Journal of Social Development in Africa (1996), 11,1,53-78 The Role of "Theatre for Development" in Mobilising Rural Communities for Primary Health Care: The Case of Liwonde PHC Unit in Southern Malawi * EZEKIEL KALIPENI & CHRISTOPHER KAMLONGERA** ABSTRACT This paper argues that the most important element in health care strategy is community participation. If social welfare is to be effectively improved it must involve the people in making their own decisions and taking their own actions. Using popular theatre as a means of communication and education, the Liwonde Primary Health Care Unit in the Southern Region of Malawi has succeeded to motivate residents of two rural communities to actively involve themselves in primary health care activities. The impact of this innovative approach to communication and education for health has been remarkable. Recent data indicates that cases of deaths due to preventable diseases such as cholera and severe diarrhoea have been dramatically reduced especially in the under-five age group. The construction of pit latrines and improved water supplies have been vital to the improved health situation. Introduction The success of development in every country must be reflected in the health and socioeconomic well-being of its people. This implies that, as a nation develops, the incidence and prevalence of infectious and killer diseases must be eradicated or curtailed, resulting in the decline of both infant and adult mortality rates, morbidity rates, and in the improvement or increase in life expectancy at birth. Health is both a prerequisite to and concomitant of development The provision of Westernstyled health facilities may not necessarily result in improved health conditions. Of critical importance is the motivation of the local people to help themselves in health matters. This can be achieved if health information and education is disseminated * Revised version based on comments of anonymous reviewer, resubmitted for consideration to the JSDA. ** Ezekiel Kalipeni (PhD) Assistant Professor of Social Geography, Department of Geography, University of Illinois 220 Davenport Hall MC-150, 607 South Mathews Street Urbana, Illinois 61801, U.S.A. Christopher Kamlongera (PhD) Professor of Fine and Performing Arts, University of Malawi, Zomba, Malawi. 54 E Kalipeni & C Kamlongera in a culturally acceptable manner at the community level. In Malawi, the provision of curative services, which are based on the Western biomedical model, takes a large proportion of the total government funds allocated to this sector ( National Statistical Office, 1992). The lack of effective outreach capacity in the health care system has been long recognised by the Ministry of Health and strategies for creating acommunky based distribution system that emphasises the primary health care approach are being implemented in various parts of the country despite the severe lack of trained medical personnel (National Statistical Office, 1992). Figure 1: Southern Malawi and Liwonde PHC Project Areas S 20 » 10 "Theatre for Development" in Primary Health Care: Malawi 55 The aim of this paper is to demonstrate one inexpensive way in which information and education about health and sanitation can be innovatively disseminated in rural settings. The paper documents an effective strategy that was used in three villages in Southern Malawi to inspire the local communities to do something on their own about their precarious health status during the latter half of the 1980 decade. These were the villages of Mbela and Mwima located close to the Shire River and Chisi Island located on Lake Chirwa (see Figure 1). First, the paper briefly reviews the current strategies used for the dissemination of primary health care information in Malawi and notes how these strategies have failed to reach out to the majority of the people in the rural countryside. Second the paper examines the health situation that existed in Mbela and Mwima areas before the introduction of the Liwonde Agricultural Development Division (ADD) Primary Health Care programme. Third, a conceptual model of the main approach that has been used to motivate the people of these areas to assist themselves in primary health care activities is briefly described. Finally, an evaluative discussion of the strategy used in these three villages is offered. Health Information and Education in Malawi: An Overview In Malawi, primary responsibility of the Health Education Services of the Ministry of Health is the health education of the public (both rural and urban). This activity is accomplished through books or magazines (eg, Moyo, Family Health Newsletter, Boma Lathu, Za Chikumbi, posters and child spacing booklets) written in both English and Chichewa, the national language. Moyo and Family Health Newsletter are published by the Health Education Unit of the Ministry of Health. Za Achikumbi (Farmers' Forum) is published by the Ministry of Agriculture and deals with matters related to agricultural production while Boma Lathu (which specialises in providing general news and information to the literate rural community) is published by the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting. These magazines contain information on ways to prevent diseases such as malaria, bilharzia, diarrhoea, tuberculosis, AIDS, leprosy and many other common ailments. Education is also effected through regular radio broadcasts of health messages prepared by various ministries and government departments (Cbilivumbo, 1975). For example, the radio programme 'OPhiri' is ajoint venture between the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Agriculture and it deals with health and agriculture issues. 'Umoyo ndi Chitukuko m'Malawi' (Health and Development in Malawi) is another jointly prepared radio programme between the Ministries of Health and Community Services and deals largely with issues relating to health and development These broadcasts are in both Chichewa, the national language spoken and understood by the majority of Malawians and English - the official Government language. 56 E KaUpeni & C Kamlongera Another channel for information diffusion is the use of visual aids: posters, pamphlets/leaflets which carry selected health subjects. Furthermore, prior to 1990, joint efforts among the Department of Agricultural Communications of the Ministry of Agriculture, the Ministry of Community Services and the Department of Information included the "yellow van" mobile units equipped with film projectors and puppet shows (see for example Kamlongera, 1986). Unfortunately the "yellow van" mobile film unit programme has been discontinued due to financial difficulties. The mobile film unit used to travel to schools and those villages that were readily accessible to present free film shows on health education and other development related issues. Private agencies such as the Christian Hospital Association of Malawi (CHAM) and religious institutions are also active in one way or another in the dissemination of health information. For example, the Christian Hospital Association runs outreach programmes at its larger hospitals. Functional literacy centres and home craft centres also play an important role in disseminating health and nutrition information to rural communities. Daily health talks at clinics, health centres and hospitals are an additional important source of information. In brief, this constitutes the information communication set up in Malawi. In spite of the commendable multi-pronged efforts directed at the rural population, coverage is limited due to a combination of factors, particularly insufficient health extension personnel, high illiteracy rales and low ownership of radios. About 88 per cent of the population in Malawi is rural and a large proportion of this population is illiterate. The results of the 1987 Population and Housing Census reveal that slightly less than half of the population aged 5 years and over had some education. About 42 per cent of the population aged 5 years and over had attended only primary school education. When this is broken down by gender, about SS per cent of male population aged 5 years and over had some education compared with abwt36per4 years) akulu (adults) KHADI YA BUNGWE LA ZAUMOYO (HEALTH REGISTER) ! kutsegula mimba malungo matenda ena died matenda amaso otumizidwa kuchipatala other diseases, specify below & J omwalira <•* eye diseases referrals diarrhoea malaria I tf a- 72 E Kalipeni & C Kamlongera experienced significant increases in households with latrines a couple years after the inception of the programme. A few people we interviewed in Mbela area pointed out a number of advantages for building latrines. Among them were selfrespect for the individual and family and prevention of diseases to attain or promote better health. This is in contrast to the experience of Chisi Island where the PHC team went in without the assistance of the "Chancellor College Theatre for Development" troupe (see Table 3). In June 1986 only 20 per cent of the houses had latrines and this increased to 30 per cent by February 1986. A difference of means t-test indicated that, on average, the increases latrine construction experienced by villages on Chisi Island was not statistically significant at the 5 per cent level of significance (see note in Table 2). Table 2. Number of Latrines in Mbela Area Village Number of Houses 262 58 168 62 150 320 319 118 239 139 Mtira Said-Son Chipole Kalambo Mbela Pyoli Makuta Herbet Abudu Nsanja Kabota 107 Total 1,906 Note: Estimated population for Mbela area- 9 530 Results of paired sample differences of m e L ttst. M2U £ £ ***, °f ^ ^ W ^ !atrines "» 19»6: 49145. standard deviation: 14.75 P a h ^ f f T w* ' a t r m e s >n 1987: 71.36, standard deviation: 18.41 « 3 M r f t ? l^- I.24- P~"bK- °0°2 <*•«• «"* difference between the means 49.45 and 71.36 is statistically significant at the .05 level of significance. Source: data compiled from Liwonde ADD Primary Health Care Unit, Monthly Returns. Number of Latrines June 1986 Number % Houses with Latrines 107 41 32 55 65 39 71 71 30 64 46 44 106 95 203 54 133 56 50 36 37 35 926 49 February 1987 Number % Houses with Latrines 47 123 90 52 45 75 77 48 91 136 79 253 82 263 91 108 63 45 75 150 62 80 71 1,350 "Theatre for Development" in Primary Health Care: Malawi 73 Once the PHC programme in Mbela and Mwima areas was introduced using the novel approach of "Theatre for Development", there were remarkable strides and gains. The village health committees motivated by the "Theatre for Development" performances, became very active and membership of the committees remained intact with just a couple of drop-outs. In contrast, the people of Chisi Island were not exposed to the "Theatre for Development" approach and seemed to lack motivation. The village health committees on the island, just like in many rural areas, appeared to inactive and unconcerned about the communities' plight in as far sanitation was concerned. The lack of motivation in Chisi Island and the enthusiastic adoption of PHC in Mwima and Mbela provides more credibility to the potency of the "Theatre for Development" approach. Table 3. Number of Latrines on Chisi Island Village Number of Houses Maluwa 170 45 Tchuka 30 Chilima Kotamu Mkumbira Chigwere 159 152 83 42 Khumali 681 Total Note: Estimated population for Mbela area: 3,405 Results of paired sample differences of means test: Mean per cent of houses with latrines in 1986: 20.46, standard deviation: 10.64 Mean per cent of houses with latrines in 1987: 30.00, standard deviation: 8.43 Paired differences t-value: -2.24, p-value: 0.066 (i.e. the difference between the means 20.46 and 30.00 is not statistically significant at the .05 level of significance). Source: Liwonde ADD Primary Health Care Unit, Monthly Returns. Maternal Care As far as maternal care is concerned, the programme selected a number of traditional birth attendants (TBAs) who commanded respect in the community. The TBAs were then trained to provide basic antenatal care including iron supplementation, malaria treatment and high risk screening. Furthermore, commuof Latrines Number June 1986 February 1987 Number % Houses with Latrines Number % Houses withi Latrines 34 20 8 33 40 13 8 10 18 33 27 26 43 20 23 31 28 15 12 42 30 26 17 40 4 15 33 9 26 176 19 129 74 E Kalipeni & C Kamlongera nity 'doctors' were selected and trained to diagnose common conditions and administer basic medications such as chloroquine, aspirin, eye ointment, scabies ointment and so on. The community 'doctors', in collaboration with the TB As, take up the tasks of nutritional and health surveillance of children (including the identification of children that require immunisation for the next mobile PHC team visit, or to encourage mothers to go to the under-five clinic on appropriate days), the distribution of chloroquine, first aid and treatment of minor ailments, the management of diarrhoea in children, and treatment of malaria and selected common conditions in children and adults. They also educate families and community groups on the prevention of these conditions. The efforts of these dedicated, community based (unpaid volunteer) PHC workers have been amply rewarded. Incidence of Disease Statistics from the PHC unit in Liwonde show that the seasonal outbreaks of cholera declined considerably between 1985 and 1986 when the PHC project was in progress (Table 4). Furthermore, immediate reporting of suspected cholera and severe diarrhoea to health institutions by the community and improved water supplies by provision of sanitary structures at wells/springs have been vital to the improved situation. There has also been a significant reduction in monthly infant and child deaths caused by diarrhoeal diseases. The incidence of diarrhoea in both children and adults experienced a remarkable reduction during the 1985-1990 period (see Table 5). However, we must caution that the data in Tables 4 and 5 could be on the low side for several reasons including under-counting due to parents not taking their sick children to the village health worker. It may also be due to the fact that the year 1987 was somewhat drier than the year 1986 in terms of rainfall. Diseases such as diarrhoea are most intense during the rainy season and drier than normal season may reduce the incidence of diarrhoea and/or cholera. However, the trends in the data were obviously encouraging. Similar data for Chisi Island was not available due to noncooperation of the village health workers charged with the responsibility of collecting such data. In addition to the reduction of communicable diseases such as diarrhoea, Mbela and Mwima experienced substantial declines in monthly infant mortality figures between the 1984/85 and 1987/88 periods as shown in Table 6. The current esumatedinfantmortality for MbelaandMwimaareas is 150compared to 180and above before the PHC project in this area. These are a few examples which illustrate the positive impact of this unique programme as evidenced from the health and sanitation data collected by the programme. It is unfortunate that comparable data on disease incidence was not readily available for Chisi Island wun tne exception of latrines which could be easily counted in surveys by the PHC Table 4. Reported Cases of Cholera and Severe Diarrhoea Incidence in Liwonde Area Total No. of Cases Total No. of Deaths Total No. Positives Source: Liwonde ADD Primary Health Care Unit, Cholera Quarterly Returns, October- December 1986. Table 5: Incidence of Diarrhoea in Children and Adults in Mbela Area Village Mtira Said-Son Chipole Kalambo Mbela Pyoli Makuta Herbert Abudu Msanja Kabota Total Note: Number of deaths reported were NOTaue to diarrhoea alone but to any other disease. Source: Liwonde ADD PHC Unit, Monthly Returns. "Theatre for Development" in Primary Health Care: Malawi 75 1985 December November October 116 92 155 0 1 2 15 8 16 June 1986 No. of Deaths No. of Cases Adults Adults 0 0 0 76 7 2 64 1 16 34 3 0 0 1 1 2 0 4 0 0 0 0 0-5 age group 1 0 1 1 3 0 1 2 4 0 0 0-5 age group 21 0 11 111 7 33 93 13 30 38 10 203 13 367 8 October 46 1986 November 29 0 0 1 0 December 15 0 0 1987 May No. of Cases No. of Deaths Adults Adults 1 0 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0-5 age group 9 7 4 21 1 6 4 1 6 2 2 0-5 age group 1 1 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 5 1 1 6 5 3 1 0 3 7 5 4 37 63 7 76 E Kalipeni & C Kamlongera By concentrating the PHC activities in a number of selected villages, the Liwonde PHC Unit hoped that these villages would serve as centres of information diffusion to other nearby villages where the programme had not as yet been initiated. The model for diffusion was through village contact Indeed this approach appears to have yielded the intended results. At the time we carried out this evaluation, surrounding villages were requesting the PHC team to initiate PHC activities in their areas. Villagers from surrounding areas were coming to Mwima and Mbela to observe and receive basic first aid care and treatment from the community 'doctors'. Table 6: Number of Deaths Among Children Aged 0-5 in Mbela Area for the periods 1984/85 and 1987/88 45- 40- 30- n 1 1 • • • (dnorf I I• u 6 5 > | 15- 10- 5- 1 0- 1 ;: I: 1 1 1 fil mww Jun» July Aug ' 3*pt ' Oct ' Nov Month Notes: | l 1 1 i 1 1 H I -1 I Tl ! • 1 •1 • • I " g Jun 9S4-F*b1985 • I Jun 1M7-F«b.19SS Results of paired sample differences of means test- Men number of death, 1984/85: 26.88, standard deviation: 4.31 Mean number of death. 1987/88: 17.89, standard deviation: 4.65 Paired deference, t-value: 4.53. p-value: 0.002 (this denotes'that the difference between «?.iT.""]."1011 r " U m b e r ° f d e i l h 8 f 0 r * e •""fc'-fi"' «ge group, ie 26.88 and 17.89 is staus ^y,1gmf,cantatthe.051evelof,ignifi a B 1ce ) . Source: auAors. data from Uwonde ADD Primary Hedth Care Unit. Monthly Returns. 1 F»b Jan "Theatre for Development" in Primary Health Care: Malawi 77 Conclusion The case study discussed in this paper confirms the assertion that PHC planning ought to be socially and community oriented, aimed at improving the well-being of rural communities. The communities should be mobilised and motivated to diagnose their own problems and find their own solutions. Popular theatre like the "Chancellor College Theatre for Development" could be employed creatively for this purpose. PHC planning has tended to adopt the rather narrow view of accessibility relating it to the maximum distance people are willing to travel to obtain a particular health service. Consequently much emphasis has been placed on building new facilities at great capital and recurrent cost to the state without necessarily improving absolute access to rural inhabitants. In reality accessibility to health services is concerned with more than just proximity to these services; it involves various social, cultural and community health education issues. Active community participation and involvement is vital in the success of any PHC programme. As shown by the Liwonde PHC programme's relative success over a short period of time, there is a clear need to involve the rural people in the planning process. In other words, the planning process should not only come from above but should also include a bottom-up grassroots-level component. Acknowledgement This paper is based on an unpublished larger report that was prepared by myself in collaboration with Professor Christopher Kamlongera of Chancellor College, University of Malawi. Fieldwork for data collection was funded by a World Health Organisation grant We are grateful to the Demographic Unit of the University of Malawi for providing the necessary logistical support such as transportation and secretarial facilities. We would also like to extend thanks to the Liwonde ADD PHC team and members of the Chancellor College Travelling Theatre for their cooperation and assistance during our numerous visits. The views expressed in this paper are those of the authors. We are also extremely grateful to the comments offered by anonymous reviewers to an earlier draft of this paper. References Bennet,FJ & Cole-King, SM (1982) "Guidelines fortheDevelopmentofPrimary Health Care", PHC Working Committee, Ministry of Health, Government of Malawi in Collaboration with WHO/UNICEF, Report 1/82 PHC EARO UNICEF, Lilongwe. Chilivumbo, A (1975) "Malawi: cultural consequences of population growth", in The Consequences of Population Change, a report on a seminar held in Bucharest, Romania, 14-17 August, 1974, The Centre for the Study of Man, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D C. 78 E Kalipeni & C Kamlongera Egan, A F; Jones, S B; Luloff, A E & Finley, J C (1995) "The Value of Using Multiple Methods: An Illustration Using Survey, Focus Group, and Delphi Techniques", Society and Natural Resources, 8 (5), 1995, pp 457-475. Eyoh, H N (1986) Hammocks to Bridges, Yaounde University Research Publication, Yaounde. Helitzer-Allen, D, et al (1994) An Investigation of Community-Based Communication Networks of Adolescent Girls in Rural Malawi for HIV/ STD/AIDS Prevention Messages, Research Report Series, No 4, International Centre for Research on Women, Washington, D C. Kalipeni, E (1993) "Determinants of infant mortality in Malawi: a spatial perspective", Social Science and Medicine, 37 (2), pp 183-198. Kamlongera, C (1984) "The Relationship between Theatre and Society in Malawi and Zambia", PhD Thesis, School of English, University of Leeds. Kamlongera, C (1986) "Puppet Theatre in Malawi's Extension Aid Branch: an Example of Extension Services in Agricultural Development", paper presented at the Workshop on Impact of Culture on Economic Development organized by the European Economic Community and the University of Dar es Salaam at Arusha, Tanzania, 22-29 February 1986. Kidd, R & Gnat, C (1980) Tradition for Development: Indigenous Structures and Folk Media in Non-formal Education, Berlin. Liwonde ADD Primary Health Care Unit (1988) Monthly Returns, Liwonde ADD PHC Unit, Liwonde. Malawi (1978) Health for AU Seminar, Report of the National Seminar on Primary Health Care, Likuni Press and Publishing House, Lilongwe. National Statistical Office (1984) Malawi Population Census 1977: Analytical Report, Vol. I, Government Printer, Zomba. National Statistical Office (1991) Malawi Population and Housing Census 1987: Summary of Final Results, Vol. 1, Government Printer, Zomba. National Statistical Office (1992) Malawi Demographic and Health Survey 1992, Malawi National Statistical Office, Zomba. Templeton, J (1994) The Focus Group: A Strategic Guide to Organising, Conducting and Analysing the Focus Group Interview, Probus Publishing Company, Chicago. Wells, W G (1974) "Group Inteviewing", in Robert Ferber, ed, Handbook of Marketing Research, McGraw Hill Publishers, New York. Yelland, J & Gifford, S M (1995) "Problems of Focus Group Methods in Cross- Cultural Public Health Research: A Case Study of Beliefs About Sudden Death Syndrome", Australian Journal of Public Health, 19 (3), pp 257-270. UNESCO (1992) Statistical Yearbook, UNESCO, Paris.