 3 0.75 per cent and 0.5 per cent dilutions were used. Eight ounce glass stoppered‘bottlss were calibrated and used for the incubation of the samples. Bottles were selected which did not vary more than five cubic centimeters from 250 cubic centimeters capacity. The samples were incubated in a water bath at 20°C. for periods of 2, 5, 10, 15 and 20 days. At the and of these periods the N dissolved oxygen content was determined by the Winklcr method. The sodium bicarbonate diluting wateril) used was prepared by adding six grams of sodium‘bicarbonsts to five gallons of distilled water and bubbling air through the contents until the dissolved oxygen content is above 7.0 p.p.m. It has been pointed out‘by Eldridge and Hallmsnnc‘) that this diluting water does not give as high 8. 0. D. values as other waters.‘but it has been temporarily accepted as a standard in sewage treatment plants and gives results comparable to practice in this part of the country. The effluent of the East Lansing Imhoff tanks was filtered and used as s seeding material. The following dilutions and seedings were made for the 2, 5, 10, 15 and 20 day B. O. D. determinations. TRIIK I“? o 1 1"Diluting - 1.0 per cent _ 0.5 per cent - each with no need. Water waste waste 2- n a» u o l «- it a 1000 “ 3- a - n - n - n n. 360. n 4- fl ‘ fl - fl .. N N 530. It TRIALS fiO. 2 AN? N0. 3 I‘Diluting-O.75 per cent -005 per cent - each with no seed. Water waste waste 2- n - n d. n - a N 100. n 3- n ‘. fl - fl - n " 300. a 4‘ n . it - n - u N 500. I Bacterial counts were made of the sewage seeding material and of the dilutions Just before the chemicals were added to make the dissolved oxygen test. These give the number of organisms added to each B. O. D. bottle and the bacterial population of the samples after the incubation periods of 2, 5, 10, 15 and 20 days. These bacterial counts are plotted against the days incubation for trial No. 2 on graphs no. 9 and to. 10. Graph No. 11 compares the bacterial count and the B. O. D. of the same sample. Graph No. 12 gives the daily B. O. D. values plotted against the days incubation. Graph 30. 5 shows the average effects of sewage seeding on the B. O. D. of a 0.5 per cent milk waste using various periods of incubation and is a composite of graphs No. 6, no. 7 and we. 8 which in turn are the reswective graphs of trials fio,~1, no. 2 and No. 3. AVA—e 65 255M725 ; NC" / 70 41. 3.0.0. or 0.5 FEB CENT 900 44/“ WA 572: . i I ~ ¥ ! I 5 800 BOD‘DDM i .. 600 ._.J i 4 /’ _>Ig-::_:’ —— I ’ ’ . ,f”= ! I d l / 1 | . I f f J ’ L f i / ‘ i ‘ : 409’ i i ‘ L I ' i f ‘ I J ! ‘ I i : ' / 1 ? é ' ' i 300 g l / I F i i 200 L 1 LEG *‘ND . —— Z— 04 Y ! ------ 5- 04 Y — — IO-DAY 00 —--— l5-04Y a — ear-0;? ‘r’ 0 i / 9 3 4 CC, SEWAGE SEED/N6 BOD-Dl—DM V . 9/41. N0. , 1 No.2 72pm; 30 OF 0.5 FEB CEN‘JY' 900 1 ML K WASTLZ‘: i i i j . I w 500 {k I ; T , i 44 CC. SEW/AGE 5 EEO/N6 600 \ I’d: i \\ ’ ~ + ‘ ‘ ‘ ’ ' I ' ‘ ‘ “'~ I 1 ‘V I, . w I i ' / 4 1 400 I i 1 a i i z i i 300 A\\ | [I k X 1 200 + i LEGAZT/VD ; 3-04 Y- ! ------ 5-way y — — /0-DAY / ; — -- — /J‘-DAY ¢ / a l o l / O 3 4 5 BOD-PPM 72197741.. 8.04 759/244 NOE? Q 0/“ 05 F759 C E 7' +IVO.3 T CC. SEWAGE S EEO/N6 900 MA’LK WASTE 800 h—.+ _ / —W '0- ', cup-u 9/ ,‘vA/ \ ”/ ' w 7 ...-——+ i ' / 4 § 1 J a 600 y i ; j , ’ d/ 5630 Ir: 7‘ ’ ’ ’ / 1X” / ’I" I \ ‘ , . . ’ l ’ i I r 300 I i I *r ____.:'h , I I I, W ' 200 ; LE VHS/v0 I e Z—Déh/ ' [I ! ----- 50A Y I —— IO-D4Y —'"— l5-04Y // —f_ g— 0 / 7 3 4 5 8 OD - PPM. 900 tTAL 80.49. 0F a5 T‘e/Az. Na 3 i MVL K WASTE . ! r \ -\ 4/ ‘ y ’i \L i L »—~‘ "i——'—-1’/ I a” / / Y . 4'" ’37 u ’2' "' i ! f ' i 9 ! i 400 if i I ! 300 in; i . 00 L i 00 i -+— galley D 1 t 0 l / 13/ 3 4 5 CC SEW/AGE SEED/N6 .0; YQ .. ngwwq 20R QmVDQS N. h.\ hv\ .UUnn llllll .UU Will .UU\ QINNW. Q\< lllxlll QQMWMV IV 00 00b C7 027 'w'ord _. 00.0 \ \ \\ ‘ 0 OK 00% a “3 Emu; 3 >\ RQ®§U\<\ .IKO MI WRMUVVS V\ l\\\\_\ K>\..UU h .D\< M} Q\Q.Nn\ WNMQFQVS W “0‘ h 6 .uxg 8% Q >\Q W>\\QINNMI WW \SMMJ KG KUIUKKW MIR \<\.m;\v ka mi WQ : QQWMQ >5 K QmSQS h..\ \ hv .0>\ mt. Us. >\Q\.h Vmbb>§ K0 WA hes; V\..N\V< k>\.mu.u m ‘ k>\0 Q>\\QM~M.W M WNQ .WU K0 .QG.Q .V «S; Mum) K0 kUMhPKN {>05 vR 0k MIR .ou lllllll ovum ll .4\ \ \s .00 \ , \ QMMW 0 ill \ \\ QENWU d \ \\~\ 00% s x \ x\ \ \\ 00m, \ \ \\ \.// X H\\ 00”? u x \ \ \ x/ \ i 4/ . *\ \\\§ 00.0 \[I / \\ ‘ \ /.Afl/||| \I‘ +\ 000 \ ’ 1: \\\ I A u u u... OON |I\l< Gems 3.0% ugmk» l VQQMQ Wmevx to see 0 0'9 >\Q \nk Uxmwbrv>§ TIN .8.“ IIIIII mi v6 .. QQWNQ h.\ .. fiv\ Al“ A4 .Uumz I I .u0\ Gum,“ g u szmv.“ 4 .N .0\ < flvxxmk R YQQQS K0 hoesxmflnx hooxmwvx 2R5 M 9%: X Sxx kins WUQ hGKO .QGmV wk 0k k .0>\ “Xx >\Q .W>\\Q.wmm/ Mum kWh: 1&0 RUNKK MFR [I] 80, C7 09 ,0; l0 : QQWQQ >\0 R Qm30\<\ C7 087 'w'do’ .. N . n\ O\ . n N WWII}: \ .00“ I ll: . \ .UU\ \ wam; 0\< l.l . \ QEMWMJ « \ \ 8.» 00m, 00 00% I I 00.0 I..V\L\ 00 . 00 m, .02 .VSmK \< R Vmwobkx k0 WQQQMQ 000\W§ 0 as 80 M ix: KS3 Emow‘thO K0 0.0% q k0k mv .0\< M \<0 QSQMUW Missal k0 kbwkkmw Nth 0; WQ- QQWMQ \<0R V‘m30>\\ m. - \ \ h. m. all“ \\ [fl 1 . V \ k I II I \ u.« l “Ill." '1’ I l N. . hl’r I n! Q 0\ [l l 4” 1 \\ \ c/II 1/ ‘\ 11/ we \ ,/ , y u. m m I / / I- I, / H 0 A»; / I .. J - / r . n y / / ~ 7 Ir / / w 0.0\ m 4/» K M s . aw / » .V1 uuuuuuu i .. V 1V4 \\ Ir N f | \ ‘ / / I i\\! / 3 / \ | \ It / W \ / / H l // xv C. N U>\ V.\ .R All/ 000 .00\ R . 00 2 2 t I all \\ ouuw s. \s n. III a \s . ”UK \s t s» IIIIIII . §\M \Vflxmw [ix ,rl Q0xmw. \<0\bv.mv\00>\\ Mka W .KKOQ 0. 8980 Q .O>\ >\\ In “MIN .UU “Q \kaU 0 k 5% \ 0) «\Q- 09qu >\0R Vmw00>§ fi\ \ ”We 3‘ Q S‘Ivswv V980 .10 ON Q \QUQ \< Oxk V‘QQU? What? ”MN.“ kom . .Q\ .Q\< >0 k 20:0qu 400 Q SQMK 0% .0 mm m! QQ- QQWQQ \<0R Vme>§ svvswv 17.9570 .10 ON \ Ox h. N. 8 ‘5‘ x - «telnet 3% .c 0% ....... x. \ szwl. 4 x 00 \ ‘ s I, . \ ‘5 N / \‘ ~ / \ ~ I \ x / \ ~ // || ‘ V n /p - \\\\\ H OWDQ\ / \\ ! N /s \ s u\./ in! ~ \ / - XIII nIIIIIIIIlI-III‘ N s\ I ~ \‘ l s \ / \ » / ~ \‘II / 1 000 0Q | x d. / x / ~ / NE meW# .. 0w§$k0 .004 t $3 QMQMMW New : _ V\ fl\\_\ RENO QMQ MG vx K0 .QGQ Nth this .UU 000.003 .\\ .0>\ QWQ - \QMKUVQ K0 QM $5? MO >\th\m~\ xxx—\OIU WV» VQI Qfiiwwq >\O\kv\mu\wrw\<\ 5de - '0'087 .UUh IIIIIII .UUMJ llllll .UU\ K QNWW Q>\ QEUWHNIV Q; N.\ .O\< .Q .Q .m >1V\¢\Q - -10.. DISCUSEIOE It is clearly shown by graph 30. l, which is a composite of graphs So. 2, K0. 3 and he. 4, that for the 2, 5 and 10 day incubation ncriods there is a marked increase in the B. O. D. of the waste with an increase in the amount of seed- ing materials. The curves for the 15 and 20 day incdbationl have shown a tendency to flatten out and even to decline with the amount of seeding. Such decline cannot be explained by the writer. Graph no. 5. being a composite of graphs No. 6, No. 7 and he. 8, shows again that the B. O. D. of a 0.5 per cent milk waste varies directly as the amount of needing nearly up to the tenth day of incubation. From this point on, the curves tend to come closer together and some even cross each other. The fact that the curve for the five cc. of seeding declines between the tenth and fifteenth days of incubation cannot be eXplained. It is apparent that the five day B. O. D. results are not dependable because of the wide variations in values from 345 to 635 P.P.m. for the can. waste with amounts of sewage seeding varying from nothing to 5 cc. Graph no. 9 shows the number of bacteria per cc. present in the B. 0. D.'bott1es after the incubation period for the 'bottles which contained only diluting water and seeding material. The curves representing the growth in the bottles with.no seed and with 1 cc. of seed show the typical lag in.the growth to maximum number of organisms, while the other curves show a rapid increase in the first two days and a gradual decline over the remainder of the period. The lag in the development of growth in the samples with no seed and a small amount of seed is present but not so pronounced in the dilutions of the 0.5 per cent milk waste as shown by graph ho. lO. Graph 30. ll compares the number of bacteria with the B. O. D. of a sample containing 1 cc. of sewage seeding, over the twenty-day incubation period. It shows how the number of organisms present in a B. O. D.‘bottle increases rapidly to a maximum in the first one or two days, then as the relative amount of food per organism decreases the bacterial pepula- tion must and does decrease steadily over he remainder of the incubation period. As the num er of organisms decrease because of a decrease of food or oxidizable organic matter the daily B. O. D. values decrease. In other works the increment of increase in B. O. D. values decreases during the incubation period. This fact is clearly shown by graph Ho. 12 which gives the increment of increase of B. O. D. values for each day, over the value for the preceeding period of incubation. CIT? CLUSIOTIS 1. With this waste selected it was found that the B. O. D. increased in direct proportion to the aspunt of sewage seeding. 2. The bacterial population of the B. 0. D. samples was found to increase rapidly in the first one or two days to a maximum then gradually drop as the incubation period proceeded. 3. From the results obtained no definite amount of seefling can be said to be the Draper amount to give the exact value of the B. O. D. of this waste. 4. It is quite certain that by using the 5 day B. O. D. values we are liable to a wide variation in results as clearly shown by granh 30. 5. 5. It was fauna that the daily B. O. 9. curves follow the same general trend as do the curves fer the number of organisms uresent in the B. 0. D. bottles as Shawn‘by centering greens fie. 10 anl Ho 12. 1 TARULATED DATA Trial Ho. 1. Seeding materiel count - 33g000 bacteria per ce- O.5 per cent milk waste Days B. 0.. De *' 13.13.12). ineu- no lee. See. See. bation eeed seed seed seed 2 44 323 230 368 5 420 552 533 520 10 722 608 636 704 15 723 812 556 412 20 734 604 732 560 Trial U0. 2 Seeding material count - 110,000 bacteria per cc. 0.5 per cent milk west- Days B. 0'. Do'popomo incuc fie 100. 300. Sec. betion seed seed seed seed 2 36 253 272 300 5 132 055 540 752 10 416 516 392 356 15 696 716 726 603 20 6&3 732 734 33 Days Ho. of Bacteria per 00. incu- E0 100. 300. 500. bation seed seed seed seed 2 84,000 550,000 900,000 590, 00 5 30,000 40,000 53,000 45,000 10 150,000 0:,000 51,300 40,000 0 15 6,900 ,600 1,600 3, 00 23 1,500 2,000 1,000 3,000 Trial ”0 o 3 Seeding Fatericl Count - 93,000 bacteria per cc. 0.5 per cent milk waste 3378 B. O. D. "" IND.“- incu- No 103. 300. Sec. bstion seed seed seed seed 2 200 312 296 33b 5 433 512 533 604 10 534 615 623 720 15 743 0&0 564 543 20 724 576 734 560 -13- 33 I LIGC-TL' THY 1. Theroux, Eldridge and fellnnnw. nnelysis of Water an; Sewage". 2. Theriault, E. J. "The Rate of Deoxyfienation of Iolluted Yeters" from Tublic Keelth Report, Vol. 41, No.6 Feb. 5, 1226. 3. Tetcnlf and Eddy. "Sewn e and Sewage Disposal" 7?. 375 - 373. A. Eldridge, E. F. and “allmann, W. L. "Influence of Dilutiog Vater on the Biochemical fixygen :enend". 5. Ruchhoft, C. C. "The B. 0. D. test and Oxidation in Serafie Treatnent". U. 0. Public Henlth Service. 6. Theriault, :. J. "Detailei Instructions for the ferfornnnce of the Discolvcl Oxygen end Biochemical Oxygen Delana Torts" 3upolemant Ho. 90 to 2ublic fienlth Reports of 1731. 7. Theriault, E. J. "The Determination of Dissolved Oxygen by the Winkler fiethod. Fublic eolth Bull. fie. 151. 3. Theriault, E. J. and icVemee, P. D. "Dissolved Oxygen in Freoence of Qrganic 7etter, Hypochlorites and Sulphitee." Industrial and Eng. Chem. Anal. Ed. 4, 57-64 (June 15, 133?) also Puolic Health Reports, V01. AB, No. A5 (Tovenber 10, 1133) and Reprint to. 1501. 9. Eldridge, E. 2. "Here About the B. 0. D. Determin- —~ ation" Sewerage Works Journal V31. 5, ?o. 5 (Sent. 1733). 10. Uitrogen“ 11. tastes." . Holderby, J. H. and Lea, W. L. "The B. O. D. test as Infliencod by the Ratio of 0 ganio Carbon to Total Sewerage Works Jour. V01. 7, No. 1. (Jan. 1935). Eldridge. E. F. "The B. U. D. of Industrial Kichigan Engineering Exp. Sta. Bull. No. 73 (Jan. 1933}. MICHIGAY‘J $7A7E UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES * m: 2 W m: J? ‘M '- NM |‘ l‘.:||.u|‘|“|“‘.fll'|+ 3 9 0 II! I 12 3 03 46 8320 c...‘ -_ 8 g I § fi 1 E 'I.‘* 1“ a t 0'. O Q‘. 9 .